基于复杂性的产业集群研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
产业集群对于一个区域、一个国家乃至世界都是非常重要的。产业集群是推动地区经济发展的一种有效形式,在全球化的时代里依然普遍存在而又具有代表性。许多国家,包括中国,都得益于众多的产业集群。提高区域或国家的竞争优势,有必要对产业集群开展深入的研究。
     尽管对产业集群的研究已经持续了百多年,但绝大多数研究拘泥于传统福特主义的观点和方法论,未能透彻掌握产业集群这一复杂系统的精要。直到20世纪90年代,复杂性和复杂系统的研究成果促使学者们重新审视产业集群和其它地理积聚的现象。复杂性研究的复兴带来了产业集群研究的再次兴盛。相关文献表明:在产业集群复杂性的研究方面,到目前为止的研究依然处于初步阶段,或局限于框架式的研究,或局限于某个侧重面或个别案例的研究。本文创新地引入了产业集群复杂自适应系统的分形数学模型,辅以仿真模拟和博弈分析的方法研究了产业集群内部各层次的主体间的互动和联系——企业集群间、企业间以及个体间的竞争合作;阐述了产业集群复杂自适应系统和其它主要系统,如社会系统及其它产业集群间的相互关系和作用。
     本文研究工作主要从以下几个方面展开:
     1,)以复杂自适应系统为出发点,对产业集群进行详细、合理的划分,建立了一个具有多个层次和主体的CAS模型。以分形粒子的数学模型为基础,描述、解释产业集群内部各企业、各创新个体相互作用,如何开始形成集聚。利用这一模型推导出形成产业集聚的重要条件之一是:各企业、创新个体所生存的经济、地理环境差异越小越好。在后续的章节中证实了产业集群的社会网络能够减少这种差异。
     2,)剖析产业集群的内部市场是一个分形市场。产业集群内部市场的本质是投资市场、分形市场;产业集群的企业家或创新个体的本质是不同阶层的投资者。多样性是产业集群存在的现实基础。
     3,)在肯定集群内企业充分竞争的基础上,揭示了这些企业间存在合作和联盟。应用分形粒子模型模拟了集群内企业横向合作、联盟的形态。解释了这种合作、联盟的可能性基础是共同利益,实现保证是以亲情为主的社会约束。
     4,)案例数据说明,产业集群不仅仅是企业的地理集聚、资源的地理集聚,更是创新个体(人才)的集聚。分形粒子模型模拟了知识如何通过人才流动在集群内传播。解释了集群社会网络如何为集群内集聚的创新个体提供创新便利和激励,如何在保证多样性的前提下减少企业和个体生存的环境差异。
     5,)从系统的角度分析、阐述产业集群这一自适应复杂系统是如何与其它相关系统进行互动的。从所在社会系统角度分析产业集群潜在的体系缺陷和系统冲突;阐述中国产业集群健康发展的主要障碍——政府作为的不当与不足。还探讨了同产业、不同产业集群间合作联盟的可能性。
     本文主要的创新性点主要有:
     (1)建立了一个多层次的产业集群分形结构模型,其中的创新个体是最基本的分形体。引入一个描述对称性产业集群的分形数学模型。从理论上证明了完全竞争条件下仍有可能形成产业和企业的集聚;解释了主体环境的差异是如何影响企业的积聚行为的。(2)将产业集群内的企业家、创新个体的经营、创造行为视为投资行为,揭示产业集群内
     部市场是一个以多样性为基础的分形市场。这有助于解释集群内充分竞争基础上存在的合作和联盟。
     (3)以系统的方法来研究产业集群与其所依存的社会系统间的关系,阐述潜在的系统缺陷和冲突。为集群政策的研究和制定提供了新的视角。
Industrial clusters are very important for an area, a country and even for the world. Industrial clustering is an efficient way to develop area economy. It is still popular and typical in current globalization stage. Many countries, including China, get more benefits from industrial clusters. To improve countries’competitive advantage, study industrial clusters more is still necessary and useful.
