结构转换模型及其在长期风险管理中的应用
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
次贷危机在全球金融市场的肆虐引发了人们对金融衍生产品及风险管理的重新思考和进一步重视。虽然金融创新产品能够成为风险重构、风险分散、风险对冲的工具,解决资金流动的瓶颈,降低资金使用成本,拓宽融资渠道,增加市场活力,但是,在金融机构对高额利润的过分追求以及对经济、金融环境发展趋势缺乏远见的情况下,金融创新产品自身的杠杆作用会使风险放大并加速传播。
     本文以长期风险管理为切入点,引入在长跨期时间序列数据建模中较为流行的,具有灵活性和非线性特征的模型——马尔科夫结构转换模型。在国外,它很早就被用于分析GNP等宏观经济数据,以捕捉经济系统里偶然但重复出现的结构变化。近年来,它也被用来度量股票、债券等金融产品的市场风险,并成为保险公司等关注长期投资风险的机构推荐使用的风险准备金计算模型。而国内对它的研究多限于实证方面,未有更深入的探讨和创新。
     本文由六个章节组成。
     第一章简述风险管理的发展与重要性,综述国内外结构转换模型的研究成果,并提出全文架构。
     第二章从结构转换模型的构造原理出发,详细介绍了模型设定、参数估计方法、残差分析以及对普通结构转换模型性进行扩展的思路。
     第三章应用结构转换模型分析信用风险。对反映市场信用风险水平的CDS指数建立结构转换模型,将其分为信用利差缩小、波动减弱状态和利差扩大、波动增加状态,分析CDS指数对金融市场事件的反应。同时,在以其为标的资产的标准化CDO权益级分券的定价中加入经济周期、行业周期等长期风险因素,预测在信用风险激增的危机时期CDO价格的变化趋势。
     第四章再次回到股票市场分析中。首先,考察了结构转换模型对股票市场长期收益率分布尖峰、厚尾、偏斜特征的描述,并通过比较它与其他模型估计的股市下跌概率,证明其在预计市场下泄风险上的准确性。其次,利用结构转换模型对样本时间序列敏感的特点,根据参数估计值的变化,设计出检测股票价格序列变点的方法。通过对美国股市的实证分析证明变点检测方法的有效性。
     第五章创新性的提出带约束的结构转换模型CRSLN。其通过在转移矩阵中加入约束条件来引入均值回复效应,既对样本时间序列的选择不过份敏感,也较好的缓解了一般均值回复模型对尾部风险的低估。最后,基于CRSLN模型描述的股指动态过程,对股指期权的定价提出初步的构思。
     最后一章是对全文的总结,指出文中亟待改进之处以及未来研究方向。
The outbreak of subprime mortgage crisis leads the world to reconsider about the financial derivatives trading and the importance of risk management. The innovation of financial products may be useful for reconstructing risk distribution, diversifying the risk and hedging the risk. At the meantime, it will help financial institution to break through the limitation of liquidity, to reduce financing cost, and then, to bring us a dynamic market. However, if market participants pay more attention to profit maximization, without noticing or foreseeing the long-term trend or changes of economic and financial environment, the leverage of derivatives will enlarge the risks and bring them to worldwide.
     Based on the necessity of long-term risk management, we focus on a popular nonlinear time series model, Markov regime-switching model. It is very flexible and widely used in analyzing long-run dynamics of macro economy, like GNP data, to capture those unexpected but recurrent phenomena. Recently, it's recommended by the investors, such as insurance company, which make long-term investments, to calculate reserve. But it has not been systematically studied by domestic researchers.
     The frame and innovation are described in six chapters in this paper.
     In Chapter 1, the development and the importance of risk management are briefly summarized, and the researches of regime-switching models are reviewed. Then, the frame of the whole paper is introduced.
     In Chapter 2, the basic theory of regime-switching type models is described. The methods to set a concrete model, estimate parameters and analyze estimation residuals are systematically presented. At last, two specific extensions of regime-switching model are listed.
     Chapter 3 is the application of regime-switching model to a new field. The model is used to measure the credit risk implied by credit default swap index. We assume that the spread of CDS index locates in one of the two states, which are spread tighten-volatility decrease state and spread widen-volatility increase state. The results show that CDS index does sensitively respond to big events in financial market. Therefore, when pricing and hedging the equity tranche of standard CDO, the regime shifts of underlying CDS index and the long-run risk of economic cycle and business cycle should be considered, especially when the credit risk increases sharply in crisis period.
