摘要
论文主要对复合土钉支护稳定性及应用情况进行相关研究。基于复合土钉支护技术国内外应用和研究情况,介绍了复合土钉支护技术的国内外应用和研究现状、发展动态。结合复合土钉支护技术的实际工程应用,分析了复合土钉支护的主要构型以及复合土钉支护的作用机理。对复合土钉支护的稳定性进行了分析。在稳定性分析中,研究了复合土钉支护时土坡稳定的安全系数:介绍了最危险滑裂面的确定方法并采用几何参数控制法来确定土体的最危险滑裂面;计算了土钉支护土体时的稳定性;研究了水、预应力锚杆(索)、水泥土搅拌桩以及超前微桩对复合土钉支护时土体稳定性的影响作用并给出了相应的计算公式。为了进一步研究复合土钉支护技术,论文进行了深基坑复合土钉支护模型的试验研究,比较了复合土钉支护深基坑与普通土钉支护深基坑时的支护效果。最后,基于工程实践,论文介绍了几个复合土钉支护的工程应用实例,在各工程应用中分别采用了不同的复合土钉支护构型。
理论研究结果表明,针对不同的地质条件可采用普通土钉支护技术或复合土钉支护技术,在采用复合土钉支护技术时又可采用不同的复合构型;复合土钉支护的作用机理主要是以土钉支护为主,依据不同土质条件、工程环境,借助于水泥土搅拌桩止水帷幕、超前微桩和预应力锚杆等其它组件的共同作用来稳定土体和边坡。复合土钉稳定性分析表明,复合土钉支护时土坡稳定的安全系数和最危险滑裂面的确定对于稳定性分析非常重要;土体内水对土体稳定性有很大的影响作用;设置超前微桩后,能增加基坑边壁的稳定性;增设深层搅拌桩后,边壁抗倾覆、抗滑移安全系数增大,同时面层强度的增加更有利于复合土钉支护体系内其它组件间的相互作用;增设预应力锚杆(锚索)和预应力土钉,对于控制基坑边壁位移有重要作用,可明显提高滑移面上土体的抗滑力。
深基坑复合土钉支护模型的试验研究结果表明,复合土钉支护的变形与普通土钉支护相比,具有不同的分布形态;由于土钉与水泥土搅拌桩的共同作用,可有效地控制基坑变形,提高基坑的稳定性。
实际工程应用情况表明,复合土钉支护技术对于复杂地质条件下土木工程基坑、边坡等的支护是有效可行的,可依据不同的地质条件采用不同的复合土钉支护构型。
In this paper, the applications and the stability analysis of compound soil nailing were studied. Based on the fact of the applications and the researches on compound soil nailing in land and overseas, it were introduced that the applications and the researches on compound soil nailing in land and overseas nowadays. With the engineering applications of compound soil nailing, main types of compound soil nailing and their working mechanism were analyzed. The stability of compound soil nailing was also analyzed. During the stability analysis, the safety coefficient and the most dangerous slipped layer of soil slope retained by compound soil nailing was studied. The stability of soil nailing was calculated. Then, the influence functions of water, prestressed anchor and cement-soil retaining wall and front small-piles in the compound soil nailing system were studied. The corresponding formulas were given. A model test of the compound soil nailing for deep excavation was carried out in laboratory in order to study the working mechanism of compound soil nailing deeply. The retain effects of compound soil nailing and those of soil nailing were compared in this experiment. At the last, some civil engineering structures retained by the compound soil nailing were introduced.
The results of theory researches show that the selection in the types of compound soil nailing should base on the geologic condition of soil slope. The working mechanism of compound soil nailing depend on the soil nailing mainly, the other part such as prestressed anchor and cement-soil retaining wall and front small-piles in the compound soil nailing system can also take part in. The researches on the stability of compound soil nailing show that it is important to determine the safety coefficient and the most dangerous slipped layer of soil slope retained by compound soil nailing in the stability analysis of compound soil nailing. Water, prestressed anchor and cement-soil retaining wall and front small-piles in the compound soil nailing system have a great influence on the stability of the whole compound soil nailing system. The front small-piles in the compound soil nailing system can improve the stability of the soil slope. The cement-soil retaining wall in the compound soil nailing system can increase the safety coefficient of soil slope retained by compound soil nailing. The prestressed anchor in the compound soil nailing system can increase the slipped resistant force JA
evidently, and it make very important in controlling the distance nearby the excavation.
The experimental results show that the deformation profiles of compound soil nailing were different from those of soil nailing, and the cooperation of the nail and the soil-cement piles can control the deformation induced by excavation effectively and improve the stability of the excavated slope.
The applications of compound soil nailing on the civil engineering structures show that the compound soil nailing technology can retain the excavation and the soil slope in the complicated geologic condition. And it also shows that Selection in the types of compound soil nailing should base on the geologic condition of soil slope.