     Even industrial clusters have been studied more than 100 years, most of them are based on conventional Fordism methods, and miss to get all the key points of this complex system. Till to 1990’s, the progress on the studies of complexity and complex system supplied researchers very useful hypothesis and method to re-study the industrial clusters and other geographic gathering phenomena. The renaissance of study on complexity booms the re-study on industrial clusters. The literature review shows: the studies on industrial cluster complexity is still at the beginning stage. Some of them focused on the outline; others just focused on special topics or case studies. This paper firstly introduced the mathematic fractal model to simulate the symmetric industrial cluster as a complex adaptive system (CAS). With computer simulation and game analysis, the relationships and the cooperation-competition modes of the agents, which are enterprise clusters, enterprise and innovation agent at different levels, were studied. The relationship and reaction between industrial cluster CAS and other key systems, such as its community system and other industrial clusters, also was discussed.
     This paper covers following studies:
     1,) With CAS hypothesis, industrial cluster was dissect to a structure with different levels and agents. A mathematic fractal model was introduced to simulate and explain how the agents act and react; and how the gathering starts. With this model, the necessary condition for clustering was predicted as less environment difference among the enterprises. It was confirmed that industrial clusters could reduce the difference with its community network in the followed chapters.
     2,) Analysis on the cluster internal markets showed they were fractal markets. These fractal markets are indeed investment markets. The enterprisers and innovation agents are investors in different levels. Diversity is the fatal foundation for clusters and their internal markets.
     3,) Confirmed the completive competition among the enterprises, paper discussed the cooperation and alliance. Fractal grains model was introduced to simulate the cooperation and alliance. The possibility of cooperation and alliance is from agents common interests. The realization is ensured by the community restriction which is based on consanguinity and friendship.
     4,) Case study data showed that industrial clusters are not only the enterprises gathering and resource gathering, but also innovation agents gathering at the same area. Another fractal model was introduced to simulate how knowledge diffuses in enterprises arrays by agents moving. The paper explained how the cluster community networks benefit innovation, remove the difference barriers for agents as well as keeps the diversity.
     5,) From system views, this paper discussed how this CAS, industrial cluster, reacts to other relevant systems. The risks of cluster defects and conflicts to community system were analysed. It explained the main issues for clusters improvement in China– too much control or un-suitable controlee from local governments. The possibility of cooperation and alliance between different clusters which belong to same industry was also discussed.
     The main innovations in this paper are as following:
     1,) Industrial clusters were modeled as different levels and agents. The capitalized innovation agents in a cluster are regarded as basic fractals. A mathematic fractal model was introduced to simulate and explain symmetric clusters. The model shows the possibility that a cluster may form even under the full-competitive conditions. It explained how cluster environment affects the enterprises behavior contribution on clustering.
     2,) Regarded the enterprisers and innovators as investors, the cluster internal markets perform as a fractal investment market. It helps to explain the cooperation and alliance based on completive competition.
     3,) Analysed the structures and relationships of clusters and their community systems; explained the potential cluster system defects and conflicts between two systems. It provides new points for studying and making cluster policies.
引文
[1] Ahedo, M. Cluster policy in the Basque country (1991-2002): Constructing 'industry-government' collaboration through cluster-associations. EUROPEAN PLANNING STUDIES. 2004. Dec.
    [2] Ahokangas, P., Hyry, M. and R?s?nen, P., 1999,“Small technology-based firms in fast-growing regional cluster”, New England Journal of Entrepreneurship: vol.2, pp.19-26.
    [3] Alberto Quadrio Curzio and Marco Fortis. Comlexity and Industrial Cluster– Dynamics and Models in Theory and Practice. New York: Physica-Verl., 2002.
    [4] Alan M. Rugman , & Alain Verbeke. Multinational Enterprises and Clusters : An Organizing Framework[ R] . Working Paper , 2003.
    [5] Andersen E. S., 1994, Evolutionary economics: post Schumpeterian contributions, London, Pinter.
    [6] Anderson ,Forsgren ,and Holm1 The Strategic Impact of External Network : Subsidiary Performance And Compentency Development In the Multinational Corporation[J ] . Strategic Management Journal , 2002 , 23 (1) .
    [7] AnnaLee Saxenian,Jinn-Yuh Hsu ;The Silicon Valley-Hsinchu Connection:Technical Communities and Industrial Upgrading. Industrial and Corporate Change, 2001
    [8] Anthony J Venables. Cities and Trade: External Trade and Internal Geography in Developing Economies [J]. NBER, Working Paper, 2000.
