听障生的身份认同及其与心理健康的关系
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
身份认同作为一种相对稳定的心理过程,反映了个体或集体对自己所属的群体特征所持的认可和接纳态度。听障生作为社会的边缘群体,存在较严重的适应问题和心理问题。身份认同作为与听障生心理社会性发展联系密切的重要因素,长久以来被国内研究者所忽视,而目前,对于聋人的身份认同研究已成为国外聋人发展研究的新热点。当前,我国的特殊教育开始重视听障生的心理研究,但这些研究大多停留在认知与聋的关系探讨上,缺乏对听障生心理社会性发展的定量研究,尤其是每个听障生无法回避的“身份认同”问题。
     本研究分为两部分。首先,参考国外相关理论建构,对国内听障生的身份认同进行深度访谈,在此基础上编制《听障生身份认同问卷》,经检验,自编问卷信效度良好,符合心理测量学要求。其次,以自编问卷和scl-90症状自评量表为工具,以378名来自不同地区和学校的听障生为被试,深入探讨听障生身份认同的状况及影响因素,并进一步探索听障生的身份认同与心理健康的关系。研究得到以下结论:
     1我国听障生存在四种不同类型的身份认同:健听文化认同、听障文化认同、双文化认同、边缘性认同。听障生的健听文化认同和双文化认同倾向较高,边缘性认同倾向最低。
     2不同年龄段听障生的听障认同和边缘性认同存在显著差异。随着年龄发展,健听认同先降低后升高,听障认同先升高后降低,双文化认同持续降低,边缘性认同持续升高。
     3听障生的身份认同在不同性别、听力损失时间、父母听力状况、沟通方式、健听朋友数量、教师教育形式等方面存在显著差异。
     4在四类认同倾向的听障生中,典型健听认同和典型边缘性认同的听障生心理健康水平较差。
     5健听认同倾向与心理健康总体水平、躯体化、强迫、人际敏感、抑郁、焦虑、敌对、恐怖及其它呈显著负相关,听障认同倾向与人际敏感、抑郁、焦虑、恐怖呈显著负相关,边缘性认同倾向与抑郁和焦虑呈显著负相关。双文化认同倾向与心理健康无显著相关。
     6听障生的健听认同对其心理健康有显著的预测作用,听障生越认同健听文化,其心理健康状况越差。听障认同倾向对其焦虑心理有显著的预测作用,听障生越认同听障文化,其焦虑心理越严重。
Identity is a relatively stable psychological process.It reflects that individuals or groups recognized and accepted their group characteristics.As a social marginal group, the deaf students have more serious adaptation problems.Although the identity is closely related to psychosocial development, it has long been neglected by domestic researchers. Currently,the research on deaf identity development has become a new hot spot among foreign countries.Although the special education in China paying attention to the psychological study of the hearing-impaired students, most studies stay in discussion the relationship between cognition and deaf, lacking of the quantitative research on psychosocial development, especially the identity which each hearing-impaired student can not avoid.
     The study includes two parts.First,we combed the relevant foreign literature and interviewed the domestic deaf students. On this basis, we complied an identity questionnaire of the hearing-impaired students. Testing shows that the reliability and validity are both well.meeting the psychometric requirements. Secondly,we used the identity questionnaire and Self-reporting inventory, measured 378 deaf students from different regions and schools. The purpose of this study is to survey the identity situation and its influencing factors,and further explore the relationship between identity and mental health condition. The results are as follows:
     1 There are four distinct stages of identity for the hearing-impaired students in China (hearing,immersion,bicultural and marginal). The deaf students'hearing and bicultural tendency is higher, and the marginal is the lowest.
     2 The immersion and marginal between different age have significant difference. As age development,the hearing first reduce and then rise,while the immersion rise at first and then reduce.The bicultural continue to drop, while the marginal continue to rise.
     3 There is significant difference between genders, parental hearing status, and among the hearing loss times, communication means, education forms and numbers of normal hearing friend in identity of the hearing-impaired students.
