公共物品提供模式的理论分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
公共物品消费过程中所具有的非排他性和非竞争性特点,导致市场在提供公共物品时出现失灵现象,在这种情况下,政府成为公共物品的唯一提供者。然而受政府财力不足、政府运营公共资金的低效率以及人们对各种公共物品的需求不断增加等因素的影响,政府提供的公共物品严重不足,不能满足经济和社会发展的需要。
     20世纪70年代出现在西方市场经济国家的公共物品市场提供模式,为我们解决这个难题提供了思路,政府可以利用市场来提供公共物品。本文详细论述了政府可以利用市场提供公共物品的原因、市场提供公共物品的理论依据以及政府与市场如何有效地配合生产社会发展所需要的公共物品。这对于我国公共物品提供体系的完善、公共财政体系的建设、以及理解市场经济条件下政府与市场之间关系,都具有非常重要的理论意义和现实意义。
     公共物品的公共性会因为经济发展水平、技术条件、需求弹性、外部性等因素的变化而改变,从而使公共物品与私人物品的边界变得模糊。正是基于这一点,公共物品两个特点的成立是有条件的,即在拥挤点之间,公共物品才具有非排他性和非竞争性,所以公共物品是指设计使用者大于1的物品。公共物品在物品序列图中位置的不确定性决定了其在物品提供者序列图中的位置也具有不确定性,政府与市场都可能成为其提供者。由此提出了公共物品提供的经济发展观,应该根据经济和技术条件的变化,按照效率与公平的原则,动态地选择公共物品的最优提供者。拓宽了公共物品提供的渠道,进一步完善了公共物品提供理论。
     基于公共物品提供的经济发展观,详细分析了公共物品提供的三种主要模式:政府直接生产模式、政府利用市场间接生产模式以及私人提供模式。政府提供公共物品是基于公平分配的考虑,而政府直接生产是从生产的角度来讲。当市场提供公共物品时,政府提供的涵义就体现在政府对于市场生产出来的公共物品通过一定的方式进行分配。政府利用市场提供公共物品,是公共部门与私人部门的有机结合,是效率与公平的有机结合。非政府组织及个人对公共物品的自愿提供以及实验经济学的结论证明了现实的人们并非总是“经济人”,每一个体都是一定程度的利他主义与利己主义的均衡体。
     为防止市场提供公共物品时对于社会公平的偏离,政府需要对提供公共物品的市场主体进行有效地管制。本文系统分析了政府管制的客体和管制的方式,以及在信息不对称约束条件下政府管制方法的创新——激励性管制和协商性管制。
    
    西北大学博士学位论文
     最后,基于公共物品提供的经济发展观,分析了我国农村公共物品供给体制内
    生的矛盾和问题,指出解决农村公共物品关键措施在于将“三提五统”的农村公共
    物品融资体制纳入国家财政收支范围,在加大政府支农力度的同时,改变重工轻农、
    重城市轻农村的传统观念,多渠道地为农村公共物品的生产提供资金。
Because of public goods' two characteristics, non-excludability and non-rivalry, the market cannot provide it efficiently, the government become the sole providers in the public goods market. But the government can hardly provide enough public goods for the society because the demands of public goods are increasing and the public sectors always inefficiently use public finance.
    In 1970s, many governments in developed countries began to use market to provide public goods with success. This gives us a useful experiment to solve the puzzle of the public goods' provision. The dissertation detailedly analyzes why the governments can utilize the market to provide public goods, the theoretical foundation of market provision public goods and how to balance the governments and the market in order to provide necessary public goods. These studies will take on the active meaning for the improvement of the public goods provision system, the construction of the public finance system and understanding the relationship between government and market under market system.
    The public goods' characteristics will be changed because of the changes of the economic development level, technical level, demand elasticity, externality, and so on. So when we talk about the public goods' characteristics, we must consider their precondition. This precondition is the public goods congestion. The public goods will have two characteristics when the number of public goods' users is less than the number of public goods' congestion point. Based on this point, the public goods is a special goods whose designed users is more than one person. Both the government and the market can provide the public goods. This is the economic development theory of the public goods provision.
    Based on the economic development theory of the public goods provision, there are three main public goods provision patterns: public provision pattern; market provision pattern and private voluntary provision pattern. These are separately analyzed in this dissertation. When the governments use market to provide public goods, the public provision means that the governments evenly distribute the public goods to the society. The voluntary provision of public goods has proved that individuals are not always free rider in the public goods provision. An economic person possesses of two characteristics:
    
