摘要
近年来,音频处理技术的飞速发展和因特网的迅速普及使得数字音频作品的获取、编辑和发布变得十分容易。音频作品的知识产权保护已成为一个急待解决的问题。数字音频水印技术作为一种潜在的解决方案受到了国内外研究者的广泛关注,并成为国际学术界的研究热点。本文对数字音频水印中的关键技术,包括零水印技术、多重水印技术以及多目的水印技术,进行了深入的研究,主要工作体现在以下几个方面。
(1)由于人类听觉系统十分敏感,要实现音频水印系统中鲁棒性和透明性之间的平衡十分困难。为了从原理上解决这一难题,对“音频零水印”技术进行了研究。首先,利用自然语音信号的短时平稳特性,提出了一种基于线性预测系数矢量量化的语音零水印算法。该算法实现了良好的检测可靠性和鲁棒性。然后,结合离散小波变换的多分辨率分析特性、离散余弦变换的能量压缩特性以及高阶累积量的高斯噪声抑制特性,提出了一种音频零水印算法。该算法对各类噪声干扰、信号处理操作和恶意攻击均表现出了很强的鲁棒性。最后,基于音频信号的高频特性设计了一种半脆弱零水印算法。该算法成功的将数字签名技术和传统半脆弱水印技术在内容完整性验证中的优势统一起来。实验结果表明该算法实现了良好的半脆弱性、检测可靠性和篡改定位特性。
(2)首先,提出了基于功率倒谱自相关的回声检测算法,并给出了算法的数学证明。借助于自相关函数的周期不变性和随机噪声抑制特性,该算法取得了较传统算法更高的回声检测率和鲁棒性。然后,考虑到回声隐藏具有隐藏算法简单、隐藏效果好、对同步要求不高、鲁棒性强以及可盲提取的优点,设计了一种基于回声隐藏的多重水印算法,并实现了多重水印的盲提取。实验结果表明该算法对各类信号处理操作和恶意攻击具有很强的鲁棒性。
(3)为了解决音频多目的水印系统中的透明性问题、不同性质水印间的相互干扰问题、以及不同性质水印的独立盲提取问题,提出了基于“零水印”的概念设计鲁棒水印算法,同时利用盲信号分离系统中的瞬时混合模型将脆弱水印嵌入到原始音频信号的高频成分中的多目的水印算法设计思路。并基于该思路先后提出了基于低频混合域系数矢量量化和独立分量分析的算法以及基于离散小波变换和主分量分析的算法。实验结果表明这两种算法取得了较其他多目的水印算法更高的透明性,同时实现了良好的鲁棒性、检测可靠性以及篡改定位特性。
(4)为了真正实现网络数字音频作品的版权保护和盗版跟踪,对数字音频水印应用系统进行了研究。首先,提出了一种基于低频混合域系数两级矢量量化的多重水印方案,采用完全不同的方法将两个水印分别嵌入到原始音频信号低频混合域系数的第一级矢量量化和第二级矢量量化的索引值中。然后,基于该多重水印方案,并结合基于数字水印技术的买卖协议,提出了一个网络数字音频作品版权保护和盗版跟踪模型。该模型采用多重水印方案将标识作品版权的数字水印和标识购买者身份的数字指纹同时嵌入到数字作品中。在发现可疑盗版作品时可通过提取水印对侵权行为进行认定并对版权纠纷进行调节。
论文最后对全文的研究工作进行了总结,并对将来可以进一步研究的领域进行了展望。
In recent years,the fast development of digital audio processing technology and the popularization of Internet make it dead easy for people to access,edit and distribute digital audio works.The copyright protection of digital audio works becomes a burning question.As a potential solution,digital audio watermarking technology is paid extensive attention by researchers at home and abroad and becomes an international academic focus.In this paper,an intensive study is made of the key technologies,including zero watermarking,multiple watermarking and multipurpose watermarking,in digital audio watermarking system.The main contributions of this dissertation are as follows:
(1) Since the human auditory system is extremely sensitive,it is very hard to achieve the balance between the robustness and transparency in audio watermarking system.To solve this difficult problem in theory,a study is made of the audio zero watermarking technique.First,in view of the transient steady property of natural speech signal,a speech zero watermarking algorithm based on the vector quantization of linear prediction coefficients is proposed.This algorithm achieves good detection reliability and robustness.Then,an audio zero watermarking scheme based on the combination of the multi-resolution analysis property of discrete wavelet transform,the energy compression property of discrete cosine transform and the Gaussian noise suppression property of higher-order cumulant is proposed.This algorithm has great robustness against all kinds of noise interference,signal processing manipulations and malicious attacks.Finally,a semi-fragile zero watermarking algorithm is designed based on the high frequency property of audio signal.This algorithm successfully combines the vantages of digital signature technology with the vantages of traditional semi-fragile watermarking technology in the integrity verification.Experimental results demonstrate that this algorithm achieves good semi-fragility,detection reliability and tampering localization property.
