摘要
多年来随着中国经济的高速增长和外汇储备的不断增加,人民币的购买力水平持续提高,进而升值压力凸显。2005年7月21日,央行宣布人民币升值2%,自此人民币结束了维持十年之久的人民币汇率“盯住制”,开始转向以市场供求为基础、参考一篮子货币进行调节、有管理的浮动汇率制度。至2008年9月底,人民币缓慢升值已有三年的时间,人民币兑美元汇率从8.28:1上升至6.83:1,累计升值幅度已达17.5%,年平均升幅约为6%。
然而,就在升值初期(2005年7月至2007年10月)出现了资产价格的大幅膨胀。中国股票市场的上证指数从2005年6月的最低点998点上涨到2007年10月最高点的6124点,同期A股指数也从最低点1047点上涨到的最高点6429点,最高涨幅为6倍多;房地产价格虽然在2005年之前就开始不断攀升,但当升值预期被市场普遍认可后,以北京、上海和深圳为首的大中城市房地产价格更是在原来的基础上进一步上涨2-3倍。而随后,中国政府从2007年10月开始的主动调控使资产价格大幅回落。上证指数曾跌至2008年9月的最低点1802点,同时,A股指数从最高点一度跌至2008年9月的最低点1892点,跌幅达到70%;2008年第二季度开始,房地产价格也出现了松动,继股票价格大跌之后房地产价格也处于风雨飘摇之中。
自汇率机制改革以来,人民币升值趋势不减,资产价格经历了从暴涨到大幅下跌的过程。2006年的流动性过剩的热钱还在到处涌动,这些流动性不仅一度造成了资产价格的大幅上涨,而且自2007年以来还造成了通货膨胀,该势头还保持到了2008年。国家实施多年的稳健的货币政策也转向从紧货币政策。同时,人民币名义汇率升值速度在加快,如果继续升值且幅度扩大,其对经济的潜在影响还无法估量。这些问题困扰着当局者,中国政府正处在经济发展的两难境地,也正面对前所未有的挑战。
这些现象引发出一系列问题和思考:为何本币升值总是伴随资产价格的大起大落?本币升值是通过何种机制作用于资产价格的?日本资产价格破灭对实体经济产生的严重影响不得不让人深思,而我国目前也已经出现了股票价格大幅下跌的局面。那么,我国是否也会重蹈覆辙?我们应该如何避免资产价格的下跌对实体经济的巨大冲击昵?
本文将从上述问题出发,通过理论探讨和实证分析研究人民币升值压力下中国资产价格大起大落的状况及成因,并分别就本币升值对我国股票市场和房地产市场的影响进行了细致思考。在此基础上,本文进一步分析了紧缩货币政策下可能产生的资产泡沫破灭及资产价格大幅下跌对宏观经济的影响,并提出相关解决方案。从某种程度上讲,资产价格的大幅下跌比大幅增长更可怕。如果中国无法妥善处理好资产价格大幅下跌的问题,不仅会影响到宏观经济的稳定和持续增长以及产业结构的调整等,还可能引发一系列的后遗症。中国不能重蹈日本之覆辙,因为那样的代价对中国这样一个发展中国家来说太大了,其后果是相当严重的,我国一定要加以防治。
全文除引言和第一章文献回顾之外,主要内容共分为四部分:
第一部分为现实篇,即第2章。在回顾人民币汇率机制改革的基础上,论述了人民币升值压力及其预期;接着探讨了由人民币升值预期带来的国际资本流动;最后描述国内资产价格全面膨胀和中国A股市场出现大幅回落以及房地产市场出现松动的现实情况。
第二部分为理论篇,即第3章。首先阐述了国际短期资本流动对货币供给的影响,接着在此基础上分析人民币升值导致的流动性,以及产生流动性的路径方式,试图从货币供给的宏观角度来分析人民币升值带来的新增货币的流动性对中国资产价格的影响及传导机制,建立了流动性对资产价格传导机制的框架模型,并从实证角度证明了流动性对资产价格的影响。
第三部分为实证篇,分为第4章和第5章。第4章是针对人民币升值对A股市场影响作了具体分析,然后对汇率与A股指数与各个行业指数分别进行实证分析。第5章则主要分析了汇率升值对中国房地产市场的影响,具体分析了人民币升值对房地产市场的影响。
第四部分为对策篇,是本文的最后2章。第6章首先阐述了自汇率机制改革以来,央行货币政策三大工具的实施,以及实施的紧缩货币政策对资产价格的影响;其次在回顾20世纪80年代末日本教训的基础上,总结紧缩的货币政策对资产价格的作用;最后论文了房地产价格大幅下跌对经济造成的伤害;第7章则是结论与政策建议,针对货币政策以及如何避免中国因货币升值和资产价格大幅下跌引致经济衰退的政策建议。
With the rapid growth of Chinese economy and the fast increase of foreign exchange reserves over the years, the purchasing power of RMB continues to rise, which results in subsequent pressures of RMB's appreciation. On July 21, 2005, the Central Bank of China announced that RMB would appreciate by 2%. Since then the decade-long "pegged" system of exchange rate has ended and shifted to a floating one based on supplies and demands, with reference to a basket of currencies. At the end-Sept of 2008, appreciation of RMB has been implemented for three years. The exchange rate between RMB and dollar has risen from 8.28:1 to 6.83:1, and the cumulative appreciation rate has reached 17.5%, the average yearly increase of 6%.
