电针介入多次实施体外受精—胚胎移植患者取卵过程镇痛效应的研究
|
摘要
本文从理论、临床两个方面对电针介入多次实施体外受精-胚胎移植(in vitrofertilization and embryo transfer,IVF-ET)患者取卵过程的镇痛问题进行了研究,并对电针介入后的术后不良反应的变化进行了观察和分析。
理论研究:综述了针剌镇痛的起源、发展、作用范围和特点,着重论述了针刺镇痛中使用最多的电针镇痛,以及电针镇痛疗效的影响因素,并从人工辅助生殖的角度论述采用电针镇痛的必要性、可行性及有效性,以及与传统麻醉或镇痛药物的比较优势。理论研究表明:电针介入IVF-ET具有科学依据和临床必要性及可行性。
临床研究:采用数字随机分组的方法,将120例多次IVF-ET治疗患者分为针药组和药物组,术前测试患者的基础痛阈和耐痛阈、焦虑评分,观察患者术中疼痛程度并予以评级评分,让患者在术后立即以视觉模拟评分法(visual analogue scales,VAS)评价疗效,并回忆最近一次取卵时的感受,以VAS评价疗效。观察患者术后1小时和术后2-5小时的术后不良反应情况。通过对最后纳入的111例病例的分析,结果提示:(1)从患者角度观察,针药组本次手术VAS值为20.55±2.67,上次手术VAS值为23.46±3.05;药物组本次手术VAS值为23.37±3.24,上次手术VAS值为24.10±3.34。针药组两次VAS值差异有显著性意义(p＜0.05);药物组两次VAS值差异无显著性意义(p＞0.05);针药组和药物组本次手术VAS值差异无显著性意义(p＞0.05),表明电针介入IVF-ET取卵过程,能有效地减轻术中疼痛。(2)在术后不良反应方面,术后1小时,针药组59例有28例发生腹痛,腹痛率为47.46%;药物组52例有37例发生腹痛,腹痛率为71.15%,两组差异有显著性意义(p＜0.05)。说明电针介入IVF-ET取卵过程,能有效地减少患者术后腹痛。在术后恶心、呕吐方面,两组出现此症状的患者均较少,对出现该症状的患者针刺双内关穴,经治疗,患者均述症状缓解,提示针刺能有效地缓解患者术后恶心、呕吐的症状。
结论:针刺麻醉具有疗效确切、生理干扰少的优势,更符合IVF-ET要求在最符合自然状态下实施的要求。电针介入IVF-ET患者取卵过程,能有效地减轻患者取卵时的疼痛,并减少术后腹痛的发生。
This paper from two aspects of theory and clinic discusses efficacy of analgesia for electro-acupuncture interventional therapy on patients with multiple oocyte aspiration process of in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer treating,and observes and analyzes the post-operative response.
Theoretical research:introducing a summary of the origin、development、action sphere and the keynote of acupuncture analgesia,emphasis on electro-acupuncture analgesia and its effect factors,discussing the necessity、feasibility、and efficacy of electro-acupuncture analgesia with the view of artificial supplementary reproduction,and also the advantages of electro-acupuncture analgesia compared with traditional anesthesia or analgesia way. Theoretical research indicated:electro-acupuncture getting involved in in-vitro fertilization and embryo transfer(IVF-ET) has scientific base and clinical necessity.
Clinical research:putting the 120 patients with multiple oocyte aspiration process into electro-acupuncture combined with medication group and medication group with the way of digital random grouping,testing the patients basic pain threshold and the max pain threshold、anxieties score before the operation,observing the pain of the operation and giving the grade and score of the pain,making the patients to give a valve of VAS,and recall the felling of latter operation,and also give a valve of VAS to judge the effect of analgesia.Observing the post-operative response of 1hour and 2-5 hour after the operation of the 111patients,the result suggested:1.observed from the view of patients,the VAS of electro-acupuncture combined with medication group is 20.55±2.67,the VAS of latter operation is 23.46±3.05,the VAS of medication group is 23.37±3.24,the VAS of latter operation is 24.10±3.34.The difference of the twice VAS of the electro-acupuncture combined with medication group has statistics meaning,p＜0.05.The difference of the twice VAS of the medication group doesn't have statistics meaning,p＞0.05.The difference between the two group of this operation doesn't have statistics meaning,p＞0.05.The result suggests that electro-acupuncture analgesia can release the pain of the operation.2.On the postoperative adverse reaction,there are 28 patients have abdominal pain in the total 59 patients of the electro-acupuncture combined with medication group,the rate of abdominal pain is 47.46%;there are 37 patients have abdominal pain in the total 52 patients of the medication group,the rate of abdominal pain is 71.15%.The difference of abdominal pain between the two group has statistics meaning,p＜0.05.The result suggests that electro-acupuncture interventional therapy can reduce postoperative adverse reaction.On the aspect of postoperative nausea and vomiting aspects,there are a few patients have those symptoms of both the two groups.For the patient with the symptoms of nausea and vomiting aspects,acupuncture at double Neiguan point can feel better.The result suggested that acupuncture can relive the symptoms of postoperative nausea and vomiting.