引文
[1] 孙铁成,张明聚,徐从平等.复合土钉支护技术(J).工程力学增刊(Ⅱ).2002年:59—62
[2] 总参工程兵科技三所,清华大学土木工程系.中国岩土工程科技报告(R).总参工程兵科技三所,2000
[3] 唐军,曹钦.复合土钉墙在超大型深基坑中的应用(J).建筑施工.2001年,23(6):394—395
[4] 汤凤林,林希强.复合土钉支护技术在基坑支护工程中的应用—以广州地区为例(J).现代地质.2000年,14(1):100-104
[5] 《基坑土钉支护技术规程》(CECS96:97),中国工程建设标准化协会标准,1997年
[6] 《建筑基坑支护技术规程》(JGJ20-99),中华人民共和国行业标准,1999
[7] 陈肇元,崔京浩.土钉支护在基坑工程中的应用.中国建筑工业出版社,1997
[8] 陈肇元,崔京浩.深基坑支护技术综述.清华大学士木工程系研究报告,1997
[9] B.R. Christopher, S.A. Gill, et al. Reinforces Soil Structures. Volume I, Design and Construction Guidelines, FHWA/R.D-89/043, Nov., 1990
[10] V.Elias, I.Juran, Soil Nailing for Stabilization of Highway Slopes and Excavation, FHWA/RD-89-198, June., 1991
[11] J.A.Porerfield, et al. Soil Nailing Field Inspectors Manual:Soil Nail walls.FHWA/SA-93/068, Apr.,1994
[12] R.J.Bynre, J.L. Walkingshaw, et al. FHWA Intrenational Scanning Tour for Getotechnology, September-October.,1992, FHWA/PL-93/020, June., 1993
[13] Recommendations CLOUTERRE 1991 for Designing, Calculating , Costrueting and Inspecting Earth Support System Using Soll Nailing, FHWA/SA-93/026,1993
[14] D.A. Bruce, R.A. Jewell, Soil Nailing:Application and Practice, Part 1, Part 2, Ground Engineering Vol, 19, Nov.9,1986, Vol.20, Jan.,1987
[15] P.P.Xanthakos, J.W.Abuamson, D.A.Bruce, Ground Control and Improvement, John Wiely & Sons Pub.,1994
[16] F.Schlosser, Behavior and Design of Soil Nailing, Proc.of Synposium, Bangkok, Nov.29,1983
[17] C.Plumelle, F. Schlosser, French National Research Project on Soil Nailing CLOUTERRE,G-eotechnical Special Publication, No.25, ASCE, 1990
[18] F. Selalousser, et al, French Research Program CLOUTERRE on Soft nailing, Geoteehnical Spec,Vol.2, No.30, ASCE, 1992
[19] F. Schlosser, et al, Soil Naining in France-Research and Practice,Transportation Rsesearch Record 1330,Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C
[20] L.Juran, et al, Design of Soil Nailed Retaining Structurse, Geotechnical Special Publication, No.25, ASCE,1990
[21] I.Juran, V.Elias, Ground Anchors and Soil Nails in Retaining Strutures, Foundation Engineering Handbook,Chapter 26 Fang.H.Y.(Ed.), Van Nostrad Beinhold Pub.,1991
[22] Juran,I.et al,Kinematical Limit Ananlysis for Design of Soil-Nailed Structures,Joue,Geotech.Eng.ASCE,Vol, 116 No. 1,1990
[23] C.K. Shen, et al, Ground Movement Analysis of Earth support System, J.Geotech.English, ASCE,Dec. 1981
[24] C.K. Shen, ea al, Field Measurement of an Earth Support System, J.Geotech.English,ASCE,Dec, 1981
[25] C.I. Ho, et al, Field Performance of a Soil Nail System in Loess, Foundation Engineering, Current Principles and Practice, GSP No.31.ASCE, 1989
[26] S.r. Thompson,Design,Construction and Performance of a Soil Nailed Wall in Seattle Washington ,Geotechnical Special Publication, No.25, ASCE,1990
[27] R.J. Byrne, Soil Nanling -A Simplified Kinematic Analysis Geotechnical Special Publication, Vol.2, No.30, ASCE, 1992
[28] M.Vuceti; et al, Dynamic Centrifuge Testing of Soil-Nailed Excavations, Geotechnical Testing Journal, Vol,l 6 No.2.June, 1993
[29] M.F. Stocker, et al, Soil Nailing, Proc. Int. Conf.on Soil Reinforcement, Paris,1979
