基于文化链的企业文化变革研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
当今企业经营面临的重大问题是市场竞争日益激烈,经营环境不断变化。只有不断根据外部环境的变化和经营战略的调整进行必需的企业变革,企业才能具有更大的灵活性,才可能拥有可持续的竞争优势,在激烈的市场竞争中方能立于不败之地。因而,组织变革已经成为管理变革的重要内容。而在所有变革环节中,文化变革居于核心地位,但同时也是最为艰巨的环节。它涉及到员工思考方式的改变,更是一种头脑中的变革。文化变革是企业变革成功的基本保证,文化变革不成功则企业其他方面的变革难以取得预期成效。所以,如何建立科学的企业文化变革模式,已经成为理论界和诸多企业管理者研究探讨的重要问题。
     本文采取了文献研究法、案例分析法和跨学科的系统研究方法,体现了规范研究与实证研究相结合、理论与实践相结合、广度分析与深度分析相结合的研究特色。通过基础研究、理论模型的构建、实证研究这样一个逻辑思路,对基于文化链的企业文化变革这一命题展开研究。本文在研究企业文化变革时将研究聚焦在“文化链”这一概念范围内,围绕这一概念衍生出与文化链密切相关的理论观点,并注意到企业文化变革和组织变革的协同,进而构建基于“文化链”的企业文化变革模型、阐述了企业文化变革的操作手段以及变革的关键驱动力量所在。
     首先,本文从文化链和企业文化变革的文献入手,回顾了现有学术文献中对“文化链”的研究;在有关企业文化变革的研究方面,主要从企业文化变革与经营绩效的关系,企业文化变革的方向、模式及步骤,企业文化变革与组织变革之间的关系三个方面对相关文献进行梳理,进而理清了企业文化变革的经典理论模式及其演进过程。在此基础上,作者分析了企业文化变革的假设及路径依赖,探讨了影响企业文化变革的内外部环境因素,阐述了企业文化的路径依赖特性以及由此给企业文化变革带来的阻力。
     论文的核心在于以学习型组织理论和组织学习理论为依托,构建了基于“文化链”的企业文化变革模型("CCBCC"模型)。重点讨论了“文化链”的背景、内涵,阐释了"CCBCC"模型的结构、要素构成、理论价值等。在"CCBCC"模型中,以企业文化变革的工具——“文化链”为核心,以领导力和管理能力作为两个变革的重要能力变量,论述了“反馈”、“反思”、“行动”和“内化”等四个子系统的内在含义,并论述了这四个子系统之间的逻辑关系以及他们之间的循环特征。同时,理清了学习型组织,、组织学习和企业文化变革的关系,即企业文化变革的关键是建立学习型组织,组织变革和文化变革都要通过“组织学习”来实现。应该说,"CCBCC"模型系统的整合了以往企业文化变革理论,具有较强的实操性和解释力,对于开展企业文化变革的企业具有较强的借鉴意义。
     其次,在"CCBCC"模型基础上,从实践的角度给出基于“文化链”的企业文化变革操作流程和具体措施。接下来,阐述了领导联盟是基于“文化链”的企业文化变革中的驱动力量,是“文化链”运行的激活因子,分析了领导联盟的“飞轮效应”及其对文化变革的作用机制,指出领导联盟在文化变革循环中起着催生、激活和加速的作用,并探讨了增强领导联盟的方法。
     最后,在本文的实证部分,以作者亲身主导的三家企业—齐鲁石化公司储运厂安全文化变革、齐鲁石化建设有限公司质量文化变革、齐鲁物流公司创建学习型文化的变革案例,分析了这三家企业文化变革的路径、手段,讨论了“文化链”这一企业文化变革工具在其中的作用机制,进而验证本研究提出的基于“文化链”的企业文化变革模型—"CCBCC"模型的理论观点。
Currently, all the companies are facing an operational environment in which competition is fierce and operational surrounding is changeable and unpredictable. In such situation, only by running coporate change according to the changing external environment and changing operational strategy, can a business be more flexible and obtain sustainable competition edge and keep growing in the market. Therefore, organizational change has already become an important part of management change. While in all the sections of change, culture change is unquestionably the core but the most difficult one, because it is a change in mind, involving changes in the way employees think. Culture change is the basic guarantee of a successful business change, the failure of which will certainly lead to unmet change objectives. Therefore, how to establish a scientific coporate culture change model becomes a hot topic theoretically and practically, which leads to the birtyh of many theories about culture.
