多视角的银行关闭策略研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
对问题银行的关闭作为监管者防范金融危机而采取的市场退出监管的重要组成部分,有助于银行形成一种审慎经营的动力。通过制定和实施恰当的银行关闭策略可以减少安全网的负效应和社会福利的损失,提高整个银行和金融体系的稳定和效率。法律法规、社会文化、经济效率和市场纪律都会直接或间接地影响监管者的银行关闭策略。
     本文从特许权价值、银行信息披露行为、委托-代理问题和系统性风险四个视角研究了监管者的银行关闭策略:(1)特许权价值的存在可以在一定程度上促使银行减少风险承担和增加资本水平。在社会福利最大化的目标下,对于具有较大特许权价值的问题银行,监管者应采取较为宽容的关闭策略。(2)在银行不披露有关其经营状况真实信息的情况下,监管者可以通过设计审计策略来监督银行。虽然监管者事后最优的关闭策略取决于银行的经营成果,但是从事前的角度看,监管者必须权衡银行操纵信息对社会福利造成的损失和其对银行进行审计的成本,并根据总的福利影响选择相应的关闭策略。(3)银行内部股东-经理间委托-代理关系会影响银行最终表现出来的行为,通过恰当的银行关闭策略和对银行经理管理租金的干预,监管者可以限制股东对经理承担过度风险的激励,从而减少社会福利的损失。另一方面,监管者是由具体的理性经济人构成的,可能会出于自身声誉等考虑拖延对问题银行的关闭,故还应加强对具体监管人员的激励和约束,使其做出较为公正的关闭决策。(4)系统风险下的银行关闭策略不同于仅考虑单个代表银行下的关闭策略。从传染性系统风险看,监管者的银行关闭策略应在关闭与宽容、救助间进行权衡。合理的审计放松,可以在一定程度上起到事前威慑和事后稳定的作用。在银行体系遭受宏观经济打击的情况下,监管者应采取一种弹性的关闭策略。
     我国现有银行关闭中存在着政府干预过多等问题,在银行关闭策略的设计和实施上存在着由产权制度缺陷等带来的难点问题。因此,现阶段我国监管者可以对国有商业银行采取一种有透明度的监管宽容策略。对中小商业银行则可以采取事前承诺较严格的关闭标准,而在事后根据具体情况适当放宽标准的策略。此外,还应从深化金融体制改革等方面建立提高我国银行关闭效率的保障措施。
The closure of problem bank as the important constituent of the regulator's positive market withdrawal supervising which adopts for the guard of finance crisis, is incentive for the bank under the information asymmetrical environment to form the prudential operation. The appropriate closure strategy may reduce the negative effect that the safety net brings, reduce the social welfare losses, and enhance the stable and efficiency of the entire bank industry and the financial system. The legal laws and regulations, the social culture, the economic efficiency and the market discipline may directly or indirectly affects the strategy of the bank closure.From the view of the franchise value, the bank information disclosure behavior, the principal-agent problem, and the systematic risk, this article systematically and thoroughly study the closure strategy of the problem bank: (1) The franchise value may cause the bank to reduce the risk which it undertakes and increase its capital level. Therefore under the social welfare maximization goal, the franchise value is bigger; the bank closure strategy should be looser. (2) Under the situation of the bank's manipulation of the real information, the regulator could design the audit strategy. The ex-ante closure strategy may not consistency with ex-post closure strategy. Because the ex-ante optimal strategy is depending on the social welfare, the ex-post optimal strategy is decided by the bank's operation achievement. (3) The regulator should consider the principal-agent problem in and out of the bank. The bank closure strategy should consider the intervention of the bank manager's managerial rents to limit the incentive, which the shareholder drives to the manager to undertake excessively the risk. On the other hand, the regulator is constituted by the concrete rational economic men, who may delay the problem bank closure from their own prestige, therefore it should give them some incentive and restrain in order to cause them make fair closure decision. (4) The bank closure strategy under the banking system risk is different from the condition under the consideration of an individually representative bank. Looking from the infectious system risk, the bank closure strategy should trade-off between closure and forbearance or rescue. Under the situation, which the bank system was suffered by a macro-economical attack, the regulator should adopt an elastic closure strategy.There are many problem in our country's existing bank closure, such as government intervenes too much etc, and also many difficult question in our bank closure strategy such as the property right system flaw etc. At present, it should carry on transparency forbearance to the state-owned commercial bank. To the middle and small commercial bank, it may adopt a strict closure policy from an ex-ante standpoint and may relax it ex-post. It should deepen finance organizational reform etc. in order to enhance the efficiency of our country's bank closure strategy.
