企业负债结构优化与最优订货决策研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
大量的理论和实践证明,企业的运营活动和营运资金融资活动之间存在着密切的联系。作为企业运营活动的基础,订货决策在企业的经营过程中扮演着重要的角色。现代的市场竞争已经成为供应链与供应链之间的竞争,企业为了生存和发展,逐渐加入到供应链当中,它的经营活动也相应地受到供应链上下游企业,特别是与它相邻的上游供应商和下游顾客的影响,这增加了企业进行订货决策的复杂性。本文主要采用理论建模的方法从财务学的角度探讨供应链企业的最优订货决策与商业信用和银行信用之间的关系。文章考察了作为与企业订货决策关系最为密切的两种负债融资方式——供应商的商业信用和银行的银行信用——对企业最优订货决策产生的影响。通过引入财务危机成本、供应链企业之间相对议价能力等因素,使模型更接近于现实。
     本文的研究结果解决了如下几个问题:当存在财务危机成本时,在供应链企业一方面既可以运用上游供应商商业信用以及短期银行信用和长期银行信用等负债融资方式,另一方面又可以以提供商业信用的形式对下游顾客进行投资的情况下,企业如何制定最优产品持有量决策?与企业最优产品持有量决策相关的最优订货量、最优期中净现金持有量、最优股利发放量等是如何决定的?当上游供应商对提供给企业商业信用制定限额时,企业又将如何制定相关的优化决策?
     通过理论建模以及数值分析,本文的研究结果的主要贡献如下:
     第一,本文引入财务约束和两级商业信用新条件,并将“校准财务危机概率”作为重要参考指标,从理论上建立了供应链企业的最优产品持有量决策和最优期中净现金持有量等模型。在只有上游供应商商业信用一种负债融资途径下,通过理论模型分析和有关数值模拟分析发现:考虑财务危机成本的情况下,上游供应商提供的商业信用会对企业的相关决策产生显著的影响。如果上游供应商拥有较强的议价能力,就会制定较为苛刻的商业信用条款,从而企业就会持有较少的产品。而企业向下游顾客提供的商业信用对自身最优决策的影响不大。
     第二,本文考虑同时存在商业信用和短期银行信用两种融资方式下企业的最优订货决策模型,发现企业的最优产品持有量和最优期中净现金持有量均随着短期银行信用利率的变动而呈同方向变动。而且在短期银行借款利率一定的条件下,随着上游供应商商业政策越来越苛刻,企业的最优产品持有量和最优期中净现金持有量逐渐降低,向银行的短期借款也降低。另外,随着短期银行信用利率的提高,与上游供应商和银行发生交易的企业受财务危机成本函数系数的约束越来越小。
     第三,当企业可以同时运用长期银行信用、短期银行信用和上游供应商商业信用三种外部融资途径时,企业每期偿还的长期银行信用的利息数量决定了企业进行相关决策的最优决策模式。
A lot of theorems and practices have asserted that there are relationships between firm's operational activities and financing decisions. As the foundations of the firm's operational activities, inventory decision and financing decision play important roles. Now the market competition is not the competition of two firms but is the competition of different supply chains. And their operations are affected by the supply chain members who are the nearest to them, which makes the inventory decision more difficult. This paper intends to model the relationships between trade credit, bank credit and inventory decision for the supply chain firm. By incorporating the factors, such as financial distress cost and bargaining power, I make my model more practical.
     This paper focuses on the following questions: When the financial distress cost exists, how does a firm make inventory decision when he can take the supplier's trade credit, short term bank credit and long term bank credit and also give trade credit to his customer? How can the supply chain firm determine the optimal cash-holding, and the optimal dividend? If there is some restriction on the supplier's trade credit, how can the supply chain firm make decision?
     In this paper, there are some main contributions:
     (1) The paper considers the optimal inventory-holding decision and optimal cash-holding decision under new conditions: two-level trade credit and financial constraints, the adjusted financial distress probability is introduced as a key index. With those above, this paper models the optimal inventory-holding and optimal cash-holding. By the theoretical and numerical analysis, the paper finds that the supplier's trade credit has a positive effect on the firm's optimal decisions, but the firm's trade credit for its customer has little effect on his optimal decision, when the supplier's trade credit is the only debt financing source.
