基于风险分析的危险品道路运输路径优化方法研究
|
摘要
随着工业化的发展,危险品的生产量和运输量与年俱增,对人类安全健康和自然环境的危害正在逐步扩大和加深。据统计,我国95%以上的危险品涉及异地运输问题,其中82%左右是通过道路运输的,年运输量达2亿吨左右。由于危险品道路运输量大、通行车辆事故率高和运输企业安全管理水平落后,近年来灾难性事故频发,后果极其严重。危险品道路运输既是一个倍受关注的社会公共安全问题,也是一个重要的战略和战术决策问题。基于运输过程风险分析的路径优化研究可降低危险品道路运输事故率和沿线人员伤亡风险,为政府监管部门和危险品生产经营单位的运输安全规划提供决策技术支持,补充和完善了移动危险源风险评价理论及技术方法。
本文首先系统地概述了国内外危险品运输管理、风险分析和路径优化选线的研究现状、发展趋势及存在的主要问题,通过典型事故案例统计分析探讨了危险品运输事故发生的特点及控制对策,辨识了主要的运输路径风险影响因素和非运输路径风险影响因素,并以危险品危险性权重等级和运输事故易发性系数来表征其风险特性。在此基础上,从道路运输网、运输危险源和影响区域3方面提出了危险品运输过程风险评价程序,引入了危险品运输事故易发性校正系数和道路固有特征、天气条件和交通状况3类风险修正因子,提出了危险品运输路径优化的影响区人员伤亡风险和环境风险评价模型以及可快速风险分级的指数评价方法,并结合影响区人员死亡概率系数给出了个人风险和单位长度(通常为1km)社会风险计算模型以及可接受风险标准。
同时,在危险品运输过程风险分析的基础上阐述了以人员伤亡风险为主的路径优化选线的内涵、特点、原则及基本方法,提出了危险品道路运输路径优化的基本程序和双层选线管理模式;以运输路径沿线影响区人员伤亡风险大小为优化选线的基准,从危险品、道路特征、伤亡人员、运输环境、应急能力、运输成本等方面构建了危险品道路运输路径优化评价指标体系,重点研究了单目标比例权重法选线和多目标Pareto最优化选线两种路径优化方法,采用权数调整节点标号算法和边线标号算法搜索最小运输事故率路径和最少影响区人员总数路径;分析了气象条件对路径优化选线的影响以及时间因素与危险品运输事故率和影响区人员密度的关系,提出了具有时变属性的影响区人员伤亡风险评价模型,可搜索最佳运输时间的最小人员伤亡风险路径,并进一步探讨了时变随机运输网的路径优化选线评价模型。
以天津地区液氯道路运输为例,定量评估了液氯运输过程泄漏事故率和灾难性事故后果以及人员伤亡风险和运输环境风险,优化决策最小运输风险和最低运输成本路径,有效降低了液氯运输灾难性事故风险,并以ArcGIS系统实现了可视化选线分析。实例研究表明:面向运输道路特征的人员伤亡风险评价模型能够较准确地反映危险品运输过程的风险水平,以路径沿线影响区人员风险大小为基准的路径优化评价模型在解决危险品道路运输风险分析和路径优化评价的不确定性和简化计算方面是科学的、合理的,具有良好的可操作性,可为危险品监管部门和运输企业提供选线决策技术支持。
Along with the development of industrialized societies, the production capacity and transport volumes of hazardous materials (hazmat), or dangerous goods (DG) rapidly boost annual year, which results in an increasing potential danger to human health and natural environment. In China, about 95% hazmat must be transported from producers to end-users, more than 80% amount of which are through road, and annual traffic volume is up to near two hundred million tons. In resent years, due to the increasing of hazmat shipment volumes, high road accident rates and poor safety management level, some catastrophic accidents involving hazmat transport frequently occurred, which usually resulted in high casualties and great environment damage. Clearly, hazmat road transport is not only a hot issue of societal public safety, but also an important strategies and tactics decision-making problem. In this paper, in order to reduce hazmat transport risk for neighboring population and environment, a risk- analysis-based optimal routing methodology for hazmat transport by road is proposed, which supports the decision associated with safety management, optimal routing and emergency response for hazmat between local government and carriers, and perfects risk assessment theory and methodology on the moving hazard sources.
Firstly, the literature pertaining to risk assessment and optimal routing of hazmat transport by road is reviewed, and the current state and some questions of the art and theory and methodology used in previous hazmat transport management, risk analysis and optimal routing are identified. Based on the statistic analysis of typical hazmat transport accidents cases, the characteristics and rules of accidents are investigated as well as control countermeasure, and the route dependent risk factors and route independent risk factors are identified. Risk characteristics of transport hazmat are depicted by the hazmat average weighted risk rank and the modifying factors of accident-proneness. On this basis, by identifying transport network, vehicles or traveling risk sources and accident impact areas, a new comprehensive systematic procedure to assessment hazmat transport risk is faced, introducing the modifying factors of accident-proneness and three kinds of risk enhancing or mitigating factors including intrinsic road characteristics, meteorological conditions, and traffic conditions. Furthermore, a route-oriented population risk and environment risk models and a rapid risk rating index approach are presented. The individual risk and societal risk models integrated with death probability coefficient of neighboring population along the hazmat route are analyzed, and the acceptability risk criterion on hazmat transport is discussed.
Secondly, according to the above-described risk assessment technique and methods for hazmat during road transport, the essential meanings, figures, principles and methods of a risk-analysis-based optimal routing methodology are illuminated, and a new and general framework for optimal routing of hazmat transport and bi-level management mode between local government and carriers are brought forward. The benchmark of optimal routing problem is dependent on the exposure population risk along the road, and the assessment framework to determine the best path of hazmat transport by road is built, which includes hazmat attributes and classifies, road characteristics, impact population distribution, traffic environmental condition, emergency response capability, transport cost and so on. It is emphasized on the scale weighted technique of single objective routing and the Pareto optimal method of multi-objective routing. Moreover, the minimum hazmat accident probability path and the least population exposure path are searched by adopting impedance-adjusting node labeling shortest path algorithm and link labeling shortest path algorithm, respective. Additionally, the influence of weather condition on hazmat routing and the characteristics of hazmat accidents probability and impact population density varying with time are discussed, and a population risk model with time attribute is presented to search the minimum population risk at the best time. And the optimal routing of hazmat in time-varying, stochastic road transportation is also investigated deeply. Thirdly, the case study for liquefied chlorine road transport in Tientsin region was systematically investigated, and quantified the release probability, catastrophic consequences, population risk, environment risk and other routing criterions, some of which were shown by the ArcGIS system. According to the above-proposed risk assessment and routing methods, the optimal routing for liquefied chlorine transport by road was determined, and it reduced neighboring population and environment risk for the used route. The case study suggests the route-oriented risk assessment model determine the risk level of hazmat during road transport well and truly, and the optimal routing methods based on the population risk along the used route decrease hazmat transport accidents frequency and catastrophic consequences and help the associated routing decision-making for hazmat.
