摘要
传统的汇率理论是构建在有效市场与理性预期假设基础上的,近年来,该理论不断遭受人们的质疑与挑战。汇率的行为金融理论从挑战传统汇率决定理论的市场有效性假设与理性预期假设两大理论前提出发,以外汇市场复杂性与交易者行为的异质性为切入点,对外汇交易进行建模、计量乃至模拟分析研究,对于认识外汇交易市场的非理性波动,研究一国央行如何对外汇市场进行适度干预,以实现影响本国货币即期汇率,消除或平抑短期经济波动对汇率预期影响的目的,此类研究具有重要的理论创新意义。
2002年以来,国际社会开始出现人民币升值的呼声,随后,由于美国政府的积极施压,升值呼声逐步形成国内外对人民币升值的强烈预期。2005年7月21日人民币汇率制度改革后,人民币升值开始走上现实历程。自此,人民币汇率经历了三年对美元持续升值过程,累计升值幅度超过20%,但国际市场对人民币的升值预期并未消失。2008年三季度,受美国次贷危机演化成全球金融危机的影响,中国对外出口面临严峻挑战,国际市场又突现较为强烈的人民币贬值预期。预期的形成与逆转具有典型的行为金融学意义上的羊群效应特征,在此背景下,对行为金融视角下的汇率波动与央行干预策略进行研究,具有重要的现实意义。
本文首先对汇率决定理论进行系统回顾与梳理,并从市场交易者的心理及行为入手,立足于外汇市场交易者的异质预期与选择行为特征,介绍早期行为金融学框架下的汇率模型。其次,在对“汇改”后人民币外汇市场结构体系特征进行描述的基础上,对人民币汇率的波动性特征、市场的有效性及基本面因素影响程度三个方面进行了实证研究,研究表明,人民币汇率不符合传统汇率决定理论所描述的特征。然后,通过引入与修正行为金融框架下的汇率决定模型,采用计算机编程模拟方法,考察了汇率变化轨迹与规律,并加入央行干预进行模型扩展,进而总结央行对汇率的不同干预策略。最后,就完善外汇市场,提高外汇市场流动性、稳定性和市场效率以及改进央行外汇市场干预策略等方面提出了相关政策建议。
本文在研究视角与方法上具有一定的创新。研究视角方面,本文摈弃了传统汇率理论的有效市场假设与理性预期假设,把行为金融理论纳入了汇率动态模型研究之中。研究方法方面,由于模型的非线性以及随机扰动,借助计算机程序设计并进行仿真模拟,可以更为深入地研究汇率波动的内在机理。当然,受限于时间与精力以及能力等因素,本文还存在很多不足,可能的不足及未来研究方向是,构建具有人民币市场特征的特定模型或寻找人民币汇率准确特征参数,以更好刻画人民币汇率动态变化的特征,研究更为有效而具体的央行干预策略。
The traditional exchange rate theory basing on the hypotheses of efficient market and rational expectations has in recent years been the victim of people's doubts and challenges. Challenging the validity of the two major theoretical premise—the assumptions of efficient market and rational expectations of traditional exchange rate theory, Behavioral finance theory of exchange rate takes the complexity of foreign exchange market and trading behavior heterogeneity as the breakthrough point, and carries out modeling, quantitative and simulation analysis on foreign exchange transactions. Which is helpful for us to gain the knowledge of non-rational fluctuation of foreign exchange market and the central bank moderate intervention that can eliminate or smooth the exchange rate expectation affected by short-term economic fluctuation having effect on the exchange rate. Which is an important theoretical innovation.
Since 2002, the international community began to voice the appreciation of the RMB, followed by the U.S. government positive pressure, the appreciation voice gradually turned into the strong expectation of RMB appreciation at home and broad. The appreciation of RMB then embarked on the course of reality since the exchange rate system reform on July 21 2005, thereafter the RMB exchange rate against the U.S. dollars has experienced more than three years course of continued appreciation, the cumulative appreciation exceeded 20% meanwhile, but appreciation expectation of RMB in the international market has not disappeared. Since the 3rd quarter of 2008, subject to the sub-loan crisis in the United Sates into the global financial crisis, the exports of China are facing severe challenges, accordingly the relatively strong devaluation expectation of RMB burst out in the international market. Formation and reversal of the expected behavior of a typical financial study on the significance of herding characteristics, in this context, the research on the exchange rate fluctuations and the central bank intervention strategies from behavioral finance perspective has important practical significance.