In the early period, asset price inflated substantially along with the appreciation of RMB. The A-share stock market index of China soared to its highest point of 6429 in October, 2007 from the lowest point of 1047 in June, 2005, with an increase of more than six times. While the price of real estates started to rise before the appreciation of RMB, and after the appreciation was generally recognized by the market, the prices of real estates of the big cities led by Beijing, Shanghai and Shenzhen have risen up by 2-3 times. Then, the Chinese government started the initiative to control asset prices from October, 2007. A stock index fell from its peak to 1892 point of September, 2008, with a decrease of 70%. After the second quarter of 2008, the real estate price also began to fall.
Since the exchange rate mechanism reform, the RMB appreciation trend has not weakened, and asset prices experienced a sharp decline from the surge. The excess liquidity was still flowing everywhere, the mobility was not only resulted in a substantial rise in asset prices, and sine 2007 also led to inflation, which maintain in 2008. Stable monetary policy used by authorities for many years has shifted to the tight monetary policy. Chinese government is facing a series of difficulties. With the acceleration of nominal exchange rate appreciation of RMB, if we continue to expand the range, its potential impact on the economy will be incalculable, so the Chinese government is now in a dilemma.
The inflation of asset prices along with the appreciation of the exchange rate is not exceptional, which can easily be found in other countries. The appreciation of the domestic currency and asset price bubbles are closely linked. Does the appreciation of the domestic currency really have an impact on asset prices? If so, what are the channels? After Japanese asset price bubbles burst, there was an economic depression which lasted for 10 years. Is there an association between economic recession and the burst of the bubble? Will China repeat the mistakes of the Japanese economy? How should we avoid the impact which the slumpin asset prices has on the real economy?