    
    
    altruism and egoism.
    In order to prevent the private companies from paying less attention to the public interests when they provide public goods, the governments always regulate their activities. This dissertation analyzes systematically the governments' regulation methods and their objects. But the traditional regulations are inefficiency because the governments did not take into account the asymmetric information between the regulators and the regulatees. In order to improve the efficiency of the regulation, the traditional methods should be innovated. The negotiated regulation between the governments and the regulatees may be a good method.
    In the end, this dissertation presents the endogenic conflicts in the rural public goods provision system based on the economic development theory of public goods provision. In order to solve these problems, the traditional provision system must be reformed institutionally, and more funds should be collected for the provision of the rural public goods, as well as improving the fiscal investment in these fields.
引文
(1) Atkinson, Anthony B.& Nicholas H. Stem(1974) . Pigou, taxation, and public goods [J]. Review of Economic Studies 41(1) : 119-128.
    (2) Ballard, Charles L.& Don Fullerton (1992) . Distortionary taxes and the provision of public goods [J].Journal of Economic Perspectives 3: 117-131.
    (3) Berliant, Marcus & Frank H. Page, JR.(2001) .Income taxes and the provision of public goods: existence of an optimum[J].Econoetria 69(3) :771-784.
    (4) Besley,T.J. and A.C.Case (1995) .Incumbent behavior: Vote seeking, tax setting and yardstick competition[J].The American Economic Review 85:25-45.
    (5) Bewley,T.( 1981) . A critique of Tiebout's theory of local public expenditures[J]. Econometrica 49:713-740.
    (6) Blank, Rebecca M. (2000) . When can public makers rely on private market? The effective provision of social services [J]. Economic Journal 110.
    (7) Boskin, M. J. (1973) . Local government tax and product competition and the optimal provision of public goods [J]. Journal of Political Economy 81(1) : 203-210.
    (8) Browning, Edgar(1987) .On the Marginal Welfare Cost of Taxation[J]. American Economic Review 77:11-23.
    (9) Brubaker (1975) . Free ride, free revelation, or golden rule [J]. Journal of Law and Economics 18: 147-161.
    (10) Brueckner, J. K. (2000) . Welfare reform and the race to the bottom: Theory and evidence[J]. Southern Economic Journal 66: 505-525.
    (11) Brueckner, J. K. and L. A. Saavedra (2001) . Do local governments engage in strategic tax competition? [J]. National Tax Journal 54: 203-229.
    (12) Buchanan, J. M.(1965) . An economic theory of clubs [J].Economica 32:1-14.
    (13) Case, A. C., H. S. Rosen and J.C. Mines (1993) . Budget spillovers and fiscal policy interdependence: Evidence from the states [J]. Journal of Public Economics 52: 285-307.
    (14) Coase, Ronald H. (1960) . The lighthouse in economics [J]. Journal of Law and Economics, 17: 357-376.
    (15) Coates, Dennis (1996) . A diagrammatic demonstration of public crowding-out of private contributions to public goods [J]. The Journal of Economic Education 27: 49-58.
    (16) Croson, Rachel & Melanie Marks (2001) . The effect of recommended contributions in the voluntary provision of public goods [J]. Economic Inquiry 39(2) :238-249.
    (17) Demsetz, Harald (1970) . The private production of public goods [J]. Journal of Law and Economics 13: 293.
    
    
    (18) Diamond, P. and J. Mirrlees (1971) .Optimal taxation and public production I: production efficiency [J]. American Economic Review 61:8-21.
    (19) Diamond, Peter A. and James A. Mirrlees (1971) . Optimal taxation and public production Ⅱ: Tax Rules [J].American Economic Review 61(3) : 261-278.
    (20) Epple,D., R.Filimon and T.Romer(1993) . Existence of voting and housing equilibrium in a system of communities with property taxes [J].Regional Science and Urban Economics 23:585-610.
    (21) Feehan, James P. & Mutsumi Matsumoto (2002) .Distortionary taxation and optimal public spending on productive activities [J]. Economic Inquiry 40(1) :60-68.
    (22) Fennell, Lee Anne(2001) .Beyond exit and voice: user participation in the production of local public goods[J]. Texas Law Review 80(1) .Nov.:1-87.
    (23) Fraser, Clive D.(2000) .When is efficiency separable from distribution in the provision of club goods[J]. Journal of Economic Theory 90:204-221.
    (24) Fredriksson, P. G. and D. L. Millimet (2002) . Strategic interaction and the determinants of environmental policy across US states [J]. Journal of Urban Economics 51: 101-122.
    (25) Fullerton, Don. (1991) . Reconciling Recent Estimates of the Marginal Welfare Cost of Taxation[J]. American Economic Review 81(1) : 302-308.
    (26) Foley, Duncan K.(1970) .Lindahl's Solution and the Core of an Economy with Public Goods[J].Econometrica 38:66-72.
    (27) Gerdes, William D. (1998) . A Case for Private Provision but Collective Ownership of Public Goods[J]. American Economist 42(1) :90-94.
    (28) Greenberg, J.(1983) .Local public goods with mobility: existence and optimality of a general equilibrium[J]. Journal of Economics Theory 30:17-33.
    (29) Grossman, Sanford & Oliver Hart (1986) . The costs and benefits of ownership: A theory of vertical and lateral integration [J]. Journal of Political Economy 94:4, 691-719.
    (30) Goldin, Kenneth D.(1977) . Equal access vs. selective access: A critique of public goods theory[J].Public Choice 29:53-71.
    (31) Hansmann, Henry(1980) .The role of nonprofit enterprise [J].Yale Law Journal 89:835-901.
    (32) Hart, Oliver, Andrei Shleifer, & Robert W. Vishny(1997) .The proper scope of government: Theory and an application to prisons[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics 112(4) : 1127-1161.
    (33) Hart, Oliver & John Moore (1990) . Property rights and the nature of the firm[J].Journal of Political Economy 9&6:1119-1158.
    (34) Hatzipanayotou, Panes & Michael S. Michael(2001) . Public Goods, Tax Policies, and Unemployment in LDCs[J].Southern Economic Journal 68(1) : 107-119.
    (35) Henderson,J.(1991) . Separating Tiebout equilibria[J]. Journal of Urban Economics
    
