投资者保护与我国资本市场发展的省际差异研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
投资者保护是影响资本市场发展的重要因素,已有的研究表明投资者保护与一国资本市场发展呈正相关关系。经过20多年的发展,中国资本市场的规模快速壮大,但同时区域间发展不平衡也较为突出。本文从投资者保护视角探讨了我国资本市场区域发展差异的原因,深入分析了我国31个省区市在面临相同立法环境的情况下,由于法律执行和以地方性法规为代表的省际剩余公司治理的差异所引起的投资者保护程度的不同,对我国资本市场区域发展差异产生的影响。
     通过研究我们得到如下结论:(1)投资者保护是形成我国资本市场发展区域差异的重要原因之一;(2)司法是产生我国各地区投资者保护程度不同的主要原因,其对资本市场发展区域差异产生显著影响;(3)省际剩余公司治理是导致我国各地区投资者保护程度不同的重要原因,但现阶段其对资本市场发展区域差异的正向影响并不明显。
     论文对我国各省区投资者保护程度和资本市场发展区域差异现状进行了定量描述,并定性分析了各地不同的法律执行和省际剩余公司治理对资本市场发展区域差异的影响,在此基础上选取我国31个省份1992-2007年的样本数据进行了实证检验,在控制了经济、市场、人口和文化素质、地理区位等因素以及时间趋势的影响之后,实证结果表明投资者保护对资本市场区域发展产生积极的影响。基于上述研究结论,本文提出了有针对性的政策建议。本研究以中国的经验证据丰富了LLSV的主要观点。
The investor protection is the important factor to impact on the development of capital market. The current researches show that the investor protection has a positive effect on one country's capital market development. After more than twenty years development the size of China's capital market has grown fast. However, the uneven of its regional development is outstanding at the same time. From the viewpoint of investor protection, this paper explores the reason of China's regional difference of capital market development (RDCMD) and analyzes the impact of the differences of investor protection on China's RDCMD, which caused by legal enforcement and inter-provincial residual corporate governance(IRCG) represented by local laws and regulations under the circumstance of facing the same legislation.
     We draw the following conclusions:(1) the investor protection is one of the important reasons to form China's RDCMD and (2) the judiciary is the main reason to produce the difference of the investor protection in China's various regions and has the significant influence on the RDCMD and (3) the IRCG is also an important reason to contributed to the difference of the investor protection in different regions, but its influence on the RDCMD is not obvious at present.
     In this paper we firstly describe quantitatively the degree of all Chinese provinces'investor protection and the status of the RDCMD, followed by analyzing qualitatively the influence of different legal enforcement and the IRCG on the RDCMD. Then we have an empirical test using panel data for the 31 Chinese provinces from 1992-2007. After controlling a series of factors (e.g., economic development, capital market volatility, cultural quality, area, time trend, etc.), the results support the conclusion, i.e. the investor protection has an active influence on the RDCMD. Finally we present some targeted policy suggestions. Using China's empirical evidences, this paper support and enrich LLSV's main viewpoint.
引文
[1]Allen,F.,Qian,J.,Qian,M.J.,2005,Law,finance,and economic growth in China, Journal of Financial Economics 77,57-116.
    [2]Armour,J.,Deakin,S.,Sarkar,P.,Siems,M.,Singh,A.,2007,Shareholder protection and stock market development:an empirical test of the legal origins hypothesis,Centre for Business Research,University of Cambridge Working Paper No.358.
    [3]Avgouleas,E.,2008,Reforming investor protection regulation:the impact of cognitive biases, SSRN Working Paper,No.1293788.
    [4]Ayyagari,M.,Demirguc-Kunt,A.,Maksimovic,V.,2008,Formal versus informal finance: evidence from China,The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No.4465.
    [5]Bai,C.E.,Liu,Q.,Lu,J.,Song,F.M.,Zhang,J.X.,2004,Corporate governance and market valuation in China,Journal of Comparative Economics 32,599-616.
    [6]Barton,J.,Waymire,G.,2004,Investor protection under unregulated financial reporting, Journal of Accounting and Economics 38,65-116.
    [7]Bebchuk,L.,1999,The rent protection theory of corporate ownership and control, Unpublished working paper.Harvard Law School,Cambridge,MA.