(2) First,an echo detection algorithm based on the autocorrelation of power cepstrum is proposed and proved mathematically.Thanks to period invariability and random noise suppression property of autocorrelation function,this algorithm achieves higher echo detection rate and greater robustness than traditional algorithms.Then,in view of the merits of echo hiding technique of simple algorithm,good transparency,undemanding synchronizing,great robustness and blind extraction,a multiple watermarking scheme based on echo hiding is designed and blind extraction of multiple watermarks is also achieved.Experimental results demonstrate this scheme has great robustness against various signal processing manipulations and malicious attacks.
(3) To achieve the transparency,avoid the mutual interference between watermarks of different properties and realize the independent and blind extraction of watermarks of different properties in audio multipurpose watermarking system,a new design idea that generates the robust watermark based on "zero watermarking" idea and utilizes the instantaneous mixing model in blind source separation system to embed the fragile watermark in the high-frequency components of of original audio signal is proposed.And,based on this design idea,a multipurpose watermarking scheme based on the vector quantization of low-frequency components of dual-transformation domain and independent component analysis and another scheme based on discrete wavelet transform and principal component analysis are proposed,respectively.Experimental results demonstrate that these two schemes achieve better transparency than other audio multipurpose watermarking schemes.They also achieve good robustness, detection reliability and tampering localization property.
(4) To realize the copyright protection and pirate tracking of digital audio works in network,a study is made of the application system of digital audio watermarking.First,a multiple watermarking scheme based on two-stage vector quantization of low-frequency coefficients of dual-transformation domain is put forward.Different methods are utilized to embed two watermarks in the indices of the first stage and the second stage vector quantization of the low-frequency coefficients of dual-transformation domain of original audio signal,respectively.Then,a copyright protection and pirate tracking model based on the proposed multiple watermarking scheme and the buyer-seller watermarking protocol is designed.In the proposed model,the multiple watermarking scheme is utilized to embed the copyright watermark for identifying the copyright owner and the digital fingerprint for identifying the buyer in the digital works,simultaneously.Once a piratical work appears, the watermarks are extracted to identify the copyright violator and to resolve the copyright dispute.
At last,the main contributions of this dissertation are summed up and the research areas worthy further studying are summarized.
引文
[1]李伟,袁群,李晓强,等,数字音频水印技术综述,通信学报,26(2):100-111.
[2]Cvejic N.,Seppanen T.,Increasing the capacity of LSB-based audio steganography,In Proceedings of 2002 IEEE Workshop on Multimedia Signal Processing,2002,336-338.
[3]Cvejic N.,Seppanen T.,Increasing robustness of LSB audio steganography using a novel embedding method,In Proceedings of International Conference on Information Technology:Coding and Computing,2004,2:533-537.
[4]Cvejic N.,Seppanen T.,A novel scheme for merging digital audio watermarking and authentication,In Proceedings of IEEE 6th Workshop on Multimedia Signal Processing,2004,151-154.
[5]Yin X.,Zhang X.M.,Covert communication audio watermarking algorithm based on LSB,In Proceedings of International Conference on Communication Technology,2006,1-4.
[6]Say Wei Foo,Theng Hee Yeo,Dong Yan Huang,An adaptive audio watermarking system,In Proceedings of IEEE Region 10 International Conference on Electrical and Electronic Technology,2001,2:509-513.