    29:128-152.
    (36) Hurwicz, L. (1979) .Outcome functions yielding Walrasian and Lindahl allocations at Nash equilibrium points[J]. Review of Economic Studies 46: 217-225.
    (37) Joskow, P and R. Schmalensee(1986) . Incentive regulation for electric utilities[J].Yale Journal on Regulation, 4(1) : 1-49.
    (38) Kaplow, Louis (1996) . The optimal supply of public goods and the distortionary cost of taxation[J].National Tax Journal 49: 513-533.
    (39) Kaufmmann, Daniel & Paul Siegelbaum (1997) . Privatization and Corruption in Transition Economies [J]. Journal of International Affairs 502:419-464.
    (40) Kodrzycki, Yolanda K.( 1994) .Privatization of local public services: Lessons for New England [J].New England Economic Review.May/Jun.:31.
    (41) Krauze, Andrzej (2000) . Let the public sector go free[J].New Statesman 129:5.
    (42) Lindsey, G. & G. Knaap(1999) . Willingness to pay for urban greenway projects[J]. Journal of the American Planning Association. Vol.65:297.
    (43) Loeb, M. and W. Magat(1979) . A decentralized method of utility regulation[J]. Journal of Law and Economics. Vol.22. P399-404.
    (44) Marwell, G. & R.E. Ames (1981) . Economists free ride, does anyone else?[J]. Journal of Public Economics 15: 295-310.
    (45) Mayshar, Joram (1990) .On measures of excess burden and their application[J]. Journal of Public Economics 43(3) :263-289.
    (46) Morrison, C., & A. Schwartz(1996) . State infrastructure and productive performance[J]. American Economic Review 86:1095-1111.
    (47) Murdoch, J. C., T. Sandier and K. Sargent (1997) . A tale of two collectives: Sulphur versus nitrogen oxide emission reduction in Europe[J].Economica 64: 281-301.
    (48) Nadiri, M. I. & T. Mamuneas(1994) . The effects of public infrastructure and R&D capital on the cost structure and performance of U.S. manufacturing industries [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics 76(1) : 22-37.
    (49) Gates, W.E.(1969) .The effects of property taxes and local public spending on property values: an empirical study of tax capitalization and the Tiebout Hypothesis[J].Journal of Political Economy 77(6) : 957-971.
    (50) Pauly, M. V. (1970) . Optimality, "public" goods, and local governments: A general theoretical analysis[J]. Journal of Political Economy 78(3) : 572-585.
    (51) Ray, Debraj & Rajiv Vohra (2001) .Coalitional power and public goods [J]. Journal of Political Economy 109(6) : 1355-1384.
    (52) Peltzman, S.(1976) . Towards a more general theory of regulation [J]. Journal of Law and Economics. Vol.19.
    (53) Perroni, Carlo & Kimberley A. Scharf(2001) .Tiebout with politics: Capital tax competition and constitutional choices[J].The Review of Economic Studies. Jan.
    (54) Ramsey, F.(1927) .A contribution to the theory of taxation[J].Economic Journal
    
