摘要
随着科学技术的发展和世界范围产品的小型化、精密化,微细加工技术正备受世界各国研究学者的关注。微细电火花加工技术以其较高的加工效率、较好的加工质量、可以加工微细、高硬度、复杂形状的三维零件等优势,在微细加工领域占有越来越重要的地位。
零件的表面形貌提供了很多重要的表面信息,对零件的摩擦、润滑特性有重要影响。然而,微细电火花加工表面形貌的评定问题,学者们一直采用切削加工表面形貌的评定参数和评定方法,这制约了微细电火花加工技术的进一步发展。基于此,本文针对微细电火花加工技术的特点及其加工工件表面形貌的特点,进行了微细电火花加工表面粗糙度评定的研究。
首先,分析了微细电火花加工表面粗糙度对零件使用性能的影响,针对影响其表面粗糙度使用性能的无数的微小凹坑和凸起的高低、陡峭程度和间距状态等特征,提出了描述微细电火花加工表面粗糙度评定参数,并给出相应参数的数值计算方法。
接着,针对微细电火花加工表面形貌的特点和小波分析具有的良好时域、频域局部化性质,能够观察分析信号的任意细节的优点,确定微细电火花加工表面粗糙度评定基准使用小波评定基准,并对常用的小波函数的优缺点及特性进行了分析比较,选择微细电火花加工表面粗糙度评定小波评定基准的小波函数为Daubechies小波。
然后,研究了基于小波分析方法的微细电火花加工二维和三维表面粗糙度提取的可行性,并建立了小波分析方法提取其二维和三维表面粗糙度数学模型,同时使用Daubechies 4小波和Daubechies8小波对微细电火花加工表面粗糙度的小波评定基准算法进行了仿真实验,仿真结果表明:对于不同组的采样数据,使用不同的小波函数都可以提取微细电火花加工表面粗糙度,而且对于同一组采样数据,使用相同的小波函数,分组数目不同不影响小波分解次数的确定,使用不同的小波函数,也不影响小波分解次数的确定。
最后,对本文提出的微细电火花加工表面粗糙度评定参数,使用基于小波分析方法的微细电火花加工三维表面粗糙度提取算法,对四个工件表面形貌数据进行了仿真实验,得到了它们的表面粗糙度参数值,而且这些参数值能够一致地反映出某个工件整体的使用性能好坏;用高斯滤波评定基准对该四组数据进行了表面粗糙度的提取和表面粗糙度参数评定的对比实验,结果表明:小波方法得到的表面粗糙度参数值与高斯滤波得到的表面粗糙度参数值,在反映四个工件中哪个工件整体性能好的结果是一致的;同时,对微细电火花加工工件表面形貌在各个区域是否均匀,进行了表面粗糙度一致性问题的统计分析。
本文的研究是表面形貌表征问题研究的一个完善与发展,也是微细电火花加工表面形貌评定研究的一个起点。同时,本文的工作也对提高微细电火花加工技术水平具有重要的理论意义。
With the development of science and technology, products are gradually miniaturization and precision all over the world, therefore, micro-fabrication technology is being concerned by the researchers around the world. However, micro-EDM plays more and more important position in the field for its many advantages, for instance, it has high machining efficiency, better processing quality, and can machine complex three-dimensional micro-parts by using high hardness materials and so on.
Research shows that the surface morphology of workpieces provides a lot of useful information, which has serious influence on the friction and lubrication characteristics of the surface. However, for the micro-EDM's surface topography evaluation problem, researchers have been using surface roughness parameters and evaluation method of mechanical process, which restrict the micro-EDM's technology further development. On this account, the surface roughness assessment of micro-EDM has been deeply studied in this paper according to its technology characteristics and the workpieces surface morphology characteristics. The main researches and creative points are as follows:
Firstly, the influence that the surface roughness of micro-EDM's parts impact on their using performance is analyzed and based on the surface morphology characteristics which are the countless tiny pits and uplift with different height degree, steep degree and spacing state, some evaluation parameters and their numerical calculation are given.
