基于博弈论的我国稀土出口政策研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
我国具有稀土比较优势。但由于我国稀土行业发展尚不成熟,产业政策尚不完善,导致稀土出口过度,资源加速耗竭,我国稀土资源大国地位岌岌可危。
     本研究以国际贸易理论、产业安全理论、可持续发展理论和博弈论为理论基础构建我国稀土出口贸易政策理论框架,并运用完全信息动态博弈模型展开我国稀土出口贸易各方利益博弈分析,探讨我国稀土出口到美、日、欧盟三方的分配方案,并据此设计我国稀土出口贸易政策,为促进我国稀土产业安全和资源的可持续发展提供理论指导和决策参考。具体创新性研究成果如下:
     第一,构建了我国稀土出口贸易政策理论框架。本文探讨了国际贸易理论、产业安全理论、可持续发展理论和博弈论与我国稀土出口贸易政策之间的内在关系,构建了我国稀土出口贸易政策理论框架,为我国稀土出口贸易博弈分析和政策制定提供理论依据。
     第二,构建了我国稀土出口贸易博弈模型。在深入剖析我国和全球稀土供需现状、梳理我国稀土产业政策的基础上,以我国稀土出口贸易政策理论框架为指导,综合考虑稀土供需关系、我国与各国的国际关系、各国国际地位和WTO规则四个影响因素,设定我国出口到美、欧盟、日的稀土份额为4:5:1或3:6:1,构建了我国与美、日和欧盟之间的贸易博弈矩阵。在此基础上,运用博弈论中的讨价还价模型和轮流出价的讨价还价模型,就稀土贸易中的经济利益,展开动态博弈分析。根据博弈结果,设计了我国稀土出口量分配方案,为我国稀土出口政策方案的设计提供了参考。
     第三,设计了我国稀土出口贸易政策。根据博弈分析,得出我国稀土出口量分配方案为①我国出口稀土到美、欧盟、日本的份额依次是40.2%,38.9%和6%;出口到世界其他国家的稀土份额占15%。②我国每年稀土出口量和国内消费量的配比为4:6。由此设计了我国稀土出口贸易政策方案,有助于进一步完善现行稀土出口政策。
China’s rare earths (REs) have the comparative advantage of mineral resources.However, China’s RE industry and its policies have been still immature and deficientuntil now, which accelerates the exhaustion of RE resources and even threatens thedominant position of China’s RE resources.
     This paper plays the benefits game between China and its RE export tradepartners using a dynamic game model of incomplete information, based on thetheoretical frame of China’s RE export trade policies including international tradetheory, industry security theory, sustainable development theory as well as gametheory. After a series of gaming activities between Sino-US, China and Japan as wellas China and EU, an allocation scheme for China to export REs to those countries isdesigned. The study results of this paper provide the theoretical guidance anddecision-making reference for promoting China’s RE industry security and REsustainable development. Then the innovative study achievements are acquired asfollows.
     (1) Building the theoretical frame of China’s RE export trade policies. Thetheoretical frame of China’s RE export trade policies is built in this paper afteranalyzing the relationships between the theories (i.e. international trade theory,industry security theory, sustainable development theory as well as game theory) andChina’s RE export trade policies, which provides a theoretical basis for China’s REexport game study and policy-making.
     (2) Building China’s RE export trade game model. Based on the analysis of thecurrent RE supply-demand situations in China and the world and China’s RE industrypolicies, in view of the influences from supply-demand relationship, internationalrelationship between China and trade partners, partners’ international status and WTOrules, three game matrixes of RE trade between Sino-US, China and EU as well asChina and Japan are built with the set RE export shares which successive are4:5:1or3:6:1. Furthermore, using Bargain Model and Alternating Offers Model of gametheory, a game-playing is conducted to analyze the economic benefits of each country in China’s RE trade. According to the results of game-playing, an allocation schemefor China to export REs to to those partners (US, Japan and EU) is designed, whichprovides the reference for designing China’s RE export policies.