    [8]Beck,T.,Levine,R.,Loayza,N.,2000,Finance and the sources of growth,Journal of Financial Economics 58,261-300.
    [9]Becker,G.S.,1968,Crime and punishment: an economic approach,Journal of Political Economy,vol 54,No 3,563-597.
    [10]Bennedsen,M.,Nielsen,K..M.,2006,The principle of proportional ownership, investor protection and firm value in Western Europe,ECGI Working Paper No.134.
    [11]Bennedsen,M.,Wolfenzon,D.,2000. The balance of power in closely held corporations. Journal of Financial Economics 58,113-139.
    [12]Bergman,N.K.,Nicolaievsky,D.,2007,Investor protection and the Coasian view,Journal of Financial Economics 84,738-771.
    [13]Block,F.,Hege,U.,2001,Multiple shareholders and control contests,IMG working paper.
    [14]Boubakri,N.,Cosset,J.C.,Guedhami,O.,2005,Postprivatization corporate governance:The role of ownership structure and investor protection,Journal of Financial Economics 76,369-399.
    [15]Boyle,G.,Meade,R.,2005,One size fits all? investor protection regulation of centralized trading platforms,SSRN Working Paper,No.801024.
    [16]Brockman P.,Chung,D.Y.,2003,Investor protection and firm liquidity,The Journal of Finance, Vol.58,921-937.
    [17]Burkart,M.,Gromb,D.,Panunzi,F.,1997,Large shareholders,monitoring,and the value of the firm,The Quarterly Journal of Economics,Vol.112,693-728.
    [18]Burkart,M.,Gromb,D.,Panunzi,F.,1998,Why higher takeover premia protect minority sharehoIders,The Journal of Political Economy,Vol.106,172-204.
    [19]Castro,R.,CIementi,G.L.,MacDonald,G.,2004,Investor protection,optimal incentives and economic growth,The Quarterly Journal of Economics 119,1131-1175.
    [20]Chang,E.C.,Wong,S.,2004,Political control and performance in China's listed firms,Journal of Comparative Economics 32,617-636.
    [21]Chen,K.,Chen,Z.H.,Wei,K.C.,2009,Legal protection of investors,corporate governance,and the cost of equity capital,Journal of Corporate Finance Volume 15,273-289.
    [22]Chen,Z.W.,2003,Capital markets and legal development:The China case,China Economic Review 14,451-472.
    [23]Cheng,S.R.,Shiu,C.Y.,2007,Investor protection and capital structure:International evidence, Journal of Multinational Financial Management 17,30-44.
    [24]Choi,J.,Wong,T.J.,2005,When no law is better than good law,Working Paper,Indiana University.
    [25]Chung,H.,2006,Investor protection and the liquidity of cross-listed securities:Evidence from the ADR market,Journal of Banking and Finance 30,1485-1505.
    [26]Claessens,S.,Djankov,S.,Joseph,F.,Lang,L.,2002,DisentangIing the incentive and entrench-ment effects of large shareholdings,Journal of Finance,vol.57,2379-2408.
    [27]Claessens,S.,Djankov,S.,Lang,L.,2000,The separation of ownership and control in East Asian corporations.Journal of Financial Economics 58,81-112.
    [28]Coffee,J.,2000,Privatization and corporate governance:the lessons from securities market failure.Working paper No.158,Columbia Law School,New York.
    [29]Cronqvist H.,Nilsson,M.,2003,Agency costs of controlling minority shareholders,The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol.38,695-719.
    [30]Cull,R., Xu,L.C.,2005,Institutions, ownership, and finance:the determinants of profit reinvestment among Chinese firms,Journal of Financial Economics 77,117-146.
    [31]Dahlquist,M.,Pinkowitz,L.,Stulz,R.M.,Williamson,R.,2002,Corporate governance, investor protection,and the home bias,SSRN Working Paper No.320222.
    [32]Daouk,H.,Lee,C.M.C.,Ng, D.,2006,Capital market governance:how do security laws affect market performance? Journal of Corporate Finance 12,560-593.
    [33]DeFond,M.,Hung,M.,Trezevant,R.,2007,Investor protection and the information content of annual earnings announcements:International evidence,Journal of Accounting and Econo-mics 43,37-67.
    [34]Demirguc-Kunt,A.,Maksimovic,V.,1998,Law,finance,and firm growth,The Journal of Finance, Vol.53,2107-2137.
