摘要
认同管理策略是弱势群体成员受到社会认同威胁时所采取的应对策略。该领域的研究关注弱势群体成员以何种方式应对弱势地位所带来的消极群体认同,人格、情境、信念及群体因素对人们的策略选择有着何种影响。对以上关系的探讨将有利于我们理解群际关系和群际行为,维护群际和谐。
本文在社会认同理论、五阶段模型理论和系统合理理论的指导下,采用实验法与问卷法相结合的方式,分别以实验情景和现实情景中的弱势群体成员(中职生)为研究对象,探讨了个体特征、情境特征以及群体特征三类因素对于认同管理策略的影响。研究的主要结论如下:
(1)个体特征因素对策略选择的影响作用
认知风格和宿命观都对人们的策略选择都存在显著影响。场独立者倾向于选择个体策略和妥协策略,场依存者倾向于选择群体策略。个体所持的宿命观越强,其采取妥协策略的可能性越大。
(2)情境特征因素对策略选择的影响作用
优势群体的开放度和成员态度对人们的策略选择都存在显著影响。优势群体开放度提高时,选择个体策略的人数将增多,反之则减少;优势群体成员态度谦逊,选择个体策略的人数将增多,反之则减少。弱势群体的团体表现也显著影响了成员的策略选择。当群体接近成功时,人们倾向于选择群体策略;而当群体接近失败时,人们则更可能选择个体策略和妥协策略。
(3)群体特征因素对策略选择的影响作用
群体实体性、理性群体认同和情感群体认同对个体的策略选择都有直接影响,且群体实体性通过理性群体认同和情感群体认同对策略选择有间接影响。
(4)相关测量工具的编制与修订
本研究通过探索性因素分析和验证性因素分析,证实编制的中职生认同管理策略问卷符合预期的三个维度,依次是个体策略、群体策略和妥协策略。中职生认同管理策略问卷的内部一致性系数为0.720,各项信度指标基本达到测量学的要求。验证性因素分析表明问卷有较理想的结构效度。
修订的归属需要量表、宿命观量表和中职生群体认同量表的一致性系数分别为0.734,0.770,0.868,以上问卷各项信度指标基本达到测量学的要求。验证性因素分析表明问卷有较理想的结构效度。
(5)中职生认同管理策略的现状分析
随着年级的升高,中职生选择个体策略的可能性逐渐增大,而选择妥协策略的可能性则逐渐降低。有工作经验的学生倾向于选择个体策略。不同性别的学生在策略选择上不存在差异。
Identity Management Strategies are defined as the coping strategies disadvantaged Group Members adopt, when they are confronted with inferior status and threatened by the negative social identity. The researches on Identity Management Strategies place emphasis on how disadvantaged Group Members coping with the negative social identity, and how factors of personality, context, belief and group influence the the identity management strategies by disadvantaged group members. It contributes to understanding intergroup relation and behavior, as well as maintaining harmony between groups.
Directed by the Social Identity Theory, Five-Stages Model and System Justification theory, the current study investigated how factors of individual characteristics, group characteristics and context influence the identity management strategies by disadvantaged group members. The subjects are minimal-group members in a laboratory context and real-life group memberships (vocational high school students).
The conclusions are the following:
(1) Effects of individual characteristics factors on identity management strategies.
Individual strategy and acceptance strategy was preferred by group member with field-independent cognitive style, and collective strategy were preferred by group member with field-dependent cognitive style. Individual strategy was preferred by group member with weak belief in fate, acceptance strategy was preferred by group member with strong belief in fate.
(2) Effects of context factor on identity management strategies.
When access to the advantaged group was open, people preferred individual strategy; when access to the advantaged group was restricted, people preferred collective strategy and acceptance strategy. When the advantaged group members were perceived arrogant, people preferred collective strategy and acceptance strategy; when the advantaged group members were perceived friendly, people preferred individual strategy. When the disadvantaged group performed well, people preferred collective strategy; when the disadvantaged group performed badlly, people preferred individual strategy and acceptance strategy
(3) Effect of group characteristics factors on identity management strategies.
Entitativity, cognitive in-group identification and affective in-group identification have direct impacts on identity management strategies by disadvantaged group members. While cognitive in-group identification and affective in-group identification can be regarded as powerful mediators between perceived entitativity and identity management strategies.
(4) Questionaire development of identity management strategies
The results of exploratory factor analysis and confirmatory factor analysis show the questionnaire of identity management strategies has acceptable psycho-metric properties. Cronbanch's a coefficients of the questionnaire is 0.720. It is composed by individual strategy, collective strategy and acceptance strategy. Confirmatory factor analysis indicated that this questionnaire has high construct validity.
