摘要
VaR作为现代银行风险管理的国际标准和理论基础,日益受到国际活跃银行的广泛应用。论文秉持《新巴塞尔资本协议》的银行风险管理精神,研究基于VaR的银行风险管理,这对我国银行业如何更有效地提高风险管理水平和国际接轨、缩小国际差距有着重要的理论意义和实用价值。论文首先系统地介绍了VaR的理论基础和计算方法及其存在的局限性,建立了在静态和动态条件下基于VaR的银行资本优化模型。在此基础上,分析了VaR和风险资本(CaR)之间的内在联系,结合我国金融发展水平的现状,提出了我国现阶段基于RAROC的商业银行全面风险管理框架和统一于VaR的银行风险资本配置思路。然后在Merton(1974)假设银行资产价值遵循几何布朗运动的分析基础上,通过引入银行的监管机制,分析了银行的监管强度与银行风险策略选择的相互影响关系。然后以持续期概念为基础,建立了在银行资产负债表中计算VaR的参数和非参数方法。接着论文分析了用VaR代替方差或标准差作为风险测量指标时均值-VaR模型的几何求解及其应用中的局限性,建立了VaR约束下基于银行借贷的投融资决策模型。由于条件风险值(CVaR)能够克服VaR不满足一致性风险度量,尾部损失测量非充分性的不足,论文提出了基于CVaR约束的投资组合优化模型,该模型考虑了银行投资组合资产的交易成本、交易限制、资金约束和投资者的风险承受度。由于一系列国际银行损失事件引发了对操作风险管理强烈地内在需求,文章最后对银行操作风险度量进行了实证分析,提出了基于VaR的银行整体风险管理框架和操作风险管理在我国的应用建议。
VaR is thought the international standard and theory basis of modern bank risk management, which is increasingly applied to international flourish bank. The paper follows the spirit of New Basel Accord on bank risk management to research bank risk management based VaR, which is of important theory and practice meaning to how to improve the risk management level and reduce the international distance of china bank industry. The paper first systematically introduces theory basis and calculation methods of VaR and its deficiency . Then the paper analyzes the relation between VaR and CaR, puts forward the commercial bank general risk management construction based RAROC and the thought of collocating CaR based unification VaR by contacting china finance development condition. As in Merton(1974),the value of the banks assets V is assumed to follow a geometric Brownian motion, the paper analyzes the relation on bank audit intensity and bank risk strategy by importing supervision mechanism. The paper builds up the parameter and nonparameter methods to calculate VaR based on Duration model in bank balance sheet. The paper analyzes geometric solution of mean-VaR model and its limit, establishes the bank investment and financing model based on VaR. Because VaR doesn’t fulfill coherence risk measurement and tail loss measurement, the paper establishes portfolio optimization model which includes trade-off cost, dealing limit , capital restriction and investor risk tolerance. As a result of series of international bank loss affairs arose intensively internal demand to operation risk management, at last ,the paper brings forward bank general risk management frame based on VaR and application propose.
引文
[1] Acerbi C, Tasche D. On the coherence of expected shortfall[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,2002,26:1487~1503
[2] Acerbi, C. and Tasche, D. (2002) Expected Shortfall: a natural coherent alternative to Value at Risk. Economic Notes 31(2), 379-388.
