贸易信贷在中国货币政策传导中的作用研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
贸易信贷具有“准货币”性质,其对银行信贷存在一定程度的替代性,因而贸易信贷能够对货币政策传导产生影响。经典的货币政策传导理论没有考虑贸易信贷的作用,对现实的解释力存在一定的问题,尤其是近几年中国的货币政策实施的效果与经典理论有较大背离。本文将贸易信贷纳入货币政策传导分析框架,在传统货币政策传导渠道理论基础上,分别构建含有贸易信贷的货币政策传导信贷渠道、汇率渠道和资产价格渠道。文章运用数理模型推导等方法对贸易信贷与货币政策关系进行了深入分析。
     本文除了对总体的贸易信贷进行讨论之外,还分别针对国际贸易信贷和伪国际贸易信贷进行分析,对三个层次的贸易信贷分别进行理论和实证研究,以求全面分析贸易信贷在中国货币政策传导中的作用。
     本文运用中国实际数据,针对贸易信贷对中国货币政策变动的响应进行了实证研究,结果表明,总体上贸易信贷对紧缩的货币政策做出增加的响应,对扩张的货币政策做出减少的响应;国际贸易信贷资产额对国内紧缩货币政策做出减少的响应,对国内扩张的货币政策做出增加的响应。货币政策对贸易信贷、国际的影响存在一定程度的“非对称效应”,扩张的货币政策影响更大。同时,分别对含有贸易信贷的货币政策传导信贷渠道、汇率渠道和资产价格渠道进行实证检验,进一步分析贸易信贷在其中的作用。从而从贸易信贷在货币政策中发挥的作用这个视角,一定程度解释了我国货币政策传导的实际情况。文章的实证分析分别针对广义贸易信贷、国际贸易信贷和“伪国际贸易信贷”展开,结果表明,贸易信贷对货币政策传导存在一定的弱化作用,国际贸易信贷对货币政策传导渠道是短期弱化长期加剧作用。对于不同的传导渠道,贸易信贷的作用方式略有差异。本文针对国际资本非法利用贸易信贷出入境的问题,对这部分“伪国际贸易信贷”规模进行了估算,并且进行了实证分析,结果表明伪贸易信贷对我国货币政策调控资产价格的作用存在一定程度的弱化作用。
     文章建议货币当局在制定货币政策时需充分考虑到贸易信贷在货币政策传导过程中所起到的作用,对于国际资本流动要加强监管防止伪国际贸易信贷的猖獗。同时,鉴于贸易信贷灵活、便捷的特点,其可以作为企业融资的一个重要方式,而且目前已经有越来越多的企业采用贸易信贷进行融资,我们需要对贸易信贷的发展进行积极引导,引导其健康发展,让贸易信贷对经济发展发挥积极作用。
Trade credit could be a kind of quasi-money. It could be substitute of money and bank credit, so it should affect monetary policy transmission. The traditional theory of monetary policy transmission had limited power to explain the effect of China's monetary policy. This paper considered trade credit into monetary policy transmission. Based on traditional theory of monetary policy transmission, this paper established three new monetary policy transfer channels containing trade credit, which were credit channel, exchange rate channel and asset price channel. The author used mathematic models and econometric models to study the relation between trade credit and monetary policy.
     This paper didn't only study the whole trade credit, but also study international trade credit and fake international tradecredi. To study trade credit's role in China's monetary policy better, we studied 3 kinds of trade credit.
     We did an empirical study of how trade credit responsed when China monetary policy changed. The result was that constrictive monetary policy made trade credit increase and expansionary monetary policy made trade credit decrease. We also found "dissymmetrical effect" exist when monetary policy affected trade credit. The second empirical study of this paper was about what trade credit do in the three new monetary policy channels, and what the real channels should be. Based on this view, it explained China's monetary policy effect well. Empirical study had been divided for three kinds of trade credit, which were generalized trade credit, international trade credit and fake international trade credit. The result showed that trade credit could frustrate monetary policy. Especially, international trade credit weakened monetary policy in the short run but strengthened it in the long run. The effects of trade credit had some differences between different channels. This paper estimated the amount of fake international trade credit, which was used as illegal channels for international hot money. We found that fake international trade credit weakened China's monetary policy effect to some extent.
     We suggested that the authority should consider trade credit's effect when they changed monetary policy. The government should control fake international trade credit more seriously. As trade credit had its advantadges like convenience, many enterprises depended on it We proposed some suggestions on how to make trade credit have good effect.
引文
1.Alex N.McLeod.Some observations on trade credit and monetary policy[J].The Economic Journal,1964,74(295):729-734
    2.Andrew K.Rose,Ben Lockwood,Danny Quah.One money,one market:the effect of common currencies on Trade[J].Economic Policy,2000,15(30):7-45.
    3.Anthony F.Herbst.A factor analysis approach to determining the relative endogen of trade credit[J].The Journal of Finance,1974,29(4):1087-1103
    4.Arthur B.Laffer.Trade credit and the money market[J].The Journal of Political Economy,1970.,78(2):239-267
    5.Benjamin S.Wilner.The exploitation of relationships in financial distress:the case of trade credit[J].The Journal of Finance,2000,55(1):153-178
    6.Ben S.Bernanke,Mark Gertler.Inside the black box:the credit channel of monetary policy transmission[J].The Journal of Economic Perspectives,1995,9(4):27-48.
    7.Bernanke Ben S.A conference panel discussion:what do we know about how monetary policy affects the economy?[J].The Federal Reserve Bank of St.Louis Review,1995,(May.-Jun.):127-142
    8.Bernanke Ben S,Mark Gertler.Agency costs,net worth,and business fluctuations[J].American Economic Review 1989,(79):14-31