Starting from the above-mentioned issues, the present thesis attempts to analyze the pressure of RMB appreciation and asset price inflation based on theoretical discussions and empirical research. This paper analyzes the impact of RMB appreciation on China's stock market and real estate market , further studies that tight monetary policy may result in the asset bubble burst which would impact on macroeconomic, and gives related solutions. To some extent, the sharp decline in asset prices is more terrible than the surge. If one government can not properly handle the sharp decline in asset prices, it will affect not only the macro-economic stability and sustained economic growth, but also the adjustment of industrial structure. China can not repeat the mistakes of Japan, because the cost for a developing country like China is too big and the consequences are very serious. China must take right actions.
引文
[1][美]罗纳德·I.麦金农[日]大野健一 著,王信 曹莉 译 陈雨露 校,麦金农经济学文集(第五卷):美元与日元[M],中国金融出版社,2006年10月
[2][美]高柏著,刘耳译,日本经济的悖论--繁荣与停滞的制度性根源[M],商务印书馆,北京,2004年12月
p]宋坚主编,德国经济与市场[M],中国商务出版社,北京,2003年11月
[4]姚先国[德]H.缪尔德斯著,两德统一中的问题[M],科学技术文献出版社,北京,1992年9月
[5]苏东斌,李沛然主编,台湾香港澳门经济史略[M],广东经济出版社,广州,2002年5月
[6]肖捷 著,德国经济体制和经济政策[M],中国计划出版社,北京,1992年4月
[7]张蕴岭 主编,东亚经济社会发展的稳定与安全--从金融危机中得出的教训[M],中国社会科学出版社,北京,2001年9月
[8]余杰著,国际资本流动与发展中国家证券市场[M],成都:西南财经大学出版社,2000年9月
[9]黑田东彦,日本汇率政策失败教训[J],财经,2004年7月,总第111期
[10]黑田东彦,日本汇率政策失败所带来的教训--以“尼克松冲击”和“广场协议”为例[J],国际经济评论,2004.1-2
[11]尹延庆,日元升值对中国的启示,对外经济贸易大学,2006年3月
[12]李非著,台湾经济发展通论[M],九州出版社,2004年6月
[13]陈作章著,日本货币政策问题研究[M],上海:复旦大学出版社,2005年9月
[14]周伟,新台币升值的启示[J],两岸关系,2006(7)
[15]余文建,台湾地区应对新台币升值压力的经验及其启示[J],福建金融,2005(8)
[16]刘云,新台币升值对台湾经济的影响及其启示[J],中国金融,2004(15)
[17]盛松成,周鹏,经济增长过程中的汇率升值问题[J],上海金融,2006(5)
[18]张斌,何帆,如何应对经济崛起时期的汇率升值压力[J],国际经济评论,2004(5-6)
[19]温彬,人民币汇率改革的效应和趋势分析[J],国际金融研究,2006(3)
[20]张碧琼,李越 汇率对中国股票市场的影响是否存在[J],金融研究,2002(7)
[21]刘建江,徐长生 本币升值影响通货紧缩的机理[J],当代经济研究,2005(1)
[22]袁冬梅,刘建江,本币升值影响股票市场的理论与实证研究[J],长沙理工大学学报(社会科学版),第21卷第4期,2006(12)
[23]陈雁云,何维达,人民币汇率与股价的ARCH效应检验及模型分析[J],集美大学学报(哲学社会科学版),第9卷第1期,2006(3)
[24]黄孝武,资产价格泡沫生成与治理理论综述[J],经济学动态,2004(11)
[25]侯青,张永军,本币升值背景下货币政策的国际比较及其启示[J],国际金融研究,2006(9)
[26]郑建明,曹龙骐,人民币升值压力的货币化、资产泡沫与宏观调控[J],国际金融研究,2005(8)
[27]高波.毛中根,汇率冲击与房地产泡沫演化:国际经验及中国的政策取向[J],经济理论与经济管理,2006(7)
[28]张秀智,吴晓光,从中国房地产市场现状看人民币升值速度与幅度[J],中国房地产金融,2006(9)
[29]周京奎,利率、汇率调整对房地产价格的影响--基于理论与经验的研究[J],金融理论与实践,2006(12)
[30]邹巍,人民币升值预期下的房地产泡沫[J],房地产金融,2005(9)
[31]宋勃,高波,国际资本流动对房地产价格的影响[J],财经问题研究,2007年3月
[32]宋建军,曹峰建,吴大雄,台湾和日本资本输出管理的经验及对我国的启示[J],财经问题研究,2005年2月
[33]唐彬,论我国货币政策中介目标的适用性[J],投资研究,2006(8)
[34]李新功,中国外汇储备过剩的原因及调整[J],投资研究,2006年10月
[35]陶卫,外汇占款对我国货币政策效果的影响[J],投资研究,2007年2月
[36]韩剑,我国外汇储备非均衡增长的原因及效应分析[J],投资研究,2006年3月
[37]罗强,新兴市场的资本流动与资产泡沫分析[J],投资研究,2006年5月
[38]吴建军,我国M2/GDP过高:基于投资利率弹性的分析[J],投资研究,2007年3月
[39]张杰,中国的高货币化之谜[J],经济研究,2006(6)
[40]薛峰光,对我国银行业流动性过剩的几点思考[J],投资研究,2006(10)
[41]赵晓艳,对货币政策中介目标选择问题的思考[J],投资研究,2007(4)
