摘要
随着科技不断的快速发展和全球化的浪潮,“动荡性”成为本世纪商业环境的主要特征,这要求企业不仅要关注流程的效率,还需要关注流程的柔性。具有柔性流程的企业能够更快的把握环境变化带来的机会,在竞争中赢得先机。
战略管理、组织设计、信息管理等领域的文献指出模块化的业务流程设计具有“封装”和“即插即用”的特性,能够快速的重新组合(拆离、修改、连接等)以应对外部变化,是提高流程柔性并保持流程效率、功能性的重要途径,是适应于网络组织的流程形式;在信息技术层面,服务导向架构(SOA)技术的成熟也为模块化流程的实施提供了可能。然而,为了进一步将模块化流程设计从理论推向实践,还需要解决如何测度、建模、设计模块化流程等问题。
业务流程的模块化设计是将端到端的流程分解为松散耦合、标准化的活动集合。为了深入的解释这一现象,本文首先基于模块化系统理论和交易成本经济学分析了实施模块化流程的促成因素、阻碍因素和调节因素,应用海尔市场链流程案例分析了这些因素,该模型为后文设计方法的研究打下了坚实的理论基础。
为了确定解决问题的目标,本文基于系统柔性研究给出了流程模块化度的测度体系,该体系包括流程模块的可配置性和松散耦合性两个测度单元:可配置性指通过模块的重新配置能够提供的服务类型范围,松散耦合性指流程模块间的松散耦合的程度,流程的整体模块化度是这两个单元的乘积。为了描述流程的可配置性和活动间耦合关系,本文以质量功能展开和设计结构矩阵为基础构建了新的“服务元素-活动-依赖结构”矩阵(SeAD矩阵)流程模型。
流程模块粒度是模块化流程设计的重要变量,本文分析了模块粒度对流程模块化度的作用原理,结果表明随着模块粒度增加,流程模块化度和柔性度随之增加,在达到一定程度后又会逐渐减少。对需求多样化、环境动荡性高的流程应选择细粒度的设计,反之应选择较粗粒度设计以获取规模经济性。在粒度分析基础上,以SeAD为流程模型,本文给出了基于多目标聚类的流程模块设计算法。
SOA是模块化流程实现的使能技术,面向服务分析设计(SOAD)与传统建模方法不同,要求基于流程的分析实现流程的“随需应变”。本文最后基于模块化流程影响因素模型提出了SOA战略分析框架以帮助管理者制定部署SOA的决策;基于模块化流程设计原理提出了服务识别、规约方法,开发实现了服务设计的辅助软件SeAD-Tools,并应用“钢铁—汽车”供货流程来说明了方法的应用。
With the rapid development of technology and globalization wave, business environment becomes more and more turbulent. Firms should pay more attention to business process flexibility besides efficiency. Firms with flexible business process can grasp opportunity brought by environment change and exceed their competitors easily.
Literatures in strategy management, organization design and business process outsourcing point out that modular design of business process have properties of "capsulation" and "plug and play", enabling business processes to be quickly reorganized(detach, modify, linking, etc.), which is a important way to improve business flexibility with little loss of efficiency and function. At the same time, service-oriented architecture (SOA) becomes mature enough to be information infrastructure to support implementation of modular business process. However to make modular process design create value in practice, problems of how to measure, model and design modular business process need to be solved.
Modular design of business processes requires end-to-end business processes be divided into loosely coupled, standardization and autonomy group of activities. We proposed influence factors model for implementation of modular process based on modular system theory and transaction cost economics. This factor model gives a solid theoretical foundation for other parts of this paper.
A measurement system of business process modularity degree was proposed based on system flexibility research. This system includes two measure units: process configurability and process loosely-coupled degree. Process configurability means the service type's scope provide by reorganization of process module. Loosely-coupled degree described how low the dependency relationship among process modules is. Loosely-coupled degree enable process module re-configure quickly without incurring high coordinating cost. To describe these two units, a "Service elements-Activity-Dependency structure Matrix (SeAD Matrix)" was designed to modeling business process based on quality function deployment (QFD) and design structure matrix (DSM). SeAD Matrix can model business service elements and dependency relationship.