本文首先系统地概述了国内外危险品运输管理、风险分析和路径优化选线的研究现状、发展趋势及存在的主要问题,通过典型事故案例统计分析探讨了危险品运输事故发生的特点及控制对策,辨识了主要的运输路径风险影响因素和非运输路径风险影响因素,并以危险品危险性权重等级和运输事故易发性系数来表征其风险特性。在此基础上,从道路运输网、运输危险源和影响区域3方面提出了危险品运输过程风险评价程序,引入了危险品运输事故易发性校正系数和道路固有特征、天气条件和交通状况3类风险修正因子,提出了危险品运输路径优化的影响区人员伤亡风险和环境风险评价模型以及可快速风险分级的指数评价方法,并结合影响区人员死亡概率系数给出了个人风险和单位长度(通常为1km)社会风险计算模型以及可接受风险标准。
同时,在危险品运输过程风险分析的基础上阐述了以人员伤亡风险为主的路径优化选线的内涵、特点、原则及基本方法,提出了危险品道路运输路径优化的基本程序和双层选线管理模式;以运输路径沿线影响区人员伤亡风险大小为优化选线的基准,从危险品、道路特征、伤亡人员、运输环境、应急能力、运输成本等方面构建了危险品道路运输路径优化评价指标体系,重点研究了单目标比例权重法选线和多目标Pareto最优化选线两种路径优化方法,采用权数调整节点标号算法和边线标号算法搜索最小运输事故率路径和最少影响区人员总数路径;分析了气象条件对路径优化选线的影响以及时间因素与危险品运输事故率和影响区人员密度的关系,提出了具有时变属性的影响区人员伤亡风险评价模型,可搜索最佳运输时间的最小人员伤亡风险路径,并进一步探讨了时变随机运输网的路径优化选线评价模型。
以天津地区液氯道路运输为例,定量评估了液氯运输过程泄漏事故率和灾难性事故后果以及人员伤亡风险和运输环境风险,优化决策最小运输风险和最低运输成本路径,有效降低了液氯运输灾难性事故风险,并以ArcGIS系统实现了可视化选线分析。实例研究表明:面向运输道路特征的人员伤亡风险评价模型能够较准确地反映危险品运输过程的风险水平,以路径沿线影响区人员风险大小为基准的路径优化评价模型在解决危险品道路运输风险分析和路径优化评价的不确定性和简化计算方面是科学的、合理的,具有良好的可操作性,可为危险品监管部门和运输企业提供选线决策技术支持。
Along with the development of industrialized societies, the production capacity and transport volumes of hazardous materials (hazmat), or dangerous goods (DG) rapidly boost annual year, which results in an increasing potential danger to human health and natural environment. In China, about 95% hazmat must be transported from producers to end-users, more than 80% amount of which are through road, and annual traffic volume is up to near two hundred million tons. In resent years, due to the increasing of hazmat shipment volumes, high road accident rates and poor safety management level, some catastrophic accidents involving hazmat transport frequently occurred, which usually resulted in high casualties and great environment damage. Clearly, hazmat road transport is not only a hot issue of societal public safety, but also an important strategies and tactics decision-making problem. In this paper, in order to reduce hazmat transport risk for neighboring population and environment, a risk- analysis-based optimal routing methodology for hazmat transport by road is proposed, which supports the decision associated with safety management, optimal routing and emergency response for hazmat between local government and carriers, and perfects risk assessment theory and methodology on the moving hazard sources.
Firstly, the literature pertaining to risk assessment and optimal routing of hazmat transport by road is reviewed, and the current state and some questions of the art and theory and methodology used in previous hazmat transport management, risk analysis and optimal routing are identified. Based on the statistic analysis of typical hazmat transport accidents cases, the characteristics and rules of accidents are investigated as well as control countermeasure, and the route dependent risk factors and route independent risk factors are identified. Risk characteristics of transport hazmat are depicted by the hazmat average weighted risk rank and the modifying factors of accident-proneness. On this basis, by identifying transport network, vehicles or traveling risk sources and accident impact areas, a new comprehensive systematic procedure to assessment hazmat transport risk is faced, introducing the modifying factors of accident-proneness and three kinds of risk enhancing or mitigating factors including intrinsic road characteristics, meteorological conditions, and traffic conditions. Furthermore, a route-oriented population risk and environment risk models and a rapid risk rating index approach are presented. The individual risk and societal risk models integrated with death probability coefficient of neighboring population along the hazmat route are analyzed, and the acceptability risk criterion on hazmat transport is discussed.
Secondly, according to the above-described risk assessment technique and methods for hazmat during road transport, the essential meanings, figures, principles and methods of a risk-analysis-based optimal routing methodology are illuminated, and a new and general framework for optimal routing of hazmat transport and bi-level management mode between local government and carriers are brought forward. The benchmark of optimal routing problem is dependent on the exposure population risk along the road, and the assessment framework to determine the best path of hazmat transport by road is built, which includes hazmat attributes and classifies, road characteristics, impact population distribution, traffic environmental condition, emergency response capability, transport cost and so on. It is emphasized on the scale weighted technique of single objective routing and the Pareto optimal method of multi-objective routing. Moreover, the minimum hazmat accident probability path and the least population exposure path are searched by adopting impedance-adjusting node labeling shortest path algorithm and link labeling shortest path algorithm, respective. Additionally, the influence of weather condition on hazmat routing and the characteristics of hazmat accidents probability and impact population density varying with time are discussed, and a population risk model with time attribute is presented to search the minimum population risk at the best time. And the optimal routing of hazmat in time-varying, stochastic road transportation is also investigated deeply. Thirdly, the case study for liquefied chlorine road transport in Tientsin region was systematically investigated, and quantified the release probability, catastrophic consequences, population risk, environment risk and other routing criterions, some of which were shown by the ArcGIS system. According to the above-proposed risk assessment and routing methods, the optimal routing for liquefied chlorine transport by road was determined, and it reduced neighboring population and environment risk for the used route. The case study suggests the route-oriented risk assessment model determine the risk level of hazmat during road transport well and truly, and the optimal routing methods based on the population risk along the used route decrease hazmat transport accidents frequency and catastrophic consequences and help the associated routing decision-making for hazmat.
引文
[1] 关于危险货物运输的建议书·规章范本(第十三修订版). 联合国. 纽约和日内瓦. 2003年[EB/OL].[2006-08-6]. http://www.unece.org/trans/danger/publi/unrec/rev13/13file sc.html.
[2] 国家重点科技项目攻关计划《工业危险品公路运输安全管理系统技术研究》,工业危险品公路运输风险分析方法研究[R]. 国家安全生产监督管理局安全科学技术研究中心,2003.
[3] Paolo Leonelli, Sarah Bonvicini, Gigliola Spadoni. New detailed numerical procedures for calculating risk measures in hazardous materials transportation [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,1999,12(6): 507-515.
[4] Advisory Committee on Dangerous Substances. Major hazard aspects of the transport of dangerous substances [R]. London: HSE,1991.
[5] 科技引领运输安全我国危险品运输现状分析[EB/OL]. 2006-07-14 [2006-8-10].中国建材信息总网, http://www.bm.cei.gov.cn/allfile/49/2006071410235749141.asp.
[6] Centre for Chemical Process Safety of AIChE. Guidelines for chemical process quantitative risk analysis. New York, 1989.
[7] G.F. List, P.B. Mirchandani, M. Turnquist, K.G. Zografos. Modeling and analysis for hazardous materials transportation: Risk analysis, routing/scheduling and facility location[J] Transportation Science, 1991,25 (2):100-114.
[8] Erhan Erkut, Vedat Verter. Modeling of Transport risk for hazardous materials [J]. Operations Research.1998,46(5):625-642.
[9] Erhan Erkut, Armann Ingolfsson.Transport risk models for hazardous materials: revisited [J]. Operations Research Letters,2005,33(1):81-89.
[10] 周珣. 基于道路危险货物运输安全的路线优化研究[D]. 长安大学硕士学位论文, 2004.
[11] Wijeratne AB. Routing and Scheduling Decisions in the Management of Hazardous Material Shipments[D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, 1990.
[12] Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Highway routing of hazardous materials guidelines for applying criteria [R]. Report No. FHWA-HI-97-003, U.S.DOT, 1996.
[13] P. Leonelli, S. Bonvicini, G. Spadoni. Hazardous materials transportation: a risk-analysis-based routing methodology [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2000,71(1-3): 283-300.
[14] Huang.B, Fery.P,Zhang. Multiobjective Optimization for hazardous materials transportation [J].Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2005(1906):64-73.
[15] Jianjun Zhang, John Hodgson, Erhan Erkut. Using GIS to assess the risks of hazardous materials transport in networks. European Journal of Operational Research[J],2000,121(2):316-329.
[16] Roberto, Sergio Di Cave, Barbara Mazzarotta. Risk analysis for road and rail transport of hazardous materials: a GIS approach [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 2004,17(6): 483-488.