    9.Blinder Alan S.Credit rationing and effective supply failures[J].Economic Journal,1987,(June.):327-52
    10.Brunner Karl,Alan H.Meltzer.Money,debt,and economic activity[J].Journal of Political Economy,1972,Sep.-Oct.(80):951-77
    11.Bruno Biais,Christian Gollier.Trade credit and credit rationing[J].The Review of Financial Studies,1997,10(4):903-937
    12.C.W.Newbury.Credit in early nineteenth century West African trade[J].The Journal of African History,1972,13(1):81-95
    13. Charles W. Haley, Robert C. Higgins. Inventory policy and trade credit[J]. Financing, Management Science, Application Series, Part 1. 1973,20(4):464-471
    14. Christian J., W. Mazek. Corporate debt structure and the differential effects of monetary policy[J].The Southern Economic Journal, 1969,35(Apr.):359-368
    15. Christina D. Romer, David H. Romer, Stephen M. Goldfeld, Benjamin M. Friedman. New evidence on the monetary transmission mechanism. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity[J]. 1990,(1):149-213.
    16. Christine R. Hekman. The effect of trade credit on price and price level comparisons.The Review of Economics and Statistics[J]. 1981,63(4):526-532.
    17. Collins M. Monetary policy and the supply of trade credit: 1830-1844[J]. Econometrica, 1978, (45):379-389
    18. Cook L.D. Trade credit and bank finance:financing small firms in Russia[J]. Journal of Bussiness Venturing, 1999,(14):493-518
    19. David C. Ewert. Trade-credit management: selection of accounts receivable Using a statistical model[J]. The Journal of Finance, 1968,23(5):891-892.
    20. Deborah J. Lucas. Comment on financial intermediation and monetary policy in a general equilibrium banking model[J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 1995,27(4):1316-1319.
    21. Edward V. Huntington. On the mathematical hypotheses underlying Carl Snyder's trade-credit-ratio theorem[J]. Econometrica, 1938,6(2):177-179.
    22. Emery, G.W. An optimal financial response to variable demand[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 1987, (Jun.): 209-225.
    23. Fleming J.M. Domestic financial policies under fixed and under floating exchange rates[Z]. IMF Staff Papers, 1962,(9): 369-379.
    24. F. P. R. Brechling; R. G. Lipsey. Trade credit and monetary policy[J]. The Economic Journal, 1963,73(292):618-641.
    25. Frank Zahn, William R. Hosek.Impact of trade credit on the velocity of money and the market rate of interest[J]. Southern Economic Journal, 1973,40(2): 202-209.
    26. Frederick C. Scherr. Optimal trade credit limits[J]. Financial Management, 1996, 25(1):71-85.
    27.Frederic S.Mishkin.Symposium on the monetary transmission mechanism[J].The Journal of Economic Perspectives,1995,9(4):3-10.
    28.Gary W,Emery.A pure financial explanation for trade credit[J].The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1984,19(3):271-285.
    29.George C.Bitros.Neoclassical theory of trade credit:a critique and a Reformulation[J].Econometrica,1979,47(1):199-202.
    30.Gertler Mark.Financial structure and aggregate economic activity:an overview[J].Journal of Money,Credit,and Banking,1988,20(3):559-88.
    31.Graham Hacche,John Townend.Exchange rates and monetary policy:modelling sterling's effective exchange rate,1972-80[Z].Oxford Economic Papers,New Series,Supplement:The Money Supply and the Exchange Rate.1981,33(Jul.):201-247.
    32.Greenwald Brace,Joseph E.Stiglitz,Andrew Weiss.Informational imperfections in the capital market and macroeconomic fluctuations[J].American Economic Review,1984,194-99
    33.G.S.Laumas.Trade credit and the demand for money by the business sector:comment[J].Southern Economic Journal,1975,42(2):320-321.
    34.Harry G.Johnson.The international monetary system and the rule of law [J].Journal of Law and Economics,1972,15(2):277-292.
    35.Harry G.Johnson.The monetary approach to balance of payments theory and policy:explanation and policy implications[J].Economica,New Series,1977,44(175):217-229.
    36.Inessa Love,Lorenzo A.Preve,Virginia Sarria-Allende.Trade credit and bank credit:evidence from recent financial crises[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2007,(83):453-469
    37.Ivan E.Brick,William K.H.Fung.Taxes and the theory of trade cebt[J].The Journal of Finance,1984,39(4):1169-1176
    38.Ivan E.Brick,William K.H.Fung.The effect of taxes on the trade credit decision[J].Financial Management,1984,13(2):24-30.
    39. James W. Christian. An approach to the analysis of the differential effects of monetary policy[J]. The Journal of Finance, 1967,22(1):97.
    