[7]Huang D.Y,Yeo T.Y,Robust and inaudible multi-echo audio watermarking,In Proceedings of the Third IEEE Pacific Rim Conference on Multimedia:Advances in Multimedia Information Processsing,2002,615-622.
[8]Byeong-Seob Ko,Nishimura R.,Suzuki Y,Time-spread echo method for digital audio watermarking using PN sequences,In Proceedings IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing (ICASSP '02),2002,2:2001-2004.
[9]Tolga Ciloglu,S.Utku Karaaslan,An improved all-pass watermarking scheme for speech and audio,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Multimedia and Expo,2000,2:1017-1020.
[10]Tilki J.F.,Beex A.A.,Encoding a hidden auxiliary channel onto a digital audio signal using psychoacoustic masking,In Proceedings of IEEE Southeastcon'97,'Engineering new New Century',1997,331-333.
[11]Litao Gang,Akansu A.N.,Ramkumar M.,MP3 resistant oblivious steganography,In Proceedings of 2001 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,2001,3:1365-1368.
[12]Shyh-shiaw Kuo,Johnston J.D.,Turin W,etc.,Covert audio watermarking using perceptually tuned signal independent multiband phase modulation,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,2002,2:1753-1756.
[13]Cox I.J.,Kilian J.,Leighton F.T,etc.,Secure spread spectrum watermarking for multimedia,IEEE Transactions on Image Processing,1997,6(12):1673-1687.
[14]Kirovski D.,Malvar,H.,Spread-spectrum watermarking of audio signals.IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing,2003,51(4),1020-1033.
[15]Cvejic N.,Keskinarkaus A.,Seppanen T.,Audio watermarking using m-sequences and temporal masking.In Proceedings of IEEE Workshop on Applications of Signal Processing to Audio and Acoustics,2001,227-230.
[16]Lceda M.,Takeda K.,Itakura,E,Audio data hiding by use of band-limited random sequences,In Proceedings of 1999 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,1999,4:2315-2318.
[17]Seok J.W.,Hong J.W.,Audio watermarking for copyright protection of digital audio data,Electronics Letters,2001,37(1):60-61.
[18]Li X.,Yu H.H,Transparent and robust audio data hiding in subband domain,In Proceedings of International Conference on Information Technology:Coding and Computing,2000,74-79.
[19]Tachibana R.,Shimizu S.,Kobayashi S.,etc.,An audio watermarking method using a two-dimensional pseudo-random array,Signal Processing,2002,82(10):1455-1469.
[20]Cheng S.,Yu H.,Xiong Z.X.,Enhanced spread spectrum watermarking of MPEG-2 AAC,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,2002,4:Ⅳ-3728-Ⅳ-3731.
[21]Yeo I.K.,Kim H.J.,Modified patchwork algorithm:A novel audio watermarking scheme,IEEE Transactions on Speech and Audio Processing,2003,11(4):381-386.
[22]Cvejic N.,Seppanen T,Robust audio watermarking in wavelet domain using frequency hopping and patchwork method,In Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium on Image and Signal Processing and Analysis,2003,1:251-255.
[23]Wang R.D.,Li Q.,Yan D.Q.,A high robust audio watermarking algorithm,In Proceedings of The Sixth World Congress on Intelligent Control and Automation,2006,1:4171-4174.
[24]Hyunho K.,Koutarou Y,Brian K.,etc.,Psychoacoustically-adapted patchwork algorithm for watermarking,In Proceedings of Third International Conference on Intelligent Information Hiding and Multimedia Signal Processing,2007,2:267-270.
[25]Cvejic N.,Tujkovic I.,Increasing robustness of patchwork audio watermarking algorithm using attack characterization,In Proceedings of 2004 IEEE International Symposium on Consumer Electronics,3-6.
[26]Xu C,Wu J.,Sun Q.,Robust digital audio watermarking technique,In Proceedings of the International Symposium on Signal Processing and Its Applications,1999,95-98.
[27]Lemma A.N.,Aprea J.,Oomen W,etc.,A temporal domain audio watermarking technique,IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing,2003,51(4):1088-1097.