    [9] AR Anderson, CJ Miller.“Class matters”: human and social capital in the entrepreneurial process [J]. Journal of Socio-Economics, 2003
    [10]Audretsch, D.B. and M.P.Feldman , 1996, "R&D Spillovers and the Geography of Innovation and Production", American Economic Review 86, No 3, pp. 630-640
    [11]Baldwin, R. E. and R. Forslid (2000)“The Core-Periphery Model and Endogenous Growth”, Economica 67, pp 307-324
    [12]BA Lundvall. National Systems of Innovation: Towards a Theory of Innovation and Interactive Learning. London, New York, 1992
    [13]Baptista, R. and Swann P., 1998,“Do firms in clusters innovate more?”,Research Policy, 27:525—540.
    [14]Becattini, Giacomo, 1991, "Italian Industrial Districts: Problems and Perspectives", International Studies of Mgt & Org, Vol.21, No.1, pp83-90.
    [15]Beaudry, Catherine and Swann, Peter, 2001,Growth in Industrial Clusters: A Bird’s Eye View of theUnited Kingdom, SIEPR Discussion Paper No. 00-38
    [16]Belleflamme, Paul, Picard, Pierre and Thisse, Jacques-Franáois, 2000,“An Economic Theory of Regional Clusters”, Journal of Urban Economics 48, 158-184.
    [17]Bent Dalum. The Formation of Knowledge based Clusters in North Jutland and Western Sweden [R] Working Paper to the DRUID Conference on National Innovation Systems, 1999.
    [18] Bent Delum,Christian Pedesen and Gert Villumsen. 2002. Technology Life Cycle:Regional Clusters Facing Disruption[R]. DRUID Working Paper No 02-10
    [19]Bergman Edward M, Edward J Feser. Industrial and Regional Clusters: Concepts and Comparative Applications [Z].2001.
    [20]Boekholt, Parties.“The public sector at arms length or in charge? Towards a typology of Cluster policies”. Paper for the OECD program National Innovation Systems, presented in Amerstdam, October 1997.
    [21]Bosworth, Brian and Daniel Broun.“Connect the Dots: Using Cluster-Based Strategies to Create Urban Employment”. Firm Connection 4(2): 1.6. 1996
    [22]Cantwell , John and Piscitello , Lucia. The Location of Technological Activities of MNCs in European Regions : The Role of Spillovers and Local Competencies[J ] . Journal of International Management , 2002 , 8 (1) .
    [23]Catherine Beaudry and Peter Swann. Growth in Industrial Cluster: a Bird’s Eye View of the United Kingdom [R]. SIEPRD icussion Paper, 2001. No 00-38.
    [24] C Crouch, P Le Galès, C Trigilia, H Voelzkow,“Local Production Systems in Europe: Rise Or Demise?”. - 2001
    [25] Chang, PL;Tsai, CT;Finding the niche position - competition strategy of Taiwan's IC design industry; TECHNOVATION 2001
    [26]Cindy Fan, C., Allen J Scott, 2003, Industrial agglomeration and development: A survey of spatial economic issues in East Asia and a statistical analysis of Chinese regions, Economic Geography, vol.79,Iss.3
    [27]Danny, Quah, 2001,“Demand-driven Knowledge Cluster in a Weightless Economy”. Working Paper.
    [28]David Keeble; Frank Wilkinson.“Collective Learning and Knowledge Development in the Evolution of Regional Clusters of High Technology SMEs in Europe”. Regional Studies, Volume 33, Issue 4 June 1999 , pages 295 - 303
    [29]Dixit A.K. and J.E. Stiglitz, 1977,“Monopolistic competition and optimum product diversity”, American Economic Review 67, 297-308.
    [30]Doeringer, P.B, and D.G. Terkla.“Business strategy and cross– industry cluster”. Economic Development Quarterly 9:225-37. 1995
    [31]Donald J., 2001,“Opening Speech at the World Congress on Local Clusters”, OECD, Paris, Jan., 24.
    [32]Dunning , J . 1Location and Multinational Enterprise , A Neglected Factor[J ] . Journal of International Business Studies , 1998 ,29 : (1) .
    [33]F Black, MC Jensen, M Scholes, The Capital Asset Pricing Model: Some Empirical Tests [J]. Studies in the Theory of Capital Markets, 1972
    [34]Fotopoulos, Georgios, and Spence, Nigel, 2001,“Regional variations of firm births, deaths and growth patterns in the UK, 1980-1991”, Growth and Change vol. 32, spring.