Secondly, because of the advantages of wavelet analysis which has good time-frequency localization property and can analysis the signal's any detail, the wavelet reference assessment is chosen to pick up micro-EDM's surface roughness, in which, by comparing the advantages and characteristics of commonly used wavelet function, Daubechies wavelet is selected as the wavelet function of wavelet reference assessment.
Thirdly, it is certified that using wavelet analysis for Micro-EDM's 2D and 3D surface roughness is the feasibility study, and then the wavelet models for picking up 2D and 3D surface roughness of Micro-EDM are presented, in which, the time of wavelet decomposition of the wavelet models for 3D surface roughness is determined by Pearson Chi-square goodness of fit test. Meanwhile, the results of simulation and experiments show that the proposed methods can separate Micro-EDM's surface roughness well.
Finally, according to the proposed evaluation parameters and the surface roughness extraction algorithm, the simulation and experiments and the comparison simulation experiments that Gaussian reference picking up surface roughness are carried out, meanwhile, the results show that the proposed methods can consistently reflect the workpieces' performance stand or fall. In addition, a homogeneous analysis has been done with statistical method between the whole surface roughness and each part.
Therefore, this research is. a perfect and development for surface morphology characterization, also is a beginning for micro-EDM's surface morphology research, furthermore, it has important theoretical significance for improving micro-EDM's technical level.
引文
[1]苑伟政,马炳和.微机械与微细加工技术.西北工业大学出版社,2000:1-12页
[2]王振龙.微细加工技术.国防工业出版社,2005:10-15页
[3]Giustino A. Interferometric GPS/Micro-mechanical Gyro Attitude Determination system:A Study into the Integration Issues. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. 1998: 24-37P
[4]X. C. Luo, K. Cheng, D. Webb. Design of ultraprecision machine tools with applications to manufacture of miniature and microcomponents. Journal of Materials Processing Technology,2005,167(2-3):515-528P
[5]杨辉.精密超精密加工技术在微机械制造中的应用.航空精密制造技术,2006,42(1):1-4页
[6]S. Dhanik, S. S. Joshi, N. Ramakrishnan, P. R. Apte. Evolution of EDM process modelling and development towards modelling of the micro-EDM process. International Journal of Manufacturing Technology and Management,2005,7(2-4):157-180P
[7]M. A. Norliana, S. Darius G, F. B. Md. A review on current research trends in electrical discharge machining (EDM). International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture, 2007,47(7-8):1214-1218P
[8]赵万生.电火花加工技术.哈尔滨工业大学出版社,2000
[9]Zhang Yong, Wang Zheng-long, Hu Fu-qiang, Jia Bao-xian, Zhao Wan-sheng. Research of micro-EDM and its applications. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology, 2007,14(6):747-751P