     (2) Under two financial sources -- the supplier's trade credit and short term bank credit, the firm's optimal inventory-holding and optimal cash-holding change with the short term bank credit rate consistently. And with the supplier's trade credit becoming stricter, firm will hold smaller inventories and borrow less both from the supplier and bank. Besides, with the short term bank credit rate becoming higher, the firm is less restricted by the coefficient of financial distress function.
     (3) The amounts that the firm pays for the long term bank credit per period determine the decision mode for the optimal decisions. With the two-level trade credit, the long term bank credit may have an important effect on his optimal inventory decisions and determine the way the firm makes the optimal decision.
引文
[1]Aggarwal S.,and C.Jaggi.1995.Ordering policies of deteriorating items under permissible delay in payments.The journal of the operational research society.46(5):658-622
    [2]Arrow K.,T.Harris,and J.Marschak.1951.Optimal inventory policy.Econometrica.19(3):250-272
    [3]Atanasova C,and N.Wilson.2003.Bank borrowing constraints and the demand for trade credit:evidence from panel data.Managerial and decision economics.24:503-514
    [4]Atanasova C,and D.Antov.2008.How do firms choose between intermediary and supplier finance? http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1255882
    [5]Babich V.,and M.Sobel.2004.Pre-IPO operational and financial decisions.Management science.50(7):935-948
    [6]Baneriee S.,S.Dasgupta,and Y.Kim.2004.Buyer-supplier relationships and trade credit.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=590482
    [7]Battiston S.,D.Gatti,M.Gallegati,B.Greenwald,and J.Stiglitz.2007.Credit chains and bankruptcy propagation in production networks.Journal of economic dynamics & control.31(6):2061-2084
    [8]Bellman R..1952.The theory of dynamic programming.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,38(8):716-719
    [9]Bellman R.,I.Glicksberg,and O.Gross.1955.On the optimal inventory equation.2(l):83-104
    [10]Biais B.,and C.Gollier.1997.Trade credit and credit rationing.The review of financial studies.10(4):903-947
    [11]Bigus J..2004.Benefits and costs of having bank and trade credit simultaneously.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=567043
    [12]Boissay R. 2003. Credit chains and the propagation of financial distress.http://repec.org/esNAWM04/up.31983.1048251240.pdf
    [13]Boissay F.,and C. Monnet. 2003. Bankruptcy in credit chains.http://repec.Org/esNAWM04/up.31983.1048251240.pdf
    [14]Bougheas S.,S.Mateut,and P.Mizen.2009.Corporate trade credit and inventories:new evidence of a trade-off from accounts payable and receivable.Journal of banking&finance.33(2):300-307
    [15]Burgin T..1975.The gamma distribution and inventory control.Operational research quartly(1970-1977) .26(3)Partl:507-525
    [16]Buzacott J.,and R.Zhang.2004.Inventory management with asset-based financing.Management science.50(9):1274-1292
    [17]Caker M..2008.Intertwined coordination mechanisms in interorganizational relationships with dominated suppliers.Management accounting research.19(3):231-251
    [18]Cardoso-Lecourtois M..2004.Chain reactions,trade credit and the business cycle.http://www.econ.umn.edu/~miguelc/tradecred.pdf
    [19]Chang C,L.Ouyang,and J.Teng.2003.An EOQ model for deteriorating items under supplier credits linked to ordering quantity.Applied Mathematical Modelling.
    [20]Chao X.,J.Chen,and S.Wang.2005.Dynamic inventory management with financial constraints.http://www.aporc.org/LNOR/5ASORA2005F02.pdf
    [21]Chao X.,J.Chen,and S.Wang.2008.Dynamic inventory management with cash flow constraints.Naval Research Logistics.55(8):758-768
    [22]Chung K-J.2008.Comments on the EOQ model under retailer partial trade credit policy in the supply chain.International journal of production economics.114:308-312
    [23]Clark A.,and H.Scarf.Optimal policies for a multi-echelon inventory problem.Management science.6(4):475-490
    [24]Cull R.,L.Xu,and T.Zhu.2007.Formal finance and trade credit during China's transition.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfrn?abstract_id=980822
    [25]Danielson M.,and J.Scott.2004.Bank loan availability and trade credit demand.The financial review.39(4):579-600
    [26]Demirguc-Kunt A.,V.Maksimoivc.1998.Law,finance,and firm growth.The journal of finance.53(6):2107-2137
    [27]Demirguc-Kunt A.,V.Maksimoivc.2001.Firms as financial intermediaries:evidence from trade credit data.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=632764
    [28]Fabbri D.,and A.Menichini.2007.Trade credit,collateral liquidation and borrowing constraints.