[17] 庄英伟. LPG 罐车公路运输风险评价方法及应用研究[D]. 北京:首都经贸大学,2004.
[18] 于群利. 有关危险品化学品管理的国际规章介绍[J]. 化工标准·计量·质量,2004,7:46～48
[19] CCPS. Guidelines for chemical transportation risk analysis [M ].New York: AICHE, 1995.
[20] 吴宗之.国内外安全(风险)评价方法研究与进展[A].二十一世纪安全科学与技术的发展趋势.北京: 科技出版社,2000.
[21] Ang A., Briscoe J. et al. Development of a systems risk methodology for single and multimodal transportation systems [R]. Final Report, Office of University Research, US DOT, Washington, DC,1989.
[22] A.G. Hobeika,B.Jamei,I.B.Santoso. Selection of preferred Highway Routes for the Shipment of Spent Nuclear Fuel Between Surry and North Anna Power Stations in Virginia. In: Recent Advance in hazardous materials transportation research: An International Exchange,67-73,U.S.Department of Transportation, Transportation Research Board, Washington,D.C.,1986.
[23] D.Kessler,Establishing Hazardous Materials Truck Routes for Shipments Through the Dallas-fort Worth Area. In: Recent Advance in hazardous materials transportation research: An International Exchange,79-87,U.S.Department of Transportation, Transportation Research Board, Washington,D.C.,1986.
[24] J.W.Cashwell,K.S.Neuhauser,P.C.Reaprdon,et al. Transportation Impacts of the Commercial Radioactive Waste Management Program [R]. Report SAND85-2715, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque,N.M.,1986.
[25] Bottelbergha P H. Risk analysis and safety policy developments in the Netherlands [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2000,71(1-3):59-84.
[26] M.Considine. Risk assessment of the transportation of hazardous substances through road Tunnels. In: Recent Advance in hazardous materials transportation research: An International Exchange,178-185,U.S.Department of Transportation, Transportation Research Board, Washington,D.C.,1986.
[27] F.F. Saccomanno, A. Chan, Economic evaluation of routing strategies for hazardous road shipments[J], Transp. Res. Record,1985,1020:12-18.
[28] T.S.Glickman. Benchmark estimates of release accident rates in hazardous materials transportation of rail and truck [J]. Trans.Res.Rec.,1988,1193:22-28.
[29] Niels Peter Hφj, Wolfgang Kroger. Risk analyses of transportation on road and railway from a European Perspective [J]. Safety Science, 2002,40(1-4):337-357.
[30] Roberto Bubbico, Cinzia Ferrari, Barbara Mazzarotta. Risk Analysis of LPG Transport by Road and Rail [J]. Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 2000,13(1):27-31.
[31] S. Bonvicini, P. Leonelli, G. Spadoni,Risk analysis of hazardous materials transportation:evaluating uncertainty by means of fuzzy logic[J],Journal of Hazardous Materials, 1998,62(1):59-74.
[32] Ertugrul Alp, Michael J.Zelensky. Risk quantification for meteorology and direction dependent hazards due to point and linear risk sources [J]. J.Loss Prev.Process Ind, 1996, 9 (2):135-145.
[33] Fabiano B., Currò F., Palazzi E., et al. A framework for risk assessment and decision-making strategies in dangerous good transportation [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2002,93(1):1-15.
[34] Fabiano B., Currò F., Reverberi A.P., et al. Dangerous good transportation by road: from risk analysis to emergency planning [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2005,18(4-6): 403-413.
[35] Erhan Erkut, Vedat Verter. A Framework of Hazardous Materials Transport Risk Assessment[J]. Risk Analysis,1995,15(5):589-600.
[36] E. Erkut, A. Ingolfsson. Catastrophe avoidance models for hazardous materials route planning [J]. Transp. Sci, 2000,34(2):165-179.
[37] E. Alp, Risk-based transportation planning practice: overall methodology and a case example, INFOR,1995,33(1):4-19.
[38] Saccomanno F.F., Van Aerde M, Queen D. Interactive selection of minimum-risk routes for dangerous shipments [J]. Transportation Research Records,1987,1148:9-17.
[39] C ReVelle, J Cohon, D Shobrys. Simultaneous siting and routing in the disposal of hazardous wastes[J], Transp. Sci.1991,25(2),138-145.
[40] M Abkowitz, M Lepofsky, P Cheng. Selecting criteria for designating hazardous materials highway routes[J], Transp. Res.Rec,1992,1333:30-35.
[41] R.A. Sivakumar, R. Batta, M.H. Karwan. Establishing credible risk criteria for transporting extremely dangerous hazardous materials, in: F.F. Saccomanno, K. Cassidy(Eds.), Transportation of Dangerous Goods: Assessing the Risks, Institute for Risk Research, University of Waterloo, 1993.
[42] R.A. Sivakumar, R. Batta, M.H. Karwan. A network-based model for transporting extremely hazardous materials[J], Oper.Res. Lett,1993,13:85-93.
[43] Rajeshwar Rao, K., Venkateswar Rao S., Chary,V. Estimation of risk indices of chemicals during transportation[J].Process Safety Progress,2004,23(2):149-154.
[44] Akgun, V, Amit.P, Rajan.B. Routing of a hazmat truck in the presence of weather systems[R]. Christopher M.Rump,Department of Applied Statistics and Operations Research Bowling Green State University Bowling Green, Ohio 43403, USA.
[45] Akgun, V. Routing of Hazardous Materials in the Presence of Weather Systems [D]. Unpub-lished Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Industrial Engineering, University at Bualo, SUNY, Bualo, NY, 14260, 2001.
[46] Parekh A. Time dependent shortest path algorithms for routing of hazardous materials in the presence of weather Systems[D]. Unpublished M.S. Thesis, Department of IndustrialEngineering, University at Bualo, SUNY, Bualo, NY, 14260, 2003.
[47] Scanmlon RD, Cantilli EJ. Assessing the risk and safety in the transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Transportation Research Record, 1985,1020:6-11.
[48] Bhanu Prakash Rao Madala. A Simulation Study for Hazardous Materials Transportation risk assessment [D]. D.Master, Concordia University, Montreal ,Quebec, Canada,2000.
[49] Bhavesh, R.G. Risk of transporting dangerous goods: South Durban case study [D]. Ma.D. dissertation, Civil engineering programme, University of KwaZulu-Natal,2005.
[50] Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Guidelines for applying criteria to designate routes for transporting hazardous materials (revised) [R]. Report No. FHWA-SA-94-083, Washington, D.C.,1994.
[51] Lepofsky, M., Abkowitz, M. & Cheng, P. Transportation hazard analysis in integrated GIS environment [J] Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2): 239-254.
[52] Harwood, D.W., Viner, J.G. & Russell, E.R. Procedure for developing truck accident and release rates for HAZMAT routing [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2):189-199.
[53] Pet-Armacost, J.J., Sepulveda, J. & Sakude M. Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis of unknown parameters in hazardous materials transportation risk assessment [J]. Risk Analysis, Society for Risk Analysis, 1999, 19(6): 1173-1184.
[54] Saccomanno, F.F. & Shortreed, J.H. Hazmat transport risk: societal and individual perspectives [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2):177-188.
[55] United States Department of Transportation (USDOT). Emergency Response Guidebook [M]. Research and Special Programs Administration, Office of Hazardous Materials Initiatives and Training, Washington, D.C.2004.
