摘要
建国以来,我国农村经历了从集体“大锅饭”到土地承包到户的变化过程,这个过程曾使农业生产力得到了极大的提高,但一段时间后,人们发现这种方式成为了农村进一步发展的桎梏,变革不可避免。最后一些地区选择了农业产业化经营模式,这种模式通过专业一化的生产与经营,生产力的又一次得到了解放。农业产业化经营被证明一种有效的方式,但其在全国的发展不平衡,湘南地区目前处在农业产业化的初级阶段。湘南地区推广农业产业化有其优势:湘南紧靠经济发达的珠三角地区,拥有便利的市场;但不利因素是金融发展落后,没有能够有效支持农业产业化的发展。本文在此背景下对如何促进农业产业化与农村金融同时发展,让两者实现良性互动进行了分析。
本文先对相关的理论进行了回顾,再结合马克思的“资本第一推动力”理论及其他理论对农业产业化与农村金融之间的关系进行分析,认为农业产业化与农村金融是一种相辅相成的关系。本文对农村金融发展较好的国家进行了简单的介绍,结合湘南地区农业产业化发展状况与在湘南地区的调查材料,再从金融供给与需求两个方面分析了湘南地区农村金融现状,认为湘南地区的金融需求多为消费性需求,而生产性需求不足;通过构建L/R(农业贷款量与第一产业增加值的比重)这样一个指标,认为金融供给水平与第一产业的发展不相称,而农村获得的借款大部分又是通过非正规金融渠道获得这样一种结构性问题。因为农业产业化发展水平不高导致了收入水平不高,从而对金融的需求停留在消费性需求,而生产性需求则不旺盛;在农村金融系统征信成本过高,导致了农村正规金融机构与非正规金融机构金融供给的结构性问题,农业保险体系的不完善与农村信用合作性的合作性不够导致了金融供给不足,这些是生产性需求小,供给也小的“平衡”的原因。提出了大力发展农业产业化来刺激对金融的生产性需求,激活农村金融的源头;建立合作性质的“农协”作为融资平台,发展农业保险系列性的服务来保障与扩大金融的供给,最后不同农村金融的需求则要以不同方式来满足。通过这些方式来实现农业产业化与农村金融的良性互动,达到一个高位的平衡,带动湘南农村经济快速发展。
Since the found of our new China, the rural areas have experienced changes from a collective "mess" to the time of distributing land to single rural family. Productivity has been greatly improved. After a period of time, people found that the way of independently production by a single farmer became the shackles of further development of rural areas. Reformation became an inevitable choice. The ultimate choice in some areas is the mode of "agricultural industrialization". The rural economy has been further developed though professional production and management. The mode of agricultural industrialization has been proved to be a more effective way. But the development of it in different regions is imbalance. The Southern area of Hunan Province is still in the initial stage of process of agricultural industrialization. Developing the industrialization of agriculture in The Southern Area of Hunan Province has its advantages: It is the neighbore of the economically developed Pearl River Delta areas, whice will provide a convenient market; but there are also negative factors: the underdevelopment of rural financial in this area fails to support the development of agricultural industrialization. In this context the article analysed how to promote agricultural industrialization and the development of rural finance at the same time, and forme positive interaction between the two.
In my paper, firstly I raised the question, and then analysed the relationship between agricultural industrialization and rural financial combining of Marx's "Capital first impetus" theory and other theories and concluded that: the agricultural industrialization and rural finance is a kind of complement each other. In the third part, an analysis of supply and demand of the financial in The Southern Area of Huan province was given combining with development of agricultural industrialization, and then concluded that most of the financial needs were consumptive demand and productive demand was insufficient. On the supply side, the construction of L / R (the proportion of the volume of agricultural loans with the added value of the primary industry) reflected the supply did not reach the national average leval and that the level of supply was not commensurate with the development of primary industry; The supply of rural finance wre implemented by non-formal financial channels rather than formal finance, such of which was a structural problem. In the fourth part the reasons were analysed combining the status. The development level of the agricultural industrialization has led to low level of the income, which remained the financial needs at the level of consumptive demand, and demand can not be productive; the high cost for the financial system to get credit information in rural areas has led to the structural problems of finance supply. The imperfect system of agricultural insurance and lack the nature of co-operation of Rural Credit Cooperatives lead to a sufficicent financial supply. In the last two parts, suggestions are proposed to develop the industrialization of agriculture to stimulate the productive needs of finance conbining the experience of developed countries and activate the source of rural finance ,and to establish the cooperate-natured "agricultural association" as a financing platform for the development of agricultural insurance services to protect and expand the financial supply, and finally put forward in different ways to meet the different needs of rural finance. We may achieve the positive interaction between agricultural industrialization and rural finance and ultimately promote the rapid development of rural economy in Southern Area of Hunan Province through these means.