     This dissertation, combining normative research with empirical research, incorporating theory and practice, uses acdamic methods of literature study, case analysis and interdisciplinary systematic research. By using fundamental research, structuring theoretical model and adopting empirical research method, this dissertation undertakes a study on coporate culture change based on culture chain. When studying coporate culture change, the dissertation focuses on the concept of culture chain and, based on which, derives relevant theoretical concepts. Noticing the synergy between culture change and coporate change, the dissertation structures a Culture-Chain-Based Culture Change model and illustrates the operational means of culture change and the underlying driving force.
     This dissertation firstly begins with literatures on culture chain and coporate culture change and makes a literature review, reviewing those researches on culture chain in existed documents. On research of business culture change, the author sorts the data from the perspectives of relationship between coporate culture change and business performance, the direction, model and steps of culture change, the relationship between culture change and coporate change, clarifying the classic theoretical models and their evolution steps. On this basis, the author analyses the hypothesis and the routing of coporate culture change, discusses the internal and external environmental factors that constrain culture change, and represents the routing dependent feature of coporate culture and the consequent resistance force thereby.
     The core of this dissertation lies in that, on the basis of learning organization theory and organizational learning theory, it establishes the model of Culture-Chain-Based Culture Change model (CCBCC model). It focuses on the background and connotation of culture chain, discusses the structure, composition and theoretical value of the model. This model, using the instrument of culture chain, a key of culture change, defining leadership and management capability as two important transformation capability variables, discusses the connotations of four subsystems, namely feedback, reflection, action and internalization, and explains the their logic interrelationship and cycle feature. Meanwhile, this dissertation clarifies the relationship between learning organization, organizational learning and corporate culture change:establishing a learning organization is the key to corporate culture change; organizational change and culture change are both achieved through oraganizational learning. Integrating previous theories on culture change and having strong practical and interpretational power, CCBCC model has a strong referential significance to those corporations conducting culture change.
     Secondly, on the basis of this model, this dissertation brings forth the operational procedure and specific measures to implement CCBCC model. Then, the dissertation conducts deep analysis on leadership alliance, which is the activator influencing the implementation of the model, discusses the flywheel effect of leadership alliance, which, considered by the author, is a driving force in the model. The author points out the catalytic, activating and accelerating role played by leadership alliance and approaches to strengthen the alliance.
     Finally, in the part of empirical research, the dissertation uses three cases, the safety culture change implemented by Qilu Petrochemical Company Storage Plant, the quality culture change taken by Qilu Petrochemical construction Ltd. and the learning culture creation practice taken by Qilu Logistics, as case study, which were dominated by the author himself, analyses the culture change routing and means taken by the three corporations, discusses the action mechanism of culture chain, a main instrument in change, in the process of culture change. The author uses the case study to try to testify the theoretical concept and practical value of the model of CCBCC.
引文
[1]Tornikoski E. T., Newbert S. L.. Exploring the determinants of organizational emergence: A legitimacy perspective. Journal of Business Venturing.2007,22 (2):311-335.
    [2]樊耘,李纪花,顾敏.基于四层次结构的组织文化与变革关系的实证分析.商业研究.2006,351(19):31-34.
    [3]王智敏,吴隆增等.基于系统观点的组织变革管理研究.经济师.2005,(8):10.
    [4]李军波,郑昭.论企业文化链与企业竞争优势的构建.湘潭大学社会科学学报.2001,25(6):113-116.
    [5]周施恩.“文化链”和“价值链”的互动机制研究.企业研究.2004,10:53-55.
    [6]杨河清,潘虎.企业经营者激励机制的文化链构建.职业.2007,36:23-24.
    [7]林竹盛.应用“文化链”理论进行企业文化变革,对企业价值增长影响作用分析.科学学与科学技术管理.2009,10:145.
    [8]Kotter, J. P., Heskett, J. L.. Corporate culture and performance. NY:The Free Press, 1992.
    [9]博纳德,博恩斯.变革时代的管理.昆明:云南大学出版社,2001.
    [10]约翰·科特,詹姆斯·赫斯科特.曾中,李晓涛译.企业文化与经营绩效.北京:华夏出版社,1997.
    [11]Barney J. B.. Organizational culture:Can it be a source of sustained competitive advantage. Academy of Management Review.1986, (11):656-665.
    [12]Steward, J. H. Theory of Culture Change:The Methodology of Multilinear Evolution. Urbana: University of Illinois Press,1955.
