我国资源型城市棕地问题发生机理及激活策略研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
资源型城市是世界范围内普遍存在的一种城市类型,资源型产业为主导的产业结构决定了资源型城市工业用地比例普遍高于全国平均水平。资源可采储量的减少,使资源型城市面临着“资源枯竭”,“产业衰退”,“环境恶化”,“社会动荡”的四重危机。大量污染、闲置、废弃、惨淡经营的土地在城市化地区蔓延开来,资源型城市失去了往日的生机与活力。此时,准确把握棕地问题的发生机理,有针对性的制订一套完善的棕地激活策略与方案进而重构城市土地利用方式,是我国实现资源型城市转型的前提条件。然而,在我国现阶段对棕地的界定还没有形成统一认识,少数研究仅停留在文献综述及学科前沿领域简介的阶段。本文在借鉴西方棕地问题研究经验的基础上,结合我国资源型城市的实际情况明确的定义了“棕地”的概念,并根据“棕地”属性、特征、再开发潜力的差异进行分类。在深入研究资源型城市发展规律、生命周期、经济结构、社会结构、生态环境的基础上探索我国资源型城市棕地问题的发生机理。选取我国最大的石油生产基地大庆油田所在地——大庆市为具体研究对象,明确大庆市资源型产业的发展趋势和城市土地利用的现状,进而分别从环境、经济、文化、社会四个方面提出城市棕地激活、城市更新的政策及措施。意在填补我国资源型城市棕地问题研究的空白,为资源型城市转型开拓思路,提供依据。
Resource-based city is ubiquitous world-widely. Generally, the proportion of industrialland in those cities is higher than that of average. The situation is resulted by industrialstructure which taken resource-based industry as leader and pillar industry. Workable reservesor recoverable reserves decline spawn subsequent crisis in resource-based cities, such as‘resource depletion’,‘industries decline’,‘environment deterioration’,‘social convulsion’.Great amount of contaminated field and, underused field, derelict field and vacant landscattered all around of the cities, the city lose vitality as it were. At that crucial moment, fullyunderstand the generation mechanism of the phenomenon would be a pressing task for thescholars in concern. It is self-evident that rearrange a whole package of the solution principlesand methods for settled down the question and fulfill Brownfield revitalization would be thebest choice at present, while the fundamental step needs to be taken as a base of undertakeresource-based cities reformation. However, putative definition of‘Brownfield’has not beeninformed in China yet, limited references lingered around document review and briefintroduce western experiences . This paper draw on the lessons from western countries, takenthe actual situation of our country into account, define‘Brownfield’and categorize theconception into several subcategories, according to feature, character, development potential.In the aim of unravel the mechanism the phenomenon as scattered Brownfield inresource-based cities of China. Further, take Daqing city as a case, the largest oil field baselocation of our country, certify land use situation for resource-based industries. Revitalizationmeasures in tackle with Brownfield question as well as city regeneration would be pointed outin the perspective of environment, economy, culture, social, four aspects respectively. Intentto fill the blank of the Brownfield research of resource-based city in contemporary China,meanwhile, provides new thought in due question, resource-based cites transition, in the longrun.
