从劳动空间分工到大都市区空间组织
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
大都市区的形成和发展是现代城市化进程中的一个重要特征,也是21世纪世界城市化的主导趋势。本文以此作为研究对象,从经济学的原点——分工切入,用赋予空间内涵的劳动空间分工理论来探究大都市区空间组织所隐藏的秩序。从而推动以大都市区为研究对象的相关领域的基础理论研究,为大都市区规划和管理提供有益的借鉴。
     全文分上下两篇,共七章。上篇由前三章构成,主要从经济学的“分工”讨论中挖掘出空间的意义,在经济学平台上搭建起新的劳动空间分工的理论框架。下篇由后四章构成,利用劳动空间分工理论研究大都市区空间组织,并以此研究上海大都市区的空间组织,验证理论的正误。
     第一章 绪论。首先阐述了选题依据及研究目的,强调劳动空间分工作为一种中观层次的理论分析工具可有效衔接微观的城市经济学和宏观的政治经济学,能够更好地解析大都市区空间组织。进而对国内外关于劳动空间分工理论做了系统的文献综述工作,将西方劳动空间分工理论归纳为国际和国内两条轨迹和区域不平衡发展、马克思主义政治经济学、新制度经济学和世界经济学四个发展取向。提出劳动空间分工理论是区位论响应人文地理学范式转型的产物,并指出国内外研究的不足及重新架构理论框架的迫切性。最后建构了本研究框架和方法。
     第二章 劳动分工的理论谱系沿革。围绕着分工这一核心,将斯密开端的古典经济学、马克思主义的政治经济学、国际贸易理论、新古典经济学、新制度经济学和新兴古典经济学等流派纳入到一个统一的框架中加以思考,讨论分工理论的沿革。对相关研究进行了综合的评述,勾勒出清晰的分工理论的演变轨迹。
     第三章 劳动空间分工:经济学到人文地理学的跨越。在上一章分工讨论的基础上,重新梳理和表述分工概念,提出分工是专业化和交易矛盾统一的观点。从而建立起关于分工经济的基本框架。然后将视角转移到对生产方式和企业组织的对立统一的关注上。通过对分工发育过程的历史流变的观察,发现分工始终是在不断平衡专业化和交易两者的矛盾中螺旋式演进。这不仅验证了前面的理论判断,而且从中挖掘出“空间”的意义,即随着分工的细化,空间的重要性逐渐凸现出来。由此从分工过渡到劳动空间分工,根据劳动过程的空间分离与否,将劳动空间分工划分为部门空间分工和产品内空间分工两个发展阶段。而在全球化和信息化的时代背景下,为追逐最大化分工经济的好处,不同的劳动过程在全球尺度中不断进行空间集聚和扩散,从而产生各种劳动空间分工现象。在上述过程中,由于内生比较优势和规模经济的存在,空间逐渐成为一种生产资料。因此,劳动空间分工就是分工演进的产物,体现了分工发育的较高阶段。本章的最后,将劳动过程和空间因素整合,
The forming and subsequent development of metropolitan regions represents an important trend of the world urbanization in the 21~(st) century. This dissertation theorizes the spatial process of division of labor. The author analyzes the economic activities in metropolitan regions to demonstrate and explain the theme of spatial organization, which focuses on the discussion of the process and mechanism rather than the description of phenomenon. The dissertation will hopefully promote the study and research on the basic theory of metropolitan regions and, thus, shed light on planning and management of the metropolitan regions.The dissertation consists of two parts and total 7 chapters. The first part is composed of three chapters, aimed at digging out the meaning of space through the discussion of division of labor in economics as well as reestablishing a theoretical base of SDL. The second part includes four chapters, which utilize SDL to study spatial organization of metropolitan regions and for the purpose of verification, include an experiential study of the Shanghai Metropolitan Area.Chapter One: Introduction. Firstly, the objective and basis for the selection of the theme will be demonstrated. The author emphasizes that SDL, as a tool for middle-scale theoretical analysis, can well connect urban economics and plutonomy, and better analyze spatial organization of metropolitan regions. Secondly, the author systematically restates the theories on SDL home and abroad, concluding the theories in the west as two loca, domestic and international, regional uneven development, Marxist plutonomy, new institutional economics, and world economics, putting forward that SDL is the product of location theory under the influence of human geography paradigm, pointing out the weak points in the study and research home and aboard, and the pressure of reestablishing the theoretical framework. Lastly, the author presents the structure and methodology of the current study and research.Chapter Two: The development of the theory's spectrum of division of labor. The author will focus on the core concept of division of labor, discussing the history of