高速公路景观生态综合体系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
高速公路是自然环境和人工构造物的结合体,也是实现景观设计研究和环境再造的重要载体。高速公路在建设过程中,会对沿线的自然景观和人文景观产生很大的负面影响,加剧人口、资源与环境的矛盾,增加对沿线生态系统的压力。随着可持续发展观念的深入,对于高速公路的要求已不仅仅满足基本的运输功能要求,如何加大景观、环境心理、生态等元素在高速公路建设中的比重,创建人-车-路和谐的环境体系是当前高速公路建设面临的一个重大课题。
     通过对高速公路景观生态系统科学的分析研究,不仅可以为具有“绿化、生态、环保”理念的高速公路提供科学的建设依据,而且还可以为采用合适的工程措施提供科学的界定尺度。本研究以理论与实际工程相结合的方式,选取孝襄高速公路为研究平台,总结了高速公路景观生态体系所涉及的各方面的要素,构建了一个科学的高速公路景观生态研究体系,并对这个体系中的研究内容和方法进行了系统的分析,其结果具有较高的学术价值和广阔的应用前景。
     多学科的交叉分析是科学、系统地研究高速公路环境景观生态体系的关键,本研究在查阅大量文献的基础上,从理论上分析了高速公路景观生态体系中涉及的美学、生态学、心理学等基本要素的特点,并将这些内容与高速公路景观生态体系进行概念上的整合,总结出了相关的研究理论和研究方法,从而为指导高速公路景观环境研究确定相应的理论基础。
     通过以环境心理学理论为指导,划分出高速公路的认知要素及细化的景观要素,以草图法、系统的问卷和访谈、图片认知以及视景仿真演示法等方法,对高速公路环境景观对道路使用者的环境影响心理特点及影响因素进行了分析。在结果分析的基础上,总结出指导高速公路景观设计的指导原则和审美情感反应理论模型。研究结果显示:通过景观意向元素的分析有助于我们了解使用者与所处的高速公路景观体系之间的相互影响的行为心理关系;把握使用者对多样性和独特性的体验要求可以更好的提升环境景观设计品质,从而为工程建设和方案决策提供相应的指导依据。
     高速公路景观设计是一个综合体系,也是道路景观研究最直观的表现。本文在阐述道路景观设计时没有单纯的从造景艺术的角度分析,而是在考虑其功能性和观赏性的同时,也考虑了自然和社会属性。在进行设计时,考虑景观要素与环境主体和客体间的影响,将环境心理影响与生态绿化设计的理念引入到景观设计过程中,在总结既有的一般性设计原则的基础上,针对景观生态体系中的某些重点部位,选取孝襄高速公路为实例来详细分析设计方法和技巧,对整个高速公路景观系统的设计指引作了较为系统的阐述。
     通过对土壤、水土流失状况、工程占地量、对农作物影响、对林地的影响、对动物的影响、对景观生态影响以及对生物影响等生态指标的分析和评定,来反映公路建设对生态环境的综合影响程度,对采取针对性强和有效的生态防护及恢复措施有重要的参考意义。本文选取了孝襄高速公路为对象,分析建设过程对于生态格局的影响,提出了生态选线、取(弃)土场、河流、农田、土壤、生态涵养带等不同要素的生态修复方法,并从中总结出高速公路建设生态修复的指导策略。研究结果既有很强的针对性,同时也据有一定的普通指导意义。
     为了提高孝襄高速公路景观设计方案分析的直观性和动态性,本文选取视景仿真技术来建立高速公路沿线的三维实时交互模型,并将不同的设计方案在视景仿真平台中进行动态演示和修改。在分析视景仿真技术的特点的基础上,本文选取的方法以普通PC机为平台,以常见的道路设计图纸为源数据,利用CAD软件、Creator/Vega系列软件结合来进行建模,改变了传统建模方法对仿真平台过高的要求,增强了模型的方便性和实用性。
     通过大量的文献调查和专家咨询,系统的建立了高速公路景观方案评价指标体系和评价标准。通过对不同群体的调查分析,确定了不同指标的相对权重,并以模糊数学理论为基础,构建了孝襄高速公路景观指标的多目标多层次模糊数学评价模型。最终的评价结果以分值计算方式进行表达,变传统定性分析的方式为定性定量结合的方式,提高了评价的客观性和科学性。
Expressway is the combo of natural environment and artificial structure, which can be used to research entironment re-building and landscape designing. The construction of expressway will take enormous negative impacts to natural landscape and humanities landscape along the line of expressway, meanwhile the worse contradictory between population, resources and entironment will add the pressure of highway ecosystem. With the ideology of sustainable development transformed drastically,the basic function of transportation is not consistent with the people’s request to the highway. How to improve the proportion of landscape, enviromental psychology and ecological elements, and build harmonious environment system of man---vehicle---road is an important theme that the engineers face in current expressway construction.