The results of exploratory factor analysis and confirmatory factor analysis show the revision of belong need scale, destination belief scale and group identity scale have acceptable psycho-metric properties. Cronbanch's a coefficients of three scale respectively is Cronbanch's a coefficients of 0.734, 0.770, 0.868. Confirmatory factor analysis indicated that three scales have high construct validity.
(5) Characteristics and developing trend of identity management strategies by vocational high school students.
When vocational high school students move forward from grade 1 to grad 3, their preference for individual strategy gradually increase, but their preference for acceptance strategy gradually decrease. Individual strategy was preferred by vocational high school students with job experience. No gender difference is found among the vocational high school students.
引文
王沛,刘峰(2007):社会认同理论视野下的社会认同威胁。心理科学进展,第5期,第822-827页。
王沛,赵国军,喇维新(2006):回族大学生的民族认同与心理健康的关系。西北师大学报(社会科学版),第5期,第38-41页。
文崇一,萧新煌(1995):中国人:观念与行为。台北:巨流图书公司,第25-42页。
卫子光,靳莹,黄晓霞(2002):认知方式的实验研究——场依存性特征对计算机辅助教学与常规教学效果的影响。化学教育,第5期,第15-25页。
孔德生(2004):高校在校贫困大学生人格特征分析及教育对策研究。吉林大学,博士学位论文。
付宗国(2005):群际冲突的社会心理实质、原因与对策探析。山东社会科学,第4期,第42-45页。
孙红,任霞(2006):农村弱势群体的心理状态分析及对策。中国健康心理学杂志,第5期,第492-493页。
李寿欣,李涛(2000):大学生认知方式与人际交往及创造力之间关系的研究。心理科学,第1期,第119-120页。
许欣欣(2000):当代中国社会结构变迁与流动。北京:社会科学文献出版社。
朱力(1995):脆弱群体与社会支持。江苏社会科学,第6期,第43-44页
何友晖,彭泗清,赵志裕(2007):世道人心——对中国人心理的探索。北京:北京大学出版社,第107-137页。
宋广文,李寿欣,王新波(2001):学生认知方式影响文章阅读理解的实验研究。心理发展与教育,第2期,第31-35页。
杨中芳(1997):如何研究中国人。台北:桂冠图书股份有限公司,第130-156页。
杨朝明(2008):《荀子》简注通说。开封:河南大学出版社,第78-99页。
杨治良,杜建政,刘国学(1998):场依存性对边界扩展效应的影响。心理学报,第4期,第361-365页。
张莹瑞,佐斌(2006):社会认同理论及其发展。心理科学进展,第3期,第475-480页。
系李群.(1995).对数线性模型的概率特征.宁波大学学报,第4期,第11-15页。
陆学艺(2004):当代中国社会流动。北京:社会科学文献出版社,第181-212。
卓然(2007):大学贫困生群体心理探究及适应能力分析。吉林师范大学学报(人文社会 科学版),第1期,第39-42页。
周六枝,王济中(1998):芜湖市打工群体心理状况调查分析。中国心理卫生杂志,第4期,第243-244页。
赵志裕(1991)义:中国社会的正义观。见杨中芳和高尚仁主编,中国人,中国心:传统篇。台北:远流出版公司,第261-285。
黄光国(1977):中国社会的应变行为。中华心理学刊,第19期,第61-73页。
蔡英文(1982):天人之际——传统思想中的宇宙意识。见黄俊杰主编,中国文化新论思想篇二:天道与人道。台北:联经出版社,第287-327页。
Albert,S.(1977).Temporal comparison theory.Psychological Review.,84,485-503.
Allport,G.W.(1954).The nature of prejudice.Cambridge,MA:Addison-Wesley.
Appelgryn,A.E.,& Nieuwoudt,J.M.(1988).Relative deprivation and the ethnic attitudes of blacks and afrikaans-speaking whites in South Africa.Journal of Social Psychology,128(3),311.
Abrams,J.(1998/1999).Biographical Entries on authors Anya Seton,George Selden,and Peggy Parrish.In American National Biography.North Carolina:Oxford University Press.
Augustinos,M.(1998).Social representations and ideology:towards the study of ideological representations.In U.Flick(Ed.),The psychology of the social.New York:Cambridge University Press.
Bandura,A.(1995).Exercise of personal and collective efficacy in changing societies.Cambridge,England:Cambridge University Press.
Branscombe,N.R.,Schmitt,M.T.,& Harvey,R.D.(1999).Perceiving pervasive discrimination among african americans:Implications for group identification and well-being.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,77,135-149.
Branscombe,N.R.,Doosje,B.,& McGarty,C.(2003).Antecedents and consequences of collective guilt.In D.M.Mackie & E.R.Smith(Eds.),From prejudice to intergroup emotions:Differentiated reactions to social groups(pp.49-66).Philadelphia,PA:Psychology Press.
