网络广告运作的若干关键问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
截止2012年底,中国网络广告市场规模突破750亿元,增长率达46.8%,随着网络广告的快速发展,广告主对网络广告和网络媒体对流量变现的需求日益增长,传统的网络广告运作模式越来越不适应大规模的网络广告交易,作为广告主和网络媒体之间的桥梁,广告网络改变了传统网络广告的运作模式,提高了网络广告市场的交易效率。
     但是,广告网络也面临着广告运作中若干急需解决的关键问题,这些关键问题的解决将会有助于网络广告市场更好地发展。本文针对目前网络广告市场中急需解决的网络媒体资源整合与评价、网络广告点击欺诈、网络广告定价和网络广告投资四种关键热点问题进行了探索性和创新性研究,主要内容包括:
     (1)网络媒体资源整合与评价研究。本文引入了22伯特兰价格博弈模型,研究了网络媒体资源的优化和整合。结果表明整合后的市场结构有利于广告主节约成本,广告网络可以实现规模经济和范围经济,网络媒体可以将流量变现,保持相对稳定的收入。构建了基于网络广告投放视角的网络媒体评价指标体系。应用区间数相离度和可能度偏差最大化多属性决策的方法,将精确型数据和区间型数据统一起来,建立了混合数据指标的评价模型,解决了网络广告的混合多属性指标决策问题。
     (2)网络广告点击欺诈研究。建立了点击欺诈监管的基本博弈模型、广告网络受到广告主惩罚时的二级监管模型、存在多个网络媒体之间竞争情况下的监管模型。模型分析结果表明,通过加强对网络媒体的监督与控制,广告主实施对广告网络的惩罚,建立网络媒体之间的竞争机制,能有效地避免点击欺诈。基于双边道德风险视角,引入对网络媒体的罚金和点击欺诈的比例系数等参数,分析网络媒体的收益共享系数与罚金、欺诈比例系数的关系。模型均衡分析表明,最优收益共享系数与点击欺诈比例系数负相关,提高点击欺诈成本有利于制止点击欺诈。
     (3)网络广告定价研究。基于风险规避的视角,建立了广告网络和网络媒体之间的两阶段收益定价模型。两阶段定价不仅使广告网络可以避免较高的广告成本支出,而且能够有效地制止点击欺诈和规避信息不对称性带来的风险,网络媒体则可以获得额外的收益。应用指数效用函数构建了CPM、CPC和CPA三种定价模型,并提出了一种新的定价转化规则,确定了合作双方对三种不同网络广告定价合约达成一致的条件,分析了点击率、行动率、风险态度等因素对三种定价模型的影响,并为广告网络和网络媒体在不同条件下指明了最优的广告定价模型。
     (4)网络广告投资研究。应用最优化理论和方法构建基于门户网络广告和长尾网络广告单周期和两周期的投资决策模型,并通过模型分析求出单周期和两周期两类网络广告投资收益的最优条件。在两周期投资模型中引入广告学习因子和折现因子,当广告学习因子的数值越大,则对后期的投资与收益影响越大;后期相对于前期来说,数值越大,投资越小但收益越大;两周期收益与折现因子呈正向关系,折现因子越大,两周期收益越大;当的数值趋近于0时,两周期投资模型就退化为单周期投资模型。
     本文对网络广告运作的若干关键问题研究的相关成果,对网络广告理论的进一步完善和未来网络广告市场的进一步发展具有积极的推动作用。
Up to Dec.2012, the market scale of online advertising in China has brokenthrough75billion and growth rate reached46.8%, respectively.With the rapiddevelopment of the internet, advertisers and online media’s demand to monetize thenetwork traffic has becoming more urgent, the traditional operation mode of onlineadvertising can’t adapt to large scale online advertising transactions. As the bridgebetween advertisers and online media, ads network has changed the operation mode oftraditional online advertising. However, the ads network itself also has many pressingcritical problems to be resolved. Based on the game theory and contract theory, theurgent and critical problems of online advertising which based on ads network has beenresearched. It provides decision-making support for the online advertising operation, themain contents include the following four aspects:
     Firstly,22Bertrand price game model was introduced and integration ofnetwork media resources by ads network was analyzed. The result shows that optimizedand integrated advertising market structure is beneficial to every partner of the wholeonline advertising industry chain. Advertisers can save cost, ads network can achieveeconomies of scale and scope economy and network media can monetize its traffic,retaining relatively stable income. For choosing appropriate network media, theevaluation index system of network media based on the view of publishing onlineadvertising was built. The maximum deviation method based on deviation degree andpossibility degree of ulti-attribute decision-making were applied, integrated the precisedata and interval data and constructed an assessment model to solve the problem ofhybrid multi-attribute decision making.
     Secondly, a basic game theory model for click fraud monitoring was established,the model was extended to the two-echelon monitoring game model that the AdsNetwork would be punished by advertisers, and then further the two-echelon model wasextended into a regulation model when considering the competition among thepublishers. Analysis of Model shows that click fraud can be effectively prevented bymany ways including strengthening the supervision and control of network media, implementing punishment on Ad network by advertisers, reducing informationasymmetry, choosing the honest network media to publish advertising and building thecompetitive mechanism among network media. According to the perspective of doublemoral hazard, the proportional coefficient of fines and ratio of click fraud on networkmedia were introduced and the relationship between the revenue sharing coefficient andthe proportional coefficient of fines and ratio of click fraud on network media werediscussed. Analyzing on the equilibrium of the model shows that the optimal revenuesharing coefficient is negatively correlated with the ratio of click fraud, increasing thecost of click fraud is helpful to prevent click fraud.