引文
[1] Hoggarth, Glenn, Reis, Ricardo and Victoria Saporta, Costs of Banking System Instability: some empirical evidence, Working Paper, Bank of England
    [2] Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, Supervisory Guidance on Dealing with Weak Banks—Report of the Task Force on Dealing with Weak Banks, March 2002
    [3] 巴曙松,当前全球金融监管的演变趋势和主要特征,中国货币市场,2003年12月(总第26期)
    [4] Fama, E., Banking in the theory of finance. Journal of Monetary Economics 6(1), 1980: 39-57
    [5] Bemanke, Benjamin, and Mark Gertler, Financial fragility and economic performance. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1990(105): 87-114
    [6] Greenwald, Bruce, and Joseph E. Stiglitz. Asymmetric information and the new theory of the firm. American Economic Review 1990(80): 160-165
    [7] Diamond, Douglas, Phil Dybvig. Bank runs, deposit insurance, and liquidity. Journal of Political Economy 1983(91): 401-419
    [8] Bhattacharya S. and Thakor A., contemporary banking theory. Journal of Financial Intermediation 1993(3): 2-50
    [9] Fischer E. O., heinkel R., Zechner J. Dynamic capital structure choice: theory and tests, Journal of Finance 1989(44): 19-40
    [10] Hart O., Firms, Contracts, and Financial Structure. Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK 1996
    [11] Dewatripont M. and Tirole J. The prudential regulation of banks. MIT Press, Cambridge USA 1994
    [12] Barth J. R., Bartholomew P.F., & Labich C., Moral hazard and the thrift crisis: an analysis of 1988 resolutions, Proceedings of a Conference on bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, 1989: 344-384
    [13] Ellis M.D.& Flannery M.J. Does the debt market assess large bank's risk? Journal of Monetary Economics, 1992(30): 481-502
    [14] Flannery M.J. & Sorescu S.M. Evidence of bank market discipline in subordinated debenture yields. Journal of Finance 1996(51): 1347-1377
    [15] Keeley, M.C. and Furlong F.T. A reexamination of mean-variance analysis of bank capital regulation. Journal of Banking and Finance 1990(14): 69-84
    [16] Saunders A., Strock E., & Travlos N.G. Ownership structure, deregulation and bank risk-taking. Journal of Finance 1990 45(2): 643-654
    [17] Hellmann T., Murdoch K., Stiglitz J. Liberalization, moral hazard in banking and prudential regulation: are capital requirements enough? American Economic Review 2000(90): 147-165
    [18] Keeley M.C. Deposit insurance, risk, and market power in banking. American Economic Review, 1990 80(5): 1183-1200
    [19] Marcu, A.J. deregulation and bank financial policy. Journal of Banking and Finance, 1984(8): 557-565
    [20] Demsetz R., Saidenberg M., Strahan P., Banks with something to lose: the disciplinary role of the franchise value. Fedreal reserve bank New York Quart. Rev. 1996(2): 1-14
    [21] Suarez J. Closure rules, marker power and risk-taking in a dynamic model of bank behavior. LSE Financial Market Group discussion paper 1994 No. 196
    [22] Blum J. Do capital adequacy requirements reduce risks in banking. Journal of Banking and Finance 1999(23):755-771
    [23] Acharya S. Charter value, minimum bank capital requirement and deposit insurance pricing in equilibrium. Journal of banking and finance 1996(20)2:351-375
    [24] Herrings R. and Vankudre P. Growth opportunities and risk-taking by financial intermediaries. Journal of Finance 1987(42):583-599