引文
3李庆庆.农业产业化经营研究,[中国优秀硕士论文],华东师范大学, 2007年5月
4朱铁辉.农业产业化四阶段论,[中国优秀博士论文],中国农业科学院, 2006年6月
5李建英.转型期农村金融新体系研究[M],经济管理出版社,2007年9月第一版,9-15页
6马克思恩格斯全集,第24卷[M],人民出版社,1972,第398到399页
7马克思恩格斯全集,第26卷Ⅱ[M],人民出版社,1973,第61页
8雷俊,饶开宇等.农业产业化经营研究[M],电子科技大学出版社,2008年4月第一版,第8页
9方妍.农业产业化发展中的融资研究,[中国优秀硕士论文],东北财经大学,2007年12月
10张庆亮.中国农村民营金融发展研究[M],经济科学出版社2008年第一版第11-12页
11彭海清.论农业产业化经营及农村金融支持对策,[中国优秀硕士论文],华中农业大学,2000年8月
12马克思恩格斯全集,第24卷,人民出版社,1972,第398到399页
13马克思恩格斯全集,第26卷Ⅱ,人民出版社,1973,第61页
14祝健.中国农村金融体系重构研究[M],社会科学文献出版社,2008年6月第一版,第27页
15程文兵.农业产业化与金融支持关联问题研究[J],金融与经济,2008年10月
16罗望林.湖南经济地理[M],新华出版社,1988年6月第一版,325-327页
18张勇,李向宝.浅析农业产业化的阶段性[J],农村、农业、农民,2001年第6期
19李建英.转轨期农村金融新体系研究[M],经济管理出版社,2007年9月第1版第46-47页
20何梦文,冯兴元,何广文.试论中国农村金融的多元化——一种局部知识范式视角[J],中国农村观察,2004年第5期
28王曙光.农村金融与新农村建设[M],华夏出版社,2006年8月第一版第129页
29谈儒勇.非正式金融批判的批判[J],甘肃社会科学,2001年第一期
30甘少浩、张亦春.中国农户金融支持问题研究[M],中国财政经济出版社,2008年1月第一版172页
31何广文等.中国农村金融发展与制度变迁[M],中国财政经济出版社,2005年11月第一版第240页
32朱有志、方向新.农民关注的十大问题[M],湖南人民出版社,2006年1月第一版第28页
33张庆亮,中国农村民营金融发展研究[M],经济科学出版社,2008年1月第一版第264页
34甘少浩、张亦春,中国农户金融支持问题研究[M],中国财政经济出版社,2008年1月第一版第129页
35朱铁辉.中国农业产业化的“四阶段”论,[中国优秀博士论文],中国农业科学院,2006年6月
36余子鹏.中国农村金融演变、创新和风险管理,[中国优秀博士论文],华中科技大学,2006年5月
37《中共中央国务院关于做好二000年农业和农村工作的意见》
38庞道沐.建设现代农业的必由之路[J],求是杂志,2008年第5期
39余子鹏.中国农村金融演变、创新和风险管理[J],[中国优秀博士论文],华中科技大学,2006年5月
[1]刘仁伍.区域金融结构和金融发展理论与实证研究[M].北京:经济管理出版.20039(1)
[2]张元红等.著当代农村金融发展的理论与实践[M].江西:江西人民出版社出版.2002(9)
[3]闫永夫.中国农村金融业--现象剖析与走向探索[M].北京:中国金融出版社.2004(11)
[4]李勇等.关于完善农村金融制度加大对三农金融之若干问题的思考[J].金融研究.2005(11)
[5]任伟.对我国农村金融抑制问题的思考[J].林业经济.2006(5)
[6]牛若峰、夏英.农业产业化经营的组织方式和运行机制[M].北京大学出版社.2000
[7]殷孟波.西南经济发展的金融支持[M].西南财经大学出版社.2002
[8]孔祥智.聚焦“三农”:180位专家学者破解“三农”难题[M].第1版.2004
[9]侯石安.财政农业投入政策研究[M].中国财政经济出版社.2002
[10]张绍焱、梅德平.中国农业产业化问题研究[M].中国经济出版社.1999
[11]谢平.中国农村信用合作制改革的争论[J].金融研究.2001(1)
[12]唐忠.对发展农业产业化经营的几点认识[J].中国农村信用合作.1999(3)
[13]严瑞珍、刘淑贞.中国农村金融体系现状分析与改革建议[J].农业经济问题.2003(7)
[14]王洪章、刘锡良.“如何将农信社改革推向纵深”[N].金融时报.2003.10.29
[15]袁靖,王建伟.金融抑制:我国产业结构调整升级的瓶颈[J].山东商业职业技术学院学报.2005,5(3)
[16]朱永德、张乐柱.农业产业化金融支持弱化成因透析[J].2004.3.24
[17]张余文.国有商业银行从农村的退出与农村金融体系的重建[J].财贸经济.2003(6)
[18]郭晓鸣.农村金融:现实挑战与发展选择[J].经济学家.2005(3)