引文
[1]于光.矿业城市经济转型理论与评价方法研究[M].北京:地质出版社, 2008.3 pp.7YU Guang. Economy Transformation Theory and Assessment Method Research in MillingCities [M]. Beijing: Geological Press. 2008.3 pp.7
    [2]田红娜.中国资源型城市创新体系营建[M].北京:经济科学出版社, 2009.5 pp.1-5TIAN Hongna. Construction and Management of Innovation System in Resource-Based Cities,China.[M]. Beijing: Economic Science Press. 2009.5 pp.1-5,94,166
    [3]Thomas Fletcher., Neighborhood change at Love Canal: contamination, evacuation andresettlement ., Land Use Policy . Volume 19, Issue 4, October 2002, PP 311-323
    [4]Gareth Thorntona, Martin Franzb, David Edwardsc et al. The challenge of sustainability:incentives for brownfield regeneration in Europe. Environmental Science & Policy Volume10, Issue 2, April 2007, PP 116-134
    [5]朱煜明,苏海棠,郭鹏.中外棕地治理与再开发政策、法规的比较研究[J].环境保护科学,2009,35(3)ZHU Yuming, SU Haitang, GUO Peng. Comparison Study on Policies and Regulations ofBrownfields Cleanup and Redevelopment at Home and Abroad. Environmental ProtectionScience. 2009,35(3) PP 40-43
    [6]陈成.西方国家棕地重建策略及其对我国的启示[J].国土资源情报,2008,(6)CHEN Cheng. Lessons from Brownfield Revitalization Strategy in Western Country to China.Land and Resource Informaiton. 2008,(6) PP 16-20
    [7]牛慧恩.美国对"棕地"的更新改造与再开发[J].国外城市规划,2001,(2)NIU Huien.Brownfields Redevelopment in the United States[J]. Urban Planning Overseas.2001,(2) PP30-31,26
    [8](美)格林斯坦等编,丁成日循环城市——城市土地利用与再利用北京:商务印书馆2007 PP250-253Rosalind Greenstein and Yesim Sungu-Eryilmaz. Recycling the city: the use and reuse ofurban land[M]. Translated by DING Changri. Beijing: The Commercial Press 2007PP250-253
    [9]莫俊文,赵延龙,宁贵霞.城市土地置换开发收益及分配研究--以兰州市南河道周边土地置换开发为例[J].中国国土资源经济,2004,17(5)MUO Junwen. ZHAO Yanlong. NING Guixia. Incomes of Displacement and Development ofCity Land and Their Sharing-- In the Instance of Lan Zhou City. Natural Recourse Economicsof China. 2004,17(5)
    [10]沈实现,韩炳越.旧工业建筑的自我更新--798工厂的改造[J].工业建筑,2005,35(8)SHEN Shixian. HAN Bingyue. Self-renewal of the oil industrial architectures—reform of 798factory. Industrial Construction. 2005,35(8)
    [11]张平宇.沈阳铁西工业区改造的制度与文化因素[J].人文地理,2006,21(2) ZHANGPing-yu. Institutional and cultural factors for the reconstruction of Shen Yang Tie Xiindustrial zone. Human Geography. 2006,21(2)
    [12]张金伟,常江.城市废弃地景观与生态恢复研究[J].现代城市研究,2007,22(11)pp40-49ZHANG Jinwei, CHANG jiang. The Study of Landscape and Ecological Restoration ofUrban Derelict Land[J]. Modern Urban Research , 2007,22(11)pp40-49
    [13]殷柏慧,张洪刚,端木山.从工业废弃地到城市游憩空间的转化与更新——以安徽省淮南大通矿生态区改造为案例[J].中国园林,2008,24(7)pp43-49YIN Baihui, ZHANG Honggang, DUANMU Shan. Transformation and Renovation fromIndustrial Wasteland to Urban Recreation Space——Case Study of the Transformation ofDatong Coal Mine Ecological Area of Huainan, Anhui Province[J]. Chinese LandscapeArchitecture,2008,24(7)pp43-49
    [14]倪敏东.国外"棕地"改造的启示——以武汉"龟山北"地区城市设计为例[J].国际城市规划,2009,24(2)NI Mindong. The Inspiration of Western "Brownfield" Regenerations——Take the UrbanDesign of Wuhan "Guibei" Area as an Example. International Urban Planning. 2009,24(2)