The granularity of business process module plays an important role in modular process design. We analyzed business process granularity's influence on process modularity degree. Results show that with the increasment of process module granularity, the process modularity degree will first increase and then after reach a certain degree it will decrease. For processes which have various customer requirements and turbulent environment, fine-grained granularity is a better choice, otherwise coarse-grained granularity is better. A business process module design algorithm was proposed based on SeAD matrix and granularity principle.
Since SOA and modular business process has similar theory base, we apply modular business process design principle to service oriented analysis and design. We proposed strategy analysis model for deployment of SOA, and method of business service identification and design. We also developed an assistant tool called SeAD-Tools for service-oriented analysis and design. Finally, we use "iron-automobile" supply chain process to show the application of this method.
引文
1.彼得·德鲁克著,姜文波译.动荡时代的管理[M]北京:机械工业出版社.2006
2.Upton.D.M.The Management of manufacturing flexibility[J].California Management Review.2000
3.Kanter,R.M.When Giants Learnto Dance:Mastering the Challenge of Strategy,Management and Careers in the 1990s[M],London:Routledge.1994
4.Morgan,G.The Schismatic Metaphor and Its Implications for Organizational Analysis'.Organization Studies,2/1:23-24.1981
5.Volberda,H.W.Building the Flexible Firm:How to Remain Competitive[M].Oxford University Press,USA.1998
6.IBM中国商业价值研究院.中国商业价值报告.战略与管理[M].北京:东方出版社.2007
7.Smith,H.Fingar.Business Process Management:the Third Wave[M].Meghan-Kiffer Press;1 edition.2003
8.M.Hammer.Reengineer Work:Don't Automate,Obliterate[J].Harvard Business Review.68(4):104-113.1990
9.Davenport,T.and Thomas H.Process Innovation Reengineering Work through Information Technology[M].Harvard Business School Press,1993
10.Sawy,O.E.Redesigning Enterprise Processes for E-Business[M].Mcgraw Hill.Irwin,USA.2000
11.Gardner.R.A.The Process-Focused Organization:a Transition Strategy for Success[M].USA:ASQ Quality Press(May 2004)
12.Jolla,S.,et al.IBM,the Solution Designers Guide to IBM on Demand Business Solutions[M].IBM Press.USA.2005
13.黄丽华,葛永利,富小丽等.企业过程柔性的概念框架[J].系统工程理论与实践,1999.10
14.Sanchez R,Tmahoney J.Modularity,Flexibility and Knowledge Management in Product and Organization Design[J].Strategic Management Journal.1996
15.Gosain,S.Arvind Malhotra,Omar A.El Sawy.Coordinating for Flexibility in E-Business Supply Chains[J].Journal of Management Information Systems.Vol.21.No 5.2004
16.Kingshuk K.Sinha,Andrew H.Van De Ven..Designing Work Within and Between Organizations[J].Organization Science.Vol.16,No.4.2005
17.Ross,J.W.,P.Weill,D.Robertson.Enterprise Architecture as Strategy:Creating a Foundation for Business Execution[M].Harvard Business School Press,Boston,MA.2006
18.Qiang Tu Et Al..Measuring Modularity-Based Manufacturing Practices and Their Impact on Mass Customization Capability:a Customer-Driven Perspective[J].Decision Sciences.2004
19.Baldwin,C.Y.,and Clark,K.B.Managing in an Age of Modularity[J].Harvard Business Review.1997
20.Baldwin,C.Y.,and Clark,K.B..Design Rules:The Power of Modularity[M].MIT Press,Cambridge,MA.2000
21.Schilling,M.Toward a General Modular Systems Theory and Its Application to Inter-Firm Product Modularity[J].Academy of Management Review.2000
22.Schilling,M.,K.H.Steensma.The Use of Modular Organizational Forms:An Industry-Level Analysis[J].Academy of Management Journal.2001
23.Gregor.S.The Nature of Theory In Information Systems[J].MIS Quarterly Vol.30 No.3,Pp.611-642.20O6
24.Alan R.Hevner Salvatore T.Design Science In Information Systems Research.MIS Quarterly Vol.28 No.1,pp.75-105/March 2004
25.库恩著,金吾伦,胡新和译.科学革命的结构[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2003.