This paper has a systematic review on exchange rate decide theory firstly, and based on heterogeneity expectation and selection behavioral characteristics of the foreign exchange traders' and from the market traders' psychological and behavioral approach, this paper introduces early exchange rate models in the framework of the behavioral finance. Secondly, this paper describes the characteristics of structural system of RMB foreign exchange market after the reform of the RMB exchange rate system, followed by empirical research on the volatility of the RMB exchange rate features, the effectiveness of foreign exchange market and the impact of fundamental factors on the exchange rate, and the results show that the RMB exchange rate is inconsistent with the characteristics the traditional exchange rate theory described. Therefore this paper introduces and amends the exchange rate model under the framework of behavioral finance, using computer program to simulate the trace of the exchange rates and study on its regular change pattern, then expands the model by adding the central bank intervention into the model, this paper summarizes the different intervention strategies the central bank has on the exchange rate. Finally, this paper proposes the relevant policies such as strengthening the building of the foreign exchange market, improving the foreign exchange market liquidity, stability, market efficiency, and improving the central bank foreign exchange market intervention strategies.
The research perspective and methods are innovative in this paper. From research perspective, the traditional theory of efficient market hypothesis and rational expectations hypothesis are abandoned in this paper and behavioral finance theory is put into the dynamic model of the exchange rate study. Because of the nonlinear and the random disturbance of the model, computer program design and simulation are introduced, through which, we can look more deeply into the inherent mechanism of exchange rate fluctuations. Of course, limited by time, energy and ability, there is still a lot of shortages. The paper shortage and the possible future research direction is to build models with the characteristics of the RMB foreign exchange market or looking for a specific parameters of RMB exchange rate model in order to better characterize the dynamic changes of RMB exchange rate features and give more effective and concrete central bank intervention strategies.
引文
①见边绪宝.新外汇管理条例有助于防范和打击热钱[N].证券时报,2008-8-8。
①麦金农(2003)《罗纳德.麦金农谈中国的汇率》,“人民币汇率问题国际研讨会”大会材料,原载《亚洲华尔街日报》2003年6月27日。
[1]李国平.行为金融学[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2006.
[2]于全辉.基于有限理性假设的行为经济学分析[J].经济问题探索,2006(7):20-23.
[3]JB De Long,A Shleifer,LH Summers,RJ Waldmann.Noise trade risk in financial markets[J].Journal of Political Economy,1990(42):557-581.
[4]KM Dominguez,JA Frankel.Does Foreign Exchange Intervention Matter:the Portfolio Effect[J].American Economic Review,1993(83):1356-1369.
[5]M Obstfeld and K Rogoff.Exchange Rate Dynamics Redux [J].Journal of Political Economy,1995,103(3):604-660.
[6]RK Lyons.The Microstructure Approach to Exchange Rate[M].MIT Press,2001.
[7]P De Grauwe,H Dewachter,and M Embrechts.Exchange Rate Theory:Chaotic Models of Foreign Exchange Markets[M].Blackwell Publishers,1993.
[8]陈雨露,侯杰.汇率决定理论的新近发展:文献综述[J].当代经济科学,2005(5):45-52.
[9]F Black.Noise[J].Journal of Finance,1986(31):529-543.
[10]P De Grauwe,R Dieci and M Grimaldi.Fundamental and Nonfundamental Equilibria in the Foreign Exchange Market.A behavioral Finance Approach[J].CESifo Group Working Paper,1431.2005.
[11]M Mussa.The Role of Official Intervention[J].Group of Thirty,New York,1981.
[12]B LeBaron.Technical Trading Rule Profitability and Foreign Exchange Intervention[J].Journal of International Economics,1999(49):125-143.
