摘要
近年来造纸机车速不断提高,幅宽不断增加,中高速纸机国产化关键技术研究已经进入我国“863”计划。对于中高速纸机,在生产过程中旋转件不平衡问题变得更加突出,已成为必须关注的重要问题。而采用现场动平衡技术能够改善纸机旋转件的工作性能,并带来显著的经济效益。本文对造纸机械旋转件现场动平衡技术做了系统的研究,必将推进这项技术在我国造纸行业的发展和应用。
本文从理论上有针对性地分析了造纸机械旋转件不平衡的类型、振动机理,以及相应平衡理论方法;探讨了造纸机械旋转件及其支承系统的典型故障的机理、构件系统在诊断不平衡等过程中可能存在的影响;通过转子实验台模拟分析了造纸机旋转件的典型故障和现场动平衡过程;建立了造纸机械现场动平衡分析系统,探讨了动平衡分析系统的现场安装过程;最后,通过复卷机进行了现场动平衡实践。
本文研究结果如下:
(1)在现场动平衡研究中,可将造纸机械旋转件—支承系统看作单自由度振动系统处理。确定了辊体的平衡品质以及允许不平衡量在校正面上的分配。由于造纸机旋转件表面属于工作区,一般不宜作为校正面。因此,校正面位置仅限于两端,对大直径辊体可在端面附加片状质量块进行校正,对小直径辊体可在辊壳内表面附加棒状平衡重进行校正。
(2)造纸机械转子系统中,各零部件故障相互影响,可能有两个或两个以上故障的耦合出现,导致振动信号特征相互叠加,增加了诊断的难度。对此,可先通过转子实验台对现场可能存在的故障进行模拟分析确定。
(3)现场动平衡模拟实验结果表明,采用影响系数法可以快速有效地实现刚性转子平衡校正,更适于造纸机旋转件的现场动平衡。另外,平衡过程中发现校正面位置的选择会对平衡质量产生明显的影响。而采用振型平衡法可很好的实现转子过1阶临界转速的平衡,但此方法起停车次数多,计算较为复杂。
(4)采用非接触电涡流传感器测轴振,减少了轴承缺陷故障振动的干扰,快速、准确实现了对不平衡故障的诊断。考虑到某些转子组成部分涡流传感器安装不便,制定了以加速度传感器代替涡流传感器进行信号采集的备用方案。动平衡分析系统设计为三个模块,即故障监测诊断模块,数据管理模块和动平衡计算分析模块。便于实现对转子系统故障监测诊断,提高诊断效率,同时也提高了现场动平衡的效率。
(5)确定了校正配重计算方法,并设计了标准配重质量块尺寸和安装方式。
(6)通过对复卷机底辊的现场测试与动平衡实践,成功地将辊体的不平衡量控制在允许范围内,说明应用本文成果于造纸机械实际是可靠可行的。
In recent years, operating speed of paper machine continuously going up, the width increased, domestic research of key technologies on high-speed Machine have been listed into China's "863" programs. For high-speed machine, in the production process rotating parts unbalance becomes more prominent, and has become an important problem which must be concerned. Application of field balancing technique can improve performance of the rotating parts of paper machine and take significant economic benefits. In this paper, the systemic study of field balancing was done, for rotors of paper machinery, and this would promote this technology’s development and application in China's paper industry.
Theoretically, the types of unbalance and vibration mechanism of rotating parts of paper machinery, and the corresponding balancing theory were analyzed; The typical fault mechanism of rotating parts and support systems of paper machinery was discussed, and the effect of component systems in the diagnosis of unbalance which might exist was analyzed; Through rotor test-bed, simulation analysis on typical faults in place and field balancing of rotors of paper machinery was done; Develop the field balancing analysis system of paper machinery, and explore on-site installation process for the balancing analysis; Finally, the winder was balanced in place.
