摘要
随着经济水平的不断提高及社会分工的进一步深化,生产者服务业的发展状况与发展水平已经成为衡量一个地区国际化、现代化程度的重要指标,对地区产业结构的优化升级起到了极大的促进作用,也在一定程度上影响了制造业的未来发展。就我国实际情况而言,生产者服务业一直处于缓慢发展的停滞阶段,而且在生产者服务业发展过程中表现出的区域和产业内部发展的“不均衡”现象将在一定程度上制约我国生产者服务业体系的未来发展。因此,在新形势下研究生产者服务业发展过程中的非均衡现状,促进生产者服务业与制造业以及整个国民经济和谐构建成为了产业结构调整与升级中一个亟待解决的问题。
本文在系统梳理生产者服务业产业演进、生产者服务业区位集聚、非均衡等相关理论的基础上,分析我国三大经济区域生产者服务业发展的现实状况,并得出结论:我国生产者服务业发展过程中存在非均衡的特点,即区域间发展的非均衡和产业内部各行业间发展的非均衡。同时,指出生产者服务业非均衡发展过程中出现了市场化程度低、投资主体单一、技术和知识投资不足等一系列问题。文章中构建了生产者服务业区域发展的多元回归模型,研究人均收入、工业化水平、城市化水平以及政府政策等在生产者服务业区域发展中的地位与影响作用,试图找出造成生产者服务业区域间发展非均衡的原因;同时,把非均衡增长理论应用于生产者服务业内部并进行一定的拓展,分析价格弹性和需求弹性对各个行业和整个产业发展的作用,并结合实证回归,研究生产者服务业内部发展非均衡的原因。在寻找生产者服务业非均衡的基础上,文章进一步研究了生产者服务业非均衡发展过程中的产业集聚,在肯定产业集聚对地区整体经济有促进作用的同时,分析了其对生产者服务业非均衡发展的重要影响。
在实践方面,本文结合生产服务者服务业发展过程中非均衡特点及存在的缺陷,提出生产者服务业发展需要注意三方面的内容,即生产者服务业自身的产业升级、生产者服务业与制造业的和谐发展以及整个生产者服务体系的和谐发展。在生产者服务体系和谐发展方面,文章提出了几点建议:1.灵活选择多种形式的生产者服务业集聚,重点发展知识和密集型产业,通过集聚促进地区经济的和谐发展;2.将生产者服务业发展与城镇化建设相结合,促进生产者服务业与城乡经济、国内国际经济协调发展。3.以制度创新为基础,促进生产者服务业的制度建设与道德建设;4.打破旧有体制的垄断,规范生产者服务业的市场结构。
Along with the development of economy and the complication of labor division, the producer services become an important index to scale the internationalization and modernization of a region. They play an active role in the optimization and upgrading of the industry structure, and will affect the development of the manufacturing. The producer services in China are in low development at a long time, and have the characteristics of disequilibrium, which will restrict the future of the whole producer services system. So, it becomes an imperative problem to solve in order to accelerate the harmonious development of manufacturing and the national economy.
This thesis reviews some theories of producer services and analyses the actuality of the three regions in our country, from which we can gain the conclusion that there exists disequilibrium during the development of producer services——the disequilibrium in different regions and in different sectors. Then we try to find out the reason why this disequilibrium of regions firstly, using the method of setting up a regress model in order to analyze the status and effects of GDP, manufacturing, the level of socialization and the government behaviors. At the same time, the equilibrium theory is introduced into interior of producer services to scale the effect of price elasticity and demand elasticity in different sectors, and we also establish the model, combine which we can research the disequilibrium in the interior of producer services. On the base of finding out the reasons for disequilibrium, the thesis analyzes the industrial cluster of producer services and its effects.
In the practice, the thesis analyzes the disequilibrium development of producer services, and there are three problems that should be paid attention: the upgrading of producer services, the harmonious development between producer services and manufacturing, and the harmonious development of the whole producer services. For the last problem, the thesis gives some advices: 1. Every region should choose its suitable cluster modal, which can speed the harmonious development; 2. Every region also should combine the development of producer services and the city town build, and advance the harmonious grow of the economy of cities and countries; 3. Effort should be made to the system build and the moral build on the base of system innovation; 4. The monopoly in the old system should be break out to optimize the market structure of producer services.