    [13]何心展,康廷虎.组织变革的多样性管理:一种系统性框架.心理科学.2004,27(4):153-156.
    [14]Reed M. I.. The Sociology of Organization:Themes, Perspectives and Prospects. London: Harvester Wheat sheaf,1992.
    [15]杰克琳·谢瑞顿,詹姆斯·L·斯特思.赖月珍译.企业文化:排除企业成功的潜在障碍.上海:上海人民出版社,1998.
    [16]苏米特拉·杜塔,让弗朗索瓦·曼佐尼著.过程改造、组织变革与绩效改进.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2001.
    [17]J·朱兰.朱兰论质量策划.北京:清华出版社,2000.
    [18]约翰·P·科特.领导变革:为什么企业转型的努力会失败.北京:中国人民大学出版社,1999
    [19]张雄.论组织变革与组织文化塑造的动态统一.学术探索,2004(9):27.
    [20]陈春花,刘晓英.组织变革中驱动机制和抵御习性的分析.软科学.2002,16(5):47-49.
    [21]Schein E. H.. The Corporate Culture Survival Guide. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,1999.
    [22]威廉·乔伊斯.张成译.组织变革..北京:人民邮电出版社,2003.
    [23]Michael B.. Revitalizing organizations:changing Process and emergent model. The Academy of Management Executive.1987,1 (2):51-55.
    [24]王南.企业再造与企业文化变革.经济与管理.2001,6:13-14.
    [25]Enrque C., Juan L., Daniel G., etal. Organizational culture for innovation and new technological behavior. The Journal of High Technology Management Research.2002,91:55-68.
    [26]孙兵.企业文化的唯一作用是持续提升企业的价值.中外企业文化.2008,5:41-42.
    [27]Wilkins A. L.., Dyer J. W.. Toward culturally sensitive theories of culture change. Academy of Management Review.1988,13(4):522-533.
    [28]埃德加·沙因.企业文化生存指南.郝继涛译.北京:机械工业出版社,2004.
    [29]约翰·P·科特,詹姆斯·L·赫斯克特.企业文化与经营业绩.李晓涛译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004.
    [30]詹姆斯·C·柯林斯,杰里·I·波勒斯.真如译.基业长青.北京:中信出版社,2002.
    [31]王玎.企业变革与企业文化管理.东北师范大学学报:哲学社会科学版.2005(3):80-83.
    [31]Flood R. L. Solving Problem Solving:A Potent Force for Effective Management. Chichester:Wiley,1996.
    [33]Cao G, Clark S, Lehaney B.. A critique of BPR from a holistic perspective. Business Process Management Journal.2001,7(4):332-339.
    [34]Bounds G., Yorks L., Adams M., et al. Beyond Total Quality Management:Toward the Emerging Paradigm. New York:McGraw Hill Inc.,1994.
    [35]赵钊,王云峰,陈晓春.组织变革、企业文化与领导力的关系研究.技术经济.2009,28(9):116.
    [36]杜漪,李真,马法洲.企业文化变革管控研究.科学学与科学技术管理.2007,11:135.
    [37]魏杰.企业文化塑造:企业生命常青藤.北京:中国发展出版社,2002.
    [38]张德.企业文化建设.北京:清华人学出版社,2003.
    [39]罗长海.企业文化学.北京:中国人民大学出版社,1999.
    [40]王成荣,周建波.企业文化学.北京:经济管理出版社,2002.
    [41]刘光明.企业文化.北京:经济管理出版社,1999.
    [42]黎群.企业文化建设100问.北京:经济科学出版社,2004.
    [43]Schein E. H.. Organizational Culture and Leadership. Sanfrancisco:Jossey-Bass,1985.
    [44]苏珊C.施奈德,简·路易斯·巴尔索克斯.跨文化管理.石永恒译.北京:经济管理出版社,2002.
    [45]马尔科姆·沃纳,帕特·乔恩特.跨文化管理.郝继淘译.北京:机械工业出版社,2004.
    [46]沃纳.伯克,燕清联合译.组织变革理论与实践.北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2004.
    [47]Burke, W. W.. Origination Change:Theory and practice. CA:Sage publications,2001.
    [48]王重鸣.管理心理学.北京:人民教育出版社,2001.
    [49]Carnall C. A.. Managing Change in Organizations. NJ:Prentice-Hall,1990.
    [50]Rochon T. R.. Culture Moves:Ideas, Activism, and Changing Values. NJ:Princeton University Press,1998.
