摘要
水土保持效益评价的目的是为了定性(定量)标识水土保持措施的影响方式、范围和程度。本研究应用系统分析与评价的理论和方法,从水土保持综合治理措施对小流域尺度的生态系统、经济系统和社会系统结构和功能的改变角度出发,遵循效益评价的原则,提出小流域综合治理效益评价指标体系。该指标体系是在充分吸收总结水土保持效益评价理论和方法的基础上提出的,适应黑土区的实际情况。该指标体系以水土保持综合治理效益为目标层,以经济效益、生态效益、社会效益为准则层,共有11个指标。采用层次分析法(AHP)确定各指标对准则层权重及组合权重,并经过一致性检验,利用线性加权模型进行小流域综合治理总体效益的评价。此指标体系可为进一步的治理提供科学的决策支持和依据。
在此基础上,针对水土保持效益评价的需求,以空间数据库和属性数据库为系统数据库,利用组件式地理信息系统软件MapObjects为开发平台,Visual Basic为开发语言,编程实现了黑土区小流域综合治理效益评价信息系统。该系统具有数据管理、报表输出、效益计算及帮助模块。系统可实现基本视图功能以及图层的添加、删除空间数据的查询、存储、管理和属性数据的查询、修改、输出等。系统通过调用小流域效益评价模型及Execl,对系统数据库进行统计分析,得出效益评价结果,形式有专题图、表单和文档的形式反映。并以黑龙江省拜泉县振祥小流域为例,对其综合治理后产生的效益进行的初步评价。利用GIS对小流域数据进行整编,归类,纳入评价系统,通过用户对11个指标值的录入,系统即可自动对该小流域综合治理效益进行评价,得出评价结果。此信息系统实现了水土保持效益评价在黑土区小流域的应用,及小流域水土保持数据信息化管理,提高水土保持效益评价信息化水平。
The purpose of evaluating soil and water conservation is to identify the influential factors, range and degree of the comprehensive management. Adopting the systematic analysis and evaluation as the theory and method, from the point of change to ecosystem, economical system and social system of small watershed from comprehensive management measures, this research proposed an index system of small watershed comprehensive management effectiveness evaluation keeping to the effectiveness evaluating principles. In addition, this index system was proposed based on some effectiveness evaluating theories and methods of soil and water conservation, which was suitable for the actual situation of the black soil region. This index system, including 11 indexes, is established to achieve the goal of conservating soil and water and to follow the rules of realizing economic, ecology and social effectiveness. AHP method to conduct weights of rules and combination was adopted, through consistency check, small watershed management total effectiveness was evaluated using linear weighting models.
On the basis of the above illustrations, this research takes advantage of space database and property database as the systematic database to program a effectiveness evaluating information system of the small watershed in black earth areas, against the needs of soil and water conservation effectiveness evaluation. This system adopts MapObjects as its developing stage and uses Visaual Basic as its developing language,. This system includes modules for data management, report form output, effectiveness caculation and help. Besides, this system can realize many basic functions of view and some extra functions such as adding or deleting layer, strorage and management of space data, as well as inquiry, modifing and output of property data. By calling and using small watershed's effectiveness evaluating model and Excel, this system conducted a statistical analysis on systematic database, thus effectiveness evaluating results was acquired, including thematic maps,forms and documents. Taking Zhenxiang small watershed as an example, which was located in Baiquan country in Heilongjiang province, preliminary evaluation in its effectiveness after comprehensive management was conducted. Small watersheds data was integrated and classified by GIS, and was bright into evaluation system. After inputing 11 indexes value, the system can evaluate comprehensive management effectiveness in small watershed automatically, and then the results were obtained. This information system realized the application of effectiveness evaluating and informational management of the soil and water conservation to the small watershed in black soil region, moreover, informational level of evaluating soil and water conservation was improved.