     Thirdly, based on the perspective of risk-averse, the two-stage revenue pricingmodel between the ads network and online media was built and Nash bargainingmethod was applied to determine the optimal two-stage pricing problem. The feasibleconditions of the implementation of the two-stage contract were identified and therelationship between the negotiation power and the first stage pricing was analyzed. Thestudy shows that two-stage pricing contract brings ads network and publishers moreflexible options. The two-stage pricing not only makes ads network (advertisers) avoidhigher advertising costs, but also effectively stops click fraud, avoids the risks ofasymmetry information and publishers will gain extra revenues. The three pricing modelthat CPM and CPC, CPM and CPA, CPC and CPA were constructed by usingexponential utility function. And then a new pricing conversion rule among CPM, CPCand CPA pricing contract was put forward. The conditions under which the partnerswould agree on the three different advertising pricing agreement were analyzed, and theinfluence of click-through rate, action rate and risk attitudes on three pricing modelwere analyzed, too. The results showed the optimal pricing model for the ads network(advertisers) and network media under different conditions.
     Finally, by introducing Cobb-Douglas sales function and applying optimizationtheory and method, non-cooperative investment model, cooperative investment modeland dynamic two-stage investment model of single-period and two-period were buitbased on the portal online advertising and the long tail online advertising. The optimalinvestment revenue conditions were gained by analyzing model of single-period onlineadvertising investment and two-period online advertising investment. Learning effectsfactor and the discount factor were introduced into two-period investment model, the research results indicated that the bigger advertising learning effects factor resulted thebigger influence on later investment and revenue. Relative to the previous investment,increasing advertising learning effects factor, the later investment is smaller while therevenue is more. The two-period revenue is positive with discount factor, increasing thediscount factor, the more two-period revenue, when the values of learning effects factortends to be zero, two-period investment model will degenerate to a single-periodmodel.
     The results of some critical problems on online advertising operation have apositive effect in further improving online advertising theory and further promotingonline advertising market development.
引文
[1] Zeff R, Aronson B. Advertising on the Internet [M]. NewYork: John Wiley&Sons,2000,1-40.
    [2] Youji K, Susumu E. Ubiquitous advertising on the WWW: merging advertisement on thebrowser [J]. ComputerNetworks and ISDN Systems,1996,28(11):1493-1499.
    [3] Www.iresearch.com.cn.美国网络广告市场数据研究报告,1995-2011:1-30.
    [4] Ken Lang. Newsweeder: learning to filter netnews [A]. Proc12Th Int Machine Learning Conference[C]. San Francisco,1995,331-339.
    [5] Langheinrich M., Nakamura A., Abe T K N., et al. Unintrusive customization techniques forweb advertising [J]. Computer Networks,1999,31(11-16):1259-1272.
    [6] Bing Pan, Xiang (Robert) Li. The long tail of destination image and online marketing [J].Annals of Tourism Research,2011,38(1):132-152.
    [7] Abe T K N, Nakamura A. Learning to optimally schedule internet banner advertisements [A].Proc of the16Th International Conferences on Machine Learning [C]. Bled, Slovenia,1999,12-22.
    [8] Tomlin J. An entropy approach to unintrusive targeted advertising on the web [J]. ComputerNetworks,2000,33(1-6):767-774.
    [9] Chatterjee P., Hoffman D L., Novak T P. Modeling the clickstream: implications for web-basedadvertising efforts [J]. Marketing Science,2003,22(4):520-541.
    [10] Kumar S., Dawande M., Mookerjee V S. Revenue maximization in web advertisement [C]. The13th Annual Workshop on Information Technologies and Systems Seattle, Washington,2003:21-26.
    [11] Bei Ju. A proposed cross-cultural examination of online advertising effectiveness in China andthe UK [J]. International Journal of Business&Management,2013,8(6):34-39.
    [12]齐洁,汪定伟.求解网络广告资源优化模型的改进微粒群算法[J].控制与决策,2004,19(8):881-884.
    [13] Young-Hoon Park, Peter S. Fader. Modeling browsing behavior at multiple websites [J].Marketing Science,2004,23(3):280-303.
    [14] L. Ha. Online advertising research in advertising journals: a review [J]. Journal of CurrentIssues and Research in Advertising,2008,30(1):31-48.
    [15] Jian Huang., Mingming Leng., Liping Liang. Recent developments in dynamic advertisingresearch [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2012,220(3):591-609.
    [16] David.S. Evans. The economics of the online advertising industry [J]. Review of NetworkEconomics,2008,7(3):359-391.
    [17] K.Fridgeirsdottir S. Naja-Asadolahi. Revenue management for a web publisher usingadvertising networks. Working Paper,2010, London Business School, London, UK.
    [18] K.Fridgeirsdottir, Naja-Asadolahi. Cost-per-click pricing for display advertising. WorkingPaper,2011, London Business School, London, UK.
    [19] Micah Adler, Phillip B., Gibbons, et al. Scheduling space-sharing for internet advertising [J].Journal of Scheduling,2002,5(2):103-119.
    [20] Kumar S., Jacob V S., Sriskandarajah C. Scheduling advertisements on a web page to maximizerevenue [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2006,173(3):1067-1089.
    [21] Jason Deane., Anurag Agarwal. Scheduling online advertisements to maximize revenue undervariable display frequency [J].Omega,2012,40(5):562-570.
    [22] David Maxwell Chickering., David Heckerman. Targeted advertising on the web withinventory management [J]. Interfaces,2003,33(5):71-77.
    [23] Ali Amiri., Syam Menon. Efficient scheduling of internet banner advertisements [J]. ACMTransactions on Internet Technology,2003,3(4):334-346.
