商业关系结束背景下的“关系”与权力的关联研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
“关系(Guanxi)”是“情理社会”运行的基本要件。在儒家文化影响下的组织间商业关系中,“关系”被视为“纽带”、“资源”、“过程”和“网络”。然而,学界和业界对“关系”交换的影响机制、影响结果及伦理判断一直处于激烈地质疑和争论中。为探询“关系”对组织过程和交换活动的影响,本研究以商业关系结束为背景,聚焦于网络结构和情境条件对“关系”行为的影响及由此造成的结果。以交换理论为分析工具,揭示“关系”的内涵和特点,采用深度访谈和内容分析方法,探索性地获得概念模型;然后,采用问卷调查方法,收集辽宁、浙江和四川三省的312份有效问卷,以结构方程模型为分析工具,运用AMOS7.0软件处理数据。
     经过深入而谨慎的文献梳理,本研究认为,“关系”是基于既定的客观基础(例如血缘、同乡等)及互动交往基础(如同事、同学)而产生和发展出按照特定交换法则而形成的、动态的人际关联,这种人际关联扩展为互动网络,通过直接或间接的联结,在特定的情境因素下,有助于个体获得特定的资源,从而成为个体和组织的社会资本。它对交换活动的影响,受到社会心理、关系网络特点、二元关系属性、决策者的道德认知特征等诸多因素的影响。
     从新经济社会学的观点看,经济活动嵌入于行为人的社会关系中。从社会镶嵌网络理论视角看,组织的“关系网”是“交易网”的人际表现形式。由此出发,为解析不同的交易关系规范(包含团结规范、分享信息规范和弹性规范)与“关系”之间的关联,以关系契约理论和“人情-面子”交换理论建立交易网络结构对“人情”、“面子”和“情谊”的影响模型。对该模型的检验发现,厂商的网络中心度和交易网络密度,不但对“面子”、“人情”和“情谊”有直接的正向影响,还通过交易关系规范间接地对厂商的“面子”、“人情”和“情谊”产生较强的正向影响。并且,在厂商的“面子”、“人情”和“情谊”行为对组织交换活动产生的影响程度上,厂商的网络中心度比网络密度有更强大的影响,在关系型交换中的影响较之离散型交换更为重大。
     从厂商二元关系层面上看,由于“人情-面子”式交换规则具有资源调动和再分配功能,因而,“关系”对“权力”有再建构的功能。经假设检验表明,“面子”、“人情”和“情谊”对组织的影响力的影响整体上大于其对依赖度的影响;所以,“关系”不但是权力的重要来源,而且是特定条件下的有效控制方式。然而,以“关系”为工具影响厂商的“权力”运用方式及程度是高度情境化的。对过程公平的干扰效果检验表明,交互公平较高时,权力较大的厂商,其关系损失也更大。
     以关系的观点看,组织的营销活动是利益基础上的关系确认、关系建立、关系维持、关系强化,及必要时与顾客或其它关系人终止关系的过程。对商业关系结束时的“关系损失”数据检验结构表明,“关系”是厂商减少进入中国市场的风险与成本的有效资源,是厂商之间增进关系质量和信任、维护正式商业关系的有效活动,而且,也是厂商保留未来合作机会、减少冲突与摩擦、实现中国式商业关系圆满结束的重要控制方式;这表明,“关系”在商业关系各个阶段都发挥着独特的作用。
     综合以上研究发现来看,“关系”不仅是“关系营销”在我国的具体实现方式与工具,也是我国市场营销系统中的重要资源交换机制、人际互动规范和社会结构之一。虽然“关系”是多因素影响下的“艺术化”、有特定功效的权衡策略,随着商业价值观念的变迁、交易网的开放程度更高、法律完善程度提高、人际关系短暂化和其他因素的现代化,“关系”在中国市场中的工具性价值可能会下降,其所能发挥效应的领域也将逐渐缩减。
Guanxi is the founder mental component of reasonableness (Qingli) society. With Confucian culture working on industry market, it is viewed as the inter-personnel ties, resources, process and network. However, there are great confusion and debates upon its working system, effects as well as the relevant ethical judgment. To explore the influence of Guanxi on exchange process and activities, the study focus on the effect of structure traits of Guanxi network and situational conditions on Guanxi behavior and its relatively results in context of business relationship dissolution. Then, firstly author draw the definition and traits of Guanxi from view of social exchange theory. Then, an conceptual model is built and adjusted after doing deep interview and content analysis. Finally, 312 valid data has been collected from Liaoning, Zhejiang and Sichuan provinces by the survey, which were deal with by means of structural equation model and running AMOS 7.0 software.
     By prudential and in-depth literature reviewing, author point out that Guanxi is the dynamic personnel tie that takes root from object base (such as consanguinity, countrymen and so on) and intercourse and then develops and follows the specific exchange rule. These personnel ties are interacting and networking directly and indirectly to become the social capital, which is the helpful resources for individual and organization under certain condition.But, its tool value is determined by many factors such as the social psychological factors, dyadic relationship attribute, decision-maker's moral recognized characters and so on.
     From view of new economic sociology, economic actions are embedded in the actors' social relationship. This research discusses the relationship between exchange network and Guanxi network in industry market. Author provides a model to show how network structure influence on favor, Mianzi and affect. The 312 survey are collected from Liaoning, Zhejiang and Sichuan provinces, and the data and structural equation models are examined by AMOS 7.0. After exploring models and analyzing paths, it can be found that firm's network centrality and the network density have both direct and indirect effect on favor, Mianzi and affect. The network position of the firm has more positively stronger effect than network density, and Guanxi is more significantly effect in relational exchange than discrete exchange.
     Meanwhile, because of the exchanging rule of Pattern of Difference Guanxi, power can be reconstructed through Guanxi. Power is one of important factor of firm controlling system under the specific condition supported by our data results. However, it's highly situational to operate the power pattern and degree by use of Guanxi. The moderator effect of interactive fairness support that the more power, the bigger relationship lost.