    [15]俞孔坚庞伟,足下文化与野草之美--岐江公园案例北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2003YU Kongjian, PANG Wei. The Culture that Has Been Ignored, The Beauty ofWeeds——Qijiang Park in Zhongshan City. Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press2003
    [16]王英,郑德高.在可持续发展理念下英国住宅建设的道路选择--读《绿地、棕地和住宅开发》[J].国外城市规划,2005,20(6)WANG Ying,ZHENG De gao.A Review on "Greenfields, Brownfields and HousingDevelopment": The Options of Housing Development in UK Based on SustainableDevelopment Framework[J]. Urban Planning Overseas, 2005,20(6)
    [17]国务院关于国家环境保护“十五”计划的批复.国函(2001)l69号,2001.11.26National Letter of China. The Sate Council response to National environmental protection ofthe 11th five year plan. No.(2001)169. 2001.11.26
    [18]财政部,国土资源部,环保总局.关于逐步建设矿山环境治理和生态恢复责任机制的指导意见.财建[2006]215号文件,2006.2.Financial Ministry, Department of Land Resource, Environmental Protection Bureau. Leadingsuggestion towards ecology and environmental rehabilitation responsibility mechanismgradually. FM[2006] NO.215. 2006,2
    [19]刘伯英,冯钟平.城市工业用地更新及工业遗产保护[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社.2009, 10 pp. 10-14LIU Boying, FENG Zhongping. City Industrial Distract Regeneration and IndustrialHeritage Protection[M]. Beijing: China Built Construction Press. 2009,10 pp. 10-14
    [20]董锁成,李泽红,李斌等.中国资源型城市经济转型问题与战略探索[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2007,17(5),pp12-17DONG Suocheng, LI Zehong, LI Bin et al. The Problems and Strategies on EconomicTransformation of Resource-based Cities in China [J]. China Population Resources andEnvironment,2007,17(5)pp12-17
    [21]齐建珍.资源型城市转型学.北京:人民出版社,2004.3 pp64QI Jianzhen. The Study on the Restructure of Mono-economic City. Beijing: People Press,2004.3 pp29
    [22]郑树峰,张柏,臧淑英等.黑龙江省大庆市产业结构对土地利用/土地覆被变化的影响[J].资源科学,2007,29(6)ZHENG Shu-feng, ZHANG Bai, ZANG Shu-ying. et al. Impact of Industrial Structure onLUCC in Daqing City of Heilongjiang Province[J].Resource Science , 2007,29(6)
    [23]宋飏.矿业城市空间结构演变过程与机理研究[D]:[博士学位论文].长春:东北师范大学,2008.SONG yang. Study on Progress and Mechanism of Urban Spatial Structure of MiningCity[D]:[Doctorial Degree Dissertation]. Changchun:Northeast Normal University, 2008.
    [24]贾敬敦,黄黔,徐铭,等.中国资源(矿业)枯竭型城市经济转型科技战略研究[M].北京:中国农业科学技术出版社. 2004. PP35JIA Jingdun, HUANG Xian, XU Ming, et al. Technical Strategy Towards ResourceExhausted Cities Transition . Beijing: Agriculture Science & Technology Press 2004 PP35
    [25]王艳珍.观念决定价值论与"东北现象"的反思[J].中国流通经济,2006,20(2)pp29-32WANG Yan-zhen. The Theory of Concept-Determined Value and the Review onNortheastern Phenomena [J]. China Business and Market, 2006,20(2)pp29-32
    [26]常江.偏远型资源枯竭矿区土地再利用研究[A].2008中国城市规划年会论文集[C].2008.CHANG Jiang. Research on Mining Area Exhaustion Area of Remote Area[A].AnnualConference of China Planning Association [C].2008
    [27]大冶,该如何走好转型的路?大冶市国土资源局Da Ye, How to do a good job in Transformation? The Bureau of Land Resourceshttp://www.dygt.gov.cn/Html/Chief/Personnel/lingdaofangtan/17899585_2.html[EB/OL].