[28]Kaabneh K.A.,Youssef A.,Muteness-based audio watermarking technique,In Proceedings of the International Conference on Distributed Computing Systems,2001,379-383.
[29]Huijuan Yang,Patra J.C.,Chan C.W,An artificial neural network-based scheme for robust watermarking of audio signals,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,2002,1:1-1029-1-1032.
[30]Xu C,Feng D.,Robust and efficient content-based digital audio watermarking,Multimedia Systems,2002,8(5):353-368.
[31]Lie W.N.,Chang L.C.,Robust and high-quality time-domain audio watermarking subject to psychoacoustic masking,In Proceedings of 2001 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems,2001,2:45-48.
[32]Lin E.T.,Podilchuk C.I.,Delp E.J.,Detection of image alterations using semi-fragile watermarks,SPIE,2000,3971:152-163.
[33]Yu G.J.,Lu C.S.,Mark Liao H.Y.,etc.,Mean quantization blind watermarking for image authentication,In Proceedings of International Conference on Image Processing,2000,3:706-709.
[34]Rey C.,Dugelay J.L.,Blind detection of malicious alterations on still image using robust watermarks,In Proceedings of IEE Seminar on Secure Image and Image Authentication,2000,7/1-7/6.
[35]杨长生,图象与声音压缩技术,浙江大学出版社,2000,(4):264-301.
[36]Li W.,Xue X.Y.,Lu,RZ.,Robust audio watermarking based on rhythm region detection,Electronics Letters,2005,41(4):218-219.
[37]Bassia R,Pitas I.,Nikolaidis N.,Robust audio watermarking in the time domain,IEEE Transactions on Multimedia,2001,3(2):232-241.
[38]Kirbiz S.,Gunsel B.,Robust audio watermark decoding by supervised learning,In Proceedings of 2006 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech and Signal Processing,2006,5:V-761-V-764.
[39]Pooyan M.,Delforouzi A.,Adaptive and robust audio watermarking in wavelet domain,In Proceedings of Third International Conference on Intelligent Information Hiding and Multimedia Signal Processing,2007,2:287-290.
[40]范满平,数字音频水印技术及其在广播系统中的应用,广播与电视技术,2007,9:24-28.
[41]Ohsawa T.,Karita M.,Automatic telecasting or radio broadcasting monitoring system,United States Patent,3760275,1973.
[42]Solar C.M.,Automatic monitor for programs broadcast,United States Patent,4025851,1977.
[43]Nakamura T.,Tachibana R.,Kobayashi S.,Automatic music monitoring and boundary detection for broadcast using audio watermarking,In Proceedings of SPIE Security and Watermarking of Multimedia Contents Ⅳ,2002,4675:170-180.
[44]王秋生,孙圣和,郑为民,数字音频信号的脆弱水印嵌入算法,计算机学报,2002,25(5):520-525.
[45]吴志军,钮心忻,杨义先,语音隐藏的研究及实现,通信学报,2002,23(8):99一104.
[46]李民政,基于信息隐藏的实时语音传输系统的研究,[硕士学位论文],广州,中山大学,2003.
[47]王向阳,多媒体信息处理技术原理,科学出版社,2005,272-273。
[48]汪小帆,戴跃伟,茅耀斌,信息隐藏技术一方法与应用,北京,机械工业出版社,2001.
[49]Lu C.S.,Multimedia Security:Steganography and Digital Watermarking Techniques for Protection of Intellectual Property,Idea Group Publishing,2005,78-79.
[50]牛夏牧,数字水印处理算法及测试研究,[博士学位论],哈尔滨,哈尔滨工业大学,2000.
[51]Wolfgang R.B.,Delp E.J.,A watermark for digital images,In Proceedings of International Conference on Images Processing,Lausanne,Switzerland,1996,3:219-222.
[52]Miller M.L.,Cox I.J.,Linnartz,J.M.G.,etc,A review of watermarking principles and practices,Digital Signal Processing for Multimedia Systems,Marcell Dekker,1999,461-485.
[53]Cox I.J.,Miller M.L.,Bloom J.A.,Watermarking applications and their properties,In Proceedings of International Conference on Information Technology:Coding and Computing,2000,6-10.