    [25] Merton R.C., An analytic derivation of the cost of deposit insurance and loan guarantees: an application of modern option pricing theory, Journal of Banking and Finance,1977(1):3-11,
    [26] Merton R.C., On the cost of deposit insurance when there are surveillance costs. J.Bus, 1978(51): 139-452
    [27] Fries S., Mella-barral P. Perraudin W. Optimal bank reorganization and the fair pricing of deposit guarantees. Journal of Banking and Finance 1997(21):441-468
    [28] Kane E.J. Appearance and reality in deposit insurance reform: the case for reform, Journal of Banking and Finance,1986(19(3-4)):175-188
    [29] Acharya S. and J.F. Dreyfus Optimal bank reorganization policies and the pricing of federal deposit insurance , Journal of Finance 1989(44): 1313-1333
    [30] Mailath G and L. Mester A positive analysis of bank closure. Journal of Financial Intermediation 1994(3):272-299
    [31] Allen L. and A. Saunders Forbearance and valuation of deposit insurance as a callable put, Journal of Banking and Finance 1993(17):629-643
    [32] Dreyfus J.F., A Saunders and L. Allen Deposit insurance and regulatory forbearance: Are caps on insured deposits optimal? Journal of Money Credit and Banking 1994(26):412-438
    [33] Davies S.M. and D.A.McManus The effects of closure policies on bank risk-taking. Journal of Banking and Finance 1991(15):917-938
    [34] Levonian M. E. What happens if banks are closed early? Manuscript, Research Department, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco 1991
    [35] Koehn M. and A. M. Santomero Regulations of bank capital and portfolio risk. Journal of Finance 1980(35): 1235-1244
    [36] Kim D. and A. M. Santomero, Risk in banking and capital regulation. Journal of Finance 1988(43):1219-1233
    [37] Leland H. Risk debt, bond covenants and optimal capital structure. Journal of Finance 1994(49): 1213-1252
    [38] Bhattacharya S. Plank M.,Strobl G, Zechner J. Bank capital regulation with random audits. Journal of Economic Dynamic Control. 2002(26):1301-1321
    [39] Goodhart C. and Huang H. Amodel of lender of last resort. IMF working paper 1999 No.9:9-39
    [40] Freixas X. Optimal bailout, conditionality and constructive ambiguity . LSE Financial Market Group Discussion paper 1999 No.237
    [41] Povel P. Optimal soft or tough bankruptcy procedures. LSE financial market group discussion paper 1996 No.240
    [42] Aghion P.,Bolton P., Fries S., Optimal design of bank bailouts:the case of transition economics. Journal of Inst. Theoretical Econ.l999(155):51-70
    [43] Boot A. and Thakor A. Self-interested bank regulator. Amer. Econ. Rev. AEA Papers and Proceeding 1993(83):206-212
    [44] Avery, R,B., Hanweck, G.A.,Kwast M.L., An analysis of risk-based deposit insurance for commercial banks. Bank Structure and Competition, 1985:217-250
    [45]Barth, J.R., Brumbaugh, R., Sauerhaft, D., Wang, H.K. Thrift institution failures: causes and
     policy issues. Bank structure and competition. Conference Proceedings, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. 1985
    [46] Sinkey, J.F., A multivariate statistical analysis of the characteristics of problem banks. Journal of Finance. 1975(30): 21-36
    [47] Tomson J.B., Predicting bank failures in the 1980s. Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland. 1991(27): 9-20
