非线性视角下能源消费与经济增长关系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
人类进入工业化社会后,能源成为社会发展的重要物质基础。能源为人类的工业化过程提供了源源不断的动力支持。能源产量与消费量的多少,直接决定了一个国家工业化进程的速度。20世纪70年代,全球范围内出现了两次石油危机。这两次石油危机的出现直接促使人们意识到了能源对经济增长的重要作用,同时也使得人们意识到了资源约束可能对经济增长产生重要影响。因此,弄清能源消费与经济增长之间的内在依存关系问题是关于如何解能源消费、环境污染与经济发展内在矛盾首要的、必须面对的问题,该问题的厘清对合理的制定我国可持续发展的能源政策具有重要意义。本文主要基于非线性视角研究了我国的总能源消费及各分类型能源消费与我国经济增长之间的动态作用关系与格兰杰因果关系。
     本文通过非参数BDS检验与参数神经网络检验法对我国的能源经济系统中的非线性依存关系进行了检验。具体地,利用线性VAR系统,对我国总能源消费、煤炭消费、电力消费、石油消费与经济增长的线性相依成分进行过滤,并对其残差进行非线性特征检验。检验结果显示我国总能源消费、煤炭消费、电力消费、石油消费与经济增长的系统中均存在着非线性依存关系,两种检验方法得出的检验结果一致。该结论也与现实经济中的经济周期、油价波动、技术进步等因素与经济系统之间的复杂的交互作用一致。由此可以认为,单纯的从线性视角来考察能源消费与经济增长之间的相互关系,会掩盖由于各变量之间的非线性作用产生的结论。因此,对我国的能源经济系统的研究视角,应该从线性建模方式向非线性建模方式转变。
     通过马尔科夫向量自回归模型的研究表明:总能源消费与经济增长之间的长期作用关系显著,总能源消费对我国的经济增长有着重要的影响作用,经济增长对我国的总能源消费也有着显著的影响作用,二者的关系符合反馈理论;煤炭消费与经济增长之间的关系式相互影响的,煤炭消费对我国的经济增长有着重要的影响作用,经济增长对我国的煤炭消费也有着显著的影响作用,二者的关系符合反馈理论;石油消费与经济增长之间的关系式相互影响的,石油消费对我国的经济增长有着重要的影响作用,经济增长对我国的石油消费也有着显著的影响作用,二者的关系符合反馈理论;电力消费与经济增长之间的关系呈现出了新的特征,即在不同区制内电力消费与经济增长的作用关系呈现出非对称型特征。在经济适速增长期,电力消费与经济增长符合中性理论,而在经济快速增长区,电力消费与经济增长之间的关系符合增长理论。
     非线性非参数格兰杰因果关系表明,短期视角看来,总能源消费与GDP增长之间存在着双向非线性格兰杰因果关系,煤炭消费与GDP增长之间存在着由煤炭消费到GDP增长的单向非线性格兰杰因果关系,石油消费与GDP增长之间不存在非线性格兰杰因果关系,电力消费与GDP增长之间存在着由电力消费到GDP增长的单向非线性格兰杰因果关系。
     由上述研究可以看出,我国的能源消费对经济增长具有重要的影响和支撑作用。因此,能源保守政策的实施会对我国的经济增长产生一定的冲击。如何在实现低碳经济的前提下,保持经济的稳定增长,是政府面临的一个重要的课题。
Energy has become the critical material basis of social development ever sincethe beginning of industrial era. Energy provided continuous power support for humanbeings to progress towards industrialization, which makes energy production andconsumption the direct decisive factors of a country’s industrialization process. In the1970s, two rounds of global oil crisis alerted the whole world to realize the crucialimportance of energy on economic growth, and in the meantime, people began toaware that resource constraint may have an important effect on economic growth.Therefore, to fully understand the interdependences between energy consumption andeconomic growth is the primary and inescapable issue to confront with if we want tosolve the inherent contradictions between energy consumption, environmentalpollution and economic development. Moreover, the clarification of this issue is alsoof great significance for our country to formulate sustainable development energypolicies. The purpose of this study is to examine the dynamic interaction relationshipsand Granger causalities between total energy consumption, energy consumptions indifferent sectors and economic growth in China.