26.Van Aken J E.Management research based on the paradigm of the design sciences:The quest for field-tested and grounded technological rules[J].Journal of Management Studies,2004,41:219-245.
27.司马贺著,武夷山译.人工科学[M].上海:上海科技教育出版社,2004.
28.DiMaggio,E J.Comments on 'What Theory is Not[J].Administrative Sciences Quarterly.VOLA0.NO3.pp.391-397.1995
29.Vaishnavi V,Kuechler B.Design Science Research in Information Systems[EB/OL].http://www.isworld.org/Researchdesign/drislSworld.htm,2008,2.
30.徐玮,尹宝林,李昭原.企业信息系统业务构件设计研究[J].软件学报,2003,Vol.14,No.7
31.Lee S.D.,Yang Y.J.COMO:A UML-based component development methodology[C].Proceedings of the 6th Asia Pacific Software Engineering Conference,Takamatsu,1998,pp.54-63
32.Ganesan R.,Sengupta S.O2BC:A technique for the design of component-based applications [C].Proceedings of the 39th International Conference and Exhibition on Technology of Object-Oriented Language and Systems,Santa Barbara,California,2001,pp.46-55
33.Cherbakov,L.G.,and Harishankar,G.R.Impact of Service Orientation at the Business Level[J].IBM Systems Journal,2005Vol.44,No.4
34.Jaap Gordijn,Eric Yu,Bas van der Raadt.e-Service Design Using i'and e3 value Modeling[J].IEEE Software.May/June 2006(Vol.23,No.3) pp.26-33
35.Padmal Vitharana,Hemant Jain,and Fatemeh Mariam Zahedi.Strategy-Based Design of Reusable Business Components[J].IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man,and Cybernetics-Part C,VOL.34,NO.4,November 2004
36.Ghauri,Gronhaug,Kristianslund.Research method in business studies:a practical guide[M].USA:Prentice Hall,1995.
37.Yin,R.K.Case Study Research:Design and Methods[M],Thousnad Oaks,CA:Sage,1994
38.Purao,S."Design Research in the Technology of Information Systems:Truth or Dare." GSU Department of CIS Working Paper.Atlanta.2002
39.Simon,H.The Architecture of Complexity[C].Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society,Vol.106:467-482 1962
40.K.E.Weick,Orton,J.D.Loosely Coupled Systems:A Reconceptualization[J],Academy of Management Review,15,2,pp.203-223.1990
41.青木昌彦,安藤晴彦.模块时代:新产业结构的本质[M].上海:上海远东出版社2003
42.Richard,P.J.,Timothy M.Devinney.Modular Strategies:B2B Technology And Architectural Knowledge[J].California Management Review Vol,47,No.4 2005
43.Wolters,M.J.J.The Business of Modularity and the Modularity of Business[D].Phd Thesis,Erasmus University Rotterdam.Holland2001
44.RN Langlois.Modularity in technology and organization[J].Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,2002
45.Abemathy,W.J.The Productivity Dilemma[M].Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press,USA.1978
46.Swaninathan,J.M.Enabling Customization Using Standardized Operations[J].Califonia Management Review2001
47.Pil,F.K.Cohen,S.K.Modularity:Implications for Imitation,Innovation,and Sustained Advantage[J].Academy of Management Review.Vol.31,No.4,995-1011.2006
48.Ethiraj S.K.and Arbor,Michigan.Modularity and Innovation in Complex Systems[J].Management Science Vol.50,No.2,pp.159-1732004
49.Hannus,Jouko.Reform of the company's performance 4th.edition[M],HM&V Research Oy,Gummerrus Kiriapaino Oy,Finland.1994
50.赵卫东,俞东慧.业务流程管理[M],北京:知识产权出版社2007
51.Alter,S.A General,Yet Useful Theory of Information Systems[J],Communications of the Association for Information Systems,VOL1 NO 13,March 1999
52.Hoogeweegen,M.R.,Wim J.M.Teunissen,Peter H.M.Vervest,et.al..Modular Network Design:Using Information and Communication Technology to Allocate Production Tasks in a Virtual Organization[J].Decision Sciences.Volume 30 Number 4.1999
53.Tanriverdi,H.,Prabhudev Konana,Ling Ge..The Choice of Sourcing Mechanisms for Business Processes[J].Information Systems Research,Vol.18,No.3.2007
54.Sanchez,R.A Process Design Approach to Managing Interdependencies in Complex Organizations[J].Working Paper.2006
55.Zander,U.,B.Kogut.Knowledge and the Speed of the Transfer and Imitation of Organizational Capabilities:an Empirical Test[J].Organization Science.6(1) 76-92.1995
56.李维安.网络组织-组织发展新趋势[M].北京:经济科学出版社.2003
57.Jones.C.et al.A General Theory of Network Governance:Exchange Conditions and Social Mechanisms[J].Academy of Management Review.22(4).1997
58.Larsson,R.The Handshake Between Invisible and Visible Hands[J].International Studies of Management and Organization 23(1).1993
59.Worren N.,Moore,K.Cardona,P..Modularity,Strategic Flexibility,and Firm Performance:a Study of the Home Appliance Industry[J].Strategic Management Journal 23:1123-11402002
60.Williamson,O.E.The Economic Institutions of Capitalism[M],Free Press,New York,NY,1985.