    [48] James, K., dennis G., Hwan S., Michele C. Prediting large US commercial bank failures. Journal of Economics & Business. 2002(54): 361-387
    [49] Dar-Yeh-Hwang, Cheng F. Lee and K. Thomas Liaw, Forecasting bank failures and deposit insurance premium, International Review of Economics and Finance 1997(6): 317-334
    [50] Benston G. and G. Kaufman FDICIA After five years: a review and evaluation Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, working paper series 1997(WP97-1)
    [51] Madura, J., Bartunek, K., Valuation effects of the FDIC Improvement Act. Applied Financial Economics 1995(5): 191-198
    [52] Liang, Y., Mohanty, S., Song, E, The effect of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Improvement Act(FDICIA) of 1991 on bank stocks. Journal of Financial Research 1996(19): 229-242
    [53] Aharony, J., Swary, I., contagion effects of bank failures: Evidence from the capital markets. Journal of Business 1983(58),: 305-322
    [54] Aharony, J., Swary, I., Additional evidence on the information-based contagion effects of bank failures. Journal of Banking and Finance 1996(20): 57-69
    [55] Pettway, R., The effects of large bank failures upon investors' risk cognizance in the commercial banking industry. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 1976(11): 465-477
    [56] Lamy, R. E. and Thompson, G.R., Penn square, problem loans, and insolvency risk. Journal of Financial Research 1986(9): 103-111
    [57] Swary, I. Stock market reaction to regulatory action in the continental Illinois crisis. Journal of Business 1986(59): 451-473
    [58] Cornell, B., Shapiro, A., The reaction of bank stock prices to the international debt crisis. Journal of banking and finance 1986(10): 55-73
    [59] Bruner, R., Simms, J., The international debt crisis and bank security returns in 1982.Journal of money, banking and credit 1987(19): 46-55
    [60] Gay, G. D., Timme, S.G., Yung, K., Bank failure and contagion effects: evidence from Hong Kong. Journal of Financial Research 1991(14): 153-165
    [61] Docking, D.S., Hirschey, M., Jones, E., Information and contagion effects of bank loan-loss reserve announcements. Journal of Financial Economics.1997(43): 219-239
    [62] 杜朝运,中国首例银行关闭案探析,统计与决策,1998年11期:25-26
    [63] 蔡臻欣、谢洁,海南发展银行的关闭及其警示,中国城市金融,1999年1期:24-26
    [64] 刘伟林,从广信破产看我国金融机构市场退出,金融研究,1999年第8期:67-71
    [65] 河南金融管理干部学院课题组,金融机构市场退出问题研究,河南金融管理干部学院学报,1999第3期:40-45
    [66] 袁德法、欧蔚岚,美国存款保险体系对银行关闭的处理,中国金融,2000年第8期:57-58
    [67] 左英利,金融机构市场退出:方式的比较和改进,国际经济合作,2003年第4期,53-55
    [68] 杨德勇,稳定与效率:中国金融业市场退出研究,当代经济科学,2004年5月26卷,第3期:33-38
    [69] 安启雷、陈超,金融机构市场退出机制的国际比较与我国的制度选择,金融研究,2003 年第10期:98-107
    [70] 周小川,保持金融稳定,防范道德风险,金融研究,2004年第4期:1-7
    [71] 乔炳亚,论我国中央银行对金融机构的市场退出监管,金融研究,1997年第11期:38-40
    [72] 郑琰,论核心原则与我国有效金融监管制度,中外法学,1999年第3期:44-50
    [73] 吴斌,金融机构市场退出法律机制的比较研究,财经科学,2003/1总 196:37-41
    [74] 张静、张乐,金融机构市场退出的若干问题及立法完善,金融论坛,2004年第10期:51-56
    [75] 阙方平,有问题银行处置制度安排研究,第1版,北京:中国金融出版社,2003
    [76] 马中华、赵荣才,成本最小化与成本分担:中小金融机构市场退出的难点与方式选择,金融研究,2001年第8期:101-109
    [77] 陈凤荣,关于金融机构市场退出的研究,城市金融论坛,1997年第11期:16-18
    [78] 施春华、樊朝晖,金融机构市场退出的若干问题研究,经济师,2002年第7期:40-41
    [79] 郭保民,金融机构市场退出工作的难点及对策,中国金融,2004年第9期:24-25
    [80] 颜亚玢,我国金融机构市场退出问题对策研究,金融与经济,2003年第5期:38-40
    [81] 闫维杰,金融机构市场退出的关键是解决债务问题,金融研究,2003年第1期:66-73
    [82] 陈岩峰,存款保险制度的效应分析及我国的理性选择,商业研究,2005/03,总第311期:58-61