    [35]Fujita, M., and Thisse, J. F., 1996,“Economics of agglomeration”, J. Jpn. Int. Econ. 10, 339–378.
    [36]Fujita M. and J.F. Thisse (2001) "Does Geographical Agglomeration Foster Economic Growth? And Who gains and Looses from It?" mimeo
    [37]Fujita, M., Krugman, P. and A. J. Venables, 1999, the Spatial Economy, MIT Press
    [38]Giovana, Ceglie and Dini, Marco, 1999,“Small Enterprises Cluster and Network Development in Developing Countries: The Experience of UNIDO”, Issues Paper of UNIDO.
    [39]Glasmeier, Amy K., and Bennett Harrison.“Response: Why Business Alone Won’t Redevelop the Inner City: A Friendly Critique of Michael Porter’s Approach to Urban Revitalization”. Economic Development Quarterly 11(1):28-38. 1997.
    [40]Guerrieri,Paolo and Pietrobelli, Carlo,2001,Models of Industrial Districts’Evolution and Changes in Technological Règimes,Paper Prepared for the DRUID Summer Conference
    [41]GMP Swann, M Prevezer.“The Dynamics of Industrial Clustering: International Comparisons in Computing and Biotechnology”. DK Stout - 1998 - Oxford University Press
    [42]Held, J.R.“Clusters as an Economic Development Tool: Beyond the Pitfalls”. Economic Development Quarterly 10:249-61. 1996.
    [43]Helpman, E., 1981,“International trade in the presence of product differentiation, economies of scale and monopolistic competition”, Journal of International Economics 11:30540.
    [44]Helpman, E., and Krugman, P., 1985, Market structure and foreign trade: Increasing returns, imperfect competition and the international economy, London: MIT Press.
    [45]Henderson, J. V. (1986). Efficiency of resource usage and city size. Journal of Urban Economics, 19(1), pp.47-70.
    [46]Henderson, J. V.,Zmarak Shalizi, and Anthony, J. Venables, 2001“Geography and Development”, NBER, Working Paper.
    [47]Henry G Overman, Stephen Redding, and Anthony Je Venables. The Economic Geography of Trade, Production and Income: A Survey of Empirics [R] NBER, Working Paper, 2000.
    [48]Holmes, Thomas J., 1999,“How Industries Migrate When Agglomeration Economies Are Important”, Journal of Urban Economics: 45, 240–263.
    [49]Jacobs, Dany and Ard- Pieter De Man.“Cluster, Industrial Policy and Firm Strategy: A menu Approach”. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 8(4):425-437. 1998.
    [50]Jacobs, Dany and Mark W. De Jong.“Industrial Clusters and the Competitiveness of the Netherlands.”De Economist 140: 233-52. 1992
    [51]J Bair, G Gereffi. Local Clusters in Global Chains: The Causes and Consequences of Export Dynamism in Torreon's Blue [J]. World Development, 2001
    [52]J Henrich, R Boyd, S Bowles, C Camerer, E Fehr, H. Cooperation, reciprocity and punishment in fifteen small-scale societies [J]. American Economic Review, 2001
    [53]J Simmie, J Sennett.“Innovative clusters: global or local linkages?”- National Institute Economic Review, 1999
    [54]JS Coleman. Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital [J]. American Journal of Sociology, 1988
    [55]J. Vernon Henderson, Zmarak Shalizi, and Anthony J. Venables. Geography and Development [R] NBER, Working Paper, 2001.
    [56]Julian Birkinshaw. Characteristics of Foreign Subsidiaries in Industry Clusters[J ] . Journal of International Business Studies , 2000 , (3) .
    [57]Kaldor, N. 1978,“The case for regional policies”, In Further essays on economic theory, 139-54.London: Duckworth.
    [58]Kanemoto, Yoshitsugu; Ohkawara, Toru; and Suzuki, Tsutomu, 1996,“Agglomeration Economies and a Test for Optimal City Sizes in Japan”, Journal of The Japanese and International Economies 10, 379–398
    [59] Kjell Hausken ,Cooperation and between-group competition Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,Vol. 42 (2000) 417–425
    [60]Knorringa, Peter, 1999, "Agra: An Old Cluster Facing the New Competition", World Development, Vol, 27.No, 9 pp1587-1604.