     With the research of the expressway landscape ecosystem, the paper not only brings forward scientific basis which advocates“Virescence, Zoology, Environment Protection”, but also provides the delimitation rules for the appropriate projects. Chooseing Xiao-xiang expressway as platform, the paper systemically summarizes all kinds of elements in expressway landscape ecosystem, and then builds an scientific research system of expressway landscape in which contents and the correlation technique are analyzed systemically by the combination of theory and actual project. The results show that the content in this paper has upper academic value and widest application prospects.
     The interlaced development of all interrelated subjects is the key to improve the research level of expressway environment landscape system. Based on the abundant correlative literature, the paper first analyzes the characters of the basic elements affect expressway landscape according to aesthetics, ecology and psychology et al. By combination of these contents and expressway landscape system, correlative theories and methods are generalized, and foundation academic theories which can be used to supervise the research of environment landscape is confirmed.
     On the basis of the environmental psychology theory, the paper divides the cognitive elements of expressway and the detail landscape elements. By the way of the sketch, the questionnaire& interview, the picture cognition and the visual simulation technology, the paper analyzes the characters and influence elements of the environment psychology, and puts out the relationship between users and expressway environment. Based on these, the instructed rules for landscape design and aesthetic responses model are deduced. The results show that the analysis of landscape orientation elements can help us to recover the behavior-psychology relationship between the expressway landscape and the users. The experience of multiplicity and particularness by the different users can improve the quality of landscape design, consequently providing the guiding principle for construction and decision-making.
     The expressway landscape design is a synthetical system that directly expressed the expressway landscape research results. Comparing with the traditional way which studied form the simplex landscape-making art limited, the design method in the paper absorbs the ideology include the demands of function, view and admire, nature and sociality and so on, and it puts emphasis on environmental psychology and ecological evanescence design. Generalizing currently design principles, the paper selected the Xiao-xiang expressway as example to analyze the design techniques of the important positions in the expressway landscape system in detail.
     Through analyzing and evaluating the indexes, such as soil, soil erosion and water loss, scalar of project, crop, woodland, animal and plants, the effect degree of construction to environment can be assessed, and it is very significative for us to selecte effective and pertinent ways of ecological protective and restoration by these content. Based on these, the paper puts forward the ecological restoration way that aims at different part of expressway, such as linearity, borrow (lend) pit ground, river, farmland, siol and ecological restraint belt, and then the instructional strategy for expressway ecological restoration is also summarized. It was indicated that the results have greatly pertinence and universal significance.
     Applying the visual simulation technology to highway engineering, an expressway visual simulation system for the visualization analysis of landscape design proposals is built during the construction of Xiao-xiang expressway. Its functional requirements and overall architecture are presented. The 3D model of expressway is created with AutoCAD DWG files as source data and the dynamic design method of expressway landscape elements is introduces. The system offers an effective tool to facilitate the analysis and evaluation of the road landscape proposals.
     Through countless document investigation, expert consultation and social research, assessment index system for expressway landscape scheme and assessment criterion is set up. By investigated the different communities, relative weights of different index are confirmed. Based on the theory of fuzzy mathematics, multi-object multi-hiberarchy fuzzy mathematics assessment model of Xiao-xiang expressway landscape index is built, and the final assessment results are expressed with score computed by this way. Being compared with qualitative analysis of the traditional, the qualitative and quantitative method mentioned in the paper improve objectivity and scientific nature.