[19]章奇.农村金融现状与政策分析.http://jlin.ccer.edu.cn
[20]陈柳钦.我国农业产业化经营的金融支持研究[J].中国改革论坛.2005.5.24
[21]翟书斌.论化解“三农”问题的金融支持[J].金融理论与实践.2004(9)
[22]姜太碧,郑景骥,杨武云.论农业的弱质性[J].经济论坛.2002(23)
[23]陈玉洁.“农民的发展,才是真正的发展”—温铁军眼中的新农村[N].人民画报.2005.12
[24]何广文.以金融创新促进农村信用社小额贷款业务健康发展[J].中国农村信用合作.2002(2)
[25]何广文、王鲁保、李莉莉.拓展农村信用社中间业务的路径思考[J].中国农村信用合作.2003(2)
[26]周其仁.反思农村金融[N].中国改革农村版.2003(11)
[27]黄卫红.我国农村信用社现状及摆脱困境的策略构想[J].甘肃农业.2005(1)
[28]朱守银、张照新等.中国农村金融市场供给和需求[J].管理世界.2003(3)
[29]陈根荣,范小虎.西方现代企业融资理论述评[J].财经问题研究,2000(4)
[30]贾玉巧.我国农业产业化进程中的问题和对策研究[J],天府新论,2007(6)
[31]吕晓普.农业利用外资的现阶段特点及趋势[J],经济师,2007(7)
[32]丁力.关于农业产业化的投融资问题[J],中国食品报,2005(ll)
[33]李春诚.我国农业产业化过程中的问题及对策[J],第三届湖北科技论坛,2006(3)
[34]李晓方,涂从勇.关于农业产业化的关健问题探讨[J],科技管理研究2005(1)
[35]巴曙松.产业基金兴起的积极意义[N],中国经济时报,2003(4)
[36]汤新华.农业上市公司融资结构研究[J],金融与保险,2004(2)
[37]魏中海.重庆农业产业化发展中的投融资问题研究[J],经济师,2006(4)
[38]高云峰.农业产业化发展中的金融约束与金融支持[J],农业经济题,2003(8)
[39]张长春,刘立峰,王元京,罗松山.我国投资形式的回顾与展望[J],金融时报,2005(l)
[40]大卫·伯格,斯坦雷·费希尔,卢迪戈·多恩布什.经济学基础[M〕.北京:人民邮电出版社,2003.57--58.
[41]部义钧,邱钧.MBA产业经济学[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2001.
[42]苏东水.产业经济学[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2001.
[43]谭崇台.发展经济学[M] .湖北:武汉大学出版社,2001.
[44]农业产业化经营的组织模式与绩效评价[J].农业技术经济,1999.1.
[45] 2002年中国农业发展报告[M].北京:中华人民共和国农业部出版社,2002,12.
[46] Win Tiejun: China,Rural Cooperative Funds,Universities Service Centre for China Studies,The Chinese University of Hong Kong.
[47] Guo Xiaoming and Lei Xiaoming: Rule China entering the 21st century Universities Service Centre for China Studies,The Chinese University of Hong Kong.
[48] H.T Patrick. Financial Policies and Economic Growth.. An Overview European Economic Review,1966,37
[49] Stiglitz J. Markets, Market Failures, and Development. American Economic Review,1989,79(1):197~203
[50] IFAD,1.December 2001:Rural Financial Services in China.[J].Thematic Study.Volume I–Main.Report No.1147-CN Rev.
[51] Park,Albert,Loren Brandt,and John Giles.1997.Giving Credit Where Credit is Due:TheChanging Role of Rural Financial Institutions in China[J].William Davidson Institute Working Paper No.71.