    37:47-61.
    (55) Rose-Ackerman, S.(1979) .Market models of local government: exit, voting, and the land market[J]. Journal of Urban Economics 6:319-337.
    (56) Samuelson, Paul A.(1954) .The pure theory of public expenditure [J], Review of Economics and Statistics. 36:387-389.
    (57) Samuelson, Paul A.(1955) .Diagrammatic exposition of a theory of public expenditure [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics 37: 350-356.
    (58) Shleifer, Andrei(1998) . State versus private ownership [J].The Journal of Economic Perspectives 12(4) :133-150.
    (59) Sprumont, Yves(2000) .On the testable implications of collective choice theories[J]. Journal of Economic Theory 93:205-232.
    (60) Stigler, G. J.(1971) . The theory of economic regulation [J]. Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 2: Spring.
    (61) Stiglitz, Joseph E. & Partha Dasgupta (1971) . Differential taxation, public goods, and economic efficiency[J]. Review of Economic Studies 38(114) : 151-174.
    (62) Tiebout, C.(1956) .A pure theory of local expenditures [J]. Journal of Political Economy 64:416-424.
    (63) Tullock, Gordon(1996) .Provision of public goods through privatization [J]. Kyklos 49(2) : 221-224.
    (64) Walker, M. (1981) . A simple incentive compatible scheme for attaining Lindahl allocations[J]. Econometrica 49: 65-71.
    (65) Williams, A.(1966) .The optimal provision of public goods in a system of local governments[J]. Journal of Political Economy 74(1) : 18-33.
    (66) Williamson, O.(1967) .Hierarchical control and optimal firm size[J]. Journal of political Economy 75: 123-128.
    (67) Wilson, John & Marc A. Musick (1997) . Work and volunteering: the long arm of the job [J]. Social Forces76:251-272.
    (68) Arentsen, Maarten J., Rolf W. Kunneke(2001) . Dutch negotiated regulation: conceptualization and illustration[A]. In: Atle Midttun, Eirik Svindland, eds. Approaches and dilemma in economic regulation: politic, economics and dynamics [C]. New York: Palgrave.P27-54.
    (69) Boardman, A., D. Greenberg, A. Vining, and D. Weimer(1996) . Cost-benefit analysis: concepts and practice[M]. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. 62-64.
    (70) Bruce, Neil (1998) . Public finance and the American economy [M]. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
    (71) Buchanan, J.M. & R.E. Wagner(1987) . Democracy in deficit: The political legacy of lord Keynes[M]. Academic Press Inc..
    
    
    (72) Colman,A.M.(1982) .Game theory and experimental games[M]. Pergamon Press.
    (73) Dolorme, Robert(2001) . Regulation as an analytical perspective: The French approach[A]. In: Atle Midttun, Eirik Svindland, eds. Approaches and dilemma in economic regulation: politic, economics and dynamics[C]. New York: Palgrave. P1-26.
    (74) Foldvary, Fred(1994) .Public goods and private communities: The market provision of social service[M]. Brookfield, Vt.: Edward Elgar.
    (75) Green, Jerry R.& Laffont, Jean-Jacques (1979) . Incentives in public decision-making[M]. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
    (76) Hanushek, Eric A.(1996) .Rationalizing school spending: efficiency, externalities, and equity and their connection to rising costs[A]. In: Victor R. Fuchs ed., Individual and social responsibility: Child care, education, medical care, and long term care in America[C]. Chicago: University Press of Chicago.
    (77) Hart, Oliver (1995) . Firms, contacts, and financial structure [M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
    (78) Heckelman, J. C., Moorhouse, J.C. and Whaples, R.M(2000) . Public choice interpretations of American economic history [M]. Norwell, Massachusetts: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
    (79) Jehle, Geoffrey A. and Philip J. Reny(2001) .Advanced microeconomic theory(2nd eds)[M].上海财经大学出版社,培生教育出版集团.
    (80) Laffont, Jean-Jacques (1987) . Incentives and the allocation of public goods[A]. In: Auerbach, Alan J. & Martin Feldstein. eds. Handbook of public economics 2[C]. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
    (81) Levitt,T.(1973) .The third sector: New tactics for a responsive society[M].New York: AMACOM.
    (82) Lindahl, E.(1919) Just taxation-a positive solution[A]. In: Musgrave,R.A. & A.T. Peacock eds. Classics in the theory of public finance[C]. London: Macmillan: 168-177.
    (83) Logan, Charles (1990) . Private prisons: cons and pros[M].New York: Oxford University Press.
    (84) Musgrave, R. A.(1959) .The theory of public finance[M].New York: McGraw Hill.
    (85) Musgrave, R.A., P. Musgrave, and R. Bird(1987) . Public Finance in Theory and Practice[M]. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson.288-289.
    (86) Myles, Gareth D.(1995) .Public economics[M].Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    (87) Nechyba, Thomas J.(1996) .Existence of equilibrium and stratification in local and hierarchical Tiebout economies with property taxes and voting [WP]. NBER Technical Working Paper No. 190.
    (88) Oates, W. E. (1972) . Fiscal federalism [M]. New York: Harcourt Brace.
    