     When viewed organizational marketing as relationship interactive process, it means developing relationship of awareness、exportation、maintaining、strengthening as well as possible dissolution with the customer. Guanxi has the unique influence through all these phases. Mianzi, favor and affect have more impact on influence than dependence between firm's powers. With the interaction justice moderating, firm with relatively stronger power will encounter more relationship lost significantly. Results of path analysis shows that Guanxi is an important patter for firms' China's beautiful exit to decrease the conflicts and reserving business chance in the future.
     According to the above findings, we can conclude that Guanxi is not only the tool for operating relationship marketing in China, but also is the important resource exchange system、interpersonal interactive norm and social structural component. Although it is the artistic and specific trading strategy influenced by complex factors, its instrumental value will decline in China industry market, with the exchange network open than before, personal ties shortened, law and statute perfected and other grounded factors changing,.
引文
[1]Dean,E.,K.Yunus.An Overview of Strategic Alliances[J].Management Decision,2001,39(3):205-218
    [2]Butzer-Strothmann,K.H.Krisen in Geschaftsbeziehungen[M].Verlagr:Deutscher Universitats,1999:3:23
    [3]Anderson,H.,Havila,V.,A.Salmi.Can You Buy a Business Relationship [J].Industrial Marketing Management,2001,30(3):575-86
    [4]Alajoutsijarvi,K.,M(o|¨)ller,K.,Tahtinen,J.Beautiful Exit:How to Leave Your Business Partner[J].European Journal of Marketing,2000,34(11/12):1270-1289
    [5]Giller,C.,Matear,S.The Termination of Inter-firm Relationships[J].Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,2001,16(2):94-112
    [6]Freeman,S.,Browne,E.The Influence of National Culture on Dissolution Communication Strategies in Western Versus Asian Business Relationships:a Theoretical Model[J].Supply Chain Management:An International Journal,2004,9(2):169-82
    [7]Sheth,Jagdish N.,Atul,P.Relationship Marketing in Consumer Markets;Antecedents and Consequences[J].Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,1995,23(4):255-271
    [8]Yeung,I.Y.M.,Tung,R.L.Achieving Business Success in Confucian Societies:The Importance of Guanxi[J].Organisational Dynamics,1996,25(2):54-65
    [9]Henry,K.H.,Fork,Ka-shing Woo.The China Market:Strategic Implications of Guanxi[J].Business Strategy Review,1998,9(3):33-43
    [10]Ricky,Y K.Chan,Louis T.W.Cheng,Ricky W.E Szeto.The Dynamics of Guanxi and Ethics for Chinese Executives[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2002,41(4):327-336
    [11]寿志钢.从交易成本透视关系营销[J].社会科学研究,2003,5:43-45
    [12]Standifird,S.S.,R.,Marshall,S.The Transaction Cost Advantage of Guanxi-based Business Practices[J].Journal of World Business,2000,35(1):21-42
    [13]Provis,C.Guanxi and Conflicts of Interest[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2008,79(1):57-68
    [14]Guthrie,D.The Declining Significance of Guanxi in China's Economic Transition[J].The China Quarterly,1998,154:254-282
    [15]Hwang,Kwang-kuo.Face and Favor:The Chinese Power Game [J].American Journal of Sociology,1987,92(January):944-974
    [16]翟 学伟.人情、面子与权力的再生产--情理社会中的社会交换方式[J].社会学研究,2004,5:48-57
    [17]庄贵军,席酉民.中国营销渠道中私人关系对渠道权力使用的影响[J].管理科学学报,2004,7(6):52-62
    [18]Ying,F.Questioning Guanxi:Definition,Classification and Implications [J].International Business Review,2002,11:543-561
    [19]Williamson,O.Transaction-cost Economics:The Governance of Contractual Process[J].Journal of Law and Economics,1975,ⅩⅫ(2):233-261
    [20]Andaleeb,S S.The Trust Concept:Research Issues for Channels of Distribution[J].Research in Marketing,1992,11:1-34
    [21]Granovetter,M.Economic Action and Social Structure:The Problem of Embeddedness[J].The American Journal of Sociology,1985,91(3):481-510
    [22]Uzzi,B.Social Structure and Competition in Interfirm Networks:the Paradox of Embeddedness[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1997,42:35-67
    [23]Heide,J.B.,George,J.Do Norms Matter in Marketing Relationships?[J].Journal of Marketing,1992,56(April):32-44
    [24]Molz,R.,Wang,X.Y.Chinese Guanxi as Network Building:the Emergence of the New Institutional Environment in China[J].Global Business and Economics Review,2006,8(1-2):44-59
    [25]Lovett,S.,Simmons,L.C.,Kali,R.Guanxi versus the Market:Ethics and Efficiency[J].Journal of International Business Studies,1999,30(2):231-248
    [26]Xin,K.R.,Pearce,J.L.Guanxi:Connections as Substitutes for Structural Support[J].Academy of Management Journal,1996,36:164-165
    [27]Wong,Y.H.,Chan,R.Y.Relationship Marketing in China:Guanxi,Favouritism and Adaptation[J].Journal of Business Ethics,1999,22:107-118
    [28]费孝通.乡土中国[M].上海书店暨观察社,1949年出版影印,上海:上海书店
    [29]Tsui,A.S.,Farh,J.L.Where Guanxi Matters:Relational Demography and Guanxi in the Chinese Context[J].Work and Occupations,1997,24:56-79
    [30]Ingmar,B.,Soren,K.Social Relationships and Business Networks:the Case of Western Companies in China[J].International Business Review 1995,4(4):519-535
    [31]Antia,K.D.,Frazier,G.L.The Severity of Contract Enforcement in Interfirm Channel Relationships,Journal of Marketing,2001,65(4):67-81
    [32]Morgan,R.M.,Hunt,S.D.[J].The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing[J]Journal of Marketing,1994,58(July):20-38
    [33]Good,D.J.,Evans,K.R.Relationship Unrest-A Strategic Perspective for Business-to-business Marketers[J].European Journal of Marketing Theory,2001,35(5/6) 549-65.