     The Nonparametric BDS test and Parametric Neural Network test approacheswere employed to test the nonlinear dependency relationships in our country’s energyeconomic system. To be specific, linear VAR system was utilized to filter out thelinear dependency relationships existing between total energy consumption, coalconsumption, electricity consumption, oil consumption and economic growth, andtest the nonlinear features of corresponding residuals. The test results indicatednonlinear dependency relationships between total energy consumption, coalconsumption, electricity consumption, oil consumption and economic growth, and thetwo test approaches yielded consistent results. In addition, the findings in this researchwere also consistent with the complicated interactions between typical factors of realeconomy, such as economic cycle, oil price fluctuation, and technical progress, andeconomic system. Based on the reasons above, simply considering the linearinteractions between energy consumption and economic growth may mask the trueresults due to the nonlinear interactions between variables. As a consequence,research on energy economy system in our country should begin to transfer fromlinear modeling approach to nonlinear modeling approach.
     The Markov vector autoregressive model results indicated that a significant longterm interaction existed between total energy consumption and economic growth with total energy consumption had an important impact on economic growth and vice versa,and the relationship between the two was consistent with the feedback theory.Moreover, the relationship between coal consumption and economic growth wasmutual interactive with coal consumption had an important influence on economicgrowth and economic growth positively affected coal consumption, and therelationship between the two was consistent with the feedback theory. Similarly, therelationship between oil consumption and economic growth was also mutualinteractive with oil consumption had an important influence on economic growth andeconomic growth positively affected oil consumption, and the relationship betweenthe two was consistent with the feedback theory. However, the relationship betweenelectricity consumption and economic growth displayed new features, that was theinteraction between electricity consumption and economic growth presentedasymmetry characteristics in different regions. In regions with optimum growth speed,the relationship between electricity consumption and economic growth accorded withthe Neutral Theory; whereas in regions with rapid growth speed, the relationshipbetween electricity consumption and economic growth corresponded to GrowthTheory.
     Nonlinear nonparametric Granger causalities showed that looking from the shortrun, bi-directional nonlinear Granger causalities presented between total energyconsumption and GDP growth; one-way nonlinear Granger causality presented fromcoal consumption to GDP growth; no significant nonlinear Granger causality wasdetected between oil consumption and GDP growth; and one-way nonlinear Grangercausality presented from electricity consumption to GDP growth
     Based on the research above, we can come to the conclusion that energyconsumption does significantly impact and support the growth of the economy in ourcountry. Therefore, the implementation of conservative energy policies will to someextent shock the development of our economy. How to stabilize the development ofthe economy under the premises of achieving low-carbon economy will be a toughissue for the government to handle in the near future.
引文
[1] BP能源统计年鉴2012
    [2]李振名.能源消费与经济增长—基于中国的实证研究:[博士学位论文],上海;复旦大学,2010
    [3]杨明.传统增量近极限经济发展亟待能源变革中国工业报2013年2月27日第A02版
    [4] Liao H., Wei Y. M. China's energy consumption: A perspective from Divisiaaggregation approach[J]. Energy,2010,(35):28-34
    [5] Yang H. Y. A note on the causal relationship between energyand GDP inTaiwan[J].Energy Economics,2000,(22):309-317
    [6] Yuan J., Kang J., Zhao C., Hu Z. Energy consumption and economic growth:evidence from China at both aggregated and disaggregated levels[J].EnergyEconomics,2008,(30):3077-3094
    [7] Saria R., Ewingc B. T., Soytasb U. The relationship between disaggregate energyconsumption andindustrial production in the United States: An ARDLapproach[J].Energy Economics,2008,(30):2302-2313
    [8] De Bruyn S. M., Van der Bergh J. C. J. M., Opschoor J. B. Economic Growth andEmissions: Reconsidering the Empirical Base of Environmental KuznetsCurves[J]. Ecological Economics,1998,(25):161-175.