    [51]齐振宏.管理变革之道.北京:清华大学出版社,2004.
    [52]Robbins S. P.. Organization Theory, Structure Design and Applications. NJ:Prentice Hall Engle2wood Cliffs,1995.
    [53]斯蒂芬·P·罗宾斯,玛丽·库尔特.管理学.孙健敏等译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004.
    [54]胡笑寒,万迪.企业组织变革的影响因素及变革模式的实证分析:以新创科技企业为例.数理统 计与管理.2005,24(1):15-20.
    [55]黎小林.价值观管理及其对企业文化变革的影响.广东商学院学报.2006,(1):29.
    [56]宋学锋.复杂性、复杂系统与复杂性科学.中国科学基金.2003,17(5):262-269.
    [57]刘洪,周玲.组织变革的复杂性增长路径.管理评论.2003,15(12):52-55.
    [58]Duncan R. B.. Characteristics of organizational environments and perceived environmental uncertainty. Administrative Science Quarterly.1972,17(2):313-327.
    [59]张鑫,刘洪.组织变革的复杂性研究.第三届(2008)中国管理学年会,长沙,2008年:3147.
    [60]樊耘,邵芳,李纪花.企业家对组织文化和组织变革影响的实证研究——基于组织文化四层次模型.管理评论.2009,21(8):104.
    [61]陈小平.企业文化的塑造和变革.企业文化.2004(5):52.
    [62]龚绍东,赵大士.企业文化变革战略.北京:科学技术出版社,1999.
    [63]彭国甫.行政组织学.长沙:湖南师范大学出版社,1990.
    [64]陈传明.企业战略调整的路径依赖特征及其超越.管理世界.2002,(6):94—-101.
    [65]王应静.基于路径依赖理论的中国企业家激励机制研究.南京:南京理工大学,2005.
    [66]李建设,王行佳.基于路径依赖理论的企业文化变革.大连海事大学学报(社会科学版).2009,8(3):49
    [67]Sull D. N.. Why good companies go bad. Harvard Business Review.1999, (7), (8):42-52.
    [68]陆奇岸.企业文化刚性的成因及其克服.华东经济管理.2006,(3):127.
    [69]张群祥,朱永法.基于新制度经济学视角的企业文化变革研究.企业活力.2008(3):65.
    [70]任凤玲.组织变革的阻力:组织惯性分析.管理科学文摘.2005,18(2):52-54.
    [71]孟晓斌,王重鸣,杨建锋.企业组织变革中的动态能力多层适应性探析外国经济与管理.2008,30(2):7.
    [72]刘秋英.企业文化刚性的变革策略.企业改革与管理.2006,(1):50.
    [73]斯蒂芬·P·罗克斯.录建敏,李原等译.组织行为学.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005.
    [74]杨文选,王艳.组织变革中动力与阻力的共生演进分析.工业技术分析.2007,26(8):97-100.
    [75]陈哗武.组织变革的动因、障碍与管理策略.经济论坛.2008,(13):69-70.
    [76]斯蒂芬·P·罗宾斯.如何克服变革的阻力.企业管理.2000,(12):52-54.
    [77]张军果,杨维霞.企业变革的阻力及对策分析.商业研究.2006,(9):78-81.
    [78]陈维政,余凯成,黄培伦.组织行为学高级教程.北京:高等教育出版社,2004.
    [79]王龙伟,李垣,王刊良.组织惯性的动因与管理研究.预测.2004,23(6):1-4.
    [80]任凤玲,彭启山,崔城.组织惯性的影响及对策研究.统计与决策.2005,(4):139-140.
    [81]郑华辉.消除抵制组织变革的阻力.中华管理论坛http:H wwwlvcmclcom,2006,(11).
    [82]陈又星,李春海.企业文化与企业变革.生产力研究.2003(3):210.
    [83]李作战.从组织变革的模式选择看组织变革的阻力及其克服.现代管理科学.2007,(6):45.
    [84]Porras J. I., Silvers R. C. Organization Development and Transformation. Annual Review of Psychology.1991,42:51-78.
    [85]Greiner L. E.. Evolution and Revolution as Organizations Grow. Harvard Business Review. 1972(8):37-463.
    [86]赖明正.组织变革中利益冲突与组织学习相关之实证研究:(博士学位论文).上海:复旦大学,2005.
    [87]Porras J. I., Robertson P. J.. Organizational development:Theory, practice and research, in Dunnette M. D., Hough L. M. Research in organization change and development. Greenwich CT:JAI,1992.