[3] Acerbi, C.,C. Nordio, And c. Sirtori. Expected Shortfall As a Tool for Financial Risk Management .Working paper, Italian Association for Financial Risk Management, 2001
[4] Ackermann, C.,R. McEnally, and D. Ravenscraft. “The Performance of Hedge Funds: Risk, Return and Incenntives.” Jountal of Finance, Vol. 54(1999), pp.833-874 [5 ]Alexander G J. Economic implication of using a mean-VaR model for portfolio selection: A comparison with mean-variance analysis[J].Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,2002,26:1159~1193
[6]Alexander, C. Volatility and Correlations: Methods, Models and Applications, Risk Management and Analysis: Measuring and Modeling Financial Risk, Ed. Wileys
[7]Alexander, G.J and A.M. Baptista. CVaR as a Measure of Risk: Implications for portfolio selection. Working Paper UCLA and university of Minnesota and university of Arizona, February 2003.http://paperd.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm
[8]Ander ,T. Bollerslev.T.Diebold & Labys.p(2000).Exchange rate returns standardized by realized volatility are (nearly) Gaussian(NBER woking papers,No.7488)
[9]Andersson, F.H. Mausser, D. Rosen and S. Uryasev. Credit risk optimization with conditional Value-at-Risk criterion. Mathematical Programming, Series B 89, 2001:273~291
[10]Artzner P , Delbaen F, Eber JM, Heah D. coherent measure of risk [J] Mathematical Finance, 1999,9(3):203~228
[11]Bank for international settlements.Public discosures by banks:results of the 2000 disclosures survey.Working paper,May 2002.
[12]Bank of Finland .A value-at-risk approach to banks capital buffers:an application to the new basel accord.Working paper,2001,9,8.
[13]Bankers Trust New York Corporation,RAROC and Risk Management:Quantifying the Risks of Business[M],New York:Bankers Trust New York Corpotation,1995.
[14]Basak, S. and A. Shapiro, 2001, “Value-at-Risk Based Risk Management: Optimal Policies and Asset Prices”, Review of Financial Studies 14, 371–405.
[15]Basel committee on Banking supervision .The Standardized Approach to Credit Risk, Supporting Document to the New Basel Capital Accord, Consultative Document(2001)
[16]Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (2003) The New Basel Capital Accord.Third consultative document. http://www.bis.org/bcbs/cp3full.pdf
[17]Basel committee on Banking supervision .Sound Practices for the Management and Supervision of Operational Risk,Basel,February 2003.
[18]Basel committee on Banking supervision .The New Basel Capital Accord ,Consultative Document. Bank For International Settlements, Basel, January 2001
[19]Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, 2002. Basel committee reaches agreement on new capital accord issues. Press release, July 10, 2002. Available from http://www.bis .org/
[20]Basel committee on Banking supervision. Overview of the New Basel Capital Accord, Consultative Document (2001c),January 2001
[21]Besis,J.I.Risk Management in Banking[M] ,2nd edition,John Wiley & sons,2002.
[22]BILLIO, M. and L. PELIZZON (2000): “Value-at-Risk: a Multivariate Switching Regime Approach”, Journal of Empirical Finance, Vol. 7, No.5, 531-554
[23]BIS 2001, Basle Committee on Banking Supervision (2001), Consultative Document, The New Basel Capital Accord, http://www.bis.org .
[24]Black F, Scholes M. The pricing of options and corporate liabilities[J].Journal of Political Economy,1974,81:637~654
[25]Bogentoft E, Romeijn H E, Uryasev S. Asset/liability management for pension funds using CVaR constraints[J].Journal of Risk Finance,2001,3:57~71
[26]Bollerslev,T R.Chou Y,KRONER K F(1992). ARCH modeling in finance: A review of the theory and empirical evidence[J].Journal of Econometrics 52:5~59
[27]Canada Imperial Bank of Commerce(CIBC),Annual Report,1999.
[28]Carey,M.Credit Risk in Private Debt Portfolios[J],Journal of Finance,August,pp:1363~1387.
[29]Carty,I.V & D.Lieberman.Corporate Defaulted Bank Load Recoveries,Moody’s Investor Services,Global Credit Research,Special Report,January.
[30]Castellacci G, Siclari M J. The practice of Delta-Gamma VaR: Implementing the quadratic portfolio model[J].European Journal of Operational Research,2003,150:529~525
[31]Cherif Guermat, Richard D.F. Harris(2002).Forecasting value at risk allowing for time variation in the variance and kurtosis of portfolio returns[J] .International Journal of Forecasting 19:409~419
[32]CommerzbankAnnual Report: 1999~2003. http://www.citydata.bvdep.com/ip6/Bankscope/
[33]Credit-Suisse-Financial-Products, 1997. CreditRiskt: A Credit Risk Management Framework, Technical Document, available from htpp://www.csfb.com/creditrisk.
