摘要
目的:分析各因素对疗效影响的差异,优选周围性面瘫的最佳电针治疗方案,探讨不同针刺参数对面神经损伤再生修复的机理,为提高针灸治疗本病的临床疗效提供科学实验依据。
方法:1、选用日本大耳白兔66只,雌雄各半,采用神经卡压法造成左侧面神经损伤,作为研究实验性周围性面瘫的动物模型。2、66只兔随机分为11组(每组6只),其中一组作为假手术组,一组作为模型对照组,其余九组运用正交试验设计的方法,采用针刺时机(急性期、静止期、恢复期)、电针波形(密波、疏波、疏密波)、腧穴配伍(面部+头穴、面部+体穴、面部+头体穴)的三因素三水平搭配组合方案,随机分入L_9(3~4)正交表安排的九组实验中,进行实验观察,共观察四周。3、采用电生理的方法测定面运动神经传导速度(MCV);用免疫组织化学方法对面神经核神经生长因子(NGF)和脑源性神经营养因子(BDNF)阳性神经元进行染色,并用表达阳性细胞数定量分析;用原位杂交方法对面神经核脑源性神经营养因子(BDNF mRNA)阳性神经元进行染色,并用表达阳性细胞数定量分析。4、统计学分析在SAS for windows 8.0统计软件上完成。正交分析采用直观分析及方差分析,各组间、组内比较采用方差分析、q检验和t检验。
结果:1、造模后兔出现鼻唇沟偏向右侧,胡须不能自主运动,并向后倾斜等症状,且MCV小于10m/s,比造模前明显减慢(P<0.01)。2、各组(除假手术组)造模前MCV比较,无显著性差异(P>0.05),各组(除假手术组)造模后MCV比较,无显著性差异(P>0.05),各组间具有可比性。3、经四周治疗后,电针组的MCV恢复明显快于模型组(P<0.01)。电针组面神经核内NGF蛋白、BDNF蛋白、BDNF mRNA表达水平明显高于模型组(P<0.01)。4、采用急性期、选择电针疏密波形、取面部+体穴针刺治疗实验性周围性面瘫可以使MCV恢复最快,且各因素
Objective:To analyze the extent of curative effect influenced by all factors, optimize the therapeutic scheme of electroaccupuncture peripheral facial palsy and to discuss the influence of regeneration and restoration on facial nerve injury through different stimulating parameters of acupuncture which can provide the scientific experimental evidence for improving the clinical curative effect of peripheral facial palsy treated by acupuncture.Methods:1、 We made the animal model of experimental peripheral facial palsy with sixty-six rabbits of Japan species, male and female each half, by the method of crashing nerve. 2、 Sixty-six rabbits were divided eleven groups of which each group include six rabbits randomly. Of them one group was choused as control group, another as model group, others were divided nine groups experiment arranged by L9(3~4)orthogonal table for experimental observation for four weeks through combination scheme arranged in groups by three factors and three level , consisting of the time of acupuncture which included acute period, quiescence period and convalescence, the wave shape of electroaccupuncture which included dense wave, sparse wave and density wave, the compatibility of points which included facial and head points, facial and body' s points, facial、 head and body' s points). 3、 Determine MCV through electrophysiological method, stain the positive neurons of NGF and BDNF through immunochemical method and stain the positive neurons of BDNF mRNA through the method of ISH, all of
which made quantitative analysis through the expressive amounts of the positive cells. 4> Statistical analysis was done on SAS software. Analysis of orthogonal design was done by analysis of intuition and variance, compared among each group and in the group by analysis of variance, student-Newman-Keuls test and t-test.Results:In Rabbits had the symptom of leaning to right of nasal lip fosse, unfree movement with whisker and leaning back with body after model done in which MCV (MCV<10m/s) was slower than preceding model (P<0.01). 2> The comparation of MCV among all the group (except for control group) in preceding model was feasible which was not significant difference(P > 0.05) and the comparation of MCV among all the group (except for control group) after model done were feasible which was not significant difference(P> 0.05). 3> The restoration of MCV was faster and albumen of NGF and BDNF in facial nucleus and the level of expression of BDNF mRNA were higher in electroaccupuncture group than in model group after treatment in four weeks(P<0.01). 4> The restoration of MCV was fastest by selecting density wave shape combined facial and body' s points in acute period for treating experimental peripheral facial palsy. According the degree of curative effect influenced by each factor from greatness to lightness was the time of acupuncture > the wave shape of electroaccupuncture > compatibility of points. 5 -, The drop of expressive level of NGF albumen in facial nucleus was restrained at the most extent by selecting density wave shape combined faciah head and body' s points in acute period for treating experimental peripheral facial palsy. The expressive level influenced by each