[13]L Sarno,MP Taylor.Official Interventions in the Foreign Exchange Markets:Is It Effective,and If So,How Does It Work?[J].Journal of economic Literature,2001(39):839-869.
[14]M Beine,S Laurent,C Lecourt.Reported and Secret Interventions In the Foreign Exchange Market[J].Financial Research Letters,2004(1):215-225.
[15]C Kubelec.FOREX Trading Strategies and the Efficiency of Sterilized Intervention[J].Mimeo,Bank of England,2004:1-51.
[16]P Bettina.Informed Traders,Intervention and Price Leader ship:A Deeper View of the Microstructure of the Foreign Exchange Market[J].The Journal of Finance,1997(52).
[17]丁剑平,俞君钛,张景煜.从外汇市场微观结构视角看中央银行入市交易效果[J].管理世界,2006(7):15-21.
[18]J Frenkel.Flexible Exchange Rates:Prices and the Role of“News” Lessons from the 1970s'[J].Journal of Political Economy,1981 (4):665-705.
[19]PR Krugman.Purchasing power parity and exchange rates:Another look at the evidence[J].Journal of International Economics,1978(3):397-407.
[20]P De Grauwe.The Cost of Disinflation and the European Monetary System [J].Open Economies Review,1990(1):147-173.
[21]EF Fama.Efficient Capital Markets:A Review of Theory and Empirical Work[J].The Journal of Finance,1970(25):383-417.
[22]MC Jensen.Some Anomalous Evidence Regarding Market Efficiency[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1978(6):95-101.
[23]JF Muth.Optimal Properties of Exponentially Weighted Forecasts[J].Journal of the American Statistical Association,1960(55):299-306.
[24]JF Muth.Rational Expectations and the Theory of Price Movements[J].Econometrica,1961(29):315-335.
[25]R Dornbusch.Expectations and exchange rate dynamics[J].The Journal of Political Economy,1976.
[26]WH Branson.Monetarist and Keynesian Models of the Transmission of Inflation[J].The American Economic Review,1975(65):115-119.
[27]JA Frenkel.A Monetary Approach to The Exchange Rate:Doctrinal Aspects and Empirical Evidence[J].The Scandinavian Journal of Economics,1976(78):200-224.
[28]JFO Bilson.The Monetary Approach to The Exchange Rate:Some Empirical Evidence[J].IMF Staff Papers,1978.
[29]Dornbusch.Exchange Rate Risk and the Macroeconomics of Exchange Rate Determination[J].NBER Working Paper No.W0493,1980.
[30]唐国兴,徐剑刚.汇率理论及模型研究[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2003.
[31]K Rogoff.The Purchasing Power Parity Puzzle[J].Journal of Economic Literature, 1996(34):647-668. [32] R Meese, K Rogoff. Empirical Exchange Rate Models of the 1970s: Do They Fit Out of Sample?[J]. Journal of International Economics, 1983(14):
[33] Chin, Menzie D.and Richard A. Meese. Banking on Currency Forecasts: How Predictable is Change in Money?[J]. Journal of International Economics, 1995(38):161-178.
[34] K Rogoff. Monetary Models of Dollar/Yen/Euro Nominal Exchange Rates: Dead or Undead?[J]. The Economic Journal, 1999(109):655-659.
[35] RP Flood, AK Rose. Understanding Exchange Volatility Without the Contrivance of MacroeconomicsfJ]. The Economic Journal,1999(109):660-672.
[36] YW Cheung, MD Chinn, AG Pascual. What Do We Know About Recent Exchange Rate Models? In -Sample Fit and Out-of Sample Performance Evaluated[J]. CESifo Working paper no.902, 2003.
[37] NC Mark. Exchange Rates and Fundamentals: Evidence on Long-Horizon Predictability[J]. American Economic Review, 1995(85):201-218.
[38] NC Mark, DG Sul. Nominal Exchange Rates and Monetary Fundamentals: Evidence From A Small Post-Bretton Woods Panel[J]. Journal of International Economics, 2001(53):29-52.