[52] Brandt,Loren,Albert Park,and Sangui Wang.2003.“Are China‘s Financial Reforms Leaving the Poor Behind ?”[ J ] . in Huang,Yasheng,Anthony Saich,and Edward Stein feld,eds.Financial Sector Reform in China(Cambridge:Harvard East Asian Press).
[53] Williamson.O,Corporate Finance and Corporate Governance.Journal of Finance.43.1988
[54] Modigliani.F.M, H.Miller.The Cost of Capital,Corporation Finance,and the Theory of Investment. American Eeonomic Review 48.1958:261-297p
[55] Baydas,Mayada,Douglas H.Graham,and LizaValenzuela.Commercial Banks in Microfinance: New Actors in the Microfinance World . Microenterprise Best Practices (MBP)paper, Bethesda,Maryland:Development Alternatives Inc.1997:15-28
[56] Berenbach,Shari and Craig Churchill.Regulation and Supervision of Microfinance Institutions: Experience from Latin America,Asia and Africa . Occasional Paper No.1,Washington,D.C.:The Microfinance Network,1997:43-47
[57] Besley,Timothy.How Do Market Failures Justify Interventions in Rural Credit Markets? The World Bank Research Observer,Vol.9,1994(1):27-48
[58] Besley,Timothy . Non-Market Institutions for Credit and Risk-Sharing in Low Income Countries. Journal of Economic Perspectives,Vol.9,1995(3):115-127
[59] Bester,Helmut . 1985 . Screening versus Rationing in Credit Markets with Imperfect Information. American Economic Review,Vol.75,No.4,1985(9):850-855
[60] Binswanger,H.P.Attitudes toward Risk:Experimental Measurement in Rural India,American Journal of Agricultural Economics 1980,62(3):395-407
[61] Bester,Helmut . Screening versus Rationing in Credit Markets with Imperfect Information. American Economic Review,1985,75(4):.850-855
[62] Binswanger,Hans P.and Klaus Deininger.Towards a Political Economy of Agriculture and Agrarian Relations.unpublished paper,Washington,D.C.:The World Bank,1995.
[63] Binswanger, Hans P.and Mark R.Rosenzweig. Behavioral and Material Determinants of Production Relations in Agriculture.Journal of Development Studies,1986,22(3):12-26
[64] Bouman,F.J.A.and Otto Hospes,“Financial Landscapes Reconstructed.The Fine Art of Mapping Development”,Boulder,Colorado:Westview Press,1994.213-224
[65] Black,J.R.,B.J.Barnett,and Y.Hu.Cooperatives and Capital Markets:The Case of Minnesota-Dakota Sugar Cooperatives . American Journal of Agricultural Economics1995,81(6):240-249
[66] Bouriaux, S.and M.Himick.Exchange-Traded Insurance Derivatives:Catastrophe Options and Swaps . In M . Himick(Editor),Securitized Insurance Risk . The Glenlake Publishing Company. Ltd.1998.78-89
[67] Branch,Brian.Savings Product Management:Establishing the Framework.In:Branch,Brian and Janette Klaehn.Striking the Balance in Microfinance:A Practical Guide to Mobilizing Savings . World Council of Credit Unions and Pact Publications . Wisconsin,USA 2002.113–154
[68] Cole,J.B.and A.Chiarenza.Convergence in the Markets for Insurance Risk and Capital.Risk Magazine,1999(2):12-78
[69] Cuevas,Carlos E.Enabling Environment and Microfinance Institutions:Lessons from Latin America.Journal of International Development,1996,8(2):195-209
[70] Cummins,J.D.and H.Geman.Pricing Catastrophe Insurance Futures and Call Spreads:An Arbitrage Approach.The Journal of Fixed Income,1995(3):46-57
[71] Dacy,D.C.and H.Kunreuther.The Economics of Natural Disasters:Implications for Federal Policy, New York:The Free Press,1969.45-79
[72] Dercon,S . Income Risk,Coping Strategies,and Safety Nets . Discussion Paper No . 2002/22 . World Institute for Development Economics Research,United Nations University.
[73] Doherty,N . A . Integrated Risk Management:Techniques and Strategies for Reducing Risk. McGraw-Hill,2000.123-145
[74] Drucker,Peter F.The Discipline of Innovation.In:Harvard Business Review on The Innovative Enterprise . Harvard Business Review School Publishing Corporation . Boston, MA, USA. 2003.111-128
[75] Dufresen,F.B.and P.Savaria.Corporate Social Responsibility and Financial Risk.The Journal of Investing,Spring 2004.57-65
[76] Ellis,F . Household Strategies and Rural Livelihood Diversification . The Journal of Development Studies,1985.35(6):45-78