员工的社会比较及其与工作压力的关系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
社会比较是指个体以他人为参照,来评估自己的状况。人与人之间的比较是生活的重要组成部分,个体通过社会比较来评价外界信息,并因其结果而受到积极或消极影响。社会比较作为一种社会现象具有复杂性。本研究侧重于两个方面:社会比较倾向和社会比较效应。社会比较倾向是指个体在社会比较需求上表现出的人格特征,具体分为能力比较倾向和观念比较倾向两个维度。社会比较效应是指在社会比较过程中产生的两种不同的结果:同化效应和对比效应。在文献与理论研究基础上采用统计测量方法分别考察了二者与员工工作压力之间的关系。具体包括:
     第一部分:社会比较倾向和工作压力的关系研究。
     采用以下三个量表进行测查:由Gibbon和Buunk编制的《社会比较倾向量表》,包括能力比较倾向和观念比较倾向两个因子,用于测量员工对他人相关信息的敏感性程度;由陈苏彰编制的《工作压力量表》,包括焦虑、疲劳、忧郁、低自尊四种因子,用于测量员工在工作情境中,受到某些因素的影响所由此而引发的紧张和不舒适的状态。测查通过随机抽样的方式,包括不同企业性质、年龄段、职位、学历的员工共264名作为施测对象,采用方差分析、相关分析、回归分析等统计分析方法对数据进行处理,研究结果发现:
     (1)员工的能力比较倾向显著高于观念比较倾向;不同人口学变量在观念比较倾向上没有显著差异,而不同婚姻状况、年龄、单位类别的企业员工的能力比较倾向差别显著,具体包括:婚姻状况为离异或丧偶的个体其能力比较倾向在0.01水平上显著高于未婚、已婚的个体;40-49岁之间的员工的能力比较倾向在0.05水平上显著高于其他年龄段的员工;民营企业员工的能力比较倾向在0.01水平上显著低于中外合资企业员工。
     (2)员工的社会比较倾向总分与工作压力总分呈显著正相关,能力比较倾向对工作压力有正面影响;观念比较倾向对工作压力有负面影响。
     第二部分:社会比较效应和工作压力的关系研究。
     采用两个量表进行测量:由Karen等人编制的《社会比较效应量表》,包括上行-认同、上行-对比、下行-认同、下行-对比四个分量表,分别用于测量员工在上行比较时的认同效应和对比效应,下行比较时的认同效应和对比效应;《工作压力量农》与第一部分同。采用相关分析和回归分析等统计分析方法对数据进行处理,研究结果发现:
     (1)不同职位、工作年限的企业员工在社会效应上有显著差别,具体如下:高层管理者的社会比较下行-同化效应在0.05水平上显著高于其他职位的员工;工龄高的员工,社会比较下行-对比效应在0.01水平上显著高于工龄低的员工。
     (2)上行-认同效应对工作压力有负面影响,上行-对比效应、下行-认同效应、下行-对比效应对工作压力有正面影响。
     (3)在社会比较倾向各维度和社会比较效应各维度的相关分析中,只有上行-同化效应与能力比较倾向之问相关不显著。社会比较倾向对工作压力各维度的标准回归方程和社会比较效应对工作压力各维度的标准回归方程之间呈对应关系,其中,观念比较倾向和上行认同效应都分别进入了低自尊、忧郁因子的回归方程,且都是负面影响;能力比较倾向和下行认同都分别进入了疲劳、忧郁因子的回归方程,且都是正面影响;能力比较倾向和上行对比、下行认同、下行对比都分别进入了焦虑因子的回归方程,且都是正面影响。
Social comparison is that the individuals use others as a reference to evaluate their own situation. The comparison to other people is an important part of life, the individual evaluates the outside world based on the social comparison information, and to be affected positively or negatively by its results. Social comparison as a social phenomenon is complex. This study focuses on two aspects:social comparison orientation and social comparison effects. Social comparison orientation refers to the personality character on the need to do social comparison. There is two different outcomes generated in the process of social comparison:identification effect and contrast effect. Based on literature review, we research the relationship between social comparison orientation/social comparison effects and the job stress through statistical measuring methods. The specific research can be summarized as follows:
     Part I:the research of the relationship between social comparison orientation and job stress.