[42]岳意定,张璇,我国外汇储备对基础货币影响的实证研究[J],世界经济研究,2007(1)
[43]王建,流动性过剩与地产、股市泡沫问题[J],金融经济,2007(3)
[44]邵蔚,货币流动性影响资产价格的理论探讨[J],财经问题研究,2007(3)
[45][美]达摩达尔N.古扎拉蒂,计量经济学基础(第4版)[M],费剑平,孙春霞 译,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005年
[46]陈雨露,汪昌云,金融学文献通论[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006年4月
[47]王碧峰,流动性过剩问题讨论综述[J],经济理论与经济管理,2007年第3期
[48]赫亮,西方汇率理论与人民币汇率问题研究[D],2006年5月
[49]王志伟[编著],现代西方经济学主要思潮及流派[M],北京:高等教育出版社,2004年9月
[50]李成,郝俊香,国际资本流动理论的发展与展望[J],西安交通大学学报(社会科学版),2006年5月
[51]钟伟,我们会重演日本和台湾地区的股灾吗?IJ),中国发展观察,2007年8期
[52]许文彬,币值调整的宏观经济环境探析--2005年的中国和1985年的日本是否具有可比性?[J],国际金融研究,2005年11期
[53][日]河合正弘,日本汇率政策对人民币的经验与教训[J],国际金融研究,2004年10期
[54]肖崎,日本泡沫经济制度性原因分析及启示[J],现代日本经济,2006年第1期
[55]吕江林,李明生,石劲,人民币升值对中国股市影响的实证分析[J],金融研究,2007年第6期
[56]刘春航,张新,“繁华预期”、流动性变化和资产价格[J],金融研究,2007年第6期
[57]陈然方,论汇率和股价的相互作用与影响[J],财经理论与实践,1999年第2期
[58]姚星垣,我国汇率与资产价格传导机制探讨[J],浙江金融,2001年01期
[59]仲大军,我国房地产资产升值和价格上涨的外部性[J],新远见,2006年06期
[60]奥利维尔·布兰查德、斯坦利·费舍尔,1998《宏观经济学(高级教程)》(1989年版),刘树成、沈利生等译,经济科学出版社
[61]刘铁军,屠梅曾,房地产、游资冲击与人民币汇率稳定[J],经济理论与经济管理,2005年第7期
[62]全毅,郑风华,刘晓丹,人民币“汇改”对境外资本流动的影响及对策[J],福建金融,2007年第10期
[63]朱圣春,人民币升值对房地产业的影响分析[J],特区经济,2005年第6期
[64]王仁涛,张维然,人民币升值对我国房地产市场的影响[J],经济论坛,2005年08期
[65]杜亚敏,韩立达,人民币升值对我国房地产市场的影响及对策[J],天津市经理学院学报,2007年8月第4期
[66]杨帆,李勇,人民币升值对中国经济影响问题探讨[J],新金融,2005年第1期
[67]郑华,人民币升值与房地产市场[J],房地产金融,2004年第6期
[68]易宪荣,房地产对国内金融业的依赖与影响[J],现代商业银行,2005第4期
[69]袁志刚,樊潇彦,房地产市场理性泡沫分析[J],经济研究,2003年第3期
[70]张松峰,日本房地产泡沫的经济史鉴[J],宏观经济管理,2005年第6期
[71]邵谦谦,王洪,日本房地产泡沫的成因分析及对我国的经验借鉴[J],中国房地产金融,2003年第5期
[72]新帕尔格雷夫经济学大词典(1992)
[73]曹红辉,王琛,东亚的汇率制度选择与人民币战略[J],经济研究参考,2007年第46期
[74]逄锦聚 等编著,韩国经济宏观调控[M],北京:东方出版社,1995年6月
[75]股市泡沫的海外比较研究,兴业基金管理有限公司,2007年10月
[76]陈佳贵主编,经济蓝皮书:2008年中国经济形势分析与预测[M],北京:社会科学文献出版社,2007年12月
[77]王洛林,李向阳主编,世界经济黄皮书:2006-2007年世界经济形势分析与预测,北京:社会科学文献出版社,2007年1月
[78]庄序莹,谈韩国政府对经济的干预[J],现代财经,1994年第4期
[79]薛东舟,韩国、台湾对外资银行的监管及给我们的启示,福建金融管理干部学院学报,1996年第3期
[80]杨金梅,李晔,韩国外汇市场干预经验与启示[J],中国外汇,2007年6月
[81]常清,中国股市不会重蹈日本覆辙[J],新财经,2007年7月
[82]王小敏,王兴化,台湾泡沫经济的形成、发展和控制初析[J],台湾研究,1998年第3期
[83]李非,台湾“泡沫经济”的形成与崩溃[J],亚太经济,1995年第4期
[84][日]三木谷良一,日本泡沫经济的产生、崩溃与金融改革[J],金融研究,1998年第6期
[85]张绍岩,泡沫还是金屑?--重新审视20世纪80年代日元升值对日本泡沫经济的影响[J],深交所,2006年6月
[86]方悦平,从国际经验看汇率调整对资产价格的影响[J],中国外汇,2007年10期
[87]朱磊,解析台湾资产价格的三次泡沫[J],两岸关系,2007年10期
[88]贝多广,朱晓莉,试析人民币对外升值与对内贬值并存[J],经济研究,2007年42卷9期
[89]徐慧贤,资产价格的波动与货币政策[J],生产力研究,2007年5期
[90]刘雄辉,加息对股票市场的影响安究竟有多大[J],当代经济,2007年10S期
[91]李宗怡,货币政策如何应对房地产泡沫--中日比较分析[J],财经理论与实践,2007年28卷5期
[92]李(摘),央行不应该挤破资产泡沫[J],资料通讯,2007年9期
[93]田风(摘),国际资本流动与资产价格泡沫[J],经济研究参考,2007年54期
[94]陆志明,国际热钱“热炒”新兴市场的资产价格[J],经济导报,2007年38期