    [9] Lindmark M. An EKC-pattern in Historical Perspective: Carbon DioxideEmissions, Technology,Fuel Pricesand Growth in Sweden,1870-1997[J].Ecological Economics,2002,(42):333-347.
    [10]Dinda S. Environmental Kuznets Curve Hypothesis: A Survey[J].EcologicalEconomics,2004,(49):431–455
    [11]杨子晖.经济增长”与“二氧化碳排放”关系的非线性研究:基于发展中国家的非线性Granger因果检验[J],世界经济,2010(10):139-160
    [12]Chiou-Wei S. Z., Chen C F, Zhu Z. Economic growth and energy consumptionrevisited—evidence from linear and nonlinear Granger causality[J]. EnergyEconomics,2008,(30):3063-3076
    [13]Lee C. C.. Energy consumption and GDP in developing countries: a cointegratedpanel analysis [J]. Energy Economics,2005,(27):415–427
    [14]吴彤,复杂性概念研究及其意义[J].中国人民大学学报,2004(5):2-9
    [15]成思危,复杂性科学探索(论文集)[M].北京,民主与建设出版社,1999
    [16]Levin,S.A. Fragile dominion: Complexity and the commons[M].Reading: PerseusBooks,1999
    [17]Gell-Mann, M. The quark and the jaguar: Adventures in the simple and thecomplex[M]. W.H. New York: Freeman and Company,1994
    [18]傅沂,产业变迁中的路径依赖研究:[博士学位论文],广州;暨南大学,2006
    [19]彭方平. STR模型及我国货币政策传导非线性研究:[博士学位论文].武汉;华中科技大学,2007
    [20]Fama.The behavior of stock-market prices[J].The Journal of Business,1965,(38):34-106.
    [21]Granger. Overview of nonlinear macroeconometric models[J]. MacroeconomicDynamics,2001,(5):466-481
    [22]王少平,彭方平.我国通货膨胀与通货紧缩的非线性转换[J].经济研究,2006,(8):35-42
    [23]HANSEN B E, SEO B. Testing for two-regime threshold cointegration in vectorerror-correction models[J]. Journal of Econometrics,2002,10:293-318
    [24]林伯强,高级能源经济学[M].北京,中国财经出版社:13-16
    [25]Solow, Robert M.A. Contribution to the Theory of EconomicGrowth[J].Quarterly Journal Economics,1956,(70):65-94
    [26]Romer,Paul M. Increasing Return and Long-Run Growth[J.Journal PoliticalEconomy,1986,(94):1002-1037
    [27]Romer,Paul M.Endogenous Technological Change[J].Journal Political Economy1990,(98):71-102.
    [28]Romer Paul M. Growth Based on Increasing Return Due toSpecialization[J].American Economic Review,1987,(77):56-62
    [29]Schultz. Theodare W. Institution and the Rising Economic Value ofMan[J].American Journal Agricultural Economics,1968,(50):1113-1122
    [30]Lucas,Robert E.Jr. On the Mechanism of Economic Development[J].Journal ofMonetary Economics,1988,(22):3-22
    [31]SolowR.M. Intergenerational Equity and Exhaustible Resourees [J]. Review ofEconomic Studies41, SymPosium on the economies of Exhaustible Resources,1974:29-45
    [32]Hartwick, John M. Intergenerational Equity and the Investment of Rents fromExhaustible Resources" American Economic Review,1977(67),972-74
    [33]肖文,唐兆希.可再生资源中间产品质量与可持续发展[J],世界经济2012(2):143-159
    [34]Dasgupta P S and Heal G M. Optimal Growth and Exhaustible Resources[J].Review of Economic Studies,1974,(41):3-28
    [35]Stiglitz.Growth with Exhaustible Natural Resources: Efficient and OptimalGrowth Paths[J].Review of Economic Studies,1974(41):123-137
    [36]William D. Nordhaus. Lethal Model2: The Limits to Growth RevisitedBrookings Papers on Economic Activity, Economic Studies Program[J], TheBrookings Institution,1992,(2):1-60
    [37]Hartwick J. M. Intergenerational Equity and the Investing of Rents fromExhaustible Resources[J].American Economic Review1977,(67):972-974
    [38]Barbier, Edward B., Markandya, Anil, The conditions for achievingenvironmentally sustainable development[J] European Economic Review1990(34):659-669.