     Iowa-Netherlands Comparison Orientation Measure(INCOM) was used to measure the workerss' sensitivity to other person's information, it is comprised of 2 factors:ability comparison orientation and opinion comparison orientation. Job Stress Scale was used to measure the workers' tension and discomfort state caused by certain factors in the work context, it is comprised of 4 factors:Anxiety, fatigue, depression and low self-esteem. we choose 264 workers as subjects through the method of random sampling, which is included different type of enterprises, age and positions. The statistical analysis for data include Multivariate ANOVA, Correlation Analysis, Regression Analysis and so on, the results state as follows:
     (1)The ability comparison orientation is significantly higher than opinion comparison orientation. Ability comparison orientation exists significant difference among marital status, age and the type of enterprises, but no difference are found on opinion comparison orientation, the details is as follows:the score of the workers who are divorced or Widowed on Ability comparison orientation is significantly higher than that of the workers who are married or unmarried at the level of 0.01;The score of the workers of 40-49 years old on Ability comparison orientation is significantly higher than that of the workers of other age at the level of 0.05; The score of the workers of the Private enterprise on ability comparison orientation is significantly higher than that of the workers of joint-venture enterprise.
     (2) The social comparison orientation has a positive correlation with job stress. Ability comparison orientation has positive effect on job stress, but opinion comparison orientation has negative effect on job stress.
     PartⅡ:the research of relationship between social comparison effects and job stress.
     Social Comparison Effects Scale which is comprised of four subsidies is used to measure the four results generated in the process of social comparison:upward identification and contrast, downward identification and contrast. The Job Stress Scale is as same as the partⅠ. The results is as follows:
     (1) The score of the workers who are Senior managers on downward identification is significantly higher than that of the workers in other positions at the level of 0.05; The score of the workers whose length of employment is long on downward identification is significantly higher than that of the workers whose length of employment is short at the level of 0.01.
     (2) The upward identification has negative effect on job stress. the upward contrast, downward identification and downward contrast has positive effect on job stress.
     (3) The relationship between social comparison orientation and social comparison effects are studied. Correlation analysis shows that just the upward identification and the ability comparison orientation are not correlated significantly. The standard regression equations of job stress on social comparison orientation correspond with the standard regression equations of job stress on Social Comparison Effects, the details is as follows:the opinion comparison orientation and upward identification have respectively entered the regression equations for low self-esteem and fatigue, their functions are all negative; the ability comparison orientation and downward identification have respectively entered the regression equations for low self-esteem and depression, their functions are all positive; the ability comparison orientation and downward identification, downward contrast, upward contrast have respectively entered the regression equations for Anxiety, their functions are all negative.
引文
[1]Gilbert P. Price J. Allan S.1995. Social comparison. Social attractiveness and evolution:How might they be related? New Idea in Psychology 13:149-165
    [2]Klein W.M.,objective standards are not enough:Affective, self-evaluative, and behavioral responses social comparison information, journal of personality and social psycholoty,1997,72:763-774.
    [3]Gibbons, F.X.&Buukn, B.P.(1999), Individual diefferences in social comparison: The development of a scale of social comparison orientation, Journal of Personality and social Psychology,76,129-142
    [4]埃里克森;《儿童与社会》,英文版,259页,1963。
    [5]白红敏,许莹,张荣华.大学生社会比较与主观幸福感的关系研究.中国健康心理学杂志.2009,17(4):418-420
    [6]Gibbons, F.X.&Buukn, B.P.(1999), Individual diefferences in social comparison:The development of a scale of social comparison orientation, Journal of Personality and social Psychology,76,129-142.
    [7]吴伟社.公务员工作压力、工作满意度和工作倦怠关系研究[D].西安市:西北大学,2008.
    [8]Karen Van der Zee, Bram Buunk, Robbert Sanderman, Gerrit Botke, Fons van den Bergh. Social comparison and coping with cancer treatment. Personality and individual differences,2000,28:17-34
    [9]Festinger L. A theory of social comparison Processes. Human Relations, 1954,7:117-140
    [10]黎琳.(2006)大学生的社会比较与情绪健康.博士论文.华东师范大学
    [11]Suls J M, Wheeler L. Handbook of social comparison:Theory and research. New York:Plenum press,2000
    [12]张保,孔凡兰,赵玉芳.社会比较研究概述.科技信息.2008,31:340-390
    [13]Gilbert,D.T., Giesler,R.B., and Morris.k.a.. When Comparison Arise[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1995,69:227-236.