[95]罗忠洲,流动性、物价稳定与资产价格上涨--从理论模型看日本的经验教训[J],证券市场导报,2007年9期
[96]林志忠,资产价格泡沫与虚拟经济发展及影响分析[J],证券市场导报,2007年9期
[97]刘红娟,崔楠楠,我国当前资产价格形势与政策分析[J],粤港澳市场与价格,2007年9期
[98)范建军,关于流动性过剩与资产价格泡沫的三个争论[J],中国金融,2007年18期
[99]魏杰,如何面对价格的全面上涨?[J],理论动态,2007年24期
[100]钱小安,流动性过剩与货币调控[J],金融研究,2007年08A期
[101]张春田,马骥,徐娜,人民币升值背景下的资产价格泡沫及宏观调控措施[J],经济纵横,2007年7期
[102]寒山,人民币升值之路还要持续多久?[J],经济导报,2007年30期
[103]唐双宁,关于解决流动性过剩问题的初步思考[J],经济研究,2007年42卷9期
[104]夏斌,陈道富,2007:中国流动性报告,国务院发展研究中心金融研究所
[105]邓琳琳,中日货币升值压力产生原因比较与经验借鉴[J],集团经济研究,2007年09Z期
[106]沈丹红,寿志敏,人民币升值对我国出口贸易结构的影响[J],商场现代化,2007年10Z期
[107]韩螈,人民币升值对宏观经济的冲击效应分析[J],中央财经大学学报,2007年7期
[108]李琳,简述人民币升值对中国经济的综合影响[J],集团经济研究,2007年07Z期
[109]刘成璧,人民币升值有望调整产业结构[J],中国改革,2007年8期
[110]程英,人民币升值与我国经济结构调整研究[J],特区经济,2007年6期
[111]王海龙,宋建江,胡国,人民币升值压力、货币失衡与资产价格波动[J],金融研究,2007年04B期
[112]关树,人民币参考一篮子货币趋势分析与预测[J],哈尔滨理工大学学报,2006年11卷5期
[113]吕剑,二元经济结构、实际汇率错位及其对进出口贸易影响的实证分析[J],金融研究,2007年09A期
[114]马德伦,中央银行宏观调控需要关注和研究的几个问题[J],金融研究,2007年08B期
[115]张谊浩,裴平,方先明,中国的短期国际资本流入及其动机--基于利率、汇率和价格三重套利模型的实证研究[J],国际金融研究,2007年9期
[116]居励,汇率变动对工资和就业结构影响的实证分析[J],世界经济研究,2007年9期
[117]徐震字,潘沁,中国资本流入负效应的实证研究与资本逆转的防范[J],国际金融研究,2007年9期
[118]周茂荣,苗迎春,人民币汇率争端与中美经贸摩擦[J],国际问题研究,2007年5期
[119]谢国忠,2008:中国的资产价格调整[J],国际经济评论,2008年1期
[120]王虎,索彦峰,货币政策的资产价格传导机制:一个文献评述[J],现代管理科学,2008年第3期
[121]邵川,紧缩货币政策下的工具选择[J],武汉金融,2008年第3期
[122]胡建国,浅析资产价格波动与央行货币政策的选择[J],四川经济管理学院学报,2008年第1期
[123]晁辉,王文胜,人民币汇率与资产价格的相关分析[J],经济研究导刊,2008年第9期
[124]陶川,人民币升值预期、资产升值预期与热钱流入[J],南方金融,2008年第7期
[125]黄燕芬,杨欣波,通货膨胀与资产价格上涨对中国社会的影响[J],河北学刊,2008年1月
[126]袁跃东,透视从紧的货币政策[J],世界知识,2008年第3期
[127]冯彩,我国短期国际资本流动的影响因素[J],财经科学,2008年6月
[128)贾健,李海平,徐展峰,资产价格波动与货币政策调整问题研究[J],南方金融,2008年第5期
[1]Abdalla, S. A. and V. Murinde, Exchange Rate and Stock Price Interactions in Emerging Markets: Evidence on Indin, Korea, Pakistan and Philippines, Applied Financial Economics, 1997,7: 25-35.
[2]Abdourahmane Sarr and Tonny Lybek, Measuring Liquidity in Financial Markets, IMF Working Paper, December 2002.
[3]Adrian Cooper, The impact of interest rates and the housing market on the UK economy. Economic outlook, 2004.
[4]Agarwal, V.B. and Phillips,R.A. Mortgage Rate Buy- Downs: Implications for Housing Price Indexes. Social Science Quarterly, 65,868- 875.1984.
[5]Aggarwal, R. Exchange Rates and Stock Prices: A Study of the US Capital Markets Under Floating Exchange Rates, Akron Business and Economic Review, Fall 1981.
[6]Aggarwal, R. and Schirm, D. C., Balance of Trade Announcements and Asset Prices: Influence on Equity Prices, Exchange Rates and Interest Rates, Journal of International Money and Finance,1992.