[34]Cristiano Zazzara.Credit risk in the traditional banking books:a var approach under correlated default.paper by presented at the IX International Tor Vergata Conference on banking and finance(November 16,2000)
[35]Crouhy, M., Galai, D., Mark, R., 2000. A comparative analysis of current credit risk models. Journal of Banking and Finance 24, 59–117.
[36]Cuoco, D. and H. Liu, 2000, “A Martingale Characterization of Consumption Choices and Hedging Costs with Margin Requirements”, Mathematical Finance 10, 355–385.
[37]Danielsson J, Casper Gde Vries. Beyond the sample of extreme quantile and probability estimation. Mimeo, Tinbergen Institute Rotterdam[M].1997a
[38]Danielsson J, Casper Gde Vries. Tail index and quantile extimation with very high frequency data [J].Journal of Empirical Finance 1997b,4:241~257
[39]Danielsson, J., H.-S. Shin, and J.-P. Zigrand, 2001, Asset Price Dynamics with Value-at-Risk Constrained Traders," Working paper, Department of Accounting and Finance, and Financial Markets Group, London School of Economics.
[40]De Schepper, A, Goovaerts & M .J[1999].The GARCH(1,1)-M model: results for the densities of the variance and the mean[J].Insurance Mathematics and Economics,24:83~94
[41]Denault, M. (2001). “Coherent allocation of risk capital,” Journal of Risk4, 1-34.
[42]Dermine,J,Pitfalls in the Application of RAROC in Loan Management[J],The Arbitrageur,1998,1,1,21~27.
[43]Dhaene, J., M.J. Goovaerts & R. Kaas (2003a). “Capital allocation derived from risk measures,” North American Actuarial Journal 7, 44-59.
[44]Domenico Cuoco, Hong Liu. An Analysis of VaR-based Capital Requirement. http://www.gloriamundi .org
[45]Don M. Chance. A Introduction to Derivatives and Risk Management(5th)[M]. Harcourt, inc.2001
[46]Dowd K. Beyond value at risk. New York: John Wiley & Sons.1998
[47]Embrechts, P. (Ed.) (2000), Extremes and Integrated Risk Management,Risk Books, Risk Waters Group, London
[48]Emmer, S., C. Kl¨uppelberg and R. Korn, 2001, “Optimal Portfolios with Bounded Capital at Risk”, Mathematical Finance 11, 365–384.
[49]Engle .Robert, ”Dynamic Conditional Correlation: A New Simple Class of Multivariate GARCH Models”. Forthcoming JBES(2002)
[50]Engle Robert, ”New Frontiers FOR ARCH Models”. Journal of Applied Econometrics 17(2002): 425~446
[51]Engle, R. F(1982).Autoregressive conditional hetero-skeodasticity with estimates of the variance of united kingdom inflation[J].Econometrics,50:987~1008
[52]Enrique Sentana etal.Mean-Variance portfolio allocation with a value at risk constraint.Working paper No.0105,June 2001,www.cemfi.es
[53]Fama E. F The Behavior of stock prices[J].Journal of Business,1965,37:34~105
[54]FDIC. Basel and the Evolution of Capital Regulation:Moving Forward and Looking Back.2003.
[55]Fischer T.; Risk capital allocation by coherent risk measures based on one-sided moments,Insurance: Mathematics and Economics 32(1) (2003)
[56]Frederic Johanson, Michael J. Seiler,Mikael Tjarnberg[1999].Measuring downside portfolio risk[J].The journal of portfolio Management(5):96~107
[57]Fredrik Andersson, Helmut Mausser, Dan Rosen Stanislar Uryasev(2001).Credit Risk Optimization with conditional value-at-risk .Math Program, ser.B 89:273~291
[58]Freixas, X. and A.M. Santomero, 2002, “An Overall Perspective on Banking Regulation”,Working Paper no. 02-1, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia.