    [29]Fabbri D.,and L.Klapper.2008.Market power and the matching of trade credit terms.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=l 293167
    [30]Fortuin L..1980.Five popular probability density functions:a comparison in the field of stock-control model.The journal of the operational research society.31(10):937-942
    [31]Frank M.,and V.Maksimovic.2005.Trade credit,collateral,and adverse selection.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=87868
    [32]Gaicia-Appendini E..2005.Soft information in bank lending:the use of trade credit.http://www.econ.upf.es/~egarcia/Files/EmiliaJMP.pdf
    [33]Garcia-Teruel P.,and P.Martinez-Solano.2008.A dynamic approach to accounts receivable:a study of Spanish SMEs.European financial management.Published online.
    [34]Giannetti M.,M.Burkart,and T.Ellingsen.2007.What you sell is what you lend? Explaining trade credit contracts.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=702928
    [35]Giri B.,T.Chaukraborty,and K.Chaudhuri.2000.A note on a lot sizing heuristic for deteriorating items with time-varying demands and shortages.Computers and operations research.27:495-505
    [36]Goyal S.1985.Economic order quantity under conditions of permissible delay in payments.Journal of operation research society.36(4):335-338
    [37]Gupta D.,and L.Wang.2008.A stochastic inventory model with trade credit.http://www.me.umn.edu/labs/scorlab/techpub/GWtcr05.pdf
    [38]Haley C,and H.Higgins.1973.Inventory policy and trade credit financing.Management Science.20:464-471
    [39]Hu Q.,and M.Sobel.2006.Capital structure and inventory management.http://weatherhead.case.edu
    [40]Hu Q.,and M.Sobel.2008.Capital structure and inventory management.http://weatherhead.case.edu/academics/departments/operations/research/technicalReports/ CapitalStructure_10_07D_2008_su-posted.pdf
    [41]Huang Y-F.2003.Optimal Retailer's Ordering Policies in the EOQ Model under Trade Credit Financing.The Journal of the Operational Research Society.54(9):1011-1015
    [42]Huang Y-F.2007.Economic order quantity under conditionally permissible delay in payments.Production,Manufacturing and Logistics.176:911-924
    [43]Huang Y.,and K.Hsu.2008.An EOQ model under retailer partial trade credit policy in supply chain.International journal of production economics.112:655-664
    [44]Huyghebaert N..2006.On the determinants and dynamics of trade credit use:empirical evidence from business start-ups. Journal of business finance&accounting.33(l)&(2):305-328
    [45]Iglehart D..1963.Optimality of(s,S) policies in the infinite horizon dynamic inventory problem.9(2):259-267
    [46]Jaber M.,and S.Goayal.2008.Coordinating a three-level supply chain with multiple suppliers,a vendor and multiple buyers.116(1):95-103
    [47]Jamal A.,B.Sarker.and S.Wang.1997.An Ordering Policy for Deteriorating Items with Allowable Shortage and Permissible Delay in Payment.The journal of the operational research society.48(8):826-833
    [48]Johnsen R.,and D.Ford.2008.Exploring the concept of asymmetry:a typology for analysing customer-supplier relationships.Industrial marketing management.37(4):471-483
    [49]Karlin S..1960.Dynamic inventory policy with varying stochastic demands.Management science.6(3):231-258
    [50]Khanra S.,K.Chaudhuri.2003.A note on an ordered-level inventory model for a deteriorating item with time-dependent quadratic demand.Computers and operations research.30:1901-1916
    [51]Kingsman B..1983.The effect of payment rules on ordering and stockholding in purchasing.The journal of the operational research society.34(11):1085-1098