factor from greatness to lightness was the wave shape of electroaccupuncture > the time of acupuncture > compatibility of points. 6^ The drop of expressive level of BDNF albumen in facial nucleus was restrained at the most extent by selecting density wave shape combined faciaK head and body' s points in acute period for treating experimental peripheral facial palsy. The expressive level influenced by each factor from greatness to lightness was the time of acupuncture > the wave shape of electroaccupuncture > compatibility of points. 7^ The drop of expressive level BDNF mRNA in facial nucleus was restrained at the most extent by selecting density wave shape combined faciaK head and body' s points in acute period for treating experimental peripheral facial palsy. The expressive level influenced by each factor from greatness to lightness was the time of acupuncture > the wave shape of electroaccupuncture> compatibility of points.Conclusions:1 n It had curative effect affirmatively on experimental peripheral facial palsy treated by electroaccupuncture with rabbits. It could lighten the swelling and denaturalization and reduce the death of neuron as well that could protect neuron and promote regeneration and restoration of function corresponding to facial nucleus after facial nerve injury in rabbits. 2> Different factor influence different curative effect of peripheral facial palsy treated by electroaccupuncture with rabbits. Each factor from greatness to lightness was the time of acupuncture > the wave shape of electroaccupuncture > compatibility of points. 3 > Through the method of orthogonal design, we concluded the best scheme for treating experimental peripheral facial palsy with rabbit was that acute period, selecting density wave shape and facial and body's
points. 4> NGF album n BDNF mRNA and album in facial nucleus as well as the drop of expressive level after facial nerve injury in rabbit was restrained and it would boost up the nutrition of opposite nerve which could protect neuron and take effect of the regeneration and restoration of facial nerve injury further through the method of density shape of electroaccupuncture combined faciaK head and body' s points in acute period. 5> Different stimulating parameters of acupuncture had different influence about the expression of neurotrophic factor. For instance, the choice of the wave shape of electroaccupuncture was the most important for the expression of NGF and the choice of the time of acupuncture was the most important for the expression of BDNF. 6> Orthogonal design was the highest effective design method of acupuncture's experiment about many factors and many levels approved by the study of experimental peripheral facial palsy treated by electroaccupuncture with rabbits. 7n Head' s points probably took effect of the regeneration and restoration after facial nerve injury through inhibit the drop of neurotrophic factor like NGF and BDNF in facial nucleus which could boost up the nutrition of facial nerve and promote the growth of facial neuraxon.
引文
1 赵瑜.面神经周围性麻痹76例分析报告[J] .中华神经精神杂志.1956,(4):263
2 张子涵.针灸治疗59例颜面神经麻痹的效果介绍[J].山东医刊.1957,(1):51
3 梅建寒.面神经麻痹定位诊断与针灸治疗[J].陕西中医学会针灸论文摘要选编.1981:86
4 杜晓山.金针治疗面神经麻痹41例的初步观察[J].新中医药.1956,4(8):34
5 陈慰苍.针灸治疗面神经麻痹112例疗效观察[J].上海中医药杂志.1958,(12):21
6 山东省立中医院.针灸治疗面神经麻痹139例临床分析[J]。山东医刊.1960,(3):44
7 马良田.针灸治疗面神经麻痹155例报告[J].江西医药杂志.1964,(3):44
8 方吉庆.针灸治疗口眼(?)斜疗效总结[J].山东医刊.1964,(11):44
9 刘森亭,吴淑珍,黄丽萍,等.面瘫的发生及病因病机研究概况[J].陕西中医.1997,18(11):525
10 赵瑜.针灸治疗面神经瘫痪110例临床观察[J].上海中医药杂志.1964,(1):23
11 洪庆达.针灸治疗面神经麻痹45例初步报告[J].中华医学杂志.1955,(10):976
12 汪金娣.温针治面瘫[J].大众医学.1983,(12):15
13 孟湘龙.电针加红外线治疗面神经炎[J] .湖南中医杂志.1986,(2):39
14 廖春华.电针治疗面瘫100例临床小结[J].湖南中医杂志.1986,(2):38
15 吕伯实,刘振兴,李克赞,等.面神经麻痹的应用解剖学研究[J].泰山医学院学报.2000,21(3):195-197
16 Blunt MJ.The possible role of the catfacial nerve[J]. Laryngoscope.1986,96:70-77
17 Bleicher JN,Hamiel S,Gengler JS,et al.A survey of facialparalysis: etiology and incidence [J].ENTJ. 1996,75(6):355-358
18 王恺,摘,徐丽蓉,校.Bell's麻痹:电生理研究及现状[J].国外医学耳鼻咽喉科学分册.1997,21:137-140
19 Balkany T, Fradis M, Jafek BVV, et al. Intrinsic vasculature of the labyrinthine segment of the facial nerve-implications for site of lesion in Bell's palsy [J]. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1991,104:20-23