Conclusion:electro-acupuncture interventional therapy on patients with multiple oocyte aspiration process of in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer treating can release the pain of the operation,and reduce the abdominal pain of postoperative adverse reaction.
理论研究:综述了针剌镇痛的起源、发展、作用范围和特点,着重论述了针刺镇痛中使用最多的电针镇痛,以及电针镇痛疗效的影响因素,并从人工辅助生殖的角度论述采用电针镇痛的必要性、可行性及有效性,以及与传统麻醉或镇痛药物的比较优势。理论研究表明:电针介入IVF-ET具有科学依据和临床必要性及可行性。
临床研究:采用数字随机分组的方法,将120例多次IVF-ET治疗患者分为针药组和药物组,术前测试患者的基础痛阈和耐痛阈、焦虑评分,观察患者术中疼痛程度并予以评级评分,让患者在术后立即以视觉模拟评分法(visual analogue scales,VAS)评价疗效,并回忆最近一次取卵时的感受,以VAS评价疗效。观察患者术后1小时和术后2-5小时的术后不良反应情况。通过对最后纳入的111例病例的分析,结果提示:(1)从患者角度观察,针药组本次手术VAS值为20.55±2.67,上次手术VAS值为23.46±3.05;药物组本次手术VAS值为23.37±3.24,上次手术VAS值为24.10±3.34。针药组两次VAS值差异有显著性意义(p＜0.05);药物组两次VAS值差异无显著性意义(p＞0.05);针药组和药物组本次手术VAS值差异无显著性意义(p＞0.05),表明电针介入IVF-ET取卵过程,能有效地减轻术中疼痛。(2)在术后不良反应方面,术后1小时,针药组59例有28例发生腹痛,腹痛率为47.46%;药物组52例有37例发生腹痛,腹痛率为71.15%,两组差异有显著性意义(p＜0.05)。说明电针介入IVF-ET取卵过程,能有效地减少患者术后腹痛。在术后恶心、呕吐方面,两组出现此症状的患者均较少,对出现该症状的患者针刺双内关穴,经治疗,患者均述症状缓解,提示针刺能有效地缓解患者术后恶心、呕吐的症状。
结论:针刺麻醉具有疗效确切、生理干扰少的优势,更符合IVF-ET要求在最符合自然状态下实施的要求。电针介入IVF-ET患者取卵过程,能有效地减轻患者取卵时的疼痛,并减少术后腹痛的发生。
This paper from two aspects of theory and clinic discusses efficacy of analgesia for electro-acupuncture interventional therapy on patients with multiple oocyte aspiration process of in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer treating,and observes and analyzes the post-operative response.
Theoretical research:introducing a summary of the origin、development、action sphere and the keynote of acupuncture analgesia,emphasis on electro-acupuncture analgesia and its effect factors,discussing the necessity、feasibility、and efficacy of electro-acupuncture analgesia with the view of artificial supplementary reproduction,and also the advantages of electro-acupuncture analgesia compared with traditional anesthesia or analgesia way. Theoretical research indicated:electro-acupuncture getting involved in in-vitro fertilization and embryo transfer(IVF-ET) has scientific base and clinical necessity.