引文
[1] Goodland R J A, Howard S I. An ecological discussion of the environmental impact of the highway construction program in the Amazon basin[J].Landscape and Planning, 1974,1:123-254
    [2] Shelley M A, Nigel M W. The effects of highway transportation corridors on wildlife: a case study of Banff National Park[J]. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 2000, 8(1-6):307-320
    [3]赵勇,孙中党,吴明作.高速公路建设项目对生态环境影响综合评价研究[J].安全与环境工程, 2003,10(3):27-30
    [4]林晓青.高速公路建设对生态环境的影响及防治对策[J].福建环境, 2000,17(3) :3-5
    [5] Baekken T. Effects of highway pollutants on a small Norwegian lake[J]. The Science of The Total Environment, 1994,146-147: 131-139
    [6] Mok J H,Landphair H C,Naderi J R.Landscape improvement impacts onroadside safety in Texas[J].Landscape and Urban Planning, 2006,78(3):263-274
    [7]黄江波,李杰,宋江平等.基于环境心理的高速公路景观设计[J].公路. 2006(8):127-131
    [8]祝遵凌,尹红梅.自然与人文景观在高速公路景观营建中的应用[J].南京林业大学学报(人文社会科学版). 2006,6(4):89-94
    [9] (联邦德国)汉斯·洛伦茨.公路线形与环境设计[M].北京:人民交通出版社,1986
    [10]陈竞飞.高速公路景观综合设计探讨[J].城市道路与防洪. 2005,(1):17-19
    [11] Highway Beautifity Aet of 1965.(USA).1965
    [12] (联邦德国)道路景观设计规范RAS-1980
    [13]王梅.美国的湿地保护和立法[J].国土资源.2002(2):48-49
    [14] Ghislaine Guyot, Jean Clobert. Conservation measures for a population of Hermann's tortoise Testudo hermanni in southern France bisected by a major highway[J].Biological Conservation. 1997,79 (2-3):251-256
    [15]林绍华.浅谈客土喷播防护绿化施工[J].西部探矿工程. 2005,(12):282-283
    [16]张玉芬.高等级公路建设与环境协调发展若干问题的探讨[J].交通环保. 1999,20 (1):28-30
    [17]张阳.公路景观学[M].北京:建筑工业出版社.2004
    [18] Lin H T,Chiu M L. From urban landscape to information landscape: Digital Tai nan as an example[J].Automation in Construction,2003,12(5):473-480
    [19] Daniel J M. Landscape history as a planning tool[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2000,49 (1-2): 67-81
    [20] William J M,James G G. The value of wetlands: importance of scale and landscape setting[J].Ecological Economics,2000,35 (1):25 - 33
    [21] Theano S T. Towards a theory of the landscape:the Aegean landscape as a cultural image[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2001,57 (3-4):197-208
    [22] Christina v H. Landscape planning facing the challenge of the development of cultural landscapes[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning,2002,60 (2):73-80
    [23] Robert B, Richard E C, Todd B. Group differences in the enjoyability of driving through rural landscapes[J].Landscape and Urban Planning, 2000,47 (1-2):39-45
    [24] Viles R L,Rosier D J. How to use roads in the creation of greenways: case studies in three New Zealand landscapes[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2001,55 (1) :15-27
    [25] Lars B. Solutions for characterising natural landscapes in New Zealand using geographical information systems[J].Journal of Environmental Management, 2005,76 (1):23-34
    [26] Ariel E L, Hermann G. Function, effects, and management of forest roads[J]. Forest Ecology and Management,2000,133 (3): 249-262
    [27] G Clarke P, Piran C L W, Stephen H. Effects of roads on badger Meles populations in south-west England[J].Biological Conservation,1998,86 (2):117-124
    [28] Matti S. Geomorphological aspects of road construction in a cold environment, Finland[J].Geomorphology,1999,31 (1-4):65-91