[7]Ajayi, R. A. and Mougoue, M., On the Dynamic Relation between Stock Prices and Exchange Rates, The Journal of Financial Research, XIX(2), 1996, Summer: 193-207.
[8]Alchian, A.A. and Klein, B., On a Correct Measure of Inflation, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, (1973)5(1), February, Part1. pp173-191.
[9]Allen F. and Gale D., Bubbles and Crises, the Economic Journal, (2000)110, pp236-255.
[10]Arcelus,F. and A.Meltzer..The Markets for Housing and Housing Services. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 1973(5), pp78- 99.
[11]Arndt, H.W., The Concept of Liquidity in International Monetary Theory, The Review of Economic Studies, Vol.15, No.1(1947-1948), pp.20-26.
[12]Baba, Naohiko and Takamasa Hisada, Japan's financial system: its perspective and the authorities' roles in redesigning and administering the system, Monetary and Economic Studies, (2002)20 (2), Institute for Monetary and Economic Studies, Bank of Japan, pp 43-93.
[13]Bahmani-Oskooee, Mohsen; Sohrabian, Ahmad. Stock prices and the effective exchange rate of the dollar. Applied Economics, Apr92, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p459, 6p, 6 charts
[14]Baks Klaas and Charles Kramer, Global Liquidity and Asset Prices: measurement, Implications, and Spillovers, IMF working paper, 1999,168.
[15]Bartov, E. and Bodnar,G., Firm valuation, earnings expectations and the exchange rate effet, Journal of Finance 1994,49, p1755-1785
[16]Bartov,E., Bodnar,G. and Kaul,A., Exchange rate variability and the riskibess of US multinational firms: Evidence from the breakdowns of the Bretton Woods system, Journal of Financial Economics, 1996.42, p105-132
[17]Ben Bernanke and Mark Gertler, Should Central Banks Respond to Movements in Asset Prices? American Economics Reviews, May 2001
[18]Ben Bernanke and Mark Gertler, Monetary policy and asset price volatility, Achieving Price Stability, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, 1999, pp 77-128.
[19]Ben Bernanke, Mark Gertler and Simon Gilchrist, The financial accelerator and the flight to quality, Review of Economics and Statistics, (1996)78 (1), pp 1-15.
[20]Benjamin Friedman, Monetary Policy, NBER Working Paper, December2000. [21]Blanchard, Oliver J and Mark Watson, Bubbles, rational expectations and financial markets, Crises in the economic and financial structure, Lexington: Lexington Books, 1982,pp 295-315.
[22]Bodnar,G., Gentry,W., Exchange rate exposure and industry characteristics, evidence from Canada, Japan and the US, Journal of International Money and Finance 1993,12, p29-45
[23]Bodart, V. and Reding, P., Exchange rate variability and the riskiness of US multinational firm: evidence from Canada, Japan and the US, Journal of International Money and Finance 1999,18, pl33-151
[24]Borio, C., Kennedy, N. and Prowse, S.D., Exploring Aggregate Asset Price Fluctuations across Countries, BIS Economic Papers 40, April1994, 89p.
[25]Borio Claudio, Craig Furfine and Philip Lowe, Procyclicality of the financial system and financial stability: issues and policy options, BIS Papers, (2001)no 1, pp 1-57.
[26]Calvo, G.A., Leiderman, L. and Reinhart, C.M., Capital Inflow and Real Exchange Rate Appreciation in Latin America: the Role of External Factors, IMF Staff Paper 40(1), 1993, pp.108-151.
[27]Caprio Gerard and Patrick Honoha, Excess Liquidity and Monetary Overhangs, the World Bank working paper, October1991, WPS796.
[28]Chari, V.V. and Kehoe, P.J., Hot Money, Journal of Political Economy, 6, 2003, pp. 1262-1292.
[29]Chow, E. H,W. Y. Yang and T. S. Wang., Stock Return and Exchange Rate Risk: Evidence from Asian Stock Markets Based on a Bivariate GARCH Model, International Journal of Business, (2000)5(2) : 972117.
[30]Dongchul Cho, Interest Rate, Inflation, and Housing Price: With an Emphasis on Chonsei Price in Korea[R] .presented at the fifteenth NBER East Asian Seminar on Economics at Tokyo in May 2004.
[31]Edison, H. and Reinhart, C.M., Stopping Hot Money, Journal of Development Economics, 66, 2001, pp.533-553.
[32]Edwards, S., Capital Flows, Real Exchange Rates and Capital Controls: Some Latin American Experiences, Cambridge Working Paper 6800. Cambridge, Mass: NBER, November, 1998.
[33]Eichenbaum, M. and Evans, C.L., Some Empirical on the Effects of Shocks to Monetary Policy on Exchange Rate, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1995, 443, pp.975-1009.
