信贷配给的机制影响与制衡研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
信用配给是中国经济发展与金融市场完善中相关信贷交易的基本特征。资金约束制约着市场当事人行为。企业发展与壮大,项目投资水平和资金效率的提高;金融服务与金融工具的改进,银行利润水平的提高,信用风险有效的控制与管理等,都离不开资金支持及其资金有效配置。不仅如此,近年来,银行积极开展消费信贷,大大缓解了收入约束,提高整个社会消费水平,平滑个人跨时消费,增进其福利。信用配给是货币政策传导的重要工具,对货币政策有着重要种影响,已经成为理论界和业界的一种共识。本文综合运用信息经济学、契约经济学、制度经济学、产业经济学、福利经济学、经济优化等基本理论与方法,紧密结合国内外实践,对信贷配给产生机制、影响以及信贷配给消除方法进行了系统研究,以期把握信贷决策深层次原因,明确金融市场化过程中,即使不存在金融管制,信贷市场也会因信息非对称和高成本监督等原因而导致均衡信贷配给,推动银行和金融机构不断进行金融产品创新,借款者和政府加快制度创新。
     论文共分八章,可概括为五个部分:概述部分、信贷配给产生机制部分、信贷配给影响部分、信贷配给治理部分、总结与展望部分,其中概述部分由第1章组成,信贷配给产生机制部分由第2章和第3章组成,信贷配给影响部分由第4部分组成,信贷配给治理部分由第5、6、7章组成,总结与展望部分由第8章组成。
     第1章主要交代了研究的背景、研究意义、研究对象、对信贷配给产生机制、影响范围、实证方法、消除方法及其制衡机制等相关文献进行了系统的梳理与总结。目的是对全文起一个总揽作用。
     第2章主要对比研究了外生信贷配给和内生信贷配给产生机制。分析了外生以非均衡配给为特征,因管制而导致资金价格不因信贷供求关系的变化而作调整,从而,在存在超额需求时,只能以配给的方式配置资金给借款者。一般认为它只能会短期或暂时达到均衡。同时根据霍奇曼违约风险模型,分析了银行因风险最小化而导致信贷配给内生,并引入贷款收益与亏损作为银行决策两目标,考察了依赖于贷款额的偿付能力。
     第3章为文章核心部分,从契约经济学角度重点阐述了非对称信息导致逆向选择效应、道德风险问题、以及高成本监督是如何产生信贷配给的。另外一个研究是放松了前述信息结构的假设,即非对称信息,即使在信息对称或完美市场下,若破产费用等交易成本特别高,信贷配给同样会产生,并且较为严重。
     第4章主要是探讨信贷配给对不同规模借款者有何影响,以及在农村信贷市场,缺乏担保和缺乏合约执行机构是如何应对信贷配给,结果是声誉和借贷关系的维护极其珍贵。
     第5章从信贷契约设计的角度探讨信贷配给的治理。分离不同风险的借款者,银行可在信贷契约中采取不同条款,即向借款者提供多样菜单。文中分析了契约引入担保、利率、贷款额等条款后,借款者根据自己风险类型进行自选择,克服了非对称导致的逆向选择效应。当研究贷款额作为契约条款时,借款者风险是给定的这一假设放松,即借款者风险会随着贷款额而变化,从而提供随机产出稽核,这会解决道德风险引起的信贷配给。
     第6章研究基于双重信贷配给的治理方法。对于非均衡信贷配给的治理,大多采取制度改革等外部方法。而对于因非对称信息导致的均衡信贷配给,经常采取契约设计分离不同类型。至于那些缺乏担保的借款者,彼此之间合作形成合作联盟,是消除信贷配给的一条可行之路。中小企业和乡村借款者均面临非均衡信贷配给和均衡信贷配给,对其治理不仅在于资金提供方银行的信贷标准和金融契约工具,还在于资金需求方及借款者条件的改进,甚至信贷第三方例如政府参与。
     第7章简要介绍了三种信用风险识别技术:k聚类和神经网络与模糊聚类方法。采用了9个财务指标,对浙江81家上市公司进行了归类,表明统计或智能技术等方法在解决大数据方面有独特优势。
     论文最后对全文作总结,并对未来的研究进行相应的展望。
Credit rationing is the principal characteristics of relevant credit transaction during the development of Chinese economy and the perfection of the financial market. Capital constraint is restricting the concerned party of the market. All of following issues such as the development and the expansion of the enterprises, the enhancement of the project investment level and the capital utilization efficiency, the improvement of the financial service and the financial tools, the increase of bank profit, the effective control and management of credit risk cannot carry on without capital injection and its effective disposition. Besides, in recent years, the bank plays a dynamic role during the development of credit rationing, which greatly alleviate the income restraint, raise the entire society consumption level, and smooth individual consumption crossing periods while with his welfare improved. The credit rationing has been an important instrument for the transmission of monetary policy