[56] 毕军, 王华东. 有害废物运输环境风险研究[J].中国环境科学,1995,15(4):241～246
[57] 孙猛,吴宗之,张宏元.危险化学品公路运输事故原因分析与对策[J].中国安全科学学报,2003,13(8):22～24
[58] 陈小能.危险货物运输的安全注意事项[J].工业安全与环保,2005,31(7):57～58
[59] 王艳华,佟淑娇,陈宝智,危险化学品道路运输系统危险性分析[J], 中国安全科学学报,2005,15(2):8～12
[60] 宇德明. 易燃、易爆、有毒危险品储运过程定量风险评价方法[M]. 北京:中国铁道出版社,2000,6
[61] 吴宗之等. 工业危险辨识与评价[M]. 北京: 气象出版社, 2000
[62] 吴宗之等. 危险评价方法及其应用[M]. 北京: 冶金工业出版社, 2001
[63] 张景林等. 危险化学品运输[M]. 北京: 化学工业出版社, 2006
[64] 吴宗之, 多英全, 刘茂等. 危险品道路运输过程风险分析与评价方法研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报,2004,12(s1):36～44
[65] 庄英伟,危险化学品公路运输定量风险分析方法探讨[J]. 中国职业安全卫生管理体系认证,2004,1:23～25
[66] 魏航, 李军. 时变条件下的有害物品运输的人口风险分析[J]. 中国安全科学学报,2004,14(10):95～98
[67] 魏 航 , 李 军 , 王 浩 . 有 害 物 品 运 输 的 总 风 险 分 析 [J]. 中 国 安 全 科 学 学 报 , 2005,15(12):97～101
[68] 魏航,魏洁.公路运输有害物品的外部成本分析[J].交通标准化,2005,64～68
[69] 郭晓琳,李军. 基于事故分级的有害物品运输路径风险度量模型研究[J].中国安全科学学报,2006,16(6):35～39
[70] 王刊良.有害危险物品后勤学的研究动态[J].系统工程理论与实践,2000,7:112～117
[71] 王刊良, 张朋柱. 有害危险物品运输风险的量化模型[R]. 第五届全国青年管理科学与系统科学论文集[C ], 天津: 南开大学出版社, 1999
[72] 王刊良, 徐寅峰, 汪应洛. 一个支持有害物品填埋场选址的决策支持系统[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 1997,17(11):60～65
[73] 任常兴, 吴宗之. 危险品道路运输选线问题分析[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2006,6(2):84～88
[74] 吴宗之, 任常兴. 危险品道路运输风险评价与优化选线的研究进展.安全与环境学报,2007,7(3)
[75] 任常兴, 吴宗之. 危险品道路运输风险分级指数法研究[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2006,6(4):126～129
[76] Harwood D.W., Russel E. R, Viner J. G. Characteristics of accidents and incidents in highway transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Transportation Research Records, 1990,1245:23-33.
[77] Saccomanno F. F, Van Aerde F, Shortreed J. H, Higgs J. Comparision of risk measures for the transport of dangerous commodities by truck and rail [J]. Transportation Research Records,1987,1245:1-13.
[78] 胡运权. 运筹学基础及应用[M]. 3 版. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学出版社, 2000
[79] 施光燕, 董加礼. 最优化方法[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 1999
[80] Zografos K.G., Androutsopoulos K.N. A heuristic algorithm for solving hazardous materials distribution problems [J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 2004, 152(2): 507-519.
[81] E.Dijkstra. A note on two problems in connection with graphs.Numer.Math,1959,1:269-271.
[82] Kessler D. Establishing hazardous materials trucks routes for shipments through the dallas-fort worth area [J]. State-of-the-Art Report, No.3, Transportation Research Board, 1986,79-87.
[83] R.Batta, S.Chiu. Optimal obnoxious paths on a network: transportation of Hazardous materials [J]. Opns.Res.1988,36(1):84-92.
[84] D.Shobrys. A model for the selection of shipping routes and storage locations for a hazardous substance [D].Ph.D. dissertation, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore,1981.
[85] J.Robbins. Routing hazardous materials shipments [D]. Ph.D. dissertation, Indiana University, Bloomington, Ind.,1981.
[86] J.R.Current, C.S.ReVelle, J.L.Cohon. The minimum-covering shortest path problem [J]. Decision Science,1988,19:490-503.
[87] R.G.Cox. Routing and scheduling of hazardous materials shipments: algorithmic approachesto managing spent nuclear fuel Transport [D]. Ph.D. dissertation, Cornell University,Ithaca,N.Y.,1984.
[88] R.G.Cox., M.A.Turnquist. Scheduling truck shipments of hazardous materials in the presences of curfews [J]. Trans. Res. Rec. 1986,1063:21-26.
[89] Zografos.K.G, Davis CF. Multi-objective programming approach for routing hazardous materials [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering 1989;115(6):661-673.
[90] Wijeratne, A. B., M. A. Turnquist, P. B. Mirchandani. Multiobjective Routing of Hazardous Materials in Stochastic Networks [J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 1993,65:33-43.
[91] Zografos.K,Samara.S. A combined location-routing model for hazardous waste transportation and disposal[J]. Transportation Research Record, 1990, 1245:52-59.
[92] J Current. A model to assess risk, equity and efficiency in facility location and transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Location Science,1995,3(3):187-201.
[93] Frank, W.C., Thill, J.-C., R. Batta. Spatial decision support system for hazardous material truck routing [J],Transportation Research Part C8,2000,8(16):337-359.
[94] Frank, W.C.. Hazardous material vehicle routing utilizing a decision support system and temporal road attributes [D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Industrial Engineering, University of New York at Buffalo, 2001.
[95] B.Y. Kara, E. Erkut, V. Verter. Accurate calculation of hazardous materials transport risks [J]. Operations Research Letters,2003,31(4):285-292.
[96] Zografos K.G., Vasilakis K.N., Androutsopoulos K.N. A real time decision support system for road network incident response logistics [J]. Transportation Research Part C,2002,10(1): 1-18.
[97] Huang, B., R. L. Cheu, Y. S. Liew. GIS and Genetic Algorithms for HazMat Route Planning with Security Considerations [J]. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2003,18(8): 769-787.
[98] E Erkut, Osman Alp. Designing a road network for hazardous materials shipments [J]. Computer & Operations Research, 2007,34(5):1389-1405.
[99] Angela L.Woods. Optimal Routing of Hazardous Substances in Time-Varying, Stochastic Transportation [R]. Department of Civil Engineering, University of Texas at Austin, ANRCP-1998-8.
[100] 沈小燕, 刘浩学, 周珣. 道路危险货物运输路线优化评价研究[J]. 中国安全生产科学技术,2006,2(1):76～79
[101] 边浩毅 季永青 李百川. 道路运输企业安全评价方法及实例分析[J].安全与环境学报,2006, 6(2):89～91
[102] 吴宗之, 任常兴. 基于风险分析的危险品道路运输选线指标研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报, 2006, 14(s1):146～152
[103] 薄瑞峰, 李瑞琴. 基于 Pareto 最优的概念结构方案多目标决策方法[J]. 西安交通大学学报,2006,40(9):1114～116
[104] REN Changxing, WU Zongzhi. Minimum risk route analysis of hazardous materials transportation. Progress in Safety Science and Technology Volume VI: Proceedings of the 2006 International Symposium on Safety Science and Technology, 2006,Part A:1950-1954.
[105] 任常兴, 吴宗之. 危险品道路安全运输路径优化方法探讨[J]. 中国安全科学学报,2006,16(6):129～134
[106] 石玉峰,门志强. 基于模糊多目标决策理论的军事运输路径优化研究[J], 交通运输工程与信息学报, 2004,2(1):112～116
[107] 刘云霞. 动态车辆调度问题分析及算法设计[D]. 西南交通大学研究生学位论文,2004.3
[108] 严季. 我国道路货物运输发展战略若干问题研究[D]. 长安大学博士论文,2003.11
[109] 余国才,周 伟.公路网布局优化的理论和方法[J],西安公路交通大学学报,1998,18(3):45～49
[110] 张 航. 高等级公路路线方案优化研究[J],武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版),2002,28(4):481～484
[111] Gopalan, R., K. Kolluri, R. Batta and M. Karwan. Modeling equity of risk in the transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Operations Research,1990, 38:961-973.
[112] Jin, H., R. Batta, M. Karwan. On the analysis of two new models for transporting hazardous materials [J]. Operations Research,1996,44:710-723.
[113] List, G. and P. Mirchandani. An integrated network/planar multiobjective model for routing and siting for hazardous materials and wastes [J]. Transportation Science, 1991, 25: 146-156.