    [39]Common, Mick, and Charles Perrings. Towards an Ecologica Economics ofSustainability[J]. Ecological Economics1992(6):7-34.
    [40]Beltratti, Andrea, Heal, Geoffrey M. and Chichilnisky Graciela, SustainableGrowth and the Green Golden Rule[R]1995
    [41]Partha Dasgupta. An Inquiry into Well-Being and Destitution[M]. Oxford:Clarendon,1993
    [42]Atkinson, W. DuBourg. The economics of sustainabledevelopment[J], AnnualReview of Energy and the Environment,1994,(19):457-474
    [43]DouglasB Reynolds.Entropy and DiminishingElastieity of Substitution[J],Resources poliey,1999,(25):51-55
    [44]Alain Ayong Le Kama.Preservation and exogenous uncertain futurepreferences[J].Economic Theory,2001,(3):745-752.
    [45]Simone Valente. Sustainable Development, Renewable Resources andTechnological Progress[J], Environmental&Resource Economics,2005,(1):115-125
    [46]Bovenberg, A Lans&Smulders, Sjak A, Transitional Impacts of EnvironmentalPolicy in an Endogenous Growth Model[J]. International Economic Review,1996,(4):861-893
    [47]Schou P. A Growth Model with Technological Progress and Non-renewableResources. mimeo, University of Copenhagen1996
    [48]Smulders S. Entropy Environment,and Endogenous Economic Growth[J].International Tax and Public Finance,1995,(2):319-340.
    [49]Grimaud, Andre&Rouge, Luc. Polluting non-renewable resources, innovationand growth: welfare and environmental policy[J] Resource and EnergyEconomics,2005,27(2):109-129
    [50]Grimaud A, Rouge L. Non-renewable resources andgrowth with verticalinnovations:optimum,equilibrium and economic policies[J].Journal ofEnvironmental E-conomics and Management,2003,45(2):433-453.
    [51]蒲勇健,经济增长方式的数量刻画与产业结构调整:一个理论模型[J].经济科学,1997,(2):24-31
    [52]蒲勇健杨秀苔.资源约束下的可持续经济增长内生技术进步模型[J],科技与管,1999,(2):4-8
    [53]王海建.耗竭性资源、R&D与内生经济增长模型[J].系统工程理论方法应用,1999,(3):38-42
    [54]王海建.耗竭性资源管理与人力资本积累内生经济增长[J].管理工程学报,2000,(3):11-13
    [55]周少波胡适耕.自然资源与经济增长模型的动态分析[J],武汉大学学报(理学版),2003,(5):585-588
    [56]杨宏林田立新丁占文.能源约束与“干中学”经济增长模型[J],企业经济,2004,(6):93-95
    [57]KRAFT J, KRAFT A. On the Relationship between Energy and GNP[J]. Journalof Energy Development,1978,(3):401–403
    [58]Akarca A.T., Long T.V. On the Relationship Between Energy and GNP: AReexamination[J].Journal of Energy and Development,1980,(5):326-331
    [59]E. Yu, J. Choi.The causal relationship between energy and GNP: an internationalcomparison [J]. Energy Dev.,1985,10(2):249–272
    [60]E.S.H. Yu, J.C. Jin.Cointegration tests of energy consumption, income, andemployment[J] J.Resour. Energy,1992,14(3):259-266
    [61]Hwang, D., Gum, B. The causal relationship between energy and GNP: the caseof Taiwan[J]. Energy Dev.1992,(12):219-226.