The results were as follows:
(1) In field balancing research, rotor-support system of paper machinery can be a single-freedom vibration system. The balance quality of roller and distribution of permissible unbalance on the end surface were determined. As the surface of rotating parts of paper machine was the working area, generally not suitable to be correction plane. Therefore, the position of correction plane was limited to two ends. For large-diameter rollers flake correction mass was added to the end surface, and for small-diameter rollers the rod of correction weight was added to inner surface of the roller crust.
(2) For paper machine rotor systems, faults of the components affect each other, may have two or more coupling fault-exist, and Superposition of characteristics of the vibration signal make the diagnosis more difficult. In this regard, we may do fault simulation analysis on possible faults in place through rotor test-bed.
(3) Simulation results of field balancing indicates that using the influence coefficient method can quickly and efficiently achieve rigid rotor’s dynamic balance, more suitable for rotors of paper machinery. In addition, the choice of correction plane is found to have a clear impact on quality of balance. And modal balancing method can be used to balance a rotor over 1st critical speed, but this method demands many times startup and stop of machine, and its calculation is more complex.
(4) Non-contact eddy current sensors were used to measure shaft vibration, to reduce vibration disturbances of the bearing defect, and rapidly, accurately realize diagnosis of unbalance fault. Taking into account the installation of eddy current sensors for some rotor components inconvenient, the spare plan of low frequency accelerometers was developed to replace eddy current sensors for signal acquisition. Balancing analysis system was designed for the three modules, namely, fault monitoring and diagnosis module, Data Management module and balance calculation and analysis module. Facilitated the achievement of monitoring and fault diagnosis for rotor system, and improved the diagnostic efficiency and the efficiency of field balancing.
(5) Determine the calculating method of counterweight, and design a standard size counterweight block and the installation method of counterweight.
(6) By field testing and balancing practice for the bottom roller of winder, roller unbalance was controlled within the permissible range. It shows that the result of this paper used to paper machinery is reliable and feasible.
引文
[1] 陈克复.制浆造纸机械与设备(下册)(第二版)[M].北京:中国轻工业出版社,2003
[2] 周保堂,贺世正.状态监测与整机动平衡技术在化工设备监测与维修中的应用[J].石油化工设备,1992,21(5):11-13
[3] 陈大禧.大型回转机械诊断现场实现技术[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2002.6-9
[4] 虞和济.设备故障诊断工程[M].北京:冶金工业出版社,2001.1-3
[5] 何正嘉,等.机械设备非平稳信号的故障诊断原理及应用[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2001
[6] 闻邦椿,武新华,等.故障旋转机械非线性动力学理论与实验[M].北京:科学出版社,2004