     4 In the four kinds of the hearing-impaired students, the individuals with typical hearing and marginal are in the worse mental health condition
     5 The hearing tendency have significant negative correlation with the overall level of mental health,somatization,obsessive-compulsiive,interpersonal sensitivity,depression,anxiety,hostility,phobia anxiety and other factor. The immersion have significant negative correlation with interpersonal sensitivity、depression anxiety and phobia anxiety.The marginal tendency have significant negative correlation with anxiety and depression.Only the bicultural tendency and mental health are not significantly correlated.
     6 The hearing tendency of the hearing-impaired students is a significant predictor to the mental health condition. The more the deaf students tended to identity with the culturally hearing, the more serious psychological conditions.The immersion is a significant predictor to the anxiety. The more the deaf students tended to identity with the culturally deaf,the more serious psychological anxiety.
引文
[1]Amiot Catherine, E., Bourhis & Richard, Y. Reconceptualizing Team Identification: New Dimensions and Their Relationship to Intergroup Bias[J]. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research & Practice,2005,9(2):75-86
    [2]Bat-Chava, Yael. Diversity of deaf identities[J]. American Annals of the Deaf, 2000,145 (5):420-428
    [3]Berzonsky, M.D. Identity style:Conceptualization and measurement[J]. Journal of Adolescent Research,1989(4):268-282
    [4]Cole,S.H, Edelmann, R. J. Identity patterns and self and teacher perceptions of problems for deaf adolescents[J]. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines,1991,32(7):1159-1165
    [5]Cornell, Sherri, L. & Lyness,K. P. Therapeutic Implications for Adolescent Deaf Identity and Self-Concept[J]. Journal of Feminist Family Therapy,2004,16(3): 31-49
    [6]Cote, J. E. Sociological perspectives in identity formation:the culture iden-tity link and identity capital[J]. Journal of Adolescence,1996(19):417-428
    [7]Dhamoon, Rita. Theorizing "culture" or Cultural Contestation? Deaf Identities and Transsexual Identities[M]. American Political Science Association.2005: 1-32
    [8]Durand, Sarah,R. Deaf identity, career-related self-efficacy, and perception of career barriers of deaf and hard-of-hearing individuals[J]. Dissertation Abstracts International Section B:The Sciences and Engineering,2008,69(4-B): 2661
    [9]Fischer, L. C., McWhirter, J. J. The Deaf Identity Development Scale:A revision and validation[J]. Journal of Counseling Psychology,200148(3):355-358
    [10]Glickman, N. S., Carey, J. C. Measuring deaf cultural identities:A preliminary investigation[J]. Rehabilitation Psychology,1993,38(4)::275-283
    [11]Grotevant,H. D. Toward a process model of identity format ion[J]. Journal of Adolescent Research,1987(2):202-222
    [12]Hadjikakou,K., Nikolaraizi, M.The impact of personal educational experiences and communication practices on the construction of deaf identity in Cyprus[J]. American Annals of the Deaf,2007,152(4):398-414
    [13]Honda, Loriene, H. Ethnic deaf identity formation[J]. Dissertation Abstracts Internationa] Section B:The Sciences and Engineering,1999,59(10-B):5619
    [14]Jackson,A. M. Black identity development. Journal of Educational Diversity, 1975(2):76-85
    [15]Johnson, D., Terry. D. & Louis, W. Perceptions of the Intergroup Structure and Anti-Asian Prejudice Among White Australians[J]. Group Processes & Intengroup Relation,2005,8(1):53-62
    [16]Kelly, C., Breinlinger, S. The Social Psychology of Collective Action:Identity, Injustice and Gender[M]. London:Taylor & Francis,1996