[114] Miller-Hooks. Optimal routing in time-varying stochastic networks: algorithms and implementation [D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Texas at Austin,1997.
[115] Sivakumar, R., R. Batta and M. Karwan. A multiple route conditional risk model for transporting hazardous materials [J]. INFOR, 1995,33:20-33.
[116] Lassarre, S., Fedra, K. & Weigkricht, E. Computer-assisted routing of dangerous goods for Haute-Normandie [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2): 200-210.
[117] Ashtakala B. Methodology to determine safe routes for hazardous materials transportation [C]. CSCE Annual Conference, Montreal, Canada, 1993,3:567-575.
[118] ERKUT E., GLICKMAN, T. Minmax population exposure in routing highway shipments of hazardous materials [J]. Transportation Research Record,1997,1602:93-100.
[119] Ashtakala, B., Eno, Lucy A. Minimum risks route model for hazardous materials [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1996, 122(5):350-358.
[120] ALK Associates, ALK’s PC*HazRoute (Version 2.0), ALK Associates, Inc., 1000 Herron town Road, Princeton, NJ,USA,1994.
[121] Jianjun Zhang. Spatial analysis tools for hazardous materials transportation logistics [D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
[122] A.V. Gheorghe, R. Mock, W. Kroège. Risk assessment of regional systems [J].Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2000,70(2):141-156.
[123] 刘强, 高晖. 危险化学品运输安全统一监控平台的探讨和设想[J].中国安全科学学报,2006,16(2):59～64
[124] 李定邦, 程真. 基于GPS-GIS技术的危险化学品运输管理的构思[EB/OL]. 中国科技论文在线. 2005-09-20 [2006-08-10]. http://www.paper.edu.cn/process/download.jsp?File =200509-183.
[125] 王宏伟. 用人工智能突破传统管理模式—天泰雷兹安全监控管理系统在危险品运输中的广泛应用[J].中国物流与采购,2006,8:34～35
[126] 何凡, 王海燕. 一个实时的危险品运输公路网络模型[J]. 物流技术, 2005,10:267～269
[127] Ale BJM: Risk Criteria and Europe, paper presented at the Risk 2000 conference, 24 April 1997, London.
[128] Boult M: Risk Management of LPG Transport Activities in Hong Kong, presented to the Symposium on Risk & Safety Management in the Gas Industry, 14 March 1997, Hong Kong.
[129] Ball DJ, Floyd PJ. Societal risks [R]. Final report, School of Health, Biological & Environmental Sciences, Middlesex University, Highgate Hill, London, 2001.
[130] E. Erkut, V. Verter. Hazardous materials logistics, in: Z.Drezner (Ed.), Facility Location: A survey of applications and methods, Springer, Berlin, 1995.
[131] United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). TransAPELL: Guidance for dangerous goods transport emergency planning in a local community [R]. Technical Report No.35. UNEP: Division of Technology, Industry and Economics, 2001.
[132] Harwood, D.W. & Russell, E.R. Present practices of the highway transportation of hazardous materials[R]. Report No. FHWA-RD-89-013, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, D.C. 1989.
[133] Khan F I, Abbasi SA. Major accidents in process industries and an analysis of causes and consequences [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 1999,12(5):361-378.
[134] 吴宗之, 孙猛. 200 起危险化学品公路运输事故的统计分析及对策研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2006,2(2):3～8
[135] 陈宝智.系统安全工程[M].沈阳:东北大学出版社,2001
[136] National Fire Protection Association, Identification of the fire hazards of materials, NFPA704 [R]. Quincy, MA: National Fire Protection Association, 1990.
[137] “八五”国家科技攻关课题《重大危险源的评价和宏观控制技术研究》鉴定材料,劳动部劳保所等单位,1996
[138] Rhyne,William R. Hazardous materials transportation risk analysis, quantitative approaches for truck and train. John Wiley & Sons Inc.1994.
[139] Abkowitz M, Cheng P. Hazardous materials transportation risk estimation under conditions of limited data availability [J]. Transportation research record, 1989,1245:14-22.
[140] Glickman T S. An expedition risk assessment of the highway transportation offlammable liquids in bulk [J]. Transportation research records, 1991, 1193:22-28.
[141] Verter, V., Kara, B.Y.. A GIS-Based Framework for Hazardous Materials Transport Risk Assessment [J]. Risk Analysis: An International Journal, 2001, 21(6):1109-1120.
[142] Saccomanno F, Shortreed J H, Van Aerde M. Assessing the risk of transporting dangerous goods by truck and rail [R]. Part2. Institute for risk research, university of waterloo, Canadian pacific Railways, and University Research Incentive Fund, 1989.
[143] Saccomanno F F, Button N P, Assar R AI. Release and fire incidents rates for the transport of dangerous goods through road tunnels and surface route. Final Report. Prepared for OECD/PIARC/EU Project No.ERS2. In: Hamouda, Ghada Mahmoud. Risk-based decision support model for planning emergency response for hazardous materials road accidents[D]. University of Waterloo (Canada),2004.
[144] Transport Canada. CANUTEC’s ERGO, ERGO2004, Emergency Response Guidebook[EB/OL], Canada. [2005-12-10]. http://www.tc.gc.ca/canutec/en/guide/ERGO/ ergo.htm.
[145] Saccomanno,F.F.,Shortreed,J.H.,Mehta,R. Fatality risk curves for transporting chlorine and liquefied petrolecum gas by truck and rail [J]. Transp.Res.Rec.1264, Transp.Res. Board, Washington,D.C,1990,29-41.
[146] 黄典剑, 吴宗之, 蔡嗣经等. 基于模糊集值统计理论的城市重大突发事件应急能力综合评价研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报,2004,12(s1):290～295
[147] 张峥. 工业设施恐怖袭击风险分析理论与风险评价方法的研究[D]. 天津: 南开大学, 2005
[148] 天 津 政 府 市 政 公 用 基 础 设 施 建 设 新 闻 发 布 会 实 录 [EB/OL].(2006-01-10) [2006-12-15]. http://news.enorth.com.cn/system/2006/01/10/001207770.shtml.
[149] 外 环 线 时 速 降 出 行 注 意 安 全 [N/OL]. 每 日 新 报 .(2005-04-27)[2006-12-15]. http://www.bh.gov.cn/news/2005-04/27/content_4141438.htm.
[150] 贾峰,颜景雷. 液氯槽车运输事故的危害及预防措施[J].氯碱工业,2005(6):34～35
[151] 天津道路交通图(ISBN 7-80532-840-4) [G]. 天津市地质工程勘察院编制. 山东省地图出版社出版发行,2006,10
[2] 国家重点科技项目攻关计划《工业危险品公路运输安全管理系统技术研究》,工业危险品公路运输风险分析方法研究[R]. 国家安全生产监督管理局安全科学技术研究中心,2003.
[3] Paolo Leonelli, Sarah Bonvicini, Gigliola Spadoni. New detailed numerical procedures for calculating risk measures in hazardous materials transportation [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,1999,12(6): 507-515.
[4] Advisory Committee on Dangerous Substances. Major hazard aspects of the transport of dangerous substances [R]. London: HSE,1991.
[5] 科技引领运输安全我国危险品运输现状分析[EB/OL]. 2006-07-14 [2006-8-10].中国建材信息总网, http://www.bm.cei.gov.cn/allfile/49/2006071410235749141.asp.
[6] Centre for Chemical Process Safety of AIChE. Guidelines for chemical process quantitative risk analysis. New York, 1989.
[7] G.F. List, P.B. Mirchandani, M. Turnquist, K.G. Zografos. Modeling and analysis for hazardous materials transportation: Risk analysis, routing/scheduling and facility location[J] Transportation Science, 1991,25 (2):100-114.
[8] Erhan Erkut, Vedat Verter. Modeling of Transport risk for hazardous materials [J]. Operations Research.1998,46(5):625-642.
[9] Erhan Erkut, Armann Ingolfsson.Transport risk models for hazardous materials: revisited [J]. Operations Research Letters,2005,33(1):81-89.
