中国开发林木生物质能源与其产业发展研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文是以我国开发林木生物质能源及其未来产业发展为研究对象。首先,本文介绍我国开发林木生物质能源的背景:通过对世界能源发展趋势的分析和对林木生物质能源的介绍,提出未来能源发展成多元化态势,新兴能源逐渐取代化石能源,包括林木生物质能源在内的生物质能源是解决未来我国乃至世界能源问题重要手段之一,并且本文还简要分析了林木生物质能源的产业价值链。
     其次,本文指出我国发展林木生物质能源最根本的两条原因:国内能源供需状况和环境污染状况。国内能源供需状况方面,利用计量经济学模型和微分方程的方法对我国能源供需现状和长短期预测进行量化分析,提出导致我国能源短缺的根本因素,分析开发林木生物质能源对解决能源短缺问题的作用。在讨论我国环境污染状况时,结合化石能源消费和环境污染的关系,利用环境库兹涅茨理论和计量经济模型对我国未来环境污染的趋势进行预测,分析开发林木生物质能源与改善环境污染之间的关系。
     再次,本文探求影响我国林木生物质能源产业发展过程的主要因素:政策因素、资源因素、市场因素、技术与设备因素。政策因素方面,在分析我国现阶段能源政策和未来能源政策走向的基础上,提出新兴能源政策的形成机制,并以林木生物质发电为例设计强制性政策的框架,以及各阶段强制性政策的变化。资源因素方面,在介绍我国现阶段林木生物质资源的现状和发展潜力基础上,分析随着该产业的发展资源供给方式的变化,提出以能源林基地培育为主的资源供给方式,并从宏观的角度上划分我国林木生物质能源培育和开发利用的优先区域等级。市场因素方面分为能源两级市场,一次能源市场以木质煤为例,利用时间序列模型分析我国煤炭市场的供需,结合资源因素方面的结论,划分木质煤发展市场等级;并对优先发展区域展开实地的调研,由调研的实际情况来分析木质煤产品的潜在市场需求。二次能源市场方面,利用时间序列模型预测我国电力市场的供需,结合资源因素方面的结论,划分林木生物质发电发展区域等级;此外,本文还提出了对能源产品成本核算的修正,并在此基础上分析林木生物质发电在产业发展各阶段的竞争力变化情况。技术与设备因素方面,以原材料预处理过程与生产过程为主线,以林木生物质发电为例分析技术和设备因素对产品成本的影响。
     最后,本文分析林木生物质能源产业发展的现状,指出现阶段该产业发展的外部环境和影响因素作用差异。结合案例分析,讨论现阶段林木生物质能源产品的市场竞争力,运用风险模糊评价理论,指出案例的整体风险和各风险因素,提出风险规避措施。此外,基于林木生物质能源产品现阶段市场竞争力不强的结论,建立静态博弈模型和多目标规划模型,得出在约束条件下,政府在多目标规划基础上政策扶持产业发展的补贴额度。
The research in the thesis focuses on the utilization of forestry bio-energy and the development of its industry in China. The thesis firstly talks about the background of forestry bio-energy utilization by analysising the trend of energy development in the world and introducing forestry bio-energy. In this part, the thesis holds that the traditional energy must be gradually replaced by new energy and the new energy is one of the most important approaches to solve the energy problem both in China and the world and discusses briefly the value chain of forestry bio-energy industry.
     Secondly, the thesis points out the most significant reasons to develop the foresty bio-energy industry: energy supply and demand and the enviroment pollution in China. The thesis describes the contradiction between the energy supply and demand, makes a forecast in Chinese energy by econometrics model and calculus equation and analysis the factors that lead to the deficiency in energy in China and the relation between forestry bio-energy and Chinese energy problem. The thesis also makes a forecast in Chinese environment pollution by Kuznetz theory and econometrics model and discusses the relationship between forestry bio-energy and environment pollution in China.