development of division of labor by studying classical economics of Adam Smith, Marxist plutonomy, international trade theory, neoclassical economics, and new international economics in a uniform framework. Further, the author will give an overall commentary on the relevant study and research, presenting a clear locus of evolution of the theory of division of labor.Chapter Three: SDL: Transformation from economics to human geography. On the basis of the discussion of the above chapter, the author will restate and reorganize the concept of labor division, proposing that labor division is the combination of specialization and transaction, so as to establish the basic framework of economics of labor division. Then the perspective will shift to the contradictory unification of mode of production and organization of enterprises. By observing the historical change of labor division development, the author finds that labor division is always the evolution based on the balance between specialization and transaction, which does not only coincide with the foregoing theoretical judgment, but digs out the meaning of space, namely, along with the process of specialization of labor division, the importance of space becomes higher. Thereby, labor division shifts to SDL. According to whether there is spatial division of the labor process or not, SDL can be divided into inter-industry SDL and intra-product SDL, as two development phases. Under the background of globalization and informationalization, for the pursuit of maximized economic benefit of labor division, different labor processes will have spatial agglomeration and dispersion in a global scale, resulting in
    varieties of phenomena of SDL. During the above described process, because of the existence of the endogenous comparative advantage and economies of scale, space generally becomes a sort of productive material. Thus, SDL is the product of the evolut
引文
波特著[1990],李明轩、邱如美译(2002).国家竞争优势.北京:华夏出版社.
    蔡来兴等编著(1995).国际经济中心城市的崛起.上海:上海人民出版社.
    陈秉钊编著(1991).城市规划系统工程学.上海:同济大学出版社.
    陈顺清(2000).城市增长与土地增值.北京:科学出版社.
    成德宁(2004).城市化与经济发展——理论、模式与政策.北京:科学出版社,
    崔功豪(2001).都市区规划——地域空间规划的新趋势.国外城市规划,(5):1.
    黄建富(2003).城市发展中的交易成本研究.上海:东华大学出版社.
    敬东、谢杰雄(1999).交易成本理论对城市及区域规划的影响——评艾伦。斯科特的“新工业区位论”.现代城市研究,(3):33-36.
    库恩著[1962],李宝恒、纪树立译(1980).科学革命的结构.上海:上海科技出版社.
    拉兹洛著[1972],钱兆化等译(1998).系统哲学引论——一种当代思想的新范式.北京:商务印书馆.
    梁志坚(1994).交易成本理论在城市与区域研究中的应用.城市问题,(6):7-9.
    卢锋(2004).产品内分工.经济学(季刊),4(1):55—82.
    马克思[1859].《政治经济学批判》序言.见马克思、恩格斯著,中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局编译(1972).马克思恩格斯选集(第二卷).北京:人民出版社.pp81-85.
    茅于轼(1985).分工、交换和生产力布局.见李旭旦编(1985).人文地理学论丛.北京:人民教育出版社.pp58-63.
    孟庆民、李国平(2000).新国际劳动分工研究动态.世界地理研究,9(2):31-37.
    孟庆民、李国平、杨开忠(2000).新国际分工的动态:概念与机制.中国软科学,(9):112-116.
    苗长虹、樊杰、张文忠(2002).西方经济地理学区域研究的新视角——论“新区域主义”的兴起.经济地理,22(6):644-650.
    闵家胤(1999).社会系统论.见闵家胤著(1999).进化的多元论——系统哲学的新体系.北京:中国科学出版社.pp316-364.
    宁越敏(1991).新的国际劳动分工、世界城市和我国中心城市的发展.城市问题,(3):2-7.
    宁越敏(1995a).从劳动分工到城市形态——评艾伦·斯科特的区位论(一).城市问题,(2):18-21.
    宁越敏(1995b).从劳动分王到城市形态——评艾伦·斯科特的区位论(二).城市问题,(3):14-16.
    宁越敏(2003).国外大都市区规划体系评述.世界地理研究,12(1):36-43.
    宁越敏(2004).外商直接投资对上海经济发展影响的分析.经济地理,24(3):313-317.
    乔继明、宁越敏(1992).试论西方国家劳动空间分工理论的发展.世界地理研究,1(1):38-44.
    盛洪(1992).分工与交易——一个一般理论及其对中国非专业化问题的应用分析.上海:上海三联书店.
    陶松龄、刘阳恒(1997).城市发展动力与可持续发展.城市,(2):3-8.