    [14]史文妍.(2008).初中生社会比较特点与心理健康的相关研究.硕士学位论文.四川师范大学
    [15]Wood,J.V, Taylor,S.E., Lichtman,R.R.(1985).Social comparison in adjustment to breast cancer.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,49,1169-1183.
    [16]Suls J M,Miller R L.Social Comparison process:Theoretical and empirical perspectives. Washington,DC Hemisphere Publication Services,1977.1~19and Social Psychology,1998,75(3):801-810
    [17]Camille S.Johnson, Diederik A.Stapel. No Pain, No Gain:The Conditions Under Which Upward Comparisons Lead to Better Performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.2007,92(6):1051-1067
    [18]Bram P. Buunk, Wilmar B. Schaufeli. Burnout:A Perspective from Social Comparison Theory.2005:201-209
    [19]Sheung-Tak Cheng, Helene H. Fungb, Alfred C.M.Chan. Living status and psychological well-being:Social comparison as a moderator in later life. Aging&Mental Health.2008,12(5):654-661
    [20]Nicolas Michinov, Jean-Marc Monteil. Social behavior and personality,1997,25(4):389-398
    [21]Abraham P.Buunk, Frederick X. Gibbons. Social comparison:The end of a theory and the emergence of a field. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 102(2007)3-21
    [22]Aspinwall, L.G. (1997). Future-oriented aspects of social comparisons. In B.P.Buunk & F.X.Gibbons (Eds.), Health, coping, and well-being:Perspectives from social comparison theory(pp.125-166).Mahwah, NJ:Erlbaum.
    [23]Judith B.White,Ellen J.Langer,Leeat Yariv,and John C.Welch IV.Frequent Social Comparisons and Destructive Emotions and Behaviors:The Dark Side of Social Comparisons. Journal of Adult Development,13(1),March 2006.
    [24]Stefan Thau, Karl Aquino. An Extension of Uncertainty Management Theory to the Self:The Relationship Between Justice, Social Comparison Orientation, and Antisocial Work Behaviors. Journal of Applied Psychology,2007,92(1):250-258
    [25]Gibbons, F.X.&Buukn, B.P.(1999), Individual diefferences in social comparison: The development of a scale of social comparison orientation, Journal of Personality and social Psychology,76,129-142.
    [26]Silvia, P. J.,& Duval, T. S. (2001). Objective self-awareness theory:Recent progress and enduring problems. Personality and Social Psychology Review,5, 230-241.
    [27]张保,徐跃红,孔凡兰,李哲,赵玉芳.中学生考试焦虑与社会比较的相关研究.西南大学学报.2009,31(2):156-159
    [28]王明姬,王垒施,俊琦.社会比较倾向量表中文版的信效度检验.中国心理卫生杂志,2006,20(5):302-305
    [29]Stapel,D.A., Blanton,H.. From seeing to being:Subliminal social comparisons affect implicit and explicit self-evaluations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2004,87,468-481.
    [30]Pelham,B.W., Wachsmuth,J.O.(1995).The waxing and waning of the social self: Assimilation and contrast in social comparison. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,69,825-838.
    [31]Unconscious and Spontaneous and...Complex:The Three Selves Model of Social Comparison Assimilation and Contrast. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.2008,94(6):1018-1032
    [32]Rebecca T.Pinkus, Penelope Lockwood, Ulrich Schimmack. For Better and for Worse:Everyday Social Comparisons Between Romantic Partners. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.2008,.95(5):1180-1201
    [33]Aron,A.,Mashek,D.,McLaughlin-Volpe,T.,Wright,S.,Lewandowski,G.,&Aron,E. N. (2005).Including close others in the cognitive structure of the self. In M.W.Baldwin(Ed.),Interpersonal cognition, (.206-232).New York:Guilford Press.
    [34]Markus,H.R.,Kitayama,S.,&Heiman,R.J.(1997).Culture and "basic" psychological principles. In E.T.Higgins, A.W.Kruglanski(Eds.) Social psychology:Handbook of basic principles(.857-913).NewYork:Guilford.
    [35]Thomas Mussweiler, Katja Ruter,and Kai Epstude.The Ups and Downs of Social Comparison:Mechanisms of Assimilation and Contrast. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2004,87(6):832-844
    [36]Tesser,A.(1986).Some effects of self-evaluation maintenance on cognition and action. Hand-book of motivation and cognition:foundations of social behavior(.435-464).New York:Guilford Press.