    [35]Desai,M.A.,Moel,A.,2008,Czech mate:expropriation and investor protection in a converging world,Review of Finance 12(1):221-251.
    [36]Djankov,S.,La Porta,R.,Lopez-de-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,2008,The law and economics of self-dealing,JournaI of Financial Economics 88 (3),430-466.
    [37]Doidge,C.,Karolys,G.,Stulz,R.M.,2007,Why do countries matter so much for corporate governance?Journal of Financial Economics 86,1-39.
    [38]Eleswarapu,V.R.,Venkataraman,K.,2006,The impact of legal and political institutions on equity trading costs:a cross-country analysis,Review of Financial Studies, vol.19, No.3, 1081-1111.
    [39]Faccio,M.,2001,debt and corporate governance,SSRN working paper.
    [40]Foley,C.,Greenwood,R.,2008,The evolution of corporate ownership after IPO: the impact of investor protection,NBER Working Paper No.14557.
    [41]Francis,B.,Hasan,I.,Sun,X.,2009,Political connections and the process of going public: evidence from china,Journal of International Money and Finance 28,696-719.
    [42]GIaeser,E.,Johnson,S.,Shleifer,A.,2001,Coase versus the Coasians,QuarterIy Journal of Economics, vol 116,853-899.
    [43]Gomes,A.,Novaes,W.,Multiple large shareholders and corporate governance,The Wharton School,University of pennsylvania.
    [44]Gorton,G.,Schmid,F.,2000,Universal banking and the performance of German firms,Journal of Financial Economics 58,29-80.
    [45]Grossman S.J.,Hart,O.D.,1986,The costs and benefits of ownership:a theory of vertical and lateral integration,The Journal of Political Economy, Vol.94,691-719.
    [46]Grossman,S.,Hart,O.,1988,One-share-one-vote and the market for corporate control,Journal of Financial Economics 20,175-202.
    [47]Haidar,J.I.,2009,Investor protections and economic growth,Economics Letters 103,1-4.
    [48]Hart,O.,1995,Corporate governance,some theory and applications,The Economic Journal 105,687-689.
    [49]Hasan,I.,Wachtel,P.,Zhou,M.M.,2009,Institutional development, financial deepening and economic growth:Evidence from China,Journal of Banking and Finance 33,157-170.
    [50]Holan,P.,Sanz,L.,2006,Protected by the family? how closely held family firms protect minority shareholders,Journal of Business Research 59,356-359.
    [51]Hughes,J.P.,2009,Corporate value,ultimate control and law protection for investors in Western Europe,Management Accounting Research 20,41-52.
    [52]Hyytinen,A.,Takalo,T.,2008,Investor protection and business creation,International Review of Law and Economics 28,113-122.
    [53]Jensen,M.C.,Meckling,W.H.,1976,Theory of the firm: managerial behavior,agency costs and ownership structure,Journal of Financial Economics 3,305-360.
    [54]Johnson,S.,La Porta,R.,Lopez-de-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,2000b,Tunneling,American Econo-mic Review Papers and Proceedings 90,22-27.
    [55]Klapper,L.F.,Love,I.,2004,Corporate governance,investor protection,and performance in emerging markets,Journal of Corporate Finance 10,703-728.
    [56]Krug,B.,Hendrischke,H.,2000,China incorporated:property rights,privatisation and the emergence of a private business sector in china,SSRN Working Paper No.3709371.
    [57]La Porta,R.,Lopez-de-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.1999,Corporate ownership around the world, Journal of Finance,vol.54,No.2,471-517.
    [58]La Porta,R.,Lopez-de-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,2006.What works in securities laws? Journal of Finance,61,1-33.
    [59]La Porta,R.,Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W,1997,Legal determinants of exter-nal finance,Journal of Finance 52,1131-1150.
    [60]La Porta,R.,Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W,2000a,Investor protection and corporate governance,Journal of finance,58 (2000),3-27.
    [61]La Porta,R.,Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W,2002,lnvestor protection and corporate valuation,Journal of finance,57 (3),1147-1170.
    [62]La Porta,R.,Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.,1998,Law and finance,Journal of Political Economy,vol.106,1113-1155.
    [63]La Porta,R.,Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.1999,Corporate ownership around the world,Journal of finance, Vol. LIV,471-517.
