烟草公司批零合作关系对合作绩效影响研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
现代烟草零售终端建设要求对市场需求的快速反应,要求卷烟供应链各节点单元间的无缝对接,要求烟草公司尽快适应从“官商”到“服务商”,从传统商业企业到现代流通企业这个角色的转变。这一轮变化中,烟草公司与零售业户间的关系建设逐渐备受重视,批零合作关系到底如何作用于这条卷烟供应链开始被烟草人关注。然而,很少有人去研究这个问题,学者们由于种种原因忽略了对现代烟草供应链合作关系的探索,他们往往局限于研究烟草物流配送效率或者烟草行政垄断行业特色。以往对合作关系的研究也往往局限于一两个方面,例如信任、信息共享、承诺对供应链绩效的影响研究等等,很少有人把合作关系的所有维度综合在一起,去探讨它们对绩效的影响,对于这些变量之间的相互作用路径的研究则更加缺乏。据此,本文选取当前我国烟草下游供应链为研究对象,以烟草公司-零售业户间的批零合作关系为出发点,去探索批零合作关系对批零双方合作绩效的作用机制,并试图去摸清批零合作关系各维度间的相互影响路径。
     本文参考国内外供应链管理相关理论,借鉴前辈学者们开发的量表体系,结合当前烟草公司-零售户合作关系实际,提出并证实烟草批零合作关系包含四个维度:零售户对烟草公司的依赖、零售户与烟草公司签订的契约、零售户信任以及双方间的信息共享,进一步研究了批零合作关系四维度与批零合作绩效间以及四维度自身之间的作用路径。全文采用理论演绎与实证分析相结合的研究方法,选取辽宁省鞍山市451户卷烟零售业户为调研对象,使用SPSS11.5、AMOS6.0统计软件对问卷样本进行了描述性统计、信度检验、效度检验、相关性分析、验证性因子分析以及对假设的结构方程模型检验。实证结果表明:烟草公司与零售业户间的批零合作关系对批零合作绩效有正向影响;零售户对烟草公司的依赖对批零合作绩效有正向作用;契约的使用对批零合作绩效有正向影响;信任对批零合作绩效的提升有积极作用;信息共享有利于提升批零合作绩效;零售户对烟草公司的依赖与零售户使用契约正相关;零售户对烟草公司的依赖与零售户对烟草公司的信任负相关;契约的使用对零售户信任有积极作用;契约的使用有利于双方的信息共享;零售户信任促进了批零双方的信息共享。
     最后,本文依据实证结果与研究结论,给当前烟草公司的零售终端建设提出了若干建议,并指出了不足与今后的研究方向,以期为烟草供应链实践和相关理论研究贡献微力。
Modern tobacco retail terminal building requires quick response to market demands and seamless supply chain, and it also requires tobacco company to change his role, from "officials and businessmen" to "service providers", from traditional to modern and circulation enterprises. In the change, the relationship, between tobacco company and tobacco retailers, becomes to be attended, and the Tobacco-People gradually pay more and more attention on the question how the relationship impacts the cooperative performance of the tobacco supply chain. However, there were few scholars to study the problem due to various reasons, and they were often limited in the tobacco's administrative monopoly, or the efficiency of logistics and distribution. On the other hand, previous researches about collaborative relationships are often limited to one dimension or two dimensions, for example, they inclined to study one element how to impact co-performance, such as trust, information sharing, or commitment, and few people integrated all the dimensions to study their impact on co-performance, and there were less explorations for the relationships among all the dimensions. As a result, the thesis selects the downstream of China-Tobacco supply chain as the range, and the cooperative relations between tobacco company and tobacco retailers as the object, and it tries to study the mechanism, how wholesale and retail partnership influence on the co-performance, and the mutual influence path among the various dimensions.
     According to the related theories and based on the tobacco practice, the thesis proves that tobacco company-retailers relationship in China included dependence, contract, trust and information sharing, and probes all path relations between variables. The study uses a research method constituted by theoretical deduction and empirical analysis, and selects 451 tobacco retailers in Anshan, Liaoning province, as the sample. Then it goes on data analysis, concluding descriptive statistics, reliability testing, validity testing, correlation analysis, confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation model checking assumptions. The empirical results showed that the cooperative relationship had positive impact on the cooperative performance, all of the dependence, contract, trust and information sharing had positive impact on the cooperative performance, dependence had a positive impact on contract, contract had a positive impact on trust, contract had a positive impact on information sharing, trust had a positive impact on information sharing, but dependence had a negative impact on trust.