    [34]Dwyer,F.R.,Schurr,P.H.,Oh,S.Developing Buyer-Seller Relationships [J].Journal of Marketing,1987,51(April):11-27
    [35]Gr(o|¨)nroos,C.Quo Vadis,Marketing? Toward a Relationship Marketing Paradigm[J].Journal of Marketing Management,1994,10(5):347-360
    [36]Li,J.,Wright,P.The Issue of Guanxi:Discrepancies,Reality and Implications[C].BRC Working Paper 99036,September(School of Business,Business Research Center,Hong Kong Baptist University,Hong Kong,1999
    [37]Shi,X.,Westwood,R.I.International Business Negotiations in the Chinese Context[M].Li,J.T.,Tsui,A.,& Weldon,E.(Eds.),Management and Organizations in China.Macmillan,NY.2000
    [39]Jacobs,J.B.A Preliminary Model of Particularistic Ties in Chinese Political Alliances:kan-chi'ing and Kuan-his in a Rural Taiwanese Township[J].The China Quarterly,1979,79:237-273.
    [40]Xin,K.R.,Pearce,J.L.Guanxi:Connections as Substitutes for Structural Support[J].Academy of Management Journal,1996,36:1641-1658.
    [41]Leung,T.,Wong,Y.H.,Wong,S.A Study of Hong Kong Businessmen's Perceptions of the Role of Guanxi in the People's Republic of China[J].Journal of Business Ethics,1996,15:749-758
    [42]Chen,Z.X,Francesco,A M.The Relationship Between the Three Components of Commitment and Employee Performance in China[J].Journal of Vocational Behavior,2003,62(3):490-510
    [43]Brunner,J.A.,Taoka,G.Marketing and Negotiating in the People's Republic China:Perceptions of American Businessmen Who Attend the 1975Canton Trade Fair[J].Journal of International Business Studies,1977,8(2):69-82.
    [44]Yang,K.S.Gifts,Favors,and Banquets:The Art of Social Relationships in China[M].New York:Cornell University Press.1994
    [45]Tsui,A.S.,Farh,J.L.,Xin,K.Guanxi in the Chinese Context.[M].J.T.Li,A.S.Tsui,& E.Weldon(Eds.),Management and organizations in the Chinese context.London:MacMillan,2000
    [46]Peng,S.Q.Guanxi in Trust:An Indigenous Study of Chinese Interpersonal Trust.[D].The University of Hong Kong,1998:1-65
    [47]金耀基.人际关系中人情之分析(初探)[M].国际汉学会议论文集,台北:中央研究院,1980:12-32
    [48]Farh,J.L.L.,Tsui,A.S.,Xin,K.,Cheng B.S.The Influence of Relational Demography and Guanxi:The Chinese case[J].Organization Science,1998,9(4):471-488
    [49]郑伯壎.差序格局与华人组织行为[J].本土心理学研究,1995,3:142-219
    [50]戚树诚,林行宜.企业高阶主观亲信关系之研究[J].管理科学学科,1995,11(2):32-54
    [51]陈介玄.协力网络与生活结构-台湾中小企业的社会经济分析[M].台北:联经出版社,1994
    [52]Kiong,T.C.,Kee,Y.P.Guanxi Bases,Xinyong and Chinese Business Networks[J].British Journal of Sociology,1998,49(1):75-96
    [53]Levinger,G.Development and Change[M].H.H.Kelley,et al.Close relationships.San Francisco:Freeman,1983
    [54]Redding,S.Gordon,A.Norman,A.Schlander.The Characteristics of Chinese Personal Ties(Guanxi):Evidence from Hong Kong[J].Organization Studies.,2004,25:1075-1093
    [55]黄光国.人情与面子:中国人的权力游戏[M].黄光国,胡先缙等著,黄光国编,面子:中国人的权力游戏,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004,1-39
    [56]彭怀真.台湾企业业主的”关系”及其转变:一个社会学的分析[D].东海大学,1989:20-60
    [57]翟学伟.中国人际关系的特质--本土的概念及其模式[J].社会学研究,1993:4-8
    [58]陈介玄,高承恕.台湾企业运作的社会秩序:人情关系与法律[J].东海学报,32
    [59]杨国枢(1993)中国人的社会取向:社会互动的观点[M].杨国枢、余安邦(主编),中国人的心理与行为1992--理念与方法篇,台北:桂冠图书公司,1991:87-142
    [60]杨中芳.中国人的人际关系、情感与信任[M].台北:远流出版公司,2001
    [61]文崇一.报恩与复仇:交换行为的分析[M].社会及行为科学研究的中国化,台北:中央研究院民族学研究所,1982:311-443
    [62]庄贵军.可操作的关系营销与相关的道德问题[J].商业研究,2004:4:120-122
    [63]Butterfield,F.China:Alive in Bitter Sea[M].NY:Coronet Books.1983
    [64]Luo,Y.Guanxi:Principles,Philosophies,and Implications[J].Human System Management,1997:16:43-51
    [65]Tomás,J.,Arias,G.A relationship Marketing Approach to Guanxi [J].European Journal of Marketing,1996:31(1/2):145-156
    [66]Gold,T.B.After comradeship:personal relations in China since the Cultural Revolution[J].The China Quarterly,1985:104:657-675.