and has significant influence on the monetary policy, which has been widely accepted in the academic and practice field. Therefore, this paper employs synthetically such fields as the information economics, the contract economic, the system economic, the industrial economics, the welfare economics, the economy optimization, the sociology, the game theory and at the same time integrate domestic and foreign practices tightly so as to conduct a systematic study on the credit rationing theory and its elimination methods. Finally, this paper contains mainly three aspects of contents:
     First is the construction and expansion of the theoretical models. Accounts for information asymmetrical, two chapters have been assigned to make a systematic introduction on the main theoretical models of credit rationing. And certain characteristics have been revealed on the mechanism of internal and provisional credit rationing, and the equilibrium and unequilibrium rationing.
     Second is the application of credit rationing elimination or diminish. This paper has investigated the roles of such factors as guarantee, interest rate, loan scale, risk and anticipated income in the discrimination of types of borrowers, as well as their influence on the enhancement of interest rate while mainly perceiving from the angel of credit contract design and taking into account different credit contract terms,.
     Third, this paper has examined the loan scale, the credit information of borrowers and the influence of government direct credit intervention with both the integration of Chinese practice and current debates in theory and the integration of small enterprises without mortgage and newly established enterprises without credit record, as well as some credit features of developing countries with imperfect financial market. Furthermore, some empirical methods are presented.
引文
[1]阿伦.德雷泽.宏观经济学中的政治经济学[M].杜两省,史永东等译.北京:经济科学出版社, 2003.
    [2]陈丹,沈艳华.合作性竞争:中资银行业务创新的助推器[J].人民大学复印资料金融与保险.003(2).
    [3]陈洪波.不完全契约、控制权实现度与金融契约效率[D].华中科技大学博士论文,2002.
    [4]程卫红.评述信贷配给论[J].金融研究.2003.
    [5]高莹,王丹,梁妤.非对称信息条件下货币政策传导效应研究[J].中国经济评论,2004(12).
    [6]郭斌,刘曼路.民间金融与中小企业发展:对温州的实证分析[J].经济研究.2002(10)
    [7]广东银行课题组.微观运行、宏观效应和制度约束:广东省银行业金融产品创新的实证研究[J].经济研究.2002.
    [8]胡红星,张亚维.中小企业信贷配给的综合模型[J].财贸研究,2005. 3
    [9]雷蒙德.W.戈德史密斯著.金融结构与金融发展[M].周朔等译.上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1998
    [10]李锐,李宁辉.农户借贷行为及其福利效果分析[J].经济研究,2004.12:96-102.
    [11]林毅夫,孙希芳.信息、非正规金融与中小企业融资[J].经济研究.2005.7.
    [12]李宝庆.中小企业发展之信用管理体系的构建[J].金融研究,2002.3
    [13]李志恽.银行结构与中小企业融资[J].经济研究.2002.6
    [14]刘冰,周文兵.中小企业融资难的成因及应对措施[J].财贸经济.2002.6
    [15]刘锡良.信息不对称与企业债务融资方式选择[J].经济学家.2004.4.