     Thirdly, the thesis looks for the main factors that influence the forestry bio-energy development: policy, resource, market and technology. In the policy factor, the thesis makes a discussion in the mechanism of energy policy and takes the forestry bio-energy generation as an example to design the outline of compulsory policy and its differences in every phrase based on the energy policy and its trend. In the resource factor, based on the quantity of the forestry resource and its potential in future, the thesis analysis the change in the mode of resource supply, puts forward that the principle resource supply will be from the energy forest and finds out the regions that have the priority to develop the forestry bio-energy industry. In the market factor, the energy market is divided into two parts. The thesis makes an example in woody coal and forecast the coal supply and demand in China by time series model. Furthermore, the thesis takes a rate in the development of woody coal market and analysis the potential demand in woody coal according to the results in observed regions. In the secondary energy market, the other part of the energy market, the thesis forecasts the power supply and demand in future and also takes a rate in the development of forestry bio-energy generation in Chinese regions. Moreover, the thesis holds the view that the current cost calculation system should be adjusted and analysis the variance in the competence of forestry bio-energy generation in different phrases. In the technology factor, the thesis discusses the cost influence by the technology and facility in accordance with the course of the material pre-treatment and production.
     Last but not the least, the research in this part focuses on the present development of the forestry bio-energy industry. With some cases in forestry bio-energy industry, the thesis makes a research on the competence of forestry bio-energy products and evaluates the whole case risk and many risk factors by the theory of risk fuzz evaluation and take some suggestions in the measurements that can reduce the whole risk rate. Additionally, since the forestry bio-energy products have no enough competence in energy market in the present phrase. The thesis erects the stationary game model and multi-target optimal model to quantitative the incentive policy in the constrict conditions
引文
[1]曹金珍,张璧光,赵广杰.小质生物质在能源方面的开发和利用[J].华北电力大学学报,2003,30,(5):102-104,108.
    [2]陈金链.未来的燃料——生物质能[J].能源工程,2000,(2):19-20.
    [3]陈喜龙,谭跃辉,王义强,严永林.我国生物质颗粒燃料推广应用中存在的问题与发展对策[J].可再生能源,2005,(1):41-43.
    [4]戴林,李景明.中国生物质能转换技术发展与评价[M].中国环境科学出版社,1998.
    [5]邓可蕴,贺亮.我国农村地区中长期能源需求预测[J],中国工程科学,2000,(7):16-21.
    [6]邓可蕴等编著.中国农村能源综合建设理论与实践[M].中国环境科学出版社,2001.
    [7]丁启朔,白金明.生物质能利用技术的开发研究[J].太阳能,1999,(3):12-13.
    [8]窦金亮,王怡,蔡琪,赵四化.市场条件下中国绿色电力发展策略研究[J].电力建设,2005,(4):57-59
    [9]范维唐.能源现状与发展趋势[J].山西能源与节能,2004,34,(3):1-3,7.
    [10]方运霆,莫江明,肖金香.关于木材能源使用的一些新认识[J].江西农业大学学报,2003,25,(4):619-622.
    [11]冯飞.中国资源问题的现状、问题和出路[J].中国发展观察,2005,(7):46-48
    [12]冯飞.中国能源市场化改革的重大问题.中国农村水电及电气化信息网,2004-03-04.
    [13]顾树华,刘文强.市场经济体制下的农村户用能源消费问题研究[J].农村源,1997,(1):3-6.
    [14]顾树华,张希良,王革华编著.能源利用与农业可持续发展[M].北京出版社,2001.4.
    [15]顾树华,王白羽.中国可再生能源配额制政策的初步研究[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,(18):27-33.
    [16]高辉清等.中国能源发展战略报告[R].中国能源,2004,(5):83-130.
    [17]国家林业局.中国林业统计年鉴2003 2004[M].北京,中国林业出版社.
    [18]国家统计局工业交通司,国家发改委能源局.中国能源统计年鉴2000-2005[M].北京,中国统计出版社.
    [19]国家发改委宏观经济研究院能源研究所课题组.中国可持续发展的能源战略[J].宏观经济研究,2003(11):35-37.
    [20]国家电力公司.2003中国电力市场分析与研究[M].北京:中国电力出版社,2003.
    [21]甘应爱,田丰.运筹学[M]:北京,清华大学出版社,1998.
    [22]韩宝瑞,沈宗麟,秦万丰.生物质炭的开发与应用[J].吉林林学院学报,1998,14,(4):236-237
    [23]胡建忠.沙棘作为农村能源植物开发的可行性分析[J].国际沙棘研究与开发,2004,(4):36-43.
    [24]黄雷,张彩虹.浅谈我国农村能源问题[J].可持续发展研究,2005(12):63-66
    [25]黄雷,张彩虹.能源产业发展区域布局分析[J].林业经济问题,2006(11):1-3
    [26]黄雷,张彩虹.浅谈环境成本与林木生物质发电[J].电力需求侧管理,2007(1):33-35
    [27]黄雷,张彩虹.绿色能源产品市场竞争力分析[J].林业经济问题,2007(4):60-63
    [28]姜书,宋维明,李怒云.关于林木生物质能源产业化问题的思考[J].林业经济,2007,(1):16-17,22.