    [64]La Porta,R.,Lopez-De-Silanes,F.,Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.W.2000b,Agency problems and dividend policies around the world,Journal of finance, Vol.LV,1-33.
    [65]Langevoort,D.C.,2006,The SEC as a lawmaker: choices about investor protection in the face of uncertainty,Georgetown Law and Economics Research Paper No.947510.
    [66]Lee,C.F.,Lee,K.W.,Yeo,G.,2009,Investor protection and convertible debt design,Journal of Banking and Finance Volume 33,985-995.
    [67]Lemmon,M.L.,Lins,K..,2001,Ownership structure,corporate governance,and firm value: evidence from the east asian financial crisis,The Journal of Finance 58,1445-1468.
    [68]Levine,R.,2004,Finance and growth:theory and evidence,NBER Working Paper, No. W10766.
    [69]Levine,R.,Zervos,S.,1998,Stock markets,banks and economic growth,American Economic Review 88,537-558.
    [70]Li,D.H.,Pan,H.B.,Xia,X.P.,2009,Investor protection,government intervention and cross-province mergers: evidence from China's emerging market,SSRN Working Paper.
    [71]Li,S.M.,2005,Why a poor governance environment does not deter foreign direct investment: The case of China and its implications for investment protection,Business Horizons 48, 297-302.
    [72]Li,X.,2006,Investor protection and financial structure,SSRN Working Paper, No.890612.
    [73]Licht,A.,Goldschmidt,C.,Schwartz,S.,2005,Culture,law,and corporate governance, Interna-tional Review of Law and Economics 25,229-255.
    [74]Liu,T.,Li,K.W.,2001,Impact of liberalization of financial resources in China's economic growth: evidence from provinces,Journal of Asian Economics 12,245-262.
    [75]Lu,S.F.,Yao,Y.,2009,The effectiveness of law,financial development,and economic growth in an economy of financial repression:evidence from China,World Development Vol.37, No.4,763-777.
    [76]Maddison,A.,2007,Chinese econonomic performance in the long run:960-2030 AD,OECD Development Centre,Paris.
    [77]Marco P.,Roell,A.,1998,The choice of stock ownership structure:agency costs,monitoring and the decision to go public,Quarterly Journal of Economics,113:187-226.
    [78]Maury,B.,Pajuste,A.,2005,Multiple large shareholders and firm value,Journal of Banking and Finance 29,1813-1834.
    [79]Milhaupt,C.J.,2003,Nonprofit organizations as investor protection: economic theory,and evidence from East Asia,Columbia Law School Working Paper No.218.
    [80]Mitton,T.,2002,A cross-firm analysis of the impact of corporate,Journal of Financial Economics 64,215-241.
    [81]Mitton,T.,2004,Corporate governance and dividend policy in emerging markets,Emerging Markets Review,5,409-426.
    [82]Morck,R.,Yeung,B.,Yu,W.,2000,The information content of stock markets:why do emerging markets have synchronous price movements? Journal of Financial Economics 58,215-260.
    [83]Mougin,F.,2007,Asymmetric information and legal investor protection,Economics Letters 95,253-258.
    [84]Nenova,T.,1999,The value of a corporate vote and private benefits:a cross-country analysis, Working Paper Series,Harvard University,Cambridge,MA.
    [85]Newman,P.,Patterson,E.,Smith,R.,2003,The role of auditing in investor protection,NBER Working Paper No.421660.
    [86]Pacces,A.,2009,Why investor protection is not all that matters in corporate law and economics,RILE Working Paper Series,No.2009/03.
    [87]Perotti,E.,Volpin,P.,2007,Politics,investor protection and competition,ECGI Finance Working Paper No.162.
    [88]Pistor K.,Chenggang Xu,C.G.,2002,Incomplete law:a conceptual and analytical framework and its application to the evolution of financial market regulation,Columbia Law School, The Center for Law and Economic Studies Working Paper No.204.
    [89]Pistor K.,Chenggang Xu,C.G.,2005,Governing emerging wtock markets:legal vs adminis-trative governance,Corporate Governance:An International Review,Vol.13,5-10.
    [90]Pistor,K.,2000,Patterns of legal change:shareholder and creditor rights intransition eeonomies,European Bank for Reconstruciton and Development Working Paper No.49.