[10] 周珣. 基于道路危险货物运输安全的路线优化研究[D]. 长安大学硕士学位论文, 2004.
[11] Wijeratne AB. Routing and Scheduling Decisions in the Management of Hazardous Material Shipments[D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, 1990.
[12] Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Highway routing of hazardous materials guidelines for applying criteria [R]. Report No. FHWA-HI-97-003, U.S.DOT, 1996.
[13] P. Leonelli, S. Bonvicini, G. Spadoni. Hazardous materials transportation: a risk-analysis-based routing methodology [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2000,71(1-3): 283-300.
[14] Huang.B, Fery.P,Zhang. Multiobjective Optimization for hazardous materials transportation [J].Journal of the Transportation Research Board,2005(1906):64-73.
[15] Jianjun Zhang, John Hodgson, Erhan Erkut. Using GIS to assess the risks of hazardous materials transport in networks. European Journal of Operational Research[J],2000,121(2):316-329.
[16] Roberto, Sergio Di Cave, Barbara Mazzarotta. Risk analysis for road and rail transport of hazardous materials: a GIS approach [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 2004,17(6): 483-488.
[17] 庄英伟. LPG 罐车公路运输风险评价方法及应用研究[D]. 北京:首都经贸大学,2004.
[18] 于群利. 有关危险品化学品管理的国际规章介绍[J]. 化工标准·计量·质量,2004,7:46～48
[19] CCPS. Guidelines for chemical transportation risk analysis [M ].New York: AICHE, 1995.
[20] 吴宗之.国内外安全(风险)评价方法研究与进展[A].二十一世纪安全科学与技术的发展趋势.北京: 科技出版社,2000.
[21] Ang A., Briscoe J. et al. Development of a systems risk methodology for single and multimodal transportation systems [R]. Final Report, Office of University Research, US DOT, Washington, DC,1989.
[22] A.G. Hobeika,B.Jamei,I.B.Santoso. Selection of preferred Highway Routes for the Shipment of Spent Nuclear Fuel Between Surry and North Anna Power Stations in Virginia. In: Recent Advance in hazardous materials transportation research: An International Exchange,67-73,U.S.Department of Transportation, Transportation Research Board, Washington,D.C.,1986.
[23] D.Kessler,Establishing Hazardous Materials Truck Routes for Shipments Through the Dallas-fort Worth Area. In: Recent Advance in hazardous materials transportation research: An International Exchange,79-87,U.S.Department of Transportation, Transportation Research Board, Washington,D.C.,1986.
[24] J.W.Cashwell,K.S.Neuhauser,P.C.Reaprdon,et al. Transportation Impacts of the Commercial Radioactive Waste Management Program [R]. Report SAND85-2715, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque,N.M.,1986.
[25] Bottelbergha P H. Risk analysis and safety policy developments in the Netherlands [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2000,71(1-3):59-84.
[26] M.Considine. Risk assessment of the transportation of hazardous substances through road Tunnels. In: Recent Advance in hazardous materials transportation research: An International Exchange,178-185,U.S.Department of Transportation, Transportation Research Board, Washington,D.C.,1986.
[27] F.F. Saccomanno, A. Chan, Economic evaluation of routing strategies for hazardous road shipments[J], Transp. Res. Record,1985,1020:12-18.
[28] T.S.Glickman. Benchmark estimates of release accident rates in hazardous materials transportation of rail and truck [J]. Trans.Res.Rec.,1988,1193:22-28.
[29] Niels Peter Hφj, Wolfgang Kroger. Risk analyses of transportation on road and railway from a European Perspective [J]. Safety Science, 2002,40(1-4):337-357.
[30] Roberto Bubbico, Cinzia Ferrari, Barbara Mazzarotta. Risk Analysis of LPG Transport by Road and Rail [J]. Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 2000,13(1):27-31.
[31] S. Bonvicini, P. Leonelli, G. Spadoni,Risk analysis of hazardous materials transportation:evaluating uncertainty by means of fuzzy logic[J],Journal of Hazardous Materials, 1998,62(1):59-74.
[32] Ertugrul Alp, Michael J.Zelensky. Risk quantification for meteorology and direction dependent hazards due to point and linear risk sources [J]. J.Loss Prev.Process Ind, 1996, 9 (2):135-145.
[33] Fabiano B., Currò F., Palazzi E., et al. A framework for risk assessment and decision-making strategies in dangerous good transportation [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 2002,93(1):1-15.
[34] Fabiano B., Currò F., Reverberi A.P., et al. Dangerous good transportation by road: from risk analysis to emergency planning [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries,2005,18(4-6): 403-413.
[35] Erhan Erkut, Vedat Verter. A Framework of Hazardous Materials Transport Risk Assessment[J]. Risk Analysis,1995,15(5):589-600.
[36] E. Erkut, A. Ingolfsson. Catastrophe avoidance models for hazardous materials route planning [J]. Transp. Sci, 2000,34(2):165-179.
[37] E. Alp, Risk-based transportation planning practice: overall methodology and a case example, INFOR,1995,33(1):4-19.
[38] Saccomanno F.F., Van Aerde M, Queen D. Interactive selection of minimum-risk routes for dangerous shipments [J]. Transportation Research Records,1987,1148:9-17.
[39] C ReVelle, J Cohon, D Shobrys. Simultaneous siting and routing in the disposal of hazardous wastes[J], Transp. Sci.1991,25(2),138-145.
[40] M Abkowitz, M Lepofsky, P Cheng. Selecting criteria for designating hazardous materials highway routes[J], Transp. Res.Rec,1992,1333:30-35.
[41] R.A. Sivakumar, R. Batta, M.H. Karwan. Establishing credible risk criteria for transporting extremely dangerous hazardous materials, in: F.F. Saccomanno, K. Cassidy(Eds.), Transportation of Dangerous Goods: Assessing the Risks, Institute for Risk Research, University of Waterloo, 1993.
[42] R.A. Sivakumar, R. Batta, M.H. Karwan. A network-based model for transporting extremely hazardous materials[J], Oper.Res. Lett,1993,13:85-93.
[43] Rajeshwar Rao, K., Venkateswar Rao S., Chary,V. Estimation of risk indices of chemicals during transportation[J].Process Safety Progress,2004,23(2):149-154.
[44] Akgun, V, Amit.P, Rajan.B. Routing of a hazmat truck in the presence of weather systems[R]. Christopher M.Rump,Department of Applied Statistics and Operations Research Bowling Green State University Bowling Green, Ohio 43403, USA.
[45] Akgun, V. Routing of Hazardous Materials in the Presence of Weather Systems [D]. Unpub-lished Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Industrial Engineering, University at Bualo, SUNY, Bualo, NY, 14260, 2001.
[46] Parekh A. Time dependent shortest path algorithms for routing of hazardous materials in the presence of weather Systems[D]. Unpublished M.S. Thesis, Department of IndustrialEngineering, University at Bualo, SUNY, Bualo, NY, 14260, 2003.
[47] Scanmlon RD, Cantilli EJ. Assessing the risk and safety in the transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Transportation Research Record, 1985,1020:6-11.
[48] Bhanu Prakash Rao Madala. A Simulation Study for Hazardous Materials Transportation risk assessment [D]. D.Master, Concordia University, Montreal ,Quebec, Canada,2000.
[49] Bhavesh, R.G. Risk of transporting dangerous goods: South Durban case study [D]. Ma.D. dissertation, Civil engineering programme, University of KwaZulu-Natal,2005.
[50] Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). Guidelines for applying criteria to designate routes for transporting hazardous materials (revised) [R]. Report No. FHWA-SA-94-083, Washington, D.C.,1994.
[51] Lepofsky, M., Abkowitz, M. & Cheng, P. Transportation hazard analysis in integrated GIS environment [J] Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2): 239-254.
[52] Harwood, D.W., Viner, J.G. & Russell, E.R. Procedure for developing truck accident and release rates for HAZMAT routing [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2):189-199.
