摘要
随着人们对臭氧层破坏和全球变暖问题的日益关注,在制冷行业中使用低ODP(Ozone Depletion Potential,臭氧消耗潜能)和GWP(Global Warming Potential,全球变暖潜能)的制冷剂已经成为不可逆转的趋势。其中自然工质因其对环境没有影响而受到广泛重视。R744、R290、R600a都是性能优良的自然工质,将它们混合后应用于自复叠制冷系统,可以扬长避短,达到理想的效果,成为制冷剂替代关注的对象。
本文基于热力学定义,对R744/R290、R744/R600a两种混合自然工质的热力性质进行计算,比较各种计算方法的准确性,确定合适的理论公式,并将这两种混合工质应用于自复叠制冷系统,提出混合工质摩尔分数选择的方法,计算自复叠制冷系统的循环特性及其影响因素。结果表明:R744/R600a比R744/R290更容易分凝,且适用于较低压力或较高温度;分凝后R744的摩尔分数在气体中高于总体水平,在液体中低于总体水平;泡点露点温度随压力的升高而升高;将两种混合工质应用于自复叠系统中,在选择混合工质摩尔分数时要同时考虑制冷温度、冷凝器压力、蒸发冷凝器压力等因素;分凝后制冷剂的干度存在最佳值,使低温流在蒸发冷凝器中充分冷凝,同时使高温流在蒸发冷凝器中充分蒸发,这时系统性能达到最佳值;适当提高回热器换热系数有助于减少蒸发冷凝器的换热负荷,有助于提高压缩机入口处制冷剂的过热度,有助于提高系统性能。
本文用数值模拟的方法计算出以上结论,为采用R744/R290和R744/R600a的自复叠制冷系统的深入研究和实际应用提供了理论依据,并对其它混合工质和采用其它混合工质的自复叠系统的研究提供了一些参考。
Nowadays, people pay more and more attentions on ozone depletion and global warming, so it's an unreversed trend to use low ODP and GWP refrigerant in refrigeration industry. Natural mixtures have broad regard because of their friendly properties to entironment. R744, R290 and R600a have nice properties, the auto-cascade refrigeration system using their mixtures also can cancel their disadvantage, so this method becomes an important one in the area of refrigerant substitute.
In this paper, proceeding from the actual thermodynamic definition, the calculation of R744/R290 and R744/R600a's thermodynamic properties are taken. The veracity and reliability of each calculation method and result are analyzed, appropriate equations are chosen, and the thermodyanamic properties of an auto-cascade refrigeration system and the factors which impact them are taken, a method how to choose the mole fraction of the mixture is taken. Results indicate that: R744/R600a is easier to separate phases than R744/R290, and adapt to work under lower pressure or higher temperature; after phases separated, the mole fraction of R744 is higher in gas and lower in liquid; the temperatures of bubble point and dew point become higher with higher pressure; in auto-cascade refrigeration system using natural binary mixture, it's necessary to consider refrigeration temperature, the pressure of condenser and evaporative condenser at the same time when choose the mole fraction of mixture; there is a optimal mole proportion between the gas and liquid at the exit of the condenser, which can make the low temperature branch condense adequately and make the high temperature branch vaporize adequately; appropriately higher heat exchanger coefficient can be helpful to lighten the heat load of evaporative condenser, enhance system capability.
The presented conclusions which are obtained from numerical simulation provide theoretic gist for the study and application of the auto-cascade refrigeration system using R744/R290 and R744/600a. Furthermore, it's effective and useful for the studies of other mixtures and auto-cascade refrigeration system using other mixtures.
引文
[1] 国家环境保护局.人类共同的责任.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1993.
[2] 林毅.无公害制冷设备选用手册.北京:石油工业出版社,1995.
[3] 陈光明,陈邦国.制冷与低温原理.北京:机械工业出版社,2000.
[4] Lorentzen G. The use of natural refrigerants: a complete solution to the CFC/HCFC predicament. Int. J. Refrig, 18 (3): 190~197.
[5] 王如竹,丁国良.最新制冷空调技术.北京:科学出版社,2002.
[6] Kim S G, Kim M S. Experiment and simulation on the performance of an autocascade refrigeration system using carbon dioxide as a refrigerant. Int J of Refrig, 2002, 25(8):1093-1101.
[7] 丁国良,黄冬平.二氧化碳制冷技术.北京:化学工业出版社,2007.