    [16]刘坚.非对称信息下的金融合约安排[J].兰州大学学报(社会科学版).2000(2):17-23.
    [17]刘端.中小企业信贷配给问题及信息共享机制[J].经济学家.2003.1.
    [18]穆争社.论信贷配给对宏观经济波动的影响[J].金融研究,2005.1:74-81.
    [19]齐志鲲.银行惜贷、信贷配给与货币政策有效性[J].金融研究.2002.8
    [20]斯蒂格利茨.两部门经济中的异质性资本品配置.国际经济评论.2001.10:373-390。
    [21]斯蒂格利茨.风险条件下的收入、财富和资本利得税效应.经济学季刊.第83卷第2册pp.263-283。
    [22]斯蒂格利茨.对莫迪格利亚尼-米勒定理的审视.美国经济评论.第59卷,pp.784-793.
    [23]宋亚敏,黄绪江.信贷配给模型的基层实证:咸宁个案[J].金融研究.2002.3.
    [24]宋玉华,虞迪锋.转型时期信贷契约的软约束———基于多重治理的思考[J]浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版)2005.7:44-51
    [25]孙立坚.金融体系的微观传导机制.清华大学中国经济研究中心学术论文.No. 200315, 2003.12.
    [26]孙天法.非均衡配额经济学[M].北京:经济科学出版社. 2003.
    [27]王珊.解读中国银行业的信贷配给[J].经济论坛.2003.
    [28]吴明理等.创新路径与比较优势:三种担保模式的实证研究[J].金融研究.2002,10.
    [29]汪三贵.中国小额信贷可持续发展的障碍和前景[J].农业经济问题.2000年第12期
    [30]夏斌,廖强.货币供应量已不宜作为当前我国的货币政策中介目标[J].经济研究,2001年第8期.
    [31]谢进城,张家峰.论抵押担保在不对称信息信贷市场中的作用[J].经济评论,2003殷孟波,贺国生.银行为什么愿意向大企业贷款[J].经济学家.2003年第4期.
    [32]徐强.风险认知差异与信贷配给程度的关系[J].预测2005.1:44-48.
    [33]杨再斌,匡霞.国有商业银行对中小企业信贷配给行为的内生制度根源分析[J].财贸研究.2003.
    [34]叶谦.信贷配给、直接信贷与借贷联盟[J].财经问题研究.2003 .10
    [35]叶谦.违约风险霍奇曼模型的拓展与信贷配给下的中小企业融资[J].财经论丛.2003.4.
    [36]郑振东,王岗.双重信贷配给与中国银行业的流动性隐患研究[J].金融与经济2004..9:12-13
    [37]章元.论团体贷款对信贷市场低效率的可能改进.经济研究[J].2005 1:47-53
    [38]周业安.金融抑制对中国企业融资能力影响的实证研究[J].经济研究,1999.2.
    [39]张元教.缓解中小企业信贷配给的方法[J].统计与决策,2003.
    [40]周好文,李辉.中小企业的关系型融资:实证研究及理论释义[J].南开管理评论.2005.8:69-74.
    [41]周鸿卫.信贷配给的效率分析[J].财经理论与实践.2001.6:35-37.
    [42] Allen N.Berger and Gregory F.U.dell.Some Evidence on the Empirical Significance of Credit Rationing .Journal of Political Economy. 1992. 100(51)
    [43] Adam, Christopher S. Asset Portfolios and Credit Rationing: Evidence from Kenya.Economica, February ,1999, 66( 261): 97-117
    [44] Amano, Masanori .Credit Rationing of a Bayesian Bank with Simple Screening Technologies. Japan and the World Economy, December, 1999, 11( 4):545-56
    [45] Ambrose, Brent W, Pennington-Cross, Anthony, Yezer, Anthony M.Credit Rationing in the U.S. Mortgage Market: Evidence from Variation in FHA Market Shares. Journal of Urban Economics, March, 2002, 51( 2):272-94.