[54]Cox I.J.,Miller M.L.,Bloom J.A.著,王颖,黄志蓓等译,数字水印,北京,电子工业出版社.2003,17-23.
[55]Zwicker E.,Fastl H.,Hartmann W.M.,Psychoacoustics:Facts and models,Physics Today,2001,54(6):64-65.
[56]Gordy J.D.,Bruton L.T.,Performance evaluation of digital audio watermarking algorithms,In Proceedings of the 43rd IEEE Midwest Symposium on Circuits and Systems,2000,1:456-459.
[57]Petitcolas F.A.R,Anderson R.J.,Evaluation of copyright marking systems,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Multimedia Computing and Systems,1999,1:574-579.
[58]Petitcolas F.,Watermarking schemes evaluation,IEEE Signal Processing Magazine,2000,17(5):58-64.
[59]Steinebach M.,Petitcolas F.A.R,Raynal F.,Dittmann J.,etc.,StirMark benchmark:audio watermarking attacks,In Proc.Int.Conf.on Information Technology:Coding and Computing,2001,49-54.
[60]Wang L.X.,Yin C.,Pang J.,An audio watermark embedding algorithm based on mean-quantization in wavelet domain,In Proceedings of 8th International Conference on Electronic Measurement and Instruments(ICEMI '07),2007,2-423-2-425.
[61]Liu H.Y.,Zheng X.F.,Wang Y.,DWT-based audio watermarking resistant to desynchronization,In Proceedings of 7th IEEE International Conference on Computer and Information Technology (CIT 2007),2007,745-748.
[62]Wu S.Q.,Huang J.W.,Huang D.R.,etc.,Self-synchronized audio watermark in DWT domain,In Proceedings of the 2004 International Symposium on Circuits and Systems(ISCAS '04),2004,5:V-712-V-715.
[63]Wu Y.J.,Shimamoto S.,A study on DWT-based digital audio watermarking for mobile Ad Hoc network,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Sensor Networks,Ubiquitous,and Trustworthy Computing,2006,2:247-251.
[64]Tzanetakis G.,Essl G.,Cook R,Audio analysis using the discrete wavelet transform,In Proceedings of International Conferences on Acoustics and Music:Theory and Applications (AMTA 2001),Skiathos,Greece,2001.
[65]Ahmed N.,Natarajan T.Rao K.R.,Discrete cosine transform.IEEE Trans.Comput.,1974,90-93.
[66]符晓娟,杨完全,利用离散余弦变换的语音信号压缩方案,信息技术,2006,11:74-76.
[67]胡广书,数字信号处理-理论、算法与实现,清华大学出版社,2003,371—372.
[68]苟大举,苟平,周群彪,语音DCT变换的一种小波编码方法,四川大学学报:自然科学版,2004,12:1153—1157.
[69]Linde Y.,Buzo A.,Gray R.M.,An algorithm for vector quantizer design,IEEE Transactions on Communication,1980,28(1):84-95.
[70]Pan J.S.,Huang H.C.,Jain L.C.,Intelligent watermarking techniques,World Scientific Publishing Company,Incorporated,2004,166.
[71]马建仓,牛奕龙,陈海洋,盲信号处理,国防工业出版社,2006,38-44.
[72]张贤达,保铮,盲信号分离,电子学报,2001,29(12A):1766—1771.
[73]Comon R,Independent component analysis,a new concept? Signal Processing,1994,36(3):287-314.
[74]Bell A.J.,Sejnowski T.J.,An information-maximization approach to blind separation and blind convolution,Neural Computation,1995,7:1129-1159.
[75]Karhunen J.,Joutsensalo J.,Representation and separation of signal using nonlinear PCA type learning,Neural Networks,1994,7(1):113 - 127.
[76]Cichocki A.,Unbehauen R.,Moszczynski R.,etc.,A new on-line adaptive learning algorithm for blind separation of source signals,In Proceedings of International Symposium on Neural Networks,Netherlands,Holland,1994,406-411.
[77]Cardoso J.F.,Laheld B.,Equivariant adaptive source separation,IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing,1996,44(45):3017-3020.