Baumeister,R.F.,& Tice,D.M.(1990).Anxiety and social exclusion.Journal of Social &Clinical Psychology,9,165-195.
Baumeister,R.F.,& Leafy,M.R.(1995).The need to belong:Desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation.Psychological Bulletin,117,497-529.
Blau,P,& Duncan,O.D.(1967).The American Occupational Structure.New York:Wiley.
Berry,J.W.(1984).Cultural relations in plural societies:alternatives to segregation and therir sociaopsychological implications.In N.Miller & M.Brewer(Eds.),Groups in contact.New York:Academic Press.
Bettencourt,B.A.,Dorr,N.,Charlton,K.,& Hume,D.L.(2001).Status differences and in-group bias:a meta-analytic examination of the effects of status stability,status legitimacy,and group permeability.Psychological Bulletin,127(4),520-542.
Blanton,H.,George,G.,& Crocker,J.(2001).Contexts of system justification and system evaluation:exploring the social comparison strategies of the(not yet) contented female worker.Group Processes and Intergroup Relations,4,127-138.
Blanz,M.,Mummendey,A.,Mielke,R.,& Klink,A.(1998).Responding to negative social identity:a taxonomy of identity management strategies.European Journal of Social Psychology,28(5),697.
Blair,I.V.,& Jost,J.T.(2003).Exit,loyalty,and collective action among workers in a simulated business environment:Interactive effects of group identification and boundary permeability.Social Justice Research,16,95-108.
Boen,F.,& Vanbselaere,N.(1998).Reactions upon a failed attempt to enter a high status group:an experimental test of the five-stage model.European Journal of Social Psychology,28,689-696.
Boen,F.,& Vanbeselaere,N.(2000).Responding to membership of a low-status group:the effects of stability,permeability and individual ability.Group Processes & Intergroup Relations,3(1),41-62.
Boen,F.,& Vanbeselaere,N.(2001).Individual versus collective responses to membership in a low-status group:the effects of stability and individual ability.Journal of Social Psychology,141(6),765-783.
Boen,F.,& Vanbeselaere,N.(2002).The relative impact of socio-structural characteristics on behavioral reactions against membership in a low-status group.Group Processes & Intergroup Relations,5(4),299.
Bowlby,J.(1973).Attachment and loss:Vol.2,Separation.New York:Basic.
Brown,R.(1995).Prejudice.Oxford:Blackwell.
Brown,R.(2000).Social identity theory:past achievements,current problems and future challenges.European Journal of Social Psychology,30(6),745.
Campbell,D.T.(1958).Common fate,similarity,and other indices of the status of aggregates of persons and social entities.Behavioral Science,3,14-25.
Caplan,N.& Nelson,S.D.(1973).On being useful:The nature and consequences of psychological research on social problem.American Psychologist,28,199-211.
Caporael,L.R.,& Brewer,M.B.(1995).Hierarchical evolutionary theory:There is an alternative,and it's not creationism.Psychological Inquiry,6(1),31-34.
Castano,E.,Yzerbyt,V.,& Bourguignon,D.(2003).We are one and I like it:The impact of ingroup entitativity on ingroup identification.European Journal of Social Psychology,33,735-754.
Commins,B.,& Lockwood,J.(1979).The effects of status differences favoured treatment and ability on intergroup comparisons.European Journal of Social Psychology,9,281-289.
Cheek,J.M.(1989).Identity orientations and self interpretation.In D.M.Buss & N.Cantor (Eds.),Personality psychology:Recent trends and emerging directions(pp.275-285).New York:Springer-Verlag.
Cook,T.D.,Crosby,F.,& Hennigan,K.M.(1977).The construct validity of relative deprivation.In J.Sulls & R.Miller(Eds.),Social comparison processes:Theoretical and empirical perspectives.(pp.307-333).Washington DC:Hemisphere.
Cozzarelli,C.,Wilkinson,A.V.,& Tagler,M.J.(2001).Attitudes toward the poor and attributions for poverty.Journal of Social Issues,57,207-227.
Crandall,C.S.(1994).Prejudice against fat people:ideology and self-interest.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,66,882-894.
Crosby,F.(1976).A model of egoistical relative deprivation.Psychological Review,83,85-113.
Crosby,F.(1982).Relative deprivation and working women.New York:Oxford University Press.
Davis,J.A.(1966).The campus as a frog pond:an application of the theory of relative deprivation to career decidions of college men.American Journal of Sociaolog.,72,17-31.
De Cremer,D.(2001).Perceptions of group homogeneity as a function of social comparison:the mediating role of group identity.Current Psychology,20(2),138.