     (3) Designing China’s RE export trade policies. With the game-playing, anallocation scheme for China to export REs to those countries (US, Japan and EU) isgotten that the radio for China to export RE to US, EU and Japan successively are40.2%,38.9%and6%. The radio to export RE to other countries is15%. And everyyear, China’s exports to internal consumptions ratio is4to6. Based on this scheme,China’s RE export trade policies are designed, which promotes the current exportpolicies’ improvement.
引文
Alexa I.V., Toma S.V. The correlation between game theory and internationaltrade. Economics and Applied Informatics,2012,(2):67~74
    Alonso E., Sherman A.M., Wallington T.J., et al. Evaluating rare earth elementavailability: a case with revolutionary demand from clean technologies. AmericanChemical Society,2012,(46):3406~3414
    Attanasi G., Garcia-Gallego A., Georgantzís N., et al. An experiment onprisoner’s dilemma with confirmed proposals. Organizational Behavior and HumanDecision Processes,2013,120(2):216~227
    Calster G.V. Case note China, minerals export, raw and rare earth materials:perfect storm for world trade organization dispute settlement. RECIEL,2013,22(1):117~122
    Carpenter R. The bottom of the smart weapon production chain: securing thesupply of rare earth elements for the U.S. military. Public Contract Law Journal,2012,41(2):411~433
    Copeland A.H. Book review: theory of games and economic behavior by Johnvon Neumann and Oskar Morgenstern, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc.1945,51(07):498~504
    Coppel E. Rare earth metals and U.S. national security. Washington DC:American Security Project (ASP),2011
    Dadwal S.R. The Sino-Japanese rare earths row: will China's loss be India's gain?Strategic Analysis,2011,35(2):181~185
    De Boer M.A., Lammertsma K. Scarcity of rare earth elements (in press).ChemSusChem,2013.
    Giacalone J.A. Can China's monopoly of the rare earth minerals market bebroken? Proceedings of ASBBS. Las Vegas: ASBBS Annual Conference,2012,19(1):385~393
    Goonan T.G. Rare earth elements-end use and recyclability. ScientificInvestigations Report2011–5094, Reston: U.S. Geological Survey,2011
    Grasso V.B. Rare earth elements in national defense: background, oversightissues, and options for congress. Washington DC: Congressional Research Service7-5700, R41744, September172013
    Gschneidner Jr.K.A. The rare earth crisis-the supply/demand situation for2010–2015. Material Matters,2011,6(2):32~41
    Hazardous Waste Consultant. EPA studies the potential and risks of rare earthelements. Technical Resources,2012,30(6):1.6~1.12
    He C.Y., Lei Y.L. Assessment of rare earth supply and demand relationships: aliterature review. Advanced Materials Research,2013(a),734-737:300~304
    He C.Y., Lei Y.L. Potential impact of U.S. re-emerging rare earths industry onfuture global supply and demand trend. International Business Research,2013(b),7(6):44~51
    Hedrick J.B. Rare earths in selected US defense applications.40th Forum on theGeology of Industrial Minerals, Bloomington, Indiana.2004,1.