    [29] Harbin L,David I G,Pu M et al. A landscape model (LEEMATH) to evaluate effects of management impacts on timber and wildlife habitat[J]. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture,2000 ,27 (1-3):263–292
    [30] Wang X H, Stauffer B.Application of GIS for enviromental impact analysis in a traffic relief study[J].Comput,Envirin and Urban Systems,1995,19(4):275-286
    [31]钟登华,刘东海.工程可视化辅助设计理论方法与应用[M].北京:中国水利水电出版社,2004
    [32]袁黎,陆键,项乔君等.高速公路绿化评价指标及方法研究[J].交通运输工程与信息学报. 2005,3 (2) :39-43
    [33] Robert J C.The effectiveness of working group risk identification and assessment techniques[J].International Journal of Project Management, 1998, 16 (6):333-343,
    [34] paul F M,Jim P. The production of interactive engineering design software using Borland Delphi[J]. Advances in Engineering Software,2001,32 (10-11):789-796
    [35] Lee J W,Kim S H. An integrated approach for interdependent information system project selection[J]. International Journal of Project Management, 2001,19(2):111-118
    [36] Rowe G,Wright G.The Delphi technique as a forecasting tool: issues and analysis[J].International Journal of Forecasting,1999,15(4):353-375
    [37] Leung C L, Cao D.On the efficacy of modeling multi-attribute decision problems using AHP and Sinarchy[J].European Journal of Operational Research ,2001,132(1): 39-49
    [38] Liu F H, Hai H L.The voting analytic hierarchy process method forselecting supplier[J].InternationalJournal of Production Economics,2005,97 (3):308-317
    [39] Kamal M. Al-Subhi Al-Harbi .Application of the AHP in project management [J].International Journal of Project Management,2001,19(1):19-27
    [40] Hurley W J.The analytic hierarchy process: a note on an approach to sensitivity which preserves rank order [J].Computers & Operations Research,2001,28 (2):185-188
    [41] Ak?akaya H R.Linking population-level risk assessment with landscape and habitat models[J].The Science of the Total Environment,2001,274(1-3):283-291
    [42] Feng S,Xu L D.Decision support for fuzzy comprehensive evaluation of urban development[J].Fuzzy Sets and Systems,1999,105(1): 1-12
    [43] Hessburg T M.Fuzzy logic control with adaptive methods for vehicle lateral guidance[J].Transportation Research Part A:Policy and Practice,1997,31(1): 61-62
    [44] Partha C,Shinya K. Evaluation of the General Motors based car-following models and a proposed fuzzy inference model[J].Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies,1999,7(4): 209-235
    [45] Boris K,Evangelos T,James R et al.Fuzzy logic in computer-aided breast cancer diagnosis: analysis of lobulation[J].Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, 1997 ,11(1):75-85
    [46] Chew E P, Goh C J, Fwa T F.Simultaneous optimization of horizontal and vertical alignments for highways[J].Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 1989, 23( 5):315-329
    [47] Jha K M; Schonfeld P. A highway alignment optimization model using geographic information systems[J].Transportation Research Part A:Policy and Practice,2004,38 (6):455-481
    [48] Moffett, Thurber J. Building highway systems with computer graphic simulations[J]. Proceedings of the IEEE, 1974,62( 4): 429-436
    [49] Antonio Guiducci.Parametric Model of the Perspective Projection of a Road with Applications to Lane Keeping and 3D Road Reconstruction[J].Computer Vision and Image Understanding, 1999, 73( 3): 414-427