61.Tomos F.E-R and Victor Padron-Robaina.Review of Outsoureing From the Resource-Based View of the Firm[J].International Journal of Management Reviews Volume 8 Issue 1 Pp.49-70,2006
62.Barney J.Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage[J].Journal of Management.1991
63.Dietmar Wikarski.An Introduction to Modular Process Nets[M].1996
64.张亮,姚淑珍.种新的基于Petri网的分层工作流过程模[J].计算机集成制造系统.Vol.12No.9.2006
65.程绍武,徐晓飞,王刚等.一个组织间松散耦合跨组织工作流的仿真模型[J].软件学报,Vol.17,No.12,Deeernber 2006,pp.2461-2470
66.窦万春,蔡士杰.基于Petri网的工作流技术复合建模与系统分解[J].计算机集成制造系 统Vol.8 No.5,2002
67.阿斯特等著,王建民等译:工作流管理:模型、方法和系统[M].清华大学出版社.2004年2月
68.A Basu,RW Blanning Synthesis and Decomposition of Processes in Organizations[J].Information Systems Research,Vol.14,No.4,December 2003,pp.337-355
69.Steward,Donald V.The Design Structure System:A Method for Managing the Design of Complex Systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management,vol.28,pp.71-74,1981.
70.Eppinger,Steven D.A Planning Method for Integration of Large-Scale Engineering Systems[C].Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering Design ICED-97,Tampere,Aug.19-21,1997.
71.Sullivan,Kevin J.Griswold,William G Hallen.The Structure and Value of Modularity in Software Design[C].Proceedings of the Joint International Conference on Software Engineering and ACM SIGSOFT Symposium on the Foundations of Software Engineering,September 2001,Vienna.
72.Safoutin,Michael J.A Methodology for Empirical Measurement of Iteration in Engineering Design Processes[D].Ph.D.Thesis(M.E.),Univ.of Washington,Seattle.2003
73.Yassine,Ali and Dan Whitney,Steve Daleiden,and Jerry Lavine,Connectivity Maps:Modeling and Analyzing Relationships In Product Development Processes[J].Journal of Engineering Design,Volume 14,No 3,September 2003.
74.Yu,Tian-Li,Goldberg,D.E.,Yassine,Ali & Chen,Y.-P.,A Genetic Algorithm Design Inspired by Organizational Theory[C].Jan.2003.Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference(GECCO) 2003.Chicago,Illinois,USA.Lecture Notes in Computer Science,Volume 2724 / 2003,Pages:1620 - 1621,Publisher:Springer-Vedag,Heidelberg,ISSN:0302-9743.