Clinical research:putting the 120 patients with multiple oocyte aspiration process into electro-acupuncture combined with medication group and medication group with the way of digital random grouping,testing the patients basic pain threshold and the max pain threshold、anxieties score before the operation,observing the pain of the operation and giving the grade and score of the pain,making the patients to give a valve of VAS,and recall the felling of latter operation,and also give a valve of VAS to judge the effect of analgesia.Observing the post-operative response of 1hour and 2-5 hour after the operation of the 111patients,the result suggested:1.observed from the view of patients,the VAS of electro-acupuncture combined with medication group is 20.55±2.67,the VAS of latter operation is 23.46±3.05,the VAS of medication group is 23.37±3.24,the VAS of latter operation is 24.10±3.34.The difference of the twice VAS of the electro-acupuncture combined with medication group has statistics meaning,p＜0.05.The difference of the twice VAS of the medication group doesn't have statistics meaning,p＞0.05.The difference between the two group of this operation doesn't have statistics meaning,p＞0.05.The result suggests that electro-acupuncture analgesia can release the pain of the operation.2.On the postoperative adverse reaction,there are 28 patients have abdominal pain in the total 59 patients of the electro-acupuncture combined with medication group,the rate of abdominal pain is 47.46%;there are 37 patients have abdominal pain in the total 52 patients of the medication group,the rate of abdominal pain is 71.15%.The difference of abdominal pain between the two group has statistics meaning,p＜0.05.The result suggests that electro-acupuncture interventional therapy can reduce postoperative adverse reaction.On the aspect of postoperative nausea and vomiting aspects,there are a few patients have those symptoms of both the two groups.For the patient with the symptoms of nausea and vomiting aspects,acupuncture at double Neiguan point can feel better.The result suggested that acupuncture can relive the symptoms of postoperative nausea and vomiting.
Conclusion:electro-acupuncture interventional therapy on patients with multiple oocyte aspiration process of in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer treating can release the pain of the operation,and reduce the abdominal pain of postoperative adverse reaction.