[7] 王明时.现代传感技术[M]. 北京:电子工业出版社,1995.15-29
[8] 姜建国.信号与系统分析基础[M].北京:清华大学出版社,1994.35-45
[9] 史习智,等.信号处理与软计算[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2003
[10] 石博强,申炎华.机械故障诊断的分形方法—理论与实践[M].北京:冶金工业出版社,2001.170-181
[11] 徐秀英,袁培新等.复杂机械故障诊断的分形与小波方法[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2003.1-10
[12] 张荣涛,孙宇等.远程分布式故障诊断技术的研究[J].工业仪表与自动化装置,2000(4).62-64
[13] 钱苏翔,杨勇,钟秉林.分布式故障诊断智能代理体系的研究[J].机电工程,2000,17(3):64-66
[14] 韩彦岭,陈云,等.基于代理与仿真技术的远程故障诊断系统[J].系统仿真学报,2004, 16(9):1961-1965
[15] Cal Keeney,J.M. (Jack) Dischner. Remote monitoring and Diagnostics of Mil Equipment[C].AIS Tech 2004 -Iron & Steel Technology Conference Proceedings (Vol. II),2004.499-503
[16] 尹学军,王伟强.转子动平衡等级、扰力与基础台板振动标准[J]. 电力建设,2003,24(9):44-47
[17] Guoxin Li, Zongli Lin, Costin Untaroiu, et al.Balancing of High-Speeding Machinery Using Convex Optimization[C].Proceedings of the 42nd IEEE Conference on Decision and Control,2003:4351-4356
[18] Goodman T P.A Least-Squares Method for Computing Balance Corrections[J].ASME J. Ind., 1964, 273–279
[19] Lund J W, Tonnesen J.Analysis and experiments on multi-plane balancing of a flexible rotor[J].Trans. ASME, J. Engineering for Industry,1972,94(1):233-242
[20] Darlow M S, Smalley A J, Parkinson A G.A Unified Approach to Flexible Rotor Balancing: Outline and Experimental Vertification[C]. “Vibration in Rotating Machinery”,2nd.Inter.Conference,1981.C340/80
[21] G B Karelitz. Field balancing rotors at operating speed[J].Power 67(6) (1928), 237-240
[22] G B Karelitz. Field balancing rotors at operating speed[J].Power 67(7) (1928), 286-289
[23] Foiles W C, Bently D E.Balancing with phase only (single-plane and multi-plane)[J].Journal of Vibration, Acoustics, Stress, and Reliability in Design, 1988, 110(2):151-157
[24] 汪海良,刘思汉.柔性转子无试重动平衡的试验研究.振动与冲击,1992(3):58-65
[25] 徐 平,周保堂,贺世正.整机和在线动平衡技术的现状[J].化工装备技术,1995,16(1):43-47
[26] 欧阳红兵,曾 胜,汪希萱.转子系统在线动平衡综述[J].机械强度,1997,19(4):20-24
[27] Abdefatah M. Mahamed, Tlene Busch-Vishnac.Imbalance Compensation and Automation Balancing in Magnetic Bearing Systems Using the Q-Parameterization Theory[J].IEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology,1995,3(2):202-211
[28] S Beale, B Shafai, P Larocca, et al. Adaptive Forced Balancing for Magnetic Bearing Control Systems[C].Proceedings of the 31st Conference on Decision and Control. IEEE, 1992.3535-3539
[29] 孙宝东,须根法,黄文虎,等. 转子自动平衡技术的实验研究[J].中国电机工程学报, 1995, 15(5):317-322
[30] Kwang-Keun Shin. Adaptive Control of Active Balancing Systems for Speeding Varying Rotating Machinery[D]. Dissertation of Ph.D.,University of Michigan.2001
[31] Shiyu Zhou, Jianjun Shi. Active Balancing and Vibration Control of Rotating Machinery:A survey[J].The Shock and Vibration Digest, 2001, 33(4):361-371
[32] 屈梁生,邱海,徐光华.全息谱动平衡技术:原理与实践[J].中国机械工程,1998,9(1):60-63
[33] 王久斌.基于 DSP 的转子动平衡测试系统的开发与研究[D].重庆大学硕士学位论文.2004
[34] 彭亮.一种智能化多功能动平衡测试仪的研究[D].华中硕士学位论文.2004
[35] 张志新.智能动平衡仪中硬件频谱分析的实现[J].流体机械,2002,30(10):40-42