     In Chapter 4, the research goes back to focus on stock market. Firstly, the capability of regime-switching model to represent the characteristics of asset return distribution, including high kurtosis, heavy tail and skewness, is studied and compared to other models. The result suggests that the regime-switching model forecasts the probability of downward stock market, especially the large crash, better than other models. Secondly, a change point detecting algorithm is proposed due to the sensitivity of regime-switching parameters to new information. Then the stock market is dived into bear market phase and bull market phase. The segmented regime-switching model is estimated in the whole series segmented by estimated change points. We can find that the segmented estimations are consistent with real market scene.
     In Chapter 5, the constrained regime-switching model is proposed for the first time to imbed mean-reversion without underestimating the high-order moments and the tail risk. Meanwhile, the parameter estimations of CRSLN model are more robust than other two regime-switching type models. Then the stock index path modeled by the CRSLN model is used to pricing stock index option, although it is only a primary design.
     The last chapter is the conclusion of the whole thesis, the shortcomings and future improvements are pointed out.
引文
Alexander, Kaeck.2008. Regime dependent determinants of credit default swap spreads [J]. Journal of Banking and Finance,32:1008-1021.
    Alexander SS.1961. Price movements in speculative markets:trends or random walks. in P. Cootner, ed.:The Random Character of Stock Market Prices (MITPress, Cambridge, Mass.), pp.199-218
    American academy of actuaries (AAA).2005. Recommended approach for setting regulatory risk-based capital requirements for variable annuities and similar products. www.actuary.org/pdf/life/c3_june05.pdf.
    Antoch J, Huskova M, Praskova Z.1997. Effect of dependence on statistics for determination of change [J]. Journal of Statistical Planning & Inference,60:291-310.
    Artzner P, Delbaen F, Eber J-M, Heath D.1999. Coherent measures of risk [J]. Mathematical Finance,9:203-228.
    Bai J.1994. Least squares estimation of a shift in linear process [J]. Journal of Time Series Analysis,15:453-472.
    Bai J.1997. Estimation of a change point in multiple regression models [J]. Review of Economics and statistics,79:551-563.
    Balvers R, Wu Y.2006. Momentum and mean reversion across national equity markets [J]. Journal of Empirical Finance,13:24-48.
    Bank of international settlements.1996. Overview of the amendment to the capital accord to incorporate market risks. http://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs23.pdf?noframes=1.
    Barrett, Ewan.2006. Credit derivative report. London:British Bankers'Association.
    Bayliffe D, Pauling B.2003. Long-term equity returns. Working paper, Towers Perrin.
    Bernstein PL.1998. Against the Gods:the remarkable story of risk [M]. New York:John Wiley & Sons.
    Black F, Scholes M.1973. The pricing of options and corporate liabilities [J]. The Journal of Political Economy,81:637-654.
    Bollen NP.1998. Valuing options in regime-switching models [J]. Jounral of Derivatives,6:38-49.
    Bollerslev T.1986. Generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity [J]. Journal of Econometrics,31:307-327.
    Bystrom.2005. Credit default swaps and equity prices:The iTraxx CDS index market. Sweden: Department of Economics, Lund University.
    Bystrom.2006. CreditGrades and the iTraxx CDS index market [J]. Financial Analysts Journal, 62:65-76.
    Canadian institute of actuaries (CIA).2002. CIA task force on segregated fund investment guarantees. http://www.actuaries.ca/members/publications/2002/202012e.pdf.
    Chen J, Gupta AK.1997. Testing and locating variance changepoints with application to stock price [J]. Journal of the American Statistical Association,92:739-747.
    Choudhry M.2004. Corporate bonds and structured financial products [M]. UK:Elsevier Science& Technology,379-412.
    Cox JC, Ingersoll JE, Ross SA.1985. A theory of the term structure of interest rates [J]. Econometrica,53:385-407.
    Determination of the December 2007 peak in economic activity. National Bureau of Economic Research. http://www.nber.org/cycles/dec2008.html
    Diebold FX, Lee JH, Weinbach G.1994. Regime switching with time-varying transition probabilities//Hargreaves C. Non-stationary time series analysis and cointegration. Oxford, UK:Oxford University Press.
    Dueker, Michael.1997. Markov switching in GARCH processes and mean-reverting stock-market volatility [J]. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics,15:26-34.
    Duffie D, Garleanu N.2001. Risk and valuation of Collateralized Debt Obligations. Working Paper, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University.
    Durland JM, McCurdy TH.1994. Duration-dependent transition in a Markov model of U.S. GNP growth [J]. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics,12:279-288.
    Einhorn D.2008. Private profits and socialized risk. GARP Risk Review.