    [50] Fukahori K,Kubota Y et al. Development of visual assessment system for planning and design of expressway[J].Proceedings of the seventh international conference on computing in civil and building engineering, 1997,(1-4):715-720
    [51] MukaiT.Virtual reality for traffic environment simulation [J].Transactions of the Information Processing Society of Japan,1998,39(1): 142-52
    [52] Robert A L; Richard C S.Commercial highway landscape reclamation: A participatory approach[J]. Landscape and Planning, 1986,12( 4):353-385
    [53] Fernandes, Joao P. Landscape ecology and conservation management - evaluation of alternatives in a highway EIA process. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2000,20( 6):665-680
    [54] Froment, Jose;Domon, Gerald. Viewer appreciation of highway landscapes: The contribution of ecologically managed embankments in Quebec, Canada. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2006,78(1-2): 14-32
    [55]杨传永.浅谈公路绿化设计[J].华东公路.2003,(3):74-75
    [56]杜春兰,毛华松.永川永铜公路环北段绿化景观规划设计研究[J].规划设计,2002 ,18 (6):41-44
    [57]林瑛.高速公路环境设计中景观与生态、文化的整合研究初探[J].江南大学学报(人文社会科学版).2006,5 (1):124-128
    [58]方萍,蔡玲.宁杭高速公路沿线景观设计浅谈[J].公路2005(3);38-41
    [59]钱国超,明图章、胡安兵等.用全新的理念打造宁杭高速[J].公路2005(3):1-5
    [60]许金良,杨宏志.公路视景仿真模型[J].长安大学学报(自然科学版),2004,24 (2) : 37-40
    [61]邹兴平,吴波.公路三维视景仿真研究[J].交通与计算机,2004,22(3):17-20
    [62]王建军,严宝杰,陈宽民高速公路建设项目后评价若干问题探讨[J].长安大学学报(社会科学版) 2005,7(2):4-8
    [63]陈传似.景观设计的误区[J].中国园林. 2000, 16 (3): 26-28
    [64] Denieul M. Highway landscape: from inside and from outside. Travaux, 1988, 63 (8):69-73
    [65] Process Architecture 33. Landscape Design: Works Of Dan Kiley.Tokyo,1986
    [66]邱紫华.黑格尔美学思想引论[M].武汉:华中师范大学出版社, 1997
    [67]罗士平.康定斯基与抽象主义绘画[M].北京:人民美术出版社, 1989.6
    [68] B.R. Erstrand (B. R).Psyohology: its principlesand meanings[M].上海:知识出版社, 1985
    [69]张海钟.中国城乡跨文化心理学和区域心理学与心理学本土化.2006,35 (1):50-58
    [70] Robinson ,Daniel N. Psychology: a study of its origins and principles Encino [M]. Dickenson Pub. Co, 1972
    [71]杨思寰.审美心理学[M].北京:人民出版社, 1991.9
    [72] (联邦德国)伊泽尔(Iser W).审美过程研究[M].霍桂桓,李宝彦译.北京:中国人民大学出版社, 1988
    [73]戚廷贵.审美理论[M].长春:东北师范大学出版社, 1992
    [74] Lukacs Guorgu.审美特性(第一卷)[M].徐恒醇,译.北京:中国社会科学出版社, 1986
    [75]王保忠,王保明,何平.景观资源美学评价的理论与方法[J].应用生态学报.2006,17(9):1733-1739
    [76] Hüttl R F, Fischer T.Carbon sequestration and landscape ecology in Western Europe[J]. Ecological Engineering, 2007,29(4):317-318
    [77] Risser P G,Karr J R,Forman R T. Landscape Ecology:Direction and Approaches [R].Special Pub. No.2,Champaign,USA:Illinois Natural History Survey,1984
    [78] Naveh Z,Lieberman A S. Landscape Ecology: Theory and Application[M].New York: Springer-Verlag, 1984
    [79]高玉华,付景春.生态修复在公路工程水土保持方案中的应用[J].黑龙江水利科技. 2006,34 (6):120-121
    [80]林玉莲,胡正凡.环境心理学[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社, 2000
    [81]俞国良,王青兰,杨治良.环境心理学[M].北京:人民教育出版社, 2000
    [82]徐磊青,杨公侠.环境、知觉和行为[M].上海:同济大学出版社, 2002
    [83]罗维宏,杨光友,卜晓励等.热带雨林高速公路总体设计理念探讨[J].公路. 2006,(2):56-62
    [84]张雨化.公路勘测设计[M].北京:人民交通出版社,1980
    [85]洪琳燕.高速公路视觉景观设计研究[J].江苏林业科技.2006,33 (4):12-15
    [86]唐强,薛志杰,石平等.高速公路中央分隔带树木种植设计与行驶车辆防眩原理及其公式构建[J].2005,32(4):466-470
    [87]耿超,王方杰.基于公路线形影响的护栏布设方法探讨[J].城市道路与防洪2005,(6):144-147.
