水中土霉味化合物的鉴定与去除研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
目前,日益增多的污染物排放到饮用水水源中,造成了水体富营养化现象严重。由此导致了藻类的大量繁殖,藻类不仅会消耗了水中的溶解氧,同时还释放嗅味物质,引起饮用水异嗅问题的出现。反-1,10-二甲基-反-9-萘烷醇(土味素,Geosmin)和二甲基异冰片(MIB)则是饮用水体中最常见的两种不良气味化合物,常规的水处理技术不能将其去除。
     研究运用比对实验、三角实验以及糖水对照实验对小组成员进行培训,建立了气味层次法(FPA),绘制出气味分析曲线,测定了在45℃的条件下,Geosmin和MIB的嗅阈值分别为5ng/L和8ng/L。同时,本研究还建立了固相微萃取—气质联用技术(SPME-GC/MS)分析水中的Geosmin和MIB,确定出最优化条件,在65℃的恒温水浴中,结合磁力搅拌萃取30min进样,脱附3min,该方法测定Geosmin的回收率为93.9%~99.2%,MIB的回收率为93.8%~96.2%,将这两种方法进行比较发现,两者之间吻合性较好,充分说明将FPA方法引入嗅味分析评价体系的可行性。
     结合FPA与SPME-GC/MS,对一年中长江水系的四大水厂、太湖以及南京中山陵风景区四大湖泊进行了气味鉴定与评价。调查发现,在上述水体中均检测出Geosmin和MIB的存在,浓度在5ng/L~25ng/L,有明显的嗅味,并且春夏季节,水中Geosmin和MIB的浓度高于秋冬季节。
     实验还探讨了余氯对FPA和SPME-GC/MS测定的影响。研究发现,当余氯的浓度达到0.8mg/L或以上时,土霉味将很难被感知,而余氯对Geosmin和MIB的SPME-GC/MS测定有11%~79%的掩蔽效应,使用硫代硫酸钠去除饮用水中的余氯的方法可以消除以上掩蔽效应。
     本课题运用光化学降解法、活性炭吸附法以及活性炭臭氧联用技术,探讨了Geosmin和MIB的去除方法,并结合FPA,对处理效果进行了评价,研究表明,臭氧、紫外对Geosmin和MIB的去除都有一定的效果,但均达不到嗅阈值以下,而粉末活性炭虽然能够有效地将Geosmin和MIB去除至嗅阈值以下,但是粉末活性炭的再生等后续工作的繁琐因素,不建议广泛使用。颗粒活性炭臭氧联用技术对饮用水中土霉味化合物的去除效果显著,结果表明:30mg/L颗粒活性炭投加量与3g/h臭氧联用可将上述气味化合物去除至嗅阈值以下。
At present,along with more and more pollutants being discharged into drinking water source,eutrophication was one of popular environmental problems happened in waters. Blooming aglae consume dissolved oxygen in water,release some components smelling disgusting.Geosmin and MIB(G&M)are the most common unpleasant compounds in water, and they can not be removed by conventional water treatment processes.
     Paired Comparison Test,Triangle Test and Sensitivity/Discrimination Test Ranking were used to train the panel of Flavor Profile Analysis(FPA)and the PFA method was established.Results showed that the olfactory threshold of Geosmin was 5ng/L,and the olfactory threshold of MIB was 8ng/L.At the same time,SPME-GC/MS was used to determine G&M in water,and the optimized operating condition was that the samples were extracted on a stirrer/hot plate schott for 30min at 65℃.The desorb time is 3min.The recovery rate of G&M can reach 93.9%~99.2%and 93.8%~96.2%repetively.
     FPA was introduced to the system of the analysis and identification on earthy and musty odors.The water samples from four water treatment plants along Changjiang River,Tai Lake and four lakes in Nanjing Sun Yat-sen in a year,were detected by PFA panel and SPME-GC/MS.The research showed that the G&M concentration in the water samples above were 5ng/L~25ng/L,and it was higher in spring and summer than that in autumn and winter.
     The impacts of residual chlorine on detecting G&M were studied.When the concentration of residual chlorine is more than 0.8mg/L,the earthy and musty odors can hardly been apperceived,and 11%~79%of reduction for G&M concentrations was observed in the presence of residual chlorine.The addition of sodium thiosulfate can effectively counteract the influence of chlorine.
     Ozone,UV,and activated carbon were used to remove G&M in water.It was found that ozone and UV have a little effect on removing G&M,but they could not decrease G&M to the concentration below olfactory threshold.Powder activated carbon(PAC)could effectively get rid of G&M,but PAC could hardly been regenerated,and it was not suggested to be used on a large scale.The removal effect of G&M in water with hyphenated techniques of granular activated carbon(GAC)and ozone was researched.The results showed that GAC of 30mg/L and ozone of 3g/h could remove these compounds to the concentration below olfactory threshold.