    [46] Angelos A.Antzoulatos 1994, credit rationing and rational behavor. Journal of Money ,credit and banking ,vol.26,no.2 may,1994.
    [47] Allen, Franklin .Credit rationing and payment incentives.Review of Economic Studies; 50 (Oct 83):639-46.
    [48] Ardeni, Pier Giorgio; Messori, Marcello Credit Rationing with Loans of Variable Size Financial constraints and market failures: The microfoundations of New Keynesian macroeconomics. 1999, pp. 141-83
    [49] Arnold, Lutz. Credit Rationing, Unemployment and Business Fluctuations. With Kredit und Kapital, vol. 33, no. 4, 2000, pp. 521-47
    [50] Artus, Patrick.How to React to a Rationing of Bank Credit? With English summary.) Revue Economique, vol. 53, no. 1, January 2002, pp. 63-82
    [51] Arzac, E.R., Schwartz, R.A.and Whitcomb, D.K. A Theory and Test of Credit ationing: Some Further Results.Amercian Economic Review, Vol. 71, Issue 4, p. 735-737, SEP 1981
    [52] Azam, P; Biais, B; Dia, M; Maurel, C.Informal and formal credit markets and credit rationing in Cote D'Ivoire. Oxford Review of Economic Policy; 17 (4) Winter 2001, p.520-34
    [53] Antonio Afonso and Miguel St.Aubyn .Credit rationing and Monetary Transmission:evidence for Portugal. (1998). ISEG Economics Department Working Paper No. 7/98.
    [54] Backhouse, Roger E.Credit Rtioning in a General Equilibrium ModelEconomica; 48 (May 81), p.173-9
    [55] Bagella, M; Becchetti, L; Caggese, A. Financial Constraints on Investments: A Three-Pillar Approach. Research in Economics, June ,2001, vol. 55, no. 2,pp. 219-54
    [56] Baltensperger,E. Credit rationing :Issue and question.Journal of Money,Credit and banking,1978,10:61-89
    [57] Bappaditya Mukhopadhyay. Costly State Verification and Optimal Investment .Journal of Economics and Finance .VOL26.NO.3 fall,2002.
    [58] Basu, Santonu.Financial liberalization and intervention: A new analysis of credit rationing New Directions in Modern Economics. Cheltenham, U.K. and Northampton, Mass.: Elgar; distributed by American International Distribution Corporation, Williston, Vt., 2002, pp. viii, 158
    [59] Baydas, Mayada M; Meyer, Richard L; Aguilera-Alfred, Nelson., Credit Rationing in Small-Scale Enterprises: Special Microenterprise Programmes in Ecuador. The Journal of Development Studies, Dec, 1994, 31(2): 279-288.
    [60] Baydas, Mayada M; Meyer, Richard L; Aguilera-Alfred, Nelson.,Discrimination against women in formal credit markets: reality or rhetoric? World Development, Jul. ,1994, 22 (7) :1073-82
    [61] Beatriz Armendariz de Aghion and Jonathan Morduch., Microfinance Beyond Group Lending .Economics of Transition ,2000, Vol8(2) :401-420.
    [62] Beatriz Armendariz de Aghion and Christian Gollier.,Peer Group Formation In Adverse Selection Model.The Economic Journal, July ,2000,110:632-643 .
    [63] Becchetti, Leonardo; Trovato, Giovanni.The Determinants of Growth for Small and Medium Sized Firms: The Role of the Availability of External Finance. Small Business Economics, December, 2002, 19( 4): 291-306
    [64] Berger, Allen N.; Udell, Gregory F. ,Some Evidence on the Empirical Significance of Credit Rationing. Journal of Political Economy, October, 1992 ,100(5):1047.
    [65] Bernhardt, Dan .Credit Rationing? American Economic Review, March, 2000, vol. 90, no. 1, pp. 235-39.