    汪斌、董赞(2005).从古典到新兴古典经济学的专业化分工理论与当代产业集群的演进,学术月刊,(2):29-36.
    谢守红、宁越敏(2003).城市化与郊区化:转型期都市空间变化的引擎.城市规划,27(11):24-29.
    许学强、周春山(1994).论珠江三角洲大都会区的形成.城市问题,(3):3-6.
    许学强、周一星、宁越敏编著(1997).城市地理学.北京:高等教育出版社
    叶舜赞(1994).大城市和国际城市集聚和扩散机制的探讨.城市问题,(4):6-10
    周维颖(2004).新产业区演进的经济分析.上海:复旦大学出版社.
    Bade,F.(1986).Berlin and the Spatial Division of Labour within the FRG. In Ewers,H. et al. eds.(1986).The Future of the Metropolis:Berlin-London-Paris-New York.Berlin:Walter de Gruyter.pp201-219.
    Bagchi-Sen, S. and Pigozzi,B.W.(1993).Occupational and Industrial Diversification in the United States:Implications of the New Spatial Division of Labor. Professional Geographer, 45(1):44-54.
    Caporaso,J.A.(1987).The International Division of Labour. In Caporaso,J.A. eds.(1987).A Changing International Division of Labor. Boulder:Lynne Rienner Publishers.pp 1-41.
    Chapman, K. and Walker, D. F.(1991).Industrial Location(2nd Edition). Massachusetts: Basil Blackwell.
    Clark, G.L.(1981).The Employment Relation and the Spatial Division of labor, A Hypothesis. Annals Association of American Geographers, 71 (3):412-424.
    Gauthier, H.L. and Taaffe, E.J.(2000).Three 20th century "Revolutions" in American geography. Urban geography, 23(6):503-527.
    Cohen,R.(1981).The New International Division of Labour, Multinationa Corporations and Urban Hierarchy, in Dear, M. and Scott, A. eds.(1981).Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society. London :Methuen.pp287-315.
    Dicken,P.(2003). Global Shift : Reshaping the Global Economic Map in the 21st Century(4th Edition). London:Sage.
    Dicken, P. and Lloyd, P.E.(1990). Location in Space: Theoretical Perspectives in Economic Geography. New York: Harper & Row.
    Ettlinger, N. and Clay, B.(1991).Spatial Divisions of Corporate Services Occupations in the United States, 1983-1988. Growth & Change, 22(1):36-53.
    Fafchamps, M. and Shilpi, F.(2003). The Spatial Division of Labour in Nepal. Journal of Development Studies, 39(6):23-66.
    Frobel,F. et al,(1980).The New International Division of Labor. Cambridge :Cambridge University Press.
    Hayter, R.(1997). The Dynamics of Industrial Location. Chichester:John Wiley & Sons.
    Heim,C.E.(1987).R & D, Defense, and Spatial Divisions of Labor in Twentieth-Century Britain.Journal of Economic History,47(2):365-378.
    Herod,A.(1997).From a Geography of Labor to a Labor Geography:Labor's Spatial Fix and the Geography of Capitalism.Antipode,29(1): 1-31.
    Higgott,R.(1987).The Dilemmas of Interdependence: Australia and the International Division of Labor in the Asia-Pacific Region. In Caporaso,J.A. eds.(1987).A Changing International Division of Labor.Boulder:Lyrme Rienner Publishers.pp 123-145.
    Hitz, H. and Schmid,C.(1994). Urbanization in Zurich: Headquarter economy and city-belt.Environment & Planning D: Society & Space, 12(2): 167-185.
    Knox, P.L.(1995).Urban Social Geography:An Introduction. Harlow: Longman Scientific & Technical.
    Lee,R.(2000a). New International Division of Labour. In R.J.Johnston et al. eds.(2000). The Dictionary of Human Geography(4th Edition). Oxford :Blackwell.pp552-554.
    Lee,R. (2000b) .Superstructure. In Johnston,R.J. et al. eds.(2000). The Dictionary of Human Geography(4th Edition). Oxford :Blackwell.pp807-809.
    Lovering,J.(1990).Fordism's Unkonwn Sueeessor:A Comment on Scott's Theory of Flexible Accumulation and the Re-emergence of Regional Economies.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 14(2): 159-174.
    Lovering,J.(1991).Theorizing Postfordism:Why Contingency Matters(A Further Response to Scott). International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 15(2):298-301.
    Massey, D.(1979). In what sense a regional problem? Regional Studies, 13:233-243.
    Massey, D.(1984).Spatial Divisions of Labour: Social Structures and the Geography of Production. London: Macuillan.
