深水桥梁的地震响应研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
桥梁在朝着更大跨度发展的同时,出现越来越多的深水桥梁。目前为止,已建或在建的深水桥梁其桥墩入水深度最深已达168米。深水桥梁在地震作用下,桥墩自身的运动会引起周围水体的辐射波浪运动,而波浪运动也反过来影响桥墩的运动,这样桥梁结构的水下部分便产生了动水压力,而使桥梁的结构动力特性发生改变并影响结构的动力响应水平。从当前深水桥梁抗震研究的文献来看,国内外对深水桥梁的计算理论及地震响应特性的研究仍较少。
     本文在查阅大量国内外文献的基础上,评述了当前关于水与结构相互作用的计算理论、水中结构地震响应的分析方法及相关的研究成果,并针对深水桥梁在地震作用下的响应特性开展了以下几个方面详细研究:
     1.采用辐射波浪理论推导了圆形空心墩内域水体附加动水压力的计算解析式;采用相同理论,同时利用矩形截面的主轴与桥的纵轴和横轴相重合的特点,推导了矩形空心墩内、外水域的附加动水压力的计算解析式;采用流固耦合有限元分析的位移—压力格式(u—p)进行了有限元分析,对本文推导的附加动水压力的求解公式的计算精度进行了验证。结果表明,本文的解析式具有较高的精确度。
     2.将动水附加压力表达为动水附加质量和动水附加阻尼,在此基础上建立了深水桥梁在地震激励下的运动方程,并对其求解方法进行了研究。
     3.对圆形空心墩和矩形空心墩的动水附加质量沿墩高的分布规律进行了分析,研究了自由表面波、总淹没水深、桥墩几何尺度等因素对动水附加质量的影响:提出了临界水深的概念,并指出临界水深以上部分的动水附加质量成抛物线分布,临界水深以下的部分动水附加质量的分布与水深无关(大小保持不变);对于高频振动的结构自由表面波的影响可忽略;相同水深时几何尺度越大动水附加质量越大,桥墩形状是影响动水附加质量的重要因素;
     4.将上述研究成果与实际工程相结合,对大跨度深水连续刚构桥进行了地震响应时程分析,分析了深水连续刚构桥在纵向、横向地震作用下响应的特点。研究表明,墩—水耦合振动使主梁和桥墩的内力响应、位移响应大幅增加,是深水连续刚构桥地震响应分析中必须考虑的因素。对内、外墩水域附加质量和总淹没水深对桥墩地震响应的影响进行了分析,结果表明,内、外域水的影响必须同时计入,总淹没水深越深,墩—水耦合振动的不利影响越大;将本文方法的计算结果与欧洲规范、日本规范的计算结果进行了对比,指出欧洲规范对于总淹没水深较浅的桥梁其计算结果过于保守,而日本规范对于总淹没水深较深的桥梁,其计算结果偏于不安全。
Nowdays more and more deep-water bridges are built with the devolpment of larg span bridges to cross water areas, and the deepest underwater foundation of deep-water bridges constructed had reached 168m. Under the effect of the earthquake, hydrodynamic pressure of structures will be occurred because of the relative movement between a structure and water induced by radiation wave movement of fluid around the structure. The dynamic characteristics and the dynamic responses of the structures will be changed due to the effects of the hydrodynamic pressure. However, the effects of hydrodynamic pressure induced by the earthquake on the deep water structures, such as underwater foundation of large span bridges have received relatively little attention in exiting literaturea.
     In this dissertation, the dynamic responses of deep-water bridges under the earthquake are studied based on extensive analysis. The main achievements of this dissertation are as follows:
     1. Based on the radiation wave theory, an analytical solution of additional hydrodynamic pressure of inner liquid of circular hollow piers is deduced, and by using the characteristic the main axis of a retangle section is coincided with the longitudinal axis and lateral axis of the bridge, and an analytical solution of addditional hydronamic pressure induced by inner and outer waters of the retangle hollow piers is also given. Using displacement-pressure model (u-p) of fluid-solid coupling, the finit element analysis (FEA) is carried out, and comparing with the analytical solution, the accuracy of the semi-analytic approach of additioanl hydrodynamic mass in this dissertation is verified.