[78]Hyv(a|¨)rinen A.,Fast and robust fixed-point algorithms for independent component analysis,IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks,1999,10(3):626-634.
[79]邱天爽,张旭秀,李小兵等,统计信号处理-非高斯信号处理及其应用,电子工业出版社.北京,2004,76—83.
[80]Swanson M.D.,Zhu B.,Tewfik A.H.,etc.,Robust audio watermarking using perceptual masking,Signal Processing,1998,66(3):337-355.
[81]Herkiloglu K.,Yaslan Y.,Sener S.,etc.,Robust audio watermarking by adaptive psychoacoustic masking,In Proceedings of the IEEE 12th Signal Processing and Communications Applications Conference,2004,29-32.
[82]Quan X.M.,Zhang H.B.,Audio watermarking for copyright protection based on psychoacoustic model and adaptive wavelet packet decomposition,In Proceedings of 2004 International Symposium on Intelligent Multimedia,Video and Speech Processing,2004,282-285
[83]Ratanasanya S.,Poomdaeng S.,Tachphetpiboon S.,etc.,New psychoacoustic models for wavelet based audio watermarking,In Proceedings of IEEE International Symposium on Communications and Information Technology,2005,1:602-605.
[84]Xu C.S.,Wu J.K.,Sun Q.B.,etc.,Applications of digital watermarking technology in audio signals,Journal of the Audio Engineering Society,1999,47(10):805-811.
[85]温泉,孙锬锋,王树勋,基于零水印的数字水印技术研究,见全国第三届信息隐藏学术研讨会论文集,西安电子科技大学出版社,2001.
[86]谢贤智,基于时间戳认证的零水印方案研究,微计算机信息,2007,23(18):289-310.
[87]Chang C.C.,Hwang K.F.,Hwang M.S.,A block based digital watermarks for copy protection of images,In Proceedings of the 5th Asia-Pacific Conference on Communications,Beijing,China,1999,2:977-980.
[88]Hu Y.F.,Zhu S.A.,Zhang D.W.,A novel zero-watermark algorithm in image subspace domain,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Control and Automation,2007,2744-2748.
[89]Huang H.C.,Wang F.H.,and Pan J.S.,Efficient and robust watermarking algorithm with vector quantisation,Electronics Letters,2001,37(13):826-828.
[90]Charalampidis D.,Improved robust VQ-based watermarking,Electronics Letters,2005,41(23):1272-1273.
[91]Sang J.,Liao X.F.,Alam M.S.,Neural-network-based zero-watermark scheme for digital images,Optical Engineering,2006,45(9):097006-1-097006-9.
[92]温泉,孙锬锋,王树勋,零水印的概念与应用,电子学报,2003,31(2):214-216.
[93]杨树国,李春霞,孙枫,孙尧,小波域内图象零水印技术的研究,中国图象图形学报,2003,8A(6):664-669.
[94]杨树国,李春霞,孙枫,孙尧,基于小波变换的零水印方案,计算机工程与应用,2003,29:128—130.
[95]张崇,于晓琳,刘建平,季称利,结合零水印的小波包图像水印方案,计算机工程与应用,2004,27:84-87.
[96]Cao H.Q.,Xiang H.,Li X.T.,etc.,A zero-watermarking algorithm based on DWT and chaotic modulation,In Proceedings of SPIE,2006,6247:624716-1-624716-9.
[97]Li J.,Liu F.L.,Double zero-watermarks scheme utilizing scale invariant feature transform and Log-Polar mapping,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Multimedia and Expo,2007,2118-2121.
[98]Zhong X.,Tang X.H.,Yuc H.L.,Zero-watermark scheme based on audio's statistical character,In Proceedings of 2007 International Symposium on Microwave,Antenna,Propagation and EMC Technologies for Wireless Communications,2007,1227-1230.
[99]季称利,杨晓元,张崇等,结合空域不变量的变换域零水印二次方案,计算机工程,2004,30(14):105-107.
[100]Lu Z.M.,Sun S.H.,Digital image watermarking technique based on vector quantization,Electronics Letters,2000,36(4):303-305.