引文
[1]范昊明,蔡强国,陈光等.世界三大黑土区水土流失与防治比较分析,自然资源学报,2005,20(3):387-393
[2]李静.基于组件式GIS的水土保持效益评价信息系统初步研究:以延河流域为例.杨凌:西北农林科技大学,2008
[3]梁会民.小流域水土保持信息系统的理论及实践研究-以宁县老虎沟水土保持效益评估系统研究为例.兰州:西北师范大学,2001
[4]李锐.试区航空遥感监测研究.黄土高原区域治理评价.北京:科学出版社,1992.347-398
[5]孙立达,孙保平,李中魁.小流域综合治理的动态监测与效益评价研究进展.水土保持学报,1993,7(4):84-96
[6]王春玲,李世明,王久丽.小流域综合治理效益评价管理信息系统的研究与应用.北京林业大学学报,2001,23(2):53-56
[7]水土保持综合治理效益计算方法,国际技术监督局,GB/T15774-1995,GB/T15774-2008
[8]叶延琼,张信宝,冯明义,等.水土保持效益分析与社会进步.水土保持学报,2006,17(2):71-113
[9]李成杰,陆洪斌.浅谈水土保持效益计算中存在问题及解决途径.水土保持通报,2000,20(3):29-30
[10]李智广,李锐,杨勤科等.小流域治理综合效益评价指标体系研究.水土保持通报,1998,18(7):71-75
[11]韩冰,汪有科,吴发启.渭北黄土高原沟壑区小流域综合治理评价的研究,水土保持学报,1995,9(3):84-95
[12]阎文哲,马助烈,赵光耀等.黄河流域水土保持综合治理效益分析.孟庆枚主编.黄土高原水土保持.郑州:黄河水利出版社,1996,464-483
[13]范海荣,王洪海.小流域治理综合效益评价指标体系及其评价方法,吉林水利,2003,(12):23-25
[14]李中魁.黄土高原小流域治理效益评价与系统评估研究:以宁夏西吉县黄家二岔为例.生态学报,1998,18(3):241-247
[15]康玲玲,王云璋,王霞.小流域水土保持综合治理效益指标体系及其应用.土壤与环境,2002,11(3):274-278
[16]戴全厚,刘国彬,刘明义等.小流域生态经济系统可持续发展评价,地理学报,2005,60(2):209-218
[17]Ted C. Sheng. Watershed Project Monitoring and Evaluation,Watershed Conservation,The Chinese Soil and Water Conservation Society and Colorado University,1986
[18]Saaty T L.J.Math.Psyehol.,1977;15(3):234
[19]韦杰,贺秀斌,汪涌等.基于DPSIR概念框架的区域水土保持效益评价新思路.中国水土保持科学,2007,5(4):66-69
[20]丁立仲,卢剑波,徐文荣.浙西山区上梧溪小流域生态恢复工程效益评价研究.中国生态农业学报,2006,14(3):202-203.
[21]王军强,陈存根,李同升.陕西黄土高原小流域治理效益评价与模式选择.水土保持通报,2003,23(6):61-64
[22]时光新,尹成信.基于熵的小流域治理效益评价模型及其应用.水土保持通报,1999,19(5):8-40
[23]姚文波,刘文兆,赵安成等.水土保持效益评价指标研究.中国水土保持科学, 2009,7(1):112-117
[24]黎锁平.水土保持综合治理效益的灰色系统评价.水土保持通报,1994,14(4):43-46.
[25]贾宁凤,段建南,陈焕伟,等.黄土高原小流域综合治理效益多维灰色动态评价.农业系统科学与综合研究,2005,21(2):156-160.
[26]李玉林,毛春芳,王得刚等.应用模糊数学原理对小流域生态经济系统评价.水土保持科技情报,2002(1):43-45.
[27]王道坦,黄炎和,王洪翠等.花岗岩强度水土流失区的治理效益综合评价.福建热作科技,2006,31(4):4-7
[28]魏强,柴春山.半干旱黄土丘陵沟壑区小流域水土流失治理综合效益评价指标体系与方法.水土保持研究,2007,14(1):87-89
[29]陈渠昌,张如生.水土保持综合效益定量分析方法及指标体系研究,中国水利水电科学研究院学报,2007,5(2):95-104
[30]张建明,小流域综合治理环境效益及其评价模型,重庆:重庆大学,1995
[31]王兵,吴斌,李建牢.小流域水土保持生态经济效益综合评价模型的研究,水土保持学报,1994,8(3):59-63
[32]赵小勇,崔广柏,付强.投影寻踪分类模型在小流域治理效益评价中的应用,水利学报,2007,(s1):435-448
[33]杨勤科,李锐.地理信息系统在水土保持研究中的应用.区域水土流失快速调查与管理系统信息系统研究.郑州:黄河水利出版社,2000:19-23
[34]王洽堂,高林.北京郊区水土流失信息系统的建立与应用.水土保持学报,1989,3(2):1-9
[35]李壁成,王玉如.小流域水土保持信息系统的建立与应用,水土保持学报,1989,3(3):26-32
[36]江忠善,王志强,刘志.应用地理信息系统评价黄土丘陵区小流域土壤侵蚀的研究.水土保持研究,1996,3(2):84-96
[37]王礼先,陆守一,洪惜英等.流域管理信息系统的建立及应用研究,水土保持学报,1992,6(2):25-32
[38]门宝辉.VB5.0在初步开发小流域水土保持规划信息系统中的应用.水土保持通报,1999,16(9):36-38
[39]焦锋,杨勤科,雷会珠.土地资源动态监测信息系统-以延安/安塞七乡镇为例,水土保持研究,2000,7(2):172-175
[40]高鹏,刘作新,丁福俊.大凌河流域水土保持信息系统的建立及应用.水土保持学报,2002,16(1):58-61
[41]史明昌,田玉柱.县级水土保持监测信息系统.北京:中国科学技术出版社,2005,94-106
[42]褚兴彬,刘霞.山东省水土保持效益监测与评价系统.安徽农学通报,2009,15(3):57-59
[43]Shi Mingchang,Yue Depeng,Sun Li. A Study on Land Use Decision-making Syste. Forestry Studies in China,1998,7(l):58-64
[44]吕康捐.基于地理信息系统(GIS)的小流域综合治理规划的研究.哈尔滨:东北农业大学,2000
[45]Z. H. Shi, C. . Cai, S. W. Ding, et al. Soil conservation planning at the small watershed level using RUSLE with GIS:a case study in the Three Gorge Area of China CATENA, 2004,55(1):33-48
[46]张可慧,刘芳圆,张胜海等.基于3S的土地整理生态环境效益评价系统.安徽农业科学,2007,35(4):1227-1229
[47]洪金益,谢琨磊,曾详坤.基于VB和ArcObjects的组件式地理信息系统开发.地理空间信息,2006,4(4):6-8
[48]文斌,邵明安.黄土高原小流域水循环GIS设计与实现.农业工程学报,2005,21(10):36-40
[49]李静.组件式GIS开发中获取降雨侵蚀力因子的技术实现.安徽农业科学,2009,37(15):7278-7280