    Humphries M. Rare earth elements: the global supply chain. Washington, DC:Congressional Research Service, R41347,2010
    Humphries M. Rare earth elements: the global supply chain. Washington, DC:Congressional Research Service, R41347,2012
    Hurst C. China’s rare earth elements industry: what can the west learn?Washington, DC: Institute for the Analysis of Global Security (IAGS), March2010
    IAMGOLD Corporation, Rare earth elements101. Canada: IAMGOLD, April2012
    Iro R. Price changes of Chinese rare earth products. First Baotou China Forumon Development of Rare Earth Industry, Baotou.2009
    Jebe R., Mayer D., Lee Y.S. China's export restrictions of raw materials and rareearths: a new balance between free trade and environmental protection? The GeorgeWashington International Law Review,2012,44(4):579~642
    Jepson N. A21st century scramble: South Africa, China and the rare earth metalsindustry. Matieland: Centre for Chinese Studies and SAIIA, March2012
    Keat P.G., Young P.K. Managerial economics economic tools for today’s decisionmakers (6th Edition). New Jersey: Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River,2008.426~427
    Keiner M. History, definition(s) and models of "sustainable development".Zürich: Eidgen ssische Technische Hochschule Zürich (ETH),2005
    Kerachian R., Fallahnia M., Bazargan-Lari M.R., et al. A fuzzy game theoreticapproach for groundwater resources management: application of Rubinsteinbargaining theory. Resources, Conservation and Recycling,2010,54(10):673~682
    Khadijeh R.E.S., Elias S.B. Rare earth elements distribution in marine sedimentsof Malaysia coasts. Rare Earth,2009,6(4):25~26
    Kingsnorth D.J. Rare earths: facing new challenges in the new decade. IMCOA(Industrial Minerals Company of Australia Pty Ltd) Presentation, Phoenix: SMEAnnual Meeting,2010
    Kingsnorth D.J. The global rare earths industry: a delicate balancing act. IMCOA(Industrial Minerals Company of Australia Pty Ltd) Presentation, Berlin,2012
    Levkowitz L. China’s rare earths industry and its role in the international market.U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission Staff Backgrounder,2010
    Limaei S.M. Mixed strategy game theory, application in forest industry. ForestPolicy and Economics,2010,12(7):527~531
    Lippai I., Heaney P. Efficient and equitable impact fees for urban water systems.Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management.2000,126(2),75~84
    Liu H.F., Lei L., Ye C.X. Study on rare earth management game between centraland local governments in China. Cross-Cultural Communication,2013,9(1),31~35
    Long K.R., Gosen B.S.V., Foley N.K., Cordier D. The principal rare earthelements deposits of the United States-a summary of domestic deposits and a globalperspective. Scientific Investigations Report2010–5220, Virginia: U.S. GeologicalSurvey,2010
    Long K.R. The future of rare earth elements: will these high-tech industryelements continue in short supply? Open-File Report2011–1189, Virginia: U.S.Geological Survey,2011
    Madani K. Game theory and water resources. Journal of Hydrology,2010,381(3):225~238
    Manind J.O., Jones E.T. Rare earth elements supply, trade and use dynamics.New York: Nova Science Pub Inc,2013.
    McLemore V.T. Rare earth elements for emerging technologies. New MexicoEarth Matters,2011,11(2):1~4
    Morrison W.M., Tang R. China’s rare earth industry and export regime:economic and trade implications for the United States. Congressional ResearchService7-5700, R42510, April302012
    Nicholson W. Microeconomic theory: basic principles and extensions7th edition.Fort Worth: The Dryden Press,1998.265~267
    Nieto A., Lannuzzi M. Supply-and-demand geoeconomic analysis of mineralresources of rare earth elements in the United States. Mining Engineering,2012,64(4):74~82
    Nowak A.S. A multigenerational dynamic game of resource extraction.Mathematical Social Sciences,2006,51(3):327~336
    Paul J., Campbell G. Investigating rare earth element mine development in EPAregion8and potential environmental impacts. EPA Document-908R11003, August152011
    Porter M.E. The competitive advantage of nations. Harvard: Harvard BusinessSchool Management Programs,1993
    POST. Rare earth metals. London: Houses of Parliament, No.368, January2011
    Ratnam G. U.S. defense department sees no rare-eEarths crisis; may aid U.S.producers. Bloomberg, October31,2010
    Roland Berger Strategy Consultants. The rare earth cchallenge: how companiesreact and what they expect for the future. Stuttgart, July2012.