[10]Takahata Ken'ichi, Gianchandani Yogesh B. Batch Mode micro-electro-discharge machining. Journal of Micro electro mechanical Systems,2002,11(2):102-111P
[11]褚旭阳,狄士春,王振龙.微齿轮轴的微细电火花加工.吉林大学学报,2010,40(6):1577-1582页
[12]李亚非.国内外表面粗糙度研究概况及趋向.长沙交通学院学报,1994,10(3):38-43页
[13]X. Chen, J. Raja, S. Simanapali. Multi-Scale analysis of engineering surface. International Journal of Machine Tool and Manufacturing,1995,35(2):231-238P
[14]Thomas T. R. Trends in surface roughness. International Journal Machine Tool and Manufacturing,1998,38(5-6):405-411P
[15]王顺兴,邵尔玉.表而粗糙度对接触疲劳寿命的影响.兵器材料科学与工程,1992,15(7):26-30页
[16]Z. M. Hu, T. A. Dean. A study of surface topography, friction and lubricants in metal forming. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufaeture,2000,40(11): 1637-1649P
[17]Andrews S, Sehitoglu H. A computer model for fatigue crack growth from rough surfaces. International Journal of Fatigue,2000,22:619-630P
[18]Miodrag Micic, Yujun Zheng, Vincent Moy, Xiao-Hui Zhang, Fotios M. Andreopoulos, Roger M. Leblanc. Comparative studies of surface topography and mechanical properties of a new, photo-switchable PEG-based hydrogel. Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces,2003,27 (2-3):147-158P
[19]张东初,裴旭明.加工工艺对表面粗糙度及疲劳寿命的影响.中国机械工程,2003,14(16):1374-1377页
[20]章刚,刘军,刘永寿,岳珠峰.表面粗糙度对表面应力集中系数和疲劳寿命影响分析.机械强度,2010,32(1):110-115页
[21]Y. C. Liang, Y. Zhao, Q. S. Bai, S. M. Wang, B. Wang, M. Q. Chen, J. H. Dou. Study on micromachine tools in fabrication of microparts. Proceedings of 1st IEEE International Conference on Nano Micro Engineered and Molecular Systems,2006:858-861P
[22]L. A. Espitia, A. Toro. Cavitation resistance, microstructure and surface topography of materials used for hydraulic components. Tribology International,2010,,43(11): 2037-2045P
[23]毛起广.表面粗糙度的评定和测量.机械工业出版社,1991
[24]Liam Blunt, Xiangqian Jiang. Advanced Techniques for Assessment Surface Topography, Kogan page science, London,2003
[25]李伯奎,刘远伟.表面粗糙度理论发展研究.工具技术,2004,38(1):63-67页
[26]林滨,黄新雁,魏莹,王岚.加工表面形貌测量理论、方法及评价.制造业自动化,2006,28(8):14-18页
[27]吴松.三维表面形貌的评价技术及其应用基础研究.南京航空航天大学硕士学位论文,2007
[28]W P Dong, P J Sulivan, K J Stout. Comprehensive study of parameters for characterizing three-dimensional surface topography Ⅰ:Some inherent properties of parameter variation. Wear,1992,159:161-171
[29]W P Dong, P J Sulivan, K J Stout.Comprehensive study of parameters for characterizing three-dimensional surface topography Ⅱ:Statistical properties of parameter variation. Wear,1993,167:9-21
[30]Dong W. P, Sullivan P. J, Stout K. J. Comprehensive study of parameters for characterization 3-D surface topography-Ⅲ. Wear,1994,178(1):29-43P
[31]Dong W. P, Sullivan P. J, Stout K. J. Comprehensive study of parameters for characterization 3-D surface topography-Ⅳ. Wear,1994,178(1):45-60P
[32]李成贵,董申.三维表面微观形貌的表征趋势.中国机械工程,2000,11(5):488-492页
[33]李成贵,张国雄,袁长良.三维表面粗糙度的均一性研究.计量学报,1999,20(1):32-36页