    [52]Kiyotaki N.,and J. Moore. 1997. Credit chain.http://www.princeton.edu/~kiyotaki/papers/creditchains.pdf
    [53]Li L.,M.Shubik,and M.Sobel.2005.Control of dividends,capital subscriptions,and physical inventories.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=690864
    [54]Liao H.,C.Tsai,and C.Su.2000.An inventory model with deteriorating items under inflation when a delay in payment is permissible.International journal of production economics.63(2):207-214
    [55]Liao J-J,and K-N Huang.2008.An inventory model for deteriorating items with two levels of trade credit taking account of time discounting.Acta applicandae mathematicae:an international survey journal on applying mathematics and mathematical applications.Online first.[56]Lieber Z.,Y.Orgler.1975.An integrated model for accounts receivable management.Management Science.22(2):212-219
    [57]Luciano E.,and L.Peccati.1999.Some basic problems in inventory theory:the financial perspective.European journal of operational research.114:294-303
    [58]Maddah B.,M.Jaber,and N.Abboud.2004.Periodic review(s,S) inventory model with permissible delay in payments.Journal of the operational research society.5 5(2):147-159
    [59]Martin B.,and K.Gobert.2007.Financing investment with trade credit.http://scse2007.ecn.ulaval.ca/fileadmin/scse2007/documents/Papiers/FITCkg.pdf
    [60]Mcmillan J.,and C.Woodruff.2002.Interfirm relationships and informal credit in Vietnam.The quarterly journal of economics.114(4):1285-1320
    [61]Metz R...2008.Stochastic tools in supply chain management.In Logisttic optimization of chemical production processes,edited by S.Engell.WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH&Co.KGaA
    [62]Miwa Y,and J.Ramseyer.2005.Trade credit,bank loans,and monitoring:evidence from Japan.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=843526
    [63]Modigliani F.,M.Miller.1958.The cost of capital .corporation finance and the theory of investment.The American economic review.48(3):261-297
    [64]Moors J.,and L.Strijbosch.2002.Exact fill rates for(R,s,S) inventory control with gamma distributed demand.Journal of the operational research society.53(11):1268-1274
    [65]Ng C,J.Smith,and R.Smith.1999.Evidence on the determinants of credit terms used in interfirm trade.Journal of finance.54(3):1109-1129
    [66]Nilsen J..2002.Trade credit and the bank lending channel.Journalof money,credit and banking.34(1):226-253
    [67]Niskanen J.,and M.Niskanen.2006.The determinants of corporate trade credit policies in a bank-dominated financial environment:the case of Finnish small firms.European financial management.12(1):81-102
    [68]Ouyang L.,J.Teng,S.Goyal,and C.Yang.2008a.An economic order quantity model for deteriorating items with partially permissible delay in payments linked to order quantity.Production,Manufacturing and Logistics.Article in press.
    [69]Ouyang L.,J.Teng,S.Goyal,and C.Yang.2008b.An economic order quantity model for deteriorating items with partially permissible delay in payments linked to order quantity.European Journal of Operational Research.Article in press.
    [70]Ouyang L.,K.Wu,and C.Yang.2006.A study on an inventory model for non-instantaneous deteriorating items with permissible delay in payments.Computers& industrial engineering.51:637-651
    [71]Paul S.,and R.Boden.2008.The secret life of UK trade credit:supply setting a new research agenda.The British Accounting Review.(40):272-281.