    [88]理查德.L.达夫特著.李维安等译.组织理论与设计精要.北京:机械工业出版社,1999.
    [89]赵龙,李牡丹,罗超群.基于组织文化的组织变革浅析.理论观察.2006,(2):51.
    [90]何建洪.论企业成长中的路径依赖.商业时代.2007,(33):52-53.
    [91]黄速建.企业经济学.北京:经济科学出版社,1998.
    [92]周德孚,殷建平,蔡桂其.学习型组织.上海:上海财经大学出版社,1998.
    [93]David A. G.. Building a learning organization. Harvard Business Review.1993, (7-8):78-91.
    [94]Senge P. M.. The Fifth Discipline-The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization. NewYork:Bantam Double day Deli,1990.
    [95]陈国权.学习型组织的过程模型本质特征和设计原则.中国管理科学.2002(4):86-94.
    [96]保罗·麦耶斯.知识管理与组织设计.广州:珠海出版社,1998.
    [97]冯奎.学习型组织:未来成功企业的模式.广州:广东经济出版社,2000.
    [98]查尔斯·汉迪.非理性的时代.北京:华夏出版社,2000.
    [99]王重鸣.管理心理学.北京:人民教育出版社,2001.
    [100]张声雄.学习型组织的创建.上海:上海科学普及出版社,2000.
    [101]Breweron P. M., Millwind L.. Organization Research Methods:A Guide for Students and Researchers. Sage Publications,2001.
    [102]沃特金斯·马席克.21世纪学习型组织.北京:世界图书出版社,2000.
    [103]克里斯.阿吉瑞斯著.张莉,李萍译.组织学习.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002.
    [104]Argyris C, Schon D. A.. Organizational Learning:A Theory of Action Perspective. Massaehusetts:Addison-Wesley,1978.
    [105]Peter P.. Organizational learning mechanisms and managers'perceived uncertainty. Human Relations.1999,10:1233-1254.
    [106]Crossan M. M., Henry W. Lane, Roderice E. White.. An Organizational Learning Framework: From Intuition to Institution. Academy of Management Review,1999,24(3):522-537.
    [107]Pautzke.. Organizational Learning:Implications for Organizational design. Research in Organizational Behavior.1989,1:75-123.
    [108]Edmondson A., Moingeon B.. From Organizational Learning to the Learning Organization. Journal of Management Learning.1998,29(1):5-20.
    [109]Fiol C., Lyles M. A.. Organizational Learning. Academy of Management Review.1985, 10(4):803-813.
    [110]彼得·德鲁克.知识管理.北京:中国人民大学出版社,1999.
    [111]黄健.造就组织学习力.上海:上海三联书店,2003.
    [112]赖明正.织变革中利益冲突与组织学习相关之实证研究:(博士学位论文).上海:复旦大学,2005.
    [113]桑强.企业组织变革的系统科学思考.科学决策,2001(6):57.
    [114]Garvin D. A.. Building a Learning Organization. Harvard Business Review.1993(4):78-91.
    [115]Watkins K. E., Marsick V. J.. Sculpting the Learning Organization:Lessons in the Art and Science of Systematic Change. San franciscio:Jossey-Bass,1993.
    [116]杰里·W·吉雷,安·梅楚尼奇,康青译.组织学习、绩效与变革—战略人力资源开发导论.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002.
    [117]张鼎昆,陆昌.用系统观诠释组织变革.企业改革与管理.2000(8):9-10.
    [118]沃纳·伯克.组织变革理论和实践.北京:中国劳动社会保障出版社,2005.
    [119]王丽娟.企业文化变革的自组织分析框架.管理世界.2006(6):155.
    [120]许国志.系统科学与工程研究.上海:上海科技教育山版社,2000.
    [121]彭国甫.行政组织学.长沙:湖南师范大学出版社,1990.
    [122]Cameron K. S., Quinn R. E.. Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture:Based on the Competing Values Framework. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,2005.
    [123]王文臣.基于企业竞争力的企业文化理论与实证研究.北京:经济科学出版社,2008.
    [124]Addyman T.. The internet:international information highway. New Library World. 1994,95(5):4-5.
    [125]MCBUP Ltd. Flat organizations can puncture employee morale. Management Development Review.1997,10 (7):252-253.
    [126]Kim J. S., Hamner W. C.. Effect of performance feedback and goal setting on productivity and satisfaction in an organizational setting. Journal of Applied Psychology. 1976,61(1):48-57.