    [37]刘佳.社会比较中的选择通达机制.山西经济管理干部学报.2008,16(3):69-73
    [38]Smith E E, Shoben E J,RipsL J. Structure and process in semantic memory:A feature model for semantic decisions[J]. PsychologyReview,1974(81):214-241
    [39]马前锋,蒋华明.自尊研究的进展与意义.心理科学.2002,2:12-15
    [40]Vohs,K.D.,&Heatherton,T.F.(2001).Self-esteem and threats to self:Implications for self-construals and interpersonal perceptions. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,81,1103-1118.
    [41]Heatherton,T.F.,&Vohs,K.D.(2000). Interpersonal evaluations following threats to self:Role of self-esteem. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,78, 725-736.
    [42]Gardner,W.L.,Gabriel,S.,&Hochschild,L.(2002).When you and I are "we", you are not threatening:The role of self-expansion in social comparison, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,82,239-251.
    [43]许丽媛.(2009).社会比较、自尊及其与自我效能感的关系.(D).北京体育学.
    [44]梁萍,刘奇.自我效能感与大学生的成就行为培养.内蒙古财经学院学报(综版).2009,7(5);42-45
    [45]Testa,M.,&Major,B.(April 1988).Affective and behavioral consequences of social comparison. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Eastern Psychological Association, Buffalo, NY.
    [46]Nicolas Michinov. When downward comparison produces negative affect:the sense of control as a moderator. Social behavior and personality, 2001,29(5):427-444
    [47]纪丽君.社会(人际)比较.心理学动态.1995.3(2):43-48
    [48]Eysenck, H.J., Eysenck, S.B.G.(1991). Manual of the Eysenck Personality Scale(EPS Adult). London:Hodder & Stoughton.
    [49]Van der Zee, K. I., Oldersma, F. L.,& Buunk, B. P.,& Bos, D.A.J.(1998). Social comparison preferences among cancer patients as related to neuroticism and social comparison orientation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75,808-810.
    [50]Bram P. Buunk, Karen Van der Zee, Nico W. VanYperen. Neuroticism and Social Comparison Orientation as Moderators of Affective Responses to Social Comparison at Work. Journal of Personality,2001,69(5):746-760
    [51]Reed, M. A.,& Derry berry, D. (1995). Temperament and response processing: Facilitatory and inhibitory consequences of positive and negative motivational states. Journal of Research in Personality,29,59-84
    [52]Parrott WG. The emotional experiences of envy and jealousy. From Salovey P. The Psychology of Jealousy and Envy. The Guilford Press,1991,3-28.
    [53]羡慕嫉妒恨.2011-01-03取自http://baike.baidu.com/view/3414731.htm
    [54]卡斯特.著,陈瑛.译.羡慕与嫉妒:深层心理分析.生活.读书.新知三联书店.2004
    [55]姬兴华.改革中攀比的特性及其成因.合肥教育学院学报.2003(2):25-24
    [56]郑霞.2009.大学生攀比现象透视与引导策略研究.硕士毕业论文.大连理工大学
    [57]Alfred Adler著,李心明译.自卑与超越(what lift should mean to you)北京光明日报出版社,2006:2
    [58]Karen Van der Zee, Bram Buunk, Robbert Sanderman, Gerrit Botke, Fons van den Bergh. Social comparison and coping with cancer treatment. Personality and individual differences,2000,28:17-34
    [59]胡冬梅.社会比较、知觉到的控制对离职意愿、职业倦怠的影响研究[D].北京:北京师范大学硕士论文,2006
    [60]Helgeson,V.S.,&Mickelson,K.D.(1995).Motives for social comparison. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,21,1200-1209.
    [61]徐晓飞.(2005).学生学业社会比较对学业压力应对策略的影响.硕士论文.西南师范大学.
    [62]阳柳青.(2002).大学生的心理健康与社会比较研究.硕士论文.广西师范大学.
    [63]于海波,郑晓明.薪酬满意度与社会比较的关系.未来与发展,2009(1):69-80
    [64]张茜.(2009).IT员工工作压力、心理契约及工作满意度与离职倾向的关系研究.硕士学位论文.西南师范大学
    [65]Selye, H. Stress without distress. Philadelphia:Lippincott,1997
    [66]赵燕.(2007).组织公民行为与员工角色模糊、工作压力和工作家庭冲突的关系.硕士学位论文.河南大学
    [67]Lockwood P,Jordan C H,Kunda Z. Motivation by Positive or Negative Role Model:Regulatory Focus Determines Who.WillBest Inspire Us[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2002,83:854-864.