    [28]赵文祥,李颖娟,敖国杰.资源枯竭型城市:调整城市规划促进就业[J].中国国土资源经济,2006,19(7)pp13-14ZHAO Wenxiang, LI Yingjuan, AO Guo-ie. Adjusting Urban Plans and CreatingEmployment Opportunities in the City Exhausting Mineral Resources[J]. Natural ResourceEconomics of China,2006,19(7)pp13-14
    [29]陈超."春风"难度玉门关--关注油城和十万人的出路[J].中国石油石化,2004,(6)pp85-86CHEN Chao. Not a easy job for "Breeze" A Pressing Question of Oil-based City and theResidence[J]. China Petrochem,2004,(6)pp85-86
    [30]马建龙.资源型城市随资源枯竭的发展轨迹的研究[J].工业技术经济,2009,28(12)pp38-40MA Jianlong. Path Research of Resource exhaustion in Resource-based cities[J]. IndustrialTechnology & Economy,2009,28(12)pp38-40
    [31]张永凯,马国霞,田玉军.资源型城市经济转型的体制政策研究[J].淮海工学院学报(社会科学版),2008,6(4)pp58-60ZHANG Yongkai, MA Guoxia, TIAN Yujun. Study on Policies for Economic Transition inResource-oriented Cities[J].Journal of Huaihai Institute of Technology(Social ScienceEdition),2008,6(4)pp58-60
    [32]赵景海.我国资源型城市空间发展研究[D]:[博士学位论文].长春:东北师范大学,2007.Zhao Jinghai. Research on Spatial development in Resources-Based Cities ofChina[D]:[ Doctorial Degree Dissertation]. Changchun:Northeast Normal University, 2007.
    [33]汤中立,李小虎.白银大型金属矿山环境地质问题及防治[J].国土资源,2005,(8)pp4-7TANG Zhong-li, LI Xiao-hu. Environmental Geological Problems and Their PreventionCountermeasures of Baiyin Large-scale Metal Mine, Gansu Province[J]. Land &Resources,2005,(8)pp4-7
    [34]刘贵明,魏亮,郑寿亭.平顶山矿区土地塌陷影响与整治[J].煤矿环境护,2001,15(3)pp51-54LIU Guiming, WEI Liang, ZHENG Xiaoting. Influence on Treatment on Land Subsidence inPingdingshan Mine Area[J]. Coal Mine Environmental Protection,2001,15(3)pp51-54
    [35]许开营.让损毁的土地重生——山东省邹城市加强采煤塌陷地复垦的经验[J].国土资源通讯,2008,(22)pp39-40XU Kaiying. Reborn the Destroied Urban Land--Rehabilation and Reclaim Experiences ofZou Cheng City, Shan Dong Province[J]. National Land & ResourcesInformation,2008,(22)pp39-40
    [36]W.W.Rostow,The Staɡes of Economic Growth, Cambridge UniversityPress,Cambridge,Mass.,1960
    [37]孙淼,丁四保.我国资源型城市衰退的体制原因分析[J].经济地理,2005,25(2)SUN Miao, DING sibao. The Analysis on the Reason s of Institution System in ChineseResource-Typed Cities’Recession[J]. Economic Geography, 2005, 25(2) 273-276
    [38]周红梅.试论落后地区主导产业的选择[J].理论学刊,2005,(9)pp45-46ZHOU Hongmei. Research on Leading Industrial Selection in Backward Area[J]. TheoryJournal,2005,(9)pp45-46
    [39]路卓铭,于蕾,沈桂龙.我国资源型城市经济转型的理论时机选择与现实操作模式[J].财经理论与实践,2007,28(5)102-108LU Zhuo-ming, YU Lei, SHENG Guilong. The Optimal Timing in Theory and ActualOperation Mode of Economic Restructuring of China's Resource Based Cities[J]. The Theoryand Practice of Finance and Economics , 2007,28(5)102-108
    [40]王胜今,于逢良.论东北振兴过程中的政府职能[J].东北亚论坛,2006,15(3)pp3-8WANG Shengjin,YU Fengliang. Discussion on Government Function in Revival of NortheastChina[J]. Northeast Asia Forum, 2006,15(3)pp3-8
    [41]刘玉劲,陈凡,邢怀滨.我国资源型城市产业转型的分析框架[J].东北大学学报(社会科学版),2004,6(3)pp184-187LIU yujin, CHEN fan,XING huaibin. Framework for Analyzing Industrial Conversion ofResource-Based Cities in China[J] .Journal of Northeastern University(Social Science),2004,6(3)pp184-187