    40. Janet Kiholm Smith. Trade credit and informational asymmetry[J].The Journal of Finance, 1987,42(4): 863-872.
    
    41. J. B. Coates. Trade credit and monetary policy: a study of the accounts of 50 companies[J]. Oxford Economic Papers, New Series, 1967,19(1):116-132.
    
    42. Jeffrey H. Nilsen. Trade credit and the bank lending channel[J]. Journal of Money,Credit and Banking, 2002,34(1):226-253.
    
    43. Jensen Michael, William Meckling. Theory of the firm: managerial behavior,agency costs, and capital structure[J]. Journal of Financial Economics.1976,(Oct.):305-60.
    
    44. J. Stephen Ferris. A transactions theory of trade credit use[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1981,96(2):243-270.
    
    
    45. Johann Scharler. Bank lending and the stock market's response to monetary policy shocks[J]. International Review of Economics and Finance,2008,17(3):425-435.
    
    46. John B. Taylor. The monetary transmission mechanism: an empirical framework[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1995,9(4): 11-26.
    
    47. John B. Taylor. The role of the exchange rate in monetary-policy Rules[J]. The American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings of the Hundred Thirteenth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association. 2001,91(2):263-267.
    
    48. John O. Gerald. Influence of trade credit on broiler production[J]. Journal of Farm Economics, 1955,37(5):950-959
    
    49. Jon Faust, Lars E. O. Svensson. The equilibrium degree of transparency and control in monetary policy[J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 2002,34(2):520-539.
    
    50. J. Vernon Henderson. Increasing returns to scale, free trade, and factor mobility: a note on equilibrium[J].The Canadian Journal of Economics, 1972,5(2):293-298.
    
    51. Ka-Fu Wong. Variability in the effects of monetary policy on economic activity[J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 2000,32(2): 179-198.
    52.Karen K.Lewis.Are foreign exchange intervention and monetary policy related,and does it really matter?[J].The Journal of Business,1995,68(2):185-214.
    53.Karl Brunner,Allan H.Meltzer.Money and credit in the monetary transmission process[J].The American Economic Review,1988,78(2):446-451.
    54.Kashyap Anal K,Jeremy C.Stein,David W.Wilcox.Monetary policy and credit conditions:evidence from the composition of external finance[J].The American Economic Review,1993,83(1):78-98.
    55.King Stephen R.Monetary transmission:though bank loans or bank liabilities[J].Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,1986,(18):290-303
    56.Kiyotaki;Nobuhiro,John Moore.Credit cycles[J].Journal of Political Economy,1997,105(2):211-248.
    57.Kohler M.,Britton E.,Yates T.Trade credit and monetary transmission mechanism[Z].Woking paper issued by the Bank of England,2000,115.
    58.Kurt F.Hausafus.Trade finance,capital movements and the stability of the foreign exchange market[J].International Economic Review,1975,16(2):404-414.
    59.Kurt F.Hausafus.Financial institutions and international capital movements:portfolio selection ortrade finance?[J].Journal of Money,Credit and Banking,1976,8(3):359-371.
    60.Laffer Arthur B.Trade credit and the money market[J].The Journal of Political Economy,1970,78(2):239-267.
    61.Lawrence J.Christiano,Martin Eichenbaum,Charles Evans.The effects of monetary policy shocks:evidence from the Flow of Funds[J].The Review of Economics and Statistics,1996,78(1):16-34.
    62.Marc Deloof,Marc Jegers.Trade credit,product quality,and intragroup trade:some european evidence[J].Financial Management,1996,25(3):33-43.
    63.Marc Nerlove,Kenneth J.Arrow.Optimal advertising policy under dynamic conditions[J].Economica,1962,29(114):129-142.
    64.Mark Gertler,Simon Gilchrist.The role of credit market imperfections in the monetary transmission mechanism:arguments and evidence[J].The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 1993, 95(1): 43-64.