    
    (89)Olsen (1965).The logic of collective action[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    (90)Pigou, Arthur C. (1947). A study in public finance [M].London: Macmillan.
    (91)Rubinfeld, Daniel (1987).The economics of the local public sector[A].In: Alan Auerbach & Martin Feldstein eds., Handbook of public economics[C]. Amsterdam: North-Holland: 571-645.
    (92)Savas, E. S.(1982). Privatizing the public sector: How to shrink government [M].Chatham, N.J.: Chatham Holse Publishers.
    (93)Schotter, Andrew (1981). The economic theory of social institutions [M].Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    (94)Thompson, E. A.(1996). A Pareto optimal group decision process[A].In: G. Tullock, ed. Papers on non-market decision making[C]. Charlottesville: University of Virginia: 133-140.
    (95)Tollison, Robert D.(1998).Regulation and interest group[A], In: Robert B. Ekelund, Jr. (ed.) The foundation of regulatory economics, Volume Ⅲ, Regulation and deregulation: industries and issues[C].Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.
    (96)Wickstrm, Bengt-Arne(1993).Rent-seeking in different political environments[A]. In: Peder Andersen, Vibeke Jensen, and Jorgen Birk Mortensen, eds. Governance by legal and economic measures[C]. Copenhagen: G.E.C.Gad.
    (97)Wickstrm, Bengt-Arne(2001).Regulation of natural monopoly: A public-choice perspective[A]. In: Atle Midttun & Eirik Svindland eds. Approaches and dilemma in economic regulation: politic, economics and dynamics[C]. New York: Palgrave: 55-73.
    (98)Acocella,Nicola(1998,中译本,2001).经济政策原理:价值与技术[M].郭庆旺,等译.北京:中国人民大学出版社.
    (99)Arrow(1951,中译本,2000).社会选择与个人价值[A].载于Arrow.社会选择:个性与多准则[C].钱晓敏.孟岳良译.北京:首都经济贸易大学出版社.
    (100)Atkinson,A.B.& J.E.Stiglitz(1980,中译本,1994).公共经济学[M].蔡江南等译.上海:上海三联书店.上海人民出版社.
    (101)Barnett,Richard R.(1993,中译本,2000).偏好表露与共用品[A].载于P.Jackson主 编.公共部门经济学前沿问题[C].郭庆旺等译.北京:中国税务出版社.北京腾图电子出版社.P128-135.
    (102)Bail,Nicholas & Darid Whynes(1993,中译本,2000).福利经济学前沿问题[C].贺晓波,等译.北京:中:国税务出版社,北京腾图电子出版社.
    (103)Bromley,Daniel W(1989,中译本,1996).经济利益与经济制度——公共政策的理论基础[M].陈郁,等译.上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社.
    
    
    (104)Brown, C. V. & P. M. Jackson(1990,中译本,2000).公共部门经济学(第四版)[M].张馨,等译.北京:中国人民大学出版社.
    (105)Buchanan, J.M.(1986,中译本,1989).自由、市场与国家[M].上海:上海三联书店.
    (106)Buchanan,J. M. & G. Tullock(1962,中译本,2000).同意的计算——立宪民主的逻辑基础[M1.陈光金译.北京:中国社会科学出版社.
    (107)Eatwell, J., M. Milgate and P. Newman(1987,中译本,1996).新帕尔格雷夫经济学大辞典(第一卷).北京:经济科学出版社.
    (108)Hobbes(中译本,1985).利维坦[M].黎思复,等译.北京:商务印书馆.
    (109)Hume(1739,中译本,1980).人性论(下册)[M].北京:商务印书馆.
    (110)IBRD, World Bank(1999).1998/1999年世界发展报告:知识与发展[WP].蔡秋生,等译.北京:中国财政经济出版社.
    (111)马克思,恩格斯(中译本,1972).马克思恩格斯选集(第三卷)[C].北京:人民出版社.
    (112)Mcginnis, Michael(2000,中译本,2000).多中心体制与地方公共经济[M].毛寿龙译.上海:上海三联书店.
    (113)Mueller, D. C. (1989,中译本,1999)公共选择理论Ⅱ[M].杨春学等译.北京:中国社会科学出版社.
    (114)Olson, Mancur(1980,中译本,1995).集体行动的逻辑[M].陈郁等译.上海:上海三联书店.上海人民出版社.
    (115)Osborne, David & Ted Gaebler(1993,中译本,1996).改革政府:企业精神如何改革着公营部门[M].上海市政协编译组.东方编译所编译.上海:上海译文出版社.
    (116)Ostrom, Elinor(1990,中译本,2000).公共事物的治理之道[M].余逊达,等译.上海:上海三联书店.
    (117)Ostrom, E., Parks and Whitaker(1978,中译本,2000).公共服务的制度建构[M].宋全喜,任睿译.上海:上海三联书店.
    (118)Reynolds, L.G.(中译本,1982).微观经济学[M].北京:商务印书馆.
    (119)Samuelson, P. A. and W.D.Nordhaus(1985,中译本,1992).经济学(第12版)[M].北京:中国发展出版社.
    (120)Smith,A.(1776,中译本,1974).国民财富的性质和原因的研究(下卷)[M].郭大力.王亚南译.北京:商务印书馆.
    (121)Spulber, D.F.(1989,中译本,1999).管制与市场[M].余晖等译.上海:上海三联书店.上海人民出版社.
    (122)Stevens,J.B.(1993,中译本,1999).集体选择经济学[M].杨晓维等译.上海:上海三联书店.上海人民出版社.
    (123)Stretton, Hugh & Lionel Orchard(1994,中译本,2000).公共物品、公共企业和公共选择——对政府功能的批评与反批评的理论纷争[M].费昭辉,等译.北京:经济
    