    [88]王亚兵.景观桥梁结构造型设计与评价[硕士毕业论文].合肥:合肥工业大学,2006
    [89]魏中华,王珊,任福田.高等级公路景观序列构成研究[J].公路交通科技.2004,21(11):134-137
    [90]许慧,王家骥编著.景观生态学的理论与应用[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社, 1993.8
    [91] Negishi J N, Sidle R C, Noguchi S et al.Ecological roles of roadside fern (Dicranopteris currani) on logging road recovery in Peninsular Malaysia: Preliminary results[J].Forest Ecology and Management,2006,224(1):176–186
    [92] Paulo S, Bert B,Symone A.Qualitative models about stream ecosystem recovery :Exploratory studies[J].Ecological Modelling,2006,194(1-3): 80-89
    [93]章梦涛,邱金淡,颜冬.客土喷播在边坡生态修复与防护中的应用[J].国水土保持科学.2004, 2(3):10-12
    [94]田瑞丽,罗人明,国洁.生态城市规划中生态敏感地区的判定与分析.河北工业科技.2006, 23(6):334-337
    [95] Lockaby B G,Stanturf J A, Messina M. Effects of silvicultural activity on ecological processes in floodplain forests of the southern United States:a review of existing reports[J].Forest Ecology and Management,1997,90 (2-3):93- 100
    [96]孙中党,赵勇,吴明作.公路建设项目对生态影响及保护对策[J].公路交通科技,2004, 121(13):128-131
    [97]黄勇,何萍,李启明.新技术、新工艺、新材料在焦晋高速公路第一合同段的应用[J].交通标准化,2005(144):124-127
    [98] P feifer N.A subdivision algorithm for smooth 3D terrain models[J].ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2005,59( 3):115-127
    [99] Kreuseler M, Schumann H.A flexible approach for visual data mining[J]. IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 2002, 8(1):39-51.
    [100]谢承安.利用透视图进行高速公路优化设计[J].湖南交通科技,2006,32 (4):23-26
    [101] Danahy J W.Technology for dynamic viewing and peripheral vision in landscape visualization[J].LandscapeandUrbanPlanning,2001, 54(1):127-138
    [102] Wang WC ,Jiang X H, Han K Q.Optimzing Real-Time Performance of 3D Virtual Mining Environment with MultiGen Creator[J]. CADDM, 2004, 14 (1):61-67
    [103] Clayton M J,Warden R B,Parker et al. Virtual construction of architecture using 3D CAD and simulation[J]. Automation in Construction,2002,11(2):227-235.
    [104] Zhu H, Menq C H. B-Rep model simplification by automatic fillet round suppressing for efficient automatic feature recognition[J]. Computer-Aided Design,2002,34(2):109-123
    [105] MultiGen-Paradigm Inc.Creating Models for Simulations[Z]. MultiGen-Paradigm Inc, 2001.
    [106]吴家铸,党岗,刘华峰,等.视景仿真技术及其应用[M].西安:西安电子科技大学出版社,2001
    [107] LI Qing-quan,TANG Lu-liang,ZUO Xiaoqin et al.Transect-based Three - Dimensional Road Modeling and Visualization[J] . Geo-spatial Information Science,2004,7(1):14-17
    [108]何业兰.基于pc的实时交互视景仿真系统的实现与研究[硕士学位论文].武汉:武汉理工大学,2006
    [109]龚卓蓉,朱衡君. vega程序设计[M] .北京:国防工业出版社.2002.8
    [110] Silvennoinen H, Alho J, Kolehmainen O, Pukkala T. Prediction models of landscape preferences at the forest stand level [J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2001, 56(1):11-20
    [111] Yu K J,Li D H,Li N Y,The evolution of Greenways in China[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2006 ,76( 1-4): 223-239
    [112] Lim E M, Tsuyoshi H ,Kiyoshi U.The validity of VRML images as a stimulus forlandscapeassessment[J].LandscapeandUrbanPlanning, 2006,77(1-2):80-93
    [113]曾小明,陈军,罗旗帜等.基于模糊数学的公路景观环境评价[J].公路,2003(7):120-122
    [114]宋晓秋.模糊数学原理与方法[M].徐州:中国矿业大学出版社, 2004

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700