    [24] Jason Deane. Hybrid genetic algorithm and augmented neural network application for solvingthe online advertisement scheduling problem with contextual targeting [J]. Expert Systems withApplications,2012,39(5):5168-5177.
    [25] Jakub Marsza kowski., Maciej Drozdowski. Optimization of column width in website layoutfor advertisement fit [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2013,226(3):592-601.
    [26] Bernd Skiera., Jochen Eckert., Oliver Hinz. An analysis of the importance of the long tail insearch engine marketing [J]. Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2010,9(6):488-494.
    [27] A Ghose, S Yang, An empirical analysis of search engine advertising: sponsored search inelectronic markets [J]. Management Science,2009,55(10):1605-1622.
    [28] B Edelman, M Ostrovsky, M Schwarz. Internet advertising and the generalized second priceauction: selling billions of dollars worth of keywords [J]. The American Economic Review,2007,97(1):242-259.
    [29] Guang Qiu., Xiaofei He., Feng Zhang., et al. DASA: dissatisfaction-oriented advertising basedon sentiment analysis [J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2010,37(9):6182-6191.
    [30] Feng J., Bhargava H., Pennock D. Implementing sponsored search in web search engines:computational evaluation of alternative mechanisms [J]. Informs Journal on Computing,2007,19(1):137–148.
    [31]张娥,郑斐峰,刘亚旭等.供大于求时关键字广告位拍卖保留价设计研究[J].预测,2011,30(2):40-45.
    [32]张娥,汪应洛.关键字广告位拍卖的收益等价性研究[J].中国管理科学,2006,14(3):92-96.
    [33]戎文晋,刘树林.关键词拍卖中最优保留价的研究[J].管理科学学报,2010,13(4):29-37.
    [34] Daniele Broccolo., Lorenzo Marcon., Franco Maria Nardini., et al. Generating suggestions forqueries in the long tail with an inverted index [J]. Information Processing and Management,2012,48(2):326-339.
    [35] Chetan Kumar., John B Norris., Yi Sun. Location and time do matter: a long tail study ofwebsite requests [J]. Decision Support Systems,2009,47(4):500–507.
    [36] Kursad Asdemir., zden Yurtseven., MA Yahya. An economic model of click fraud inpublisher networks [J]. International Journal of Electronic Commerce,2008,13(2):61-90.
    [37] Yong Yuan., Daniel Zeng. Co-evolution-based mechanism design for sponsored searchadvertising [J]. Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2012(11):537-547.
    [38] De Liu., Jianqing Chen. Designing online auctions with past performance information [J].Decision Support Systems,2006,42(3):1307-1320.
    [39] Benjamin Edelman., Michael Ostrovsky. Strategic bidder behavior in sponsored search auctions[J]. Decision Support Systems,2007,43(1):192-198.
    [40] Carolyn Pitchik. Budget-constrained sequential auctions with incomplete information [J].Games and Economic Behavior,2009,66(2):928-949.
    [41] Maurizio Naldi., GD Acquisto., GF Italiano. The value of location in keyword auctions [J].Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2010,9(2):160-170.
    [42] Tian-Ming Bu., Xiaotie Deng., Qi Qi. Forward looking Nash equilibrium for keyword auction[J]. Information Processing Letters,2008,105(2):41-46.
    [43] Joseph J Spengler. Vertical integration and antitrust policy [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1950,58(2):347-352.
    [44] Economides, Steven C. Sloap. Competition and integration among complements, and networkmarket structure [J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,1992,40(1):105-123.
    [45] Nicholas Economides. The incentive for non-price discrimination by an input monopolist [J].International Journal of Industrial Organization,1998,16(3):271-284.
    [46] ML Greenhut., H.Ohta. Vertical integration of successive oligopolists [J].American EconomicReview,1979,69(1):137-141.
    [47] MA Salinger. Vertical mergers and market foreclosure [J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1988,103(2):345-356.
    [48] TR Beard, DL Kaserman., JW Mayo. Vertical integration and sabotage [J]. The Journal ofIndustrial Economics,2001,18(4):319-333.
    [49] Kenneth Arrow. Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention [J]. The Rateand Direction of Inventive Activity,1962,26(2):609-625.
    [50] Oliver E Williamson. The vertical integration of production: market failure considerations [J].American Economic Review,1971,61(4):112-123.
    [51] David J Teece. Vertical integration and vertical divestiture in the U.S. oil industry [J]. Institutefor Energy Studies,1976,36(2):305-349.
    [52] George Baker., Robert Gibbons., Kevin J Murphy. Relational contracts and the theory of thefirm [J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.2002,117(1):39-84.
    [53] MR Subramani., N Venkatraman. Safeguarding investments in asymmetric interorganizationalrelationships: theory and evidence [J]. Academy of Management Journal.2003,46(1):46-62
    [54] Peijian Song., Heng Xu., Angsana Techatassanasoontorn., et al. The influence of productintegration on online advertising effectiveness [J]. Electronic Commerce Research andApplications,2011,(10):288-303.
    [55] Marilyn H., Oermann. Norma F., et al. Evaluation of web sites on management of pain inchildren [J]. Pain Management Nursing,2003,4(3):99-105.
    [56] Marjo Prusti., Susanna Lehtineva., Marika Pohjanoksa-Ma ntyla. The quality of onlineantidepressant drug information: an evaluation of English and Finnish language web sites [J].Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy2012,8(3):263-268.
    [57] Sandra Shropshire. Beyond the design and evaluation of library web sites: an analysis and fourcase studies [J]. The Journal of Academic Librarianship,2003,29(2):95-101.
    [58] Vera Silva Carlos., Ricardo Gouveia Rodrigues. Web site quality evaluation in higher educationinstitutions [J]. Procedia Technology,2012(5):273-282.