    科学出版社.
    (124)Varian, Hal R. (1992,中译本,1997).微观经济学(第三版).周洪,等译.北京:经济科学出版社.
    (125)Weyman-Jones, Thomas G. (1994,中译本,2000).公用事业规制经济学的最新发展[A].Cable, J. 主编.产业经济学前沿问题[C].于立,等译.北京:中国税务出版社.北京腾图电子出版社.P229-268.
    (126)World Bank(1994).1994年世界发展报告[WP].毛晓威,等译.北京:中国财政经济出版社.
    (127)Yergin, Daniel & Joseph Stanislaw(1998,中译本,2000).制高点:重建现代世界的政府与市场之争[M].段宏,等译.北京:外文出版社.
    (128)植草益(中译本,1992).微观规制经济学[M].朱绍文,等译.北京:中国发展出版社.
    (129)植草益等(中译本,2000).日本的产业组织理论与实证的前沿[M].锁箭译.北京:经济管理出版社.中文期刊、报纸及网络文献
    (130)尼古拉·阿克塞拉(2001).全球性公共品供应的分配问题[J].经济理论与经济管理.第8期.P5-10.
    (131)陈振明(1996).市场失灵与政府失败——公共选择理论对政府与市场关系的思考及其启示[J].厦门大学学报(哲社版).第2期.
    (132)崔玉泉(2000).有政府干预的市场经济条件下收入及价格的变化对公共物品使用率的影响[J].经济数学,第2期.P20-30.
    (133)方晓利,周业安(200D.财政分权理论述评[J].教学与研究.第3期.
    (134)冯兴元(2001).论辖区政府间的制度竞争[J].国家行政学院学报.第6期.P27-32.
    (135)冯云廷,张素芬(2000).公共设施与服务的供给:民营化及其有效边界[J].东北财经大学学报.第1期.P48-51.
    (136)高洁,张奋勤(2002).农村税费改革须注意的几个问题.http"//202.112.118.59
    (137)龚六堂,邹恒甫(2001).政府公共开支的增长和波动对经济增长的影响[J].经济学动态.第9期.P58-63.
    (138)胡鞍钢(2002).中国发展的首要问题是农民问题.http"//www.chinanews.com.cn/2002-08-09/26/210352.html
    (139)胡东书(2002).政府规模和财政分权、集权的适宜度[J].改革.第1期.P70-73.
    (140)胡家勇(1997).政府与市场配合消除基础产业瓶颈[J].社会科学辑刊.第2期.P53-60.
    (141)胡建渊(2001).“公共产品”与财政“缺位”分析[J].经济师.第7期.P24-25.
    (142)胡乐明(2001).公共物品与政府的作用[J].财经研究.第8期.P11-16.
    
    
    (143)胡启生(1999).公共性一致同意规则——对中国事业单位改革的一种解释[J].天津社会科学.第6期.P57-61.
    (144)胡拓坪(2001).乡镇公共产品的供求矛盾探析[J].财政研究.第7期.P31-36.
    (145)黄志冲(2001).农村公共产品供给机制创新研究[J].农业经济学(人大复印资料).第2期.
    (146)黄耀军.黄瑞庆(2001).公共产品实验研究概述[J].经济学动态.第10期.P84-86.
    (147)贾明德(1996).我国事业单位改革探讨[J].管理世界.第3期.P198-201.
    (148)贾明德,雷晓康(2002).市场机制与公共物品的提供模式[J].上海经济.第9/10期.P25-27.
    (149)雷原(1996).农民负担与我国农村公共产品供给体制的重建[J].财经问题研究.第6期.P52-55.
    (150)黎炳盛(2001).村民自治下中国农村公共产品的供给问题[J].开放时代.第3期.P71-81.
    (151)李彬(2002).西方国家公共服务市场化的实践及其评价[J].管理世界.第4期.P142.145.
    (152)李富忠,麻德业,林万龙(2002).目前我国乡镇制度外财政的规模和作用研究[J].生产力研究.第2期.P108-109.
    (153)李洪江,潘洪清(2000).论公共物品的提供[J].中国煤炭经济学院学报.第4期.P20-22.
    (154)林万龙(2002).乡村社区公共产品的制度外筹资:历史、现状及改革[J].中国农村经济.第7期.P27-35.80.
    (155)刘戒骄(2001).自然垄断产业的放松管制与管制改革[J].学术研究.第4期.P32-35.
    (156)刘磊(1997).税收与公共产品关系之研究[J].税务与经济.第1期.P7-10.
    (157)刘玉庭(2002).教育产业化与国际教育市场[J].管理世界.第4期.P143.153.
    (158)马拴友(2001).政府规模与经济增长:兼论中国财政的最优规模[J].财政与税务(人大复印资料).第1期.P9-13.
    (159)门建辉(1999).自然垄断行业放松管制:经验与借鉴[J].中国经济问题.第2期.
    (160)苗丽静(2002).论公共事业的社会化与市场化[J].东北财经大学学报.第3期.P12-15.
    (161)齐守印(2002).努力推进公共经济责权横向配置的合理化[J].理论前沿.第7期.P24-25.
    (162)莎琳(2002).财富和福利的创造——企业家精神和中国农村的发展型政府[J].经济社会体制比较.第1期.P62-69.
    (163)单学勇(2002).合理分权:中央与地方税收关系的必然选择[J].财政与税务(人大复印资料).第3期.P44-49.
    