    [66] Blinder, Alan S., Credit rationing and effective supply failures .Economic Journal, Jun.,1987, 97: 327-52.
    [67] Brian Hillier and Tim Worral, The Welfare Implications of Costly Monitoring In The Credit Mraket”,The Economic Journal, March,1994,104:350-362.
    [68] Bruce D.Smith and Michael J.,Stutzer,credit rationing and Government loan programs :A Welfare analysis AREUEA Journal , 1989.vol.17,no.2,.
    [69] Boucher,Stephen R, Information asymmetries,risk,and non-price rationing :An exploration of rual credit markets in northern Peru. PhD .2000.
    [70] Boissay, Frederic.,Credit Rationing, Output Gap, and Business Cycles European Central Bank Working Paper: 87, November 2001, 29
    [71] Canning, David; Jefferson, Clifford W.and Spencer, John E., Optimal Credit Rationing in Not-for-Profit Financial Institutions.International Economic Review, February 2003, vol. 44, no. 1, pp. 243-61.
    [72] Catt, A J L., Credit rationing and the Keynesian model. Economic Journal; 75 (Jun 65), p.358-72
    [73] Cesaroni, Giovanni.,Credit Multiplier and Its Consequences on Rationing Originated by Certain Conditions of Informational Asymmetry. Economia Politica, vol. 17, no. 3, December 2000, pp. 445-68.
    [74] Chakravarty, Sugato; Scott, James S.,Relationships and Rationing in Consumer Loans Journal of Business, vol. 72, no. 4, October 1999, pp. 523-44.
    [75] Charles W.Calomiris and R.Glenn Hubbard, Firm heterogeneity internal finance and credit rationing. the Economic Journal,1990.
    [76] Chatelain, J-B,Investment facing credit rationing. Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies; 66 Suppt. 1998, p.102-15
    [77] Cieply, Sylvie; Grondin, Marcelline.Screening and Monitoring of SME: An Alternative to Credit Rationing. Revue d'Economie Financiere, vol. 0, no. 54, 1999, pp. 59-78
    [78] Clifford W.Smith,Jr. Pricing Mortgage Originations .AREUEA Journal ,vol.10. 1982
    [79] Coco, Giuseppe.Collateral, Heterogeneity in Risk Attitude and the Credit Market Equilibrium. European Economic Review, vol. 43, no. 3, March 1999, pp. 559-74
    [80] Costas Azariadis Bruce Smith .Adverse selection in a neoclassical growth model .North American Journal of Economics and Finance ,1999,10:339-361
    [81] Cressy, Robert. Credit Rationing or Entrepreneurial Risk Aversion? An Alternative Explanation for the Evans and Jovanovic Finding.Economics Letters, vol. 66, no. 2, February 2000, pp. 235-40
    [82] Cukierman, Alex.The Horizontal Integration of The Banking Firm, Credit Rationing and Monetary Policy. Review of Economic Studies; 45 (Feb 78), p.165-78.
    [83] C.W.M.Naastepad,2001,“The Macro-Economic Effects of Directed Credit Policies:A Real-Financial CGS Evaluation for India”,Development and Change Vol.32,477-506
    [84] C.W,Sealey ,JR 1979 Credit rationing in the Commercial Loan Markets:Estimates of a Structural Model Under Conditions of Disequilibrium .THEJOURNAL OF FINANCE.VOL34 .NO.3 JUNE.
    [85] David de Meza.Overlending ? The Economic Journal, 2002, 112 .
    [86] David Leece. Rationing ,Mortgage demand and the impact of financial deregulation .Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics .57.variability and the availability doctrine. Quarterly Journal of Economics
    [94] Elosegui, Pedro Luis (Ph.D.). Banking with Credit Rationing and Default Risk with an Application to Developing Countries. University of Illinois, 2002
    [95] Eric Van Tassel.Signal Jamming in New Credit Markets .Journal of Money ,Credit ,and Banking ,Vol.34,no.2,May, 2002.