    [59] Andrew Potter. Accessibility of Alabama government web sites [J]. Journal of GovernmentInformation,2002,29(5):303-317.
    [60] Lisa A Sutherland., Barbara Wildemuth., Marci K Campbell. Unraveling the web: an evaluationof the content quality, usability, and readability of nutrition web sites [J]. Nutrtion EducationBehavior,2005,37(6):300-305.
    [61] Benjamin Yen., Paul Jen-Hwa Hu, May Wang. Toward an analytical approach for effectiveweb site design: a framework for modeling, evaluation and enhancement [J]. ElectronicCommerce Research and Applications2007,6(2):159-170.
    [62] Noboru Nakamichi., Makoto Sakai., Kazuyuki Shima., et al. WebTracer: a new web usabilityevaluation environment using gazing point information [J]. Electronic Commerce Research andApplications,2007,6(1):63-73.
    [63] Aline Chevalier, Nathalie Bonnardel. Articulation of web site design constraints: effects of thetask and designers’expertise [J]. Computers in Human Behavior,2007,23(5):2455-2472.
    [64] Aline Chevalier, Maud Kicka. Web designers and web users: Influence of the ergonomicquality of the web site on the information search [J]. International Journal of Human-ComputerStudies,2006,64(10):1031-1048.
    [65] Xiang Fang., Clyde W. Holsapple. An empirical study of web site navigation structures'impactson web site usability [J]. Decision Support Systems,2007,43(2):476-491.
    [66] Layla Hasan., Emad Abuelrub. Assessing the quality of web sites [J].Applied Computing andInformatics,2011,9(1):11-29.
    [67] Paul van Schaik., Jonathan Ling. Modelling user experience with web sites: usability, hedonicvalue, beauty and goodness [J]. Interacting with Computers,2008,20(3):419-432.
    [68] F.J Miranda Gonzalez, T.M Banegil Palacios. Quantitative evaluation of commercial web sites:an empirical study of Spanish firms [J]. International Journal of Information Management,2004,24(4):313-328.
    [69] Moshe Zviran., Chanan Glezer., Itay Avni.User sagisfaction from commercial web sites: theeffect of design and use [J]. Informtion&Management,2006,43(2):157-178.
    [70] Kristof De Wulf., Niels Schillewaert., Steve Muylle. The role of pleasure in web site success [J].Information&Management,2006,43(4)434-446.
    [71] Jean Ethier., Pierre Hadaya., Jean Talbot., et al. B2C web site quality and emotions duringonline shopping episodes: an empirical study [J]. Information&Management,2006,43(5):627-639.
    [72] David Robins., Jason Holmes. Aesthetics and credibility in web site design [J]. InformationProcessing and Management,2008,44(1):386-399.
    [73] Sangwon Lee., Richard J. Koubek. The effects of usability and web design attributes on userpreference for e-commerce web sites [J]. Computers in Industry,2010,61(4):329-341.
    [74] Benedict GC Dellaert., Barbara E Kahn. How tolerable is delay? Consumers’ evaluations ofinternet web sites after waiting [J]. Journal of interactive marketing,1999,13(1):41-54.
    [75] Yung-Hsiang Cheng. Evaluating web site service quality in public transport: evidence fromTaiwan High Speed Rail [J]. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies,2011,19(6):957-974.
    [76] Menno de Jonga., Leo Lentz. Scenario evaluation of municipal web sites: development and useof an expert-focused evaluation tool [J]. Government Information Quarterly,2006,23(2):191-206.
    [77] Jean éthier., Pierre Hadaya., Jean Talbot., et al. Interface design and emotions experienced onB2C web sites: empirical testing of a research model [J]. Computers in Human Behavior,2008,24(6):2771-2791.
    [78] Don Zimmerman., Dawn Bastian Paschal. An exploratory usability evaluation of ColoradoState University Libraries' digital collections and the Western Waters Digital Library web sites[J]. The Journal of Academic Librarianship,2009,35(3):227-240.
    [79] Wen-Hsien Tsai, Wen-Chin Chou. Jun-Der Leu. An effectiveness evaluation model for theweb-based marketing of the airline industry [J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2011,38(12):15499-15516.
    [80] Raquel Benbunan-Fich.Using protocol analysis to evaluate the usability of a commercial website [J].Informtion&Management,2001,39(2):151-163.
    [81] Elif K l Delice., Zülar Güng r. The usability analysis with heuristic evaluation and analytichierarchy process [J]. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics,2009,39(6):934-939.
    [82] C. Ranganthan., Shobha Ganapathy. Key dimentions of business-to-consumer web sites [J].Informtion&Management,2002,39(6):457-465.
    [83] Gwo-Jen Hwanga, Tony C. K. Huang., Judy C.R. Tseng. A group-decision approach forevaluating educational web sites [J]. Computers&Education,2004,42(1):65-86.
    [84] Enrique Herrera-Viedma., Eduardo Peis., Jose M. Morales-del-Castillo., et al. A fuzzylinguistic model to evaluate the quality of web sites that store XML documents [J]. InternationalJournal of Approximate Reasoning,2007,46(1):226-253.
    [85] Adrian Fernandez., Emilio Insfran., Silvia Abrah. Usability evaluation methods for the web: asystematic mapping study [J]. Information and Software Technology,2011,53(8):789-817.
    [86] Maria De Marsico., Stefano Levialdi. Evaluating web sites: exploiting user’s expectations [J].International Journal of Human-Computer Studies,2004,60(3):381-416.