    
    (164)申曙光(2001).论社会保险的公共品性与政府管理[J].学术研究.第6期.P34-37.
    (165)盛洪(2002).走向超越功利的社会.Sohu视线(http://www.sohu.com.).2002.6.24.
    (166)孙开(1999).公共产品学说与分级财政理论[J].山东财政学院学报.第4期.P41-44.
    (167)孙开(2002).地方财政若干理论问题研究[J].东北财经大学学报.第3期.P3-7.
    (168)孙钰(1999).公共物品的经营效率研究[J].南开经济研究.第6期.P28-32.
    (169)孙钰(2000).城市公共物品的运营与政策研判[J].中国房地产金融.第3期.P17-20.
    (170)孙钰,姚晓东(2001).提高公共物品配置效率问题研究[J].现代财经.第2期.P15-18.
    (171)谭秋成(2002).地方分权与乡镇财政职能[J].中国农村观察.第2期.P2-12,20.
    (172)唐任伍,等(2001).A. D. Atkinson及其对公共经济学的贡献[J].经济学动态.第6期.P71-75.
    (173)唐文进,李敛锋(2001).西方公共提供理论的新发展[J].经济学动态.第8期.P58-60.
    (174)汪永成,马敬仁(1999).香港政府的公共物品供给模式及其对内地城市政府的启示[J].城市发展研究.第3期.P39-45.
    (175)王海宁(1999).西方公共物品市场化理论浅析[J].聊城师范学院学报(哲社版).第4期.P90-92.
    (176)王晶(1999).论城市公共品的界定及其有效供给[J].现代财经.第2期.P5-8.
    (177)王金秀(2002).“政府式”委托代理理论模型的构建[J].管理世界.第1期.P139-140.
    (178)王俊豪,等(1998).西方国家的政府管制俘虏理论及其评价[J].世界经济.第4期.P25-28.
    (179)王凯涛,顾志明(1999).论城市公共物品及其提供[J].武汉治金科技大学学报(社科版).第4期.P26-29.
    (180)王小燕(2002).“辩诉交易”首次亮相我国法院[N].中国青年报.2002-04-22-(7).
    (181)王艳萍(1999).我国公共物品供给的低效率及对策分析[J].经济经纬.第6期.
    (182)王艳萍(2000).浅析准公共物品的定价问题[J].河南社会科学.第4期.P38-40.
    (183)魏建(1998).“公共产品”的强制性供给与农民负担的谈判制度[J].南开经济研究.第1期.P15-20.
    (184)文贯中(2002).市场机制,政府定价和法制——对市场失灵和政府失灵的匡正之法的回顾与展望[J].经济社会体制比较.第1期.
    (185)文建东(1996).西方官僚经济理论述评[J].经济学动态.第4期.P61-65.
    (186)吴士健,薛兴利,左臣明(2002).试论农村公共产品供给体制的改革与完善[J].农
    
    业经济问题.第7期.P48-52.
    (187)武彦民(2001).公共财政论的理论缺陷[J].财经问题研究.第1期.P33-36.
    (188)冼国明,张岸元,白文波(2001).“三提五统”与农村新税费体系——以安徽农村税费改革试点为例[J].经济研究.第11期.P76-81.
    (189)晓晨(1999).农村税费制度改革的难点与思路[J].中国农村经济.第10期.
    (190)熊巍(2002).我国农村公共产品供给分析与模式选择[J].中国农村经济.第7期.P36-44.
    (191)邢福俊(1999).城市公共物品供给的主体选择、效应分析与对策探讨[J].中央财经大学学报.第9期.P11-14.
    (192)邢福俊(2000).试论城市财政对城市公共物品的适度供给[J].财经论丛.第6期.P21-28.
    (193)徐诗举(1997).公共产品均等化:政府间转移支付制度的目标[J].内蒙古财经学院学报.第1期.P44-45.
    (194)许云霄,米君利(2002).谈我国公共投资政策的有效边界[J].生产力研究.第1期.P42-44.
    (195)阎坤,王进杰(2000).公共品偏好表露与税制设计研究[J].经济研究.第10期.P61-66.
    (196)杨建荣(1996).宏观调控下中央与地方关系的调整[J].财经研究.第3期.P3-11.
    (197)杨志勇(2000).20世纪西方财政学的发展与演变[J].厦门大学学报(哲社版).第3期.P82-88.
    (198)叶兴庆(1997).论农村公共产品供给体制的改革[J].经济研究.第6期.P57-62.
    (199)袁静(2001).城市建设举债的理论基础[J].财经理论与实践.第5期.P85-87.
    (200)曾国安(2000).试论政府供应公共物品的范围[J].武汉市经济管理干部学院学报.第2期.P27-30.
    (201)张军,何寒熙(1996).中国农村的公共产品供给:改革后的变迁[J].改革.第5期.P50-57.
    (202)张克中(2002).政府失灵、规制与我国反垄断[J].上海经济研究.第1期.P16-20.
    (203)张丽清,石小法(2000).不确定性公共物品模型研究[J].山东师大学报(自然科学版).第3期.P93-97.
    (204)张铭(2002).在市场经济与公共管理之间——西蒙与新古典主义经济学的对话[J].国外社会科学.第2期.P46-52.
    (205)张山林(200D.城市基础设施建设:公共物品投资主体的异化[J].中南财经大学学报.第6期.P100-103.
    (206)张馨(1995).公共产品论之发展沿革[J].财政研究.第3期.P26-32.
    (207)赵静(1996).怎样改革自然垄断行业的国家管制模式[J].经济论坛.第8期.
    