[34]Filardo, Andrew J., Asset Prices and Monetary Policy, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Economic Review, (2000)3nd Quarter.
[35]Franck, Peter and Young, Allan. Stock Price Reaction Of Multinational Firms To Exchange Ralignments. Financial Management (1972), Winter72, Vol. 1 Issue 3, p66-73, 8p, 3 charts.
[36]Friedman M., Money and the Stock Market, Journal of Political Economy, (1988)96(2), pp221-245.
[37]Garber, Peter M, Famous first bubbles: the fundamentals of early mania, Cambridge: The MIT Press (2000).
[38]Goodhart, C, Time, Inflation and Asset Prices, Paper presented at conference on "The Measurement of Inflation" organized by the Office of National Statistics and Eurostat at the University of Wales, Cardiff, August 30,1999.
[39]Goodman, J.L., Interest Rates and Housing Demand 1993 -1995: Common Sense versus Econometrics, Paper presented at the Mid- year AREUEA Meeting of 1995.
[40]Gouteron, Sylvain and Daniel Szpiro, Excess Monetary Liquidity and Asset Prices, Bank of France, Preliminary version, 3June 2005.
[41]Granger, C. W. ,BwonNung Huang, Chin Wei Yang, A Birvariate Causality Between Stock Prices and Exchange Rates : Evindence from Recent Asian Flu", The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 2000, (40).
[42]Greenspan,Alan,Opening remarks:achieving price stability,at a symposium sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City,Jackson Hole,Wyoming.(1996)
[43]Gurley,John G.,Excess Liquidity and Europe an Monetary Reforms,1944-1952,American Economic Review,Vol.43,No.1.(Mar,1953),pp76-100.
[44]Harris,J.,The effect of Real Rates of Interest on Housing Prices.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,1989.2,p47-60.
[45]Harald Hau and Hélène Rey,Exchange Rates,Equity Prices,and Capital Flows,Review of Financial Studies,Spring2006,Vol.19 Issue 1,p273-317,45p
[46]Haruhiko Kurod,The "Nixon Shock" and the "Plaza Agreement":Lessons from Two Seemingly Failed Cases of Japan Exchange Rate Policy,China & World Economy 3-1,Vo112,No 1,2004
[47]Ibrahim,M.H.,Co-integration and Granger Causality Tests of Stock Price and Exchange Rate Interactions in Malaysia,Asian Economic Bulletin,2000,17(1),pp.36-47
[48]Ito,T.and lwaisako,T..Explaining asset bubbles in Japan.Bank of,Japan Monetary and Ecomomic Studies,(1996) 14(1),p 143-193
[49]Jodon,Philippe.,The exchange-rate exposure of U.S.multinationals.Journal of Business,Jul90,Vol.63 Issue 3,p331,15p,5 charts,1 graph
[50]Jodon,Philippe.,The Pricing of Exchange Rate Risk in the Stock Market.Journal of,Financial & Quantitative Analysis,Sep91,Vol.26 Issue 3,p363,14p Jodon,P.,The exchange rate exposure of US multinationals,Journal of Business,1990,63,p331-345
[51]Joseph,N.L.,Modeling the impacts of interest rate and exchange rate change on UK stock returns,Derivatives Use,Trading and Regulation,2002,7,p306-323
[52]Kaminsky,G.L.and Reinhart,C.M.,Financial crises in Asia and Latin America:then and now,American Economic Review,1998,88,pp.444-449.
[53]Kau,James B.,and Donald C.Keenan.1980.The theory of housing and interest rates.Journal of financial and quantitative analysis,volume XV,No.4,November,833- 847.
[54]Kenny,G.Modelling the Demand and Supply Sides of the Housing Market:Evidence from Ireland.Economic Modeling,1999(16),389- 409.
[55]Kim,Ki-ho.Dollar exchange rate and stock price:evidence from multivariate cointegration and error correction model.Review of Financial Economics,Fall,2003, Vol. 12 Issue 3, p301,13p
[56]Kindleberger, Charles P, Asset inflation and monetary policy, BNL Quarterly Review, (1995)no 192, pp 17-37.
[57]Klaas Baks and Charles Kramer, Global Liquidity and Asset Prices: Mearurement, Implications, and Spillovers, IMF Working Paper, December1999.
[58]Kouri P.J.K., The Exchange Rate and the Balance of Payments in the Short Run and in the Long Run: A Monetary Approach, Scand.J.Econ., No.2,1976,78, 208-304
[59]Kumhof, M., Sterilization of Short-Term Capital Inflows through Lower Interest Rates, Journal of International Money and Finance, 2004,23, pp.1209-1221.