    [91]Pistor,K.,Raiser,M.,Gelfer,S.,2000,Law and finance in transition economies,Economics of Transition 8,325-368.
    [92]Pistor,K.,Xu,C.,2005,Governing stock market in transition economies:lessons from China,American Law and Economic Review 7(1),184-210.
    [93]Rajan,R.,Zingales,L.,1998,Financial dependence and growth,American Economic Review 88,559-586.
    [94]Ran,J.,Voon,J.P.,Li,G.Z.,2007,How does FDI affect China? Evidence from industries and provinces,Journal of Comparative Economics 35,774-799.
    [95]Rose,C.,2007,The Challenges of Quantifying Investor Protection in a Comparative Context, European Business Organization Law Review (EBOR)8:369-400,Cambridge University Press.
    [96]Shen,C.H.,Chih,H.L.,2005,Investor protection,prospect theory,and earnings management: an international comparison of the banking industry,Journal of Banking and Finance 29,2675-2697.
    [97]Shleifer,A.,Vishny,R.,1997,A survey of corporate governance,Journal of Finance 52,737-783.
    [98]Shleifer,A.,Wolfenzon,D.,2002,Investor protection and equity markets,Journal of Financial Economics 66,3-27.
    [99]Tang,Q.L.,Chen,H.F.,Lin,Z.J.,2008,Financial reporting quality and investor protection:a global investigation,SSRN Working Paper No.1290910.
    [100]Thapa,C.,Poshakwale,S.,2009,Investor protection and foreign equity portfolio investments,SSRN Working Paper.
    [101]Wang,Q.,Wong,T.J.,Xia,L.J.,2008,State ownership,the institutional environment,and auditor choice:Evidence from China,Journal of Accounting and Economics 46,112-134.
    [102]Wang,X.Z.,Xu,L.C.,Zhu,T.,2004,State-owned enterprises going public, Economics of Transition Volume 12(3),467-487.
    [103]Wang,Y.H.,Liao,L.,Deng,X.T.,2003,The effect of investor protection on information asymmetry in a stock market,SSRN Working Paper,No.383901.
    [104]Wurgler,J.,2000,Financial markets and the allocation of capital,Journal of Financial Economics 58,187-214(28).
    [105]Xu,C.,Pistor,K.,2002,Law enforcement under incomplete law:theory and evidence from financial market regulation,Working Paper No.TE/02/442,London School of Economics.
    [106]Yao,Y.,Yueh,L.,2009,Law,finance,and economic growth in China: an introduction, World Development Vol.37,753-762.
    [107]Yavuz,M.D.,2008,Why does investor protection matter for the cost of equity?NBER Working Paper No.1129355.