20 刘亚峰,摘,周光耀,校.鼓膜冷空气暴露诱发动物急性面瘫的实验研究[J].国外医 学耳鼻咽喉科学分册.1997,21(3):184
21 Zealear DL, Bryant GL Jr, Logan MB, et al. An investigation of acute facial paralysis in animals induced by exposure of the tympanic membrane to cold air [J]. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1995,113(6): 760-765
22 Sugita T, Murakami S, Yanagihara N, et al. Facial nerve paralysis induced by herpes Simplex Virus in mice: an animal model of acute and transient facial paralysis [J]. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1995,104(7):574-581
23 Burgess RC, Michaels L, Bale JF Jr, et al. Polymerase chain reaction amplification of herpes Simplex Viral DNA from the genicnlate ganglion of a patient with Bell's palsy [J]. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol.1994,103(10):775-77924 Murakami S, Hato N, Mizobuchi M, et al. Role of herpes Simplex Virus infection in the pathogenesis of facial paralysis in mice [J]. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1996,105(1):49-53
25 汪月月,张来虎,摘,凌贤才,校.面神经麻痹2.5低聚腺苷酸合成酶关系的研究[J].国外医学耳鼻喉咽科学分册.1996,20(4):248
26 Pitkaranta A, Hovi T, Peltomaa M, et al. Impaired interferon production by leukocytes from patients with Bell's palsy and lack of findings suggestive for a systemic viral involvement [J]. Am J Otol.1997,18(2): 243-248
27 Ikede M, Lijima M, Kukimoto N, et al. Plasma endothelin level in the acute stage of Bell's palsy [J]. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1996,122(8): 849-852
28 Omori H, Lkeda M. Intravascular hypercoagulability in patients with recent Bell's palsy [J]. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol.1994,251:278-282
29 MrGovern FH et al.laryngoscope. 1980,(90):1640-1645
30 JonssonL.ORL. 1987,(49):294-301
31 张来虎,汪月月,摘,凌贤才,校.冷冻实验性面神经麻痹恢复过程组织学研究[J].国外医学耳鼻咽喉科学分册.1996,20(4):248
32 宋军,摘,林尚泽,校.卵巢类固醇激素与妊娠Bell's面瘫发病率增高的相互关系[J].国外医学耳鼻咽喉科学分册.1996,20(4):246-247
33 沈宁江,朱家恺.周围神经损伤和修复功能评价的方法学探讨[J].中华显徽外科杂志.1995,13(1):35
34 May M. Microanatomy and pathophysiology of the facial nerve. In: May M(ed):The Facial Nerve[J]. New York: Thieme Inc. 1986:63
35 Thomas PK. Diseases of the peripheral nerves. In:Adams JH(eds):Greenfield's Neuropathology[J]. 5thed, London: Edward Arnold. 1992:1116
36 Conley J, Miehlke A, Millesi H, et al. Factors influencing results in extratemporal facial nerve repair[J]. In:Fisch U(eds): Facial Nerve Surgery.Amsterdam : Kugler Medical Publishing Co.1977:216
37 May M. Neurobiology of regeneration and degeneration. In: May M(ed) : The Facial Nerve[J]. New York:Yhieme Inc.1986:75
38 Crumley RL. Electromyography and muscle biopsy infacial paralysis. In: Graham MD(eds): Disorder of the Facial Nerve[J]. New York: Raven Press.1982:147
39 Ylikoski J. J Laryngol Otol .1990 ,104(3):294
40 Henry CP, Peter WL. Peripheral neuropathy. In:Roge NR(eds):The Clinical Neurosciences (Neuropathology)[J]. London: Churchill Livingstone. 1983:325
41 王胜资,王正敏.内听门区血管与神经的解剖关系[J].国际耳鼻咽喉头颈外科杂志. 1991,26(2):100
42 Ylikoski J, et al. Acta Otolaryngol.1981,92(2):239
43 左其勇,陈日亭,杨连甲,等.兔面神经再生效果的扫描电镜观察[J].实用口腔医学杂志.1988,4(4):202
44 Seddon HJ. Brain. 1943,66(2):237
45 Terzis JK. Peripheral nerve injury[M]. In: Terzis J K(ed), The Peripheral Nerve Structure ,Function and Reconstruction, New York: Ahampton Press Publication. 1988:38
46 王海风,王新宇,程俊杰,等.周围性面瘫定位诊断与针刺疗效关系的研究[J].中国针灸.2003,23(3):143-144
47 周章玲,黄德晖,刘丽平.面神经功能诊断对指导针刺治疗面神经炎的意义[J].中国临床康复.2004,19(8):3874-3875
48 汤晓芙.神经系统临床电生理学[M].北京:人民军医出版社.2002:27
49 乔志恒,范维铭.物理治疗学[M].北京:科技文献出版社.2001:579
50 林瑞声.神经肌电图在特发性面瘫中临床评估观察[J].医学理论与实践.2001,14 (5):397
51 钟洪海,谢岳锐.Bell氏麻痹十项记分法的临床应用(附39例对比观察)[J].中国神经精神疾病杂志.1993,(1):54
52 任重.颞骨内面瘫面肌支配神经运动点的受伤性[J].中国医科大学学报.1987,(3):141
53 王燕酋.电生理检查在特发性面神经麻痹中的应用[J].中华耳鼻喉科杂志.1990,(3):181
54 Terzis J K and Schars R H. Facial nerve reconstruction in salivary gland pathology:a review[J]. Microsurgery. 1993,14:355
55 Millesi H. Nerve suture and grafting to restore the extratemporal facial nerve[J]. Clin Plast Surg. 1979,6:333
56 Rouleau M, Crepeau J, Tetrault L, et al. Facial nerve suture at the epineural versus perineural sutures [J]. J Otolaryngol. 1981,10:338