De Cremer,D.(2002).Respect and cooperation in social dilemmas:The importance of feeling included.Ersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin,28,1335-1341.
De Cremer,D.,& Van Vugt,M.(1999).Social identification effects in social dilemmas:A transformation of motives.European Journal of Social Psychology,29,871-893.
Demick,J.(1991).Organismic factors in field dependence-independence:gender,personality,psychopathology.In S.Wapner and J.Demick(eds.),Field Dependence- Independence:cognitive style across the life span,Hillsdale,NJ.:Erlbaum.
Doosje,B.,Ellemers,N.,& Spears,R.(1995).Perceived intragroup variability as a function of group status and identification.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,31(5),410-436.
Doosje,B.,Spears,R.,& Ellemers,N.(2002).Social identity as both cause and effect:the development of group identification cation in response to anticipated and actual changes in the intergroup status hierarchy.British Journal of Social Psychology,41(1),57.
Dovidio,J.F.,Gaertner,S.L.,& Validzic,A.(1998).Intergroup bias:status,differentiation,and a common in-group identity.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,75(1),109.
Dube,L.,& Guimond,S.(1986).Relative deprivation and social protest:the personal group issue.In J.Olson,C.P.Herman & M.Zanna(Eds.),Relative deprivation and social comparison.(pp.201-216).Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum.
Ellemers,N.(1993).The influence of socio-structural variables on identity management strategies.In &.M.H.W.Stroebe(Ed.),European review ofsocialpsychology(Vol.4,pp.27-57).Chichester,U.K:John Wiley.
Ellemers,N.,& Bos,A.E.R.(1998).Social identity,relative deprivation,and coping with the threat of position loss:a field study among native shopkeepers in amsterdam.Journal of Applied Social Psychology.,28(21),1987-2006.
Ellemers,N.,Doosje,B.,van,K.A.,& Wilke,H.(1992).Status protection in high status minority groups.European Journal of Social Psychology,22(2),123.
Ellemers,N.,Spears,R.,& Doosje,B.(1997).Sticking together or falling apart:in-group identification as a psychological determinant of group commitment versus individual mobility.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,72(3),617-626.
Ellemers,N.,Van,K.A.,de,V.N.,& Wilke,H.(1988).Social identification and permeability of group boundaries.European Journal of Social Psychology,18(6),497.
Ellemers,N.,& Van,R.W.(1997).Identity needs versus social opportunities:the use of group-level and individual-level identity management strategies.Social Psychology Quarterly,60(1),52.
Ellemers,N.,Wilke,H.,& Van Knippenberg,A.(1993).Effects of the legitimacy of low group or individual status on individual and collective status-enhancement strategies.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,64(5),766-778.
Fischer,P.,Greitemeyer,T.,Omay,S.I.,& Frey,D.(2007).Mergers and group status:the impact of high,low and equal group status on identification and satisfaction with a company merger,experienced controllability,group identity and group cohesion.Journal of Community &Applied Social Psychology,17(3),203.
Fiske,S.T.,Cuddy,A.J.,Glick,P.,& Xu,J.(2002).A model of(often mixed) stereotype content:competence and warmth respectively follow from perceived status and competition.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,82(6),878-902.
Foiger,R.(1986).A referent cognitions theory of relative deprivation.In J.M.Olson,C.P.Herman,& M.P.Zanna(Eds.),Relative deprivation and social comparison:The Ontario symposium(Vol.4,pp33-55).Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum.
Gaerner,S.L.,Dovidio,J.F.,Anastasio,P.A.,Bachman,B.A.,& Rust,M.C.(1993).The common ingroup identity model:recategorization and the reduction of intergroup bias.European Review of Social Psychology,4,1-26.
Gardner,W.L.,Pickett,C.L.,& Brewer,M.B.(2000).Social exclusion and selective memory:How the need to belong influences memory for social events.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,26,486-496.
Gibson,J.L.(2006).Do strong group identities fuel intolerance? Evidence from the south african case.Political Psychology,27(5),665.
Glick,G.P.,& Fiske,S.T.(2001).Ambivalent stereotypes as legitimizing ideologies:differentiating paternalistic and envious prejudice.Jost,John T.;Major,Brenda(2001).The psychology of legitimacy:Emerging perspectives on ideology,justice,and intergroup relations.(pp.278-306).New York,NY,US:Cambridge University Press..
Goffrnan,E.(1963).Stigma:Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity.Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice-Hall.
Gold,G.J.,& Weiner,B.(2000).Remorse,confession,group identity,and expectancies about repeating a transgression.Basic & Applied Social Psychology,22(4),291.
Gramsci,A.(1937).Selections from the prison notebooks.New York:Intemational Publishers.