引文
① V.R.,Fuchs. The Service Economy[M]. New York:National Bureau of Economic Research,1968:1-3
② Daniel, Bell. The Coming of Post-industrial Society[M]. Heinemann Educational Books Ltd,1974:127-133
③ Cohen, R B.. The New International Division of Labor, Multinational Corporations and Urban Hierarchy[J]. Urbanization and Urban planning in Capitalist Society,1981: 287-315
① Daniels., P.W. Services Industries[M]. Great Britain: Cambridge University Press,1995
② Gillespie, A. E. and A. E. Green. The Changing Geography of Producer Services Employment in Britain[J]. Regional Studies,1987,21:.397-411
③ Goe, W. R.. Do Producer Services Industries: Sorting Through the Externalization Debate[J]. Growth and Change,1991: 118-41
④ Tschetter, J.. Producer Services Industries: Why Are They Growing So Rapidly? [J]. Monthly Labor Review,1987,12:.31-40
⑤ 刘志彪.论现代生产和服务业发展的基本规律.中国经济问题,2006,1:3-9
⑥ Shelp ,R. The Role of Service Technology in Development, in Service Industries and Economic Development-Case studies in Technology Transfer [M]. New York: Praeger Publishers,1984
⑦ Riddle, D.. Service-Led Growth: the Role of the Service Sector in World Development[M]. New York: Praeger Publishers,1996
⑧ W. Richard, Goe.. Factors Associated with the Development of Nonmetropolitan Growth Nodes in Producer Services Industries [J]. Rural Sociology, 2..2002,3:416-441,
⑨ 程大中.论服务业在国民经济中的“黏合剂”作用[J] .财贸经济,2004,2:73-88
① H.C,Greenfield. Manpower and the Growth of Producer Services [M]. New York: Columbia University Press,1996
② Herbert G. Grubel and Michael A.. Walker, Service Industry Growth: Cause and Effects[M]. Fraser Institute,1989
③ Juleff. Advanced Producer Services: Just a Service to Manufacturing? [J]. Service Industries,1996,6(1)
④ Stanback, T. M. and J. Madden. Post-Industrial Philadelphia: Structural Changes in the Metropolitan Economy [M]. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania,1990
⑤ Marshall, N. and Wood,p. . Service and Space [M]. New York: Longman Scientific Technical,1995
⑥ Howells and Green. Location, Technology and Industrial Organization in UK Services[J]. Progress in Planning,1986,7
⑦ M.J. ,Healey and B.W. ,Ilbery. Location & Change: Perspectives of Economic Geography[M]. Oxford University Press,1990
① [美]迈克尔.波特,国家竞争优势[M],北京:华夏出版社,2002
② Smith, D.F. Jr and R. Florida. Agglomeration and industrial location: an econometric analysis of Japanese affiliated manufacturing establishments in automotive-related industries[J]. Journal of Urban Economics,36:23-41
③ Kaldor, N.. The case for regional policies[J]. The Scottish Journal of Political Economy,1970,99:483-499
④ T.J., Noyelle and T. M. , Stanback. The Economic Transformation of American Cities[M]., Totawa: Rowman & Allanheld,1984:98-118
① 甄峰,顾潮林,朱传耿.西方生产者服务业研究述评[J].南京大学学报,2001,3:31-37
② Daniel, P.W.. Locational Dynamics of Producer and Consumer Services[M]. London: Methuen,1985:Chpter 8
③ Goe, W., Producer Services, Trade and Social Division of Labor[M], Regional Studies,1990, 24:327-342
④ Coe, N.M.. Exploring Uneven Development in Producer Service Sectors: Detailed Evidence form the British Compter Services Industry[J]. Environment and Planning, 1998, 30(11):2041-2068
⑤ Markusen,J. .Trade in Produces Services and in Other Specialized Intermediate Inputs[J]. The American Economic Review ,1989,79: 85-95