57 Sade J.Facial nerve reconstruction and its prognosis[J].Ann Otolaryngol.1975,84: 695
58 Scaramella L F. On the repair of the injured facial nerve[J]. Ear Nose Throat J.1979, 58:127.
59 Zorub D S and May H. Neurosurgery and the facial nerve. In May(ed):The Facial Nerve[J]. New York. Thieme.1986,619-629
60 Baker D C. Facial paralysis. In McCarthy JG (ed):Plast Sutgery Philadelphia, WB Saunder Company[J]. 1990,2237-2319
61 Brudny J, Hammerschlag PE, Byhen NL, et al. Electromyographic rehabilitation of facial function and introduction of afacial paralysis grading scale for hypoglossal-facial nerve anastomsis[J]. Laryngoscope.1988,98:405
62 Tamai S, Sakamoto H, et al. Free muscletransplants in dogs with microsurgical neurovascular anastomosis [J]. Plast Reconstru Surg. 1970,46:219
63 Harii H, Ohmori K, Torii S. Free gracilis muscle transplantation with microneuromascular anostomosis for the treatment of facial paralysis[J].Plast Reconstru Surg. 1976,57:133
64 Terzis J K. Pectoralis minor: auniquemuscle for correction of facial palsy[J]. Plast Reconstru Surg. 1989,5:767
65 Rubin L R. Temporalis and masseter muscle transplantation. In May(ed): The Facial Nerve[J]. New York, Thieme. 1986,665-679
66 Spector JG. Patty L. Early stages of facial nerve regeneration through silicone chambers in the rabbit[J].1991,101:1109-1123
67 Spector JG. Patty L. July P. Facial nerve regeneration through autologous nerve graft: a clinical and experimental study[J]. Larygoscope.1991,101:537-554
68 Pereira JH, Palande DD, Subramanian A, et al. Denatured autologous muscle graft in leprosy[J]. Lancet. 1991,338:1239-1240
69 Bailes JE, Cozzens JW, Hudson AR, et al. Laser-assisted nerve repair in primates [J].J Neurosurg. 1989,71:266-272
70 Dort JC, Wolfensberger M, and Feidi H. CO_2 laser repair of the facial nerve: an experimental study in the rat[J]. J Laryng otol.1994,108:466-469
71 Eppley BL, Kalenderian E, Winkelmam T, et al. Facia nerve graft repair: suture versus laser-assisted anastomosis[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1989,18:50-63
72 Menovsky T, Beek JF, Gemert MJ. CO_2 laser nerve welding: optimal laser parameters and the use of solders in vitro[J]. Microsurgery. 1994,15(1):44-51
73 Huang TC, Blands RH, Grumley RL. Laser—assisted nerve repair. Laser—triming of nerve ends with epineurial suture anastomosis[J]. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1992,118(3):227-280
74 蔡志刚,俞光岩,马大权,等.家兔创伤性面神经损伤的组织病理学研究[J].中华口腔医学杂志.1997,32(4):236-238
75 王立军,周树夏,董绍忠,等.大鼠创伤性面瘫实验动物模型的建立[J].实用口腔医学杂志.1999,15(3):183-185
76 姜燕平,王正国,刘宝松,等.面神经撞击伤实验模型[J].ACTA ACADEMIAE MEDICINAE MILITARIS TERTIAE.1997,6:275-276
77 王杰,戴春富,赵晖,等.大鼠缺血性面神经瘫痪动物模型的建立[J].临床耳鼻咽喉科杂志.1999,13(10):464-465