引文
[1]张丽珠.世界之交展望试管婴儿科技工作[J].生殖医学杂志.1998.7(4):195-198.
[2]陆桂月、耿建平.不孕不育的诊治进展.实用临床医学[J].2005.6(7):144-146
[3]Sabine M.Sator-Katzenschlager、Monika M.W(o|¨)lfler、Sibylle A.Kozek-Langenecker.Auricular electro-acupuncture as an additional perioperative analgesic method during oocyte aspiration in IVF treatment.Human reproduction[J].2006.11.(8):2114-2120
[4]韩济生.《针刺镇痛原理》(第一版)[M].上海科技教育出版社.1999.12:27、28、29、31-34、37、38-40、55、89
[5]陈怀龙、王明山、王世端.针刺麻醉的临床应用及前景展望.国际麻醉学与复苏杂志[J].2006.27(6):347-350
[6]张兆发、庄鼎.《电针基础与临床》(第一版)[M].中国科学技术出版社.1993.1:37-38
[7]郭惠夫,方圆,王晓民等.不同频率电针激活大鼠中枢神经系统不同部位的Fos蛋白表达.针刺研究.1994.19(3-4):52
[8]Han TS、Chen XH、Sun SL、et al.Effect of low and high frequency TENS on Metenkephalin-Arb-Phe and dynorphin A immuoreactivity in human lumbar CSF.Pain[J].1991.47(3):295
[9]韩济生.针刺镇痛频率特异性的进一步证明.针刺研究[J].2001.26(3):224
[10]韩济生.影响针刺镇痛效果的若干因素.针剌研究[J].1994.19(3-4):1
[11]李忠仁.《实验针灸学》(第一版)[M].中国中医药出版社.2003.1:154-155、166、241
[12]尹利华、李万山、招伟贤等.针刺麻醉在直肠癌手术中的作用.中国针灸[J].2005.25(12):876-878
[13]江澄川、赵志奇、蒋豪.《疼痛的基础与临床》(第一版)[M].上海复旦大学出版社、上海医科大学出版社.2001.7:168、169
[14]滕杨、刘峻.《内经》对疼痛机制的认识.中国临床康复[J].2005.9(24):191-192
[15]粟胜勇、邓柏颖、李扬帆等.经络“气伤”在痛证病机中的意义浅探.中医药学刊[J].2005.23(2):327
[16]鞠大宏、侯依泽.针刺镇痛的中医机理探讨.中国中医基础医学杂志[J].[998年8第4卷增刊(上):162-163、169-179
[17]何志晶.手术焦虑与心理护理.中华护理杂志[J].1996.31(7):43
[18]王元芝、吴红霞、潘庆华.对妇科术前病人进行心理干预效果的研究.护理研究[J].2004.18(9):1548-1550
[19]何广新、曲延华.疼痛针灸治疗学[M].中国中医药出版社 1994:119-12
[20]许培昌、李达良.疼痛患者对针灸信任度与针灸疗效关系的观察.中国针灸[J].2006.26(5):355-356
[21]Dahl JB,Monish S.Pre-emptive analgesia.Br Med Bull[J].2004.71:13-27
[22]殷光甫、林传友、曹福元等.针刺大鼠“曲池”和“臂臑”穴对“人中'、“禾髎”及“承浆”穴区SP利NPY免疫阳性神经的影响.同济医科大学学报[J].1997.26(4):266-270
[23]吴月兵、张灿珍、沈丽达.内源性阿片肤与电针镇痛的研究.医学综述.2005.11(1):81-82
[24]王金兰、娄季宇、王建祯.福尔马林致痛和针刺镇痛时大鼠脑内孤啡肽的变化.郑州大学学报(医学版)[J].2002.37(3):288-291
[25]杨波、殷光甫、曹福元等.电针对大鼠肠肌间丛神经元前脑啡肽原mRNA的影响.针刺研究[J].1999.24(2):135-137
[26]高秀、辛冰牧、朱崇斌等.大鼠鞘内注射多巴胺受体激动剂与拮抗剂对痛及针刺镇痛的影响.生理学报[J].1998.50(1):43-48
[27]姬广臣、张玉秋、马飞等.鞘内微量注射白细胞介素-1β对炎症痛敏反应和针刺镇痛作用的影响.针刺研究[J].2001.26(3):212-213
[28]黄彰海、孙文颖、刘昱等.创伤痛大鼠下丘脑背内侧核神经元放电变化及电针效应.第一军医大学学报.1996.16(1):9-11
[29]曾玲、胡世风、玉小玲等.刺激额叶皮层对丘脑腹后外侧核痛放电的影响及其与电针的关系.广西医科大学学报[J].1995.12(2):205-208
[30]吴红金、周雷、薛峥等.电针抗大鼠急性炎症性内脏痛的肠神经机制.针刺研究[J].1999.24(2):138-142
[31]雷亚宁、胡道松、茹立强.电针抗内脏牵拉痛肠神经机制的研究.针刺研究[J].1994.19(3-4):69-70