    [83] 崔金平,我国建立存款保险制度的效应分析和现实选择,济南金融,2004第6期
    [84] 弓劲梅,论存款保险中的道德风险,南开经济研究,2001年第4期:49-55
    [85] 陈国华,商业银行道德风险监管杂谈,河南金融管理干部学院学报,2003年第6期:116-117
    [86] 付强等,基于风险的存款保险定价能解决道德风险吗,西南民族大学学报·人文社科版,2004年3月:99-101
    [87] 潘颖、韩冰、凌桦,存款保险与道德风险,中国金融,2003年第5期:23-24
    [88] 傅桃生,存款保险制度与道德风险,财贸经济,2002年第5期,48-51
    [89] 叶炜、王瑛,浅析存款保险制度中的道德风险,广东经济管理学院学报,2005年2月,第20卷第1期:51-54
    [90] 戴晓凤、尹伯成,论存款保险制度与银行的道德风险,世界经济,2001年11期:45-48
    [91] 慕刘伟、曾志耕、张勤,金融监管中的道德风险问题,金融研究,2001年第11期:121-124
    [92] 陈志英,银行危机过程中的道德风险及其对银行危机成本的影响,当代经济科学,2002年5月第24卷第3期:66-70,95
    [93] 王勰,存款保险制度的信息经济学分析,科技创业月刊,2005年第1期:41-42
    [94] 贺瑛,存款保险定价银行重组模型研究,上海金融学院学报,2004年第3期:3-11,34
    [95] 王爱民、王金桃、徐丽群,激励相容:我国安全网改进的新思路,上海金融,2004年第12期:18-21
    [96] 陈正勇,激励相容:我国银行监管的现实选择,济南金融,第4期:29-31
    [97] 王燕、沈雅琴,激励相容的金融机构退出机制,上海金融,2005年第1期:24-26
    [98] 巴曙松、陈华良,金融机构的政府救助对监管声誉的影响,证券市场导报,2005年3月号:8-13
    [99] 胡斌,次级债券与市场约束——《新巴塞尔资本协议》与银行经营,金融会计,2002年第1期:13-15
    [100] 王颖捷,陷入困境银行的退出壁垒和我国相关问题研究,金融论坛,2003年第2期:45-49
    [101] 科斯,《社会成本问题》,第1版,上海:上海三联书店1991
    [102] 科斯,《财产权利和制度变迁》,第1版,上海:上海三联书店1991
    [103] 吴思华,《策略九说》,第1版,上海:复旦大学出版社2002
    [104] 扬德慧,《策略思维》,第1版,北京:北京大学出版社,2005
    [105] Dybvig P H, Chester S. Spatt Adoption Externalities as Public Goods. Journal of Public Economics, 1984(20): 231-247.
    [106] Dermine J, Lajeri F. Credit Risk and the Deposit Insurance Premium, a Note. Journal of Economics and Business, 2001, 53(5): 497-508.
    [107] Cooper R, Ross T W., Bank Runs: Liquidity and Incentives[EB/OL] http: //www.nber.org/papers/w3921, 1991.
    [108] Cooper R, Ross T W. Bank Runs: Deposit Insurance and Capital Requirements. Economic Review, 1998(43): 55-72.
    [109] Knopf J D, Teall J L. Risk-taking Behavior in the US Thrift Industry: Ownership Structure and Regulatory Changes. Journal of Banking and Finance, 1996(20): 1329-1350.
    [110] Wilson B, Kane E. Evidence of Safety Net Support During Economic Development in Canada, the U.K., and the U.S: A Progress Report[EB/OL] .http: //econ.worldbank.org/programs/finance/topic/depinsurance/library/doc?id=16157, 2000.
    [111] Dowd K., Models of Banking Instability: A Partial Review of the Literature. Journal of Economic Surveys. 1992(2): 107-132.
    [112] Dziobek, C. and C. Pazarbasioglu "Lessons From Systemic Bank Restructuring: A Survey of 24 Countries." IMF Working Paper 161, International Monetary Fund, Washington, D. C. 1997
    [113] Nakajima, Z., and H. Taguchi, Toward a more stable financial framework: Long-term alternatives. Bank of Japan, Institute of Monetary and Economic Studies, Tokyo. 1993
    [114] John Hawkins, "Bank restructuring in South-East Asia", Bank for International Settlements, 1999
    [115] Goldstein, M and Turner (1996): "Banking crises in emerging economies: origins and policy options". BIS Economic papers, No. 46 October.
    [116] Jones, D.S. and Kathleen K.K., The implementation of Prompt Corrective Action. In Credit Markets in Transition, Federal Reserve bank of Chicago, May, 1992: 98-100
    [117] Jones, D.S. and Kathleen K.K., The implementation of Prompt Corrective Action: An assessment. Journal of Banking and Finance, 1995(19): 491-510
    [118] Ryan, T, United Stated, Hausman & Rojas-Suarez 1996
    [119] Benston, G.J., and R. Eisenbeis, P. Horvitz, E. Kane and G. Kaufman, Perspectives on safe and sound banking: Past, present, and future 1986 MIT Press, Cambridge.