[36] Kim P Y. Machinery Dynamics and Machinery Health Monitoring Technologies with Special Reference to Pulp and Paper Industry[C]. 75th Annual Meeting of the Canadian Pulp and Paper Association Technical Section, 1989, A85-A90
[37] 张 辉.造纸机械状态监测与故障诊断技术的应用与进展[J].中国造纸,2003,22(11):51-54
[38] 张 辉.现代造纸机械状态监测与故障诊断[M].北京:中国轻工出版社,2004
[39] McNally Robert H. Benefits of Roll Balancing[J].PIMA Magazine (Paper Industry Management Association), 1994, 33-34
[40] 赵彦荣. RYQ-1500 型辊筒动平衡机的研制[J].中国造纸,1995(5):30-34
[41] 周仁睦,石惟坚. 造纸机械滚筒与烘缸动平衡技术的近期发展[J].中华纸业,1993(4):55-57
[42] Bailey B. Roll Balancing In Place with a Portable Microprocessor Balancer [J].Pulp & Paper Canada, 1985, 86(11):82-84
[43] Alberto J. Flexible Roll Balancing [J]. Pulp & Paper Canada, 1997, 98(1):37-38
[44] Robichaud, J M.In-situ Roll Balancing: A Revolutionary Method for Improving Dryer Section Performance[J]. Pulp and Paper Canada, 2002, 103(12):83-86
[45] 张 辉,杨 超,陈明邦,等.纸机压榨部动态监诊方法[J].中国造纸,2004(6):31-35
[46] 张 辉,陈明邦.造纸机压榨部在线监测与故障诊断系统研究[J].振动、测试与诊断, 2004,24(4):285-289
[47] Darlow M S. Balancing of High-Speed Machinery: Theory, Methods and Experimental Results[J]. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 1987, 1(1):105-134
[48] Meacham W L, Talbert P B, Nelson H D, et al. Complex Model Balancing of Flexible Rotors including Residual Bow[J]. Journal of Propulsion and Power, 1988, 4(3):245-251
[49] Eshleman R. Field balancing of rotating machinery [C].Canadian Machinery Vibration Association Proceedings of 17th Machinery Vibration Seminar,1999
[50] Foiles W C, Allaire P E, Gunter E J. Review: Rotor balancing [J]. Shock and Vibration,1998,5(5-6):25-336
[51] 克利宗,齐曼斯基,雅科夫列夫(苏).转子动力学-弹性支承[M].北京:科学出版社,1987
[52] 钟一谔,何衍宗,王正,等.转子动力学[M].清华大学出版社,1987
[53] R.伽西,H.菲茨耐(西德). 转子动力学导论[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1975
[54] 周仁睦.转子动平衡:原理、方法和标准[M].北京:化学工业出版社,1992.
[55] 叶能安,余汝生.动平衡原理与动平衡机[M].武汉:华中工学院出版社,1985
[56] 三轮修三,下村玄(日本).旋转机械的平衡[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1992
[57] 韩平利,黄树红,贺国强,等.基于实验的转子动平衡影响系数优劣评价与提取[J].振动与冲击,2003,22(2):81-85
[58] 刘 石,屈梁生.回转机械故障诊断中的三维全息谱技术[J].西安交通大学学报,2004,38(9):900-903
[59] 邱 海,屈梁生.全息谱力、力偶分解法在全息动平衡中的应用[J]. 中国机械工程,1998,9(3):44-46
[60] 刘 雄,等.转子监测与诊断系统[M]. 西安:西安交通大学出版社,1991
[61] 刘 石,屈梁生.全息谱技术在现场动平衡前故障诊断中的应用[J].振动、测试与诊断,2004,24(4):270-274
[62] 贾民平,许飞云.小波尺度函数在旋转机械故障诊断中的应用[J].振动、测试与诊断.2004,24(1):6-10
[63] 乔卫东,马 薇,刘宏昭,等.小波包分析在机组转子系统不平衡测试中的应用[J].水力发电学报.2005, 24(3):48-51
[64] 张 鹏,孟 光,吴峰崎.小波分析降噪方法在碰磨和突加不平衡信号特征提取中的应用[J].汽轮机技术,2005,47(6):441-443
[65] 解德厚.纸机压辊的受力分析及查图求解[M].北京:中国轻工业出版社,1995
[66] 陈丽华. 纸机轴承故障的诊断分析和维护[J].中国造纸,2003,22(12):61-62
[67] 张 辉,王世雄,贾民平.宽幅纸机毛毯张紧辊特征故障振动频谱研究[J].2005, 24(10):43-44
[68] 刘鸿文.简明材料力学[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2002.191
[69] 杨 超.4800 纸机压榨部动态运行特征及其监诊方法的研究[D].南京林业大学,2005
[70] 张燕平,杨新超,师鹏.涡流传感器安装调试应注意的问题[J].西北电力技术,2003(2):26-32
[71] 董 瑾,潘育生.一种动平衡失效的简单校正方法[J].氯碱工业,1999(12):50
[72] 方 勇. 周移配重法现场校正动平衡[J].风机技术,2004(5):32-33