    P22-23.
    (208)赵阳(2001).农村税费体制改革试点情况与问题.中国农业信息网.2001.10.11.
    (209)仲伟周(1999).论地方公共物品的私人供应[J].当代经济研究.第8期.P66-69.
    (210)周小亮(2002).市场失灵及其制度矫正的两种经济理论分析[J].当代经济研究.第2期.P64-67.
    (211)周业安(2002).乡镇政府的“额外收入”[J].改革内参.第4期.P19-22.
    (212)朱柏铭(1998).科学界定中央与地方政府之间的事权范围[J].杭州大学学报.第4期.P26-32.
    (213)朱钢(2002).农村税费改革与乡镇财政缺口[J].中国农村观察.第2期.P13-20.
    (214)朱学东,李旭(2001).我国基础设施建设融资的一种新思路[J].经济理论与经济管理.第3期.P70-73.
    (215)祝世京,等(1995).一类确定大众偏好结构的方法研究[J].系统工程学报.第4期.P25-30.
    (216)陈东琪(2000).新政府干预论[M].北京:首都经贸大学出版社.
    (217)丁冰(1995).现代西方经济学说[M].北京:中国经济出版社.
    (218)高鸿业,等(2000).研究生用西方经济学(微观部分,第二版)[M].北京:经济科学出版社.
    (219)高培勇,崔军(2001).公共部门经济学[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.
    (220)郭庆旺,等(1999).公共经济学大辞典.北京:经济科学出版社.
    (221)胡代光(1998).西方经济学说的演变及其影响[M].北京:北京大学出版社.
    (222)胡家勇(1996).政府干预理论研究[M].大连:东北财经大学出版社.
    (223)黄然(2002).地方财政的扩张及其理由[A].贝多广,等编.财政金融前沿论丛[C].北京:中国人民大学出版社.
    (224)刘辉(1999).公共产品供给的理论考察[D].北京大学经济学院博士论文.
    (225)刘溶沧,赵志耘(1999).中国财政理论前沿[C].北京:社会科学文献出版社.
    (226)刘溶沧,赵志耘(2001).中国财政理论前沿Ⅱ[J].北京:社会科学文献出版社.
    (227)刘宇飞(1999).公共晶提供的经济学分析[D].北京大学经济学院博士论文.
    (228)毛寿龙,李梅(2000).有限政府的经济分析[M].上海:上海三联书店.
    (229)平新乔(2001).微观经济学十八讲[M].北京:北京大学出版社.
    (230)任俊生(2002).中国公用产品价格管制[M].北京:经济管制出版社.
    (231)盛洪(1993).经济学透视下的民主[A].载于汤敏.茅于轼主编.现代经济学前沿专题(第二集)[C],北京:商务印书馆.P82-106.
    (232)王传纶,高培勇(1995).当代西方财政经济理论(上,下册)[M].北京:商务印书馆.
    
    
    (233)王俊豪(1998).英国政府管制体制改革研究[M].上海:上海三联书店.
    (234)王绍光(1999).多元与统一——第三部门国际比较研究[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社.
    (235)杨小凯(1997).当代经济学与中国经济[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社.
    (236)杨之刚(1999).公共财政学:理论与实践[M].上海:上海人民出版社.
    (237)于立,王询(1996).当代西方产业组织学[M].沈阳:东北财经大学出版社.
    (238)周喜安(1999).透视政府经济职能[M].北京:经济科学出版社.
    (239)张军(1995).特权与优惠的经济分析[M].上海:立信会计出版社.
    (240)张军(1997).中国农村公共产品的供给:改革后的变迁[A].胡春惠.转型期的中国社会经济问题[C].香港:香港珠海书院亚洲研究中心.
    (241)张昕竹,让·拉丰,安·易斯塔什(2000).网络产业:规制与竞争理论[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社.
    (242)张维迎(1996).博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海:上海三联书店.上海人民出版社.
    (243)郑秉文(1993).市场缺陷分析[M].沈阳:辽宁人民出版社.
    1.[J]:期刊
    2.[M]:专著
    3.[C]:论文集
    4.[A]:论文集中析出的文献
    5.[N]:报纸
    6.[D]:学位论文
    7.[WP]:工作论文

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700