    [120] Kane, E.J., No room for weak links in the chain of deposit-insurance reform. Journal of Financial Services Research 1987(1): 77-111
    [121] Kane, E.J., Changing incentives facing financial services regulators, Journal of Financial Services Research 1989(3): 265-274
    [122] Baer, H.L., What we know about the deposit insurance problem, Chicago Fed Letter, 1990, July
    [123] Nagarajan S., C.W. Sealey, Forbearance, deposit insurance pricing, and incentive compatible bank regulation. Journal of Banking and Finance, 1995(19): 1109-1130
    [124] Hendershott R., Forbearance, financial stability, and the social cost of deposit insurance, working paper 1992
    [125] Berger, Allen N., Market Discipline in Banking, Proceedings of a conference on bank structure and competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, 1991
    [126] Lane, T.D., Market discipline, IMF Staff Papers, 1993(40), March: 53-88
    [127] Basel Committee, The New Basel Capital Accord. Consultative Document, 2003
    [128] Llewellyn D.T., Comment in Prompt Corrective Action: Ten Years Later, G.G.Kanfman, ed.Amsterdam: JAI, 2002a: 321-333
    [129] Kane, E. J., A six-point program for deposit insurance reform, Housing Finance Review, 1983(4): 269-278
    [130] Maclachlan, F. C., Market discipline in bank regulation, Independent Review, 2001(6): 227-235
    [131] Thomson, E., Using market incentives to reform bank regulation and Federal Deposit Insurance. Economic Review (Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland)1990(26): 28-32
    [132] Berger, A. N., King, K. K., J.M. O'Brien, the limitations of market value accounting and a more realistic alternative, Journal of Banking and Finance 1991(15): 753-784
    [133] Carey M., Partial market value accounting, bank capital volatility, and bank risk, Journal of Banking and Finance 1995(19): 607-622
    [134] Buser, S., A. Chen and E.Kane, Federal deposit insurance, regulatory policy and optimal bank capital. Journal of Finance 1981 (36): 51-60
    [135] Marcus, A.J. Deregulation and bank financial policy. Journal of Banking and Finance 1984(8): 557-565.
    [136] Gary Gorton and Andrew Winton, Bank capital regulation in general equilibrium, NBER Working Paper 1995: 5244
    [137] 阎龙光,银行隐性资本的监管效应,国际金融研究,2004(2):26-31
    [138] 梁缤尹,论银行自律及其实现,中南大学学报(社会科学版)2005(6):378-384
    [139] Greenbaum, S.I., G.Kanatas, and I.Venezia, Equilibrium loan under the bank-client relationship. Journal of Banking and Finance 1989(13): 221-235
    [140] Sharpe, S.A. Asymmetric information, bank lending and implicit contracts: a stulised model of customer relationship. Journal of Finance 1990(55): 1069-1087
    [141] A.S. Cebenoyan, E.S.Cooperman, C.A.Register, Ownership structure, charter value, and risking-taking behaviror for thrifts, Financial Management 1999(28), No. 1 Spring
    [142] Merton R, On the pricing of corporate debt: the risk structure of interest rates, Journal of Finance 1974(29): 449-470
    [143] Ronn, E and A. Verma, Pricing risk-adjusted deposit insurance: an option=based model. Journal of Finance 1986(41): 871-895
    [144] Marshall D. and S. Venkataraman, Bank capital standards for Market risk: a welfare analysis, European Review 1999(2): 125-157
    [145] Hellman T., K. Murdock and J. Stiglitz, Liberalization, moral hazard in banking, and prudential regulation: are capital requirements enough? American Economic Review 2000: 147-165
    [146] 丁碧慧,吴寿山,吴钦杉,稽查成本之边际效益、固定存款保险费率与银行重组策略之拟订,国家科学委员会研究专刊:人文社会科学,2000(9):282-297
    [147] 谢康,乌家培,阿尔克洛夫,史宾斯和斯蒂格利茨论文精选[C].北京:商务出版社.2002.
    [148] Flannery, M, Using market information in prudential bank supervision: a review of the U.S. empirical evidence, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 1998(30):273-305
    [149] Evanoff D., and Wall L., Subordinated debt and prompt corrective regulatory action. Federal Reserve Bank of Working Paper 2002-18
    [150] Calomiris, C., Building an incentive-compatible safety net. Journal of Banking and Finance 1999(23):1499-1519
    [151] Davies S.M. and D.A.McManus The effects of closure policies on bank risk-taking. Journal of Banking and Finance 1991(15):917-938
    [152] Mailath G. and L. Mester A positive analysis of bank closure. Journal of Financial Intermediation 1994(3):272-299
    [153] Noe T. H., Rebello, M.J., and Wall, L. D. Managerial rents and regulatory intervention in troubled banks, Journal of Banking and Finance 1996(20):331-350
    [154] Suarez. J. Risk taking and the prudential regulation of banks, European Economic Review 1998(36): 1137-1178
    [155] Hellman T.E, Murdock C, Stiglitz J. E. Liberalization, moral hazard in banking, and prudential regulation. American Economic Review, 2000, March,90(1).