    [29]蒋剑春,刘石彩,戴伟娣,陶渊博,刘汉超,徐建华,潘嘉亮,沈卫,姜伟忠.林业剩余物制造颗粒成型燃料技术研究[J].林产化学与工业,1999,19,(3):25-30.
    [30]李炳焕.生物质能源的开发利用与前景[J].唐山师范学院学报,2002,24,(2):36-38.
    [31]李改莲,王远红,杨继涛,李继红,黄浩,张凯.中国生物质能的利用状况及展望[J].河南农业大学学报,2004,38,(1):100-104.
    [32]李俊峰,王仲颖,梁志鹏,时景丽.我国未来可再生能源开发利用的战略思考[J].中国能源,2004,26,(3):4-10.
    [33]李俊峰,时丽.国内外可再生能源政策综述与进一步促进中国可再生能源发展的建议[J].可再生能源,2006,(1):1-6.
    [34]李瑞阳.21世纪的重要能源——生物质能[J].世界科学,1999,(1):16-17,
    [35]李志合,易维明.生物质能源利用及发展[J].山东工程学院学报,2004,14(4):34-38.
    [36]李美华,俞国胜.生物质燃料成型技术研究现状[J].木材加工机械,2005(2):36-40.
    [37]林伯强.结构变化、效率改进与能源需求预测[J].经济研究,2003,(5):57-65.
    [38]林伯强.电力短缺、短期措施与长期战略[J].经济研究,2004,(3):28-35.
    [39]刘红.我国的能源现状及发展[J].商场现代化,2004,(11):21.
    [40]刘圣勇,陈开碇,张百良.国内外生物质成型燃料及燃烧设备研究与开发现状[J].可再生能源,2002(2):14.
    [41]刘守,李海潮,张世润.木质生物能源利用技术研究[J].中国林产,2001,58,(3):37-39.
    [42]刘勇.欧洲三国生物质能利用考察行[J].可再生能源,2003,110,(4):53-54.
    [43]刘音,张升堂,苏少林.二十一世纪的绿色生物能源.杨凌技术学院学报,2002,1(2):36-38
    [44]吕文,王春峰,王国胜,俞国生,张彩虹,张大红,刘金亮.中国林木生物质能源发展潜力研究(1)[J].中国能源,2005.27,(11):21-26.
    [45]吕文,王春峰,王国胜等.中国林木生物质能源发展潜力研究报告[J].中国林业产业,2006(1):6-11.
    [46]吕文,俞国胜,袁湘月,李涛.初探开发林木生物质成型燃料的潜力[J].中国林业产业,2006,(10):31-32
    [47]刘吉发.产业政策学[M],北京:经济管理出版社2004:130-138
    [48]倪守强,李兴华.我国能源现状及可持续利用对策[J].工业安全与保.2004,30,(7):1-3.
    [49]倪建民.国家能源安全报告[M].北京:人民出版社,2005.
    [50]潘效仁.加强农村能源建设,改善农业生态环境[J].甘肃农业,1997,(11):27-29.
    [51]任东明,张宝秀等.可再生能源发电配额制政策(RPS)研究[J]。中国人口、资源与环境,2002(2):30-36
    [52]乔淑滨.生物质能的利用及生物质型煤[J].应用能源技术,2003,81,(3):1-3.
    [53]邱凌,甘雪峰.生物质能利用现状与固化技术应用前景[J].山东能源,1990(2):9.
    [54]宋洪远等编著.中国农村经济分析和对策研究[M],北京:中国农业出版社,2001.12:114-136.
    [55]王国胜,吕文,刘金亮,等.中国林木生物质资源培育与发展潜力研究报告[J].中国林业产业,2006,(1):12-21.
    [56]王效华,高树铭,中国农村能源可持续发展:现状、挑战与对策[J].中国沼气,2003(4):41-43.
    [57]王效华.中国农村家庭能源消费现状与发展[J].南京农业大学学报,1994(3):134-141.