    [62]Masih A.M. M., Masih R. Energy Consumption Real Income and TemporalCausality: Results from A Multi-Country Study Based on Cointegration andError-Correction Modeling Techniques [J].Energy Economics,1996,(3):165–183
    [63]Glasure, Y. U., Lee, A. R. Cointegration Error-Correction, and the Relationshipbetween GDP and Energy: The case of South Korea and Singapore[J]. ResourceEnergy Economics,1997,(20):17-25
    [64]Cheng S. B., Lai T. W. An investigation of cointegration and causality betweenenergy consumption and economic activity in Taiwan Province ofChina[J].Energy Economic,1997,(19):435-444
    [65]U. Soytas, R. Sari.Energy consumption and GDP: causality relationship in G-7countries and emerging markets[J],Energy Econ.,2003,25(1):33–37
    [66]Fatai K,Oxley L,Scrimgeour F G. Modeling the causal relation-ship betweenenergy and GDP in New Zealand, Australia, India,Indonesia,the Philippinesand Thailand[J]. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation,2004,(64):431-445
    [67]Wolde-Rufael Y. Disaggregated industrial energy consumption and GDP: Thecase of Shanghai1952–1999[J]. Energy Economics,2004,(26):69-75.
    [68]Lee C. C. Energy consumption and GDP in developing countries: a cointegratedpanel analysis [J]. Energy Economics,2005,(27):415–427
    [69]Al-Iriani M. A. Energy–GDP relationship revisited: an example from GCCcountries using panel causality[J]. Energy Policy,2006,(34):3342–3350
    [70]Lee C. C., Chang C. P. The impact of energy consumption on economic growth:Evidence from linear and nonlinear models inTaiwan[J].Energy,2007,(32):2282-2294
    [71]Huang, Bwo-Nung, M. J. Hwang, and C. W. Yang, Causal RelationshipBetween Energy Consumption and GDP Growth Revisited:A Dynamic PanelData Approach[J]. Ecological Economics,2008,67(1),41-54
    [72]Stem,D., Energy Use and Economic Growth in the USA,a MultivariateApproach[J],Energy economic1993,(15):137-150.
    [73]Masih A.M. M., Masih R.A multivariate cointegrated modelling approach intesting temporal causality between energy consumption, real income and priceswith an application to twoAsian LDCs[J]. AppliedEconomics,1998,(30):1287-1289
    [74]John Asafu-Adjaye. The relationship between energy consumption, energy priceand economic growth: time series evidence from Asian developing countries[J]. Energy Economics,2000(22):615-625
    [75]Hondroyiannis,G., Lolos, S., and Papapetrou, E. Energy consumption andeconomic growth: assessing the evidence from Greece[J], Energy Economics,2002,(24),319-336.
    [76]Oh W,Lee K.Causal Relationship between Energy Consumption and GDPRevisited: the case of Korea1970-1999[J]Energy Economics,2004,26(1):51-59.
    [77]Ghali K. H., El-Sakka M. I. T. Energy use and output growth in Canada: amultivariate cointegration analysis[J]. Energy Economics,2004,(2):225-238
    [78]Lee, C.C. and C.P. Chang, Energy consumption and economic growth in Asianeconomies: A morecomprehensive analysis using panel data[J], Resource andEnergy Economics,2008(1):50-65.
    [79]J.E. Payne. On the dynamics of energy consumption and output in the US[J] Appl.Energy,2009,(4):575–577
    [80]Gross C.. Explaining the (non-) causalitybetween energy and economic growthin the U.S.—A multivariate sectoral analysis[J].Energy Economics,2012,(34):489-499
    [81]Hamilton J. D. What is an oil shock[J]. Journal of Econometrics,2003,(2):363-398
    [82]Lee C. C., Chang C. P. The impact of energy consumption on economic growth:Evidence from linear and nonlinear models inTaiwan[J].Energy,2007,(32):2282-2294
    [83]Huang B. N., Hwang M. J., Yang C. W. Does more energy consumption bolstereconomic growth? An application of the nonlinear threshold regression model[J].Energy Policy,2008,(36):755-767
    [84]FALLAHI F. Causal relationship between energy consumption (EC) and GDP:AMarkov-switching (MS) causality[J]. Energy,2011,(36):4165-4170
    [85]魏斌贤.经济持续增长的能源障碍及其对策[J],能源工程,1996,(2):1-6
    [86]陈书通.我国未来经济增长与能源消费关系[J],中国工业经济,1996,(9):21-26
    [87]林伯强.电力消费与中国经济增长:基于生产函数的研究[J].管理世界,2003,(11):18-27
    [88]张明慧,李永峰.我国能源生产和消费增长的周期性波动探析[J].煤炭经济研究2006,(7):29-33
    [89]韩智勇,魏一鸣.中国能源消费与经济增长的协整性与因果关系分析[J].系统工程,2004(12):17-20.