     At last, in order to make contribution to China-Tobacco's supply chain practices and theoretical research, the study, based on empirical results and findings, provides a number of recommendations on current tobacco terminal building, and points out the shortage and future research directions.
引文
[1]霍佳震,隋明刚,刘仲英.企业绩效及供应链绩效评价研究现状.同济大学学报,2001年8月第29卷第8期.
    [2]Krause D R.The Relationships between Supplier Development,Commitment,Social Capital Accumulation and Performance Improvement.Journal of Operations Management,2007,25(2):528-545.
    [3]Hau L Lee,v.Padmanabhan.The bull whip effect in supply chains,solon management review spring,1997:93-102.
    [4]潘文安,张红.供应链伙伴间的信任、承诺对合作绩效的影响.心理科学,2006,29(6):1502-1506.
    [5]《中国人民共和国烟草专卖法》第2条.
    [6]姜向阳等.中国烟草零售终端网络优化与控制的路径安排.现代管理科学,2009年第6期.
    [7]Maloni MJ,Benton W C.Supply chain partnerships:opportunities for operations research.European journal of operational research,101;419-429,1997.
    [8]Rackham.Coordinated Supply Chain Management.European Journal of Operational Research,1995,94(1):1-5.
    [9]马士华,林勇,陈志祥.供应链管理.北京:机械工业出版社,2000.
    [10]Maloni MJ,Benton W C.Supply chain partnerships:opportunities for operations research.European journal of operational research,101:419-429,1997.
    [11]马士华,林勇,陈志祥.供应链管理.北京:机械工业出版社,2000.
    [12]侯玉华.供应链企业间合作关系的动因及其构建.河北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2009年第5期.
    [13]Ragatz,G L等.success factors for integrating suppliers into new product development.journal of production innovation management,1997,14:190-201.
    [I4]Cannon J P等.buyer-seller relationships in business markets.Journal of marketing research,1999,36(4):439-460.
    [15]Campbell,A.buyer-supplier partnerships:flip sides of the same coin? Journal of business & industrial marketing,1997,12(6):417-434.
    [16]Fynes B,ross C.The Moderating Effect of Buyer-supplier Relationships on Quality Practices and Performance.International Journal of Operations & Production Management,2002(22):589-613.
    [17]Benton W C,Maloni.The Influence of Power Driven Buyer/seller Relationships on Supply Chain Satisfaction.Journal of Operations Management,2005,23(1):1-22.
    [18]陈志祥.供应链管理中的供需合作关系研究.武汉理工大学学报.信息与管理工程版,第26卷第5期,2007.
    [19]张杰.中国制造业买方供应链合作伙伴一体化模式实证研究:(博士学位论文).北京:对外经济贸易大学,2007.
    [20]Chan L Y.The Impact of Supplier Development on Buyer-supplier Performance.Omega,2004,32(2):131-143.
    [21]MCGEE J E,DOWLING M J,M EGGINSON W L.Cooperative Strategy and 77 New Venture Performance:the Role of Business Strategy and Management Experience.Strategy Management Journal,1995,16(7):565-580.
    [22]GANESAN S,AMBROSE M,HESS R L.The Relationship between Justice and Attitudes:An Examination of Justice Effects on Event and System-related Attitudes.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2007,103(1):21-36.
    [23]ANDERSON J A,FAFF R W.Point and Figure Charting:A Computational Methodology and Trading Rule Performance in the S&P 500 Futures Market.International Review of Financial Analysis,2008,17(1):198-217.
    [24]潘文安.供应链伙伴间的信任、承诺对合作绩效的影响.心理科学,2006,29(6).
    [25]武志伟,陈莹.关系专用性投资、关系质量与合作绩效.预测,2008,27(5):33-37.
    [26]林义屏.市场导向、组织学习、组织创新与组织绩效间关系之研究——以科学园区信息电子产业为例:(博士学位论文).台湾:中山大学,2001,5.
    [27][美]罗杰·布莱克威尔/季建华,任建立,赵平译.重构新千年零售业供应链.上海:上海远东出版社,2000.
    [28]Davis.T.Effective supply chain management.Sloan Management text and cases.New York:McGraw-Hill 1996.
    [29]汤世强.供应链合作伙伴绩效评价研究.商业研究,总第368期,2007/12.
    [30]Zollo.The Impact of Supplier Development on Buyer-Supplier Performance.Omega,2002,32(2):131-143.