    [17]Leigh, I. W., Marcus, A. L. D. & Patricia, K. Deaf/hearing cultural identity Paradigms:Modification of the Deaf Identity Development Scale[J]. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education,1998,3(4):329-338
    [18]Marcia, J. E, AS Waterman, Matteson,D.R et al. Ego-identity:the Handbook of Psychosocial research[M]. New York:open university press,1993
    [19]Mccay, V., Jean F. A. The Psychology of Deafness-Understanding Deaf and Hard-of-Hearing People[M]. Longman New York&London,1990,5
    [20]Meeus, W., Iedema, J., Helsen, M., & Vollebergh, W. Patterns of adolescent identity development:Review of literature and longitudinal analysis[J]. Developmental Review,1999(19):419-461
    [21]Melick,A.M. Deaf identity development:A qualitative inquiry[J]. Dissertation Abstracts International Section B:The Sciences and Engineering,1999,59(8-B): 4511
    [22]Moradi, Bonnie, Rottenstein. Culture, Ethnicity, and Gender-Objectification Theory and Deaf Cultural Identity Attitudes:Roles in Deaf Women"s Eating Disorder Symptomatology[J]. Journal of Counseling Psychology,2007,54 (2): 178-188
    [23]Mottez, B. Deaf identity[J]. Sign Language Studies,1990(68):195-216
    [24]Nikolaraizi, M. Analysing the concept of deaf identity [J]. Hellenic Journal of Psychology.2007,4(2):185-204
    [25]Nikolaraizi, M.,Hadjikakou,K. The Role of Educational Experiences in the Development of Deaf Identity[J]. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education, 2006,11(4)::477-492
    [26]Overstreet, S. V. Deaf-centered or hearing-centered Understanding deaf identity[J]. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A:Humanities and Social Sciences.1999,60(5-A):1784
    [27]Robb, Monica Annette. Gender,racial,and deaf identity development and self-esteem in Black, deaf women[J]. Dissertation Abstracts International Section B:The Sciences and Engineering,2004,64(9-B):4632
    [28]Sidanius, J., Laar, C. V. & Levin, S. Ethnic Enclaves and the Dynamics of Social Identity on the College Campus:The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly[J]. Journal of Personality Social Psychology,2004,87(1):96-110
    [29]Simon, B., Loewy,M. & Sturmer,S. Collective identification and social movement participation[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psycology,1998(74): 646-658
    [30]Stein,L.K.,Mindel,E.D. & Jabaley, T. Deafness and mental health[M]. NewYork: Grune and Stratton,1981
    [31]Stryker, S. Identity salience and role performance[J]. Journal of Marriage and the Family,1968(4):558-564
    [32]Tajel, H. Differentiation Between Social Groups:Studies in the Social Psychology of intergroup Relations[M].London:Academic Press,1978
    [33]Tajfel,H. Social psychology of intergroup relations[J].Annual Review of Psychology,1982(33):1-39
    [34]Weinberg, N., Sterritt,M. Disability and identity:A study of identity patterns in adolescents with hearing impairments[J]. Rehabilitation Psychology,1986, 31 (2):9-5102
    [35]Yamaguchi, Toshikatsu. On the relations between conflicts with the hearing world and deaf identity in college students with hearing impairments[J]. Japanese Journal of Educational Psychology,1997,45 (3):284-294
    [36]蔡希美,罗其昌.聋生盲生SCL-90测试结果研究[J].中国特殊教育,1998(3):19-22
    [37]陈树婷.高中生情绪智力、人际关系和学业成绩的相关性研究[D].硕士学位论文,浙江大学,2006
    [38]陈香.青少年自我同一性发展——同一性地位及其相关因素的研究[D].硕士学位论文,河北大学,2001
    [39]邓文.聋哑学校聋生心理危机及其干预探讨[J].中国特殊教育,1997(3):35-38
    [40]冯年琴.聋生心理健康状况调查与研究[J].中国特殊教育,2004(10):64-68
    [41]郭金山.西方心理学自我同一性概念的解析[J].心理科学进展,2003,11(2):227-234
    [42]韩静.社会认同理论研究综述[J].山西煤炭管理干部学院学报,2009(1):55-57
    [43]韩晓峰,郭金山.论自我同一性概念的整合[J].心理学探新,2004(2):7-11
    [44]胡霜.听障生心理健康教育[N].甘肃日报,2008-10:第003版.