Grant,G.P.,& Brown,R.(1995).From ethnocentrism to collective protest:responses to relative deprivation and threats to social identity.Social Psychology Quarterly.,58(3),195-212.
Guimond,G.S.,& Dub,S.L.(1983).Relative deprivation theory and the quebec nationalist movement:the cognition-emotion distinction and the personal-group deprivation issue.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.,44(3),526-535.
Gurr,T.R.(1970).Why men rebel.Princeton,NJ:Princeton University Press.
Haines,E.L.,& Jost,J.T.(2000).Placating the powerless:effects of legitimate and illegitimate explanation on affect,memory,and stereotyping.Social Justice Research,13,219-236.
Hamilton,D.L.,Sherman,S.J.,& Rodgers,J.S.(2004).Perceiving the groupness of groups:Entitativity,homogeneity,essentialism,and stereotypes.In V.Yzerbyt,C.M.Judd,& 0.Corneille (Eds.),The psychology of group perception:Contributions to the study of homogeneity,entitativity,and essentialism.Philadelphia:Psychology Press.
Harenberg,W.(1991).Vereint und verschieden(unified and different).Spiegel Spezial,1,10-23.
Tajfel,H.,& Turner,J.C.(1986).The social identity theory of inter-group behavior.In S.Worchel(Ed.),Psychology of Inter-group Relation.Chicago:Nelson-Hall Publishers.
Henry,P.,& Saul,A.(2006).The development of system justification in the developing world.Social Justice Research,19(3),365.
Hinkle,S.,& Brown,R.(1990).Intergroup comparisons and social identity:some links and lacunae.In D.Abrams & M.A.Hogg(Eds.),Social identity theory:Constructive and critical advances.(pp.48-70).New York:Springer-Verlag.
Hinkle,S.,Taylor,L.A.,Fox-Cardamone,L.,& Ely,P.G.(1998).Social identity and aspects of social creativity:shifting to new dimensions of intergroup comparison.In S.Worchel,D.P.J.F.Morales & C.Desehamps(Eds.),Social identity:lnternationalperspectives(pp.166-179).London:Sage.
Hirschman,A.O.(1970).Exit,voice,and loyalty:response to decline in firms,organisations,and state.Cambridge.MA:Harvard University Press.
Hogg,M.A.,& Abrams,D.(1988).Social identifications.Londen:Routledge.
Homans,G.C.(1961).The human group.London:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Ji,L.,Peng,K.,& Nisbett,R.E.(2000).Culture,control and perception of relationships in the environment.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,78,943-955.
Jost,J.T.(1997).An experimental replication of the depressed entitlement effect among women.Psychology of Women Quarterly,21,387-393.
Jost,J.T.(2001).Outgroup favoritism and the theory of system justification:an experimental paradigm for investigating the effects of socio-economic success on stereotype content.In G.Moskowitz(Ed.),Cognitive social psychology:The Princeton symposium on the legacy and future of social cognition(pp.89-102).Hillsdale,NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
Jost,J.T.(2001).The psychology of legitimacy:emerging perspectives on ideology,justice and intergroup relations.New York:Cambridge University Press.
Jost,J.T.,& Banaji,M.R.(1994).The role of stereotyping in system justification and the production of false consciousness.British Journal of Social Psychology,33,1-27.
Jost,J.T.,Banaji,M.R.,& Nosek,B.A.(2004).A decade of system justification theory:accumulated evidence of conscious and unconscious bolstering of the status quo.Political Psychology,25(6),881.
Jost,J.J.,& Burgess,D.(2000).Attitudinal ambivalence and the conflict between group and system justification motives in low status groups.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.,26(3),293-305.
Jost,J.T.,Burgess,D.,& Mosso,C.(2001).Conflicts of legitimation among self,group,and system:the integrative potential of system justification theory.In J.T.Jost & B.Major(Eds.),The psychology of legitimacy:Emerging perspectives on ideology,justice,and intergroup relations.(pp.363-388).New York:Cambridge University Press.
Jost,J.T.,Pelham,B.W.,& Carvallo,M.(2002).Non-conscious forms of system justification:cognitive,affective,and behavioral preferences for higher status groups.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,38,586-602.
Jost,J.T.,Pelham,B.W.,Sheldon,O.,& Sullivan,B.N.(2003).Social inequality and the reduction of ideological dissonance on behalf of the system:evidence of enhanced system justification among the disadvantaged.European Journal of Social Psychology,33(1),13.
Jost,J.T.,& Thompson,E.P.(2000).Groupbased dominance and opposition to equality as independent predictors of self-esteem,ethnocentrism and social policy attitudes among african americans and european americans.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,36,209-232.
Katz,I.,& Hass,R.G.(1988).Racial ambivalence and american value conflict:correlation and priming studies of dual cognitive structures.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,55,893-905.