[60]Kunio Okina, Masaaki Shirakawa and Shigenori shiratsuka, The Asset Price Bubble and Monetary Policy: Japan's Experience in the Late 1980s and the Lessons, Monetary and Economic Studies (Special Edition) 2001.2
[61]Lei Vivian, Charles Noussair and Charles Plott, Asset Bubbles and Rationality: Addtional Evidence From Capital Gains Tax Experiments, California Institute of Technology, Social Science working paper, 2002.
[62]Lewis, K.K., Are Foreign Exchange Intervention and Monetary Policy Related, and Does it really matter? Journal of Business, 1995, 68, pp.185-214.
[63]Louis Kuijs, Investment and Saving in China, Research working Paper, World Bank Beijing Office, May2005.
[64]Ma, Christopher K. and Kao, G. W., Exchange Rate Changes And Stock Price Reactions. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Summerl990, Vol. 17 Issue 3, pp441-449.
[65]Magnus Saxegaard, Excess Liquidity and Effectiveness of Monetary Policy: Evidence from Sub-saharan Africa. IMF Working Paper, May2006.
[66]Market Liquidity: Research Findings and Selected Policy Implications, Committee on the Global Financial System of the Central Banks of the Group of Ten Countries, Bank for International Settlements, Mayl999.
[67]Marshall, D., Inflation and Asset Returns in a Monetary Economy, Journal of Finance, 1992, Vol.47, No.4, pp.1315-1342.
[68]Mieno Yasushi, The conduct of monetary policy by the Bank of Japan, Bank of Japan Quarterly Bulletin, (1994)2 (3), Bank of Japan, pp 5-12.
[69]Mookerjee, R., Monetary Policy and the Informational Efficiency of the Stock Market: The Evidence from Many Countries, Applied Economics, 1987,19(11), pp.1521-1532.
[70]Nagahata Takashi and Toshitaka Sekine,The effects of monetary policy on firm investment after the collapse of the asset price bubble:an investigation using
[71]Japanese micro data,Research and Statistics Department Working Paper,(2002)02-3,Bank of Japan.
[72]Nan-Kuang Chen.Asset price fluctuations in Taiwan:Evidence from stock and real estate prices 1973 to 1992,Journal of Asian Economics,12(2001)pp215-232.
[73]Okina,Kunio and Shigenori Shiratsuka,Asset price bubbles,price stability and monetary policy:Japan's experience,Monetary and Economic Studies,(2002)20(3),Institute for Monetary and Economic Studies,Bank of Japan,pp 35-76.
[74]Oskooee,M.B.and Sohrabian,A.,Stock Prices and the Effective Exchange Rate of the Dollar,Applied Economics,1992,24,pp.459-464.
[75]Quan,Daniel C.and Titman Sheridan,Do Real Estate and Stock Prices Move Together? An International Analysis,Real Estate Economics,Summer1999.
[76]Rasmus Ruffer and Livio Stracca,What Is Global Excess Liquidity,and Does It Matter? ECB Working Paper Series,No.696,November2006.
[77]Robert E.and Lucas J.,Asset Prices in An Exchange Economy,Econometrica,Vol.46,No.6,November,1978.
[78]Rodrik,D.and Velasco,A.,Short-Term Capital Flows,NBER Working Paper No.7364,1999,pp.1-44.
[79]Roosa,Robert V.,Balance of Payments Adjustment and International Liquidity,The Journal of Finance,Vol.19,No.1(Mar,1964),pp1-15.
[80]Rudiger Dornbusch,Expectations and Exchange Rate Dynamics.Journal of Political Economy,Dec1976,Vol.84 Issue 6,pp1161-1176.
[81]Rudiger Dornbusch.and Stanley Fischer,Exchange rates and the Current Account,The American Economic Review,December,1980.
[82]Saito Makoto and Shigenori Shiratsuka,Financial crises as the failure of arbitrage:implications for monetary policy,Monetary and Economic Studies,(2001)19(S-1),Institute for Monetary and Economic Studies,Bank of Japan,pp239-270.
[83]Shibuya Hiroshi,Dynamic Equilibrium Price Index:Asset Price and Inflation,Bank of Japan Monetary and Economic Studies,Bank of Japan.1992,Vol.10(1),p995-109.
[84]Shimizu Tokiko and Shigenori Shiratsuka,The credit risk of Japanese banks during the bubble period:a pilot study of macro stress simulation,IMES Discussion Paper,2000-E-31,Institute for Monetary and Economic Studies,Bank of Japan.
[85]Smith, C.E., Stock Markets and the Exchange Rate: Multi-country Approach, Journal or Macroeconomics, 1992,14(4), pp607-629.
[86]Taylor, M. P. and I. Tonks., The Internationalization of Stock Markets and the Abolition of UK Exchange Control, Review of Economics and Statistics, 1989,71.