[39] L Kilian. Exchange Rates and Monetary Fundamentals: What Do We Learn From Long-horizon Regressions?[J]. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 1999(14):491-510.
[40] J Berkowitz, L Giorgianni. Long-horizon Exchange Rate Predictability?[J]. Review of Economics and Statistics,2001(83):81-91.
[41] CJ Neely, L Sarno. How Well Do Monetary Fundamentals Forecast Exchange Rates?[J].Federal Reserve Bank of St.Louis Review,2002(84):51-74.
[42] J Faust, JH Rogers, JH V/right. Exchange Rate Forecasting :The Errors We've Really Made[J]. Journal of International Economics,2003(60):35-59.
[43] M Baxter, AC Stockman. Business Cycles and the Exchange Rate Regime: Some International Evidence[J]. Journal of Monetary Economics, 1989(23):377-400.
[44] RP Flood, AK Rose. Understanding Exchange Rate Volatility Without the Contrivance of Macroeconomics, The Economic Journal, 1999(109):660-672.
[45] MD Goldberg, R Frydman. Macroeconomic Fundamentals and the DM/$ Exchange Rate: Temporal Instability and the Monetary Model[J]. International Journal of Finance & Economics,2001 (6):421 -43 5.
[46] R Schmidt. The Behavioral Economics of Foreign Exchange Markets-A Psychological View on Human Expectation Formation in Foreign Exchange Markets[M]. Die Deutsche Bibliothek, Germany, 2005.
[47] L Kilian, MP Taylor. Why Is It So Difficult to Beat the Random Walk Forecast of Exchange Rates?[J]. Journal of International Economics, 2003(60):85-107.
[48] GP Poole. Speculative Prices As Random Walks: An Analysis of Ten Time Series of Flexible Exchange Rates[J]. Southern Economic Journal, 1967(33):468-78.
[49] RM Levich. Empirical Studies of Exchange Rates: Price Behavior, Rate Determination and Market Efficiency [A]. Handbook of International Economics[C].Jones and Kenen (eds.),1985(2):979-1040. Amsterdam: North -Holland.
[50] RE Cumby, M Obstfeld. A Note on Exchange-Rate Expectations and Nominal Interest Differentials: A Test of the Fisher Hypoth[J]. Journal of Finance, 1981(36): 697-703.
[51] MP Dooley, J Shafer. Analysis of Short-run Exchange Rate Behavior: Mar. 1973 to 1981 [A]. in: Exchange Rate and Trade Instability[C]. David Bigman, Teizo Taya. ( eds), 1983:43 - 69,.Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
[52] LP Hansen, RJ Hodrick. Forward Exchange Rates As Optimal Predictors of Future Spot Rates: An Econometric Analysis[J]. The Journal of Political Economy, 1980(88):829-853.
[53] KA Froot, RH Thaler. Anomalies: Foreign Exchange[J]. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1990(4): 179-192.
[54] M Mussa. Empirical regularities in the behavior of exchange rates and theories of the foreign exchange market[Z]. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 1979(11):9-57.EF Fama. Forward and Spot Exchange Rate [J]. Journal of Money Economics, 1984(14):319-38.
[55] LS Copeland. The Pound Sterling-US Dollar Exchange Rates and the "news"[J]. Economics Letters, 1984(15): 109-13.
[56] P De Grauwe . Exchange Rates In Search of Fundamentals, The Case of The Euro/dollar Rate[A]. in The Financial System Under Stress, AN Architecture for the New World Economy[C], edited by Marc Uzan.2000(9): 196-225.
[57] G Galati and C Ho. Macroeconomic News and The Euro/dollar Exchange Rate[J]. Economic Notes by Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA, 2003(32):371-398.
[58] M Ehrmann, M Fratzscher. Exchange Rates and Fundamentals: New Evidence From Real-time Data[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance, 2005(24):317 - 341.