    [67]Bian,Y.J.Guanxi and the Allocation of Jobs in Urban China[J].The China Quarterly,1994,140:971-999
    [68]林南.社会资源理论:宏网研究[J].社会学与社会调查,1990:2:57-60
    [69]Lee,Don Y.,Dawes,Philip L.Guanxi,Trust,and Long-Term Orientation in Chinese Business Markets[J].Journal of International Marketing,2005:13(2):28-56
    [70]翟学伟.是“关系”,还是社会资本?[C].社会网及关系管理研究第三届社会网络与关系学术会议,南京:南京大学,2007
    [71]杨中芳.有关人际关系及人际情感的构念化[J].本土心理学研究,2000:12:105-179
    [72]乔健.Chinese Strategic Behavior:Some General Principles,in The Content of Culture:Constants and Variants.Studies[M].In Honor of John M.Roberts.Ralph Bolton,ed..New Haven:HRAF Press,1988:525-537
    [73]陈明璋.家族文化与企业管理[M].见杨国枢、黄光国、庄仲仁(主编):中国式管理研究会论文集,台北:台湾大学心理学系,1984
    [74]彭泗清.关系与信任:中国人人际信任的一项本土研究[M].中国社会学年鉴(1995-1998),社会科学文献出版,2000:290-297
    [75]杨国枢,文崇一.社及行为科学研究中国化[M].中国台北台湾研究院民族所,1982:12-66
    [76]Fiske,A.P.The Four Elementry Forms of Sociality:Framework for a Unified Theory of Social Relations[M].Goodwin,R.(eds) Personal Relationships Across Cultures Routledge,London,1992:22-36
    [77]朱瑞玲.中国人的慈善观[M].中国人的心理与行为科际研讨会论文集,台北:中央研究院民族学研究所,1992
    [78]陈介玄.关系与法令:台湾企业运作的一个传统面向[J].思与言,1990,28:47-64
    [79]汪涛,陈露蓉.中国本土文化环境下的商务“关系”:一项探索性研究[J].营销科学学报,2006,2(3):1-14
    [80]罗家德,谢朝霞.中国人关系强度的构面分析[C].社会网及关系管理研究第三届社会网络与关系学术会议,南京:南京理工大学,2007
    [81]胡先缙.中国人的面子观[M].黄光国,胡先缙等著,黄光国编,面子:中国人的权力游戏,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004:40-62
    [82]王轶楠.从东西方文化的差异分析面子与自尊的关系[J].社会心理科学,2006,21(2):102-108
    [83]Ho,David Yau-fai.On the Concept of Face[J].The American Journal of Sociology,1976,81(4):867-884
    [84]Davies,H.,Leung,T.K,Luk,S.,Wong,Y.The Benefits of Guanxi:The Value of Relationships in Developing The Chinese Market[J].Industrial Marketing Management,1995,24:207-214
    [85]Styles,C.,Ambler,T.The Coexistence of Transaction and Relational Marketing:Insights from the Chinese Business Context[J].Industria Marketing Management,2000,32(8):633-642
    [86]Wong,Y.H.An Integrated Relationship(Guanxi) Marketing Model in China[J].Journal of professional Services Marketing,1998,18(1):25-48
    [87]庄贵军.关于关系营销的几个问题[J].企业销售,1997,6:48-51
    [88]Jacobs,B.J The Concept of Guanxi and Social Politics in a Rural Chinese Cultural Setting[M].Greenblatt,S.L.,Wilson,R.W.& Wilson,A.A.(Eds.),Social Interaction in Chinese Society.New York,Praeger.,1982.
    [89]Wang,C.L.Guanxi vs.Relationship Marketing:Exploring Underlying Differences[J].Industrial Marketing Management,2007,36(1):81-86
    [90]Geddie,M.W.,DeFranco,A.L.,Geddie,M.F..A Comparison of Relationship Marketing and Guanxi:its Implications for the Hospitality Industry[J].International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management,2005,17(7):614-632
    [91]肖舒羽.浅析中国的人际关系营销[J].商场现代化,2006,486(11月下旬):88-90
    [92]陈波.关系营销与中国关系型商业模式的兼容性研究-社会网络理论的视角[J].北京工商大学学报.社会科学版,2005,20(3):66-71
    [93]Yau,O.H.M.,Lee,J.S.Y.,Chow,R.P.M,Sin,L.Y.M.,Tse,A.C.B.Relationship Marketing the Chinese Way Business Horizons,January 2000,43(1-2):16-24
    [94]Geddie,M.W.,DeFranco,A.L.,Geddie,M.F.From Guanxi to Customer Relationship Marketing:How the Constructs of Guanxi can Strengthen CRM in the Hospitality Industry[J].Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Marketing,2002,13(3):19-33
    [95]Bagozzi,R.P.Marketing as Exchange[J].Journal of Marketing,1975,39(4):32-39
    [96]杨中芳.试论如何研究中国人的性格[M].载杨国枢、余安邦主编,中国人的心理与行为:理念及方法篇,台北:桂冠图书公司,1992;
    [97]Yum,J.O.The Impact of Confucianism on Interpersonal Relationships and Communication Patterns in East Asia[J].Communication Monographs,December,1988,347-388
    [98]Hofstede,G.The Confucius Connection:From Cultural Roots To Economic Growth[J].Organization Dynamics,1988:39-60
    [99]杨宜音.试析人际关系及其分类--兼与黄光国先生商榷[J].社会学研究,1995,5:18-23
    [100]Emerson,R.M.Power-dependence Relations[J].American Sociological Review,1962:27:47-52
    [101]蔡仁厚.儒家思想的现代意义.台北:文津出版社,1987
    [102]O'Donnell,A.,Gilmore,A.,Cummins,D.,Carson,D.The Network Construct in Entrepreneurship Research:a Review and Critique[J].Managemnt Decision,2001,39(9):749-760
    [103]石秀印.中国企业家成功的社会网络基础[J].管理世界,1998,6:187-96
    [104]Luk,S.T.K.,Fullgrabe,L.,Li,S.C.Y.Managing Direct Selling Activities in China:A Cultural Explanation[J].Journal of Business Research,1999,45:257-266.
    [105]Lee,M.Y.,Ellis,P.Insider-outsider Perspectives of Guanxi[J].Business Horizons,2000,43(1):25-30
    [106]Kao,J.The Worldwide Web of Chinese Business[M].Harvard Business Review,1993,71(2):24-36
    [107]Tsang.E.W.K.Can Guanxi be a Source of Sustained Competitive Advantage for Doing Business in China?[J].Academy of Management Executive,1998,12:64-73
    [108]Ho,P.S.,Luo,Ya-dong.Guanxi and Organizational Dynamics:Organizational Networking in Chinese Firms[J].Strategic Management Journal,2001,22:445-477
    [109]T(a|¨)htinen J.,Halinen A.Research on Ending Exchange Relationships.A Gategorisation,an Assessment,and an Outlook[J].Marketing Theory,2002,2(2):165-88.