    [61]Koopmans T.C., 1957, Three Essays on the State of Economic Science, New York, McGraw-Hill.
    [62]Krugman, P. 1979.,“Increasing returns, monopolistic competition and international trade”, Journal of International Economics 9:46979.
    [63]Krugman, P., and A.J.Venables, 1990,“Integration and the competitiveness of peripheral industry”, In Unity with diversity in the European Community, ed. C. Bliss and J. Braga de Macedo, 56-75, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    [64]Krugman, P. and A.J.Venables, 1995, "Globalization and the Inequality of Nations", Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(4), pp 857-880.
    [65]Leo van den Berg, Erik Braun and Willem van Winden,2001, Growth Clusters in European Cities: An Integral Approach, Urban Studies, Vol. 38, No. 1, 185–205, 2001
    [66]Lissoni, F. (2001). Knowledge codification and the geography of innovation: The case of Brescia mechanical cluster. Research Policy, 30, 1479-1500.
    [67]Markusen, A. 1993.“Trade as a regional development issue: Policies for job and community preservation”, In Trading industries, trading regions, ed. H., Noponen, J. Graham, and A. Markusen, 285-302. London: Guilford Press.
    [68]Martin, P. and G. Ottaviano, 2001,“Growth and Agglomeration”, International Economic Review 42, No 4, pp 947-968
    [69]Martin Bell and Michael Albu, 1999,“Knowledge Systems and Technological Dynamism in Industrial Clusters in Developing Countries”, World Development Vol. 27, No. 9, pp. 1715-1734.
    [70]Martin, Ron and Sunley, Peter, 1996,“Paul Krugman's geographical economics and its implications for regional development theory: A critical assessment”, Economic Geography v72n3: 259-292
    [71]MP Feldman, JL Francis. Homegrown Solutions: Fostering Cluster Formation [J]. Economic Development Quarterly, 2004
    [72]MP Feldman, JL Francis. Fortune Favours the Prepared Region: The Case of Entrepreneurship and the Capitol Region [J]. European Planning Studies, 2003
    [73]New information and communication technologies and local clustering of firms: A case study of the Xingwang Industrial Park in Beijing/URBAN GEOGRAPHY
    [74]North, Douglass C., 1981, Structure and Change in Economic History, W. W. Norton& Company, Inc., New York.
    [75]OECD. Boosting Innovation: The Cluster Approach [Z]. Paris: OECD, 1999
    [76]Overman, Henry G., Stephen Redding and Anthony J. Venables, 2001,“The Economic Geography of Trade, Production, and Income: A Survey of Empirics”,Working Paper.
    [77]Peters, E .“Fractal structure in the capital market”, Financial Analysis Journal, July/August, 1989
    [78]Phelps, N. 1992,“External economies, agglomeration and flexible accumulation”, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers: 17(1):35-46.
    [79]Pimden Hertog, Edward M Bergman, David Charles. Creating and Sustaining Innovative Clusters: Towards a Synthesis [Z]. 2000.
    [80]Poter, M. E., 1998,“Clusters and new economics competition”, Harvard Business Review, No.11.
    [81]Porter, E Michael.“New Strategies for Inner- City Economic Development”. Economic Development Quarterly 11(1):11-27.
    [82]Porter, E Michael. Location, Competition, and Economic Development: Local Clusters in a Global Economy”- Economic Development Quarterly, 2000
    [83]Pouder, R. and St. John, C., 1996,“Hot spots and blind spots: Geographical clusters of firms and innovation”, Academy of Management Review, vol.2, no.4, pp.1192-1196
    [84]P Swann, M Prevezer.”A comparison of the dynamics of industrial clustering in computing and biotechnology”, Research Policy, 1996
    [85]Roelandt, T. and Hertog, P., 1999,“Boosting innovation: The cluster approach”, Paris: OECD, 1999。
    [86]Rosenfeld, Stuart A. Industrial Strength Strategies: Regional Business Clusters and Public Policy. Aspen Institute. 1995.
    [87]Rosenfeld Stuart A. Overachievers, Business Clusters that Work: Prospects for Regional Development [M]. Chapel Hill, NC: Regional Technology Strategies,1996.
    [88]Rosenfeld Stuart A. Bringing Business Clusters into the Mainstream of Economic Development [J]. European Planning Studies, 1997,5(1):3—23.