    Engle RF.1982. Autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity with estimates of U.K. inflation [J]. Econometrica,50:987-1008.
    Engle RF, Gonzalez-Rivera G 1991. Semiparametric ARCH models [J]. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics,9:345-359.
    Filardo AJ.1994. Business-cycle phases and their transitional dynamics [J]. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics,12:299-308.
    Francq C, Roussignol M, Zakoian J.2001. Conditional heteroskedasticity driven by hidden Markov chains [J]. Journal of Time Series Analysis,22:197-200.
    Furbush D.1989. Program trading and price movement:evidence from the October 1987 market crash [J]. Financial Management,18:68-83.
    Gibson M.2004. Understanding the risk of synthetic CDOs. Trading Risk Analysis Section. Division of Research and Statistics, Federal Reserve Board.
    Gray B, French D.1990. Empirical comparisons of distributional models for stockindex returns [J]. Journal of Business, Finance & Accounting,17:451-459.
    Gray SF.1996. Modeling the conditional distribution of interest rates as a regime-switching process [J]. Journal of Financial Economics,42:27-62.
    Haas M, Mittnik S, Paolella MS.2004. Mixed normal conditional heteroscedasticity [J]. Journal of Financial Econometrics,2:211-250.
    Hamilton JD.1989. A new approach to the economic analysis of nonstationary time series and the business cycle [J]. Economrtica,57:357-384.
    Hamilton JD, Susmel R.1994. Autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity and changes in regime [J]. Journal of Econometrics,64:307-333.
    Hamilton JD, Lin G.1996. Stock market volatility and the business cycle [J]. Journal of Applied Econometrics,11:573-593.
    Hardy MR.2001. A regime-switching model of long-term stock returns [J]. North American Actuarial Journal,4:41-53.
    Hardy MR.2003. Investment guarantees:modeling and risk management for equity-linked life insurance [M]. New York:John Wiley & Sons.
    Hardy MR, Freeland RK, Mattew CT.2006. Validation of long-term equity return models for equity-linked guarantees [J]. North American Actuarial Journal,10:28-47.
    Hsu DA.1977. Tests for variance shift at an unknown time point [J]. Applied Statistics,26:279-284.
    Hull J, White A.1990. Pricing interest rate derivatives securities [J]. Review of Financial Studies, 4:573-592.
    Hull J, White A.2004. Valuation of a CDO and nth to default CDS without Monte Carlo simulation [J]. Journal of Derivatives,12:8-23.
    Hull J, White A.2005a. The perfect copula. Working Paper, University of Toronto.
    Hull J, White A.2005b. The valuation of correlation-dependent credit derivatives using a structural model. Working Paper, University of Toronto.
    Hull, Pedrescu, White.2006. The valuation of correlation-dependent credit derivatives using a structural model. Toronto:University of Toronto.
    International Swaps and Derivatives Association.2008. ISDA Market Survey, Year-End. http://www.isda.org/index.html.
    Jiang WJ, Wu ZY, Chen G 2008. A new quantile function based model for modeling price behaviors in financial markets [J]. Statistics and Its Interface,1:327-332.
    Kendall MG.1953. The analysis of economic time series-part I:prices [J]. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. A,116:11-34.
    Kevin Dowd,2005. Measuring market risk [M]. New York:John Wiley & Sons.
    Kim CJ.1994. Dynamic linear models with Markov-switching [J]. Journal of Econometrics,60: 1-22.
    Kim CJ, Nelson CR.1999. State-space models with regime switching:classical and Gibbs-sampling approaches with applications [M]. Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
    Kim CJ, Piger J, Startz R.2008. Estimation of Markov regime-switching regression models with endogenous switching [J]. Journal of Econometrics,143:263-273.
    Krishnaiah P, Miao B.1988. Review about estimation of change points//Handbook of Statistics. Amsterdan:Elsevier,7:375-402.
    Krolzig MH.1997. Markov-switching vector autoregressions:modeling, statistical inference, and application to business cycle analysis [M]. Berlin:Springer.
    Lam PS.2004. A Markov-switching model of GNP growth with duration dependence [J]. International Economic Review,45:175-204.
    Li D.2000. On default correlation:A Copula function approach [J]. Journal of Fixed Income.9: 43-54.
    Loschi R.H., Cruz F.R.B.2005. Extension to the product partition model:computing the probability of a change [J]. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis,48:255-268.
    Maheu JM, McCurdy TH.2000. Volatility dynamics under duration-dependent mixing [J]. Journal of Empirical Finance,7:345-372.