    65. Maurice Mann. How does monetary policy affect the economy[J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 1969,1(3):538-548.
    66. Meade J.E. The Theory of International Economic Policy Voll:The Balance of Payments[M]. London:Oxford University Press. 1951,58-60.
    67. Meir Tamari. The nature of trade credit[J]. Oxford Economic Papers, New Series, 1970,22(3):406-419.
    68. Meltzer, A. H. Mercantile credit, monetary policy and size of firms[J]. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1960,42(4) :429-43 7.
    69. Menachem Katz. The cost of borrowing, the terms of trade and the determination of external debt[J]. Oxford Economic Papers, New Series, 1982,34(2):332-345.
    70. Michael Collins. Monetary policy and the supply of trade credit, 1830- 1844[J]. Economica, New Series, 1978,45(180):379-389.
    71. Michael S. Long, Ileen B. Malitz, S. Abraham Ravid. Trade credit, quality guarantees and product marketability[J]. Financial Management, 1993,22(4):117-127.
    72. Michell A. Peterson, Raghuram G. Rajan. Trade credit: theories and evidence[J]. The Review of Financial Studies, 1997,10(3) :661-691.
    73. Mike Burkart, Tore Ellingsen. In-kind finance: a theory of trade credit[J]. The American Economic Review, 2004,94(3):569-590.
    74. M. I. Nadiri. The determinants of trade credit in the U.S. total manufacturing sector[J]. Econometrica, 1969,37(3): 408-423.
    75. M. J. Artis, D. A. Currie. Monetary targets and the exchange rate: a case for conditional targets[J].Oxford Economic Papers New Series, Supplement: The Money Supply and the Exchange Rate. 1981,33 (Jul.): 176-200.
    76. Morgan Donald. The lending view of monetary policy and loan commitments[Z]. Research working paper, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, 1992,92-09
    77. Moshe Ben-Horim, Haim Levy. Inflation and the trade credit perlod[J]. Management Science, 1982,28(6):646-651.
    78. Mundell Robert A. Capital mobility and stabilization policy under fixed and flexible exchange rates[J].Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science,1963,(Nov.):475-485.
    79.Newmarch W.An attempt to a scertain the magnitude and fluctuations of the amount of bills of exchange:1828-1847[J].Journal of the Statistical Society,1851,(14):143-183.
    80.Oliner Stephen,Glenn Rudebusch.The transmission of monetary policy to small and large firms[Z].Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System,1992,653-54.
    81.Patrick Minford.The exchange rate and monetary policy[J].Oxford Economic Papers,New Series,Supplement:The Money Supply and the Exchange Rate.1981,33(Jul.):120-142.
    82.Paul E.Junk.Monetary policy and fluctuations in the extension of trade credit[J].The Journal of Finance,1962,17(4):677-678.
    83.Paul E.Junk.Monetary policy and the extension of trade credit[J].Southern Economic Journal,1964,30(3):274-277.
    84.Pentti J.K.Kouri,Michael G.Porter.International capital flows and portfolio Equilibrium[J].The Journal of Political Economy,1974,82(3):443-467.
    85.Peter J.Montiel.The transmission mechanism for monetary policy in developing countries[J].Staff Papers-International Monetary Fund,1991,38(1):83-108.
    86.Raymond Fisman,Inessa Love.Trade credit,financial intermediary development and industry growth[J].The Journal of Finance,2003,58(1):353-374.
    87.Ravul V.Fabella.The debt-adjusted real exchange rate[J].Journal of International Money and Finance,1996,15(3):475-484.
    88.R.G.Lipsey,F.P.R.Brechling.Trade credit and monetary policy:a rejoinder[J].The Economic Journal,1966,76(301):165-167.
    89.Richard A.Ward.U.S.monetary policy and the balance of payments:1950-60[J].The Journal of Finance,1962,17(4):675-676.
    90.Richard H.Keenh.A note on the cost of trade credit and the discriminatory effects of monetary policy[J].The Journal of Finance,1974,29(5):1581-1582.
    91.R.K.Ashton.Trade credit and the economic order quantity-a further extension[J]. The Journal of the Operational Researrch Society, 1987,38(9): 841-846.
    