    [89]Ronald S.Burt. Structural Holes: The Social Structure of Competition. 1992
    [90]Rugman , A. M. 1Multinationals as Flagships Firms : Regional Business Network1[M] . Oxford : Oxford University Press ,2000.
    [91] Rui Baptista, Peter Swann. Do firms in clusters innovate more?[J], Research Policy27(1998) 525-540
    [92] Samuel Bowles and Herbert Gintis;Social Capital and Community Governance;December 22, 2000
    [93]S BRESCHI, F LISSONI. Knowledge Spillovers and Local Innovation Systems: A Critical Survey. Industrial and Corporate Change, 2001
    [94]Scott, A. J. and Storper, M, 1992a,“Regional development reconsidered”, In Regional development and contemporary industrial response: Extending flexible specialization, ed. H. Ernste and V. Meier, 1-24. London: Belhaven.
    [95]Simon, H. A., 1947,“Effects of increased productivity upon the ratio of urban to rural population”, Econometrica: 15, 31-42.
    [96] Sonobe, T;Hu, DH;Otsuka, K;《Process of cluster formation in China: A case study of a garment town》JOURNAL OF DEVELOPMENT STUDIES
    [97]Starrett D., 1978,“Market allocations of location choice in a model with free mobility”, Journal of Economic Theory: 17, 21-37.
    [98]Storper M. The Regional World : Territorial Development in a Global Economic[M] . The Guilford Press , 1997.
    [99]Thomas Andersson, Emily Hansson, Sylvia Schwaag-Serger and Jens S?rvik.The Cluster Policies Whitebook, IKED . August, 2004.。
    [100] Thomas Brenner. Simulating the Evolution of Localised Industrial Clusters-An Identification of the Basic Mechanisms. Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation, 2001
    [101] Thomson, R. (ed.), 1993, Learning and Technological Change, New York: St Mation's Press.
    [102] Tichy G,1997. Are today`s Clusters the Problem Areas of Tomorrow?, in Competemce Clusters [R],ED.M Steiner
    [103] TJA Roelandt, P den Hertog, U Dialogic. ? Cluster analysis and cluster-based policy making in OECD countries: introduction to the theme“Boosting Innovation: the Cluster Approach, 1999
    [104] UNCTAD, 1998,“Promoting and Sustaining SMEs Clusters and Networks for Development”, Commission on Enterprise Business Facilitation and Development, Geneva, 2-4, Sept.
    [105] Van Dijk, M.P., 1999,“Small Enterprise Clusters in Transition, A Proposed Typology and Possible Policies per Type Cluster”, Working Paper.
    [106] Venables, Anthony J., 2000,“Cities and Trade: External Trade and Internal Geography in Developing Economies”, NBER Working Paper.
    [107] Yang, Xiaokai and Shi, Heling, 1992,“specialization and product diversity”, American Economic Review,82, pp.392-398.
    [108] Young, Allen, 1928,“increasing Returns and Economic Progress”, Economic Journal 38: pp.537-40.