78 赵文峰,张虎威,向军,等.颌面部爆炸伤动物模型的建立和损伤特点的观察[J].现代口腔医学杂志.1996,10(2):91-93
79 牙祖蒙,陈宗基,王建华,等.弦式加载法延长面神经模型的建立[J].中国修复重建外科杂志.2000,14(2):90-92
80 任重,任登霄,马秀岚.面肌及其支配神经的生理学和解剖学特点[J].中国医科大学学报.1994,23(5):413-415
81 Provis J. The organization of the facial nucleus of the brush-tailed possum(Trichosurus vulpecula)[J]. J Comp Neurol. 1977,172:177-188
82 Shohara E, Sakai A. Localization of motoneurons innervating deep and superficial facial muscles in the rat: a horseradish peroxidase and electrophysiologic study[J]. Exp Neurol.1983,81:14-33
83 Welt C, Abbs JH. Musculotopic organization of the facial motor nucleus in Macaca fascicularis: a morphometric and retrograde tracing study with cholera toxin B-HRP[J]. J Comp Neurol.1990,291:621-636
84 Komiyama M, Shibata H, Suzuki T. Somatotopic representation of facial muscles within the facial nucleus of the mouse: a study using the retrograde horseradish peroxidase and cell degeneration techniques [J].Brain Behav Evol. 1984,24:144-151
85 Klein BG, Rhoades RW, Jacquin MF. Topography of the facial musculature within the facial (Ⅶ)motor nucleus of the neonatal rat[J].Exp Brain Res.1990,81:649-653
86 Baisden RH, Woodruff ML, Whittington DL, et al. Cells of origin of the branches of the facial nerve: a retrograde HRP study in the rabbit[J]. Am J Anat. 1987,178:175-184
87 卢连军,王锦玲,邱建华,等.大鼠面神经核运动神经元的分布及神经损伤再支配后的变化[J].中华耳鼻咽喉科杂志.2002,37(6):428-431
88 Tsai TC, Wu CH, Wen CY, et al. Studies of the motoneurons following the injection of horseradish peroxidase into the peripheral branches of the facial nerve in rats[J]. Acta Anat. 1993,148:42-48
89 Asahara T, Lin M, Kumazawa Y, et al. Long-term observation on the changes of somatotopy in the facial nucleus after nerve suture in the cat: morphological studies using retrograde labeling[J]. Brain Res Bull.1999,49:195-202
90 Fawcett JW, Keynes RJ. Peripheral nerve regeneration[J]. Annu Rev Neurosci. 1990,13:43-60
91 Lundborg G. Nerve regeneration and repair: a review[J]. Acta Orthop Scand. 1987, 58:145-169
92 Ungar Sargon J, Goldberger ME. Maintenance of specificity by sprouting and regeneration peripheral nerve. Ⅱ. Variability after lesion[J]. Brain Res.1987,407: 124-136
93 Thomander L. Reorganization of facial motor nucleus after peripheral nerve regeneration: an HRP study in the rat[J]. Acta Otolaryngol.1984,97:619-626
94 Baker RS, Stava MW, Nelson KR, et al. Aberrant reinnervation of facial musculature in a subhuman primate: a correlative analysis of eyelid kinematics, muscle synkinesis, and motoneuron localization[J]. Neurology. 1994,44: 2165-2173
95 Asahara T, Lin M, Kumazawa Y, et al. Long-term observation on the changes of somatotopy in the facial nucleus after nerve suture in the cat: morphological studies using retrograde labeling[J]. Brain Res Bull.1999,49:195-202