    [90]马超群,储慧斌,李科.周四清.中国能源消费与经济增长的协整与误差校正模型研究[J].系统工程,2004,(10):47-50
    [91]田晓飞杨志勇.关于中国的能源消费与经济增长的实证研究[J].科技信息2008,(4):75-77
    [92]杨朝峰,陈伟忠.能源消费和经济增长:基于中国的实证研究[J].石油大学学报(社会科学版),2005,(2):18一21
    [93]贡兴振,杨宝臣,中国能源消费与经济增长的协整关系分析[J].哈尔滨理工大学学报,2005,(8):117一119
    [94]王海鹏,田澎,靳萍,中国电力消费与经济增长的变参数协整关系[J]华北电力大学学报2005,(4):48-51
    [95]范雪红,张意翔.基于计量经济模型的能源消费与经济增长关系研究[J]理论月刊2005,(12):78-81
    [96]黄敏,赫英.中国能源消费与经济增长关系的模型与实证[J]统计与决策2006,(22):69-71
    [97]刘朝明,曾胜,刘博.我国能源消费与经济增长的关联模型分析[J].华东经济管理,2006,(11):29-34
    [98]王海鹏,田澎,靳萍.基于变参数模型的中国能源消费经济增长关系研究[J].数理统计与管理,2005,25(3):253~258
    [99]晏正春,彭莉莎,岳大波.我国能源消费与经济增长关系的数量分析[J],商场现代化2006(27):40-41
    [100]赵进文,范继涛.经济增长与能源消费内在依从关系的实证研究[J].经济研究,2007,(8):13-25
    [101]周建.经济转型期中国能源需求的长期均衡及短期波动:1978-2005[J].南开经济研究,2007,(03):3-18
    [102]徐小斌,李传昭,徐锦绣,徐小凤.中国东西部省份能源消耗与经济增长关系比较研究一基于面板数据的协整分析仁[J].科技管理研究,2008,(5):132一134
    [103]王火根,沈利生.中国经济增长与能源消费空间面板分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2007,(12):98-108
    [104]王火根,沈利生.中国经济增长与能源消费关系研究-基于中国30省市面板数据的实证检验[J].统计与决策,2008,(3):125-128
    [105]王建林,赵佳佳.能源消费与经济增长的因果关系测度与分析-基于中国样本[J]工业技术经济,2008(1):86~91
    [106]杨宜勇,池振合.中国能源消费与经济增长关系研究-基于误差修正模型[J].经济与管理研究,2009(09):39-45
    [107]尹建华,王兆华.中国能源消费与经济增长间关系的实证研究:基于1953-2008年数据的分析[J].科研管理,2011,(07):122-129
    [108]高斌,甘法岭.我国能源消费与经济增长的实证研究[J],金融经济,2010,(10):88-89
    [109]胡彩梅,韦福雷.中国区域能源消费与经济增长关系-基于面板数据的实证分析[J],经济问题探索,2010(12):77-87
    [110]曾胜.中国能源消费、经济增长与能源需求预测的研究[J],管理评论2011,(2):38-44
    [111]谭元发.能源消费与工业经济增长的协整与ECM分析[J],统计与决策,2011,(4):89-91
    [112] JUMBLE C B L. Cointegration and causality between electricityconsumption and GDP: Empirical evidence from Malawi[J]. Energy Economics,2004,(1):61–68.