     2. In this dissertation, the hydrodynamic additional pressure is expressed as the hydrodynamic additional mass and the hydrodynamic additional damping. Moreover, a motion equation of deep-water bridges induced by earthquake is presented and its solution method is extensivly investigated.
     3. The distribution characteristics of hydrodynamics additional mass along the depth of circle hollow piers and retangle hollow piers are analyzed .The effect of free surface wave, whole depth of submerged water and geometry dimensions on hydrodynamic additional mass are studied and also summarized: a critical depth is found.The hydrodynamic additional mass distributes is a parabola when above the critical depth and the distribution of hydrodynamic additional mass is not effected by the water depth when below the depth. The effect caused by vibration of free-surface wave of structure at a high frequency can be ignored. The hydrodynamic additional mass will increase as the geometry dimensions increase if at the same depth. The shape of piers is the main factor which affects hydrodynamic additional mass.
     4. According to the preceding thoeries, a time-history analysis of the earthquake responses of long-span continuous rigid frame bridges is carried out and the characteristics of responses of continuous steel frame bridges in deep water under the effect of the longitudinal and lateral earthquake excitation are analyzed. It is indicated that the pier-water coupling vibration increases inner force responses and displacement responses of the main beam and piers, which should be considered in an analysis of earthquake response of continuous steel frame bridges in deep water. The effect of additional mass arising from waters inner and outer piers and whole depth of submerged water on the earthquake responses of piers is invesitigated, and the result shows that the effect of inner water and outer water should be considered. The disadvantages of pier-water coupling vibration increase as the whole depth increases of submerged water. Comparing the results with those calculated according to the Japanese and European criterion, it is found that the results calculated by the European criterion is much too conservative, such as the bridge whose whole depth of submerged water are relative fleet, and it is insecure while the results calculated by Japanese codes such as the bridges whose whole depth of submerged water are relative deep.
引文
[1]毕家驹.近海力学导论.上海同济大学出版社,1989
    [2]文圣常,余宙文,海浪理论与计算原理.北京:科学出版社,1984
    [3]居荣初,曾心传,弹性结构与液体的耦联振动理论,地震出版社,1983
    [4]O.C.律基威兹,R.W.路易斯,K.G.斯塔格,近海工程数值方法,海洋出版社,1984,大连工学院水利系,海洋工程研究所,译
    [5]公路工程抗震设计规范(JTJ004-89).北京:人民交通出版社,1999
    [6]道路桥示方书·同解说,V耐震设计编,平成14年3月,社团法人,日本道路协会
    [7]Eurocode 8—Design provisions for earthquake resistance of structures—Part 2:Bridges,European Committee for standardization,ENV 1998-2.
    [8]ATC-40:Seismic Evaluation and Retrofit of Concrete Buildings
    [9]Bureau of Indian Standards,Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structure (Part Ⅲ:Bridges and Retaining Walls),(Draft) 2005,IS:1893,NewDelhi.
    [10]《铁路桥梁耐震设计规定》,台湾地区,交通部中华民国九十四年十二月.
    [11]S.K.Thakkar,Sadaqat Ali,"A COMPARITIVE STUDY OF SEISMIC CODES FOR EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT DESIGN OF BRIDGES",Advances In Bridge Engineering,March 24-25,2006.
    [12]SEISMIC DESIGN CRITERIA·DECEMBER 2001 VERSION 1.2
    [13]赖伟,地震和波浪作用下深水桥梁的动力响应研究,上海:同济大学博士论文,2004
    [14]张宁勇,深水桥梁地震反应特性分析,上海:同济大学硕士学位论文,2002
    [15]P.W.Wemer,and K.J.Sundqist,"On Hydrodynamic Earthquake Effects"Transaction of the American Geophysical Union,vol.30.,No.5,636,657,1949
    [16]Westergaard H.M.,"Water pressures on dams during earthquakes",TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF CivilEngineers 98,1933,418-433.