[8] Bodinus P E, William S. The Rise and Fall of Carbon Dioxide Systems. ASHRAE journal, 1999, 41(4):29-34.
[9] Thevenot R. A History of refrigeration throughout the world. Paris: International Institute of Refrigeration, 1979.
[10] Lorentzen G. Trans-critical Vapor Compression Cycle Device. International Patent Publication WO 90/07683, 1990.
[11] 马一太,魏东,王景刚.国内外自然工质研究现状与发展趋势.暖通空调,2003,33(1):41-46.
[12] 黄小池,吴世庆,谭蓁等.异丁烷(R600a)制冷剂在无霜电冰箱上的应用.制冷学报,1999,(3): 5-11.
[13] 马贞俊,晏刚,周晋等.HCs类物质在制冷行业中的应用分析.天然气工业,2003,23(3): 106-109.
[14] 金晓春,付海芬.HCs冷柜系统最佳充注量的实验研究与理论分析.制冷与空调,2005,5(2): 66-70.
[15] 杨峰,刘志刚,金晓春.HCs冷柜系统最佳充注量的实验研究与理论分析.家电科技,2004,(8): 75-78.
[16] 秦娜,吕静,要丽娟.HCs商用制冷装置中工质泄漏对系统性能影响的实验研究.天津商学院学报, 2006,26(3):49-52.
[17] 肖洪海,张桃,胡艳.R290小型家用空调器的性能匹配研究.制冷学报,2006,27(4):26-30.
[18] 宁静红,彭苗,李慧宇.R290家用空调的替代与应用研究.流体机械,2006,34(12):72-74.
[19] 南晓红,郭亚军,刘咸定.R290的管内冷凝实验研究.制冷学报,2003,(3):6-9.
[20] 刘玉东,童明伟,项勇.R290用于大型冷水机组的实验研究与可行性分析.重庆大学学报, 2002,25(8):7-10.
[21] 廖洪鹏.异丁烷用作船舶制冷系统制冷剂时应注意的安全问题.机电设备,2003,(4):33-35.
[22] 韩晓霞,南晓红,刘咸定.R290与R404A在水平管内沸腾换热的压降研究.制冷学报,2006,27(2): 17-20.
[23] 朱金松.R600a制冷系统液击和对策研究.家电科技,2005,(10):48-50.
[24] 王倩.房间空调器R290替代R22的可行性分析.茂名学院学报,2005,15(3):38-42.
[25] 陈永强,刘金平,张波.新型制冷剂R290热物性分析及试验研究.环境技术,2004,(6):19-23.
[26] 刘圣春,马一太,胡来红等.碳氢制冷剂应用于汽车空调的可行性分析.制冷与空调,2004,4(6): 43-47。
[27] 杜雅萍,吕静,尹从绪等.碳氢化合物在冷冻箱系统中的试验研究.低温工程,2004,(2):53-56.
[28] 刘敬辉,陈江平,陈芝久.碳氢制冷剂用于汽车空调的理论分析和实验研究.化工学报,2006, 57(9):2048-2052.
[29] 吴春华,陈雪忠,包国兴.R600a高效节能电冰箱压缩机的设计.节能压缩机,2001,(3):44-45.
[30] Zhou Guobing, Zhang Yufeng, Hao Hong. Numerical Modeling of perform of R22 and R290 in adiabatic capillary tubes considering metastable two-phase region. Transactions of Tianjin University, 2005,11(3):209-215.
[31] Zhou Guobing, Zhang Yufeng, Hao Hong. Numerical Modeling of the perform of R22 and R290 in adiabatic capillary tubes considering metastable two-phase region-folw characteristics and parametric analysis of R22 and R290. Transactions of Tianjin University, 2005,11(3):209-215.
[32] 丁国良,张春路,赵力.制冷空调新工质热物理性质的计算方法与实用图表.上海:上海交通大学出版社,2003.
[33] 童景山,高光华,刘裕品.化工热力学.北京:清华大学出版社,2001.
[34] Nyvad J, Elefsen F. Energy efficient cooling by use of cycloid water vapor compressor. ⅡR Com1/2 Gent, 1993:67-74.
[35] 董天禄,华小龙.制冷剂替代技术的最新动态.制冷技术,1999,(1):15-20。
[36] 南晓红,C.A.Infante Ferreira,刘咸定.R22及其替代工质管内相变换热实验系统的比较研究. 制冷技术,2005,33(5):63-66.