    Scheffran J. The dynamic interaction between economy and ecology:cooperation, stability and sustainability for a dynamic-game model of resourceconflicts. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation,2000,53(4):371~380
    Schüler D., Buchert M., Liu R., et al. Study on rare earths and their recycling,Darmstadt: ko-Institut e.V., January2011
    Seaman J. Rare earths and clean energy: analyzing China's upper hand, rareearths and clean energy. Ifri Center for Asian Studies, September2010
    Shih J.S., Linn J., Brennan T.J., Darmstadter J., Macauley M.K., Preonas L. Thesupply chain and industrial organization of rare earth materials: implications for theU.S. wind energy sector. Resources for the Future, February2012
    Shiraishi P.A. The rare earths revolution: The dirty secret of green technologies.Spring: Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich,2010
    Szumigala D. Rare earth elements-a brief overview of these elements, includingtheir uses, worldwide resources and known occurrences in Alaska. Fairbanks: AlaskaDivision of Geological&Geophysical Surveys,2011
    Tanton T. Dig it! Rare earth and uranium mining potential in the States.Washington, DC: American Legislative Exchange Council,2012
    Tanton T. Rare earths mining potential in the United States. Policy Report No.348, Dallas: National Center for Policy Analysis, April2013
    Tietenberg T. Disclosure strategies for pollution control. Environmental andResource Economics,1998,11(3-4):587~602
    Ting M.H., Seaman J. Rare earths: future elements of conflict in Asia? AsianStudies Review,2013,37(2):234~252
    Tse P.K. China’s rare-earth industry. Open-File Report2011-1042, Virginia: U.S.Geological Survey,2011
    U.S. EPA Rare Earth Elements: A review of production, processing, recycling,and associated environmental issues, EPA-600-R-12-572,2012. Available at
    US Department of the Interior, US Geological Survey. Mineral CommoditySummaries2013. Available at
    Walker S. Breaking the rare-earth monopoly. Engineering and Mining Journal,2010,211(10):46~53
    Weber R.J., Reisman D.J. Rare earth elements: a review of production,processing, recycling, and associated environmental issues. U.S. EnvironmentalProtection Agency, May2012
    World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED). Our commonfuture, from one earth to one world. London: Oxford,1987. Available at
    Wray P. Rare-earths revisited: global jockeying intensifies in response toshortages and soaring prices. American Ceramic Society Bulletin,2011,90(6):30~33
    Wübbeke J. Rare earth elements in China: policies and narratives of reinventingan industry. Resources Policy,2013,38(3):384~394
    Yang X.J., Lin A., Li X.L., et al. China’s ion-adsorption rare earth resources,mining consequences and preservation (in press). Environmental Development,2013