    92. Robert A. Schwartz. An economic model of trade credit[J]. The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 1974,9(4):643-657.
    
    93. Romer Christina D., David H.Romer. Does monetary policy matter? A new test in the spirit of Friedman and Schwartz[J]. NBER Macroeconomics Annual 1989,(4): 121-70.
    
    94. Schwartz T. Whitcomb. The Trade Credit Decisions. In J. Bicksler (ed.),Handbook of Financial Economics[M] .Amsterdam: North Holland, 1980, 257-73.
    
    95. Silber W.M. Polakoff. The differential effects of tight money: an econometric study[J]. Journal o f Finance, 1970,25(1):83-97.
    
    96. Stiglitz Joseph E., Andrew Weiss. Credit rationing in market with imperfect information[J]. American Economic Review, 1981,393-410.
    
    97. Thomas R. Saving. Monetary-policy targets and indicators[J]. The Journal of Political Economy, 1966,75(4):446-456.
    
    98. Tobin James. A general equilibrium approach to monetary theory[J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking. 1970,(Nov.):2461-72.
    
    99. Tooke T., Newmarch W. A history of prices[M]. London: Longman, Brown,Green, Longman and Roberts, 1857,584.
    
    100.Willi Semmler, Wenlang Zhang. Asset price volatility and monetary policy rules:a dynamic model and empirical evidence[J].Economic Modelling,2007,(24):411-430.
    