    [45]明雅梅.聋人大学生身份认同的研究[D].博士学位论文,辽宁师范大学,2005
    [46]黄锦玲,蔡太生,娄星明.聋生与健全学生心理健康状况及相关因素的比较研究[J].中国健康心理学杂志,2008,16(6):618-620
    [47]简洁,兰继军.耳聋中学生的心身症状调查[J].中国心理卫生杂志,2007,21(2):124
    [48]李光宇,佘翠萍.耳聋的分级及分类[J].中国社区医师,2002(6):14-15
    [49]李静华.影响聋哑儿童的心理健康因素及对策[J].中华临床医学卫生杂志,2006,4(9):60-61
    [50]李强,张然等.聋大学生心理健康状况及相关因素分析[J].中国特殊教育,2004(2):68-71
    [51]李祚山.听觉障碍儿童自我意识与心理健康的研究[J].重庆师范大学学报,2006,23(2):84-87
    [52]林于萍.聋哑学生心理健康状况的初步调查[J].中国特殊教育,2000(4):10-12
    [53]刘毅玮,冯谦.初中聋生心理健康状况的家庭影响因素研究[J].中国学校卫生,200627(5):439-440
    [54]刘在花,许家成等.聋大学生心理健康状况研究[J].中国特殊教育,2006(8):91-95
    [55]娄明星.生活事件对聋生心理健康状况的影响[J].中国校医,2009,23(1):36-38
    [56]卢月娥.听障者心理健康的研究历史及教育启示[J].南京特教学院学报,2007,(2):42-45
    [57]彭秀杰.“农转非”居民的身份认同——对上海近郊某居住区的个案研究[D].硕士学位论文,华东师范大学,2009
    [58]石彩秀.初中阶段聋生的自我意识与应付方式的相关研究[J].中国特殊教育,2006(2):27-30
    [59]孙频捷.身份认同研究浅析[J].前言,2010(2):68-70
    [60]陶新华,朱艳,张卜林.聋生心理健康与成就动机、行为方式的相互影响[J].心理学报,2007,39(6):1074-1083
    [61]汤华.聋哑学生SCL-90,心理评定分析[M].中国心理卫生协会残疾人心理卫生分会第四届学术交流会论文集,2002
    [62]汤盛钦,曾凡林,刘春玲.教育听力学[M].上海:华东师范大学出版社,2000:41-42
    [63]王刚.美国华裔离散群体的身份认同——任璧莲《梦娜在希望之乡》的人物分析[D].硕士学位论文,天津理工大学,2007
    [64]王玲凤.聋学生的自我概念和心理健康状况的研究[J].中国特殊教育,2004(5)44-47
    [65]王沛,赵国军,喇维新.回族大学生的民族认同与心理健康的关系[J].西北师大学报(社会科学版),2006,5(43)::38-41
    [66]王树青.大学生自我同一性形成的个体因素与家庭因素[D].博士学位论文,北京师范大学,2007
    [67]王亚鹏.少数民族认同研究的现状[J].心理科学进展,2002,10(1):102-107
    [68]谢伯瑞.论当代大学生的文化身份认同[J].湖南商学院学报,2003,10(1):121
    [69]谢鼎华,杨伟炎.耳聋的基础与临床[M].湖南:湖南科学技术出版社,2004.
    [70]严吉菲,谭和平.聋高中生与普通高中生自尊比较研究[J].中国特殊教育,2006(8)55-60
    [71]杨素华.残疾学生社会支持与心理健康关系的研究[J].现代特殊教育,2001(5):11-13
    [72]叶景山.大学生自我同一性与心理健康的关系研究[J].健康心理学杂志,2003,11(5):335-337
    [73]于辉.朝鲜族大学生民族认同、文化适应与心理健康的关系研究[D].硕士学位论文,延边大学,2008
    [74]张海洋.中国的多元文化与中国人的认同[M].北京:民族出版社,2006:39
    [75]张静.身份认同研究:观念、态度、理据[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2006.
    [76]张敏.教师学习的理论与实证研究[M].杭州:浙江大学出版社,2008:48-51
    [77]张日升,陈香.青少年的发展课题与自我同一性[J].河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2001,26(1):11-16
    [78]张莹瑞,佐斌.社会认同理论及其发展[J].心理科学进展,2006,14(3):475-480
    [79]张熙君,张淑芳.关于聋哑儿童人格特质的实验研究[J].保定师范专科学校学报,2005,18(3):52-53
    [80]张宇迪,陈呈超.聋生心理健康状况的初步调查[J].中国特殊教育,2006(5):28-32
    [81]赵联防.大学生学业情绪、学校归属感和心理健康的关系研究[D].硕士学位论文,福建师范大学,2009
    [82]周永康.大学生角色认同实证研究[D].博士学位论文,西南大学,2008

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700