96 清·林佩琴.类证治裁(第1版)[M].上海科技出版社.1959:4
97 刘洁声.面瘫病因病机之我见[J].中医杂志.1959,(12):54
98 南京中医学院,诸病源候论核释[M].北京(第1版).人民卫生出版社.1980,28-29,1-37.1329
99 南京中医学院.黄帝内经灵枢译释[M].上海(第1版).上海科技出版社.1986:138-139
100 明·李梃.医学入门(卷四)[M].万历三年刊本.1575:1
101 王惠国.针刺加闪罐治疗周围性面瘫87例[J].中国针灸.2001,21(2):69
102 王舒,王敏,张杰,等.“经筋刺法”治疗周围性面神经麻痹50例疗效观察[J].中国针灸.2001,21(3):156
103 李延辉.灸健侧针患侧治疗面瘫35例[J].中国针灸.2002,22(2):104
104 王扶盛.透刺加电针治疗周围性面瘫22例[J].针灸临床杂志.2001,17(3):21
105 何智芳.针刺加穴位注射治疗重症周围性面瘫80例[J].针灸临床杂志.2001,17(3):25
106 徐秀梅.针药并用治疗面瘫的体会[J].针灸临床杂志.2001,17(8):13
107 宋志娥.针灸治疗面神经麻痹226例[J].针灸临床杂志.2001,17(4):3
108 张旭霞.针刺为主治疗周围性面瘫[J].湖北中医杂志.2004,26(6):49
109 刘长军.针灸治疗面瘫60例[J].湖南中医药导报.2001,7(3):114
110 李镤.穴位治疗法临床大全[M].北京:中国中医药出版社.1996:356
111 李玉梅.针刺治疗颜面神经麻痹40例[J].江苏中医.1997,18(2):32
112 宋水田.辨证针灸配合挑刺治疗面瘫52例[J].中医外科杂志.2003,12(40):45
113 何树槐,唐玉秀,唐丽亭.针灸治疗面神经麻痹75例的临床观察[J].中国针灸.1985,5(3):10
114 李传岐.针灸辨治面瘫病的三因四法[J].四川中医.2001,19(7):69
115 夏晨,陈亮.周围性面瘫早期临床表现与预后的相关性研究[J].临床神经病学杂志.1997,10(4):248
116 丛品,李正虹.63例周围性面瘫的辨证治疗[J].山东中医学院学报.1994,18(1):45-46
117 郭润田.辨证治疗周围性面瘫临床总结[J].北京中医.1997,(1):32
118 陈立富.葛根牵正汤治疗周围性面瘫56例[J].吉林中医药.1995,(1):18
119 卢国莲,王胜.祛风通络饮治疗周围性面瘫100例[J].湖北中医杂志.1995,17(6):14
120 于功浩.柴葛解肌汤治疗周围性面瘫40例[J].中国基层医药.1999,6(5):283
121 周桂云.牵正散加味治疗周围性面瘫50例[J].云南中医药杂志.2001,22(4):31-32
122 徐分根.普济消毒饮加味治疗面瘫12例疗效观察[J].时珍国医国药.2000,11(5):461-462
123 夏时金.龙胆泻肝汤治疗急性周围性面瘫31例[J].成都中医学院学报.1994,17(1):29
124 潘进财.苏合香丸治疗面瘫23例[J].新疆中医药.1997,15(2):47
125 刘庆武,王霞.仙虫汤治疗周围性面瘫89例疗效观察[J].现代中西医结合杂志.2001,10(22):2205
126 张怡安.补阳还五汤加蜈蚣治疗周围性面瘫26例[J].中医研究.1998,11(5):26
127 胡地生.对针刺太冲、合谷穴治面瘫的认识[J].江西中医学院学报.1987,9(增刊):16
128 曹少鸣.李芝荣治疗面神经炎经验总结[J].云南中医中药杂志.1987,18:41
129 申旭德.再论面瘫针灸法[J].新疆中医药.1997,15(1):21-22
130 戴果福.针刺治疗面瘫106例疗效观察[J].针灸临床杂志.1998,14(2):19-20
131 李玉梅.针测治疗颜面神经麻痹40例[J].江苏中医.1997,18(2):32
132 李桂兰,陆小左.单用肘髎穴治疗周围性面瘫[J].针刺研究.1998,(4):309-310
133 何业理.针灸治疗周围性面瘫100例[J].河北中医.1993,15(5):24-25
134 吴清明.关于针刺治疗面神经麻痹的手法适宜问题[J].针灸学报.1992,8(1):36
135 钱德金,张桂香,提慧,等.治疗周围性面神经麻痹的最佳穴位和手法的筛选[J].江苏中医杂志.1986,(3):1
136 刘傲霜.环透针治疗周围性面神经炎120例[J].新中医.1995,27(10):36
137 杨洁.四联针透穴法治疗面瘫50例[J].陕西中医.1995,16(10):465
138 徐锦平.透穴治疗面神经麻痹39例[J].辽宁中医杂志.1996,23(5):230
139 田雁.面三针透刺法治疗周围性面瘫48例[J].四川中医.2002,20(2):77
140 李素仁.扇形透刺法治疗面瘫[J].四川中医.2001,19(11):72
141 董德礼.两点一圈法治疗周围性面瘫临床观察[J].天津中医学院学报.1993,12(1):18
142 戴自明.透刺法治疗周围性面瘫60例临床观察[J].中国针灸.1998,(11):679—680
143 李常度,李应昆,蒋振亚.多针浅刺法治疗难治性面瘫[J].中医杂志.1994,35(7):439
144 王铸.浅刺法加走罐治疗周围性面瘫60例[J].天津中医学院学报.2000,19(3):23-24
145 吴奇方.短针浅刺法治疗面瘫60例[J].上海针灸杂志.1999,(18):28
146 刘敏.浅针多刺法和药物疗法治疗面瘫130例疗效的对比观察[J].针灸临床杂志.1996,12(5,6):56
147 冯娅,刘芳.多针浅刺治疗面瘫100例疗效观察[J].云南中医中药杂志.1997,18(4):23
148 吴奇方.短针浅刺法治疗面瘫60例[J].上海针灸杂志.1999,18(3):28
149 董洪英,尚秀英,李慧娟.浅刺法治疗急性面瘫的临床体会[J].针灸临床杂志.1997,13(10):23-24
150 甘承铨,李维全.针刺健侧治疗周围性面神经麻痹40例[J].安徽中医学院学报.1992,11(1):46-47
151 王子臣,王声强.“分期针刺法”治疗周围性面瘫31例疗效观察[J].中国针灸.2002,22(7):453-454.