[34]李成贵,张国雄,袁长良.三维表面粗糙度的等方性评定.机械工程学报,1999, 35(1):15-19页
[35]李成贵,李行善.三维表面粗糙度的均方根波长评定.北京航空航天大学学报,2002,28(2):190-193页
[36]杨培中,蒋寿伟.表面粗糙度三维评定的研究.机械设计与研究,2002,18(2):64-67页
[37]李丽伟,董申,程凯.表面微观形貌定量表征中几种新方法的应用.2002,13(19):1702-1705页
[38]D. J. Whitehouse. Survey of reference lines in the assessment of surface texture. Ann CIRP.1972,21(2):267-273P
[39]Chenggui Li, Shen Dong, Guoxiong Zhang. Evaluation of the root-mean-square wavelength of 3D surface topography. Wear,1999,232(1):76-83P
[40]王中宇,付继华,孟浩.二维表面粗糙度最小二乘评定基准线的改进.计量学报,2008,29(3):203-206页
[41]J. Raja, V. Tadhakrishnan. Filtering of Surface Profiles Using Fast Fourier Transform. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacturing,1979,19(3):133-141P
[42]Krystek M. A fast Gauss filtering algorithm for roughness measurements. Precision Engineering,1996,19(2-3):198-200P
[43]Yuan Yibao. A fast algorithm for determining the Gaussian filtered mean line in surface metrology. Precision Engineering,2000,24(1):62-69P
[44]S. Brinkmann, H. Bodschwinna, H. W. Lemke. Accessing Roughness in Three-Dimensions Using Gaussian Regression Filtering. Machine Tools and Manufacture,2001,41(13-14):2153-2161P
[45]曾文涵,高咏生,谢铁邦,李柱.三维表面粗糙度高斯滤波快速算法.计量学报,2003,24(1):10-13页
[46]曾文涵,谢铁邦,蒋向前.表面粗糙度的稳健提取方法研究.中国机械工程,2004,15(2):126-130页
[47]许景波,袁怡宝,朴伟英.表面粗糙度测量中的高斯滤波快速算法.计量学报.2005,4(26):209-312页
[48]李惠芬,蒋向前,李柱.高斯滤波稳健性能的研究与改进.仪器仪表学报,2004,5(25):633-637页
[49]Huifen Li, Xaingqian Jiang, Zhu Li. Robust Estimation in Gaussian Filtering forEngineering Surface Characterization. Precision Engineering,2004,28(2):186-193P
[50]陈庆虎,谢峰,谢铁邦,李柱.小波滤波的频谱结构分析及其在表面形貌分析中的应用.武汉交通科技大学学报,1998,22(3):231-233页
[51]陈庆虎,李柱.表面粗糙度评定的小波基准线.计量学报,1998,19(4):254-257页
[52]Chen Q, Yang S, Li Z. Surface roughness evaluation by using wavelets analysis. Precision Engineering,1999,23(3):209-212P
[53]Bruno Josso, David R. Burton, Michael J. Lalor. Frequency normalized wavelet transform for surface roughness analysis and characterization. Wear,2002,252(5-6): 491-500P
[54]J. Raja, B. Muralikrishnan. Recent advances in separation of roughness waviness and form. Precision Engineering,2002,26(2):222-235P
[55]Shengyu Fu, B. Muralikrishnan, J. Raja. Engineering surface analysis with different wavelet bases. Journal of Manufacturing Science and engineering,2003,125(4): 844-852P
[56]X. Jiang, L. Blunt, K. J. Stout. Lifting wavelet for three-dimensional surface analysis. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacturing,2001,41(13-14): 2163-2169P
[57]X. Jiang, L. Blunt. Third Generation Wavelet for the Extraction of Morphological Features from Micro and Nano Scalar Surfaces, Wear,2004,257(12):1235-1240P
[58]Kumar Jagadeesha, Shunmugam M. S. Fitting of robust reference surface based on least absolute deviations. Precision Engineering,2007,31(2):102-113P