    101.William H. Branson. The capital account in the United States balance of payments[J]. The Journal of Finance, 1968,23(4):679-680.
    102.William H. Branson, Lawrence Krause, John Kareken, Walter Salant. Monetary policy and the new view of international capital movements[J]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1970,(2) :235-270.
    103 .William H. White. Trade credit and monetary policy: a reconciliation[J]. The Economic Journal, 1964,74(296):935-945.
    104.William McChesney Martin. Monetary policy and international payments[J]. The Journal of Finance, 1963,18(l):l-10.
    105.Ying Ge,Jiaping Qiu.Financial development,bank discrimination and trade credit[J].Journal of Banking & Finance,2007,(31):513-530.
    106.Yiting Li.A search model of money and circulating private debt with applications to monetary policy[J].International Economic Review,2001,42(4):925-946.
    107.Yul W.Lee,John D.Stowe.Product risk,asymmetric information,and trade Credit[J].The Journal of Financial and Quantitative.Analysis,1993,28(2):285-300.
    108.彼得.纽曼[美],默里.米尔盖特[美],约翰,伊特韦尔[英].新帕尔格雷夫货币金融大辞典[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2000:672,740.
    109.陈涛.中国货币政策非对称效应研究[D].硕士学位论文,西南财经大学,2006:3-4.
    110.楚尔鸣.中国货币政策汇率传导有效性的实证分析[J].湘潭大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2006,(3):52-58.
    111.陈永锋.我国货币政策传导渠道的研究[D].硕士学位论文,重庆大学,2007
    112.戴世宏.不完全汇率传递理论:汇率变动对改善贸易差额的作用有限[J].中国外汇,2007,(2-3):28-29.
    113.韩红梅,刘斌.我国贸易信贷抽样调查的研究与实践[J],统计研究,2004,(9):53-54.
    114.和萍.渐进资本开放下中国货币政策的独立性[J].经济理论与经济管理,2006,(11):26-31.
    115.何泽荣,徐艳.论国际热钱[J].财经科学,2004,(2):87-90.
    116.黄蔚,彭真善.我国资本外逃与经济开放度的实证研究:1982-2004年[J].国际贸易问题,2006,(12):108-114.
    117.蒋丽丽,伍志文.资本外逃与金融稳定:基于中国的实证检验[J].财经研究,2006.(3):93-102.
    118.金雪军,张雪芳,李红坤.国际游资流入对我国宏观经济冲击机制分析[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2006,(3):112-121.
    119.李红坤.国际游资流入效应及其防范[J].统计研究,2005(11):43-47.
    120.李如一,李光泉.贸易信贷的或有债权分析[J].天津理工学院学报,2004.(2):16-19.
    121.刘彬.贸易信贷:小企业的有效融资方式[J].国际经济合作,2006,(4):48-51.
    122.刘纪显,张宗益,陈建梁.货币政策的汇率效应及人民币汇率定价研究[J].中国软科学,2004,(7):30-38.
    123.刘民权,徐忠,赵英涛.商业信用研究综述[J].世界经济,2004(1):66-80.