⑥ S. ,Illeris. Producer Services: The Key Sector for Future Economic Development[J]. Entrepreneurship and Regional Development,1989,8
① Hirschman, A O.. The Strategy of Economic Development. New Haven[M]. Conn.: Yale University Press,1958
② W.J. ,Baumol. Macroeconomics of Unbalanced Growth[J]. American Economic 1967, 6
① 国家实施西部大开发战略后的最新划分标准中采用了,即“新三区”,即东部包括北京、天津、河北、辽宁、上海、江苏、浙江、福建、山东、广东、海南;中部地区包括山西、吉林、黑龙江、安徽、江西、河南、湖北、湖南;西部地区包括四川、贵州、云南、西藏、陕西、甘肃、青海、宁夏、广西、内蒙古、新疆和重庆。本文选取三个区域中的有代表性的部分城市进行数据分析。
② 中国经济统计信息网,http://db.cei.gov.cn 《中国统计年鉴》,北京:中国统计出版社
① 陈秀山,徐瑛.我国区域发展的结构性特征与发展趋势[J].教学与研究,2004,6:24-31
② 韩颂善.论规模经济与企业规模的扩大[N].光明日报,1998,10(25)
① 胡艳苹.生产者服务业的演变规律分析[J].广东经济,2004,6:53-55
① Se Hark, Park. Intersectional Relationships between Manufacturing and Service: New Evidence from Selected Pacific Basin Countries[M]. ASEAN Economic Bulletin,1999
① 程大中.论服务业在国民经济中的“黏合剂”作用[J].财贸经济,2004,2:73-88
② Singelmann, Joachim .From agriculture to service: the transformation of industrial employment[M. Beverly Hills: CASage Publications,1978
③ 唐珏岚,国际化大都市与生产者服务业集聚[J],世界政治与经济,2004,11:64-65
① 本部门推导参考:黄少军, 服务业与经济增长, 北京:经济科学出版社,2000:221-223
② 数据结果来自于:曹跃群,中国服务业发展的现状与对策研究[D],重庆大学,2004:58
① [美]迈克尔.波特,国家竞争优势[M],北京:华夏出版社,2002
①程大中,论服务业在国民经济中的“黏合剂”作用[J],财贸经济,2004,2:21-23
[1] 曹跃群.中国服务业发展的现状与对策研究[D].重庆:重庆大学,2004:
[2] 陈凯.服务业在经济发展中的地位和作用:国外理论评述[J].经济学家,2005,4:112-118
[3] 陈秀山,徐瑛.我国区域发展的结构性特征与发展趋势[J].教学与研究,2004,6:24-31
[4] 程大中.论服务业在国民经济中的“黏合剂”作用[J].财贸经济,2004,2:73-88
[5] 代文,秦远建.基于产业集群的现代服务业发展模式研究[J].科技进步与对策,2006,3:123-125
[6] 高春亮.文献综述:生产者服务业概念、特征与区委[J].上海经济研究,2005,11:64-70
[7] 顾乃华.生产服务业、内生比较优势与经济增长:理论与实证分析[J].商业经济与管理,2005,4:43-39
[8] 韩颂善.论规模经济与企业规模的扩大[N].光明日报,1998,10(25)
[9] 胡艳苹.生产者服务业的演变规律分析[J].广东经济,2004,6:53-55
[10] 黄少军.服务业与经济增长[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2000:221-223
[11] 黄维兵.现代服务经济理论与中国服务业的发展[M].重庆:西南财经大学,2003
[12] 江小涓,裴长洪著.中国服务业发展报告[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2004:282-300
[13] 江小涓,李辉.服务业与中国经济:相关性和加快增长的潜力[J].经济研究,2001,6:4-15
[14] 李宏梅.论生产服务业发展中的政府角色[J] .统计研究,2002,8:63-66
[15] 李江帆,毕斗斗.国外生产服务业研究述评[J].外国经济与管理,2004,11:16-25
[16] 李善同,华而诚.21 世纪初的中国服务业[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2002
[17] 梁琦.产业集聚论[M],北京:商务印书馆,2004:5-22
[18] 刘志彪.论现代生产者服务业发展的基本规律[J].中国经济问题,2006,1:3-9
[19] [美]古扎拉蒂.计量经济学(上下册)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2003:118-245
[20] [美]迈克尔.波特.国家竞争优势[M].北京:华夏出版社,2002
[21] 唐珏岚.国际化大都市与生产者服务业集聚[J].世界政治与经济,2004,11:64-65
[22] 王晓玉.国外生产性服务业集聚研究评述[J].当代财经,2006,3:92-96
[23] 徐从才,张涛.信息化条件下生产者服务体系的构建与水平提升[J].产业经济研究,2006,2
[24] 杨公仆,夏大尉.产业经济学教程[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2002:3-133
[25] 甄峰,顾潮林,朱传耿.西方生产者服务业研究述评[J].南京大学学报,2001,6:31-37
[26] 郑吉昌,夏晴.论生产性服务业的发展与分工的深化[J].科技进步与对策,2005,2:13-15
[27] 周明生,王辉龙.浅论生产性服务业对产业集群创新的作用机理[J].南方经济,2005,10:68-70
[28] Coe, N.M.. Exploring Uneven Development in Producer Service Sectors: Detailed Evidence forms the British Computer Services Industry [J]. Environment and Planning, 1998, 30: 2041-2068
[29] Cohen, R B. The New International Division of Labor. Multinational Corporations and Urban Hierarchy [J], Urbanization and Urban planning in Capitalist Society, 1981: 287-315
[30] Daniel, Bell. The Coming of Post-industrial Society [M]. Heinemann Educational Books Ltd, 1974: 127-133
[31] Daniel, P.W.. Locational Dynamics of Producer and Consumer Services [M]. London: Methuen, 1985