[53] Pet-Armacost, J.J., Sepulveda, J. & Sakude M. Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis of unknown parameters in hazardous materials transportation risk assessment [J]. Risk Analysis, Society for Risk Analysis, 1999, 19(6): 1173-1184.
[54] Saccomanno, F.F. & Shortreed, J.H. Hazmat transport risk: societal and individual perspectives [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2):177-188.
[55] United States Department of Transportation (USDOT). Emergency Response Guidebook [M]. Research and Special Programs Administration, Office of Hazardous Materials Initiatives and Training, Washington, D.C.2004.
[56] 毕军, 王华东. 有害废物运输环境风险研究[J].中国环境科学,1995,15(4):241～246
[57] 孙猛,吴宗之,张宏元.危险化学品公路运输事故原因分析与对策[J].中国安全科学学报,2003,13(8):22～24
[58] 陈小能.危险货物运输的安全注意事项[J].工业安全与环保,2005,31(7):57～58
[59] 王艳华,佟淑娇,陈宝智,危险化学品道路运输系统危险性分析[J], 中国安全科学学报,2005,15(2):8～12
[60] 宇德明. 易燃、易爆、有毒危险品储运过程定量风险评价方法[M]. 北京:中国铁道出版社,2000,6
[61] 吴宗之等. 工业危险辨识与评价[M]. 北京: 气象出版社, 2000
[62] 吴宗之等. 危险评价方法及其应用[M]. 北京: 冶金工业出版社, 2001
[63] 张景林等. 危险化学品运输[M]. 北京: 化学工业出版社, 2006
[64] 吴宗之, 多英全, 刘茂等. 危险品道路运输过程风险分析与评价方法研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报,2004,12(s1):36～44
[65] 庄英伟,危险化学品公路运输定量风险分析方法探讨[J]. 中国职业安全卫生管理体系认证,2004,1:23～25
[66] 魏航, 李军. 时变条件下的有害物品运输的人口风险分析[J]. 中国安全科学学报,2004,14(10):95～98
[67] 魏 航 , 李 军 , 王 浩 . 有 害 物 品 运 输 的 总 风 险 分 析 [J]. 中 国 安 全 科 学 学 报 , 2005,15(12):97～101
[68] 魏航,魏洁.公路运输有害物品的外部成本分析[J].交通标准化,2005,64～68
[69] 郭晓琳,李军. 基于事故分级的有害物品运输路径风险度量模型研究[J].中国安全科学学报,2006,16(6):35～39
[70] 王刊良.有害危险物品后勤学的研究动态[J].系统工程理论与实践,2000,7:112～117
[71] 王刊良, 张朋柱. 有害危险物品运输风险的量化模型[R]. 第五届全国青年管理科学与系统科学论文集[C ], 天津: 南开大学出版社, 1999
[72] 王刊良, 徐寅峰, 汪应洛. 一个支持有害物品填埋场选址的决策支持系统[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 1997,17(11):60～65
[73] 任常兴, 吴宗之. 危险品道路运输选线问题分析[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2006,6(2):84～88
[74] 吴宗之, 任常兴. 危险品道路运输风险评价与优化选线的研究进展.安全与环境学报,2007,7(3)
[75] 任常兴, 吴宗之. 危险品道路运输风险分级指数法研究[J]. 安全与环境学报, 2006,6(4):126～129
[76] Harwood D.W., Russel E. R, Viner J. G. Characteristics of accidents and incidents in highway transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Transportation Research Records, 1990,1245:23-33.
[77] Saccomanno F. F, Van Aerde F, Shortreed J. H, Higgs J. Comparision of risk measures for the transport of dangerous commodities by truck and rail [J]. Transportation Research Records,1987,1245:1-13.
[78] 胡运权. 运筹学基础及应用[M]. 3 版. 哈尔滨: 哈尔滨工业大学出版社, 2000
[79] 施光燕, 董加礼. 最优化方法[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 1999
[80] Zografos K.G., Androutsopoulos K.N. A heuristic algorithm for solving hazardous materials distribution problems [J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 2004, 152(2): 507-519.
[81] E.Dijkstra. A note on two problems in connection with graphs.Numer.Math,1959,1:269-271.
[82] Kessler D. Establishing hazardous materials trucks routes for shipments through the dallas-fort worth area [J]. State-of-the-Art Report, No.3, Transportation Research Board, 1986,79-87.
[83] R.Batta, S.Chiu. Optimal obnoxious paths on a network: transportation of Hazardous materials [J]. Opns.Res.1988,36(1):84-92.
[84] D.Shobrys. A model for the selection of shipping routes and storage locations for a hazardous substance [D].Ph.D. dissertation, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore,1981.
[85] J.Robbins. Routing hazardous materials shipments [D]. Ph.D. dissertation, Indiana University, Bloomington, Ind.,1981.
[86] J.R.Current, C.S.ReVelle, J.L.Cohon. The minimum-covering shortest path problem [J]. Decision Science,1988,19:490-503.
[87] R.G.Cox. Routing and scheduling of hazardous materials shipments: algorithmic approachesto managing spent nuclear fuel Transport [D]. Ph.D. dissertation, Cornell University,Ithaca,N.Y.,1984.
[88] R.G.Cox., M.A.Turnquist. Scheduling truck shipments of hazardous materials in the presences of curfews [J]. Trans. Res. Rec. 1986,1063:21-26.
[89] Zografos.K.G, Davis CF. Multi-objective programming approach for routing hazardous materials [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering 1989;115(6):661-673.
[90] Wijeratne, A. B., M. A. Turnquist, P. B. Mirchandani. Multiobjective Routing of Hazardous Materials in Stochastic Networks [J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 1993,65:33-43.
[91] Zografos.K,Samara.S. A combined location-routing model for hazardous waste transportation and disposal[J]. Transportation Research Record, 1990, 1245:52-59.
[92] J Current. A model to assess risk, equity and efficiency in facility location and transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Location Science,1995,3(3):187-201.
[93] Frank, W.C., Thill, J.-C., R. Batta. Spatial decision support system for hazardous material truck routing [J],Transportation Research Part C8,2000,8(16):337-359.
[94] Frank, W.C.. Hazardous material vehicle routing utilizing a decision support system and temporal road attributes [D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Industrial Engineering, University of New York at Buffalo, 2001.
[95] B.Y. Kara, E. Erkut, V. Verter. Accurate calculation of hazardous materials transport risks [J]. Operations Research Letters,2003,31(4):285-292.
[96] Zografos K.G., Vasilakis K.N., Androutsopoulos K.N. A real time decision support system for road network incident response logistics [J]. Transportation Research Part C,2002,10(1): 1-18.
[97] Huang, B., R. L. Cheu, Y. S. Liew. GIS and Genetic Algorithms for HazMat Route Planning with Security Considerations [J]. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2003,18(8): 769-787.
[98] E Erkut, Osman Alp. Designing a road network for hazardous materials shipments [J]. Computer & Operations Research, 2007,34(5):1389-1405.
[99] Angela L.Woods. Optimal Routing of Hazardous Substances in Time-Varying, Stochastic Transportation [R]. Department of Civil Engineering, University of Texas at Austin, ANRCP-1998-8.
[100] 沈小燕, 刘浩学, 周珣. 道路危险货物运输路线优化评价研究[J]. 中国安全生产科学技术,2006,2(1):76～79
[101] 边浩毅 季永青 李百川. 道路运输企业安全评价方法及实例分析[J].安全与环境学报,2006, 6(2):89～91
[102] 吴宗之, 任常兴. 基于风险分析的危险品道路运输选线指标研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报, 2006, 14(s1):146～152
[103] 薄瑞峰, 李瑞琴. 基于 Pareto 最优的概念结构方案多目标决策方法[J]. 西安交通大学学报,2006,40(9):1114～116
[104] REN Changxing, WU Zongzhi. Minimum risk route analysis of hazardous materials transportation. Progress in Safety Science and Technology Volume VI: Proceedings of the 2006 International Symposium on Safety Science and Technology, 2006,Part A:1950-1954.