    [17]H.Goto,K.Toki:Vibrational Characteristics and Aseismic Design of Sub-merged Bridge Piers,Proceedings of the Third World Conference on Earthquake Engineering,Vol.2,1965
    [18]上歧宪三,千冢昌信:在水中桥墩上起作用的动水压力的近似值,土木学会第20次年次学术演讲会演讲概要Ⅰ,1965年6月
    [19]项海帆,沿海高等级高速公路上的跨海大桥工程,同济大学学报,Vol.26,No.2,1998
    [20]谢瑞振,岑国基,超级工程的前期工作,中国土木工程学会桥梁级结构工程学会第十二届年会论 文集(上册),1996年11月,广州,3-15
    [21]唐寰澄,世界跨海工程的规划概况,中国土木工程学会桥梁级结构工程学会第十二届年会论文集(上册),1996年11月,广州,93-103
    [22]傅作新,水—坝相互作用的若干有效解法,华水科技情报,2(1985):1-10
    [23]傅作新,结构与水体的相互作用问题,水利水运科学研究,2(1982):105-119
    [24]戴大农,流固耦合系统动力分析的若干基本问题与数值分析方法,北京:清华大学博士学位论文,1988
    [25]王勖成,邵敏,有限单元法基本原理与数值方法(第二版),北京:清华大学出版社
    [26]李宏波,地震激励下储液容器的动力响应分析,北京,清华大学硕士学位论文,1999
    [27]王忠,库坝相互作用及抗震技术研究,成都:四川大学博士学位论文,2001
    [218]许建国,大型渡槽结构抗震分析方法及其应用,大连理工大学博士学位论文,2005
    [29]O.C.Zeinkiewicz and R.E.Newton,Coupled Vibrations of a Structure Submerged in a Compressible Fluid,in Proc.International Symposium on Finite Element Techniques,Ed.M.Sorensen Univ.of Stuttgart,W.Germany(1969)
    [30]D.K.Paul,O.C.Zienkiewicz and E.Hinton,Transient Dynamic Analysis of Reservion-Dam Interaction Using Staggered Solution Schemes,in Numerical Method for Coupled Problems,ED.E.Hionton,et al.,Pineridge Press,Swansea,U,K(1981)
    [31]D.Shantaran,D.R.J.Owen and O.C.Zienkiewicz,Dynamic Transient behviour of two and Three Dimensional Structure,Including Plasticuty.Large Deformation and Fluid Interaction,Earthq.Engng.Struct.Dyn.Vol.4,561-578(1976)
    [32]O.C.Zienkiewicz and P.Bettess,Fluid-Structure Dynamic Interaction and Wave Force.Introduction to Numerical Treatment,Int.J.Num.Meth.Engng.VOL.13,1-16(1978)
    [37]O.C.Zienkiewicz,The finite element method,McGRAW-HILL,1977
    [34]A.K.Chopra,E.L.Wilson and I.Farhoomand,Earthquake Analysis of Reservior- Dam System,Proc.4th Wld.Conf.Earthq.Engng,Santiago,Chile(1969)
    [35]Nitikitpaiboon C,bath K J,An Arbitrary Lagarangian-Eulerian velocity potential formulation for Fluid-structure interaction.Comput.&.Struct.,1993,47(4/5):871-891
    [36]Liu W.K and Chang H.G,"A method for fluid structure interaction",Computers and Structures,1985,20,311-320
    [37]Harn.C.C.and Robert.L.T.,"Vibration analysis of fluid-solid systems using finite element displacement formulation ",International Journal for Numerical Methods In Engineering,1990,29,683-698
    [38]Maheri M.R.and Khodaej-Nassaj M.R.,"Dynamic solution of 3-D structure-fluid system using a new lagrangian-based curvilinear fluid element",Dam engineering,1997,8,83-122
    [39]刘正兴,孙雁,谢守国.流体介质中结构的动力特性及响应分析.上海交通大学学报,1995,29(4),7-16
    [40]吴一红,谢省宗.水工结构流周耦合系统动力特性分析.水利学报,1995(1),27-34
    [41]戴大农,王勖成,杜庆华.流固耦合系统动力响应的模态分析理论.固体力学学报,1990,11(4),306-312
    [42]Black J.L.,Mei C.C.and Bray C.G,"Radiation and scatering of water waves by rigid bodies",J.Fluid Mech.,1 9 71,4 6,151-164
    [43]DanielW IT," Modal method infi nitee lementfl uid-structuree igenvaluep roblems",In ternationalJo urnal Fo rN um er ica IM eth odsln E ngineering,19 80,15(8),1161-1176
    [44]OlsonL.and B atheK.," Analysiso fluid-structure interaction.A directsy mmetricc oupledf ormulationbas ed o n th eft ui dv elocityp otential",C omputersan dS tructures,19 85,21,21 -32
    [45]戴大农,王勖成,杜庆华.流固祸合系统动力响应的模态分析理论.固体力学学报,1990,11(4),306-212
    [46]吴一红,谢省宗.水工结构流M合动力特性分析.水利学报,1995(1),27-
    [47]NilratF.,"H ydrodynamicp ressurea nda ddedm assfo ra xisymmetricb odies",R eportN o.E ERC80-12,Earthquake engineering research center,University of California,Berkeley,19 80
    [48]Liu W%,"Development of finite element procedures for fluid-structure interaction",Reprot No.EERL80-0 6,Earthquake engineering research laboratory,C alifomialn stituteo fTe chnology,P asadena,1980
    [49]Sharon S.K.,"Hydrodynamic loadings due to the motion of large offshore structures",Computers &Structure s,1989,32(6),12 11-121
    [50]杜建镔,旋转周期流固耦合系统动力分析的数值方法研究,北京:清华大学博士学位论文,1999
    [51]B.M.Irons,"Role of Part—Inversion in Fluid—Structure Problems with Mixed Variables",J.AIAA,VOL.8,568,1970.