[59]Zahouani H. Spectral and 3D motifs identification of anisotropic topographical components. Analysis and filtering of anisotropic patterns by morphological rose approach. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacturing,1998,38(5-6): 615-623P
[60]杨练根,谢铁邦,蒋向前.表面形貌的Motif评定方法及其发展.中国机械工程,2002,13(21):1862-1865页
[61]郭军,谢铁邦Motif合并算法研究.计量学报,2004,25(3):207-210页
[62]张维强,陈国强.基于地貌学的零件表面三维形貌评定.机械设计与研究,2007,23(2):76-79页
[63]李志强,陈小安,杨学恒,韩贤武.三维motif方法及其对微观形貌的表征重庆大学学报,2006,29(11):10-14页
[64]杨松,张维强,徐秀英.基于邻域分析的3D-motif表面评定算法研究.机械设计与研究,2008,24(4):84-86页
[65]Gangepain J, Roques Carmes C. Fractal approach to two dimensional and three dimensional surface roughness. Wear,1986,109(1-4):119-126P
[66]Suryaprakash G, Bharat B. Generalized fractal analysis and its applications to engineering surfaces. Wear,1995,180(1-2):17-34P
[67]Brown C A, Johnsen W A, Butland R M. Scale-sensitive Fractal Analysis of Turned Surfaces.Annals of the CIRP,1996,45 (1):515-518P
[68]He L, Zhu J. Fractal model for contact of rough surfaces.Tribology,1996,16(4): 375-384P
[69]汪慰军,陈历喜,曹麟祥.表面形貌的分形描述及其评定.航空学报,1997,18(3):336-340页
[70]Ge S R. The fractal behavior and fractal charac-teri-zation of rough surfaces. Tribology, 1997,17(1):73-80P
[71]郭世荣,Tonder K粗糙表面的分形特征与分形表达研究.摩擦学学报,1997,17(1): 73-80页
[72]Othmani A, Kaminsky C. Three dimensional fractal analysis of sheet metal surfaces.Wear,1998,214(2):147-150P
[73]John C. Russ, Fractal dimension measurement of engineering surfaces. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacturing,1998,38(5-6):567-571P
[74]蒋书文,姜斌,李燕,邓宏,郑昌琼,尹光福.磨损表面形貌的三维分形维数计算.摩擦学学报,2003,23(6):533-536页
[75]刘晋春,赵家齐,赵万生.特种加工.机械工业出版社,1999
[76]刘明,谢常青,王丛舜.微细加工技术.化学工业出版社,2004
[77]郭永丰,白基成,刘晋春.电火花加工技术.哈尔滨工业大学出版社,2005
[78]张天鹏.微细电火花加工工艺的基础性研究.南京航空航天大学硕士学位论文,2006
[79]崔景芝.微细电火花加工的基本规律及其仿真研究.哈尔滨工业大学博士学位论文,2007
[80]贾珂.微小器件的电火花成形加工应用技术研究.南京航空航天大学硕士学位论文,2007
[81]李惠芬,蒋向前,李柱.三维表面功能评定技术发展综述.工具技术,2002,17(4):8-11页
[82]李惠芬.基于新一代GPS体系的表面稳健高斯滤波技术的研究.华中科技大学大学博士学位论文,2004
[83]王建军,徐西鹏,黄辉.高斯滤波在花岗石表面粗糙度研究中的应用.计量学报,2006,27(2):104-106页
[84]葛世荣,索双富.表面轮廓分形维数计算方法的研究.摩擦学学报,1997,17(4):354-362页
[85]王建军,徐西鹏.花岗石抛光表面的粗糙度、分形维数及其关系研究.计量学报,2007,28(2):124-128页
[86]全书海.基于表面灰度图像的加工表面形貌分形特征研究.武汉理工大学博士学位论文,2003
[87]李志强.表面微观形貌的测量及其表征.重庆大学硕士学位论文,2006
[88]郭军.激光干涉表面形貌测量系统及3D-MOTIF评定研究.华中科技大学大学博士学位论文,2004
[89]杨松.表面粗糙度的三维motif评定方法研究.南京农业大学硕士学位论文,2009
[90]Albert B, Franeis J N. A First course in Wavelets with Fourier Analysis电子工业出版版社,2002
[91]文鸿雁.基于小波理论的变形分析模型研究.武汉大学博士学位论文,2004
[92]潘泉,张磊,孟晋丽,张洪才.小波滤波方法及应用.清华大学出版社,2005
[93]刘明才.小波分析及其应用.清华大学出版社,2005
[94]王大凯,彭进业.小波分析及其在信号处理中的应用.电子工业出版社,2006
[95]S. G. Mallat. A wavelet tour of signal processing, academic press,1998
[96]I. Daubechies. Ten Lectures onWavelets. SIAM,1992
[97]袁长良.表面粗糙度及其测量.机械工业出版社,1989
[98]吴松青.表面粗糙度应用指南.机械工业出版社,1990
[99]ISO/DIS 4287, Geometrical product specification(GPS)-surface texture:profile method-Terms, definitions and surface texture parameters. International Organization for Standardization,1997
[100]S Mezghani, H Zahouani. Characterisation of the 3D waviness and roughness motifs. Wear,2004, (257):1250-1256