[32] Daniels, P.W. Services Industries [M], Great Britain: Cambridge University Press, 1995: chapter 8
[33] Gillespie, A. E. and A. E. Green. The Changing Geography of Producer Services Employment in Britain [J]. Regional Studies, 1987, 21:.397-411
[34] Goe, W. R.. Do Producer Services Industries: Sorting Through the Externalization Debate [J]. Growth and Change, 1991: 118-41
[35] Goe, W... Producer Services, Trade and Social Division of Labor [M]. Regional Studies, 1990, 24
[36] H.C, Greenfield. Manpower and the Growth of Producer Services [M]. New York: Columbia University Press, 1996
[37] Herbert G.. Grubel and Michael A., Walker, Service Industry Growth: Cause and Effects[M]. Fraser Institute,1989
[38] Hirschman, A O.. The Strategy of Economic Development. New Haven[M]. Conn.: Yale University Press, 1958
[39] Howells and Green. Location, Technology and Industrial Organization in UK Services[J]. Progress in Planning, 1986, 7
[40] Juleff. Advanced Producer Services: Just a Service to Manufacturing? [J]. Service Industries, 1996, 6(1)
[41] Kaldor, N.. The case for regional policies [J]. The Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 1970: 483-499
[42] Markusen, J..Trade in Produces Services and in Other Specialized Intermediate Inputs[J]. The American Economic Review ,1989,79: 85-95
[43] Marshall, N. and Wood,p.. Service and Space[M]. New York: Longman Scientific Technical,1995
[44] M.J.,Healey and B.W. .Liberty,Location & Change: Perspectives of Economic Geography[M]. Oxford University Press,1990:
[45] Riddle, D.. Service-Led Growth: the Role of the Service Sector in World Development[M]. New York: Praeger Publishers,1996
[46] Se Hark, Park. Intersectional Relationships between Manufacturing and Service: New Evidence from Selected Pacific Basin Countries[M]. ASEAN Economic Bulletin,1999
[47] Shelp ,R.. The Role of Service Technology in Development, in Service Industries and Economic Development-Case studies in Technology Transfer [M]. New York: Praeger Publishers,1984
[48] S. ,Illeris. Producer Services: The Key Sector for Future Economic Development[J]. Entrepreneurship and Regional Development,1989,8
[49] Singelmann, Joachim .From agriculture to service: the transformation of industrial employment [M]. Beverly Hills: CASage Publications, 1978
[50] Smith, D.F. Jr and R. Florida. Agglomeration and industrial location: an econometric analysis of Japanese affiliated manufacturing establishments in automotive-related industries [J]. Journal of Urban Economics, 1985: 23-41
[51] Stanback, T. M. and J. Madden. Post-Industrial Philadelphia: Structural Changes in the Metropolitan Economy [M]. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania, 1990
[52] T.J., Noyelle and T. M., Stanback. The Economic Transformation of American Cities [M]. Totowa: Rowman&Allanheld, 1984: 98-118
[53] Tschetter, J.. Producer Services Industries: Why Are They Growing So Rapidly? [J]. Monthly Labor Review, 1987, 12:.31-40
[54] V.R.,Fuchs. The Service Economy [M]. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research,1968
[55] W.J.,Baumol.Macroeconomics of Unbalanced Growth[J]. Americaneconomic 1967
[56] W. Richard, Goe.. Factors Associated with the Development of Nonmetropolitan Growth Nodes in Producer Services Industries[J]. Rural Sociology, 2002, 3: 416-441