    124.刘仁伍.国际短期资本流动监管:理论与实证[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社.2008,(4-6):113-120.
    125.刘淄,仪垂林.开发性金融下我国货币政策传导机制探讨[J].南京经济学院学报,2002,(1):49-52.
    126.刘淄.金融开放条件下中国货币政策传导机制探讨[J].北方经贸,2002,(2):43-45.
    127.鲁炳荣,赵洪波.国际资本流动对我国货币政策的影响[J].中国外汇管理,2004(8):60-61.
    128.卢庆杰.中国货币政策工具有效性分析[J].复旦学报,2007,(1):47-56.
    129.孟晓宏,李春吉.国际资本流动对我国房地产价格的影响[J].世界经济与政治论坛,2006,(6):27-30.
    130.欧永生.货币政策传导的“信贷渠道”探讨[D].博士学位论文,华中科技大学,2004:15-17,31-33.
    131.曲凤杰.中国短期资本流动状况及统计实证分析[J].经济研究参考,2006(40):14-21.
    132.任惠,王智.资本外逃之谜[J].经济月刊,2001,(8):26-28.
    133.任啸.货币传导——中国货币政策传导的制度分析[M].成都:四川大学出版社,2005:9-26.
    134.盛朝晖.中国货币政策传导渠道效应分析:1994-2004[J].金融研究,2006,(7):22-29.
    135.宋勃,高波.国际资本流动对房地产价格的影响——基于我国的实证检验(1998-2006年)[J].财经问题研究,2007,(3):55-61.
    136.宋维佳.中国资本外逃:总量估计与成因分析[J].财经问题研究,1999,(5):28-33.
    137.宋红兵.中国的资本外逃问题研究:1987-1997[J].经济研究,1999,(5):39-48.
    138.宋旺,钟正生.我国货币政策区域效应的存在性及原因——基于最优货币区理 论的分析[J].经济研究,2006,(3):46-58.
    139.宋效中.我国货币政策的低效性及其原因[J].中国软科学,2002,(3):14-18.
    140.孙志贤.我国货币政策传导机制分析[D].博士学位论文,对外经济贸易大学,2005:11-20.
    141.唐旭,梁猛.中国的贸易顺差与热钱的关系[J].金融研究,2007,(9):1-19.
    142.陶为群.贸易结售汇差额与进出口差额关系的分析框架及实证[J].中国外汇管理,2003,(12):20-20.
    143.田素华.国际资本流动与货币政策效应[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,2008:240-247.
    144.王少平,涂正革,李子奈.预期增广的菲利普斯曲线及其对中国适用性检验.中国社会科学,2001(4):76-84.
    145.王琦.关于我国国际资本流动影响因素计量模型的构建和分析[J].国际金融研究,2006,(6):64-69.
    146.王振全,汪寿阳.我国资本外逃的渠道、规模与对策[J].战略与决策研究,2006,(3):202-206.
    147.吴青.国际收支管理对货币政策的影响[J].国际贸易问题,1999(4):45-49.
    148.徐明东,田素华.证券资本国际流动形式与货币政策有效性分析[J].国际金融研究,2007(3):61-67.
    149.杨波.对外贸易信贷规模及其统计方法的研究[J].浙江统计,2004(8):20-21,28.
    150.杨全发,陈平.国际资本流动的贸易效应分析[J].对外经济贸易大学学报,2002(6):11-16.
    151.杨胜刚,刘宗华.国际资本流动对中国货币供给的影响及政策分析[J].世界经济,2001,(6):61-66.
    152.于辉.中国货币政策有效性分析[D].博士学位论文,吉林大学,2005:128-135.
    153.余沿福,张敬来.国际游资涌入对货币供给的影响与对策[J].特区经济,2005,(8):234-235.
    154.张国亭,赵敏.我国资本外逃的主要渠道探析[J].经济工作导刊,2001,(2):18-19.
    155.张宏伟.国际贸易融资研究[D].博士学位论文,中国社会科学院研究生院,2001:7-8.
    156.赵进文,高辉.中国货币政策行为传导的动态模型检验——1993-2002年的实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2004(3):95-102.
    157.赵宇翔.商业信用影响因素研究:来自银行信贷的证据[J].金融理论与实践,2008,(6):38-42.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700