[59]Frerik Andersson etal.Credit risk optimization with conditional value-at risk criterion.Math Program,2001, Ser.B89:273~291
[60]Frey, R. and McNeil, A. (2004) Dependent Defaults in Models of Portfolio Credit Risk. To appear in Journal of Risk 6(1).
[61]Frey, R., McNeil, A., 2001. Modelling dependent defaults, Preprint, ETH Z€urich, available from http://www.math.ethz.ch/_frey.
[62]Frey, R., McNeil, A., Nyfeler, N., 2001. Copulas and credit models. Risk 10, 111–114.
[63]GeorgCh. Pflug. Some Remarks on the value-at-risk and conditional Value–at-risk[A]. georg.plug@univis.ac.at
[64]Gordy, M. (2003) A Risk-Factor Model Foundation for Ratings-Based Bank CapitalRules. Journal of Financial Intermediation 12(3), 199-232.
[65]Gordy, M., 2000. A comparative anatomy of credit risk models. Journal of Banking and Finance 24, 119–149.
[66]Gordy, M., 2001. A risk-factor model foundation for ratings-based bank capital rules, Working Paper.
[67]Grandell, J., 1997. Mixed Poisson Processes. Chapman and Hall, London.
[68]Hallerbach WG. Decomposing porfolio value-at-risk: A general analysis.[working paper].Rotterdam.Erasmus University Rotterdam and Tinbergen Institute Graduate School of Economics,1999
[69]Imad A.moosa, Bernard Bollen(2002).A benchmark for measuring bias in estimated daily value at risk{J}.International review of financial analysis 11:85~100
[70]J.P.Morgan Chase, Annual Report,2001.
[71]J.P.Morgan Securities Inc.Risk Management Research.Modeling Credit Migration.Working paper,March 17,2000.
[72]Jackson, P.,D.J, Maude and W.Perraudin.Bank Capital and Value-at-Risk.Journal of Derivatives,4(Spring),1997,pp:73~90.
[73]Jeremy Berkowitz and James Obrien.How accurate are value-at-risk models at commercial banks.The Journal of Finance,2002(3)
[74]Jin Wang .Mean-Variance-VaR Based Portfolio Optimization. http://www.gloriamundi .org
[75]Jorion, P., 2001. Value at Risk: The New Benchmark for Measuring Financial Risk. McGraw-Hill, New York.
[76]Jose A.Lopez,2004.The Empirical relationship between average asset correlation,firm probability of default and asset size.Financial Intermediation[J],13,265-283
[77]Jurczenko, E., and B. Maillet. “The Three-Moment CAPM: Theoretical Foundations and an Asset Pricing Models Comparison.” Working paper, 2001
[78]Kaas, R., M.J. Goovaerts, J. Dhaene & M. Denuit (2001). Modern Actuarial Risk Theory, Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
[798]Kealhofer, S. and J.R.Bohn.Portfolio Management of Credit Risk,KMV LTC,2001,http://www.kmv.com.
[80]Keith Cuthbertson, Dirk Nitzsche. Financial Engineering Derivatives and Risk Management [M].John Wiley & Sons,Ltd. 2001
[81]King, J.L. Operational Risk:Measurement and Modeling[M].2001 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
[82]KMV-Corporation, 1997. Modelling default risk, Technical Document, available from http://www.kmv.com.
[83]Lamoureux C G, Lastraps W D[1990]. Heteroskedasticity in stock return data: volume versus GARCH effects[J].Journal of Finance,55:221~229
[84]Leippold, M., F. Trojani and P. Vanini, 2001, “Equilibrium Impact of Value-at-Risk”,Working Paper, University of Zurich.
[85]Lintner J. The valuation of risk assets and the selection of risky investments in stock portfolios and capital budgets[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1965,47:13~37
[86]MANFREDO, M.R. and R.M. LEUTHOLD (2001): “Market Risk and the Cattle Feeding Margin: An Application of Value-at-Risk”, Agribusiness: An International Journal, Vol.17, No.3, 333-353
[87]Mark Carey.A guide to choosing absolute bank capital requirements.Journal of Banking & Finance26(2002)929~951
[88]Markowitz, H., 1952. Portfolio Selection. Journal of Finance 7, 77-91.