    [110]Stewart,K.,The Customer Exit Process-A Review and Research Agenda [J].Journal of Marketing Management,1998,14:235-20
    [111]Ping,Jr.,Robert A.The Effects of Satisfaction and Structural Constraints on Retailer Exiting,Voice,Loyalty,Opportunities and Neglect[J].Journal of Retailing,1993,69(3):320-52
    [112]Ping,Jr.,Robert A.Some Uninvestigated Antecedents of Retailer Exi't Intention[J].Journal of Business Research,1995,34(3):171-80
    [113]Bluedom,A.C.The Theories of Turnover:Causes,Effects,and Meaning [M].in Research in the Sociology of Organizations,Samuel B.Bacharach,ed.Greenwich,CT:JAI Press,1982:75-128
    [114]Michalski,S.Relationship Dissolution[C].Bliemel,F,Eggert A and Fassott G.(Eds),Proceedings of the 10th International Colloquium in Relationship Marketing.Kaiserslauter,2002(1):233-246
    [115]Rosson,P.J.Time Passages:The Changing Nature of Manufacturer-Overseas Distributor Relations in Exporting[J].Industrial Marketing and Purchasing,1986.1(2):48-64.
    [116]Gadde,L.E.,Mattsson,L.G.Stability and Changein Network Relationships[J].International Journal of Research in Marketing,1987,4(1):29-41.
    [117]T(a|¨)htinen,J.,Halinen-Kaila,A.The Death of Business Triads:The Dissolution Process of a Net of Companies[C].Proceedings of the 13th IMP Conference.Lyon,France.1997
    [118]Jones,M.A.,Mothersbaugh,D.L.,Beatty,S.E.Why Customers Stay:Measuring The Underlaying Dimensions of Service Switching Costs and Managing Their Differential Strategic Outcomes[J].Journal of Business Reasearch,2002,55:441-50.
    [119]徐忠海,黄拥军.被企业营销管理遗忘的角落:恢复客户关系管理[J].商业经济与管理,2001,119:26-29
    [120]Ping, R., Dwyer, F.R. A Preliminary Model of Relationship Termination in Marketing Channels[M]. G.L. Frazier (ed.) Advances in Distribution Channel Research.Greenwich: JAI Press, 1992
    
    [121]Tahtinen, J., Halinen, A. A Business Divorces. How does it happen? [C].Australian & New Zealand Marketing Academy Conference, Jack Cadeaux and Mark Uncles (Ed.). Sydney, Australia, 1999
    
    [122]Pressey, A.D., Mathews, B.P. Jumped, Pushed or Forgotten? Approaches to Dissolution [J].Journal of Marketing Management, 2003,19 (1-2): 131-55.
    [123]Inger, B. P.. A Multi-level Perspective on the Dissolution of Business Relationships[C].17th IMP-conference in Oslo, Norway,2001
    [124]Friman M., Garling, T., Millett, B., Mattssond, J., Johnston, R. An Analysis of International Business-to-business Relationships Based on the Commitment-Trust Theory [J].Industrial Marketing Management, 2002,31(5): 403-409
    
    [125]Abdul-Muhmin, Alhassan G Instrumental and Interpersonal Determinants of Relationship Satisfaction and Commitment in Industrial Markets [J]. Journal of Business Research ,2005,58 (5): 619-628
    
    [126]Doyle, P., Corstjens, M., Michell, P. Signals of Vulnerability in Agency-Client Relations[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1980, 44 (Fall): 18-23
    [127]Henke, L. A Longitudinal Analysis of the Ad Agency-Client Relationship Predictors of an Agency Switch' [J]. Journal of Advertising Research, 1995,36(2): 25-30
    
    [128]Buchanan, B.,Michell, Paul C. Using Structural Factors to Assess the Risk of Failure in Agency - Client Relations[J].Journal of Advertising Research, 1991,31 (4): 68-75
    
    [129]Michell, P.C.N. Point of View: Advertising Account Loyalty-A Segmentation Approach [J].Journal of Advertising Research, 1987/8, 27 (6):61-67
    
    [130]Michell C, Paul N. The Influence of Organizational Compatibility on Account Switching [J].Journal of Advertising Research, 1988, 28 (3):33 - 38
    [131]Michael, B., Francis F., Zeb, W. The Role of Value Change Management in Relationship Dissolution:Hygiene and Motivational Factors[J].Journal of Marketing Management,2004,20(9-10):927-939
    [132]Baxter,L.A.Accomplishing Relationship Disengagement in Understanding Personal Relationships.An Interdisciplinary Approach[M].Sage,London:Duck,S.and Perlman,D.(Eds.),1985;
    [133]Clegg,Stewart R.Modern Organizations:Organization Studies in the Postmodern World[M].London,Newbury Park and New Delhi:Sage Publications.1990;
    [134]Zukin S.,Paul,D.Structures of Capital:the Social Organization of the Economy.[M].London,Cambridge University Press Publications,1990
    [135]Rooks,G.,Raub,W.,Selten,R.,Tazelaar,F.Cooperation Between Buyer and Supplier:Effects of Social Embeddedness on Negotiation Effort[J].Acta Sociologica,2000,43:123-137
    [136]Raub,W.,Weesie,J.The Management of Matches:Decentralized Mechanisms for Cooperative Relations with Applications to Organizations and Households[C].ISCORE- Paper No.1.Utrecht:Utrecht University.,1991;
    [137]Gulati,R.Alliances and Networks[J].Strategic Management Journal,1998,19(4):293-317
    [138]林竞君.嵌入性,社会网络与产业集群--一个新经济社会学的视[J]经济经纬,2004,5:45-48
    [139]Ritter,T.,Gem(u|¨)nden,H.G.The Impact of a Company's Business Strategy on Its Technological Competence,Network Competence and Innovation Success[J].Journal of Business Research,2004,57(5):548-556
    [140]Baum,J.A.C.,Dutton,J.The Embeddedness of Strategy[M].P.Shrivastava,A.S.Huff and J.E.Dutton(eds.),Advances in Strategic \Management.Greenwich,CT:JAI Press,1996
    [141]Dacin,M.T.,Ventresca,M.J.,Beal,B.D.The Embeddedness of Organizations:Dialogue and Directions[J].Journal of Management,1999,25(3):317-356
    [142]Davern,M.Social Networks and Economic Sociology:A Proposed Research Agenda for a More Complete Social Science[J].American Journal of Economics & Sociology,1997,56(3):287-302
    [143]张存刚,李明,陆德梅.社会网络分析--一种重要的社会学研究方法[J].甘肃社会科学,2004,2:109-111
    [144]Madhavan R.,Koka,B.R.,Prescott,J.H..Networks in transition:How industry-events(re)shape interfirm relationships[J].Strategic Management Journal,1998,19(2):439-459.