[37] 王倩,吴挺,张于峰等.R22替代物R290的理论与试验研究.流体机械,2004,32(7):46-50.
[38] Spatz M W, Motta F Y. An evaluation of options for replacing HCFC-22 in commercial refrigeration systems. International Congress of Refrigeration, Wanshington, D.C., 2003:510-518.
[39] 徐敬东,周贻博.使用异丁烷作电冰箱制冷剂的几个问题.家用电器科技,1998,(2):35-37.
[40] 李先碧,冯雅康.二氧化碳跨临界循环制冷的研究进展.真空与低温,2007,13(3):173-177.
[41] Girotto S, Minetto S, Neksa P. Commercial refrigeration system with CO_2 as refrigerant experimental results. International Congress of Refrigeration, Wanshington, D.C.,2003: 290-298.
[42] 宁静红,马一太,陈启.R290/CO_2复叠式循环中使用R22压缩机的分析研究.压缩机技术,2006, (1):22-24.
[43] 张于峰,贡征峰,牛宝联等.带回热器的自然工质复叠制冷系统性能分析.流体机械,2007,35(2): 53-57.
[44] 牛宝联,张于峰.CO_2/R170混合物作为复叠式制冷系统低温环路制冷剂的性能.化工学报,2007, 58(3):555-561.
[45] 宁静红,马一太,管海清.自然工质冷凝蒸发器的设计制造.流体机械,2007,35(1):53-55.
[46] 马一太,宁静红,陈启等.自然工质复叠式制冷循环替代与节能研究.节能技术,2005,23(4): 309-311.
[47] 查世彤,马一太,王景刚等.自然工质低温复叠式制冷循环的热力学分析与比较.热科学与技术, 2003,2(1):20-24.
[48] 宁静红,李惠宇,彭苗.自然工质超市制冷系统的分析与比较.节能环保技术,2007,(4):30-31.
[49] Kim G C, Bertilsen P. Refrigeration systems in supermarkets with propane and CO_2-energy consumption and economy. International Congress of Refrigeration, Wanshington, D.C., 2003:131-140.
[50] Elefsen F, Wnite S. Cost effective comparison of supermarket refrigeration systems. International Congress of Refrigeration, Wanshington, D.C., 2003:649-657.
[51] 宁静红,马一太,苏维诚.R290/CO_2蒸汽压缩复叠式制冷系统实验.天津大学学报,2006,39(11): 1341-1344.
[52] 宁静红,马一太,李敏霞.R290/CO_2自然工质低温复叠式制冷循环理论分析.天津大学学报,2006, 39(4):449-453.
[53] 刘永忠,杨丽坤,孙皓等.复叠式与二级压缩式热泵冷冻干燥系统循环特性比较.真空与低温, 2004,10(2):89-93.
[54] 宁静红,查世彤,李慧宇等.利用熵产最小法分析R290/CO_2复叠式制冷循环.制冷与空调,2007, (1):85-88.
[55] 宁静红,彭苗,李慧宇.新型环保超市制冷系统.制冷,2006,25(1):57-59.
[56] 宁静红,李慧宇,彭苗.冷热组合型超市系统的设计与经济性分析.节能技术,2007,(4):16-20.
[57] 宁静红,马一太.R290/CO_2制冷循环的能效分析与节能探讨.流体机械,2005,33(7):70-72.
[58] Sawalha S, Palm B. Energy consumption evaluation of indirect systems wiry CO_2 as secondary refrigerant in supermarket refrigeration. International Congress of Refrigeration, Wanshington, D.C., 2003:434-442.
[59] 周彦红,郇中杰,何绍书.低温工况下碳氢化合物替代R22的制冷循环分析.制冷与空调,2001, 1(6):26-28.
[60] 宋新齐,李允昌.汽车空调系统中用烃混合物取代HFC-134a的可行行分析和实验研究.装备制造技术,2007,(8):9-11.
[61] 张于峰,马九贤,孙延禄.丙烷及其混合物作为空调制冷剂可行性研究.制冷学报,1999,(2): 18-24.
[62] 王松岭,论立勇,谢英柏等.不同混合比下丙烷和二氟乙烷替代R22理论研究.制冷与空调,2006, 6(2):59-63.