[30] F.M.Stocker, G. Riedinger, The Bearing Behavior of Nailed Retaining Structures, GPS, No.25.ASCE, 1990
[31] R J. Bridle, Soil Nailing-Analysis and Design ,Ground Engineering ,Sept,1989
[32] G.Gassler, G.Gudenhus, Soil Nailing-Some Aspects of a New Technique, Pros. ICSMEF,Vol.3,1981
[33] C.J.F.P.Jones, Earth Reinforcement And Soil Structures, Butter worths
Pub.,1986
[34] C.R.J.Clayton, et al, Earth Pressure and Earth-Retaining Structures, 2nd edition, Blackie Academic & Professional Pub., 1991
[35] R.A.Jewell, M.L.Pedley, Soil Nailing Design:The Role of Bending Stiffness, Discussion by F. Schlosser, Ground Engineering, March, 1990, Nov., 1991
[36] G. Gassler, In-situ Techniques of Reinforced Soil, State of the Art Report, Performance of reinforced Soil Structures, British Geotechnical Society,1990
[37] R.A. Jewell, Soil Nailing, Geoneral Report, ibid
[38] S.Bang, et al, Investigation of Soil Nailing System, Advances in Geotechnical Engineering, Transport Research Record 1369,1992
[39] D.A.Baker, Soil Nainling in Weathered Deuper Marl-A Case Study, Ground Engineering, Feb., 1994
[40] N.Sabhahit, et al, Generalized Procedure for the Optimum Design of nailed Soil Slopes, International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics,Vol. 19, No.6, June,1995
[41] 王步云,周龙翔.岩土工程治理手册.辽宁科学技术出版社,1993:674-687
[42] 王步云.土钉墙设计.岩土工程技术,1997年,第4期
[43] 曾宪明,曾荣生,陈德兴,王作民.岩土深基坑喷锚网支护法原理.设计.施工指南.同济大学出版社,1997年
[44] 吴观今,刘民强.插筋补强护坡技术.建筑技术开发,1992年,第3期
[45] 黄玉田,插筋补强护坡技术的工程验证.岩土锚固工程技术的应用与发展.万国学术出版社,1996:239-242
[46] 程良奎、张作嵋、杨志银.岩土加固实用技术.地震出版社,1994
[47] 修学纯,李保国,陈叶青.基坑边坡土钉支护设计与施工工程实践中的若干问题.建筑技术(增刊),1998:297-301
[48] 苏绍曾.全长砂浆锚杆在华盛大厦软土深基坑支护中的应用.深基坑开挖的土钉支护技术研讨会会议论文,清华大学,1996
[49] 江水德.土钉墙的工作原理与强度特性.深基坑开挖的土钉支护技术研讨会会议论文,清华大学,1996
[50] 曾宪明,李保国,张六一等.广州065工程18深基坑滑坡处理设计与施工.深基坑开挖的土钉支护技术研讨会会议论文,清华大学,1996
[51] 李象范,徐水根等.软弱土层复合型土钉支护专辑.上海地质.1999年,第3期
[52] 周丰峻.土钉支护的应用和发展.建设部科学技术委员会万富大厦基坑土钉支护现场会报告,1997年7月
[53] 张明聚,宋二祥,陈肇元.土针支护设计的修正条分法.工程勘察.1997年,第6期
[54] 宋二祥,陈肇元.土钉支护及其有限元分析.工程勘察,1996年,第2期
[55] 陈叶青,宋二祥,陈肇元.基坑土钉支护工程应用中特殊情况的处理及应注意的问题.工程勘察.1999年,第5期
[56] 陈叶青,李保国,苏绍曾等.土钉支护在复杂地质条件基坑支护中的应用.施工技术.1999年,第1期。
[57] 刘建航,候学渊.基坑工程手册.中国建筑工业出版社,1997年
[58] 龚晓南,高有潮.深基坑设计施工手册.中国建筑工业出版社,1998年
[59] 余志成,施文华.深基坑支护设计与施工.中国建筑工业出版社,1997年
[60] 江正荣.地基与基础施工手册.中国建筑工业出版社,1997年
[61] 叶书麟,叶观宝.地基处理.中国建筑工业出版社,1997年
[62] 黄强.深基坑支护工程设计技术.中国建材工业出版社,1997年
[63] 黄强,惠永宁.深基坑支护工程实例集.中国建筑工业出版社,1997年
[64] 卢肇钧.锚定板档土结构稳定性的研究.铁道部科学研究院研究报告,1989年
[65] 张肇钧.单锚原理及其在锚定板结构中的应用.铁道部科学研究院研究报告,1988年
[66] 吴肖茗,魏殿兴.锚定板档土结构使用情况的调查报告.铁道部科学研究院研究报告,1989年
[67] 卢肇钧,吴肖茗,刘国楠.锚定支护工程实践中的几个问题的探讨.海峡两岸土力学及基础工程施工技术学术研讨会论文集,西安,1994年10月
[68] D、G费雷德隆德,H.拉哈尔佐著,陈仲颐,张在明等译.非饱和土力学.中国建筑工业出版社,1997年
[69] 陈仲颐,周景星,王洪瑾.土力学.清华大学出版社,1994年
[70] 陈希哲.土力学与地基基础.清华大学出版社,1993年
[71] 陈祖煜.边坡稳定的极限平衡法和极限分析法.海峡两岸土力学及基础工程施工技术学术研讨论会论文集,西安,1994年10月
[72] 栾茂田,金崇磐,林皋.土体稳定分析极限平衡法改进极其应用.岩土工程学报(增刊),1992年
[73] 赵锡宏,陈志明,胡中雄.高层建筑深基坑围护工程实践与分析.同济大学
出版社,1996年
[74] 李静.基坑土钉支护工作性能研究.清华大学工学学士学位论文.1999年
[75] TALREN 97 CALCULATION METHOD,Stability Analysis of Geotechnical Structures Developed by TSRRASOL
[76] TALREN 97 DEMO VERSION,Program for the Stability Analysis of Geotechnical Structures