    [96] Ernst Baltensperger. The Borrower-Leader Relationship ,Competitive Equilibrium, and the Theory of Hedonic Prices。
    [97] Espinosa-Vega, Marco A; Smith, Bruce D; Yip, Chong K.Monetary Policy and Government Credit Programs.Journal of Financial Intermediation, vol. 11, no. 3, July 2002, 232-68
    [98] Fahad Khalil and Bruno M.Parigi .Loan Size as a Commiment Device.International Economic Review ,vol.39 ,no.1 ,February ,1998.
    [99] F.Bourguignon ,M.Fournier,and M.Gurgand.Fast Development with a Stable Income Distribution:Taiwan,1979-94 . Review of income and wealth .Series 47,Number 2,June 2001.2001
    [100] Ferrara, Ferdinando.A Post Keynesian Analysis of Credit Rationing. Studi Economici, vol. 54, no. 69, 1999, 101-17.
    [101] Fielding, David .Investment under Credit Rationing and Uncertainty: Evidence from South Africa. Journal of African Economies, vol. 9, no. 2, June 2000, ,189-212
    [102] Franklin Allen. Credit Rationing and Payment Incentives. Review of Economic Studies ,1983。
    [103] Giovanni Majnoni, Margaret Miller, Nataliya Mylenko, and Andrew Powell.Improving Credit Information, Bank Regulation, and Supervision: On the Role and Design of Public Credit Registries. 2004, 11(2).
    [104] Gregorio impavido.Credit Rationing ,Group Lending and Optimal Group Size.Annals of Public and Coperative Economics , 1998,69:2
    [105] Grossl-Gschwendtner, Ingrid.Credit Rationing: Microeconomic Foundations and Macroeconomic Implications. Jahrbucher fur Nationalokonomie und Statistik, vol. 212, no. 1-2,July 1993, 120-39
    [106] Harl E.Ryder,Jr.Credit Risk and Credit Rationing Commment. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1965
    [107] Henry Buist,Peter D.Linneman,and Isaac F.Megbolugbe.Residential-Mortgage Lending Discrimination and Lender-Risk-Compensating Policies. Real Estate Economics,1999,V27 4,695-717.
    [108] Helmut Bester,Screening vs. Rationing in Credit Markets with Iplication Information .The Amercian Economic Review . 1985 ,Vol.75 No.4 .September.
    [109] Hermann, Jennifer.The Credit Rationing Model and the New-Keynesian Monetary Policy: A Critical Analysis. With Brazilian. Journal of Political Economy, vol. 20, no. 2, April-June 2000, 53-75
    [110] Hickok, Susan; Gray, Clive S.Capital-market controls and credit rationing in Mali and Senegal. Journal of Modern African Studies; March, 1981,57-73
    [111] Hildegard C.Wette, Collateral in Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Iformation :Note,The Amercian Economic Review . 1983,VOL.73.NO.3
    [112] Hogman, D.,Credit risk and credit rationing,Quanterly Joural of Economics, 1960,74,258-278.
    [113] Horst Tomann,Private Home-ownership Finance for Low-income Households, Urban Studies, 1996,Vol.33,No.10,1879-1889.
    [114] Hung-Jen Wang Symmetrical information and credit rationing :Graphical demonstrations.
    [115] Jaffee ,D& F.Modegliani, A theory and test of credit rationing,Amercian Economic Review, 1969,59:850-872.
    [116] Jean Helwege and Frank Pecker .Determinants of the choice of bankruptcy procedure in Japan. Journal of Financial Intermediation ,2003,12, 96-120.
    [117] Job Swank Theories of the banking firm:A Review of the literature Bulletin of Economics Research 48:3,1996,0307-3378.
    [118] John McCallum,Credit Rationing and the Monetary Transmission Mechanism.The Amercian Economic Review September 1991
    [119] John Umbeck and Robert E.Chatfield, The structure of contracts and transaction costs . journal of Money ,credit and banking , 1982.vol.14,no.4.