引文
[1]Kajino M.The relationship between musty-odor-causing organisms and water quality in Lake Biwa[J].Wat.Sci.Tech.,1999,23(6):39-44
    [2]Suffet I H.The drinking water taste and odor wheel for the millennium:beyond Geosmin and 2-methylisobomeol[J].Wat.Sci.Tech.,1999,56(6):1-13
    [3]Yong G W F,Horth H.,Crane R.Taste and odor threshold concentration of potential potable water contaminants.Water Research,1996,33(2):331-340
    [4]Susan W.Biologically produced taste,odour and toxic compounds in drinking water[J].Environment Canada.
    [5]Hayes S J,Hayes K P,Robinson B S.Geosmin as an odorous metabolite in cultures of a free living amoeba Vannella species(Gymnamoebia,Vannellidae).J Protozool,1991,38(1):44-47
    [6]周勤,孙伟.给水中的致味物质及其检测方法[J].工业水处理,2004,12(1):5-7
    [7]熊小庆,周驰.饮用水中气味有机物来源及检测方法[J].环境监测管理与技术,1999,21(5):9-11
    [8]Suffet I H,Brenner L,Cairo P R.GC/MS Identification of trace organics in philadephia drinking waters during a 2-Year period[J].Water Research,1980,56(14):853
    [9]Namkund E,Rittmann B E.Removal of taste and odor-causing compounds by biofilms grown on humic substances[J].Jour AWWA,1987,36(7):107
    [10]Hrudey S E,Gac A,Daignault S A.Potent odour-causing chemicals arising from drinking water disinfection[J].Water Science and Technology,1988,28(9):55
    [11]Skulberg O M.Chemical ecology and off-flavour substances[J].Water Science and Technology,1988,11(9):167-178
    [12]Montiel H.Study investigating the origin and mechanism of formation of sapid components preceding musty taste in our water supply[J].Proceedings,AWWA Water Quality Technology.Conf.
    [13]Bartels J H M,Brady B M,Suffet I H.Training panelists for the flavor profile analysis method[J].Jour AWWA,1987,13(1):26-32
    [14]Krasner S W,Mcguire M J and Ferguson V B.Tastes and odors:the flavor profile method[J].Jour AWWA,1985,37(12):39
    [15]Rashash D M C,Dietrich A M,Hoehn R C.FPA of selected odorous compounds[J].Jour AWWA,1997,15(2):131-140
    [16]马晓雁,高乃云,李青松,等.饮用水中异嗅物质—上臭素及二甲基异冰片的测定方法[J].环境污染与防治,2006(8):631-636
    [17]Brownlee B G,Gaminie L.A simple extraction procedure for moderately volatile taste and odor compounds such as geosmin and 22met hylisoborneol2met hod and applications[J].Water Science and Technology.1988,20:91-97
    [18]Bao M L,Barbieri K,Burrini D.Determination of trace levels of taste and odor compounds in water by microextraction and gas chromatography-ion-trap detection-mass spectrometry[J].Water Research,1997,25(7):1719-1727
    [19]Shin H S,Aim H S.Simple,rapid,and sensitive determination of odorous compounds in water by GC/MS[J].Chromatography,2000,11(1):107-113
    [20]Palmentier J P F P,Vince Y T,Steve W D J,et al.The determination of geosmin and 2-methylisoborneol in water using isotope dilution high resolution mass spectrometry[J].Water Research,1998,12(2):287-294
    [21]Hassett A J,Rohwer E R.Analysis of odorous compounds in water by isolation by closed-loop stripping with a multichannel silicone rubber trap followed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry[J].Journal of Chromatography,1999,849:521-528
    [22]Amy K Z,Patricia P.Membrane-based extraction for detection of tastes and odors in water[J].Water Research,1997,31:301-309
    [23]Lloyd S W,Lea J M,Zimba P V,et al.Rapid analysis of geosmin and 2-methylisoborneol in water using solid phase micro extraction procedures[J].Water Research,1998,32:140-142,146