    [108]Zingales,L.,1994,The value of the voting right:a study of the milan stock exchange experience,Review of Financial Studies,vol.7,125-148.
    [109]白重恩、刘俏、陆洲等,中国上市公司治理结构的实证研究[J],经济研究,2005(2):81-91。
    [110]白重恩、路江涌、陶志刚,投资环境对外资企业效益的影响-来自企业层面的证据[J],经济研究,2004(9):82-89。
    [111]毕先萍、李正友,投资者保护与公司股权结构:一个家族企业继任模型[J],当代财经,2004(8):59-64。
    [112]蔡防、都阳,中国地区经济增长的趋同与差异—对西部开发战略的启示[J],经济研究,2000(10):30-37(80)。
    [113]常巍、贝政新,资本市场发展中的投资主体与投资行为—“资本市场与金融投资研讨会”综述[J],经济研究,2002(7):58-62。
    [114]陈冬华、章铁生、李翔,法律环境、政府管制与隐性契约[J],经济研究,2008(3):60-72。
    [115]陈刚、詹正茂、廉晓红,中国资本市场的区域差异研究[J],中国软科学,2003(9):118-122。
    [1]6]陈国阶,我国东中西部发展差异原因分析[J],地理科学,1997(1):1-7。
    [117]陈国进、赵向琴、林辉,法律制度与金融发展:中国经验与理论创新[M],北京:经济科学出版社,2008年12月第1版。
    [118]陈汉文、刘启亮、余劲松,国家、股权结构、诚信与公司治理-以宏智科技为例[J],管理世界,2005(8):134-142。
    [119]陈小悦、徐晓尔,股权结构、企业绩效与投资者利益保护[J],经济研究,2001(11):3-11。
    [120]崔光庆、王景武,中国区域金融差异与政府行为-理论与经验解释[J],金融研究,2006(6):79-89。
    [121]达摩达尔·N·古扎拉蒂,计量经济学基础[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005年4月第1版。
    [122]邓建平、曾勇、李金诺,最终控制、权力制衡和公司价值研究[J],管理工程学报,2006(3):26-32。
    [123]邓思清,论我国司法体制改革的几个问题[J],中国法学,2003(3):155-163。
    [124]董茂云,司法独立:司法公正的重要制度保证[J],中国法学,2003(1):9-10。
    [125]樊纲,股份合作制与中国资本市场的多层次发展[J],学习与实践,1998(4):13-16。
    [126]樊纲、王小鲁,中国市场化指数:各地区市场化相对进程2006年报告[M],北京:经济科学出版社,2007年2月第1版。
    [127]冯果、张焰、陶光辉,法律诉讼案例[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2003年3月第1版。
    [128]高永辉、李小毛,股权结构、公司治理与机构投资者保护的一个分析框架[J],北方经贸,2003(10):35-36。
    [129]顾培东,中国司法改革的宏观思考[J],法学研究,2000(3):3-16。
    [130]郭金龙、王宏伟,中国区域间资本流动与区域经济差距研究[J],管理世界,2003(7):45-58。
    [131]郭亚军,综合评价理论、方法及应用[M],北京:科学出版社,2007年5月第1版。
    [132]何德旭、张捷,加强投资者保护促进资本市场发展[J],中国发展观察,2008(10):44-46。
    [133]何旭强、朱戎,投资者保护与证券市场发展:理论、经验与政策[J],产业经济研究,2005(5):26-34。
    [134]洪修文,法律、投资者保护与金融发展[M],武汉:武汉大学出版社,2007年9月第1版。
    [135]胡汝银、司徒大年,投资者保护的理论与实践[M],上海:上海证券交易所内部研究报告,2002。
    [136]计小青、曹啸,标准的投资者保护制度和替代性投资者保护制度:一个概念性分析框架[J],金融研究,2008(3):151-162。
    [137]计小青、曹啸,国有股权、内部人掠夺与外部人约束:一个理论模型[J],财经研究,2009(5):52-62。
    [138]计小青、曹啸,国有股权、投资者信心与中国股票市场发展理论及经验证据[J],财贸经济,2008(4):30-35。
    [139]计小青、曹啸,投资者保护、股票市场发展可能性边界与内生均衡:一个理论分析框架[J],财贸经济,2009(4):66-70。
    [140]计小青、曹啸,中国转轨时期的法律体系与投资者保护:一个比较的视角[J],科研管理,2007(3):114-122。
    [141]计小青、曹啸,中国转轨时期的市场机制与投资者保护[J],经济经纬,2008(1):142-145。
    [142]姜付秀、支晓强,张敏,投资者利益保护与股权融资成本[J],管理世界,2008(2):117-125。
    [143]焦媛媛、王琦,区域金融体系理论研究综述[J],工业技术经济,2007(7):148-151。
    [144]金雪军、田霖,我国区域金融成长差异的态势:1978-2003年[J],经济理论与经济管理,2004(8):24-30。