    [120] John H.Kareken, Lenders preferences credit rationing and the effectiveness of monetary policy . Review of Economics and Statistics XXXIX 1957. (AUG.1957)292-302.
    [121] Jones, C; Maclennan, D. Building societies and credit rationing: an empiricalExamination of redlining . Urban Studies; 24 (Jun 87) p.205-16.
    [122] Jung, Jeeman. Credit Rationing with a Moral Hazard Problem. Seoul Journal of Economics, vol. 13, no. 2, Summer 2000,65-83.
    [123] Kose John and Anthony W.Lynch. Credit Rationgs ,Collateral and Loan Characteristics :Implications for Yield .Journal of Business ,2003,vol.76,no.3 ,371-409
    [124] ]Koskela, Erkki; Viren, Matti,Credit Rationing and Consumer Intertemporal Choice.Oxford Economic Papers; 36 (Jun 84), p.241-7 .
    [125] Lederman, Daniel,et al..Mexican Investment after the Tequila Crisis: Basic Economics, Confidence Effects or Market Imperfections? Journal of International Money and Finance, February 2003, vol. 22, no. 1,131-51.
    [126] Levenson, Alec R; Willard, Kristen L. Do Firms Get the Financing They Want? Measuring Credit Rationing Experienced by Small Business in the U.S.Small Business Economics, March 2000, vol. 14, no. 2, 83-94.
    [127] Lizal, Lubomir; Svejnar, Jan.Investment, Credit Rationing, and the Soft Budget Constraint: Evidence from Czech Panel Data.Review of Economics and Statistics, May 2002, vol. 84, no. 2, 353-70.
    [128] Mayada M.Baydas, Richard L.Meyer and Nelson Aguilera–Alfred.Credit Rationing in Small-Scale Enterprises:Special Microenterprise Programmes in Ecuador”, The Joural of Development Studies, December1994 ,Vol.31,No.2,279-309.
    [129] Marco A. Espinpsa–Vega ;Bruce D.Smith. Socially Excessive Bankruptcy Costs and the Benefits of Interest Rate Ceilings on Loans.FED of Atlanta working paper 2001,27
    [130] Marshall Freimer and Myron J.,Gordon.Why bankers ration credit. Quarterly Journal of Economics , 2001,11 .
    [131] Moshe Kim,Doron Kliger Bent Vale,Estimating switching costs:the case of banking journal of financial intermediation ,2003, 12,25-56.
    [132] Naastepad, C W M.,The Macro-economic Effects of Directed Credit Policies: A Real-Financial CGE Evaluation for India. Development and Change, June 2001, vol. 32, no. 3,491-520
    [133] Nesiba, Reynold F. Racial Discrimination in Residential Lending Markets: WhyEmpirical Researchers Always See It and Economic Theorists Never Do. Journal of Economic Issues, 1996, 30, 1, Mar, 51-77.
    [134] Pamela Labadie.Aggregate Fluctuations,Financial Constraints and Risk Sharing.Economic Theory , 1998,12:621-648
    [135] Parker, S C.,Do Banks Ration Credit to New Enterprises? And Should Governments Intervene? President's lecture delivered at the annual general meeting of the Scottish Economic Society 4-5 September 2001. Scottish Journal of Political Economy; 49 (2) May 2002, p.162-95
    [136] Peter Winker,Sluggish adjustment of interest rates and credit rationing :an application of unit root testing and error correction modeling Applied Economics,1999,31:267-277.
    [137] Qiu, Larry D.,Credit Rationing and Patterns of New Product Trade.Journal of Economic Integration, March 1999, vol. 14, no. 1,75-95
    [138] Rajan R. and L. Zingales.Financial Dependence and Growth", American Economic Review, 1998 ,vol 88, 559-586.
    [139] Robert Lensink &Elmer Sterken. The Option to Wait to Invest and Equilibrium Credit Rationing .Journal of Money ,Credit ,and Banking ,Vol .34, No.