[89]Matten,C.,Managing Bank Capital[M],2nd edit.,New York,John Wiley&Sons,2000.
[90]Mausser.H, Rosen. D. (1999):Applying Scenario Optimization to Portfolio Credit Risk . Algores. Quartz,19-33
[91]Merton R. The theory of rational option pricing [J].Journal of Economic Theory,1976,13:341~361
[92]Merton, R., 1974. On the pricing of corporate debt: The risk structure of interest rates. Journal of Finance 29, 449–470.
[93]Michel Crouhy, Dan Galai & Robert Mark . Risk Management[M] . McGraw-Hil Companies, Inc.2001
[94]Michel Crouhy, Dan Galai, Robert Mark. A Comparative Analysis of Current Credit Risk Models. Journal of Banking & Finance ,24(2000):59~117
[95]Moody’s special report, (2000), ’The Lognormal Method Applied to ABS Analysis’.
[96]Moody’s special report, (2003), ’Residential Mortgage Servicer Quality (”SQ”) Ratings in EMEA Analysis: Moody’s Methodology’.
[97]Moodys investors service for global credit research. Moodys rating migration and credit quality correlation 1920~1996.working paper , July 1997.
[98]Morgan , J.P(1996). Risk metrics technical document(4th ed.)
[99]Mossin J. Equilibrium in a capital asset market[J].Econometrica,1966,34:768~783
[100]Najard M, Yung K[1991].A GARCH examination of the relationship between volume and price variability in futures markets[J].Journal of Futures Markets,11:613~621
[101]Oldrich Vasick.2002,Load portfolio value,Risk[J],12,160-162
[102]Overbeck, L. (2000). “Allocation of economic capital in loan portfolios,” In:Measuring Risk in Complex Systems, ed. J. Franke, W. Haerdle & G. Stahl,Heidelberg: Springer Verlag.
[103]Patricia Jackson etal. Bank capital and value at risk.Working paper ,Bank of England 1998,ISSN 1368-5562.
[104]Philippe Jorion . Value at risk [M]. New York: The McGraw-Hill Inc, 2001(2nd )
[105]Philippe Jorion . Value at risk: The new benchmark for controlling market risk[M]. New York:The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc, 1997
[106]Philippe Jorion.How information are value-at-risk disclosures?.The Accounting Review,2002(4)
[107]Plug G .Some remarks on the Value-at-Risk and the conditional Value-at-Risk[A].S. Uryasev Ed. Probabilistic Constrained Optimization: Methodology and Applications[C].Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers,2000
[108]R.Tyrrell Rockafellerand Stanislaw Uryaesv. Conditional value-at-risk for General Loss Distribution Research Report. http://www.glorianmundi.org
[109]Renault and H. S. Shin (2001), An Academic Response to Basel II, Special Paper Series, No 130, London School of Economics Financial Markets Group and ESRC Research Center, May 2001
[110]RiskMetrics-Group, 1997. CreditMetrics, Technical Document, available fromhttp://www.riskmetrics.com/research.
[111]RiskMetricsGroup.RiskManagement:Practical guide[M].1999,http://www.riskmetrics.com.
[112]Rochet, J.-C., 1999, “Solvency Regulations and the Management of Banking Risks”, European Economic Review 43, 981–990.
[113]Rockafellar R T, Uryasev S. Conditional Value-at-Risk for general loss distributions[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,2002,26:1443~1471
[114]Rockafellar R T, Uryasev S. Optimization of conditional Value-at-Risk[J].The Journal of Risk,2000,2:21~41
[115]Roy A D.Safety-first and the holding of assets[J].Economics,1952,20:431~449
[116]Rubinstein M.Markowitz’s “Portfolio Selection”:A fifty year restropective[J].Journal of Finance,2002,57:1041~1045
[117]Santos, J.A.C., 2002, “Bank Capital Regulation in Contemporary Banking Theory: A Review of the Literature”, BIS Working Paper no. 90, Bank for International Settlements.