[63] 任挪颖,晏刚,丛伟等.混合工质HFC134a/HCs替代R502的性能分析.制冷技术,2006,34(5): 381-385.
[64] 张永磊,沈永年.烷烃混合工质在逆向布莱尔循环制冷中的应用.天然气工业,2004,24(6): 115-118.
[65] 杨昭,金国民,张世钢.含R290混合物用于家用空调冷媒的性能研究.制冷空调与电力机械, 2005,26(1):1-4.
[66] 杜雅萍,吕静,尹从绪.环保型制冷剂R600a/R290的应用研究.节能环保技术,2004,(4):37-38.
[67] 王松岭,论立勇,谢英柏等.用R290与R152a混合制冷剂替代R22.天然气工业,2005,25(7): 115-118.
[68] 徐明仿,杜维明,晏刚.近共沸制冷剂R134a/R290的研究.制冷与空调,2004,4(5):71-74.
[69] 毛力,孙勇,律宝莹等.R290/R600a在冷柜蒸发器中的换热性质及对柜内温度分布影响分布影响的实验研究.冷饮与速冻食品工业,2005,11(2):28-31.
[70] 秦娜,吕静,要丽娟.工质泄漏对HCs商用制冷系统性能影响的理论分析.制冷与空调,2006, 6(2):22-25.
[71] 陈艳阳,徐明仿,晏刚.近共沸制冷剂R134a/R600a/R600的应用研究.冷藏技术,2004,6(2): 16-18.
[72] 朱德英.浅议制冷剂替代品的发展.安徽化工,2007,33(3):62-63.
[73] 任挪颖,颜俊,钱伟等.自复叠制冷循环的研究状况.制冷与空调,2006,6(6):5-8.
[74] 韩润虎.自然复叠系统与低温制冷.制冷学报,1999,(4):59-61.
[75] 罗二仓,公茂琼,周远.30K~60K温区混合工质自复叠节流制冷循环及其实验验证.工程热物理学报,2000,21(2):142-146.
[76] 龙建佑,朱冬生,陈礼.自然复叠制冷系统的仿真与优化.制冷与空调,2006,(2):5-9.
[77] 杜凯,廖开蒙.自然复叠制冷系统初探.低温工程,2002,(3):29-32.
[78] Dale J. Missimer. Refrigerant conversion of auto-refrigerating cascade systems. Int. J. Refrig., 1997, 20(3): 201-207.
[79] 张华,方建良,陆向阳.两级自动复叠制冷系统的试验研究.制冷空调与电力机械,2004,25(2): 14-15.
[80] 张绍志,王建锋,张红线等.具有精馏装置的自动复叠制冷循环分析.工程热物理学报,2001, 22(1):25-27.
[81] 曹丹,王勤,陈光明.一种新型的自动复叠制冷循环.低温工程,2003,(5):49-54.
[82] 陆向阳,张华,黄森等.R134a/R23自动复叠循环的试验研究.低温与特气,2004,22(5):26-30.
[83] 宋世亮,沈永年,王兆华.CO_2用于自动复迭制冷系统的理论分析.深冷技术,2004,(5):8-11.
[84] 宋世亮,沈永年,王兆华.CO_2用于自然复叠制冷系统的理论分析.低温与特气,2004,22(5): 13-16.
[85] 晏刚,任挪颖,徐荣吉等.船舶多温冷库新型自复叠制冷循环的研究.西安交通大学学报,2006, 40(5):536-538.
[86] 任挪颖,晏刚,颜俊等.自复叠制冷循环中混合工质泄露性能的研究.制冷技术,2007,35(1): 61-64.
[87] 任挪颖,晏刚,严俊等.自复叠双温冰箱的流程改进和性能分析.西安交通大学学报,2007,41(5): 549-552.
[88] 宋锡谨,张未星,吴兆立.新型制冷剂R134、R134-R134a及R134-R22的热力学性质.高校化工工程学报,1997,11(3):238-243.
[89] 侯虞钧,张彬,唐宏青.马丁-侯状态方程向液相发展.化工学报,1981,(1):1-10.
[90] J. J. Martin, Yuchun Hou. Development of an equation of state for gases. A. I. CH. E. Joural, 1955, (1): 142-151.
[91] 陈宏芳,杜建华.高等工程热力学.北京:清华大学出版社,2003.
[92] 齐铭.制冷附件.北京:航空工业出版社,1992.