    Malik F, Ewing BT, Payne E.2005. Measuring volatility persistence in the variance of Canadian stock returns [J]. Canadian Journal of Economics,38:1037-1056.
    International Index Company (ⅡC).2008. Markit iTraxx Europe Presentation. www.indexco.com.
    Ogden RT, Parzen E.1996. Data dependent wavelet thresholding in nonparametric regression with change-point applications [J]. Computational Statistics and Data Analysis,22:53-70.
    Osborne MFM.1959. Brownian motion in the stock market [J]. Operations Research,7:145-173.
    Overview of the S&P 500. Standard & Poor's, http://www.standardandpoors.com.
    Pagan AR, Hong YS.1991. Nonparametric estimation and the risk premium.//Barnett W, Powell J, Tauchen GE. Nonparametric and Semiparametric Methods in Econometrics and Statistics. UK:Cambridge University Press.
    Panneton CM.2002. Mean-reversion in equity models in the context of actuarial provisions for segregated fund investment guarantees. Segregated Funds Symposium Proceedings. Canadian Institute of Actuaries.
    Peters E.1991. Chaos and order in the capital markets:A new view of cycles, prices and market volatility [M]. New York:John Wiley & Sons.
    Quandt RE.1958. The estimation of the parameters of a linear regression system obeying two separate regimes [J]. Journal of the American Statistical Association,53:873-880.
    Quandt RE.1972. A new approach to estimating switching regressions [J]. Journal of the American Statistical Association,67:306-310.
    Rabemananjara R, Zakoian JM.1993. Threshold ARCH models and asymmetries in volatility [J]. Journal of Applied Econometrics,8:31-49.
    Rodriguez JC.2007. Measuring financial contagion:A Copula approach [J]. Journal of Empirical Finance,14:401-423.
    Task force on segregated funds.2000. Report of the task force on segregated fund investment guarantees. Ottawa:Canadian Institute of Actuaries.
    Tong H.1978. On a threshold model//Chen C. Pattern recognition and signal processing. NATO ASI Series E:Applied Science. Netherlands:Sijthoff & Noordhoff,575-586.
    Tong H, Lim KS.1980. Threshold autoregression, limit cycles and cyclical data [J]. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society (Series B),42:245-292.
    Vasicek OA.1977. An equilibrium characterization of the term structure [J]. Journal of Financial Economics.5:177-188.
    Xie Y, Yu J.2005. Consistency of maximum likelihood estimators for the reduced regime-switching GARCH models. Technical Report, Centre of Biostochastics, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences.
    Xie Y.2009. Consistency of maximum likelihood estimators for the regime-switching GARCH model [J]. Statistics,43:153-165.
    Yao YC.1987. Approximating the distribution of the maximum likelihood estimate of the change-point in a sequence ofindependent random variable [J]. Annals of Statistics,15:1321-1328.
    Yu F.2005. How profitable is capital structure arbitrage?. California:University of California.
    巴塞尔银行监管委员会.2004.统一资本计量和资本标准的国际协议:修订框架[M].第一版.北京:中国金融出版社.
    冯谦,杨朝军.2006.担保债权凭证定价-——Copula函数的非参数估计与应用[J].运筹与管理,15:104-107.
    古德曼,法博齐.2005.CDO的结构与分析[M].第一版,北京:机械工业出版社.
    过蓓蓓,张曙光.2008.非参数方法在股票市场预测中的应用[J].浙江大学学报,35:11-14.
    郭名媛,张世英.2005.DDMRS-GARCH模型及其在上海股票市场的实证研究[J].系统 工程学报,20:367-373.
    宿成建,陈洁.2003.应用变点模型来研究沪深股股市波动性突变行为[J].重庆大学学报(自然科学版),10:152-155
    孙金丽,张世英.2003.具有结构转换的GARCH模型及其在中国股市中的应用[J].系统工程,21:88-93.
    谭常春.2007.变点问题的统计推断及其在金融中的应用[Ph.D].安徽:中国科学技术大学.
    王建军.2007.Markov机制转换模型研究及其在经济周期分析中的应用:[Ph.D].福建:厦门大学.
    王欣,尹留志,方兆本.2009.异常交易行为的甄别研究[J].数理统计与管理,28:671-677.
    闫冀楠,张维.1998.关于上海股市收益分布的实证研究[J].系统工程,1:21-25.
    张维,邱勇,郝刚.2007.基于多银行贷款池的合成CDO设计[J].现代财经,27:6-13.
    中国银行业监督管理委员会.2004.商业银行市场风险管理指引.http://www.cbrc.gov.cn/chinese/home/jsp/docView.jsp? docID=1123.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700