    [42]王若菊,王士君.东北地区资源型城市转型的城市联盟制度探索[J].城市发展研究,2009,16(9)pp1-4WANG Ruoju, WANG Shijun. A New Path Seeking for Establish City Alliance in RegionalPerspective to Promote Old Industrial Resource based cities Reformation in NortheastChina[J].Urban Studies ,2009,16(9)pp1-4
    [43]沙景华,李刚.矿业城市经济转型的模式路径及经验研究--以吉林省辽源市为例[J].中国矿业,2005,14(12)SHA Jinghua, LI Gang. The Research of Mode and Experience of Economic Transforation inMiddle-Aged Mineral City--Taking LiaoYuan City of Jinlin Province as an Example. ChinaMining Magazine .2005,14(12)pp22-25
    [44]http://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/[EB/OL]
    [45] Martha Matsuoka. Building Health Communitise: Environmental Justice inCalifornia[EB/OL]. 2003, 9 http://www.cbecal.org/pdf/healthy-communities.pdf
    [46] Frederick H. Gareau. "Morgenthau's Plan for Industrial Disarmament in Germany" [J].The Western Political Quarterly, Vol. 14, No. 2 (Jun., 1961), pp. 530
    [47]http://www.ebns.co.uk/downloads/Enviro%20Delivery%20Plan%20March%202009.pdf[EB/OL]
    [48] Lewis Mumford, The City in History San Diego, Harcourt Inc, 1961; p. XI
    [49]邹德慈.人性化的城市公共空间[J].城市规划学刊,2006,(5)pp9-12ZOU Deci. The Humanized Urban Public Space[J]. Urban Planning Forum,2006,(5)pp9-12
    [50] Adams, David, De Sousa, Christopher, Tiesdell, Steven. Brownfield Development: AComparison of North American and British Approaches[J].Urban Study 2010 47: PP75-104
    [51] Gareth Thorntona, Martin Franzb, David Edwardsc.et al. The Challenge of Sustainability:Incentives for Brownfield Regeneration in Europe [J]. Environmental Science & PolicyVolume 10, Issue 2, April 2007, PP 116-134
    [52] DoE (1995a) Projections of Households in England to 2016. London: HMSO.
    [53]大庆市统计局.大庆统计年鉴[M]. 2008 PP169Daqing Statistical Yearbook [M]. Bureau of Statistic. 2008 PP169
    [54]杜新强.大庆市地下水位降落漏斗区水资源人工调蓄关键技术研究[D]: [博士学位论文].长春:吉林大学,2006pp53DU Xinqiang. Study on the Key Technologies of Water Resources Regulation byGroundwater Depression Cone in Daqing City[D]. [Ph.D Degree Dissertation]. Changchun: JiLin University. 2006pp53
    [55]大庆年鉴2007[M].哈尔滨:大庆市史志办编.黑龙江人民出版社,2007.12pp63-66Daqing Yearbook 2007[M]. Harbin: Local History Office. Heilongjiang People Press,2007.12pp63-66
    [56]周志祥,齐素文,秦延军.大庆市西部地下水库建设方案初步研究[J].水利规划与设计,2008,(2)20-23ZHOU Zhixiang, QI Suwen, QIN Yanjun. Primary Plan for West Daqing City UndergroundReservoir[J]. Water Conservancy Plan & Design, 2008,(2)20-23
    [57]大庆市域城镇体系规划专题论证报告之二(内部资料)2004
    [58]姜吉生,王勇.大庆市主要环境地质问题及其综合治理[J].黑龙江水专报,2004,31(4)86-89JIANG Jisheng, WANG Yong. Major geological Questions and ComprehensiveImplements[J]. Professional Water Report of HEI Longjian Province, 2004,31(4)86-89
    [59]王国君.大庆油田用地管理问题研究[D]:[硕士学位论文].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工程大学,2004.WANG Guojun. Research on Land use Management Issue of Daqing Oilfield [D]: [MBADegree Dissertation]. Harbin: Harbin Engineering University. 2004
    [60]大庆市国民经济和社会发展第十一个五年规划纲要

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700