    [145]马汀 奇达夫,蔡文彬著,王凤彬等译.社会网络与组织[M].中国人民大学出版社,2007:40-74
    [146]Burt,R.S.Structural Holes:The Social Science of Competition[M].Cambridge,MA:Harvard University Press,1992:65-103
    [147]Wasserman,S.,Faust,K.D Social Network Analysis:Methods and Applications[M].New York:Cambridge University Press,1994
    [148]Owen,G.,Pozo,M.del.,Tejada,J.Centrality and Power in Social Networks:a Game Theoretic Approach[J].Mathematical Social Sciences,2003,46:27-54
    [149]Nieminen J.On the Centrality in a Graph[J].Scandinavin Journal of Psychology,1974,15(4):332-36.
    [148]Galaskiewicz,J.Exchange Networks and Community Politics.CA:Sage [M]:Beverly Hills,1979
    [151]Nohria,N.Is A Network Perspective A Useful Way of Studying Organizations?[M].Networts and Organizations:Structure,Form and Action,Nohria & R.Eccles(Eds.) N,Ed.Boston:Harvard Business School Press,1992
    [152]Valente,T.W.Network models of the Diffusion of Innovations[M].Cresskill,NJ:Hampton Press,1995
    [153]Brass.D.J,Burkhardt M.E.Centrality and Power In Organizations in Networks and Organizations:Structure,Form and Action[M].N.Nohria & R.Eccles(Eds.),Ed.Boston:Harvard Business School Press.,1992
    [154]Laumann,E.O.,Galaskiewicz,J.,Marsden,P.V.Community Structure as Interorganizational Linkages[J].Annual Review of Sociology,1978,4:455-484
    [155]Lee,K.H.,Lo,T.Wing-chun.American Business People's Perceptions of Marketing and Negotiation in the People Republic of China[J].International Marketing Review,1988,Summer:22-36
    [156]Szeto,R.,Wright,P.C.Business Networking in the Chinese Context Its Role in the Formation of Guanxi:Social Capital and Ethical Foundations[J].Management Research News,2006,29(7):425-438
    [157]Ouchi W.G.Markets,Bureaucracies and Clans[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1980,25:129-141
    [158]Anderson,J.C.,Narus,J.A.Capturing the Value of Supplementary Services[J].Harvard Business Review,January-February:1995:75-83
    [159]T(a|¨)htinen J.,Vaaland T.Business Relationships Facing the End:Why Restore Them?[J].Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing,2006,21(1):14-23
    [160]Lee,Dong-Jin.,Pae,Jae H.,Wong,Y.H.A Model of Close Business Relationships in China(guanxi)[J].European Journal of Marketing,2001,35(1/2):51-69
    [161]Au,Alan K.M.,Wong,Danny S.N.The Impact of Guanxi on the Ethical Decision-Making Process of Auditors - An Exploratory Study on Chinese CPAs in Hong Kong[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2000,28(1):87-93
    [162]Su,C.,Sirgy,M.J.,Littlefield,J.E.Is Guanxi Orientation Bad,Ethically Speaking? A Study of Chinese Enterprises[J].Journal of Businesee Ethics,2003,44(4):303-312
    [163]Buckley,P.J.,Clegg,J.,Tan,H.Cultural Awareness in Knowledge Transfer to China--The Role of Guanxi and Mianzi[J].Journal of World Business 2006,41:275-288
    [164]庄贵军,席酉民.关系营销在中国的文化基础[J].管理世界,2003,10:98-156
    [165]Su,C.,Mitchell,R.K.,Sirgy,M.J.Enabling Guanxi Management in China:A Hierarchical Stakeholder Model of Effective Guanxi[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2007,71:301-319
    [166]Baker,G,Gibbons,R.,Murphy,K.J.Relational Contracts and the Theory of the Firm[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,2002,117(1):39-81.
    [167]Poppo L.,Zenger T.Do Formal Contracts and Relational Governance Function as Substitutes or Complements[J]Strategic Management Journal,2002,23:707-725.
    [168]Parnell,Martin F.Chinese Business Guanxi:an Organization or Non-organization?[J].Journal of Organisational Transformation and Social Change 2005,2(1):29-47
    [169]Coase,R.H.Industrial Organization:a Proposal for Research[M].Policy Issues and Research Opportunities in Industrial Organization:1972:59-73
    [170]Williamson O.The Economic Institutions of Capitalism[M].New York.The Free Press,1985
    [171]罗家德.为什么硅谷能击败128公路区-以人际关系网络观点探讨网优势[J].中山管理评论,1997,5(2):287-314
    [172]Polanyi K.The Livelihood of Man[M].Harry W.Pearson,New York et al.:Academic Press,1977
    [173]Moth,M.K.,Seashore,S.Norms Governing Corporate Behavior:An Alternative to Markets and to Administration[C].Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association,89th,Los Angeles,CA,1981
    [174]Powell L W.Neither Market Nor Hierarchy:Network Forms of Organization[J].Research in Organizational Behavior,1990,12:295-336
    [175]Berger,P.L.,Luckmann T.The Social Construction of Reality:a Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge[M].The Penguin Press edition,Doubleday and Co.,New York,NY,1966
    [176]Thibaut,J.W.,Kelly,H.H.The Social Psychology of Group[M].New York:Wiley,1959
    [177]Adams,J.S.Inequity in Social Exchange[M].New York:Academic Press,1965
    [178]罗家德,叶勇助.中国人的信任游戏[M].社会科学文献出版社:北京,2007:76-83
    [179]Macneil,I.R.The New Social Contract[M].Yale UniversityPress:New Haven,1980
    [180]麦克尼尔.雷喜宁、潘勤译,新社会契约论[M].中国政法大学出版社:北京,1994
    [181]Mohr,J.,Spekman,R.Characteristics of Partnership Success:Partnership Attributes,Communication Behavior,and Conflict Resolution Techniques[J].Strategic Management Journal,1994,15(2):135-152
    [182]Anderson,J.C.,Narus,J.A.A Model Of Distributor Firm And Manufacturer Firm Working[C].Journal of Marketing,Chicago;Jan;1990,54(1):90-102
    [183]Achrol,R.S.,Kotler,P.Marketing in the Network Economy[J].Journal of Marketing,63,Fundamental Issues and Directions for Marketing,1999,146-163.