152 陈静.分期针刺治疗周围性面瘫60例[J].中国民间疗法.2001,9(7):10
153 卓华.针刺治疗周围性面瘫340例[J].广西中医药.2000,23(4):36
154 陈雪琴.周围性面瘫针灸治疗时机之我见[J].浙江中医学院学报.2002,26(6):57
155 李文金.面瘫针刺治疗时机探析[J].辽宁中医杂志.2004,31(4):339-340
156 王世惠,王宏亮.针灸治疗周围性面神经麻痹141例[J].上海针灸杂志.1996,15(5):21
157 方善美,冯桂梅.周围性面神经麻痹针刺时机选择[J].中国针灸.2001,21(7):405
158 由利明,魏峰,何玉珂.刺络艾灸治疗150例面瘫疗效观察[J].中国民间疗法.1997,(1):18
159 史彩兰,姜华.琦艾灸翳风穴治疗周围性面瘫146例[J].安徽中医临床杂志.1997,(5):248
160 沈美兰,丁仁详.隔姜灸治疗顽固性面瘫21例[J].针灸临床杂志.1997,(9):36
161 赵圣文,任大昌.冷灸发泡治疗面瘫56例[J].中医外治杂志.1997,(2):17
162 熊青光,刘民勇.药物温烤劳宫治疗面瘫初探[J].江西中医学院报.1997,(3):28
163 张俊,张德基.灸神闭穴为主治疗面瘫110例[J].上海针灸杂志.1997,(2):22
164 袁志太.隔苇管灸治疗周围性面瘫30例[J].中医外治杂志.1997,(5):6
165 缪希寿.药棉灸治疗贝尔氏面瘫86例临床观察[J].福建中医杂志.1999,(4):55
166 朱红影.艾灸翳风、下关穴治疗周围性面瘫186例[J].上海针灸杂志.1998,(4):28
167 张峰.天灸法治疗面神经麻痹24例[J].湖北中医杂志.2000,(3);46-47
168 许晓玲.自制药艾盘灸下关、翳风穴治疗周围性面神经麻痹120例[J].中医外治杂志.2001,(2):21
169 侯文凤.电针治疗急性期面瘫54例疗效观察[J].陕西中医函授.1997,(1):29
170 俞迈红.电针治疗面瘫的临床体会[J].浙江中医学院报.1997,(3):49
171 黄国峰,周章玲.穴位结合肌肉走行电针治疗顽固性面瘫25例临床疗效分析[J].中国针灸.1999,(12):733-734
172 郑平.电针最佳选穴方法治疗周围性面瘫66例[J].针灸临床杂志.1998,(10):14-15
173 张兰杰,杨炎.周围性面瘫分期电针治疗结果对比分析[J].吉林中医药.1998,(5):12
174 郭金友,赵锦梅,王云芳.电针透穴法治疗面瘫143例临床疗效分析[J].陕西中医. 2000,(11):515
175 张雅琳.电鍉针配合新穴治疗周围性面瘫疗效观察[J].针灸临床杂志.2000,(4);37
176 李应时.针灸治疗周围性面神经麻痹不同治疗频度的疗效观察[J].中国针灸.2000,(9):527-528
177 蔡爱珍.针灸配穴位注射治疗面瘫43例[J].福建中医药.2003,34(1):18
178 杨奉源.听宫穴注射治周围性面瘫[J].新中医.2004,22(5):142
179 于金栋.穴位注射结合针刺治疗周围性面瘫疗效分析[J].中国针灸.2004,24(7):465
180 李先锋.穴位注射配合中药治疗周围性面神经麻痹49例[J].河南中医药学刊.2000,(15):426
181 史彦凤.针刺加穴位注射加兰他敏治疗面瘫80例[J].中国中医基础医学杂志.2003,9(4):65
182 章进.牵正膏治疗面神经炎94例[J].中医外治杂志.2000,(1);21
183 张园.中药敷贴治疗周围性面神经麻痹46例[J].中医外治杂志.2000,(1):9
184 段成华.新牵正膏治疗面神经麻痹407例[J].中医外治杂志.2000,(2):189
185 焦福全,周修予,闻清海.面瘫膏穴位敷贴治疗特发性面神经麻痹590例临床观察[J].针刺研究.1998,(3):189
186 靳慧涛.放血疗法治疗面神经麻痹42例[J].中华实用中西医杂志.2004,4(17):15
187 韩小军.耳背放血配合中药口服治疗周围性面瘫[J].中国临床医生.2003,31(2):52
188 连远义.放血疗法治疗面瘫120例[J].北京中医.2004,23(4):247
189 宋守军.蜂针治疗面瘫临床观察[J].黑龙江中医药.2001,24(2):39
190 付欣.蜂针治疗顽固性面瘫64例临床观察[J].中国民间医药杂志.2000,47:333
191 张亿平.滞针奇拉法治疗顽固性面瘫[J].山东中医杂志.2001,20(9):574
192 王燕.滞针法结合功能锻炼治疗面瘫后遗症70例[J].新疆中医药.2003,21(2):28
193 姜卫东.温针治疗周围性面瘫180例[J].山东中医杂志.2004,23(2):91
194 刘存本.针刺结合温灸翳风分期治疗周围性面瘫58例[J].现代中西医结合杂志.2001,10(20):1982
195 吕其林.透刺加拔罐治疗周围性面神经麻痹230例[J].广西中医药.1997,(1):40
196 刘金芝,杨顺益.针刺加拔罐治疗面神经麻痹的体会[J].针灸临床杂志.2000,(10): 23-24
197 陈力,俞兰英.针刺配合拔罐治疗面神经炎51例[J].上海针灸杂志.2000,(1):31
198 李颖,李建平,黄静.面部透刺配合火罐治疗面瘫[J].北京中医药大学学报.1998,(2):67
199 杨火详.针刺加药罐疗法治疗顽固性面神经麻痹51例[J].陕西中医.1998,(3):29-30
200 蔡影兵.针刺配合推拿治疗面瘫的体会[J].陕西中医杂志.1998,(4):22
201 焦使军.针灸结合推拿治疗面瘫167例[J].中国民间疗法.1999,(2):23