    [87] Ngai E. Selection of web sites for online advertising using the AHP [J]. Information andManagement,2003,40(4):233-242
    [88] Lin Chin-Tsai., Hsu Pi-Fang. Selection of advertising agencies using Grey Relational Analysis&analytic hierarchy process [J]. Journal of International Marketing and Marketing Research,2001,26(3):115-128.
    [89] Lin Chin-Tsai., Hsu Pi-Fang. Adopting an analytic hierarchy process to select internetadvertising networks [J]. Marketing Intelligence&Planning,2003,21(3):183-191.
    [90] Neil Daswani., Michael Stoppelman. The anatomy of clickbot [C]. HotBots’07Proceedings ofthe first conference on First Workshop on Hot Topics in Understanding Botnets,2007,11-11.
    [91] Mona Gandhi., Markus Jakobsson., Jacob Ratkiewicz. Badvertisements: stealthy click-fraudwith unwitting accessories [J]. Journal of Digital Forensic Practice,2006,1(2):131-142.
    [92] Andrew Bortz., Erika Chin., Neil Daswani., et al. The goals and challenges of click fraudpenetration testing systems: Camelot as an example[C].14th European Symposium on Researchin Computer Security–ESORICS2009:523-538.
    [93] Hamed Haddadi. Fighting online click-fraud using bluff ads. ACM SIGCOMM ComputerCommunication Review,2010,40(2):21-25.
    [94]袁健,张劲松,马良等.一种有效预防点击欺诈的策略[J].计算机应用,2009,29(7):1790-1793.
    [95]张祖莲,卡米力·木衣丁,王命全等.一种有效预防点击欺诈的算法[J].计算机应用,2010,30(7):1794-1796.
    [96] Yanlin Peng., Linfeng Zhang., J. Morris Chang., et al. An effective method for combatingmalicious scripts clickbots [J]. ESORICS,2009,5789:523-538.
    [97] Nicole Immorlica., Kamal Jain. Mohammad Mahdian., et al. Click fraud resistant methods forlearning click-through rates [J]. Internet and Network Economics,2005,3828:34-45.
    [98] Ari Juels., Sid Stamm., Markus Jakobsson. Combating click fraud via premium clicks [C].The16thUSENIX Security Symposium,2007, No2:17:26.
    [99] Linfeng Zhang., Yong Guan. Detecting click fraud in pay-per-click streams of onlineadvertising networks[C]. The28th International Conference on Distributed Computing Systems,2008,1063-6927:77-84.
    [100] Benard J Jansen.Click fraud [J].Computer,2007,40(7):85-86.
    [101] Chamila Walgampaya., Mehmed Kantardzic., Roman Yampolskiy. Evidence fusions for realtime click fraud detection and prevention [J]. Intelligent Automation and Systems Engineering,2011(103):1-14.
    [102] A Metwally, D Agrawal, AE Abbadi. Detectives: Detecting coalition hit inflation attacks inadvertising networksStreams [C]. The16th International Conference on World Wide Web,2007, pp:241-250.
    [103] Chulyun Kim., HuiMiao, KyuseokShim. CATCH: a detecting algorithm for coalition attacksof hit inflation in internet advertising [J]. Information Systems,2011,36(8):1105-1123.
    [104]王先林,丁圣伟.网络广告中的点击欺诈及其对策[J].中国工商管理研究,2007(4):15-18.
    [105]刘春年,潘钦.网络广告欺诈点击的性质分析与防范.[J].商业时代,2008(8):58-62.
    [106] Vishal Midha. The glitch in on-line advertising: a study of click fraud in pay-per-clickadvertising programs [J]. International Journal of Electronic Commerce,2008,13(2):91-111.
    [107] Bobji Mungamuru., Stephen Weis., Hector Garcia-Molina. Should ad networks botherfighting click fraud?(Yes, they should.). Stanford Info Lab, Technical Report, July2008.
    [108] Benjamin Edelman. Deterring online advertising fraud through optimal payment in arrears [J].Financial Cryptography and Data Security,2009,5628:17-31.
    [109] Joshua Goodman. Pay-per-percentage of impressions: an advertising method that is highlyrobust to fraud. Workshop on Sponsored Search Auctions, June5,2005.
    [110] LIN Hongwei., SHAO Peiji. The study on supervision model for online advertising clickfraud [J]. Management Science and Engineering,2011,5(3):101-113.
    [111] Kenneth C Wilbur., Yi Zhu. Click fraud [J].Marketing Science,2009,28(2):293-308.
    [112] Wei Zhou., Subhajyoti Bandyopadhyay., Hsing K Cheng., et al. A mechanism for on-lineadvertisement placement to deter click fraud [J]. International Journal of ElectronicCommerce,2008,13(2):9-27.
    [113] Sanjay Mittal., Rahul Gupta., Mukesh Mohania., et al. Detecting frauds in online advertisingsystems [C].The International Coference on E-Commerce and Web Technologies,2006,4082:222-231.
    [114]高志坚.引入第三方监测根治点击欺诈[J].生产力研究,2007(18):72-73.
    [115] Tamara Dinev., Qing Hu., Ali Yayla. Is there an on-line advertisers’ dilemma? A study ofclick fraud in the pay-per-click model [J]. International Journal of Electronic Commerce,2008,13(2):29-59.
    [116] Xuhua Ding. A hybrid method to detect deflation fraud in cost-per-action online advertising[C]. International Conference on Applied Cryptography and Network Security ACNS2010,6123:545–562.
    [117] Saugat Majumdar., Dhananjay Kulkarni., Chinya V Ravishankar. Addressing click fraud incontent delivery systems [C].The26th IEEE International Conference on ComputerCommunications, INFOCOM2007, pp:240-248.