[118]Susanne Emmer,Dirk Tasche2003,Calculating credit risks capital charges with the one-factor,Susanne.emmer@nagler-company.com
[119]SAUNDERS, A. (1999): Financial Institutions Management: A modern Perspective (3rd edit.). Irwin Series in Finance, McGraw-Hill, New York
[120]Saunders, A. Financeal Institution Management: A Modern Perspective {M},3nd Edition ,1999,McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
[121]Scotiabank. Annual Report(2000~2003).http://www.citydata.bvdep.com/ip6/Bankscope/
[122]Sharp W. Capital asset prices: A theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk[J]Journal of Finance,1964,19:425~442
[123]Stefan. R., Quantile-VaR is the Wrong Measure to Quantify Market Risk for Regulatory Purpose. Working Paper, March 6,2001.
[124]Tasche, D. and Theiler, U. (2003) Calculating Concentration-Sensitive Capital Charges with Conditional Value-at-Risk. Working paper.http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0309003
[125]Thomas dangl and Alfred Lehar.Value-at-risk vs. buliding block regulation in banking.Journal of Financial Intermediation,January 2002.
[126]Thomas Ho and Mark Abbott.Value at risk of a banks balance sheet.International Journal of and Applied Finances,1999(1):43~58
[127]Topaloglou N, Vladimirou H, Zenios S A. CVaR Models with selective hedging for international asset allocation[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,2002,26:1535~1561
[128]Tsanakas, A. (2003). “Dynamic capital allocation with distortion risk measures,”Working Paper Imperial College London.
[129]Ursula Theiler.Determination of Risk Return Efficient Bank Portfolios.2003ISINI Conference,http://www.ursula-theiler.de
[130]Uryasev S. conditional value at risk: optimization algorithms and application [N]. Financial engineering news 14,February 2000,1~5
[131]Uryasev S.Dordrecht. Constrained Optimization: Methodolgy and Applications [C]. Kluner Academic Publishers. 2000,272~281
[132]Wlater, C. and J.Lopez.Is Implied Correlation Worth Calculating:Evidence From FX Options and Historical Data,Swiss National Bank Working Paper,2000
[133]Zaik E,Walter,J.,Kelling.J.G.,RAROC at Bank of America:From Theory to Practice[J].Journal of Applied Corporate Finance,Summer,1996,9,2,83~93
[134]Zhu S S, Li D, Wang S Y. Myopic efficiency in multi-period portfolio selection with mean-variance formulation[A].s. Chen etal. Eds. Lecture Notes in Decision SciencesⅡ: Finance Systems Engineering[M].Hong Kong: Global-Link Publisher,2003
[135]Zhu S S, Li D, Wang S Y. Risk control over bankruptcy in dynamic portfolio selection: A generalized mean-variance formulation[J].IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control,2004,49:447~457
[136]陈毅恒著,黄长全译.时间序列与金融数据分析[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2004,8
[137] 韩 其 恒 , 唐 万 生 , 李 光 泉 . 机 会 约 束 下 的 投 资 组 合 问 题 [ J ] 系 统 工 程 学报,2002,17(1):87-91
[138]李仲飞,汪寿阳.投资组合优化与无套利分析[M]. 北京:科学出版社,2001
[139]邵宇.微观金融学及其数学基础[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2003,11
[140]沈沛龙, 任若恩. 新巴赛尔协议资本充足率计算方法[J] 金融研究,2002,(6):34-38
[141]王春峰.金融市场风险管理[M].天津:天津大学出版社,2001.
[142]吴冲锋,王海成,吴文峰.金融工程研究[M],上海交通大学出版社,2002。
[143]易丹辉.数据分析与 EVIEWS 应用[M].北京:中国统计出版社,2002,10
[144]詹原瑞.银行信用风险的现代度量与管理[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2004,11
[145]赵先信. 银行内部模型和监管模型:风险计量与资本分配[M].上海:上海人民出版社, 2004,6
[146][美]汉普尔等著,陈雨露等译.银行管理—教程与案例(第五版)[M].北京:中国人民大 学出版社,2001,4