    [145]劳伦斯·汉密尔顿,应用STATA做统计分析[M],重庆:重庆大学出版社,2008年8月第1版。
    [146]李敬、冉光和、孙晓铎,中国区域金融发展差异的度量与变动趋势分析[J],当代财经,2008(3):34-40。
    [147]李兴江、赵锋,我国金融发展的非均衡性与中西部区域金融成长[J],甘肃金融,2003(11):13-14,17。
    [148]李扬、王国刚,资本市场导论[M],北京:经济管理出版社,1998年7月第1版。
    [149]李扬、王国刚、刘煜辉,中国地区金融生态环境评价(2006-2007)[M],北京:中国金融出版社,2007年12月第1版。
    [150]李治国,中国区域间资本流动-基于Feldstein-Horioka方法的检验[J],统计研究,2008(10):73-81。
    [151]林毅夫、蔡防、李周,中国经济转型时期的地区差距分析[J],经济研究,1998(6):3-10。
    [152]林勇、陈创练,投资者保护理论与中国实践的发展[M],北京:人民出版社,2008年10月第1版。
    [153]刘俊海,论证券市场法律责任的立法和司法协调[J],现代法学,2003(1):3-13。
    [154]刘少波,控制权收益悖论与超控制权收益-对大股东侵害小股东利益的一个新的理论解释[J],经济研究,2007(2):85-96。
    [155]龙宗智,论司法改革中的相对合理主义[J],中国社会科学,1999(2):130-140。
    [156]卢峰、姚洋,金融压抑下的法治、金融发展和经济增长[J],中国社会科学,2004(1):42-55。
    [157]栾天虹,投资者法律保护理论述评[J],浙江学刊,2005(3):190-194。
    [158]罗党论、唐清泉,大股东的隧道挖掘与制衡力量—来自中国市场的经验证据[J],中国会计评论,2005(6):63-86。
    [159]罗望、胡国文、何乐、秦丽,金融资源区域配置的失衡性探析—四川与东部部分省市金融增长的比较分析[J],西南金融,2004(6):8-12。
    [160]潘文卿、张伟,中国资本配置效率与金融发展相关性研究[J],管理世界,2003(8):16-23。
    [161]皮天雷、汪燕,转轨经济下的法律和金融发展[J],财经科学,2007(7):24-31。
    [162]钱颖一,市场与法治[J],经济社会体制比较,2000(3):1-111。
    [163]让·梯若尔,公司金融理论[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007年11月第1版。
    [164]沈艺峰、许年行、杨熠,我国中小投资者法律保护历史实践的实证检验[J],经济研 究,2004(9):90-100。
    [165]宋绪钦、叶晓枫,我国资本市场区域差异研究[J],地域研究与开发,2005(4):51-53。
    [166]孙曙伟,证券市场个人投资者权益保护制度研究[M],北京:中国金融出版社,2006年6月第1版。
    [167]谈儒勇、吴兴奎,中国各地金融发展差异的司法解释[J],财贸经济,2005(12):14-17。
    [168]谭崇台,发展经济学[M],太原:山西经济出版社,2001年8月第1版。
    [169]唐宗明、蒋位,中国上市公司大股东侵害度实证分析[J],经济研究,2002(4):44-50。
    [170]王保树,投资者利益保护[M],北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003年12月第1版。
    [171]王国刚,国民:中国资本市场上的重要角色[J],经济研究,1994(12):19-27。
    [172]王克敏、陈井勇,股权结构、投资者保护与公司绩效[J],管理世界,2004(7):127-133。
    [173]王鹏,投资者保护、代理成本与公司绩效[J]经济研究,2008(2):68-82。
    [174]王维强,我国区域金融政策问题研究[J],财经研究,2005(2):110-119。
    [175]王小鲁、樊纲,中国地区差距的变动趋势和影响因素[J],经济研究,2004(1):33-44。
    [176]王秀婷,中小投资者利益保护评价指标体系研究[D],重庆工商大学硕十学位论文,2007。
    [177]威廉·H·格林,计量经济分析[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2007年7月第1版。
    [178]魏锋,法制建设、金融发展与经济增长—基于中国省际面板数据的实证研究[J],重庆大学学报(社会科学版),2009(4):23-30。
    [179]吴晓求,关于当前我国金融改革和资本市场发展若干重要问题的看法[J],金融研究,2006(6):15-22。
    [180]吴晓求,证券投资学[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004年2月第2版。
    [181]吴耀宏、吴敏、刘红,区域资本市场与发挥区域比较优势[J],经济体制改革,2001(6):131-133。
    [182]伍海华,金融区域二元结构及发展对策[J],经济理论与经济管理,2002(8):22-27。