75.Pedro Matos Jr Rafael Duarte Ivan Cardim Paulo Borba.Using Design Structure Matrices to Assess Modularity in Aspect-Oriented Software Product Lines[C].First International Workshop on Assessment of Contemporary Modularization Techniques.2007
76.Alan MacCormack,John Rusnak,Carliss Y.Baldwin.Exploring the Structure of Complex Software Designs:An Empirical Study of Open Source and Proprietary Code[J].Management Science Vol.52,No.7,July 2006,pp.1015-1030
77.Tyson R.Browning.Applying the Design Structure Matrix to System Decomposition and Integration Problems:A Review and New Directions[J].IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT,VOL.48,NO.3,AUGUST 2001
78.王爱虎,杨曼丽.基于设计结构矩阵的过程系统优化方法[J].工业工程Vol.8 No.6November 2000
79.Shi-Jie Chena,Li Linb.Decomposition of interdependent task group for concurrent engineering[J].Computers & Industrial Engineering 44(2003) 435-459
80.赵卫东.模块化组织流程研究[J].工业工程与管理 Vol 32005
81.Stremersch,S.,Allen M.Weiss,Benedict G.C.Dellaert et.al..Buying Modular Systems in Technology-Intensive Markets[J].Journal of Marketing Research.Vol.XL,335-3502003
82.Fine,C.H.,Clockspeed - Winning Industry Control in the Age of Temporary Advantage[M].Perseus Books,Massachusetts.1998
83.罗珉.大型企业的模块化:内容、意义与方法[J].中国工业经济.vol.204 no.32005
84.Zaheer,A.Venkatraman.N.Determinants of Electronic Integration in the Insurance Industry:An Empirical Test[J].Management Science/Vol.40,No,5,May 549.1994
85.Zaheer,A.Venkatraman.N.Relational Governance as an Inter-organizational Strategy:An Empirical Test of the Role of Trust in Economic Exchange[J].Strategic Management Journal,Vol.16,No.5.Pp.373-392.1995
86.Bharadwaj,A.S..A Resource-Based Perspective on Information Technology Capability and Firm Performance:An Empirical Investigation[J].MIS Quarterly,Vol.24,No.1 Pp.169-1962000
87.Masten S,J.W.Meehan.and E,A,Snyder,Vertical Integration in the US Auto Industry[J].Economic Behavior and Organization,12,(1989),265-273.John H.,John Seely Brown.Your Next IT Strategy.Harvard Business Review2001
88.John,G.and B,Weitz,Forward Integration into Distribution:An Empirical Test of Transaction Cost Analysis[J].Law,Economics and Organization,4,1988,337-355.
89.Nelson,R,R,and S.G,Winter,An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change[J].Harvard University,Cambridge,MA,1982,
90.Collins,D.J.,and Montgomery.C.A.Corporate Strategy:a Resource-Based Approach,Second Edition[M].Mcgraw-Hill USA.2005
91.Malone,T.W.,Crowston,K.,Lee,J.,and Pentland,B..Tools for Inventing Organizations:Toward a Handbbok of Organizational Processes[J].Management Science(45:3),pp.425-443.1999
92.Sambamurthy,V.,Anandhi Bharadwaj,Varun Grover..Shaping Agility through Digital Options:Reconceptualizing the Role of Information Technology in Contemporary Firms[J].MIS Quarterly Vol.27 No.2.Pp.237-26.2003
93.Chung,S.H.Terry Anthony Byrd,Bruce R.Lewis,Et Al..An Empirical Study of the Relationships between IT Infrastructure Flexibility,Mass Customization,and Business Performance[J].The DATABASE for Advances in Information Systems.36(3):26-44.2005
94.管益忻.探索海尔市场链业务流程再造机理的一篇力作[J].南开管理评论.2001(1)
95.蒋黔贵等编著.海尔市场链与信息化[M].北京:中国经济出版社2003
96.苏慧文.海尔管理变革:市场链与业务流程再造[J].南开管理评论.2001(1)2001
97.冯圣洪.一种多指标综合评价合成技术方法研究[J].模糊系统与数学.1999
98.Feitzinger,E.,H.L.Lee.1997.Mass Customization at Hewlett-Packard:The Power of Postponement,HarvardBusiness Review,Jan.-Feb.1997,pp.116-121.
99.Slack,N.and H.Correa.,1992,The Flexibilities of Push and Pull International Journal of Operations & Production Management,12(4),82-92.