    [113] ALTINAY G,KARAGOL E. Electricity consumption and economic growth:Evidence from Turkey[J].,Energy Economics,2005,(27):849–856
    [114] SHIU A, Lam P L.Electricity consumption and economic growth inChina[J]. Energy Policy,2004,(32):47–54.
    [115] GHOSH S. Electricity consumption and economic growth in India[J]. EnergyPolicy,2002,(30):125–129.
    [116] YOO S H. The causal relationship between electricity consumption andeconomic growth in the ASEAN countries[J].Energy Policy,2006,(34):3573-3582.
    [117] Volkan S,Edigem,Sertac,Akar.ARIMA Forecasting of Primary EnergyDemand by Fuel in Turkey[J]. Energy Policy,2007,(35):1701~1708
    [118]梁巧梅,魏一鸣,范英.中国能源需求和能源强度预测的情景分析模型及其应用[J].管理学报,2004,l(1):62-66
    [119]周倩,黄树红,李爱军.湖北省能源需求预测及分析[J].统计与决策,2007,(4):89-90.
    [120]徐明德,李维杰.线性回归分析与能源需求预测[J].内蒙古师范大学学报,2003,(3):17-20.
    [121]陈洪涛,周德群.基于GM(1,1)模型的中国能源消费预测研究[J].矿业研究与开发,2007,(7):77-79
    [122]梁娜,张吉刚.基于灰色RBF网络的我国能源消费预测[J].佳木斯大学学报:自然科学版,2008,(2):224-226.
    [123]黄俊,周猛,王俊海. ARMA模型在中国能源消费预测中的应用[J].统计与决策,2004,(12):49-50.
    [124]卢奇,顾培亮,邱世明.组合预测模型在我国能源消费系统中的建构及应用[J].系统工程理论与实践,2003,(3):24-30
    [125]卢二坡.组合模型在我国能源需求预测中的应用[J].数理统计与管理,2006,(5):505-511
    [126] DUNKERLEY J. Estimation of energy demand: the developing countries.Energy Journal[J],1982,(3):79-99.
    [127]陈宗胜,任重,周云波.中国经济发展奇迹的本质和特征研究:基于改革开放30年的路径演化分析[J].财经研究,2009,(5):4-16
    [128]钞小静惠康中国经济增长质量的测度[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2009,(6):75-86
    [129]赵凌云向新,1979-2001年中国经济增长格局的历史剖析[J].中国经济史研究,2005,(1):123-132
    [130]袁志刚,何樟勇.以新的视角审视当前中国宏观经济增长[J].经济研究,2004,(7):38-47
    [131]刘树成.论中国经济周期波动的新阶段[J].经济研究,1996,(11):3-10
    [132]孔令丞.论中国产业结构优化升级[博士学位论文]北京,中国人民大学;2003
    [133]魏一鸣,廖华.能源效率的七类测度指标及其测度方法[J].中国软科学2010,(1):128-137
    [134]魏楚,沈满洪.能源效率研究发展及趋势:一个综述[J].浙江大学学报(人文社科),2009,(3):55-63
    [135] Jonathan E. Sinton. Accuracy and Reliability of China’ s EnergyStatistics[J].China Economic Review,2001,(12):373-383.
    [136] Xiaolu Wang, Lian Meng.A Reevaluation of China’ s EconomicGrowth[J].C hina Econom ic Review,2001,(12):338-346.
    [137]史丹.我国经济增长过程中能源利用效率的改进[J].经济研究,2002,(9):49-56
    [138]王美今等译.金融中的统计方法[M].上海格致出版社2004:291
    [139]张晓峒.计量经济学基础[M].天津:南开大学出版社,2001
    [140] Teraesvirta T., Lin C.F., Granger C.W.J. Power of the Neural NetworkLinearity Test[J]. Journalof Time Series Analysis1993,(14):209–220
    [141] Diks C., Panchenko V. A new statistic and practical guidelines fornonparametric Granger causality testing[J]. Journal of Economic Dynamics andControl,2006,(30):1647–1669

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700