[101]H. T. Lee, T. Y. Tai. Relationship between EDM parameters and surface crack formation. Journal of Materials Processing Technology,2003,142(3):676-683P
[102]S. Bigot, J. Valentincic, O. Blatnik, M. Junkar. Micro-EDM parameters optimization. 2nd International Conference on Multi-Material Micro Manufacture,2006,195-198P
[103]Zhijie Chen, Jihong Shen, Libin Guo. Research on 3D surface roughness assessment parameters of micro-EDM(已投)
[104]Zhi-jie Chen, Ji-hong Shen, Li-bin Guo. Wavelet method for roughness of micro-EDM's surface contour lines. Key Engineering Materials 2009:401-404P
[105]Zhi-jie Chen, Ji-hong Shen, Libin Guo. Surface roughness assessment of micro-EDM by wavelet analysis based on goodness of fit test. Key Engineering Materials 2011: 304-307P
[106]Zhijie Chen, Jihong Shen, Libin Guo. A wavelet method based on goodness of fit test for roughness of micro-EDM. IEEE ICIA 2010:2026-2030P
[107]徐超,杨林德.随机变量拟合优度检验和分布参数Bayes估计.同济大学学报,1998,26(3):340-344页
[108]龚自立,贾新章,白永亮.元器件质量与可靠性数据统计分布规律的拟合.西安电子科技大学学报,200 1,28(3):336-339页
[109]Chen Gemai, Balakrishnan N. General purpose approximate goodness-of-fit test. Journal of Quality Technology,1995,27(2):154-161P
[110]杨振海.拟合优度检验.安徽教育出版社,1997
[111]梁小筠.正态性检验.中国统计出版社,1997
[112]杨永发,籍明文,张崇岐,张志海,金少华.概率论与数理统计.南开大学出版社,2000:271-278页
[113]陈桂明,张明照,戚红雨.应用MATLAB语言处理数字信号与数字图像.科学出版社,2000
[114]董长红,赖志国,余啸海Matlab图象处理与应用,国防工业出版社,2004
[115]余成波.数字图像处理及MATLAB实现.重庆大学出版社,2003
[116]李伯奎,左敦稳,刘远伟.轮廓支承长度率曲线的应用研究.润滑与密封,2006,1:114-116页
[117]李伯奎,刘远伟.表面承载和液体滞留性能评价参数的研究.润滑与密封,2004,4:66-74页
[118]李伯奎.三维粗糙度参数算术平均偏差与均方根偏差的规律研究.工具技术,2008,42(9):107-110页
[119]K FEhmann, M SHong. A Generalized Model of the Surface Generation Process in Metal Cutting. Annals of the CIPP,1994,43:483-486P
[120]孔令叶,阎秋生,宋军辉.基于表面粗糙度均匀性的曲面磨削研究.中国机械工程,2008,19(21):2557-2560页
[121]刘莹.准分子激光加工表面微观形貌表征及其特征研究,武汉理工大学博士学位论文,2002
[122]李小兵,刘莹,郭纪林,余桂英.不同机加工表面微观形貌的特征分析.润滑与密封,2007,32(7):26-28页
[123]Kane Malal, Bou-Said Benyebka. A comparison of homogenization and direct techniques for the treatment of roughness in incompressible lubrication. Journal of Tribology,2004,126(4):733-737P
[124]Singh Udaibir, Singh Amit Pratap, Kapoor Avinashi. Homogeneous model for surface roughness in identical double layer system. Optics and Laser Technology,2007,39(2): 247-255P
[125]Bernd M Schumacher. After 60 years of EDM the discharge process remains disputed. Journal of Materials Processing Technology.2004,149(1-3):376-381P
[126]Lee H. T, Tai T. Y. Relationship between EDM parameters and surface crack formation. Journal of Materials Processing Technology,2003,142(3):676-683P
[127]Keskin Yusuf, Halkaci H. Selcuk, Kizil Mevlut. An experimental study for determination of the effects of machining parameters on surface roughness in electrical discharge machining. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2006,28(11-12):1118-1121P