    [58]王仲英世界可再生能源发展的大趋势[J].中国能源,2003(6):25-28
    [59]王景丽,李俊峰.英国可再生能源义务法令介绍及实施效果分析[J].中国能源,2004,(11):20-23
    [60]王景丽,李俊峰可再生能源发展的制度保证[J].建设科技,2005,(12):82-84
    [61]王慧炯,甘师俊等.可持续发展与经济结构[M].北京:科学出版社,1999:275-300
    [62]吴创之,马隆龙主编.生物质能现代化利用技术[M].北京:化学工业出社,2003.5:80-90
    [63]徐华清等.中国能源环境发展报告2006[M].中国环境科学出版社,2006.8:4-6.
    [64]许静,俞国胜,肖江.生物质燃料的加工及其应用[J].中国林业,2004,(1):32-33.
    [65]谢治国,胡化凯,张逢.建国以来我国可再生能源政策的发展[J].中国软科学,2005,(9):53-36
    [66]闫丽珍,闵庆文,成升魁.中国农村生活能源利用与生物质能开发[J].资源科学,2005,(1):8-13.
    [67]杨克美,何小东,唐伟.生物质能在农村能源中的地位与薪炭林建设[J].安徽农业科学,2001,(1):103-105.
    [68]杨克美,张均.从农村用能结构的变化看薪炭林假设如何发展[J].农村能源,1997(1):30-31.
    [69]杨艳华,汪征辉,王全等.生活能源消费结构对荒漠化的影响——以喀什地区为例[J].林业经济问题,2003,23,(4):195-199.
    [70]杨纪珂,尹春涛.绿色电力来自用户的选择如何促进可再生能源的发展[J].21世纪论坛—绿色与环保会议论文,2003
    [71]姚向君,田宜水.生物质能资源清洁转化利用技术[M].化学工业出版社,北京,2005.1:10-12.
    [72]俞国胜,袁湘月等.中国林木生物质能源开发利用技术设备研究[J].中国林产工业,2006,(1):22-34.
    [73]于渤.中国煤炭替代的经济分析.中国能源,2000,22(3):
    [74]袁振宏,吴创之,马隆龙,等编著.生物质能利用原理与技术[M].北京,化学工业出版社,2005.3:3,11,149-165.
    [75]尹春涛.绿色电力营销:可再生能源发展的市场动力[J].中国能源,2004,(1):10-15.
    [76]翟秀静,刘奎仁,韩庆编著.新能源技术[M].北京,化学工业出版社,2005.9.
    [77]张彩虹,张大红,黄雷等.林小生物质能源的经济分析和可行性研究报告[J].中国林业产业,2006,(1):22-34.
    [78]张彩虹.林业投资新方向:中国林木生物质生物能源产业发展[J].北京林业大学学报(社会科学版),2006,(12):24-28.
    [79]张无敌,宋洪川,韦小岿,等.21世纪生物质能前景广阔.中国能源,2001,(5):35-39
    [80]赵纪新,孟祥华.我国的能源结构与能源构成战略探讨[J].发展论坛,2005,(6).104-107
    [81]郑戈,杨世关,孔书轩等.生物质压缩成型技术的发展与分析[J].河南农业大学学报,1998,4,(12):349-354.
    [82]中国农村能源年鉴编辑委员会.中国农村能源年鉴1998-1999[M].中国农业出版社,1999.11:107-109
    [83]中国农业年鉴编辑委员会.中国农业年鉴2004[M].北京,中国农业出版社,2004.12:30-32
    [84]中华人民共和国国家统计局.中国统计年鉴2005[M].北京,中国统计出版社,2005.9.
    [85]中国农业部\美国能源部项目专家组.开发生物质能对中国的重要意义[R].2004年中国生物质能技术研讨会,2005.
    [86]中国可再生能源信息网http://www.biodiesel.net/
    [87]中国生物能源网http://www.bioenergy.cn/
    [88]中国节能发展网.中国可再生能源的成就与发展http://www.newenergy.org.cn/html/2006-8/200688_11362.html.
    [89]中国国家电力咨询网.他山之石——国外发展绿电经验.http://www.spis.com.cn/pub/gd/gjjldt/t20041028_0769.htm
    [90]中国新能源网.世界可再生能源发展的大趋势.http://www.newenergy.org.en/html/2006-8/200688_11365_2.html.
    [91]中国可再生能源发展战略与政策研究[R].国家发改委能源研究所可再生能源发展中心、清华大学核研院技经能源所,2004.
    [92]中国电力改革与可持续发展战略研究[R].国务院发展研究中心产业经济研究部,2003.