    [118] Vinod Anupam., Alain Mayer., Kobbi Nissim., et al. On the security of pay-per-click andother web advertising schemes [J], Computer Networks,1999,31:1091–1100.
    [119] Michae K Reiter., Vinod Anupam., Alain Mayer. Detecting hit shaving in click-throughpayment schemes [C].The3rd USENIX Workshop on Electronic Commerce,1998, pp:155-166.
    [120] Markus Jakobsson., Philip D MacKenzie., Julien P Stern. Secure and lightweight advertisingon the web [J].Computer Networks,1999(31):1101-1109.
    [121] D Klein. Defending against the wily surfer-web-based attacks and defenses [C]: The USENIXID Workshop on Intrusion Detection and Network Monitoring,1999, pp:81-92.
    [122] Yung-Ming Li., Jhih-Hua., Jhang-Li. Pricing display ads and contextual ads: competition,acquisition, and investment [J]. Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2009,8(1):16-27.
    [123] De Liu., Siva Viswanathan. Information asymmetry and payment schemes in onlineadvertising.Working paper,2013, Social Science Electronic Publishing.
    [124] Dickinger A., Zorn S. Compensation models for interactive advertising [J]. JournalofUniversal Computer Science,2008,14(4):557-565.
    [125] Brian T Ratchford. Online pricing: review and directions for research [J]. Journal ofInteractive Marketing,2009,23(1):82-90.
    [126] Andrea Mangani. Online advertising: pay-per-view versus pay-per-click [J]. Journal ofRevenue and Pricing Management,2004,2(4):295-302.
    [127] Fjell K. Online advertising: pay-per-view versus pay-per-click-a comment [J]. Journal ofRevenue and Pricing Management,2009,8(2/3):200-206.
    [128] Kumar S., Sethi S. Dynamic pricing and advertising for web content providers [J]. EuropeanJournal of Operational Research,2009,197(3):924-944.
    [129] Moon Y., Kwon C. Online advertisement service pricing and an option contract [J]. ElectronicCommerce Research and Applications,2011,10(1):38-48.
    [130] Roels G., Fridgeirsdottir K. Dynamic revenue management for online display advertising [J].Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management,2009(8):452-466.
    [131] Karmarkar S., Dutta G. Multi-period revenue management model for internet advertising [J].Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management,2012(11):225-239.
    [132] Kwon C. Single-period balancing of pay-per-click and pay-per-view online displayadvertisements [J]. Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management,2011,10(3):261-270.
    [133] Md Tanveer Ahmed., Changhyun Kwon. Pricing game of online display advertisementpublishers [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2012,219(2):477-487.
    [134] Greg Taylor. The informativeness of on-line advertising [J]. International Journal of IndustrialOrganization,2011,29(6):668-677.
    [135] Vural Aksakall. Optimizing direct response in Internet display advertising [J]. ElectronicCommerce Research and Applications,2012,11(3):229-240.
    [136] B. Selcuk.,. zlük. Optimal keyword bidding in search-based advertising with targetexposure levels [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2013,226(1):163-172.
    [137] Balseiro S., Feldman J., Mirrokni V., et al. Yield optimization of display advertising with adexchange[C]. The12th ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce,2011, pp:27-28.
    [138] Ashutosh Prasad., Vijay Mahajanb., Bart Bronnenberg. Advertising versus pay-per-view inelectronic media [J]. International Jounal of Research in Marketing,2003,20(1):13-30.
    [139] Timothy N Cason., Shakun Datta. An experimental study of price dispersion in an optimalsearch model with advertising [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2006,24(3):639-665.
    [140] John Morgan., Henrik Orzen., Martin Sefton. A laboratory study of advertising and pricecompetition [J]. European Economic Review,2006,50(2):323-347.
    [141] Andrea Galeotti., José Luis Moraga-González. Segmentation, advertising and prices [J].International Journal of Industrial Organization,2008,26(5):1106-1119.
    [142] LAN Zhao, Anna Nagurney. A network equilibrium framework for Internet advertising:models, qualitative analysis, and algorithms [J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2008,187(2):456-472.
    [143] Yun Chu Chen, Shu-Cherng Fang, Ue-Pyng Wen. Pricing policies for substitutable productsin a supply chain with Internet and traditional channels [J]. European Journal of OperationalResearch,2013,224(3):542-551.
    [144] Richard van der Wurff., Piet Bakker., Robert G Picard. Economic growth and advertisingexpenditures in different media in different countries [J].Journal of media Economics,2008,21(1):28-52.
    [145] Jean J Gabszewicz., Didier Laussel., Nathalie Sonnac. Competition in the media andadvertising markets [J].The Manchester School,2006,74(1):1-22.
    [146] Prasad A Naik., Kalyan Raman. Understanding the impact of synergy in ultimedia commun-ications [J].Journal of Marketing Research,2003,40(4):375-388.
    [147] David Berkowitz., Arthur Allaway., Giles D'Souza. The impact of differential lag effects onthe allocation of advertising budgets across media [J].Journal of Advertising Research,2001,41(2):27-36.
    [148] Prasad A Naik., Kay Peter. A hierarchical marketing communications model of online andoffline media synergies [J].Journal of Interactive Marketing,2009,23(4):288-299.
    [149] David Soberman. The complexity of media planning today [J].Journal of Brand Management,2005,12(6):420-429.
    [150] Lance Richard. The paradox of ROI and decrea-sed spending in the ad industry [J].AmericanJournal of Business,2009,24(2):11-15.
    [151] Peter J Danaher., Roland T Rust. Determining the optimal return on investment for anadvertising campaign [J].European Journal of Operational Research,1996,95(3):511-521.
    [152] zgür zlük., Susan Cholette. Allocating expenditures across keywords in search advertising[J].Journal of Revenue and Pricing Management,2007,6(4):347-356.