    [184]Kaufmann,P.J.,Stern,L.W.Relational Exchange Norms,Perceptions of Unfairness,and Retained Hostility in Commercial Litigation[J].The Journal of Conflict Resolution,1988,32(3):534-552
    [185]Ganesan,S.Determinants of Long-Term Orientation in Buyer-Seller Relationships[J].Journal of Marketing,1994,58(2):1-19
    [186]Noordewier,T.G.,John,G.,Nevin,J.R.Performance Outcomes of Purchasing Arrangements in Industrial Buyer-Vendor Relationships[J].Journal of Marketing,1990,54(October):80-93
    [187]Pearce,J.A.,Robinson,R.B.Cultivating Guanxi as a Foreign Investor Strategy[J].Business Horizons,1988,43(1):31-38
    [188]Ghoshal,S.,Bartlett,C.A.The Multinational Corporation as an Interorganizational Network[J].The Academy of Management Review,1990,15(4):603-625
    [189]Standifird,S.S.Using Guanxi to Establish Corporate Reputation in China[J]2006,9(3):171-178
    [190]Thorelli,H.B.Network:Between Markets & Hierarchies[J].Strategic Management Journal,1986,7:37-51
    [191]Rowley,T.J.Moving Beyond Dyadic Ties:A Network Theory of Stakeholder Influences[J].Academy of Management Review,1997,22:887-910
    [192]Brass, D. J., Burkhardt, M. E. Centrality and Power in Organizations [M] .N. Nohria & R. Eccles (Eds.) , Networks and Organizations: Structure, Form and Action, Boston: Harvard Business School Press,1992,191-215
    
    [193]Artz, K. W., Brush, T. H. Asset Specificity, Uncertainty and Relational Norms: an Examination of Coordination Costs in Collaborative Strategic Alliances[J] Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 2000,41(4): 337-362
    [194]Lusch, Robert F., James R. Brown. Interdependency, Contracting, and Relational Behavior in Marketing Channels [J]. Journal of Marketing, 1996,60:19-38
    
    [195]Sheppard, B.H., Tuchinsky, M. Interfirm Relationships: A Grammar of Pairs [J].Research in Organizational Behavior, 1996, 18:331-373.
    [196]Fiske, A. P. The Four Elementry Forms of Sociality: Framework for a Unified Theory of Social Relations [M]. R., Goodwin (eds) Personal Relationships Across Cultures, Routledge, London ,1992,22-36
    [197]Sheppard, Blair H., Sherman, Dana M. The Grammars of Trust: A Model and General Implications [J].The Academy of Management Review,1998,23(3):422-437
    
    [198]Coleman J.S. Foundations of Social Theory [M].Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press, 1990;
    
    [199]Valente, T. W. Network Models of the Diffusion of Innovations [M].Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press., 1995;
    
    [200]Burt, Ronald S. The Network Structure of Social Capital. [C] Social Networks and Social Capital Conference, Duke University, Durham, NC, 1998
    [201]Gnyawali Devi R., Madhavan R. Cooperative Networks and Competitive Dynamics: A Structural Embeddedness Perspective [J].Academy of Management Review, 2001,26(3):431-455
    
    [202]Walker,G, Bruce,B., Shan,W. Social Capital, Structural Holes and the Formation of an Industry Network [J].Organization Science, 1997,8(2):109-125
    [203]Lawler, Edward J., Bacharach, Samuel B. Comparison of Dependence and Punitive Forms of Power[J].Social Forces,1987,66(2):446-462
    [204]Lewicki,Litterer J.A.Negotiation[M].Homewood ILL:Richard R.J.&D.Irwi.1985;
    [205]Pfeffer Jeffrey.Power in Organizations[M].Pitman Publishing,Marshield,Massachusetts,1981
    [206]文崇一.从价值取向谈中国国民性[M].台北,全国出版社,1981
    [207]Ippolito,C.A.,Pruitt,D.Power Balancing inmediation:Outcomes and Implications of Mediator Intervention[J].International Journal of Conflict Management,1991,1:341-55.
    [208]Zartman,I.W.Decision Support and Negotiation Research:A Researcher'S Perspective[J].Theory and Decision,1993,34(3):345-351
    [209]El-Ansary,A.,Stern,L.W.Power Measurement in the Distribution Channel[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1972,9:47-52.
    [210]Kale,Sudhir H.Dealer Perceptions of Manufacturer Power and Influence Strategies in a Developing Country[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1986,23:387-93
    [211]Buchanan,L.Vertical Trade Relationships:The Role of Dependence and Symmetry in Attaining Organizational Goals[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1992:29:65-75.
    [212]Zhuang,G.,Zhou,N.The Relationship Between Power and Dependence in Marketing Channels:A Chinese Perspective[J].European Journal of Marketing,2004,38(5/6):675-669
    [213]T(a|¨)htinen,J.The Process of Business Relationship Ending-Its Stage and Actors[J].Journal of Market-Focused Management,2002,5:331-53.