[105] 任常兴, 吴宗之. 危险品道路安全运输路径优化方法探讨[J]. 中国安全科学学报,2006,16(6):129～134
[106] 石玉峰,门志强. 基于模糊多目标决策理论的军事运输路径优化研究[J], 交通运输工程与信息学报, 2004,2(1):112～116
[107] 刘云霞. 动态车辆调度问题分析及算法设计[D]. 西南交通大学研究生学位论文,2004.3
[108] 严季. 我国道路货物运输发展战略若干问题研究[D]. 长安大学博士论文,2003.11
[109] 余国才,周 伟.公路网布局优化的理论和方法[J],西安公路交通大学学报,1998,18(3):45～49
[110] 张 航. 高等级公路路线方案优化研究[J],武汉理工大学学报(交通科学与工程版),2002,28(4):481～484
[111] Gopalan, R., K. Kolluri, R. Batta and M. Karwan. Modeling equity of risk in the transportation of hazardous materials [J]. Operations Research,1990, 38:961-973.
[112] Jin, H., R. Batta, M. Karwan. On the analysis of two new models for transporting hazardous materials [J]. Operations Research,1996,44:710-723.
[113] List, G. and P. Mirchandani. An integrated network/planar multiobjective model for routing and siting for hazardous materials and wastes [J]. Transportation Science, 1991, 25: 146-156.
[114] Miller-Hooks. Optimal routing in time-varying stochastic networks: algorithms and implementation [D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Civil Engineering, The University of Texas at Austin,1997.
[115] Sivakumar, R., R. Batta and M. Karwan. A multiple route conditional risk model for transporting hazardous materials [J]. INFOR, 1995,33:20-33.
[116] Lassarre, S., Fedra, K. & Weigkricht, E. Computer-assisted routing of dangerous goods for Haute-Normandie [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1993,119(2): 200-210.
[117] Ashtakala B. Methodology to determine safe routes for hazardous materials transportation [C]. CSCE Annual Conference, Montreal, Canada, 1993,3:567-575.
[118] ERKUT E., GLICKMAN, T. Minmax population exposure in routing highway shipments of hazardous materials [J]. Transportation Research Record,1997,1602:93-100.
[119] Ashtakala, B., Eno, Lucy A. Minimum risks route model for hazardous materials [J]. Journal of Transportation Engineering, 1996, 122(5):350-358.
[120] ALK Associates, ALK’s PC*HazRoute (Version 2.0), ALK Associates, Inc., 1000 Herron town Road, Princeton, NJ,USA,1994.
[121] Jianjun Zhang. Spatial analysis tools for hazardous materials transportation logistics [D]. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
[122] A.V. Gheorghe, R. Mock, W. Kroège. Risk assessment of regional systems [J].Reliability Engineering and System Safety, 2000,70(2):141-156.
[123] 刘强, 高晖. 危险化学品运输安全统一监控平台的探讨和设想[J].中国安全科学学报,2006,16(2):59～64
[124] 李定邦, 程真. 基于GPS-GIS技术的危险化学品运输管理的构思[EB/OL]. 中国科技论文在线. 2005-09-20 [2006-08-10]. http://www.paper.edu.cn/process/download.jsp?File =200509-183.
[125] 王宏伟. 用人工智能突破传统管理模式—天泰雷兹安全监控管理系统在危险品运输中的广泛应用[J].中国物流与采购,2006,8:34～35
[126] 何凡, 王海燕. 一个实时的危险品运输公路网络模型[J]. 物流技术, 2005,10:267～269
[127] Ale BJM: Risk Criteria and Europe, paper presented at the Risk 2000 conference, 24 April 1997, London.
[128] Boult M: Risk Management of LPG Transport Activities in Hong Kong, presented to the Symposium on Risk & Safety Management in the Gas Industry, 14 March 1997, Hong Kong.
[129] Ball DJ, Floyd PJ. Societal risks [R]. Final report, School of Health, Biological & Environmental Sciences, Middlesex University, Highgate Hill, London, 2001.
[130] E. Erkut, V. Verter. Hazardous materials logistics, in: Z.Drezner (Ed.), Facility Location: A survey of applications and methods, Springer, Berlin, 1995.
[131] United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). TransAPELL: Guidance for dangerous goods transport emergency planning in a local community [R]. Technical Report No.35. UNEP: Division of Technology, Industry and Economics, 2001.
[132] Harwood, D.W. & Russell, E.R. Present practices of the highway transportation of hazardous materials[R]. Report No. FHWA-RD-89-013, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, D.C. 1989.
[133] Khan F I, Abbasi SA. Major accidents in process industries and an analysis of causes and consequences [J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 1999,12(5):361-378.
[134] 吴宗之, 孙猛. 200 起危险化学品公路运输事故的统计分析及对策研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2006,2(2):3～8
[135] 陈宝智.系统安全工程[M].沈阳:东北大学出版社,2001
[136] National Fire Protection Association, Identification of the fire hazards of materials, NFPA704 [R]. Quincy, MA: National Fire Protection Association, 1990.
[137] “八五”国家科技攻关课题《重大危险源的评价和宏观控制技术研究》鉴定材料,劳动部劳保所等单位,1996
[138] Rhyne,William R. Hazardous materials transportation risk analysis, quantitative approaches for truck and train. John Wiley & Sons Inc.1994.
[139] Abkowitz M, Cheng P. Hazardous materials transportation risk estimation under conditions of limited data availability [J]. Transportation research record, 1989,1245:14-22.
[140] Glickman T S. An expedition risk assessment of the highway transportation offlammable liquids in bulk [J]. Transportation research records, 1991, 1193:22-28.
[141] Verter, V., Kara, B.Y.. A GIS-Based Framework for Hazardous Materials Transport Risk Assessment [J]. Risk Analysis: An International Journal, 2001, 21(6):1109-1120.
[142] Saccomanno F, Shortreed J H, Van Aerde M. Assessing the risk of transporting dangerous goods by truck and rail [R]. Part2. Institute for risk research, university of waterloo, Canadian pacific Railways, and University Research Incentive Fund, 1989.
[143] Saccomanno F F, Button N P, Assar R AI. Release and fire incidents rates for the transport of dangerous goods through road tunnels and surface route. Final Report. Prepared for OECD/PIARC/EU Project No.ERS2. In: Hamouda, Ghada Mahmoud. Risk-based decision support model for planning emergency response for hazardous materials road accidents[D]. University of Waterloo (Canada),2004.
[144] Transport Canada. CANUTEC’s ERGO, ERGO2004, Emergency Response Guidebook[EB/OL], Canada. [2005-12-10]. http://www.tc.gc.ca/canutec/en/guide/ERGO/ ergo.htm.
[145] Saccomanno,F.F.,Shortreed,J.H.,Mehta,R. Fatality risk curves for transporting chlorine and liquefied petrolecum gas by truck and rail [J]. Transp.Res.Rec.1264, Transp.Res. Board, Washington,D.C,1990,29-41.
[146] 黄典剑, 吴宗之, 蔡嗣经等. 基于模糊集值统计理论的城市重大突发事件应急能力综合评价研究[J]. 应用基础与工程科学学报,2004,12(s1):290～295
[147] 张峥. 工业设施恐怖袭击风险分析理论与风险评价方法的研究[D]. 天津: 南开大学, 2005
[148] 天 津 政 府 市 政 公 用 基 础 设 施 建 设 新 闻 发 布 会 实 录 [EB/OL].(2006-01-10) [2006-12-15]. http://news.enorth.com.cn/system/2006/01/10/001207770.shtml.
[149] 外 环 线 时 速 降 出 行 注 意 安 全 [N/OL]. 每 日 新 报 .(2005-04-27)[2006-12-15]. http://www.bh.gov.cn/news/2005-04/27/content_4141438.htm.
[150] 贾峰,颜景雷. 液氯槽车运输事故的危害及预防措施[J].氯碱工业,2005(6):34～35
[151] 天津道路交通图(ISBN 7-80532-840-4) [G]. 天津市地质工程勘察院编制. 山东省地图出版社出版发行,2006,10