[32]罗美华、刘莲凤、周玉梅.疼痛评估量表在体温单上的临床应用.井冈山学院学报(自然科学)[J].2006.27.12:137-138
[33]赵继军、陆小英、赵存凤等.数字疼痛量表和描述疼痛量表的相关性研究和改进.Modern Nursing.2002.8(9):660-661
[34]涂冰、韦安阳.《不孕不育的诊断与治疗》(第一版)[M].人民军医出版社.2005.1:1
[35]陆桂月.耿建平,不孕不育的诊治进展,实用临床医学.2005.6(7):144-146
[36]付杰军.人类辅助生殖技术研究进展.生物学教学[J].2005.30(11):4-7
[37]经阴道超声引导穿刺取卵12例.耿丹明、朱建平.人民军医[J].2001.44(11):658-659
[38]Madjar S,Vativ O,Barbara J,et al,Diagnostic and therapeutic approach to sexually transmitted disease.Harefuah[J].1996.130:811
[39]Luo M,Zhang L,Xiao Y.The prevalence of Chlamydia trachomatis and Ureaplasma urealyticum cervical infection in infertility women and the observation of therapeutic efficacy.Hunan Yi Ke Da Xue Xue Bao[J].1998.23:444
[40]杨艳、胡敏.静脉麻醉下行人工流产道德探讨.实用护理杂志[J].1999.15(6):23-24
[41]林绮丽、李林娜.异丙酚不同给药速度在人工流产术中的应用研究.中国医师杂志[J].2004年增刊:234-235
[42]张玲、洪名云.异丙酚、芬太尼复合麻醉用于阴道取卵术的临床探讨.安徽医药[J].20048(6):414-415
[43]周寒鹰、师娟子、刘朝阳等.异丙酚用于经阴道取卵术的妊娠结局观察.国外医学妇幼保健分册[J].2004.15(5):313-314
[44]Sleigh J W,Stern R D A,Steyn R M L,et al.Cortical entropy changes with general anaesthesia:theory and experiment.Physiol Meas[J].2004,25(4):921-934
[45]边文会、郝威、陈惠娟等.穴位电刺激在人流镇痛中应用的临床研究.河北中医药学报[J]:2007.22(3):32-33
[46]夏海燕、李岩、冯坤等.异丙酚麻醉不同阶段对卵细胞受精和对早期胚胎质量的影响.中国优生与遗传杂志[J].2004.12(3):103-104、114
[47]蔡如鹏、庄芳芳.试管婴儿:技术仍有缺陷.中国新闻周刊[J].2007.3(5):52-53
[48]吴根诚、陈正秋、秦必光.优化针药复合麻醉和镇痛的临床及机理研究.针刺研究[J].2001.26(3):161-162
[49]Ann-Louise Gejervall、Elisabet Stener-Victorin、Anders M(o|¨)ller3.Electro-acupuncture versus conventional analgesia:a comparison of pain levels during oocyte aspiration and patients' experiences of well-being after surgery,human reproduction[J].2005.11(3):728-735
[50]罗惠煌、王雪珍、王永斌.52例骨转移癌放射治疗止痛效果分析.福建医药杂志[J].2006.28(6):50-52
[51]刘家瑛、韩颖、张宁等.电针刺激合谷穴对分娩的镇痛效果.国际中医中药杂志.2006.28(4):244-246
[52]曾永蕾.合谷配穴谈.针灸临床杂志[J].2006.22(12):45-46
[53]刘哲、杨柳、席时燕等.针刺对人工流产术扩宫镇痛作用的临床研究.中国针灸[J].1997.17(1):5-6
[54]李云、查炜.古代针灸歌赋论痛证.黑龙江中医药[J].2006.6:41-42
[55]朱俊峰、江伟.芬太尼复合鲁诺昔康用于妇科术后静脉镇痛.临床麻醉学杂志[J].2007.23(9):744-745
[56]王海霞.芬太尼透皮贴用于妇产科术后镇痛的临床效果观察.河南外科学杂志 [J].2002.8(5):60-61
[57]梁春玲、高瑞芳、王爱玲.针灸配合心理护理治疗术后疼痛的体会.职业与健康[J].2003.19(9):173
[58]刘仁玉,杭燕南.围术期恶心呕吐[A].杭燕南.当代麻醉与复苏[c].上海科学技术出版社.1994:612-620
[59]应时达.人工流产的无痛术.实用妇科与产科杂志[J],1992.6(8):293
[60]Rawal N.Epidural and spinal agents for postoperative analgesia.Sure Clin Nor Ame[J].1999,79(2):313-336.
[61]张立贤、彭亮、王家双.韩氏仪应用于妇科手术病人术后镇痛的临床研究.实用医学杂志[J].2001,17,(4):315-316
[62]张建民、吕世亭、刘伟国等,针刺麻醉在幕上开颅手术中的进一步临床应用研究,中国中西医结合杂志[J],2000.20(3):170