    [214]Bannister,E.Sociodynamics:An Integrative Theorem of Power,Authority,Influence,andlove[J].American Sociological Review,1969,34:374-393
    [215]El-Ansary,A.Determinants of Power-dependence in the Distribution Channel[J].Journal of Retailing,1975,51(2):59-74
    [216]罗子衡.权力位阶与信任关系对外包谈判策略的影响--以交易成本理论与镶嵌理论解释分析[D].元智大学资讯社会学研究所,2005
    [217]Tuusj(a|¨)rvi,E.,Blois,E.Interpretations of Fairness in Dissolution of Complex Relationships[J].Journal of Marketing Management,2004,20(9-10):959-975
    [218]Kumar,N.,Scheer,L.K.,Steenkamp,J.B.E.M.The Effects of Perceived Interdependence on Dealer Attitudes[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1995,32(3):348-356
    [219]Gaski,John F.The Theory of Power and Conflict in Channels of Distribution[J].Journal of Marketing,1984,48(3):9-29
    [220]Moim,Linda D.Theron M.Quist,Phillip A.Wiseley.Reciprocal Justice and Strategies of Exchange[J].Social Forces,1994,72:19-43
    [221]Frazier,G.On the Measurement of Interfirm Power in Channels of Distribution[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1983,20:158-166
    [222]Gundlach,Gregory T.,Cadotte,Ernest R.Exchange Interdependence and Interfirm Interaction:Research in a Simulated Channel Setting[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1994,31(4):516-532
    [223]Kale,S.H.Dealer Perceptions of Manufacturer Power and Influence Strategies in a Developing Country[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1986,\23:387-93
    [224]Buchanan,L.Vertical Trade Relationships:The Role of Dependence and Symmetry in Attaining Organizational Goals[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1992,29:65-75
    [225]Zhuang,G.,Zhou,N.The Relationship Between Power and Dependence in Marketing channels:A Chinese Perspective[J].European Journal of Marketing,2004,38(5/6):675-693
    [226]Adeli,El-ansary,Stern,Louis W.Power Measurement in the Distribution Channel[J].Journal of Marketing Research,1972,Ⅸ:47-52
    [227]Berry,Leonard L.,Seiders,K.Service Fairness:What It Is and Why It Matters[J].Academy of Management Executive,1998,12(2):8-20
    [228]Swan,John E.,Oliver,Richard L.An Applied Analysis of Buyer Equity Perceptions and Satisfaction with Automobile Salespeople[J].Journal of Personal Selling and Sales Management,1991,11:15-26
    [229]杰瑞·W·瑞安和H·拉赛尔·伯纳德.数据处理与分析方法[M].定性研究: 经验资料收集与分析的方法,诺曼·K·灯津,伊冯娜·S·林肯,风笑天等译,重庆大学出版社,2007:823-858
    [230]安德里亚·方塔纳,詹姆斯·H·弗里.访谈:从结构式问题到引导式话题[M].定性研究:经验资料收集与分析的方法,诺曼·K·灯津,伊冯娜·S·林肯,风笑天等译,重庆大学出版社,2007:683-712
    [231]Lincoln,Y.,Guba,E.G.Naturalistic Inquiry[M].Beverly Hills CA:Sago.,1985:312-320
    [232]瓦莱丽J简西克.定性研究设计的编舞艺术:米奴哀小步舞、即兴表演与晶体化[M].定性研究:策略与艺术定性研究:经验资料收集与分析的方法,诺曼·K·邓津,伊冯娜·S·林肯,风笑天等译,重庆大学出版社,2007:407-428
    [233]Corbin,J.,Strauss,A.Grounded Theory Research:Procedures,Canons and Evaluative Criteria[J].Qualitative Sociology,1990,13:3-21
    [234]Hair,Joseph F.,Anderson,J.E.,Rolph,Tatham,R.L.,Black,W.C.Multivariate Data Analysis[M].New Jersey:Prentice Hall,1998
    [235]Byrne,Barbara M.Structural Equation Modeling With Amos:Basic Concepts,Applications,and Programming[M],Lawrece Erlaum Associates,Majiwall,New Jersey,2001:100-118
    [236]Bollen,Kenneth A.Multiple Indicators:Internal Consistency of no Necessary Relationship?[J].Quality and Quantity,1984,18:377-385
    [237]Bagozzi,R.P.,Yi,Y.On the Evaluation of Structural Equation Models [J].Academy of Marketing Science,1988,16:76-94
    [238]Bagozzi,R.P.Issues in the Application of Covariance Structure Analysis:A Further Comment[J].Journal of Consumer Research,1983,9:449-450
    [239]Vanhonacker,W.R.Guanxi Networks in CHINA-How to be the Spider,Not the Fly[J].The China Business Reviews,2004:May-June:48-53
    [240]Kraatz,M.S.Learning by Association? Interorganizational;Networks and Adaptation to Environmental change[J].Academy of Management Journal,1998,41:621-643
    [241]Luo,Jar-Der,Y.C.Yeh.The Transaction Cost-embeddedness Approach to Study Chinese Subcontracting.[C].International Social Capital Conference: Communities,Organizations,Classes and Social Networks,TaiChung,2004
    [242]张雅婷.关系网络连结与顾客忠诚度关联性研究-以人寿保险业为例[D]私立东海大学企业管理研究所,2002:101-134
    [243]Yang,K S.Chinese Personality and its Change[M].Bond M H ed.The Psychology of the Chinese People.Hong Kong:Oxford University Press,2002:106-170
    [244]H0,D.Y.F.,Chiu,C.Y.Component Ideas of Individualism,Collectivism,and Social Organization:An Application in the Study of Chinese Culture[M].Bond M.Ed.The Psychology of the Chinese People.Hong Kong,Oxford University Press,1996:143-181
    [245]李乃和,刘静.上海和新加坡现代商业社会中“关系”比较研究[J].关系管理研究,2006:3:1-24
    [246]Zhang,Y.,Zhang Z.,Guanxi and Organizational Dynamics in China:a Link Between Individual and Organizational Levels[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2006,67:375-392
    [247]Lauden,L.Progress and its Problem:Toward a Theory of Scientific Growth[M].New Dehli,Ambika Publications,1992
    [248]黄国光.探索中华文化的深层结构[M].黄国光,胡先缙著,黄国光编,中国人民大学出版社,2004:1-4
    [249]Swedberg,R.New Economic Socidogy..What Has Been Accomplished,What is Ahead?[J].Acta Sociologiea,1997,(40):161-182
    [250]Ruan D.Social Network in Urban China[D]Columbia University,1993.
    [251]Wiley,J.,Wilkinson,I.,Young,L.Toward Developing Measures of Business Relationships,http://impgroup.org/uploads/papers/4204.pdf
    [252]Tichy,Noel M.,Tushman,Michael L.,Fombrun,C.Social Network Analysis for Organizations[J].The Academy of Management Review,1979,4(4):507-519
    [253]肖鸿.试析当代社会网研究的若干进展[J].社会学研究,1999,3:2-5
    [254]罗家德.社会网分析讲义[M].社会科学文献出版社,2005:1-24
    [255]郭景萍.情感是如何制度化的[J].社会科学,2006,4:143-149

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700