    [24]Rebecca M,Phillip P,Russell S,et al.Determination of geosmin and 2-methylisoborneol in water using solid phase micro extraction and gas chromatography-chemical ionization/electron impact ionization-ion-trap mass spectrometry[J].Analyst,1998,123:2155-2160
    [25]Susan B W,Brownlee B,Trevor S,et al.Quantitative analysis of trace levels of geosmin and MIB in source and drinking water using headspace SPME[J].Water Research,2000,10:818-2828
    [26]Sung Y H,Ai T Y,Huang S D.Analysis of earthy and musty odors in water samples by solid phase microextraction coupled with gas chromatography/ion trap mass spectrometry[J].Talanta,2005,65:518-524
    [27]姜永军.饮用水消毒技术[J].甘肃科技.2004,12(20):5-7
    [28]宋瑞霞,徐凤丹.上海市饮水重要污染源有机致突变性的动态研究[J].卫生研究,1997,5(26):23-26
    [29]徐凤丹,周世伟,范美云,等.我国典型地区饮水中致突变性表征[J].环境科学,1994,3(15):41-44
    [30]王荣生.城市污水厂尾水氯消毒及其余氯控制技术进展[J].贵州环保科技,2003,6(9):9-12
    [31]魏建荣.饮用水中消毒副产物的研究进展[J].卫生研究,2004,8(33):35-36
    [32]中华人民共和国.生活饮用水标准,GB 5749-85
    [33]曹连城.DPD光度法测定水中余氯[J].环境工程,2003,4(21):65-66
    [34]刘文明.褪色光度法测定自来水中余氯[J].淮海学院科技学报,1998,3(6):33-35
    [35]秦文静.丁香醛连氮分光光度法测定饮用水中余氯[J].环境与健康杂志,1994,16(11):82
    [36]李宪平.库仑法测自来水中的余氯[J].岳阳大学学报,1999,12:62
    [37]李建鄂.水中余氯测定新方法研究[J].四川师范大学学报,1994,17:85
    [38]孟样萍,张霞.甲基橙分光光度法快速测定饮用水中余氯的方法探讨[J].中国公共卫生,1996,5(12):128
    [39]中华人民共和国.水质游离氯和总氯的测定N,N-二乙基-1,4-苯二胺分光光度法.中华人民共和国国家标准GB11898-1989
    [40]国家环保局编.水和废水监测分析方法(第三版)[M].北京中国环境出版社.1989
    [40]丁志斌,江作义.活性炭脱除水中余氯的试验研究.工业水处理[J],1997,14(17):56-58
    [42]许景文.活性炭在水处理中新应用[J].净水技术,1994,48:9-10
    [43]哈斯勒.活性炭净化[M].中国建筑工业出版社,1980
    [44]Kohei Urano.Adsorption of Chlorinated Organic Compounds on Activated Carbon from water[J].Water Research,1991(25):1459-1464
    [45]韩怀芬,丁勇.饮用水中余氯的脱除[J].水处理技术,1996,4(22):6
    [46]价常伟,徐凤玲.活性炭与其过滤装置的应用[J].有色矿冶,1996,21(6):12-15
    [47]张寿恺,邱梅.应用KDF55过滤介质从水中除氯[J].给水排水,2001,5(27):37
    [48]Heskett D E.US Patent.4.642.192.1987
    [49]Suffet I H,Schweitzer L,Khiari D.Olfactory and Chemical Analysis of Taste and Odor Episodes in Drinking Water Supplies[J].Entironmental Science and Biotechnology,2004,3(1):3-13
    [50]Bruchet A.,N'Guyen K,Mallevialle J,Anselme C.Identification and behaviour of iodinated haloform medicinal odor[J].Proceedings,AWWA Ann.Conf.,1989
    [51]Worley J L,Dietrich A M,Hoehn R C.Dechlorination Techniques for Improved Sensory Odor Testing of Geosmin and MIB[J].Jour.AWWA,2003,95(3):34-41
    [52]Oestman E,Schweitzer L,Tomboulian P,Corado A,Suffet I H.EffEcts of Chlorine and Chloramines on Earthy and Musty Odors in Drinking Water[J].Water Science and Technology,2004,49(9):153-159
    [53]Lin T F,Liu C L.Effect of residual chlorine on the analysis of geosmin,2-MIB and MTBE in drinking water using the SPME technique[J].Water Research,2003,37:21-26
    [54]Lalezary S.Oxidation of Five Earthy-Musty Taste and Odor compounds[J],Jour AWWA,1986,78(3):62-69
    [55]Moniwa T,Okada M,Motoyama N,Morioka Thoshikawa H.Study on Rate Constant of Odorous compounds Reaction with Ozone[C].Japan:Proceedings of 42nd Conference of Japan Waterworks Association,1991:145-147
    [56]Terashima K.Reduction of musty odor substances in drinking water—a pilotplant study[J].Water Science and Technology,1988,20(8):275-281
    [57]William H G.Evaluating Oxidants for the removal of model taste and odor compounds from a municipal water supply[J].AWWA,1990,82(5):79-84
    [58]Linda A L,Peter K J,Russell F R,et al.The destruction of 2-methylisoborneol and GSM using titanium dioxide photocatalysis[J].Applied Catalysis B:Environmental,2003,44(1):9-13
    [59]Narayan L V,Nunez W J.Biological Control:isolation and bacterial oxidation of the taste and odor compounds[J].Jour AWWA,1974,66(9):532-536