    [153] He Huang, Robert J Kauffman. On the design of sponsored keyword advertising slot auctions:an analysis of a generalized second-price auction approach [J]. Electronic CommerceResearch and Applications,2011,10(2):194-202.
    [154] S Muthukrishnan., Martin Pál., Zoya Svitkina. Stochastic models for budget optimization insearch-based advertising [J].Algorithmica,2010,58(4):1022-1044.
    [155] Jae Won Lee, Jae Kyu Lee. Online advertising by the comparison challenge approach [J].Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2006,5(4):282-294.
    [156] Alfredo Martín-Oliver., Vicente Salas-Fumás. The output and profit contribution ofinformation technology and advertising investments in banks [J].Journal of FinancialInetrmediation,2008,17(2):229-255.
    [157] C Edward Fee., Charles J Hadlock., Joshua R Pierce. What happens in acquisitions? Evidencefrom brand ownership changes and advertising investment [J]. Journal of Corporate Finance,2012,18(3):584-597.
    [158] Lisa M George., Christiaan Hogendorn. Aggregators, search and the economics of new mediainstitutions [J]. Information Economics and Policy,2012,24(1):40-51.
    [159] Kari S., Fridriksson, Gylfi Zoega. Advertising as a predictor of investment [J]. EconomicsLetters,2012,116(1):60-66.
    [160] Kwangmin Park., SooCheong (Shawn) Jang. Duration of advertising effect: consideringfranchising in the restaurant industry [J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management,2012,31(1):257-265.
    [161] Syed Zulfiqar Ali Shah., Andrew W Stark., Saeed Akbar. The value relevance of major mediaadvertising expenditures: some U.K. evidence [J]. The International Journal of Accounting,2009,44(2):187-206.
    [162] Tanses Gülsoy. Managing a strategic business relationship in an emerging market: advertisingagency-client relationships in Turkey [J]. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,2012,58(12):1386-1394.
    [163] Ralph Breuer., Malte Brettel.Short-and long-term effects of online advertising: differencesbetween new and existing customers [J].Journal of Interactive Marketing,2012,26(3):155-166.
    [164] Hilde AM., Voorveld. Media multitasking and the effectiveness of combining online andradio advertising [J]. Computers in Human Behavior,2011,27(6):2200-2206.
    [165] Nada Ben Elhadj-Ben Brahim., Rim Lahmandi-Ayed., Didier Laussel. Is targeted advertisingalways beneficial?[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2011,29(6):678-689.
    [166] Gene M.Grossman., Carl Shapiro. Informative advertising with differentiated products [J].Review of Economic Studies,1984,51(1):63-81.
    [167] Ram Gopal, Xinxin Li., Ramesh Sankaranarayanan. Online keyword based advertising:impact of ad impressions on own-channel and cross-channel click-through rates [J]. DecisionSupport Systems,2011,52(1):1-8.
    [168] Daniel F Leach., W Duncan Reekie. A natural experiment of the effect of advertising on sales:The SASOL case [J].Applied Economics,1996,28(9):1081-1091.
    [169] Kristin Kennedy., Bonnie Brayton Kennedy. A small company's dilemma: using search engi-nes effectively for corporate sales [J].Management Research News,2008,31(10):737-745.
    [170] Zo Abrams., S Sathiya Keerthi., Ofer Mendelevitch., et al. Ad delivery with budgetedadvertisers: a comprehensive LP approach [J].Journal of Electronic Commerce Research,2008,9(1):16-32.
    [171] Hsiao-Chien Tsui. Advertising, quality, and willingness-to-pay: experimental examination ofsignaling theory [J]. Journal of Economic Psychology,2012,33(6):1193-1203.
    [172] Cookhwan Kim., Kwiseok Kwon., Woojin Chang., et al. How to measure the effectiveness ofonline advertising in online marketplaces [J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2011,38(4):4234-4243.
    [173] Cookhwan Kim., Sungsik Park., Yongseok Chang., et al. Random effects model for estimatingeffectiveness of advertising in online marketplaces [J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2011,38(8):9867-9878.
    [174] Cookhwan Kim., Sungsik Park., Kwiseok Kwon., et al. An empirical test to measure theeffectiveness of online advertising in online marketplaces using a hierarchical Bayes model [J].Expert Systems with Applications,2012,39(1):117-128.
    [175] Simon Pierre Sigué., Pradeep Chintagunta. Advertising strategies in a franchise system [J].European Journal of Operational Research,2009,198(2):655-665.
    [176] C Beltran-Royo., H Zhang., LA Blanco., et al.Multistage multiproduct advertising budgeting[J]. European Journal of Operational Research,2013,225(1):179-188.
    [177] Eric Bax., Anand Kuratti., Preston Mcafee., et al. Comparing predicted prices in auctions foronline advertising [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2012,30(1):80-88.
    [178] Kai Li., Jianyuan Yan., Xiaowen Wang. A bayesian network model for optimizingadvertisements allocation in intermediate online targeted advertising [C]. The4thInternational Conference on Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing,2008, pp:1-4.
    [179] Aruna Seneviratne., Kanchana Thilakarathna., Suranga Seneviratne., et al. Reconciling bitterrivals: towards privacy-aware and bandwidth efficient mobile ads delivery networks [C]. TheFifth International Conference on Communication Systems and Networks,2013, pp:1-10.
    [180] Yong Wang., Daniel Burgener., Aleksandar Kuzmanovic., et al. Understanding the networkand user-targeting properties of web advertising networks [C]. The31st InternationalConference on Distributed Computing Systems,2011, pp:613-622.