100.Slack,Nigel,Manufacturing systems flexibility an assessment procedure[J],Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems,Vol.l(1 ),25-31.1988
101.Gupta,Y P,Goyal,S.Flexibility of manufacturing systems:Concepts and measurements[J],European Journal of Operational Research 43,119-135.1989
102.Dixon,J.R.Measuring manufacturing flexibility:An empirical investigation[J].European Journal of Operational Research,60,131-143.1992
103.Christopher Lovelock,Jochen Wirtz.Services Marketing(6th Edition)[M].USA:Prentice-Hall Press.2006
104.Thompson.Organizations in Action[M].New York:Mcgraw-Hill.1967
105.Malone,T.W.Coordination Theory and Collaboration Technology[M].Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.2001
106.Malone,T.W.and Kevin Crowston[M].What Is Coordination Theory and How Can It Help Design Codperative Work Systems? CSCW 90 Proceedings 1990
107.Malone,T.W.and Kevin Crowston.The Interdisciplinary Study of Coordination[J].ACM Computing Surveys,Vol.26,No.1,March 1994
108.Kavakli.V.Pericles Loucopoulos.Goal-Driven Business Process Analysis Application in Electricity Deregulation[J].Information Systems Vol.24,No.3,Pp.187-2071999
109.张云波.面向敏捷制造的供应链柔性管理[D].成都:西南交通大学.2004
110.熊伟.质量机能展开[M].北京:化学工业出版社.2005-3
111.郑大兵,黄丽华,李勇.QFD在企业过程优化中的应用[J].管理科学学报.Vol.2 No.4.Dec.1999
112.Ali A.Yassine.An Introduction to Modeling and Analyzing Complex Product Development Processes Using the Design Structure Matrix(DSM) Method[EB/OL].iese.uiuc.edu
113.范玉顺,王刚.集成化企业建模方法与工具系统研究[J].计算机集成制造系统.2000
114.范玉顺 编著.集成化企业建模方法与系统[M].北京:中国电力出版社.2007-2
115.H.Tan and W.M.P.van der Aalst.Implementation of a YAWL Work-List Handler based on the Resource Patterns[C].Proceedings of the 10th IEEE International Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work in Design(CSCWD 2006),pages 1184-1189.IEEE Computer Society Press,2006.
116.N.Russell,A.H.M.ter Hofstede,D.Edmond,and W.M.P.van der Aalst.Workflow Resource Patterns[J].BETA Working Paper Series,WP 127,Eindhoven University of Technology,Eindhoven,2004.
117.Biddle B J,Thomas E J.Role Theory:Concepts and Research[M].New York John Wiley &Son Inc.1996
118.布奇,兰宝,雅各布著,邵维忠,麻志毅译UML用户指南(第二版)[M].北京:人民邮电出版社.2006年06月
119.巴拉赫,兰宝.车皓阳,杨眉译.UML面向对象建模与设计(第2版)[M].人民邮电出版社.2006年01月
120.Gregory Mentzas,Christos,Stylianos Kavadias.Modeling Business Process with Workflow Systems:An Evaluation of Alternative Approaches[J].International Journal of Information Management,21:123 -135.2001
121.Eisenhardt,K.M.and Brown,S.L.Patching Restitching Business Portfolios in Dynamic Markets[J].Harvard Business Review.77(3):72-82.1999
122.Galunie,D.C.and K.M.Eisenhardt Architectural Iinnovation and Modular Corporate Forms[J].Academy of Management Journal,44(6),1229-50.2001
123.Jarzabkowski,P.Strategy as Practice:Recursiveness,Adaptation and Practices-in-use[J].Organization Studies,25:489-520.2004.
124.康立山.非数值并行算法(第一册).模拟退火算法[M].北京:科学出版社出版时间.2000年06月
125.Ohrstrom.J.Business Value Using Service Oriented Architecture[D].Master Thesis.Stockholm,Sweden.2007
126.Booker,E.2000.Enterprise Software Projects Rarely Satisty[J].InternetWeek,28 Mar.