[59] KM Dominguez. Are Foreign Exchange Forecasts Rational? New Evidence From Survey Data[A], in: Exchange Rate Efficiency and The Behavior of International Asset Markets[C],edited by KM Dominguez, New York, 1992:3-39.
[60] S Cavaglia, WFC Verschoor, CCP Wolff. Further Evidence on Exchange Rate Expectations[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance, 1993(12):78-98.
[61] JT Harvey. The Nature of Expectations in the Foreign Exchange Market: A Test of Competing Theories[J]. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 1999(21): 181-200.
[62] PC Liu, GS Maddala. Rationality of Survey Data and Tests for Market Efficiency in the Foreign Exchange Markets[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance,1992(11):366-381.
[63] SJ Kim. Testing the Rationality of Exchange Rate and Interest Rate Expectations: An Empirical Study of Australian Survey-based Expectations, 1997(29): 1011-1022.
[64] WP Osterberg. New Results on the Rationality of Survey Measures of Exchange Rate Expectations[J]. The Economic Review, 2000(36): 14-21.
[65] JA Frankel, KA Froot. Using Survey Data to Test Standard Propositions regarding Exchange Rate Expectations[J]. American Economic Review, 1987a(17): 133-153.
[66] GW Beng, WK Siong. Exchange Rate Expectations and Risk Premium in the Singapore/US Dollar Exchange Rate: Evidence From Survey Data[J]. Applied Financial Economics,1993(3):365-373.
[67] D Sobiechowski. Rational Expectations in the Foreign Exchange Market? Some Survey Evidence[J]. Applied Economics, 1996(28): 1601 -1611.
[68] M Evans, R Lyons. Order Flow and Exchange-Rate Dynamics [ J]. Journal of Political Economy, 2002(110): 170-180.
[69] P De Grauwe, H Dewachter, M Embrechts. Exchange Rate Theory:Chaotic of Foreign Exchange Markets[J]. The Economic Journal,1993(104):381-402.
[70]陆前进.汇率理论研究的新方法——混沌理论及其评述[J].国际金融研究,2000(2):21-25.
[71]张华.有效市场假设和行为金融学-关于资本市场效率的理论[J].上海管理科学,2003(2):13-14.
[72][美]安德瑞·史莱佛.赵英军译.并非有效的市场——行为金融学导论[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2003年版.
[73][美]赫伯特·A·西蒙.杨砾等译.管理行为[M].北京:北京经济学院出版社,1988年版.
[74]J.M Keynes.The General Theory of Unemployment,Interest and Money[M],Harcourt,Brace andWorld,New York,1936.
[75]D Kahneman,A Tversky.On the Psychology of Prediction[J].The Psychological Review,1973( 80):237-251.
[76]A Tversky,D Kahneman.Judgment Under Uncertainty:Heuristics and Biases[J].Science,1974(185):1124-1131.
[77]KA Froot,DS Scharfstein,JC Stein.Herd on the Street:Informational Inefficiencies in a Market with Short-Term Speculation[J].The Journal of Finance,1992(47):1461-1484.
[78]W Sharpe,G Alexander.Investment[M].4th edition.Englewood,N J:Prentice Hall,1990.
[79]M Friedman.The Case of Flexible Exchange Rates[M],In:Essays in positive economics,Univercity Chicago Press,1953.
[80]A Shleifer,Vishny R.The Limit of Arbitrage[J].Journal of Finance,1997(52):35-55.
[81]Robert Fildes,H.O Stekler.The State of Macroeconomic Forecasting[J].Journal of Macroeconomics,2002(24):
[82]赫什.舍大林著,贺学会译.超越恐惧和贪婪——行为金融学与投资心理诠释[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2005年版.
[83]K.A Froot,J.A Frankel.Forward Discount Bias:Is It An Exchange Rate Premium?[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics 1989(104):139-161.
[84]J.A Frankel,K.A.Froot.The Rationality of the Foreign Exchange Rate,Chartists,Fundamentalists and Trad ing in the Foreign Exchange Market[J].American Economic Review 1990(80): 181-185.