    [31]Kale dyer,Singh.The relational view:cooperative strategy and sources of interorganizational competitive advantage.Academy of management review,1998:660-679.
    [32]宋华.供应链管理中企业间的冲突和合作机制分析.中国人民大学学报,2004,4:65-71.
    [33]何晓晴.工程项目成功合作及其管理指标体系的构建与研究:(博士学位论文).长沙:湖南大学,2006.
    [34]宋常,郭天明.企业间合作绩效及其影响机制研究.财经问题研究,第4期(总第281期),2007年4月.
    [35]Kamp B.Formation and Evolution of Buyer-supplier Relationships:Conceiving Dynamism in Actor Composition of Business Net works.Industrial Marketing Management,2005,34(7):658-668.
    [36]Rabade L A,Alfaro JA.Buyer-supplier Relationships' influence on Trace ability Implementation in the Vegetable Industry.Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management,2006,12(1):39-50.
    [37]Caniel,M C.power and interdependence in buyer supplier relationships:a purchasing portfolio approach.Industrial marketing management,2007,36(2):219-229.
    [38]Kogut.Seller and buyer firm factors affecting industrial buyers' negotiation behavior and outcomes.Journal of Marketing Research,1988,21(February),pp39-53.
    [39]Das,T.K.and Teng,B.S.A resource-based theory of strategic alliances.Journal of Management,2000,26(1),pp31-61.
    [40]Peteraf.M.A.The cornerstones of competitive advantage:A resource-based view.Strategic Management Journal,1993,14,pp179-191.
    [41]Finkelstein S,D.C.Hambrick.Strategic leadership:top executives and their effects on organizations.St.Paul,MN:West,1996.
    [42]LUSCM,ROBERT F,BROWN,JAMES R.Interdependency,Contracting,and Relational Behavior in Marketing Channels.Journal of Marketing,1996,60(4):19-38.
    [43]DYER,J H.Effective interfrim collaboration:How Firms Minimize Transaction Costs and Maximize Transaction Value.Strategic Management Journal,1997(18):535-556.
    [44]HOLM,D.B.,K.Eriksson and J.Johansson.Creating Value through Mutual Commitment to Business Network Relationships.Strategic Management Journal,1999,(20):467-486.
    [45]庄贵军,周筱莲,周南.零售商与供应商之间依赖关系的实证研究.商业经济与管理,2006,176(6):20-25.
    [46]张杰.中国制造业买方供应链合作伙伴一体化模式实证研究:(博士学位论文).北京:对外经济贸易大学,2007.
    [47]林筠,薛岩.企业-供应商关系与合作绩效路径模型实证研究.管理科学,第21卷第4期,2008年8月.
    [48]Aghion,Phillipe.Contracts as a barrier to entry.American economic review,1987,77:388-401.
    [49]Anupiki,Bassor.Y.Centralization of Stocks:Retailers Vs Manufacturer.Management Science,1999,45(2):178-195.
    [50]Padmanabhan等.Double-sided moral hazard and the nature of share contracts.University of Michigan,school of business administration working paper no.698,1995.
    [51]LARIYIERE M.Inducing Forecast Revelation Through Restricted Returns.Northwestern University,2002.
    [52]DANA J,SPIER K.Revenue Sharing and Vertical Control in the Video Rental Industry.The Journal of Industrial Economics,2001,49(3):223-245.
    [53]Anderson J,Narus J.A model of distributor firm and manufacturer firm working partnerships.Journal of Marketing,1990,Vol.54,January,pp42-58.
    [54]刘咏梅,夏至刚.供应链契约研究综述.企业技术开发,25卷第12期,2006.
    [55]柳键,马士华.供应链合作及其契约研究.管理工程学报,2004年第1期.
    [56]Mayer.Building trust in international alliances.Journal of World Business,1995,33(4).
    [57]Doney 等.The role of trust and relationship structure in improving supply chain responsiveness.Industrial Marking Management,1997,31(4).
    [58]Denise M.Rousseau,Sim B.Sitken,Colin Camerer.Not so different after all:a Cross-discipline View of Trust.Academy of Management Review.1998,(3):393-404.
    [59]王蔷.论战略联盟中的相互信任问题.外国经济与管理.2000,(4):22-25.
    [60]卢曼,熟悉、信赖、信任:问题与替代选择.国外社会学.2000,(3):12-15.