[101]Jo M.,Kim H.D.,A digital image watermarking scheme based on vector quantization,IEICE Transactions on Information and Systems,2002,E85-D(6):1054-1056.
[102]Lu Z.M.,Pan J.S.,Sun S.H.,VQ-based digital image watermarking method,Electronics Letters,2000,36(14):1201-1202.
[103]Wu H.C.,Chang C.C.,A novel digital image watermarking scheme based on the vector quantization technique,2005,24(6):460-471.
[104]Pan J.S.,Sung M.T.,Huang H.C.,etc.,Robust VQ-based digital watermarking for memoryless binary symmetric channel,In Proceedings of the 2004 International Symposium on Circuits and Systems,2004,5:V-580-V583.
[105]Lu Z.M.,Xing W.,Xu D.G.,etc.,Digital image watermarking method based on vector quantization with labeled codewords,IEICE Trans.Inf.& Syst.,2003,E86-D(12):2786-2789.
[106]Lin Y.C.,Huang Z.K.,Pong R.T.,etc.,A robust watermarking scheme combined with the FSVQ for images,In Proceedings of Third International Conference on Information Technology and Applications,2005,2:597-602.
[107]Makur A.,Selvi S.S.,Variable dimension vector quantization based image watermarking,Signal Processing,2001,81(4):889-893.
[108]Wang F.H.,Pan J.S.,Jain L.C.,etc.,A VQ-based image-in-image data hiding scheme,In Proceedings of 2004 International Conference on Multimedia and Expo,2004,2191-2194.
[109]Huang H.C.,Wang F.H.,Pan J.S.,Efficient and robust watermarking algorithm with vector quantization,Electronics Letters,2001,37(13):826-828.
[110]Huang H.C.,Wang F.H.,Pan J.S.,A VQ-based robust multi-watermarking algorithm,IEICE Transactions on Fundamentals of Electronics,Communications and Computer Sciences,2002,E85-A(7):1719-1726.
[111]Lu Z.M.,Liu C.H.,Xu D.G.,etc.,Semi-fragile image watermarking method based on index constrained vector quantization,Electronics Letters,2003,39(1):35-36.
[112]Pan J.S.,Hsin Y.C.,Huang H.C.,etc.,Robust image watermarking based on multiple description vector quantization,Electronics Letters,2004,40(22):1409-1410.
[113]Chu S.C.,Hsin Y.C.,Huang H.C.,etc.,Multiple description watermarking for lossy network,In Proceedings of IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems,2005,4:3990-3993.
[114]Lu Z.M.,Sun Z.,An image watermarking method based on mean-removed vector quantization for multiple purposes,In Proceedings of IAPR Conference on Machine Vision Applications,2005,558-561.
[115]Shieh C.S.,Huang H.C.,Wang FH.etc.,An embedding algorithm for multiple watermarks,Journal of Information Science and Engineering,2003,19:381-395.
[116]Wang X.Y,Zhao H.,A novel synchronization invariant audio watermarking scheme based on DWT and DCT,IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing,2006,54(12):4835-4840.
[117]W Stallings,Cryptography and Network Security-Principles and Practices,3rd edition,Prentice Hall,2003.
[118]Bender W.,Gruhl D.,Morimoto N,etc.,Techniques for data hiding,IBM Systems Journal,1996,35(3&4):313-336.
[119]Gruhl D.,Lu A.,Bender W,Echo Hiding,In Proceedings of the First International Workshop on Information Hiding,1996,293-315.
[120]Oh H.-O.,Hyun Wook Kim,Jong Won Seok,etc.,Transparent and robust audio watermarking with a new echo embedding technique,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Multimedia and Expo,2001,317-320.
[121]Hyen O Oh,Jong Won Seok,Jin Woo Hong,etc.,New echo embedding technique for robust and imperceptible audio watermarking,In Proceedings of 2001 IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,2001,3:1341-1344.
[122]Hyoung Joong Kim,Yong Hee Choi,A novel echo-hiding scheme with backward and forward kernels,IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology,2003,13(8):885-889.
[123]江源源,现代信号处理理论和方法,上海:复旦大学出版社,2003,121-132.
[124]R.C.Kemerait,Signal Detection and Extraction by Cepstrum Techniques,IEEE Transactions on Information Theory,1972,18(6):745-759.