127.Sommer,R.A.2003.Business Process Flexibility:A Driver for Outsourcing[J].Industrial Management and Data Systems.Vol103 No3
128.Bob Sutor.Plumbing Web Connections[J].Harvard Business Review.2003
129.Francisco Curbera,Rania Khalaf,Nirmal Mukhi.The Next Step In Web Services[J].Communications of ACM October 2003/Vol.46,No.10
130.TA.Whitea,E.M.Danielb,M.Mohdzainhe.Role of Emergent Information Technologies And Systems in Enabling Supply Chain Agility[J].International Journal of Information Management 25(2005) 396-410
131.J.Leon Zhao.Michael Goul.Sandeep Purao.Impact of Service-Centric Computing on Business and Education[J].Comunication of AIS.Volume 22,Article 16,pp.295-310,March 2008
132.J.Leon Zhao & Mohan Tanniru & Liang-Jie Zhang.Services Computing as The Foundation of Enterprise Agility:Overview of Recent Advances and Introduction to The Special Issue[J].Inf Syst Front(2007) 9:1-82007
133.Carter S.The New Language of Business SOA & Web 2.0[M].USA:IBM Press.2007
134.Erl T.Service-Oriented Architecture,Concepts,Technology,and Design[M],Pearson Education,Inc(2004)
135.Sprott,D.and Wilkes,U Understanding Service-Oriented Architecture[EB/OL],CBDI Forum(2004),
136.W3C,Service-Oriented Architecture[EB/OL].http://www.w3.org/TR/ws-gloss/.2004
137.M.R Papazoglou and D.Georgakopoulos.Service-Oriented Computing[J].COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM.October 2003/Vol.46,No.10
138.C.H.Crawford,G.P.Bate,L.Cherbakov.Toward an on demand service-oriented architecture[J].IBM SYSTEMS JOURNAL,VOL 44,NO 1,2005
139.Schroth,C.The Service-Oriented Enterprise[J].Journal of Enterprise Architecture.November,2007
140.Vargo,S.L.,R.F.Lusch.Evolving to a new dominant logic for marketing[J].J.Marketing 681-17.2004
141.Rai.A.,Vallabh Sambamurthy.The Growth of Interest in Services Management:Opportunities for Information Systems Scholars[J].Information Systems Research Vol.17,No.4,December 2006,Pp.327-331.2006
142.Philip Kotler,Kevin Keller.Marketing Management(13th Edition)[M].USA:Prentice Hall.2008
143.Neil Maiden.Servicing Your Requirements[J].IEEE Software.2006
144.岳昆,王晓玲,周傲英.Web服务核心支撑技术:研究综述[J].软件学报.Vol.15,No.3,2006
145.Bieberstein,N.,S.Bose,L.Walker,A.Lynch..Impact of service-oriented architecture on enterprise systems,organizational structures,and individuals[J].IBM Systems Journal,VOL 44,NO 4 2005
146.Iyer,B.,Jim Freedman,Mark Gaynor,George Wyner.Web Services:Enabling Dynamic Business Networks[J].Communications of the Association for Information Systems(Volume 11,2003) 525-554.2003
147.W.M.P.van der Aalst,E Leymann,and W.Reisig.The Role of Business Processes in Service Oriented Architectures(Editorial).International Journal of Business Process Integration and Management,2(2):75-80,2007.
148.Olaf Zimmermann,Pal Krogdahl,Clive Gee.Elements of Service-Oriented Analysis and Design An interdisciplinary modeling approach for SOA projects[EB/OL].http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/webservices/library/ws-soad1,2004
149.毛新生.SOA原理·方法·实践[M].电子工业出版社.2007年05月
150.Kang,K.Cohen,S.Hess,J.Feature-Oriented Domain Analysis(FODA) Feasibility Study[EB/OL].http://www.sei.cmu.edu/publications/documents/90.reports/90.tr.021.html
151.Henderson,J C,Venkatraman N..Strategic Alignment:Leveraging Information Technology for Transforming Organizations[J].IBM Systems Journal,32(1):4-16.1993
152.Hagel,J.,J.S.Brown..Your Next IT Strategy[J].Harvard Business Review2001
153.Venkatraman.N..IT-Enabled Business Transformation:From Automation to Business Scope Redefinition[J].Sloan Management Review;1994,35(2):73-87 1994
154.Samulson,R.Global Mythmaking[J].Newsweek.1994
155.Booth,Jacobson[J],1996