Kawakami,K.,& Dion,K.L.(1995).Social identity and affect as determinants of collective action:toward an integration of relative deprivation and social identity theories.Theory and Psychology.,5,551-577.
Kessler,T.,& Mummendey,A.(2002).Sequential or parallel processes? A longitudianal field study concerning determinants of identity- management strategies.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,82(1),75-88.
Kiuegel,J.R.,& Smith,E.R.(1986).Beliefs about inequality:americans' view of what is and what ought to be.Hawthorne,NJ:Aldine de Gruyer.
Knowles,E.D.,& Kaiping,P.(2005).White selves:conceptualizing and measuring a dominant-group identity.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,89(2),223.
Kramer,R.M.,& Brewer,M.B.(1984).Effects of group identity on resource use in a simulated commons dilemma.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,46,1044-1057.
Kuehnen,U.,Hannover,B.,Roeder,U.,Shah,A.A.,Schubert,B.,Upmeyer,A.,et al.(2001). Cross-cultural variations in identifying embedded figures:Comparisons from the United States,Germany,Russia and Malaysia.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,32,365-371.
Lalonde,L.R.,& Silverman,R.A.(1994).Behavioral preferences in response to social injustice:the effects of group permeability and social identity salience.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.,66(1),78-85.
Lalonde,R.N.,& Cameron,J.E.(1994).Behavioral responses to discrimination:a focus on action.In M.P.Z.&.J.M.Olson(Ed.),The psychology of prejudice:The Ontario Symposium(Vol.7,pp.257-288).Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum.
Lalonde,R.N.,& Silverman,R.A.(1994).Behavioral preferences in response to social injustice.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,66,78-85.
Leary,M.R..,& Kowalski,R.M.(1995).The self-presentational model of social anxiety/phobia.In R.Heimberg,M.Liebowitz,D.Hope,& F.Schneier(Eds).Social phobia:Diagnosis,assessment,and treatment.New York.:Guilford..
Lerner,M.J.(1977).The justice motive:some hypotheses as to its origins and forms.Journal of Personality,45,1-52.
Lerner,M.J.(1980).The belief in a just wordl:a fundamental delusion.New York:Plenum Press.
Lickel,B.,Hamilton,D.L.,& Sherman,S.J.(2001).Elements of a lay theory of groups:Types of groups,relational styles,and the perception of group entitativity.Personality and Social Psychology Review,5,129-140.
Lukacs,G.(1923).History andclass consciousness..Cambridge,MA::The MIT Press.
Major,B.,McFarlin,D.B.,& Gagnon,D.(1989).Overworked and underpaid:on the nature of gender differences in personal entitlement.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,47,1399-1412.
Major,B.,Gramzow,R.H.,McCoy,S.K.,Levin,S.,Schmader,T.,& Sidanius,J.(2002).Perceiving personal discrimination:the role of group status and legitimizing ideology.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,82(3),269-282.
Mak,A.S.,Heaven,P.C.,& Rummery,A.(2003).The role of group identity and personality domains as indicators of self-reported delinquency.Psychology,Crime & Law,9(1),9.
Mark,M.M.,& Folger,R.(1984).Responses to relative deprivation:a conceptual framework.In p.Shaver(ed.),Review of personality and social psychology(vol.5,pp.192-218).Beverly hills,ca:sage(Vol.5).Beverly Hills,CA:Sage.
Marx,K.E.(1970).The german ideology.C J.Arthur(ed.).New York:International Publishers.
Maslow,A(1968).The Farther Reaches of Human Nature.Journal of Transpersonal Psychology,1,1-9.
Masters,J.C.,& Keii,L.J.(1978).Generic comparison processes in human judgment and behavior.In J.C.Masters & W.P.Smith(Eds.),Social comparison,social justice and relative deprivation(pp.11-54).Hiilsdale,NJ::Lawrence Erlbaum.
Matheson,K.,& Cole,B.M.(2004).Coping with a threatened group identity:psychosocial and neuroendocrine responses.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,40(6),777.
Marx,K.& Engels,F.(1970) The German Ideology(C.J.Arthur,ed.;W.Lough,C.Dutt &C.P.Magill,trans.).New York:International Publishers.(Original work written in 1846)
McCoy,M.C.,& Major,B.(2007).Priming meritocracy and the psychological justification of inequality.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.,43(3),341-351.
McFarland,C.,& Buehler,R.(1995).Collective self-esteem as a moderator of the frog-pond effect in reactions to performance feedback.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,68(6),1055-70.
Moghaddam,F.M.,Taylor,D.M.,& Lalonde,R.N.(1987).Individualistic and collective integration strategies among iranians in canada.International Journal of Psychology,22,301-313.