    [60]Chance V L,Henry C A,Angela S L.Isolation and characterization of a bacterium capable of removing taste and odor causing 2-methylisoborneol from water[J].Water Research,2004,38(19):4135-4142
    [61]Huck P M,Kenefick S L,Hrudey S E,et al.Bench-scale determination of the removal of odour compounds with biological treatment[J].Water Science and Technology,1995,31(11):203-209
    [62]Rittmann B E,McCarty P L.Model of steady-state biofilm kinetics[J].Biotech and Bioeng,1980(22):2343-2357
    [63]Cook D,Newcombe G.,Sztajnbok P.The Application of Powdered Activated Carbon for MIB and Geosmin Removal:Predicting PAC Doses in Four Raw Waters[J].Water Research,2001,35(5):1325-1333
    [64]Gayle N,Morrison J,Hepplewhite D,Knappe R U.Simultaneous adsorption of MIB and NOM onto activated carbonⅡCompetitive effects[J].Carbon,2002,40(12):2147-2156
    [65]张小满,曹达文.常规水处理工艺应用粉末活性炭技术的最佳投加点研究[J].给水排水,1998,24(2):29-31
    [66]李大鹏,李伟光,王铁民.投加粉末活性炭去除原水中的嗅味[J].中国给水排水,2004,20(6):44-46
    [67]张小平.合肥巢湖水投加粉末活性炭除臭[J].中国给水排水,1992,8(3):28-29
    [68]Lionel H,Gayle N.Effect of NOM,turbidity and flocsize on the PAC adsorption of MIB during alum coagulation[J].Water Research,2005,39(15):3668-3674
    [69]Graham,M.,Summers,R.S.,Simpson,M.R.,Macleod,B.W.Modeling Equilibrium Adsorption of 2-Methylisoborneol and Geosmin in Natural Waters[J].Water Research,2000,34(8):2291-2300
    [70]梁存珍,王东升,桑义敏,陈家庆.粉末炭去除饮用水中土霉味物质的影响因素研究[J].中国给水排水,2007,23(9):15-18
    [71]王琳,王宝贞.饮用水深度处理技术[M].北京:化学工业出版社,2002
    [72]王九思,陈学民,肖举强,等.水处理化学[M].北京:化学工业出版社,2002
    [73]伍海辉,朱斌,徐斌,高乃云.饮用水深度处理中活性炭的筛选试验研究[J].给水排水,2005,31(1):27-32
    [74]Elhadi S L,Huck P M,Slawson R M.Removal of geosmin and 2-methylisoborneol by biological filtration[J].Water Science and Technology,2004,49(9):273-280
    [75]Massoud P,Badrin B.GAC adsorber design protocol for the removal of off-flavors[J].Water Research,1993,27(7):1153-1166
    [76]Jellis W K.Removal of Geosmin and Methylisoborneol from drinkingwater by adsorption on ultrastable zeolite-Y[J].Water Research,1993,27(4):535-539
    [77]陈蓓蓓,高乃云,马晓雁,徐斌.饮用水中嗅味物质—土臭素和二甲基异冰片去除技术[J].四川环境,2007,26(3):89-90
    [78]吴德好.饮用水中土腥味和霉烂味的去除方法研究[J].安徽化工,2005,4:41-43
    [79]岳舜琳.提高自来水水质的策略[J].中国给水排水,1999,15(5):42-45
    [80]Youngsug K,Yeongho L,ChaiS G,et al.Treatment of taste and odor causing substances in drinking water[J].Water Science and Technology,1997,35(8):29-36
    [81]Smuramo,Dagawa T U,Kamura T O.Effective removal of musty odor in the Kanamachi purification plant[J].Water Science and Technology,1995,31(11):219-222
    [82]Masaki S,Kenji S,Hirotaka F.Ozone decomposition of 2-methylisoborneol(MIB)in adsorption phase on high silica zeolites with preventing bromate formation[J].Water Research,2005,39(13):2926-2934
    [83]Pendleton P,Wong S H,Schumann R,et al.Properties of activated carbon controlling 2-methylisoborneol adsorption[J].Carbon,1997,35(8):1141-1149
    [84]Graham M.R.,Summers R.S.,Simpson M.R.,et al.Modelling equilibrium adsorption of 2-methylisobomeol and Geosmin in natural water[J].Water Research,2000,34(5):2291-2300
    [85]Anna B,Robert P,Eugeniuchert.Adsorption from aqueous solutions of chlorinated organic compounds onto activated carbons[J].Journal of Colloid and Interface Science,2002,65(2):276-282
    [86]Wang Z P,Suffet I H,AL-Samarrai.Sensory and Chemical Analysis Mehtods for Earthy and Musty Odors in Drinking Water Caused by Geosmin and 2-Methylisoborneol[J].Water Science and Technology,2006,6(3):147-155

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700