[63]肖亮、彭海东、蔡清萍.腹部针麻手术穴位选择和药物配伍研究进展.上海针灸杂志[J].2006.25(3):48-50
[2]陆桂月、耿建平.不孕不育的诊治进展.实用临床医学[J].2005.6(7):144-146
[3]Sabine M.Sator-Katzenschlager、Monika M.W(o|¨)lfler、Sibylle A.Kozek-Langenecker.Auricular electro-acupuncture as an additional perioperative analgesic method during oocyte aspiration in IVF treatment.Human reproduction[J].2006.11.(8):2114-2120
[4]韩济生.《针刺镇痛原理》(第一版)[M].上海科技教育出版社.1999.12:27、28、29、31-34、37、38-40、55、89
[5]陈怀龙、王明山、王世端.针刺麻醉的临床应用及前景展望.国际麻醉学与复苏杂志[J].2006.27(6):347-350
[6]张兆发、庄鼎.《电针基础与临床》(第一版)[M].中国科学技术出版社.1993.1:37-38
[7]郭惠夫,方圆,王晓民等.不同频率电针激活大鼠中枢神经系统不同部位的Fos蛋白表达.针刺研究.1994.19(3-4):52
[8]Han TS、Chen XH、Sun SL、et al.Effect of low and high frequency TENS on Metenkephalin-Arb-Phe and dynorphin A immuoreactivity in human lumbar CSF.Pain[J].1991.47(3):295
[9]韩济生.针刺镇痛频率特异性的进一步证明.针刺研究[J].2001.26(3):224
[10]韩济生.影响针刺镇痛效果的若干因素.针剌研究[J].1994.19(3-4):1
[11]李忠仁.《实验针灸学》(第一版)[M].中国中医药出版社.2003.1:154-155、166、241
[12]尹利华、李万山、招伟贤等.针刺麻醉在直肠癌手术中的作用.中国针灸[J].2005.25(12):876-878
[13]江澄川、赵志奇、蒋豪.《疼痛的基础与临床》(第一版)[M].上海复旦大学出版社、上海医科大学出版社.2001.7:168、169
[14]滕杨、刘峻.《内经》对疼痛机制的认识.中国临床康复[J].2005.9(24):191-192
[15]粟胜勇、邓柏颖、李扬帆等.经络“气伤”在痛证病机中的意义浅探.中医药学刊[J].2005.23(2):327
[16]鞠大宏、侯依泽.针刺镇痛的中医机理探讨.中国中医基础医学杂志[J].[998年8第4卷增刊(上):162-163、169-179
[17]何志晶.手术焦虑与心理护理.中华护理杂志[J].1996.31(7):43
[18]王元芝、吴红霞、潘庆华.对妇科术前病人进行心理干预效果的研究.护理研究[J].2004.18(9):1548-1550
[19]何广新、曲延华.疼痛针灸治疗学[M].中国中医药出版社 1994:119-12
[20]许培昌、李达良.疼痛患者对针灸信任度与针灸疗效关系的观察.中国针灸[J].2006.26(5):355-356
[21]Dahl JB,Monish S.Pre-emptive analgesia.Br Med Bull[J].2004.71:13-27
[22]殷光甫、林传友、曹福元等.针刺大鼠“曲池”和“臂臑”穴对“人中'、“禾髎”及“承浆”穴区SP利NPY免疫阳性神经的影响.同济医科大学学报[J].1997.26(4):266-270
[23]吴月兵、张灿珍、沈丽达.内源性阿片肤与电针镇痛的研究.医学综述.2005.11(1):81-82
[24]王金兰、娄季宇、王建祯.福尔马林致痛和针刺镇痛时大鼠脑内孤啡肽的变化.郑州大学学报(医学版)[J].2002.37(3):288-291
[25]杨波、殷光甫、曹福元等.电针对大鼠肠肌间丛神经元前脑啡肽原mRNA的影响.针刺研究[J].1999.24(2):135-137
[26]高秀、辛冰牧、朱崇斌等.大鼠鞘内注射多巴胺受体激动剂与拮抗剂对痛及针刺镇痛的影响.生理学报[J].1998.50(1):43-48
[27]姬广臣、张玉秋、马飞等.鞘内微量注射白细胞介素-1β对炎症痛敏反应和针刺镇痛作用的影响.针刺研究[J].2001.26(3):212-213
[28]黄彰海、孙文颖、刘昱等.创伤痛大鼠下丘脑背内侧核神经元放电变化及电针效应.第一军医大学学报.1996.16(1):9-11
[29]曾玲、胡世风、玉小玲等.刺激额叶皮层对丘脑腹后外侧核痛放电的影响及其与电针的关系.广西医科大学学报[J].1995.12(2):205-208
[30]吴红金、周雷、薛峥等.电针抗大鼠急性炎症性内脏痛的肠神经机制.针刺研究[J].1999.24(2):138-142
[31]雷亚宁、胡道松、茹立强.电针抗内脏牵拉痛肠神经机制的研究.针刺研究[J].1994.19(3-4):69-70
[32]罗美华、刘莲凤、周玉梅.疼痛评估量表在体温单上的临床应用.井冈山学院学报(自然科学)[J].2006.27.12:137-138
[33]赵继军、陆小英、赵存凤等.数字疼痛量表和描述疼痛量表的相关性研究和改进.Modern Nursing.2002.8(9):660-661