Moscovici,S.(1998).Social consciousness and its history.Culture and Psychology,4,411-429.
Mullen,B.,Brown,R.,& Smith,C.(1992).Ingroup bias as a function of salience,relevance,and status:an integration.European Journal of Social Psychology.,22,104-122.
Mummendey,A.,Kessler,T.,Klink,A.,& Mielke,R.(1999).Strategies to cope with negative social identity:predictions by social identity theory and relative deprivation theory.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,76(2),229.
Mummendey,A.,Klink,A.,Mielke,R.,Wenzel,M.,& Blanz,M.(1999).Socio-structural characteristics of intergroup relations and identity management strategies:results from a field study in east germany.European Journal of Social Psychology,29(2),259.
Nadler,N.A.(2002).Inter-group helping relations as power relations:maintaining or challenging social dominance between groups through helping.Journal of Social Issues.Vol 58(3),Fal 2002,pp.487-502,58(3),487-502.
Niens,U.,& Cairns,E.(2002).Identity management strategies in northern ireland.The Journal of Social Psychology,142(3),371-380.
Pelham,B.W.,& Hetts,J.J.(2001).Underworked and overpaid:elevated entitlement in men's self-pay.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,37,93-103.
Petta,G.,& Walker,I.(1992).Relative deprivation and ethnic identity.British Journal of Social Psychology,31,285-293.
Pickett,C.L.,Gardner,W.L.,& Knowles,M.(2004).Getting a Cue:The Need to Belong and Enhanced Sensitivity to Social Cues.Pets Soc Psychol Bull,30,1095-1107.
Postmes,T.,Spears,R.,Lee,A.T.,& Novak,R.J.(2005).Individuality and social influence in groups:inductive and deductive routes to group identity.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,89(5),747.
Ridgeway,C.(2001).The emergence of status beliefs:from structural inequality to legitimizing ideology.New York:Cambridge University Press.
Rawls,J.(1971).A Theory of Justice.Cambridge,Massachusetts:Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Rothgerber,H.,& Worchel,S.(1997).The view from below:intergroup relations from the perspective of the disadvantaged group.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,73(6),1191-1205.
Rubin,Z.,& Peplau,L.A.(1975).Who believes in a just world.Journal of Social Issues,31,65-89.
Runciman,W.G.(1966).Relative deprivation and social justice:a study of attitudes to social inequality in twentieth-century england.Berkeley:university of california press.Berkeley:University of California Press.
Schachter,S.(1959).The psychology of affiliation.Stanford University Press.
Schmitt,M.T.,Spears,R.,& Branscombe,N.R.(2003).Constructing a minority group identity out of shared rejection:the case of international students.European Journal of Social Psychology,33(1),1.
Seta,C.E.,& Seta,J.J.(1992).Observers and participants in an intergroup setting.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.,63(4),629-643.
Seta,J.J.,& Seta,C.E.(1996).Big fish in small ponds:a social hierarchical analysis of intergroup bias.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.,71(6),1210-1221.
Shaver,P.,Hazan,C.,& Bradshaw,D.(1988).Love as attachment:The integration of three behavioral systems.In R.J.Steinberg & M.L.Barnes(Eds.),The psychology of love(pp.68-99).New Haven,CT:Yale University Press.
Sherif,M.(1966).Group conflict and cooperation.Their social psychology.Londen:Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Sherman,S.J.,Hamilton,D.L.,&Lewis,A.C.(1999).Perceived entitativity and the social identity value of group memberships.In D.Abrams & M.A.Hogg(Eds.),Social identity and social cognition(pp.80-110).Oxford,UK:Blackwell.
Sidanius,J.,& Pratto,F.(1999).Social dominance:an intergoup theory of social hierarchy and oppression.New York:Cambridge University Press.
Simon,B.,Pantaleo,G.,& Mummendey,A.(1995).Unique individual or interchangeable group member? The accentuation of intragroup differences versus similarities as an indicator of the individual self versus the collective self,.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,69(1),106-119.
Smith,M.B.(1969).Socialsychology andhuman values.CHicago:Aldine.
Spears,R.,Doosje,B.,& Ellemers,N.(1997).Self-stereotyping in the face of threats to group status and distinctiveness:The role of group identification.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,23,538-553
Spinelli,D.,Antonucci,G.,Goodenough,D.R.,& Zobbolotti,L.(1991).Psychophysio-logical mechanisms underlying the Rod-and-Frame illusion.In S.Wapner & J.Demick(Eds.),Field Dependence-Independence:Cognitive style across the life span(pp.37-60).Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum.
Tajfel,H.(1978).Interindividual behavior and intergroup behavior.In H.Tajfel(Ed.),Differentiations between social groups:Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations(pp.27-45).New York:Academic Press.