    [68]梁洁.职业倦怠现象的性别分析.西安电子科技大学学报(社会科学版).2009,19(1):20-25
    [69]Douglas J.Brown, D.Lance Ferris, Daniel Heller b, Lisa M. Keeping. Antecedents and consequences of the frequency of upward and downward social comparisons at work. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 102(2007)59-75
    [70]Bram P.Buunk, Rosario Zurriaga, JoseM.Peiro, Aukje Nauta, Isabel Gosalvez. Social Comparisons at Work as Related to a Cooperative Social Climate and to Individual Differences in Social Comparison Orientation. Applied psychology:an international review,2005,54(1),61-80
    [71]彭鹤.(2008).社会比较与组织公平的相关研究.暨南大学.硕士学位论文
    [72]Folger,R.,&Konovsky,M.A.(1989).Effects of procedural and distributive justice on reactions to pay raise decisions. Academy of Management Journal,32,115-130.
    [73]An Extension of Uncertainty Management Theory to the Self:The Relationship Between Justice, Social Comparison Orientation, and Antisocial Work Behaviors. Journal of Applied Psychology,2007,92(1)250-258
    [74]Jonathon R.B.Halbesleben&M.Ronald Buckley. Social comparison and burnout: The role of relative burnout and received social support. Anxiety, Stress,and Coping,2006;19(3):259-278
    [75]Miller,D.T.,&McFarland,C.(1991).When social comparison goes awry:The case of pluralistic ignorance.In J. Suls,&T.Willis(Eds.), Social comparison: Contemporary theory and research. Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
    [76]Buunk,B.P.,Shaufeli,W.B.,&Ybema,J.F.(1994). Burnout, uncertainty, and the desire for social comparison among nurses. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 24,1701-1718.
    [77]Bram P. Buunk, Wilmar B. Schaufeli. Burnout:a perspective from social comparison theory.1999:122-134
    [78]Buunk,B.P., Ybema,J.F., Gibbons,F.X., Ipenburg,M. (2001).The affective consequences of social comparison as related to professional burnout and social comparison orientation. European Journal of Social Psychology,31,337-351.
    [79]Bakker,A.B.,Schaufeli,W.B.,Sixma,H.J.,&Bosveld,W.(2001).Burnout contagion among general practitioners. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,20,82-98.
    [80]Kernis,M.H.,Paradise,A.W.,Whitaker,D.J.Wheatman,S.R.,&Goldman,B.N.(2000). Master of one's psychological domain? Not likely if one's self-esteem is unstable. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,26,1297-1305.
    [81]Judith B.White,Ellen J.Langer,Leeat Yariv,and John C.Welch Ⅳ.Frequent Social Comparisons and Destructive Emotions and Behaviors:The Dark Side of Social Comparisons. Journal of Adult Development,13(1),March 2006.
    [82]国企员工工作压力比外企还要大.2011-02-09.http://business.Sohu.com/08/21/ article211692108.shtml
    [83]关于中国国企员工压力研究报告.2011-02-09取自http://www. psyczx.com/ old/update/2005/12/es.htm
    [84]赵冬梅.山口裕幸.国企员工压力和工作满意度的对比研究.中国健康心理学杂志.2009,17(3):261-263
    [85]马庆国.管理统计:数据获取、统计原理、SPSS工具与应用研究四J.北科学出版社,2002:27-327
    [86]Heather J.S.& ColinW.L., Group membership and everyday social comparison experiences, European Journal of Social Psyehology.2004.34:297-308
    [87]邢淑芬.俞国良社会比较:对比效应还是同化效应?心理科学进展2006,14(6):944-949
    [88]杨志蓉.团队快速信任、互动行为与团队创造力研究.博士学位论文,浙江大学,2006
    [89]王垒,姚宏,廖芳怡等.实用人事测量.北京:经济科学出版社,1999
    [90]汪京.企业员工工作压力与工作态度关系的研究[D].首都经济贸易大学,2006
    [91]侯杰泰.,成子娟.结构方程模型及其应用.北京.2010中国教育出版社
    [92]Taylor, S.E.,&Lobel, M.(1989).Social comparison activity under threat: downward evaluation and upward contacts. Psychological Review,96,569-575.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700