    [156] Aleix C. Closure policy when bank inspection can be manipulated. European Finance Review. 2003(7):385-408
    [157] Gorton, G. and R. Rosen, Overcapacity and exit from banking, Paper presented at a Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Chicago,IL
    [158] Kumar, R. and G. Morgan, Bank regulatory triage: optimal closure rules and an economic explanation for forbearance, Working paper, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University Blacksberg, VA. 1992
    [159] Kaufman George, Comment on systemic risk, Research in Financial Services:Banking,Financial Markets, and Systemic Risk. 1995(7):47-52
    [160] Bank for International Settlements,64th Annual Report,Basel,Switzerland 1994
    [161] Bartholomew, Philip and Gary Whalen, Fundamentals of Systemic Risk Research in Financial Services: Banking, Financial Markets, and Systemic Risk 1995(7): 3-18
    [162] Gorton, Gary, Clearinghouses and the origin of Central Banking in the United States, Journal of Economic History, 1985 XLV(2):277-283
    [163] Gorton, G. and D. Mullineaux The joint production of confidence: endogenous regulation and nineteenth century commercial-bank clearinghouses, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 1987(19):457-467
    [164] Corbett, J. "Crisis? What crisis? The policy response to Japan's banking crisis?" in Why did Japan Stumble? Causes and Cures, ed. By C. Freedman 1999:191-229. Edward Elgar, Cheltertham
    [165] Kelichiro Kobayashi, Yunmi Saita, Toshitaka Sekine, Forbearance lending: a case for Japanese firms. Bank of Japan, Working Paper 2002-02-2
    [166] Dewatripon,, Mathias and Tirole, Jean. The prudential regulation of banks, MIT Press 1994
    [167] 秦凤鸣,现代金融危机与银行体系脆弱性,山东大学学报,哲学社会科学版,2004年第6期:92-98
    [168] Radelet, S., and J. Sachs, The onset of the East Asian Financial Crisisi NBER Working Paper 1998,
    [169] Radelet, S., and J. Sachs, What have we learned, so far, from the Asian Financial Crisis? NBER Working Paper 1999
    [170] Staub, M., Swiss regional bank crisis. Schweizerische Zeirschrift fur Volkswirtschaft und Statistik,1998(134):654-683.
    [171] Hellwig M., Systemic aspects of risk management in banking and finance. Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics. 1995,131(4/2):723-737
    [172] Hellwig. M., Banks, markets, and the allocation of risks in an economy. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics. 1998,154(1):328-345
    [173] Kenneth Kasa, Mark M. Spiegel, The Role of Relative Performance in Bank Closure Decisions.Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, working paper, March, 1999
    [174]李宗怡、冀勇鹏,我中是否应该建立显性存款保险制度 http://www.ehongyuan.com/ 2003-08-05
    [ 175] Sheng, A., Bank Restructu ring: Lessons from the 1980s. World Bank, W ash ington D. C.. (1996)
    [176] Acharya, V., A theory of systemic risk and design of prudential bank regulation . Paper for conference on "Banks and systemic risk", held at the Bank of England ,2001 May:23-15
    [ 177] Jean-Paul D., Jean-Charles R., and Benoit R., The three pillars of Basel Ⅱ: optimizing the mix. Journal of Financial Intermediation 2004(13): 132-155
    [178]Tito Cordelia and Eduardo Levy Yeyati, Bank bailouts: moral hazard vs. value effect. Journal of Financial Intermediation 2003(12):300-330
    [179]Michael Andrews and Mats Josefsson, What happens after supervisory intervention? Considering bank closure options. IMF working paper wp/03/17
    [180]Aigbe Akhigbe, Jeff Madura, Why do contagion effects vary among bank failures? Journal of Banking and Finance. 2001(25):657-680