    Zepf V. Rare earth elements: a new approach to the nexus of supply, demand anduse: exemplified alongthe use of neodymium in permanent magnets:[DoctoralThesis]. Augsburg: Augsburg University,2013
    安忠梅.包钢稀土高科核心竞争力测评和提升研究:[硕士学位论文].内蒙古:内蒙古科技大学,2011
    白小伟,王天乙,吴玉璟.基于演化博弈的中外稀土价格谈判研究.中国管理科学,2011,19(专辑):107~113
    白雪.稀土产业可持续发展评价研究——以包头稀土产业为例:[硕士学位论文].秦皇岛:燕山大学,2011
    北京大学中国持续发展研究中心,东京大学生产技术研究所.可持续发展:理论与实践.北京:中央编译出版社,1997
    毕吉耀,张一.就美欧日利用世贸组织对我稀土管制政策施压的应对策略与建议.中国经贸导刊,2012,(16):21~22
    柴阁庆.中国稀土资源出口问题分析:[硕士学位论文].吉林:吉林大学,2013
    常彤.包头市稀土产业发展战略研究:[硕士学位论文].天津:南开大学,2007
    陈果.稀土资源产业竞争力指标体系构建及动态评价:[博士学位论文].中国地质大学(北京),2012
    陈甲斌.我国稀土行业竞争力分析及其发展策略.国土资源,2003,(9):58~59
    陈甲斌.稀土资源出口问题分析及其优化构想.南方国土资源,2004,(8):20~21
    晨光.稀土:一场不见硝烟的战略博弈.生态经济,2010,(12):18~23
    程慧.论中国稀土资源出口管制的战略意义与合法性.中国经贸导刊,2011,(4):53~55
    程慧.我国优势战略矿产资源出口管制问题研究:[博士学位论文].北京:中国地质大学(北京),2012
    程潇黎.浅析我国稀土安全及安全战略:[硕士学位论文].北京:中国地质大学(北京),2006
    邓强.中国稀土资源合理开发利用的经济学分析——基于可持续发展的自然资源价值论的视角:[硕士学位论文].内蒙古:内蒙古财经学院,2010
    丁凯.国际贸易理论发展综述.经济纵横,2004,(9):57~60
    董瑾.国际贸易学.北京:机械工业出版社,2006.65,119,121
    董竞泽.稀土价格决定与最优开采路径研究:[硕士学位论文].内蒙古:内蒙古大学,2012
    杜凤莲,董竞泽.中国稀土产业政策及其对出口市场的影响.内蒙古大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2011,43(6):37~42
    段国蕊.我国出口“贫困化增长”分析.经济论坛,2007,(5):54~56
    冯瑞华,黄健,潘懿,马廷灿,万勇.浅析日本稀土战略.稀土信息,2010,(8):21~23
    郭茂林,贾志琦,刘翠玲,等.中国稀土产业现状及战略安全的几点建议.科技情报开发与经济,2009,19(32):95~98
    国家发展和改革委员会产业协调司.中国稀土——2008.稀土信息,2009,(4):4~8
    国家发展和改革委员会产业协调司.中国稀土——2009.稀土信息,2010,(3):4~8
    国家发展和改革委员会产业协调司.中国稀土——2010.稀土信息,2011,(3):4~8
    国家发展和改革委员会产业协调司.中国稀土——2011.稀土信息,2012,(4):4~8
    国家发展和改革委员会产业协调司.中国稀土——2012.稀土信息,2013,(4):4~7
    国家发展和改革委员会稀土办公室.2003年中国稀土年评.稀土信息,2004,(3):2~5
    国家发展和改革委员会稀土办公室.中国稀土——2004.稀土信息,2005,(3):4~7
    国家发展和改革委员会稀土办公室.中国稀土——2005.稀土信息,2006,(3):4~7
    国家发展和改革委员会稀土办公室.中国稀土——2006.稀土信息,2007,(3):4~8
    国家发展和改革委员会稀土办公室.中国稀土——2007.稀土信息,2008,(3):4~8
    哈尔·R·范里安(美).微观经济学:现代观点(第八版)(费方域,等译).上海:格致出版社,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,2011
    郝戊,安忠梅,李文龙.资源环境约束下资源型企业可持续发展的策略思考——以我国稀土企业为例.中国证券期货,2011,(4):115~116
    何静波.中国稀土出口贸易政策演变及政策影响研究:[硕士学位论文].内蒙古:内蒙古大学,2012
    何茂春.控制资源性产品出口的国际惯例.资本市场,2006,(4):20~21
    侯云先,林文,于英川.两国产业保护非合作博弈分析.上海大学学报(自然科学版),2002,8(5):467~470
    胡建州.美日欧诉中国稀土出口限制的博弈论分析.对外经贸,2013,(4):25~26
    黄继炜.我国稀土定价权的缺失与对策建议.改革与战略,2011,(12):37~38
    黄小柯,姚文治.整合铟业,谋话语权.中国金属通报,2010,(25):14~16
    姬明亮.完善稀土产品出口配额管理制度促进稀土产业发展.稀土信息,2004,(5):16~17
    贾怀东.把好稀土资源国门.中国外资,2008,(2):68~69
    江南.世界稀土产业格局的异变与中国的应对.经济论坛,2010,(11):162~164
    金通.稀土出口管制和最优出口配额设计.浙江社会科学,2011,(12):62~67
    李龙熙.对可持续发展理论的诠释与解析.行政与法(吉林省行政学院学报),2005,(1):3~7
    李孟刚.产业安全理论研究.北京:经济科学出版社,2006
    李孟刚.产业安全理论研究.管理现代化,2006,(3):49~52
    李珊.中国稀土出口贸易研究:[硕士学位论文].北京:中国地质大学(北京),2011
    李少琳,徐晋.中日东亚能源博弈分析.东岳论丛,2009,30(7):70~73
    李文龙.金融危机下内蒙古稀土产业可持续发展SWOT分析.中国商贸,2011,(6):221~222
    李旭霞.浅谈出口退税政策调整对我国稀土行业影响及对策.稀土信息,2004,(1):19~21
    李艳.我国国际稀土贸易定价权缺失博弈分析.赤峰学院学报:科学教育版,2011,3(5):71~72
    李勇.我国稀土产业发展研究:[硕士学位论文].南昌:江西财经大学,2012
    梁杰,周小苑.稀土行业:限制出口并不违背世贸规则.化工管理,2011,(7):19~20.