    [127]Frappaolo C.. Knowledge Management. NH:Capstone,2006. [128] Dalkir K.. Knowledge Management in Theory and Practice. Oxford:Butterworth-Heinemann, 2005.
    [129]Beckhard R., Harris R. T. Orgnizational Transitions:Managing Complex Change. Reading, MA:Addision-Wesley,1997.
    [130]李继先.企业文化变革理论与实务—基于“浙商”的企业文化实践.北京:经济管理出版社,2009.
    [131]Chandler A. D.. Strategy and Structure:Chapters in the History of the American Industrial Enterprise. Massachusetts:The MIT Press 1969.
    [132]韩平.沟通管理:新经济条件下管理变革的基本趋势.延安大学学报:社会科学版.32003,25(1): 73.
    [133]Burke W. W.. Organization Change:Theory and Practice. CA:Sage Publications,2007.
    [122]Kanter, R. M..Dilemmas of managing participation. Organizatinal Dyanamics.1998, 11(1):5-27.
    [135]Argyris C., Schon D.. Theory in Practice. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,1982.
    [136]阎世平.制度视野中的企业文化.北京:中国时代经济出版社,2003.
    [137]张锋雄.论企业文化变革中价值理念制度化的必要性和原则.社会科学家.2005(S1):169.
    [138]Kolb D. A.. Experiential Learning:Experience as the Source of Learning and Development. New Jersey:Prentice Hall,1983.
    [139]金·S·卡梅隆,罗伯特·E·奎因.组织文化诊断与变革.谢晓龙译.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006.
    [140]Huber G. P., Glick W. H.. Organizational change and redesign:ideas and insights for improving performance. NewYork:Oxford University Press,1995.
    [141]Nadler D. A., Tushman M. L.. Beyond the charismatic leader:leadership and organizational change. California Management Review.1990,32(2):77-97.
    [142]Bantel K. A., Jackson S. E.. Top management and innovations in banking:Does the composition of the toP team make a difference? Strategic Management Journal.1989, (10):107-124.
    [143]Li J, Xin K. R.,Tsui A, et al; Building effective international joint venture leadership teams in China. Journal of World Business.1999,34(1):52-61.
    [144]Chell, E., Haworth J., Brearley S.. The Entrepreneurial Personality:Concepts, Cases, and Categories (Routledge Small Business Series). Landon:Routledge,1991.
    [145]KOTTER J.. Force for Change:How Leadership Differs from Management. New York:The Free Press,1990.
    [146]孙海法,伍晓弈.企业高层管理团队研究的进展.管理科学学报.2003,6(4):82-89.
    [147]樊耕,李纪花,顾敏.基于四层次结构的组织文化与变革关系的实证研究.商业研究,2006(19):31-35.
    [148]王云峰.领导力理论溯源及创业领导研究方向.技术经济.2008,27(6):21-26.
    [149]DAVIS S.. Managing Corporate Culture. New York:Ballinger Pub,1984.
    [150]伊查克·爱迪斯.企业生命周期.赵睿译.北京:华夏出版社,2004.
    [151]Drucker P. F. Management Challenges for the 21st Century, NY:Harper Paperbacks,2001.
    [152]Gates B. H.. Business @ the Speed of Thought:Succeeding in the Digital Economy. Business Plus,2000.
    [153]Kotter J. P.. A Sense of Urgency. MA:Harvard Business Press,2008.
    [154]李立新.从科学决策看领导团队建设.HR经理人,2009(6):53.
    [155]Jon S., Greene R. W.. Sociology and You. Ohio:Glencoe McGraw-Hill,2003.
    [156]欧阳桃花.试论工商管理学科的案例研究方法.南开管理评论.2004,7(2):100.
    [157]刘丽华,杨乃定.针对案例研究局限性的案例研究方法操作过程设计.科学管理研究.2005,23(6):118.
    [158]Yin R. K.. Applications of Case Study Research Second Edition. CA:Sage Publications, 2002.
    [159]Sanders P.. Phenomenology:A new way of viewing organizational research. The Academy of Management Review.1982,7:353-360.
    [160]吴金希,于永达.浅议管理学中的案例研究方法—特点、方法设计与有效性讨论.科学学研究 2004 (22):105-111.
    [161]Tellis W.. Information technology in a university:a case study. Campus-Wide Information Systems.1997,14(3):78-91.
    [162]Yin R. K.. Case Study Research:Design and Methods. Fourth Edition. CA:SAGE Publications,2009.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700