[50]吉玉碧,谢锋,谭红,等.基于GIS的土壤管理信息系统的设计与实现:以贵州省为例.农业网络信息,2008,(1):10-13
[51]李文凤,杨勤科,李静等.基于组件式GIS的黄河流域水土保持信息系统的设计与实现.西北农林科技大学学报,2008,36(3):90-96
[52]黄健熙,吴炳方.基于B/S的水土保持信息查询系统的设计和实现.计算机应用研究,2006,(7):138-144
[53]Mellerowicz, K.T., Rees, H.W., Chow, T.L., Ghanem, I. Soil conservation planning at the watershed level using the universal soil loss equation with GIS and microcomputer technologies:A case study Soil Water Cons.1994,49(2):194-200
[54]Christopher Cox, Chandra Madramootoo. Application of geographic information systems in watershed management planning in St. Lucia.Computers and Electronics in Agriculture.1998,20(1):229-250
[55]E Z.Nyakat awaa,K..C. Reddya.Predicting soil erosion in conservation tillage cotton production systems using the revised universersal soil loss equation(RUSLE). Catena,1996,(16):15-18
[56]Van Der Knijff J M,Jones R J, Montanarella L.Soil erosion rish assessment in Europo.http://eusoils.jrc.it/ESDB_Archive/Pesera/pesera_cd/pdf/ereurnew2.pdf
[57]Yang D W,Shinjiao Kabae,Taikan OKL,er al.Global potential soil erosion with reference to land use and climate changes.Hydrological Processes,2003,17:2913-2928
[58]Lu H,Gallant J,Prosser I P,et al.Prediction of sheet and rill erosion over the australian continent, incorporating monthly soil loss disribution//CSIRO land and water technical report13/01.Canberra:CSIRO land and water,2001
[59]Lionel Mabit, Claude Bernard, Marc R. Laverdiere.Assessment of erosion in the Boyer River watershed (Canada) using a GIS oriented sampling strategy and 137Cs measurements.CATENA,2007,71(2):242-249
[60]Udoyara,S.T., Jolly, R..Evaluating agricultural non-point source pollution using integrated geographic information systems and hydrologic:water quality model. Environ Qual.1994,23(1):25-35
[61]Lant,C.L., Kraft,S.E.,Beaulieu,J.,et al. Using GIS-based ecological-economic modeling to evaluate policies affecting agricultural watersheds. Ecological Economics 2005,55(4):467-484
[62]Paul A. Zandbergen. Urban watershed ecological risk assessment using GIS:a case study of the Brunette River watershed in British Columbia, Canada,Journal of Hazardous Materials,1998,61(1-3):163-173
[63]Tetsuo Masuyama,Toshiharu Yamamoto, Keitarou Hara,at al. Gis approach to landscape evaluation base on small watershed units. http://www.cartesia.org/geodoc/isprs2004/comm7/papers/50.pdf.
[64]European Commission.1996." Enviromental Indicators and Green Accounting:Practical Steps towards the Implementation of the Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Union on Environmental Indicators and Green national Accounting."
[65]J.A.Bakkes,GJ.Van den Born et al.An overview of environmental indicators:state of the art and perspectives.Environment Assessment Technical Report. UNEP/EATR,94-10, RIVM/402001001,Jane 1994
[66]朱志丹.基于GIS的小流域水土保持减沙效益研究.武汉:华中农业大学,2006
[67]郝海,踪家峰.系统分析与评价方法,北京:经济科学出版社,2007,7-18,63-67,117-137
[68]苏为华.多指标综合评价理论与方法问题研究.厦门大学博士论文,2000,84-87
[69]王军强.陕北黄土高原小流域治理及效益评价.陕西杨凌:西北农林科技大学,2001
[70]谢树煜,程序员教程同步辅导.北京:清华大学出版社,2002.134-141
[71]张平华,李军杰,李云辉.GIS的发展现状及其应用.电脑知识与技术(学术交流),2006,(11):186-187
[72]李静.基于组件式GIS的水土保持效益评价信息系统初步研究.西北农林科技大学,2008
[73]范文义,周洪泽.资源与环境地理信息系统,北京:科学出版社,4-8,10-13
[74]薛伟.MapObjects地理信息系统程序设计.北京:国防工业出版社,2004,1-3
[75]刘光,刘小东.地理信息系统二次开发实例教程-VC.net和MapObjects,北京:清华大学出版社,2004,91-95