    [93]周凤起.中国可再生能源发展战略[J]石油化工技术经济,2005,(4):16-18
    [94]赵媛,郝丽莎世界能源政策框架及形成机制[J]资源科学,2004,(6):11-15
    [95]朱信凯,涂圣伟.国际生物技术产业政策评论及对我国的启示[J].中国软科学,2005,(11):18-23.
    [96]郑勇奇.国际木质能源发展现状与趋势[J].国家林业局西部地区木质能源研讨会论文集,2000
    [97]周公乐.发展生物质能源——林业在行动.绿色中国,2006(1):34-37
    [98]詹姆斯·D·汉密尔顿.时间序列分析[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,1999.
    [99]BAI Hua.The EU renewable energy flying-off movement[J]Outlook on the World Science,Technology and Economy,1999,(9):48-50.
    [100]Bard JF,Falk J E.An explicit solution to thematic-level programming problem[J].Computer,1992,9(10):77-00.
    [101] Bernhard Truffer, Jochen Markard, Rolf WuK stenhagen. Eco-labeling of electricity strategies and tradeoffs in the definition of environmental standards[J]. Energy Policy, 2001, 29(11):885-897.
    [102] Bird, L. Sweaey. Green Electric power Marketing in the United States: A Status Report [J]. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2003(36): 456-469.
    [103] Catherine Mitchell, Peter Connor. Renewable energy policy in the UK1990-2003[J]. Energy Policy,2004,32 (19):1 935-1 947.
    [104] CHANG Da. A comprehensive view on offing wind electric power in 11 European countries[J]. Solar Energy, 2002, (6):31-32.
    [105] CHENHe-ping. The new development measures for renewable energy in 4 EU countries[J]. Planning andMarketing,2001, (7):28-29.
    [106] CHENHe-ping, LI Jing-jing, ZHOUHuang.The world implementing experience on Renewable Portfolio Standard policies[J]. Energy ofChina, 2000, (7):3-6.
    [107] DanyelReiche, Mischa Bechberger. Policy Difference in the Promotion of Renewable Energies in the EU Member States[J]. Energy Policy, 2004, (32): 843-849.
    [108] Fredric C. Mena. Green Electricity Policies in the United State: Case Study [J].Energy Policy, 2005, 33: 2398-2410.
    [109] Graham A. Davis, Brandon Owens. Optimizing the level of renewable electric R&D expenditures: using real options analysis[J]. EnergyPolicy, 2003, 31 (15):1589-1608.
    [110] Garc(?)a-Cebri(?)n, Lucia Isabel. The influence of subsidies on the production process:the case of wind energy in Spain [J]. TheElectricityJournal,2002,15(4):79-86.
    [111] KminoryM . Perfect equilibrium in a trade liberalization game[J]. The American Economics Review, 1999, 80: 480-491.
    [112] Kostantions D Patlitzianas, Argyris GKagiannas, John Psarras. Renewable energy current status, future development and challenges in EU[J]. EnergyEngineering,2003, (5): 29-32.
    [113] KUAI Ming. Renewable energy policies in several foreign countries and the revelation to our country[J]. Energy ofChina, 2000, (6):15-17.
    [114] LAI Fu-rong. American wholesale competition and new energy promoting policies[J]. North China Electric Electric power, 1999, (8):28,31.
    [115] LIANG Zhi-peng. Review of development mechanism, legislation and policies of international windelectric power[J]. Energy ofChina, 2002, (10):33-36.
    [116] LIU Lian-yu. Investigation and deliberations on renewable portfolio standard[J]. Electric Electric power ofChina, 2002, 35(9):74-77.
    [117] LIU Hong-peng. New energy and renewable energy in German and Italy[J]. Energy of China, 1995, (11):42-44.
    [118] LONG Zhe-qiang. Law on renewable energy and wind electric power development in Germany[J]. SolarEnergy, 2001, (3):5-6.
    [119] Lawrence J Hill and Stanton W Hadley. Federal tax effects on the financial attractiveness of renewable versus conventional electric power plants[J]. Energy Policy, 1995,23(7):593-597.
    [120] Lori Bird, Rolf Wustenhagen, Jorn Aabakken. Green Electric power Marketing Abroad:Recent Trends and Experience [J].National Renewable Laboratory, 2002(31):237-296.
    [121] Mitchell,C. The renewable NFFO.A review[J].EnergyPolicy, 1995,23(12):1077-1091.