[85] J.A Frankel, K.A.Froot. Chartists, Fundamentalists and the Demand for Dollars[J]. NBER Working Paper No. R1655, 1991.
[86] J.A Frankel, K.A.Froot. Short-term and Long-term Expectations of the Yen/Dollar Exchange Rate: Evidence from Survey Data[J]. NBER working paperNo. 2216,1987(b).
[87] LH. Allen, M. Taylor. Charts, Noise and Fundamentals in the London Foreign Exchange Market[J]. The Economic Journal, 1990(100): 49-59.
[88] M.P Taylor, H Allen. The Use Of Technical Analysis in the Foreign Exchange MarketfJ], Journalof International Money and Finance 1992(11): 304-314.
[89] Y Lui, D Mole. The Use of Fundamental And Technical Analysis By Foreign Exchange Dealers: Hong Kong evidence[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance 1999(17):535-545.
[90] E.C Zeeman. The Unstable Behavior of Stock Exchange[J]. Journal of Mathematical Economics, 1974 (1):39-49.
[91] CH Hommes. Heterogeneous Agent Models in Economics and Finance[J]. Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper No.056,2005.
[92] JB De Long, A Shleifer, LH Summers, RJ Waldmann. Noise Trader Risk in Financial Markets[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1990a( 98): 703-738.
[93] JB De Long, A Shleifer, LH Summers, RJ Waldmann. Positive Feedback Investment Strategies and Destabilizing Rational Speculation[J]. Journal of Finance 1990b( 45): 379-395.
[94] H Hong, J Stein. A Unified Theory of Underreaction, Momentum Trading and Overreaction in Asset Markets[J]. Journal of Financel999( 55): 265-295.
[95] P De Grauwe, M Grimaldi. Heterogeneity of Agents, Transactions Costs and the Exchange Rate[J]. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 2005(29):691-719.
[96] P De Grauwe, M Grimaldi. Exchange Rate Puzzles: A Tale of Switching Attractors[J]. European Economic Review, 2006(50): 1-33.
[97] 张光平.人民币衍生产品[M].北京:中国金融出版社, 2005.
[98] M Hohensee, K Lee. A survey on hedging markets in Asia : a description of Asian derivatives markets from a practical perspective[R], BIS , 2003.
[99]L Lipscomb.An Overview of Non-Deliverable Foreign Exchange Forward Markets[R].Federal Reserve Bank of New York,2005.
[100]陈蓉,郑振龙.NDF市场:挑战与应对—各国NDF市场比较与借鉴[J].国际金融研究,2008(9):39-47.
[101]中国外汇交易中心暨全国银行间同业拆借中心研究部.2006年银行间外汇市场运行报告[R].中国货币市场,2007(1):69-73.
[102]中国外汇交易中心暨全国银行间同业拆借中心研究部.2007年银行间外汇市场运行报告[R].中国货币市场,2008(1):57-61.
[103]李晓峰,陈华.人民币即期汇率市场与境外衍生市场之间的信息流动关系研究[J].金融研究,2008(5):14-24.
[104]徐剑刚,李治国,张晓蓉.人民币NDF与即期汇率的动态关联性研究[J].财经研究,2007(9):61-68.
[105]罗鹏宇.人民币远期:境外决定境内[N].中国证券报,2007-6-12,A11版.
[106]代幼渝,杨莹.人民币境外NDF汇率、境内远期汇率与即期汇率的关系的实证研究[J].国际金融研究,2007(10):72-80.
[107]黄学军,吴冲锋.离岸人民币非交割远期与境内即期汇率价格的互动:改革前后[J].金融研究,2006(11):72-80.
[108]任兆璋,宁忠忠.人民币汇率预期与人民币NDF汇率的实证研究[J].学术研究,2005(12):34-39.
[109]张陶伟,杨金国.人民币NDF与人民币汇率失调关系的实证分析[J].国际金融研究,2005(10):49-54.
[110]B Mandelbrot.The variation of certain speculative prices[J].Journal of Business of the University of Chicago,1963(36):615-623
[111]高铁梅.计量经济分析方法与建模-EViews应用及实例[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2005年.