    [72]Petersen M.,and R.Rajan.1997.Trade credit:theories and evidence.The review of financial studies.10(3):661-691
    [73]Pike R.,and N.Cheng.2001.Credit management:an examination of policy choices,practices and late payment in UK companies.Journal of business finance&accounting.28(7-8):1013-1042
    [74]Raddatz C..2008.Credit chains and sectoral comovement:does the use of trade credit amplify sectoral shocks,http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1096848
    [75]Robb D.,and E.Silver.2006.Inventory management under date-terms supplier trade credit with stochastic demand and leadtime.Journal of operational research society.57(6):692-702
    [76]Sana S.,and K.Chaudhuri.2008.A deterministic EOQ model with delays in payments and price-discount offers.European Journal of Operational Research.184:509-533
    [77]Sarimveis H.,P.Patrinos,C.Tarantilis,and C.Kiranoudis.2008.Dynamic modeling and control of supply chain systems:a review.Computers&operations research.35:3530-3561
    [78]Scarf H..1960.The optimality of(S,s) policies in the dynamic inventory problem.http://dido.econ.yale.edu/-hes/pub/ss-policies.pdf
    [79]Schneider H..1978.Methods for determining the re-order point of an(s,S) ordering policy when a service level is specified.Journal of operational society.29(12):1181-1193
    [80]Serrano A.,and S.Kraiselburd.2007.Economic order quantity and the value of the firm.http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1027547
    [81]Silver E.,and D.Robb.2008.Some insights regarding the optimal reorder period in periodic review inventory systems.International journal of production economics.112(1):354-366
    [82]Sobel M.,and D.Turcic.2007.Coordination of inventory,capital and dividends in nascent firms.http://weatherhead.case.edu/academics/departments/operations/research/technicalReports/Technical%20Memorandum%20Number%20816.pdf
    [83]Soufani K.,and P.Poutzioursis.2008.Trade credits and accounts payables.http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=497022
    [84]Sundaram R.,2008.A first course in optimization theory.Posts&Telecom press.
    [85]Stiglitz J.,and A.Weiss.1981.Crdit rationing in markets with imperfect information.The amercian economic review.71(3):393-410
    [86]Teng J-T,and SK Goyal.2007.Optimal ordering policies for a retailer in a supply chain with up-stream and down-stream trade credits.Journal of operational research society.58(9):1252-1255
    [87]Uchida H.,G.Udell,and W.Watanabe.2006.Are trade creditors relationship lenders?http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=926976
    [88]Veinott A..1965a.Optimal policy in a dynamic,single product,nonstationary inventory model with several demand classes.Operational research.13(5):761-777
    [89]Veinott A..1965b.Optimal policy for a multi-product,dynamic,nonstationary inventory problem.Management science.12(3):206-221
    [90]Veinott A.1966.The status of mathematical inventory theory.Management science.12(11):745-772
    [91]Veinott A.,and H.Wagner.1965.Computing optimal(s,S) inventory policies.Management science.11(5):525-553
    [92]Von Horen N..2007.Customer market power and the provision of trade credit:evidence from eastern Europe and central Asia.http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=990782
    [93]Xu X.,and J.Birge.2004.Joint production and financing decisions:modeling and analysis.http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=652562
    [94]Xu X.,and J.Birge.2005.Equity valuation,production,and financial planning:a stochastic programming approach,http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=652565
    [95]Zhang J..2004.Three essays on inventory management.http://www.ohiolink.edu/etd/view.cgi?acc_num=case 1087418721
    [96]刘民权,徐忠,赵英涛.2004.商业信用研究综述.世界经济.(1)66-77
    [97]邱昊,梁樑.2007.延期支付条件下的最优付款时间确定:考虑现金折扣情形.管理学报.(2):191-194
    [98]邱昊,梁樑,檀大水.2008.基于延期支付的双卖主垄断市场供应链决策.中国科技大学学报(自然科学版).(2):163-170
    [99]邱吴,梁樑,杨树.2006.供应商给定延期付款和现金折扣策略下的零售商最优库存策略.系统工程.(9):18-23
    [100]邱昊,梁樑,余玉刚,杜少甫.2007.基于订货量的延期付款条件下三阶段经济订货模型.系统管理学报.(6):669-672
    [101]徐晓燕,孙燕红.2008.供应链企业财务困境的传递过程研究.中国管理科学.(4):132-139
    [102]杨树,梁樑,董骏峰.2007.延期支付条件下单个生产商多个销售商库存模型.系统工程.(4):9-14
    [103]杨树,梁樑,邱昊.2006.考虑延期支付的斯坦博格库存模型.系统工程.(4):21-24
    [104]查迎春,徐晓燕.2007.考虑需求率变化与延期支付的临时订货模型.运筹与管理.(5):147-152

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700