    [52]T.Belytschko and R.Mllen,"Mesh Partition of Explicit-Implicit time Integration"in Formulation and Computatial Algorithms in Finite Element Analysis,Ed.K.J.Bathe etal,MIT Press(1977)
    [53]T.Belytschko and R.Mllen,"Stability of Explicit-Implicit Mesh Partition in time integration",Int.J.Num.Meth.Engng.,Vol,12,1575-1580,1978.
    [54]T.Belytschko,H.J.Yen and R.Mllen,"Mixed Methods for Time Integration",Comp.meth.Appl.Mech.Engng.,VOL.12,259-275(1979)
    [55]T.J.R.hughes and W.K.Liu,"Implicit Explicit Finite Element in Transient Analysis Stability Theory",J.Appl.Mech.Vol.45,371-374,1978
    [56]Landweber L.,"Vibration of a flexible cylinder in a fluid",J.Ship Res.,1967,11,143-150
    [57]王敏,曹国敖.土-平台沉箱基础-流体相互作用体系的动力反应分析.地震工程与工程振动,1989,9(3),30-37
    [58]Chopra A.K.,"Earthquake behaviour of reservoir-dam systems",J.Engng Mech.Div.,ASCE,1968,94,1475-1500
    [50]Liaw C.Y.and Chopra A.K.,"'Dynamics of towers surrounded by water",Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics,1974,3,33-49
    [60]钟明全,潘亦苏.考虑流体.结构交互作用的桥梁地震反应分析方法的研究进展.第一界全国公路科技创新高层论坛论文集,公路设计与施工卷,2001,671-675
    [61]钟明全,姚小松,潘亦苏.奉节长江公路大桥桥墩地震动水压力的分析研究.第一界全国公路科技创新高层论坛论文集,公路设计与施工卷,2001,561-567
    [62]王志培,何颖强,毕家驹.水中圆柱体地震分析.第四届全国近海工程学术讨论会,上海,1987
    [63]李世森,张伟,秦崇仁.大直径圆筒结构上波浪力的数值模拟与实验研究.中国港湾建设,2003,123(2),11-16
    [64]奚定平.贝塞尔函数.北京:高等教育出版社,1998
    [65]祁德庆.工程流体力学.上海:同济大学出版社,1996
    [66]Nilrat F.,"'Hydrodynamic pressure and added mass for axisymmetric bodies",Report No.EERC 80-12,Earthquake engineering research center,University of California,Berkeley,1980
    [67]王敏,曹国敖.土-平台沉箱基础-流体相互作用体系的动力反应分析.地震工程与工程振动,1989,9(3),30-37
    [68]曹国敖,多利.多自由度海洋结构随机地震响应的近似计算方法.地震工程与工程振动,1991,11(1),30-35
    [69]贾学敏.海岸高桩码头结构受地震和海浪荷载作用的近似计算.振动、测试与诊断,1993,13(1)
    [70]考虑结构—土相互作用的高桥墩和塔墩抗震分析.国家自然科学基金重大项目专题年度研究报告.同济大学土木工程防灾国家重点实验室,2000
    [71]Penzien J.and Kaul M.K.,"Response of Offshore Towers to Strong Motion Earthquakes",International Journal of Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics,1972,1(1),55-68.