156.Padmal Vitharana,Hemant Jain,and Fatemeh Mariam Zahedi.Strategy-Based Design of Reusable Business Components[J].IEEE Transactions on Systems,Man,and Cybernetics-Part C,VOL.34,NO.4,November 2004
157.Jose Acosta,Jeffrey C.Befumo,Albert.E.Chauza.Treasury Enterprise Architecture Framework.[EB/OL].http://www.eaframeworks.com/TEAF/teaf.doc
158.John Zachman,Samuel Holcman.Zachman Framework[EB/OL].http://www.zifa.com/
159.ERNEST M J,NISAVIC M.Adding value to the IT organization with the Component Business Model[J].IBM System Journal.2005
160.GORDIJN J,YU E,RAADT B.e-Service Design Using i*and e~3 value Modeling[J].IEEE Software.May/June 2006(Vol.23,No.3) pp.26-33
161.W.M.P.van der Aalst,Akhil Kumar,H.M.W.Verbeek.Organizational Modeling in UML and XML in the context of Workflow Systems[C].SAC,Melbourne,Florida,USA.2003
162.JE Robbins,DF Redmiles.Cognitive support,UML adherence,and XMI interchange in Argo/UML[J].Information and Software Technology,2000
163.TJ Grose,GC Doney,SA Brodsky.Mastering XMI:Java programming with XMI,XML and UML[EB/OL].2002 stoyanov.org
164.F Keienburg,A Rausch.Using XML/XMI for tool supported evolution of UML models[C].System Sciences Proceedings of the 34th Annual Hawaii 2001
165.Linda Heaton.MOF 2.0 / XMI Mapping Specification,v2.1.1[EB/OL]http://www.omg.org/technology/documents/formal/xmi.htm
166.张志刚等.Matlab与数学实验[M].北京:中国铁道出版社,20041
67.王正林等.Matlab/Simulink与控制系统仿真[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2005
168.董维国.深入浅出Matlab7.x混合编程[M].北京:机械工业出版社
169.Billy S H,Rockford L著,康博译.高效掌握Visual Basic.NET[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2002,10
170.陈文军,陈晓铭.Visual Basci.NET数据库编程[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2005,1
171.Kimel P著,吕建宁译.Visual Basci.NET技术内幕[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2002,8
172.凯慈林诺著,李增民,王黎译.ASP.NET组建工具包--VB.NET Web解决方案[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2003.6
173.Douglas M.Lambert,Martha C.Cooper.Issues in Supply Chain Management[J].Industrial Marketing Management,2000
174.Brian Fugate,Funda Sahin.Supply Chain Management Coordination Mechanisms[J].Journal of Business Logistics,2006
175.Greg Aimi and Ian Finley SOA:The New Value Driver[J].Supply Chain Management 2007
176.A.Whitea,E.M.Danielb,M.Mohdzain The role of emergent information technologies and systems in enabling supply chain agility[J].Information and Management
177.Peter Buxmann,Anette von Ahsen,Luis Martin Diaz Kristina Wolf.Usage and evaluation of Supply Chain Management Software - results of an empirical study in the European automotive industry[J].Info Systems Journal.14,295-309.2004
178.Fensel,D.,& Bussler,C.The web service modelling framework.[J].Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,1(2),113-137.2002
179.Hagel,J.Edging into web services[J].McKinsey Quarterly,4,29-38.2002
180.Vidgen,R.,Francis,D.,Powell,P.,& Woerndl,M.Web service business transformation:Collaborative commerce opportunities in SMEs[J].Journal of Enterprise Information Management,17(5),372-381.2004
181.Wu,C.A.Readiness model for adopting web services[J].Journal of Enterprise Information Management,17(5),361 - 371.2004
182.Sawhney,M.e-Hubs:The new B2B Marketplaces[J].Harvard Business Review,78(3),97 -102.2000
183.Daft,R.L.Organization Theory and Design(8th Ed.)[M].South-Western College Publishing,a Division of Thomson Learning.USA.2003
184.万猛,赵锡斌,胡飞虎.业务流程网建模技术及应用研究[J).管理科学学报.Vol 12 No.6.2007
185.W.M.P.van der Aalst.Loosely Coupled Interorganizational Workflows:Modeling and Analyzing Workflows Crossing Organizational Boundaries[J].Information and Management,37(2):67-75,March 2000.
186.Issam Chebbi,Schahram Dustdar,Samir Tara.The View-Based Approach to Dynamic Inter-Organizational Workflow Cooperation[J].Data & Knowledge Engineering.56.139-173.2006