Tajfel,H.(1981).Human groups and social categories.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
Tajfel,H.,& Turner,J.C.(1979).An integrative theory of intergroup conflict.In w.G.Austin & s.Worchel(eds.),The socialpsychology of intergroup relations:Monterey,CA:Brooks/Cole.
Tajfel,H.,& Turner,J.C.(1986).The social identity theory of intergroup behavior.Chicago:Nelson-Hall.
Tajfel,H.,& Turner,J.C.(1986).The social identity theory of intergroup behavior.In W.G.Austin & S.Worchel(Eds.),The social psychology of intergroup relations(pp.7-24).Chicago:Nelson-Hall.
Tajfel,H.,& Turner,J.C.(1979).An integrative theory of intergroup conflict.In W.G.Austin & S.Worchel(Eds.),The socialpsychology of intergroup relations(pp.33-47):Monterey,CA:Brooks/Cole.
Tamir,Y.& Nadler,A.(2007).The Role of Personality in Social Identity:Effects of Field-Dependence and Context on Reactions to Threat to Group Distinctiveness.Journal of Personality 75(5),927-953.
Taylor,D.M.,& McKiman,D.J.(1984).A five-stage model of intergroup relations.British Journal of Social Psychology,23,291-300.
Taylor,D.M.,& Moghaddam,F.M.(1994).Theories of intergroup relation:international socialpsychologicalperspectives..Westport,CT:Praeger.
Taylor,D.M.,Moghaddam,F.M.,Gamble,I.,& Zellerer,E.(1987).Disadvantaged group responses to perceived inequality:from passive acceptance to collective action.Journal of Social Psychology,127(3 ),258.
Taylor,T.D.,Wright,S.C.,Moghaddam,F.M.,& Lalonde,R.N.(1990).The personal/group discrimination discrepancy:perceiving my group,but not myself,to be a target for discrimination.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.,16(2),254-262.
Thompson,J.B.(1990).Ideology and modern culture:critical social theory in the era of mass communication.Stanford,CA:Stanford University Press.
Tripathi,T.R.,& Srivastava,R.(1981).Relative deprivation and intergroup attitudes.European Journal of Social Psychology.,11(3),313-318.
Turner,J.C.,& Brown,R.(1978).Social status,cognitive alternatives,and intergroup relations.In H.Tajfel(Ed.),Differentiation between social groups:Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations(pp.202-234).New York:Academic Press.
Turner,J.C.(1999).Some current issues in research on social identity and self-categorization theories.In &.B.D.N.Ellemers,R.Spears(Ed.),Social identity:Context,commitment,content (pp.6-34).Oxford,England:Blackwell.
Turner,J.C.,Hogg,M.A.,Oakes,P.J.,Reicher,S.D.,& Wetherell,M.S.(1987).Rediscovering the social group:a self-categorization theory.Oxford,England:Blackwell.
Tyler,T.R.(1990).Why people obey the law:Procedural justice,legitimacy,and compliance.New Haven:Yale University Press.
Van Knippenberg,A.(1989).Strategies of identity management.Amsterdam,Swets &Zeitlinger.
Vanneman,R.D.,& Pettigrew,T.F.(1972).Race and relative deprivation in the urban united states.Race,13,461-486.
Verkuyten,M.,& De,W.A.(2007).The development of in-group favoritism:between social reality and group identity.Developmental Psychology,43(4),901.
Walker,I.,& Mann,L.(1987).Unemployment,relative deprivation,and social protest. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,,13,275-283.
Walker,I.,& Pettigrew,T.F.(1994).Relative deprivation theory:an overview and conceptual critique.British Journal of Social Psychology,23(4),301-310.
Walster,E.,Berscheid,E.,& Walster,G.W.(1973).New directions in equity research.Journal of Personality and Social Pychology.,25,151-176.
Walster,E.,Walster,G.,& Berscheid,E.(1978).Equity:theory and research.Boston.MA:Allyn & Bacon.
Warburton,W.A.,& Williams,K.D.(2005).Ostracism:When competing motivations collide.In J.P.Forgas,K.D.Williams & S.M.Laham(Eds.),Social motivation:Conscious and 97 unconscious processes.(pp.294-313).New York,NY:Cambridge University Press.
Williams,K.D.,& Sommer,K.L.(1997).Social ostracism by coworkers:Does rejection lead to loafing or compensation? Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,23,693-706.
Wright,S.C.,Taylor,D.M.,& Moghaddam,F.M.(1990).Responding to membership in a disadvantaged group:from acceptance to collective protest.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,58(6),994-1003.
Yzerbyt,V.Y.,Rogier,A,,& Fiske,S.T.(1998).Group entitativity and social attribution:On translating situational constraints into stereotypes.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,24,1089-1103.