    [181]Nakamura, Leonard I. Closing troubled financial institutions: What are the issues? Business Review. May/Jun 1990:15-25
    [182]Raj Aggarwal, Kevin T. Jacques, The impact of FDICIA and prompt corrective action on bank capital and risk: Estimates using a simultaneous equations model. Journal of Banking and finance 2001(25): 1139-1160
    [183]Aigbe Akhigbe, Ann Marie Whyte, The impact of FDICIA on bank returns and risk: Evidence from the capital marets. Journal of Banking and Finance. 2001(25):393-417
    [184]David S. Jones, Kathleen Kuester King. The implementation of prompt corrective action: an assessment. Journal of Banking and Finance. 1995(19):491 -510
    [185]David G Mayes. Who pays for bank insolvency in transition and emerging economies? Journal of Banking and Finance. 2005(29):161-181
    [186]James R. Barth, Gerard Caprio Jr. and Ross Levine, Bank regulation and supervision:what works best? Journal of Financial Intermediation.2004(13):205-248
    [187] Sudipto Bhattacharya, Arnoud W. A. Boot, Anjan V. Thakor. The Economics of Bank regulation. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 1998(30):745-770
    [188]Nobuyuki Oda and Tokiko Shimizu, Prospects for prudential policy: toward achieving an efficient and stable banking system. Monetary and Economics Studies. May 2000:119-136
    [189]George G Kaufman and Denneth E. Scott. What is systemic risk, and do bank regulators retard or contribute to it? The Independent Review, Winter 2003:371-391
    [190]Sumon C. Mazumdar, Regulatory monitoring, closure costs and bank moral hazard behavior. Journal of Regulatory Economics. 1997(12):267-289 Levonian, M.E., Have large banks become risker? Recent evidence from option markets. Federal Research Bank of San Francisco Economic Review. Fall 1991:3-17
    [191]Arturo Estrella, Bank capital and risk: is voluntary disclosure enough? Federal Reserve Bank of New York, working paper December,2003:l-27
    [192] Peek J., Rosengren, E.S., The use of capital ratios to trigger intervention in problem banks: too little, too late. New England Economic Review, Sep/Oct 1996:49-59
    [193] Linda Allen and Anoop Rai, Bank charter values and capital levels: an international comparison. Journal of Economics and Business 1996(48):269-284
    [194] Rebecca S. Demsetz, Marc R. Saidenberg, and Philip E. Strahan, Banks with something to lose: the disciplinary role of franchise value. FRBNY Economic Policy Review, October 1996:1-14
    [195] Alan D. Morrison, Banking licences, bailouts and regulator ability. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, September 2004(51) No.4:559-579
    [196] S. Nagarajan, C.W. Sealey, State-contingent regulatory mechanisms and fairly priced deposit insurance. Journal of Banking and Finance. 1998(22): 1139-1156
    [197] 萨拉·科诺里,阿里斯泰尔·曼洛,公共部门经济学,第1版,北京:中国财政经济出版社,2003
    [198] 张维迎,《博弈论与信息经济学》,第1版,上海:上海人民出版社,1996
    [199] 谢识予.《经济博弈论》第2版,上海:复旦大学出版社,2001
    [200] 樊勇明,杜莉,公共经济学,第1版,上海:复旦大学出版社,2002
    [201] 赵霜茁主编,现代金融监管,第1版,北京:对外经济贸易大学出版社,2004
    [202] 曼昆,经济学原理,第3版,北京:机械工业出版社,2005
    [203] 因内思·马可—斯达德勒,大卫·佩雷斯—卡斯特里罗,信息经济学引论:激励与合约,第1版,上海:上海财经大学出版社,2004
    [204] 田国强,激励、信息与经济机制,第1版,北京:北京大学出版社,2000
    [205] 许长新、宋敏,风险投资中资本与技术的博弈,财经研究,2003年第11期:56-60
    [206] 许长新、谢问兰,经济数量分析,第1版,南京:南京大学出版社,1994
    [207] 许长新、方阳娥,债转股的博弈分析,国际金融研究,2001年第2期:43-48
    [208] 尚静、许长新,银行最优资本结构分析,价值工程,2004年第9期:100-102
    [209] 尚静,银行资本监管绩效研究,河海大学博士论文,2004年11月
    [210] 华坚,银行安全网效率探析,浙江金融,2005年第4期:32-33
    [211] 华坚、许长新,问题银行关闭的经济学思考,求索,2005年第5期:20-21
    [212] 华坚,银行系统性风险转嫁行为对问题银行关闭策略的影响,浙江金融,2005年第11期

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700