    [122] Muriel Watt, Hugh Outhred. Australian and international renewable energy policy initiatives[J]. Renewable Energy, 2001, (22):241-243
    [123] Michael, Kate. Harvey S. Rosen Multilayer model composed of programming[J].Microeconomics3rd Copy right by the McGraw-Hill Companies 1998, 10.
    [124] National Development and Planning Commision. The White Paper for China Sustainable Development in Energy Field and the Forest Action Contributed to Reducing the Emission of Greenhouse Gases[M].Beijing: China Planning Press, 1998. 86-87.
    [125] Niels I. Meyer, Anne Louise Koefoed. Danish energy reform: policy implications for renewables[J]. Energy Policy, 2003,31(7):597-607.
    [126] Okko van Aardenne. Policy for bio-energy in Netherlands [J]. World Environment,2001, (2):25-26.
    [127] P. E. Morthorst. A green certificate market combinedwith a liberalized electric power market[J]. Energy Policy, 2003, 31 (13):393-402.
    [128] REN Dong-ming, ZHANG Bao-xiu, Zhang Jin-qiu. The research on renewable portfolio standard(RPS) policies[J]. China Population · Resource and Environment, 2002, 12(2):117-120.
    [129] REN Long, LI Guan-bin, CHENG Xiao-bo. European sustainable energy policies and the revelation to our country[J]. Energy ofChina, 2003, (4):4-7.
    [130] SaschaN. M. Van Rooijen, MarkT.VanWees. Green Electricity Policies in the Netherlands: an Analysis of Policy Decisions [J]. Energy Policy 2006(34): 60-71.
    [131] SHENG Si. Attaching importance to renewable energy R&D in Denmark [J]. Overlook of the World Science, Technology and Economy,1994,(2):7-8.
    [132] SUNHai-yan. Lawmaking for assuring renewable energy[J]. Construction Science and Technology, 2004, (10):70-71.
    [133] Simone Espey. Renewables portfolio standards means for trade with electricity from renewable energy sources? [J]. EnergyPolicy, 2001, 29 (7):557-566.
    
    [134] V. V. N. Kishore, Preety M, Bhandari, Pratul Gupta. Biomass energy technologies for rural infrastructure and village electric power—opportunities and challenges in the context of global climate change concerns[J]. Energy Policy, 32(2004): 801-810.
    
    [135] Y. G. Pan, V. Enrique, P. Luis. Pyrolysis of blends of biomass with poor coals[J]. Fuel,1996, 75(4):412-418.
    [136] Willebrand E, Ledin S, Verwijst T. Willow coppice systems in short rotation forestry.Biomass and Bioenergy, 1993, (4):323-331.
    
    [137] Willebrand E, Verwijst T, Population dynamics of willow coppice systems and their implications for management of short rotation forest. The Forestry Chronicle,1993,69:699-704.
    [138] Wu C Z, Huang S P. An economic analysis of biomass gasification and electric power generation in china [J]. Bioresource technology, 2002, 83:65-70.
    [137] WANG Qing-yi. Renewable energy current status, prospect and policy[J]. Electric Electric power of China, 2002, 56(1):71-73.
    
    [138] WANG Zhong-ying. The discussion on the mechanism of renewable energy development in China with the British experience for referenced)[J]. Energy of China,2000, (2):15-20.
    [139] WU Zhong-hua. The policy measures on extending new energy in Japan[J]. Outlook on the World Science, Technology and Economy, 2000, (3):22.
    
    [140] WU Li-bin, WANG Xin-tai. Survey on technology management and development of renewable energy in the United Kingdom[J]. Engineering Science of China, 2001, 3(6): 89-92.
    
    [141] XING Xiao-jun, SHI Zu-lin, SU Ming-shan. Renewable energy policies in electricity industry reform-experience from USA[J]. China Population · Resource and Environment, 2002, 12(6):147-149.
    [142] YAN Hui-min. Deliberations on renewable portfolio standard[J]. Energy Research and Utilization, 2003, (5):3-6.
    [143] ZHANG Zheng-min, LI Jing-jing, LI Jun-feng. American renewable energy policies[J]. Energy of China, 1999, (6):9-13.
    
    [144] ZHANG Jie-qing. Application of mandate market share policy in promotion of renewable energy [J]. Environment Protection,2003, (5):6-11.
    
    [145] ZHOU Guang-ming. Looking at American renewable energy development[J]. Energy Engineering, 2000, (3):16-19

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700