    [109] [美]安东尼奥·R.达马西奥著,《笛卡尔的错误:情绪、推理和人脑》,毛彩凤译,教育科学出版社2007年6月第一版
    [110]阿尔弗雷德·韦伯,1909:《工业区位论》,中译本,1997商务印书馆。
    [111]埃德加·胡佛,1990:《区域经济学导论》,商务印书馆。
    [112]安纳利·萨克森宁,1999:《地区优势:硅谷和128公路地区的文化与竞争》,上海远东出版社。
    [113]百濑惠夫,《中小企业互助组织的变革——二十个成功案例的启示》,北京大学出版社,2003。
    [114]保罗·克鲁格曼,2000:《地理和贸易》北京大学出版社。
    [115]蔡宁等:企业集群风险的研究:一个基于网络的视角[J],中国工业经济,2003年第4期,59-63
    [116]车维汉,2000:《论知识经济中企业经营模式和产业集聚的新变化》,《中国社会科学院研究生院学报》,第6期。
    [117]陈继祥等,企业竞争优势中的合作协同作用,企业经济,2000年第7期。
    [118]陈继祥,超竞争下的企业战略协同,上海交通大学学报(哲社版),2000年第4期。
    [119]陈迅,杨守鸿,赵三英.论技术战略联盟框架下的产业集群及竞争优势[J];经济纵横, 2005年第1期
    [120]陈云,王浣尘,杨继红,戴晓波.产业集群中的信息共享与合作创新研究[J].系统工程理论与实践, 2004
    [121]陈忠,金炜,章琪. 2002.复杂性的探索:系统科学与人文.合肥:安徽教育出版社
    [122]柴立和,杨战:复杂性科学的几大学派及其研究特点[J],现代物理知识, 2004
    [123]仇保兴,1999:《小企业集群研究》,复旦大学出版社。
    [124]仇保兴:入园企业的非集群化:科技园区发展的障碍[J],浙江经济,1998年第12期,43-45
    [125]戴菊贵,有效市场假说与分形市场假说之争;金融教学与研究
    [126]邓宏钟,谭跃进;多人混合博弈的仿真分析;管理科学学报,2002年8月Vol.5
    [127]冯薇,产业集群发展与风险资本投资,中央财经大学学报,2005年7期
    [128]盖文启,王缉慈,1999 :《论区域创新网络对我国高新技术中小企业发展的作用》,《中国软科学》,第9期。
    [129] H.钱纳里,《工业化和经济增长的比较研究》,三联,1995
    [130]胡皓,楼慧心,《自组织理论与社会发展研究》,上海科技教育出版社,2002。
    [131]胡艳曦,陈雪梅,2002 :《企业集群理论的发展及其意义》,《广东商学院学报》第1期。
    [132]黄文静,赵江明.企业家心智模式与企业集群成长的关联机理[J].经济论坛, 2005
    [133]惠宁;“社会资本与产业集群的互动研究”;西北大学学报(哲学社会科学版);2006年3月,第36卷第2期
    [134]杰伊·B.巴尼,1999:《从内部寻求竞争优势》,载坎贝尔等编,《核心能力战略:以核心竞争能力为基础的战略》,东北财经大学出版社。
    [135]剑锋,唐振鹏,2002:《国外产业集群研究》,《外国经济与管理》,第8期。
    [136]理查德·达夫特,1999:《组织理论与设计精要》,机械工业出版社。
    [137]李海刚,吴启迪.多Agent系统研究综述[J].同济大学学报:自然科学版, 2003
    [138]李新春.企业家协调与企业集群——对珠江三角洲专业镇企业集群化成长的分析[J].南开管理评论, 2002
    [139]李勇,史占中,屠梅曾.企业集群中的创新传播动力学研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2005
    [140]李永刚、祝青:浙江小企业群落式发展初探[J],财经论丛,2000(9),25-31
    [141]李永华,吴治国,石金涛,论产业集群生成机制中的人力资本要素,第23卷第6期深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版) Vol.23 No.6
    [142]李军民,张义宽;“一个分形生长的计算机模拟及其维数”;西安科技学院学报,2000年6月
    [143]李生校蔡芳芳;产业集群中的企业家间信任问题研究;《经济师》2006年第1期
    [144]梁小萌,2000:《规模经济和产业集聚及区域协调》,《改革与战略》第5期。
    [145]刘斌,《产业聚集竞争优势的经济分析》,中国发展出版社,2004。
    [146]刘军国,郭文灵,2001:《非正式交流与知识经济》,《生产力研究》第1期。
    [147]刘友金,2002:《集群式创新的企业入群行为及其约束条件研究》,
    [148]刘冰,陶海青;“撒网”模型与企业家社会网络演化;学术月刊2005·11
    [149]刘金钵,任荣明;我国纺织业产业集群研究[J].纺织学报, 2004
    [150]罗若愚:我国区域间企业集群的比较及启示[J],南开经济研究, 2002
    [151]罗良忠,史占中.从美国硅谷小企业集群看上海高科技园区的发展[J].当代财经, 2003
    [152]罗炜,唐元虎.企业合作创新的原因与动机[J].科学学研究, 2001
    [153]吕坚,孙林岩,马新莉.企业集群与虚拟企业组织模式比较及发展研究.中国机械工程, 2003
    [154]马歇尔,1991:《经济学原理》,商务印书馆。
    [155]迈克尔·波特,2001:《竞争优势》,华夏出版社。
    [156]迈克尔·波特,2002:《国家竞争优势》,华夏出版社。
    [157]迈克尔·波特等,2000:《未来的战略》,四川人民出版社。
    [158]聂鸣,李俊,骆静,2002 :《OECD国家产业集群政策分析和对我国的启示》,《中国地质大学学报(社会科学版)》,第2卷第1期。
    [159]宁钟:企业集群理论的演进及其评述[J],武汉大学学报:哲学社会科学版, 2002
    [160]日本政府在技术创新中的作用;《技术创新》2000年7月31日
    [161] Stoyan Tenev中国经济高速增长之谜《远东经济评论》
    [162]石培哲,2000:《产业集聚的形成原因探析》,《经济师》,第3期。
    [163]史东明:我国中小企业集群的效率改进[J],中国工业经济2003年第2期,71-76
    [164]盛世毫,郑燕伟,《浙江现象——产业集群与区域经济发展》,清华大学出版社,2004。
    [165]〔美〕托马斯·福特·布朗.社会资本理论综述[ J ].木子西译,马克思主义与现实, 2000, (2).