    梁咏. WTO框架下稀土纠纷可能引致之争端与解决.太平洋学报,2011,19(5):60~68
    廖建求,邓敏.稀土资源保护法律与政策的缺陷分析.国土资源科技管理,2013,30(1):121~127
    廖列法,毛克贞.我国稀土产业环境监管策略研究:国外环境监管政策的启示.有色金属科学与工程,2013,4(1):89~94
    廖作鸿,李晓昭,张黎丽.从博弈论看中国稀土价格战.科技和产业,2005,5(12):40~42
    林勃.耕地保护政策博弈分析.现代商贸工业,2009,21(20):50~51
    林佳.中国稀土对外政策与国际博弈.理论界,2013,(3):83~85
    刘刚.稀土企业生产计划模糊优化模型研究:[硕士学位论文].内蒙古:内蒙古科技大学,2009
    刘慧芳.我国稀土出口贸易中利益相关方博弈分析.财贸经济,2011,(9),85~91,136
    刘慧芳.中国稀土出口管制及其效果分析.中国商贸,2013,(2):137~139
    刘艳,饶振华.江西稀土产业竞争力分析.江西有色金属,2008,22(1):3~7
    马硕丽,卢虎生.稀土市场中多主体博弈的仿真研究——针对包头稀土企业进行的研究.产业与科技论坛,2011,10(2):41~42,58
    马硕丽.轻稀土市场中多主体博弈的仿真研究:[硕士学位论文].内蒙古:内蒙古科技大学,2011
    毛克贞,吴一丁.稀土出口价格与稀土储备.有色金属科学与工程,2012,3(5):82~88
    倪平鹏,蒙运兵,杨斌.我国稀土资源开采利用现状及保护性开发战略.宏观经济研究,2010(10):13~20
    欧阳化雪.中国稀土出口管制效应分析:[硕士学位论文].长沙:中南大学,2011
    邱巨峰.国外稀土产业现状与发展趋势.内蒙古:包头稀土研究院信息中心,2001
    全国稀土信息网.稀土应用现状与未来——国外稀土调研报告汇编.稀土信息,1999
    任福兵.中国稀土产业整合模式研究.内蒙古社会科学,2011,32(6):110~114
    任忠宝,余良晖.稀土资源储备刻不容缓.地球学报,2011,32(4):507~512
    商务部新闻办公室.第六届中欧工商峰会在比利时首都布鲁塞尔举行.中华人民共和国商务部,2010-10-8.
    尚宇.中国稀土产业国际竞争力研究:[博士学位论文].中国地质大学(北京),2011
    沈欣. GATT第20条下中国资源出口保障措施研究:[硕士学位论文].大连:东北财经大学,2011
    宋胜洲,郑春梅,高鹤文.产业经济学原理.北京:清华大学出版社,2012.130,277
    苏文清.中国稀土产业经济分析与政策研究.北京:中国财政经济出版社,2009.246,303
    苏文清.中国稀土产业竞争力评价和分析.稀土,2004,25(5):5~6
    孙海泳,李庆四.中美稀土贸易争议的原因及影响分析.现代国际关系,2011,(5):41~46
    万龙.中国工业环境问题成因分析——以稀土资源为例.致富时代,2010,4(6):22~25
    汪立新.稀土企业产品定价的博弈分析.内蒙古财经学院学报,2012,10(2):126~129
    王柄根.稀缺:巴菲特“经济护城河”的另一种诠释.股市动态分析,2010,(21):9~11
    王春笋.2011年中国稀土产品出口情况浅析.稀土信息,2012,(8):17~19
    王华民.中国稀土产业组织研究:[博士学位论文].北京:中国地质大学(北京),2012
    王俊峰,吴彩云.中国稀土深加工技术开发的经济博弈研究.中国经贸导刊,2012,(17):5~6
    王珺之.中国稀土保卫战.北京:中国经济出版社,2011
    王利清,洪梅.从出口税率变化看我国稀土出口结构调整.稀土,2012,33(2):92~97
    王武平.我国稀土产业环境分析及对策研究:[硕士学位论文].天津:天津大学,2005
    王志华.我国自然资源出口管制措施法律协调问题的思考.山东社会科学,2010,183(11):144~147
    魏龙,潘安(a).中国稀土资源供给水平及其可持续发展评价.改革,2012,(11):55~60