[34]涂冰、韦安阳.《不孕不育的诊断与治疗》(第一版)[M].人民军医出版社.2005.1:1
[35]陆桂月.耿建平,不孕不育的诊治进展,实用临床医学.2005.6(7):144-146
[36]付杰军.人类辅助生殖技术研究进展.生物学教学[J].2005.30(11):4-7
[37]经阴道超声引导穿刺取卵12例.耿丹明、朱建平.人民军医[J].2001.44(11):658-659
[38]Madjar S,Vativ O,Barbara J,et al,Diagnostic and therapeutic approach to sexually transmitted disease.Harefuah[J].1996.130:811
[39]Luo M,Zhang L,Xiao Y.The prevalence of Chlamydia trachomatis and Ureaplasma urealyticum cervical infection in infertility women and the observation of therapeutic efficacy.Hunan Yi Ke Da Xue Xue Bao[J].1998.23:444
[40]杨艳、胡敏.静脉麻醉下行人工流产道德探讨.实用护理杂志[J].1999.15(6):23-24
[41]林绮丽、李林娜.异丙酚不同给药速度在人工流产术中的应用研究.中国医师杂志[J].2004年增刊:234-235
[42]张玲、洪名云.异丙酚、芬太尼复合麻醉用于阴道取卵术的临床探讨.安徽医药[J].20048(6):414-415
[43]周寒鹰、师娟子、刘朝阳等.异丙酚用于经阴道取卵术的妊娠结局观察.国外医学妇幼保健分册[J].2004.15(5):313-314
[44]Sleigh J W,Stern R D A,Steyn R M L,et al.Cortical entropy changes with general anaesthesia:theory and experiment.Physiol Meas[J].2004,25(4):921-934
[45]边文会、郝威、陈惠娟等.穴位电刺激在人流镇痛中应用的临床研究.河北中医药学报[J]:2007.22(3):32-33
[46]夏海燕、李岩、冯坤等.异丙酚麻醉不同阶段对卵细胞受精和对早期胚胎质量的影响.中国优生与遗传杂志[J].2004.12(3):103-104、114
[47]蔡如鹏、庄芳芳.试管婴儿:技术仍有缺陷.中国新闻周刊[J].2007.3(5):52-53
[48]吴根诚、陈正秋、秦必光.优化针药复合麻醉和镇痛的临床及机理研究.针刺研究[J].2001.26(3):161-162
[49]Ann-Louise Gejervall、Elisabet Stener-Victorin、Anders M(o|¨)ller3.Electro-acupuncture versus conventional analgesia:a comparison of pain levels during oocyte aspiration and patients' experiences of well-being after surgery,human reproduction[J].2005.11(3):728-735
[50]罗惠煌、王雪珍、王永斌.52例骨转移癌放射治疗止痛效果分析.福建医药杂志[J].2006.28(6):50-52
[51]刘家瑛、韩颖、张宁等.电针刺激合谷穴对分娩的镇痛效果.国际中医中药杂志.2006.28(4):244-246
[52]曾永蕾.合谷配穴谈.针灸临床杂志[J].2006.22(12):45-46
[53]刘哲、杨柳、席时燕等.针刺对人工流产术扩宫镇痛作用的临床研究.中国针灸[J].1997.17(1):5-6
[54]李云、查炜.古代针灸歌赋论痛证.黑龙江中医药[J].2006.6:41-42
[55]朱俊峰、江伟.芬太尼复合鲁诺昔康用于妇科术后静脉镇痛.临床麻醉学杂志[J].2007.23(9):744-745
[56]王海霞.芬太尼透皮贴用于妇产科术后镇痛的临床效果观察.河南外科学杂志 [J].2002.8(5):60-61
[57]梁春玲、高瑞芳、王爱玲.针灸配合心理护理治疗术后疼痛的体会.职业与健康[J].2003.19(9):173
[58]刘仁玉,杭燕南.围术期恶心呕吐[A].杭燕南.当代麻醉与复苏[c].上海科学技术出版社.1994:612-620
[59]应时达.人工流产的无痛术.实用妇科与产科杂志[J],1992.6(8):293
[60]Rawal N.Epidural and spinal agents for postoperative analgesia.Sure Clin Nor Ame[J].1999,79(2):313-336.
[61]张立贤、彭亮、王家双.韩氏仪应用于妇科手术病人术后镇痛的临床研究.实用医学杂志[J].2001,17,(4):315-316
[62]张建民、吕世亭、刘伟国等,针刺麻醉在幕上开颅手术中的进一步临床应用研究,中国中西医结合杂志[J],2000.20(3):170
[63]肖亮、彭海东、蔡清萍.腹部针麻手术穴位选择和药物配伍研究进展.上海针灸杂志[J].2006.25(3):48-50