    [181] Kai Li., Efosa C Idemudia., Zhangxi Lin., et al. A framework for intermediated onlinetargeted advertising with banner ranking mechanism [J]. Information Systems and e-BusinessManagement,2012,10(2):183-200.
    [182] Nadia Abou Nabout., Bernd Skiera., Tanja Stepanchuk., et al. An analysis of the profitabilityof fee-based compensation plans for search engine marketing [J]. Intern. J. of Research inMarketing,2012,29(1):68-80
    [183] Mark Davies., Melvin Prince. Advertising agency compensation, client evaluation andswitching costs: an extension of agency theory [J]. Journal of Current Issues and Research inAdvertising,2010,32(1):13-31.
    [184] Deborah F Spake., Giles D'Souza., Tammy Neal Crutchfield., et al. Advertising agencycompensation: an agency theory explanation [J]. Journal of Advertising,1999,28(3):53-72.
    [185] Ramakrishnan Kannan., Dinesh Garg., Karthik Subbian Y Narahari., et al. Nash bargainingbased ad networks for sponsored search auctions [C]. IEEE Conference on Commerce andEnterprise Computing,2009, pp:170-175.
    [186] Mehdi Behboudi., Kambiz Heidarzadeh Hanzaee., Amir Abedini Koshksaray., et al. A reviewof the activities of advertising agencies in online world [J]. Intemational Joumal of MarketingStudies,2012,4(1):138-149.
    [187] Kei-Shao Chen, Ming-Huei Chen. EC2.0: Can you get profit by writing blog? an empiricalstudy in Google Adsense [C]. Technology Management for Global Economic Growth(PICMET),2010, pp:2346-2352.
    [188] Tai-Yuan Huang, Jer-San Hu, Kuo-Chia Chen. The influence of market and productknowledge resource embeddedness on the international mergers of advertising agencies: thecase-study approach [J]. International Business Review,2008,17(5):587-599
    [189] Nevena Vratonjic., Mohammad Hossein Manshaei., Maxim Raya., et al. ISPs and ad networksagainst botnet ad fraud [J]. Decision and Game Theory for Security,2010(6442):149-167.
    [190] Rotitni Williams Olatunji. An exploratory study of level of adoption of integrated marketingcommunications by advertising agencies in Nigeria [J]. International Journal of IntegratedMarketing Communications,2009(5):25-32.
    [191] Woonbong Na., Roger Marshall., Youngseok Son. How businesses buy advertising agencyservices: a way to segment advertising agencies' markets?[J]. Journal of Advertising Research,2003,43(1):86-95.
    [192] B Zafer Erdogan., Tanyn.Drollinger. Endorsement practice: how agencies selectspokespeople [J]. Journal of Advertising Research,2008,48(4):573-582.
    [193] Sharon Horsky. The changing architecture of advertising agencies [J]. Marketing Science,2006,25(4):367-383.
    [194] Tzu-wen Hsu, Jamie Murphy., Sharon Purchase. Australian and Taiwanese advertiser’sperceptions of internet marketing [J]. Australasian Marketing Journal,2001,9(1):33-45.
    [195] Kohda Y., Endo S. Ubiquitous advertising on the www: merging advertisement on thebrowser [J]. Computer Networks and ISDN Systems,1996,28(7-11):1493-1499
    [196]齐克夏.论广告效益统计指标体系的建立及其综合评价[J].浙江统计,1998(4):14-16.
    [197]徐泽水,孙在东.一类不确定型多属性决策问题的排序方法[J].管理科学学报,2002,5(3):35-39
    [198]徐泽水.基于相离度和可能度的偏差最大化多属性决策方法[J].控制与决策,2001,16(s):818-821.
    [199]徐泽水.模糊互补判断矩阵排序的一种算法[J].系统工程学报,2001,16(4):311-314.
    [200] http://www.linuxpk.com/7623.html
    [201] http://www.techweb.com.cn/manage/2006-09-04/92089.shtml.
    [202] Hong Wei Lin., Peiji Shao.Study on opertation mode for online advertisement based oncomptetition and vertical integration [C].The2nd International Conference on ArtificialIntelligence, Management Science and Electronic Commerce,2011, pp:1539-1542.
    [203] Kevin Ross., Kristin Fridgeirsdottir. Cost-per-impression and cost-per-action pricing indisplay advertising with risk preferences.Working paper,2010.
    [204]周永务,王圣东.随机需求下单制造商两零售商合作广告协调模型[J].系统工程学报,2011,26(2):203-210.
    [205]蔡洪文,蔡洪武,张殿业.零售商主导的联合广告投入共担期权契约模型[J].系统工程学报,2011,26(3):322-329.
    [206]曹文彬.企业网络广告的定价策略研究[J].中国管理科学,2006,14(1):94-99.
    [207]何建民,刘赞. Internet环境下的网络广告投资渠道合作研究[J].合肥工业大学学报(自然科学版),2008,31(8):1241-1244.
    [208] Susan X. Li., Zhimin Huang., Joe Zhu., et al. Cooperative advertising, game theory andmanufacturer-retailer supply chains [J]. Omega,2002,30(5):347-357.
    [209]胡荣.学习效应、有限理性与动态古诺竞争复杂性[J].复杂系统与复杂性科学,2011,8(4):44-50.
    [210]吴江华,翟昕.基于学习效应的供应链信息共享研究[J].运筹与管理,2011,20(3):10-17.
    [211] Rachelle C Sampson. Experience effects and collaborative returns in R&D alliances [J].Strategic Management Journal,2005,26(11):1009-1031.
    [212] Gur Mosheiov. Scheduling problems with a learning effect [J]. European Journal ofOperational Research,2001,132(3):687-693.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700