    魏龙,潘安(b).中国稀土资源可持续发展研究.软科学,2012,26(11):27~32
    乌日娜.浅析中国稀土行业发展.人口与经济,2012,(增刊):64~65
    吴竑.贸易自由化与环境保护博弈分析.黑龙江对外经贸,2009,(3):27~29
    吴建.国际贸易理论之简评.商业研究,2004,(7):12~14
    武正潇.浅议中国稀土资源出口配额制.能源技术与管理,2011,(3):121~122,139
    肖勇.稀土产业发展不对称现象探析.有色金属科学与工程,2012,3(5):89~95
    谢岚平,周频.中国稀土企业出口战略与发展措施及前景.中国水运(学术版),2007,(11):54~55
    谢识予.经济博弈论(第三版).上海:复旦大学出版社,2007.4,36-37,374
    欣然,文琪.对近期稀土热议的理性分析.稀土信息,2010,(12):13~17
    邢斐,何欢浪,金梦,等.下游国的贸易报复与中国稀土出口政策.世界经济,2012,(8):92~114
    徐栋.从“杯具”到“洗具”——稀土入世十年纵观入世十年.中国有色金属,2011,(13):32~33
    徐盛洋.出口稀土应以“稀”论价.稀土信息,2006,(3):25
    徐雅萍. WTO规则下稀土出口应对策略.中国有色金属,2013,(6):33~34
    严良,李伟,骆葶苈.西部矿产资源不合理开发的博弈分析.煤炭经济研究,2008,(1):51~53
    杨文兰.中国稀土出口管制纷争中的利益博弈.价格月刊,2012,(8):44~47
    姚钰.世界稀土市场综述.稀土,1994,15(4):71~73
    姚远生.中国稀土行业现状与经济学浅析.稀土信息,2005,(9):8~10
    尹翔硕,李春顶(a).国际贸易摩擦中的“南北不对称”问题解析.中央财经大学学报,2007,(1):60~65
    尹翔硕,李春顶(b).国际贸易摩擦南北不对称与摩擦的形成——基于一个三国贸易模型的分析.南开经济研究,2007,(5):53~66,90
    张古.世界稀土资源市场需求以及我国可持续发展对策:[硕士学位论文].大连:东北财经大学,2012
    张侃.中国稀土出口定价权问题研究:[硕士学位论文].大连:东北财经大学,2012
    张磊.我国稀土出口问题研究.商,2013,(10):193
    张平.世界稀土市场现状分析及我国的对策.国际贸易问题,2006,(10):39~43
    张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学.上海:上海人民出版社,2004.200
    张晓青,毛克贞.基于静态和动态纳什均衡的我国稀土出口价格分析.有色金属科学与工程,2012,3(4):91~93
    赵殿玉.中日之间能源战略的博弈.内蒙古煤炭经济,2008,(2):13~15
    赵文静,郭咏梅.稀土功能材料产业发展状况.2013第四届国际稀土峰会综述报告,2013.Available at
    赵耀华,蒲永健.博弈论与经济模型.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2010.126~131
    赵增祺.国外稀土发光材料产业状况及发展趋势.稀土信息,2010,(10):10~13
    中国周刊.中国控制稀土出口引发美日两国利益博弈.稀土信息,2009,(11):18~19
    中华人民共和国国务院新闻办公室.中国的稀土状况与政策.北京:人民出版社,2012
    周晓唯,孙赟.稀土资源出口保护度分析.华东经济管理,2010,24(7):54~58
    周晔,王万山.我国大宗商品出口需求价格弹性与最优出口关税——以稀土为例.国际经贸探索,2012,28(3):26~34,98
    朱震葆.博弈论与经济学的新发展.江苏统计,1998,(1):14~16
    庄惠明,黄建忠.国际贸易理论的演化:维度、路径与逻辑.国际贸易问题,2008(11):123~128

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700