    [166]王必达,《后发优势与区域发展》,复旦大学出版社,2004。
    [167]汪炜,史晋川,孙福国,2001:《经济增长的区域影响与集聚效应分析》,《数量经济技术研究》,第5期。
    [168]王缉慈,童昕,2001:《简论我国地方企业集群的研究意义》,《经济地理》,第5期。
    [169]王缉慈,2002:《地方产业群战略》,《中国工业经济》,第3期。
    [170]王缉慈等,2001:《创新的空间:企业集群与区域发展》,北京大学出版社。
    [171]王王君:企业簇群的创新过程研究[J],管理世界,2002年第10期,3-11
    [172]王旭章,1998:《区域性的主导产业市场选择、集聚和扩散》,《铁道师院学报》,第5期。
    [173]卫玲,产业集群背景下的企业竞争行为的转型,当代经济科学, 2006年5月
    [174]魏后凯,2003:《对产业集群与竞争力的考察》,《经济管理·新管理》,第6期。
    [175]魏江,陈志辉,张波.企业集群中企业家精神的外部经济性考察[J].科研管理, 2004
    [176]吴永红,保建云,2001:《论企业集聚、扩张的区域效应》,《西南民族学院学报(哲社版)》,第3期。
    [177]徐飞,陈洁,孟令春.上海高新区产业集群与技术创新联动效应研究[J].科技与经济, 2004
    [178]许庆明等:产业集群发展的可持续性[J],经济理论与经济管理,2003(11),21-25
    [179]辛安娜,李志强企业组识结构的复杂性分析晋阳学刊2004年第2期
    [180]辛厚文.分形介质反应动力学[M].上海:上海科技教育出版社,1997.
    [181]许国志,顾基发,车宏安,《系统科学与工程研究》,上海科技教育出版社,2000。
    [182]亚当·斯密,1776:《国富论》,中译本,1990,商务印书馆。
    [183]杨建梅、冯广森:东莞台资IT企业集群产业结构剖析[J],中国工业经济,2002(8),45-50
    [184]杨雪冬.社会资本:对一种新解释范式的探索[A ].李惠斌,杨雪冬.社会资本与社会发展[ C ].北京:社会科学文献出版社, 2000.
    [185]〔澳〕杨小凯,黄有光.专业化与经济组织———一种新兴古典微观经济学框架[M ].张玉纲译.北京:经济科学出版社, 1999. 2522260.
    [186]约翰.H.霍兰,《隐秩序——适应性造就复杂性》,2000。
    [187]张炳申:中小企业集群、城市化与就业扩张[J],经济学动态,2002(12),32-35
    [188]张元智,2001:《基于企业核心竞争能力的产业集聚观点》,《人文杂志》第四期。
    [189]张智元,2001:《产业集聚、竞争优势与西部开发》,《西安电子科技大学学报(社科版)》,第3期。
    [190]赵昌平,王方华;战略联盟竞争优势的保存机制研究;中国地质大学学报(社会科学版); 2002年6月;第2卷第2期
    [191]郑勇军汤筱晓;沿海地区产业集群跨区域整合的动因分析与模式比较;浙江社会科学;2006年第3期
    [192]周兵,蒲勇键,2003:《产业集群的增长经济学解释》,《中国软科学》,第5期。
    [193]周红云.社会资本理论述评[ J ].马克思主义与现实,2002, (5).

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700