    [72]Penzien J.,Kaul M.K.and Berge B.,"Stochastic response of offshore towers to random sea waves and strong motion earthquakes",Comput.Struct.,1972,2,733-756
    [73]Yamada Y.,lemura H.,Kawano K.and Venkataramana K.,"'Seismic response of offshore structures in random seas",Earthquake engineering and structural dynamics,1989,18,965-981
    [74]Venkataramana K.,et al.,"'Seismic Response of Offshore Structures in Random Seas",Proceedings of ninth World Conference on Earthquake Engineering,Tokyo-Kyoto,1988
    [75]Venkataramana,K.,et al.,"Dynamic Soil-structure interaction Effects on the Random Response of Offshore Platforms",Proceedings:8th Int.Conference Offshore Mech.Polar Engrg.,Netherlands,1989
    [76]Morison,J,R.,O'Brien,M,P,.Johnson,J.W.and Schaaf,S.A.,"The force exerted by surface wave on piles",Transaction of the American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical Engineers,VOL.189,p.149-154,1950
    [77]宫必宁.重力坝地震动水压力试验研究.河海大学学报,1997,25(1),98-102
    [78]张务德.作用在墩柱平台结构上的波浪力.科技通报,2001,17(4),53-59
    [79]Byrd R.C.,"A laboratory study of the fluid-structure interaction of submerged tanks and caissons in earthquake",Report No.UCB/EERC-78/08,Earthquake engineering research center,University of California,Berkeley,1978
    [80]哈勒姆,黑弗,伍顿.海洋建筑物动力学.北京:海洋出版社,1981
    [81]王福保.概率论及数理统计.上海:同济大学出版社,1984
    [82]Clough R.W.and Penzien J.,Dynamics of Structures.McGraw-Hill,Inc.,1975
    [83]郭敦仁.数学物理方法.北京:人民教育出版社,1965
    [84]殷学纲,陈淮.结构振动分析的子结构方法.北京:中国铁道出版社,1991
    [85]山县 守,小林 真,(郝育森译).海浪对长跨桥梁基础设计施工的影响.国外桥梁,1994(3),230-238
    [86]Wilson E.L.and Khalvati M.,"Finite elements for dynamic analysis of fluid-solid systems",International Journal For Numerical Methods In Engineering,1983,19,1657-1668
    [87]Liu W.K.and Chang H.G.,"A method for computation for fluid structure interaction",Computers and Structures,1985,20,311-320
    [88]Harn C.C.and Robert L.T.,"Vibration analysis of fluid-solid systems using finite element displacement formulation",International Journal For Numerical Methods In Engineering,1990,29,683-698
    [89]Maheri M.R.and Khodaei-Nassaj M.R.,"Dynamic solution of 3-D structure-fluid system using a new lagrangian-based curvilinear fluid element",Dam Engineering,1997,8,83-122
    [90]Zienkiewicz O.C.and Bettess P.,"Fluid-structure dynamic interaction and wave force.An introduction to numerical treatment",International Journal For Numerical Methods In Engineering,1978,13,1-16
    [91]刘正兴,孙雁,谢守国.流体介质中结构的动力特性及响应分析.上海交通大学学报,1995,29(4),7-16
    [92]Black J.L.,Mei C.C.and Bray C.G.,"Radiation and scattering of water waves by rigid bodies",J.Fluid Mech.,1971,46,151-164
    [93]Daniel W.J.T.,"Modal method in finite element fluid-structure eigenvalue problems",International Journal For Numerical Methods In Engineering,1980,15(8),1161-1176
    [94]Olson L.and Bathe K.,"Analysis of fluid-structure interaction.A direct symmetric coupled formulation based on the fluid velocity potential",Computers and Structures,1985,21,21-32
    [95]Dean R.G,,"Stream function representation of nonlinear ocean waves",J.Geo-phys.Res.,1965,70,4561-4572
    [96]Dean R.G.,"Relative validities of water wave theories",J.Waterways and Hartors Division,ASCE,1970,96,No.WW1,105-119
    [97]Le Mehaute B.,"An introduction to hydrodynamics and water waves",Springer-Verlag,New York,1976