    [183]夏立军、方轶强,政府控制、治理环境与公司价值—来自中国证券市场的经验证据[J],经济研究,2005(5):40-51。
    [184]小股东权益保障委员会,2008年度中国小股东权益保护评价报告[J],商务周刊,2009(4):86-93。
    [185]谢玲芳、朱晓明,董事会控制、侵占效应与民营上市公司的价值[J],上海经济研究,2005(1):63-69。
    [186]辛宇、徐莉萍,投资者保护视角下治理环境与股改对价之间的关系研究[J],经济研究,2007(9):121-133。
    [187]徐静琳、刘力铭,地方性法规与政府规章关系论[J],政治与法律,2008(1):123-130。
    [188]许成钢,法律、执法与金融监管-介绍“法律的不完备性”理论[J],经济社会体制比较,2001年(5):1-12。
    [189]许成钢、卡塔琳娜·皮斯托,执法之外的机制—中俄金融市场的治理[J],比较,第6辑:87-108。
    [190]许崇正,中国企业并购与资本市场发展—企业迅速扩大的杠杆效益研究[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2002年8月第1版。
    [191]许琳,投资者法律保护与公司上市后长期业绩表现—基于法和金融理论的实证分析[J],南开管理评论,2006(2):96-101。
    [192]宣伟华,虚假陈述民事赔偿与投资者权益保护[M],北京:法律出版社,2003年4月第1版。
    [193]杨贵宾、王晓芳,投资者保护、证券市场与经济增长[J],系统工程理论方法应用,2004(13):524—529。
    [194]余劲松、梁红英,我国证券市场参与的地区差异及影响因素研究[J],城市发展研究, 2008(2),11-14。
    [195]苑德军、任志宏,强化中国资本市场功能的理论思考[J],财贸经济,2002(3):15-20。
    [196]詹正茂、陈刚、李俊,区域资本市场融资差异对区域经济发展的影响分析[J],工业技术经济,2004(1):49-51。
    [197]张薄洋、牛凯龙,金融发展指标的演进逻辑及对中国的启示[J],南开经济研究,2005年(1):79-85。
    [198]张建伟,法律、投资者保护与金融发展-兼论中国证券法变革[J],江西财经大学学报,《中国法学会经济法学研究会2005年年会专辑》:150-153。
    [199]张俊生、曾亚敏,社会资本与区域金融发展-基于中国省际数据的实证研究[J],财经研究,2005(4):37-45。
    [200]张人骥、刘春江,股权结构、股东保护与上市公司现金持有量[J],财贸经济,2005(2):3-9。
    [201]张维迎,法律制度的信誉基础[J],经济研究,2002(1):3-13(92)。
    [202]张维迎、柯荣住,信任及其解释:来自中国的跨省调查分析[J],经济研究,2002(10):59-70(92)。
    [203]张文路、赵雪芹,关于构建中国多层次化证券市场的分析与建议[J],金融研究,2004(8):136-141。
    [204]张祥建、刘建军、徐晋,大股东终极控制与掠夺行为研究[J],当代经济科学,2004(9):60-64。
    [205]张育军,投资者保护法研究[M],北京:人民出版社,2007年2月第1版。
    [206]章美锦、万解秋,我国区域性资本市场发展路径研究[J],财贸经济,2008(1):72-78。
    [207]章铁生,证券监管、地方政府与投资者保护[J],财政研究,2008(11):44-46。
    [208]赵伟、马瑞永,中国区域金融增长的差异-基于泰尔指数的测度[J],经济地理,2006(1):11-15。
    [209]赵向琴、朱孟楠,上市公司的双重侵权和外部投资者保护[J],南开经济研究,2005(5):88-93。
    [210]赵胄豪,区域资本市场发展与创新[M],北京:中国时代经济出版社,2003年10月第1版。
    [211]郑振龙、林海,法律和投资者保护:国际比较[J],福建论坛(经济社会版),2001(8):29-33。
    [212]郑志刚,法律对投资者权力的保护和经理人薪酬合约的奖金设计[J],世界经济,2009(1),52-61。
    [213]支大林,中国区域金融研究[D],东北师范大学博士学位论文,2002(10)。
    [214]中国社会科学院法学研究所,中国法制30年:1978-2008[M],北京:社会科学文献出版社,2008年12月第1版。
    [215]中国证券监督管理委员会,中国资本市场发展报告[M],北京:中国金融出版社,2008年3月第1版。
    [216]周立、胡鞍钢,中国金融发展的地区差距状况分析(1978-1999)[J],清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002(2):60-74。
    [217]周立、王子明,中国各地区金融发展与经济增长实证分析:1978-2000[J],金融研究,2002(10):1-13。
    [218]周勤业、夏立军、李莫愁,大股东侵害与上市公司资产评估偏差[J],统计研究,2003(10):39-44。
    [219]朱从玖,投资者保护-国际经验与中国实践[M],上海:复旦大学出版社,2002年10月第1版。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700