    [146] Seza Danisoglu Rhoades and Z.Nuray Guner.Economic Uncertainty and Credit Crunch _Evidence from an emerging Market. Emerging Markets Finance and trade, July-August , 2003 , vol.39,no.4,5-23.
    [147] Shen, Chung-Hua.Credit Rationing for Bad Companies in Bad Years: Evidence from Bank Loan Transaction Data. International Journal of Finance and Economics, July 2002, vol. 7, no. 3, 261-78.
    [148] Simon C.Parker .Do banks Ration Credit to New Enterprises ?and Should Governments in Tervene? Scotish Journal of Political Economy, May,2002, vol.49,no.2
    [149] Spencer, P D .Bank Regulation, Credit Rationing and the Determination of MoneyMarket Interest Rates. Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies; 50 (Mar 82), p.41-60.
    [150] Stanley D.Longhofer and Joao A.C.Santos . the Importance of Bank Seniority for Relationship Lending . Fderal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Working Paper 9808 .1999
    [151] Stacey L.Schreft and Anne P.Villamil“credit rationing by loan size in commercial loan markets ) Economic Review May/June 1992
    [152] Stigliz and Weiss .Credit rationing in markets with imperfect information. Amercian Economic Review, 1981,73:912-927.
    [153] []Swain, Ranjula Bali.Credit Rationing in Rural India. Journal of Economic Development, December 2002, vol. 27, no. 2, 1-20
    [154] Swinnen, Johan F M; Gow, Hamish R.Agricultural Credit Problems and Policies during the Transition to a Market Economy in Central and Eastern Europe. Food Policy, February 1999, vol. 24, no. 1, 21-47.
    [155] Takatosh Ito and Kazuo Ueda. Tests of the Equilibrium Hypothesis in Disequilibrium Econometrics: An International comparison of credit rationing 1981.
    [156] Theofanis Tsoulouhas,Renegotiation_proof Labour and credit contracts with worker mobility. Ecomica ,1999, 66,433_54.
    [157] Valentini, Laura. Credit Rationing and Capital Structure: A Survey of Empirical Studies University of Southampton, Discussion Paper in Economics and Econometrics: August,1999, 34..
    [158] Vlad Ivanenko .Nonmonetary Trade and Differential Access to Credit in the Russian Transition. Problems of Economic Transition,April. 2003, vol.45,no.12
    [159] William Beranek &Frederik C.Scherr. On the Significance of Trade Credit Limits. Financial Practice and Education Fall/Winter, 1991
    [160] Winker, Peter.Sluggish Adjustment of Interest Rates and Credit Rationing: An Application of Unit Root Testing and Error Correction Modelling.Applied Economics, vol. 31, no. 3, March 1999, pp. 267-77.
    [161] Wu, Chung-Shu; Hu, Sheng-Cheng.Interest Rates, Credit Rationing, and Banking Deregulation in Taiwan. Institute of Econ, Academia Sinica; Institute of Econ, Academia Sinica
    [162] Xu, Bin.The Welfare Implications of Costly Monitoring in the Credit Market: A Note Economic Journal, April 2000, vol. 110, no. 463, 576-80,
    [163] Yukio Rimbara and Anthony M Santomero.A Study of Credit Rationing in Japan.International Economic Review, 1976, vol. 17, issue 3, 567-80
    [164] Yoram Kroll and Assaf Cohen . Alternative Solutions to Underinvestment ,Under Equity and Credit Rationing Journal of Business Finance &Accounting 27(3)&(4)April/May, 2000.
    [165] Yuk-Shee Chan and Anjan V.Thakor.Collateral and Competitive Equilibria with Moral Hazard and Private Information. The Journal of Finance. June 1987, Vol.xlii,no.2
    [166] Zeller, Manfred. Determinants of credit rationing: a study of informal lenders and formal credit groups in Madagascar.World Development; Dec1994, 22 no12,1895-1907

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700