[112]JM Zakoian.Threshold Heteroskedastic Models[J].Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control,1994(18):931-944.
[113]LR Glosten,R Jagannathan,DE Runkle.On the relation between the expected value and the volatility of the normal excess return on stocks[J].Journal of Finance,1993(48):1779-1801.
[114]DB Nelso,Conditional Heteroskedasticity in asset returns:a new approach[J].Econometrics,1991(59):347-370.
[115]T Lux.The socio-economic dynamics of speculative markets:interacting agents,chaos,and the fat tails of return distributions[J].Journal of economic behavior and organization,1998(33):143-165.
[116]V Ukpolo.Exchange Rate Market Efficiency: Further Evidence from Cointegration Tests[J].Applied Economics Letters,1995(2):196-198.
[117]TA Rapp,SC Sharma.Exchange Rate Market Efficiency:Across and within Countries[J].Journal of Economics and Business,1999(51):423-439.
[118]Belkacem Lotfi,El Zahael Meddeb,Heni Boubaker.Foreign Exchange Market Efficiency:Fractional Cointegration Approach [J].Working Paper,2005.
[119]CY Liu,J He.A Variance-ratio Test of Random Walks in Foreign Exchange Rates[J].Journal of Finance,1991(46):773-785.
[120]K Yilmaz.Martingale Property of Exchange Rates and Central Bank Interventions[J].Journal of Business & Economic Statistics,2003(21):383-395.
[121]曾五一,方琦.关于外汇市场有效性的实证研究[J].当代财经,2005(8):28-32.
[122]吴志国,王相宁.运量策略与外汇市场效率研究[J].南开经济研究,2006(4):111-125.
[123]杨胜刚,卢向前.噪声交易、H指数与中国外汇市场效率研究[J].湖南大学学报(社会科学版),2003(2):81-85.
[124]戴国强,李良松.人民币外汇市场弱式有效性的鞅差分检验[J].国际金融研究,2008(3):36-42.
[125]程宏志.我国股票市场有效性实证研究[D],江西财经大学,2006年.
[126]姜波克.外汇市场的有效性理论述评[J].浙江社会科学,200196):25-31.
[127]高铁梅.计量经济分析方法与建模—Eviews应用及实例[M].北京:清华大学出版社.
[128]TG Andersen,T Bollerslev,FX Diebold,C Vega.Micro Effects of Macro Announcements:Real-time Price Discovery In Foreign Exchange[J].American Economic Review 2003(391):38-62.
[129]S.Edwards.Exchange Rates,Market Efficiency and New Information[J].Economics Letters, 1983(9):377-82.
[130]DC Leonard,ME Solt.Stock Market Signals of Changes in Expected Inflation[J],Journal of Financial Research,1987(10):57-63.
[131]P De Grauwe,M.Grimaldi.The Exchange Rate in a Behavioral Finance Framework[M].Princeton University Press Princeton and Oxford,2006.
[132]L.Mentkhoff.Examining the Use of Technical Currency Analysis[J].International Journal of Finance and Economics 1997(2):307-318.
[133]L.Mentkhoff.The Noise Trading Approach-Questionnaire Evidence From Foreign Exchange[J].Journal of International Money and Finance,1998(17):547-564.
[134]YW Cheung,MD Chinn,IW Marsh,P Str.How Do UK-Based Foreign Exchange Dealers Think Their Market Operates?[J].NBER Working Paper No.W7524,2000.
[135]S Schulmeister.The Interaction Between Technical Currency Trading and Exchange Rate Fluctuations[J].Finance Research Letters,2006(3):212-233.
[136]J.Williamson.The Exchange Rate System[M].Washington,D.C.:International Economics,1983.
[137]贝多广,朱晓莉.试析人民币对外升值与对内贬值并存[J].经济研究,2007(4):32-48.
[138]边绪宝.新外汇管理条例有助于防范和打击热钱[N].证券时报,2008-8-8.
[139]黄瑞玲.汇率稳定机制——以钉住汇率制下的货币危机为视角[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2005.