    Massey, D.(1988). Uneven Development: Social Change and Spatial Division of Labour, in Massey, D. and Allen,J. eds.(1988). Uneven Re-Development: Cities and Regions in Transition. London: Hodder and Stoughton.pp250-276.
    Massey, D.(1999).Spaces of Politics. In Massey, D.,Allen,J. and Sarre, P.eds.(1999). Human Geography Today. Cambridge :Polity Press.pp279-294.
    Massey, D. and Meegan,R.(1989).Spatial Division of Labour in Britain. In Gregory, D. and Walford,R. eds.(1989 ).Horizons in Human Geography.Houndmills:Macmillan.pp244-257.
    Oinas, P. and Malecki, E.J.(2002).The Evolution of Technologies in Time and Space: National and Regional to Spatial Innovation Systems. International Regional Science Review,25(1): 102-131.
    Park, S.O.(1993).Industrial Restructuring and the Spatial Division of Labor: The Case of the Seoul Metropolitan. Environment & Planning A,25(1):81-93.
    Peck, J (2000).Places of Work. In Sheppard,E. and Barnes,T.J. eds.(2000). A Companion to Economic Geography Oxford:Blackwell.pp 133-148.
    Scott, A.J.(1981).The Spatial Sturcture of Metropolitan Labour Markets and the Theory of Intra-urban Plant Location. Urban Geography,2(1): 1-30.
    Scott,A.J.(1982a).Location Patterns and Dynamics of Industrial Activity in the Modem Metropolis. Urban Studies, 19(1):111-142.
    Scott,A.J.(1982b).Production System Dynamics and Metropolitan Development. Annals Association of American Geographers,72(2): 185-200.
    Scott,A.J.(1983a).Industrial Organization and the Logic of Intra-Metropolitan Location: I.Theoretical Considerations. Economic Geography,59(3):233-249.
    Scott, A.J.(1983b).Industrial Organization and the Logic of Intra-Metropolitan Location: Ⅱ.A Case Study of the Printed Circuits in Industry in the Greater Los Angeles Region. Economic Geography, 59(4):343-367.
    Scott,A.J.(1986a). Industrialization and Urbanization:A Geographical Agenda. Annals Association of American Geographers, 76(1):25-37.
    Scott, A.J.(1986b).Industrial Organization and Location: Division of Labor, the Firm, and Spatial Process. Economic Geography,62(3):215-231.
    Scott,A.J.(1988a). Metropolis:From the Division of Labor to Urban Form. London: Pion Limited.
    Scott,A.J.(1988b).New Industrial Spaces: Flexible Production Organization and Regional Development in North America and Western Europe. London: Pion Limited.
    Scott,A.J.(1998). Regions and the World Economy." The Coming Shape of Global Production, Competition, and Political Order Oxford:Oxford University Press.
    Skak, M.(1987).The International Division of Labour and East-South Relations. In Caporaso,J.A. eds.(1987).A Changing International Division of Labor. Boulder:Lynne Rienner Publishers: 123-145.
    Storper, M.(1997). The Regional World." Territorial Development in a Global Economy. New York: The Guilford Press.
    Storper, M. and Walker, R.(1983).The Theory of Labor and the Theory of Location.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 7(1): 1-41.
    Storper, M. and Walker, R.(1984).The Spatial Division of Labour:Labour and the Location of Industries, in Sawers, L. and Tabb, W. eds. (1984),Sunbelt/Snowbelt: Urban Development and Regional Resructuring. Oxford: Oxford University Press.pp 19-47.
    Stohr, W.B.(1987).Regional Economic Development and the World Economic Crisis. International Social Science Journal,39(2): 187-197.
    Tsui-Auch, L.S.(1999). Regional Production Relationships and Developmental Impacts: A Comparative Study of Three Production Networks. International Journal of Urban & Regional Research,23(2):345-359.
    Walker, R.(1985). Class,Dibision of Labour and Employment in Space. In Gregory, D. and Urry, J. eds.(1985). Social Relations and Spatial Structures.London:Macmillan.pp 164-189.
    Walker, R.(1988).The Geographical Organization of Production-Systems. Environment and Planning D: Society & Space,6:377-408.
    Walker, R.(2000). The Geography of Production. In Sheppard,E. and Barnes,T. J. eds.(2000)A Companion to Economic Geography. Oxford: Blackwell.pp113-132.
    Walker, R. and Storper, M. (1981).Capital and Industrial Location. Progress in Human Geography, 5(4):473-509.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700