[125]华先胜,石青云,多类水印的同时嵌入,北京大学学报(自然科学版),2001,37(3):305-314.
[126]Lu C.S.,Mark Liao H.Y.,Multipurpose watermarking for image authentication and protection,IEEE Transactions on Image Processing,2001,10(10):1579-1592.
[127]Wang Z.F.,Yang B.,Niu X.M.,etc.,A practical multipurpose watermarking scheme for visual content copyright protection and authentication,In Proceedings of International Conference on Intelligent Information Hiding and Multimedia Signal Processing,2006,461-464.
[128]Xiong S.H.,Zhou J.L.,He K.,etc.,A multipurpose image watermarking method based on adaptive quantization of wavelet coefficients,In Proceedings of First International Multi-Symposiums on Computer and Computational Sciences,2006,1:294-297.
[129]Zhao Y.,Campisi P.,Kundur D.,Dual domain watermarking for authentication and compression of cultural heritage images,IEEE Transactions on Image Processing,2004,13(3):430-448.
[130]Lu C.S.,Hsu C.Y.,Content-dependent multipurpose watermarking resistant against generalized copy attack,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Multimedia and Expo,2004,3:2039-2042.
[131]Fan M.Q.,Wang H.X.,A novel multipurpose watermarking scheme for copyright protection and content authentication,In Proceedings of Second Workshop on Digital Media and its Application in Museum & Heritage,2007,19-24.
[132]Shefali S.,Deshpande S.M.,Moment invariants for digital image authentication and authorization,In Proceedings of International Conference on Control,Automation and Systems,2007,1296-1300.
[133]Zhuang L.,Jiang M.Y.,Multipurpose digital watermarking algorithm based on dual-tree CWT,In Proceedings of Sixth International Conference on Intelligent Systems Design and Applications,2006,2:316-320.
[134]Pan J.S.,Cheng C.S.,Liao B.Y.,etc.,Optimization of multi-purpose watermarking algorithm,In Proceedings of 2004 IEEE Asia-Pacific Conference on Circuits and Systems,2004,1:601-604.
[135]Sheppard N.P.,Safavi-Naini R.,Ogunbona P.,On multiple watermarking,in Proceedings of the 2001 workshop on Multimedia and security,2001,3-6.
[136]Wang F.H.,Yen K.K.,Jain L.C.,etc.,Multiuser-based shadow watermark extraction system,Information Sciences,2007,177(12):2522-2532.
[137]纪震,肖薇薇,王建华等,基于混沌序列的多重数字图像水印算法,计算机学报,2003,26(11):1555—1561.
[138]Wong P.H.W.,Au O.C.,Yeung Y.M.,A novel blind multiple watermarking technique for images,IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology,2003,13(8):813-830.
[139]Lu Z.M.,Xu D.G.,Sun S.H.,Multipurpose image watermarking algorithm based on multistage vector quantization,IEEE Transactions on Image Processing,2005,14(6):822-831.
[140]Lu C.S.,Mark Liao H.Y.,Chen L.H.,Multipurpose audio watermarking,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Pattern Recognition,Barcelona,Spain,2000,3:282-285.
[141]Wang R.D.,Xu D.W.,Li Q.,Multiple audio watermarks based on lifting wavelet transform,In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Machine Learning and Cybernetics,Guangzhou,China,2005:1959-1964.
[142]Takahashi A.,Nishimura R.,Suzuki Y.,Multiple watermarks for stereo audio signals using phase-modulation techniques,IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing,2005,53(2):806-815.
[143]丁小燕,基于盲源分离的数字音频水印技术研究,[学位论文],大连理工大学硕士论文,2006年12月.
[144]Mintzer F.,Braudaway G.W.,If one watermark is good,are more better? In Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,Speech,and Signal Processing,Phoenix,Arizona,1999,4:2067-2069.
[145]Juergen S.,Digital watermarking for digital media,Information Science Publishing,2005,55-56.
[146]Nasir Memon and Ping Wah Wong,A buyer-seller watermarking protocol,IEEE transactions on image processing,2001,10(4):643-649.