    [98]Connor J.,"Wave,current and wind loads",Department of Civil Engineering,Massachusetts Institute of Technology,Cambridge,Massachusetts,1979
    [99]Hogben N.and Standing R.G.,"Experience in computing wave loads on large bodies".OTC,No.2189,1975,Vol.Ⅱ,413-431
    [100]Sommerfeld A.,Partial differential equations in physics,New York:Academic Press,1949
    [101]Guido Morgenthal,"Cable-stayed bridges Earthquake response and Passive control",
    [102]刘应中,缪国平.高等流体力学.上海:上海交通大学出版社,2000
    [103]Sun K.and Nogami T.,"Earthquake induced hydrodynamic pressure on axisymmetric offshore structures",J.Earthquake Engng struct.Dynamics,1991,20,429-440
    [104]Martin P.A.and Farina L.,"Radiation of water waves by a heaving submerged horizontal disc",J.Fluid Mech.,1997,337,365-379
    [105]Brebbia C.A.,Boundary element research.Springer-Verlag,Berlin,1984
    [106]Bathe K.J.and Hahn W.F.,"On transient analysis of fluid-structure systems",Computers and Structures,1979,10,383-391
    [107]Bi J.J.,He Y.Q.and Wang Z.P.,"Seismic analysis of vertical circular cylinders surrounded by water",Proc.Shanghai Symposium on Marine Geotechnology and Nearshore/Offshore Structures,Tongji University Press,Shanghai,1983,255-261
    [108]Goyal A.and Chopra A.K.,"Hydrodynamic mass for intake towers",J.Engng Mech.,ASCE,1989,115(7),1393-1412
    [109]Goyal A.and Chopra A.K.,"Earthquake response spectrum analysis of intake-outlet towers",Journal of Engineering Mechanics,1989,115(7),1413-1433
    [110]Chopra A.K.and Goyal A.,"Simplified earthquake analysis of intake-outlet towers",Journal of Structural Engineering,1991,117(3),767-788
    [111]Goto H.and Toki K.,"Vibration characteristics and aseismic design of submerged bridge piers",Pro.3rd world conf.on earthquake eng.New Zealand,Ⅱ,1965
    [112]Xing J.T.,Price W.G.,Pomfret M.J.and Yam L.H.,"Natural Vibration of a Beam-Water Interaction System",Journal of Sound and Vibration,1997,199(3),491-512
    [113]Tanaka Y.and Hudspeth R.T.,"Restoring forces on vertical circular cylinders forced by earthquake",Earthquake engineering and structural dynamics,1988,16,99-119
    [114]MacCamy R.C.and Fuchs R.A.,"Wave Forces on Piles:A Diffraction Theory",U.S.Army Corps of Engineers Beach Erosion Board,Tech.Mem.No.69,1954
    [115]Garrett C.J.R.,"Wave forces on a circular dock",J.Fluid Mech.,1971,46,129-139
    [116]Bhatta D.D.and Rahman M.,"On scattering and radiation problem for a cylinder in water of finite depth",International Journal of Engineering Science,2003,41,931-967
    [117]Isaacson M.,"Wave forces on compound cylinders",Proc.Civil Engineering in the Oceans Ⅳ,Ⅰ,ASCE,San Francisco,1979,518-530
    [118]Sabuncu T.and Calisal S.,"Hydrodynamic coefficients for vertical circular cylinders at finite depth",Ocean Engng.,1981,8,25-63
    [119]Ray P.S.Han and Hanzhou Xu,"A simple and accurate added mass model for hydrodynamic fliud-structure interaction analysis",J.Franklin Inst.,1996,333B(6),929-945
    [120]流体-重力式锥状单腿平台结构-土相互作用体系的地震动力响应.海洋工程,1996,14(2),83-89
    [121]房营光.土-桩-平台-水流系统的地震反应分析.广东工学院学报,1994,11(4),8-12
    [122]房营光,孙钧.平台-群桩-水流-土体系统的地震反应分析.土木工程学报,1998,31(5),56-64
    [123]朱睎,高学奎.桥梁抗震分析中动水压力的计算.中国铁道科学,2007,3,44-48
    [124]袁迎春,赖伟,王君杰,胡世德.Morison方程中动水阻力项对桥梁桩柱地震反应的影响桥.世界地震工程,2005,3

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700