202 陈学农,周清毅,赵开祝,等.穴位理线治疗陈旧性面瘫158例的临床研究[J].针灸临床杂志.2003,19(12):35
203 潘良德.针灸加短波治疗周围性面瘫38例临床分析[J].针灸临床杂志.2004,20(4):27
204 余其华.针灸治疗面瘫60例[J].现代医药卫生.2004,20(8):664
205 齐军.针刺下关穴配合He-Ne照射治疗面神经麻痹25例体会[J].甘肃中医.2000,13(6):44
206 牙祖蒙,王建华,李忠禹,等.穴位针刺对面神经再生影响的实验研究[J].针刺研究.1999,24(2):111-115
207 刘洋.多针浅刺分期治疗周围性面瘫的临床与实验研究.2005,4:46
208 Hare GMT, Evans PJ,Mackinnon SE,et al.Walking track anyasis:A long-term assessment of peripheral nerve recovery[J].Plast Reconstr Surg. 1992,89:251-258
209 卢世壁,徐仕奇,刘郑生,等.神经节苷脂对损伤神经再生作用的动物实验[J].中华骨科杂志.1988,8(2):134
210 胥少汀,郭世绂主编.脊髓损伤基础与临床[M].北京:人民卫生出版社.1993:264
211 Yasuda I. Fundamental aspects of fractures treatment[J]. J Kyoto Med Soc. 1953, 4:395
212 Bassctt CAL,et al. Effects of electrical currents on bone formation in vivo[J]. Nature. 1964,204:652
213 Shamos MH,Lawine LS. Piezoelectricity as a fundamental property of biological tissues[J]. Nature. 1967,213:267
214 Jaffe LF, et al. An ultrasensitive vibrating probe for measuring steady extracellular currents[J].J Cell Bio1.1974,63:614
215 Jaffe LF, et al. Neurites grow faster towards the cathode than the anode in a stead field[J]. J Exp Zool.1979,209:115
216 Poo MM,et al. In situ electriphoresis of membrance components[J]. Annu Rev Biophys Bioeng. 1981,10:245
217 Hinke L. Mecaig CD, Robinaon KR. The direction of growth of differentiating neurons and myoblasts in an applied electrie field[J]. J Physiol(Lond).1981,314: 121
218 Blackshaw SE, Warner AE, Alterations in resting membrance properties during neural plare stages of development of the nervous system[J]. J Physiol(Lond). 1976,255:231
219 Pomerny B. Mullen M,Markus H. Effects of applied electric fields on sprouting of intact saphenous nerve in adult rat[J]. Bunin Res.1984,303:331
220 Berry CM,et al.The electrical activity of regenerating nerves in the cat[J].J Neurophysiology. 1944,7:103
221 Hodes R,et al.The human electromyogram in response to nerve stimulation and the conduction velocity of motor axons[J].Arch Neurol Psychia. 1948,60:340
222 Bruce H,Terzis JK.Single lascicular recordings;An interoperation diagnostic tool for the managerment of peripheral nerve lesions[J].Plas Surg. 1976,57:562-569
223 近藤彻.末梢神经传导速度耐定法[J].整形外科.1980,31:411
224 Dehon AL,Mackinnon SE.Selection of the appropriate parameter to measure neural regeneration[J].Annals Plastic Surgery. 1989,2:197
225 Levi-Montalcini R.The Nerve Growth Factor Thirty-five years Later[J]. Sicence. 1987, 237:1154
226 丁玄宙.1986年诺理尔生理学或医学奖:神经生长因子和表皮生长因子的发现[J].生理科学进展.1987,18(2):191