    [61]宋立荣.供应商的竞争环境及策略分析.中国流通经济.2001,(6):41-43
    [62]LEWICKIR J,BUNKER B.Developing and Maintaining Trust in Work Relationships.Kramer M,Tyler TR.Trust in Organization:Frontiers of Theory and Research.Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage Publications,1996:114-139.
    [63]威廉姆森.王健等译.治理机制.中国社会科学出版社,2001:315-324.
    [64]F.Robert Dwyer,Paul H.Developing Buyer-Seller Relationships.Journal of Marketing,Vol.51(April 1987),11-27.
    [65]C Moorman,G Zaltman,R Deshpande.Relationships Between Providers and Users of Market Research.The Dynamics of Trust Within and Between Organizations.Journal of Marketing Research;Vol.29,No.3,1992.
    [66]Nooteboom B.Trust,opportunism and governance:A process and control model.Organization Studies,1996.
    [67]Walter.A 等.Functions of Industrial Supplier Relationships and Their Impact on Relationship Quality.Industrial Marketing.Volume 32,Issue 2,February 2003,Pages 159-169.
    [68]张剑渝.《营销渠道——关系视角下的解读》.成都:西南财经大学出版社,2005年12月第1版.
    [69]Danny Pimentel Claro,Geoffrey Hagelaar.Coordinating collaborative joint efforts with suppliers-the effects of trust,transaction specific investment and information network in the Dutch flower industry.Supply Chain Management.An International Journal,2006,216-224.
    [70]BRADACH JL,ECCLESR G.Price,Authority and Trust:From Ideal Types to Plural Forms.Annual Review of Sociology,2002,15:97-118.
    [71]Rackham 等.The role of trust relationship structure in improving supply chain responsiveness.Industrial Marketing Management,1995:367-382.
    [72]潘文安,张红.供应链伙伴间的信任、承诺对合作绩效的影响.心理科学,2006(09).
    [73]张旭梅,陈伟.供应链企业间基于信任的知识获取和合作绩效实证研究.科技管理研究,2009年第2期.
    [74]李培亮.拉动式供应链信息共享价值分析与机制实现:(博士学位论文).上海:同济大学,2007.
    [75]Stein T,Sweat J.Killer.Supply Chains.Information Week,1998,708:36-46.
    [76]马新安,张列平,田澎.供应链中的信息共享激励.动态模型.中国管理科学,2001,9(1):19-24.
    [77]齐源.供应链管理中信息共享研究:(博士学位论文).上海:上海大学,2002.
    [78]Thonemann U.W.Improving Supply Chain Performance by Sharing Advance Demand Information.European Journal of Operational Research,2002,142:81-10.
    [79]Rhonda R 等.Managing the demand chain through managing the information flow:capturing moments of the information.Production and inventory management journal,first quarter 1999,40(1):16-21.
    [80]Srinagesh Gavimeni.Information Flows in Capacitated Supply Chains with Fixed Ordering Cost.Management Science,2002:456-472.
    [81]Taylor T.A.SuPPly Chain Coordination Under Channel Rebates with Sales Effort Effects.Management Science,2002,48(8):992-1007.
    [82]Elizabeth A Williamson 等.Information systems development within supply chain management.International Journal of information Management,2004,24:375-385.
    [83]Frank Chen等.Quantifying the Bullwhip Effect in a simple supply chain.The Impact of Forecasting,Lead Times,and Information.Management Science,VOL.46,No.3,March 2000:436-443.
    [84]Gerard P.Cachon,Marshall Fisher.Supply Chain Inventory Management and the Value of Shared Information.Management Science,Vol.46,No 8,August 2000:1032-1048.
    [85]Jingquan 等.A Strategic analysis of inter organizational information sharing.Decision Support Systems,2004:1-16.
    [86]宋常,郭天明.企业间合作绩效及其影响机制研究.财经问题研究,第4期(总第281期),2007年4月.
    [87]Miyamoto.T,Rexha.N.determinants of three facets of customer trust:a marketing model of Japanese buyer-supplier relationship.Journal of business research,2004:312-319.
    [88]HOLM,D.B,K.Eriksson.Creating Value through Mutual Commitment to Business Network Relationships.Strategic Management Journal,1999,20:467-486.
    [89]林筠,薛岩.企业-供应商关系与合作绩效路径模型实证研究.管理科学,第21卷第4期,2008年8月.
    [90]张旭梅,陈伟.供应链企业间基于信任的知识获取和合作绩效实证研究.科技管理研究,2009年第2期.
    [91]尹艳.供应链的信息共享契约研究初探.科技情报开发与经济,2009年第19卷第3期.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700