基于供应链的效益背反问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
物流是一个综合系统,由运输、存储、包装、装卸搬运、流通加工和物流信息六个环节要素构成。这六个环节相互影响、相互作用,形成一个有机整体,发挥综合效益。近年来,物流作为“第三利润的源泉”越来越受到关注,降低物流成本成为研究的重点,但是系统内各要素之间存在着“效益背反”,尽管企业采取了多种措施降低物流成本,但成本却没有明显下降。所以,能否贯彻好系统原理即对物流进行系统管理相当重要。
     伴随着各种先进管理理念、管理思想的出现,特别是现代通讯、信息技术的发展,出现的供应链管理是当今管理理论和实践的热点。供应链管理逐渐被认为是企业增强竞争力的重要途径。二十世纪八十年代,西方发达国家,如美国、法国和德国等都提出了“物流一体化”的现代理论,应用于指导其物流发展并取得了明显的效果,使他们的生产商、供应商和销售商均获得了显著的经济效益。
     论文首先分析了国内外在效益背反、物流成本和供应链管理方面的相关文献,认为可以应用供应链思想解决物流系统中由效益背反引起的物流成本过高的问题。
     其次,论文对物流系统的构成要素的性质、目标和物流成本构成进行了分析,认为物流要素活动形成的成本加总形成了物流总成本,同时得出效益背反的根本冲突就存在于物流各职能要素的活动之中。因此解决效益背反问题,降低物流总成本必须考虑物流的系统特性。
     接下来,重点研究了供应链管理思想的起源和发展方向,并提出可以在现实中应用的物流组织形式——战略联盟;在阐述了供应链理论的基础上,站在物流成本角度应用由系统论衍生出的耗散结构理论证实了供应链理论解决效益背反问题的可行性。
     在定量分析方面,运用SCOR模型归纳出供应链上物流企业的运作步骤,并对其进行协同效应分析,考证供应链管理对物流企业经济效益的影响;在供应链模式中,供应链成员之间是既合作又竞争的关系,供应链目标是实现“共赢”。合作博弈问题关系到供应链的成效。论文应用博弈理论重点研究了供应链的整体收益情况,同时描述了供应链利益的分配模式。
     最后,采用数学包络分析衡量供应链绩效。在充分研究了传统绩效评价的缺陷和当前供应链绩效评价的现状后,本文建立了投入—产出型的供应链绩效评价体系,选择DEA中的C2R模型评价了某行业内的供应链管理改进效果,并得出通过提升系统化管理水平确实可以使供应链效益增加,只有整体利益得到保证,个体将损失降到最低,才能使物流成本得到控制,从根本上抑制了效益背反问题。
The physical distribution is a system ensemble, by transportation, stocking, and packing, load and unload transporting, circulation processing and physical distribution information six-link essential factor constitution. These six links affect mutually form an organic whole. In recent years, the physical distribution achievement as the third profit fountainhead; more and more received the attention, reduced the physical distribution cost to become the key point to be researched, but in the system between various essential factors have trade off, although the enterprise took many kinds of measures to reduce the physical distribution cost, the cost did not have to drop obviously. Therefore, whether implements the good system principle to carry on the physical distribution is quite important.
     Following each kind of advanced management idea, the management thought appearance, specially the information technology development, appears the supply chain management is the theory and the practice hot spot now. The supply chain management was considered gradually the important way for the enterprise strengthens the competitive power. 1980s, the Western developed country, like US, France and Germany and so on all proposed the modern theory of "physical distribution integration", applied in instructs its physical distribution to develop and to obtain the tangible effect, caused their producer, supplier and the seller has obtained the remarkable economic efficiency.
     The paper has first analyzed domestic and foreign in the trade off, the physical distribution cost and the supply chain management aspect related literature, obtains may apply the supply chain theory solution physical distribution system cost excessively high.
     Next, this article to the physical distribution system integrant part nature, the goal and the physical distribution cost constitution has carried on the analysis, thought the physical distribution essential factor activity forms the cost added has always formed the physical distribution total cost, simultaneously obtained the trade off basic conflict during various functions essential factor activity. Therefore the solution of trade off reduces the physical distribution total cost has to consider the performance of physical distribution system.
     In the third part, has with emphasis on the supply chain management thought origin and the development direction, and proposes may reality in the application physical distribution organization form strategy alliance; Stood the diffusion structural theory which grew by the system theory confirmed the supply chain theory solution trade off feasibility in the physical distribution cost angle application.
     In the fourth, five parts, induce using the SCOR model supply chain the physical distribution enterprise's operation step, and carries on the coordination effect on it; In the supply chain pattern, supplies between the chain member is both cooperates and competes, supply chain goal is the realization "win-win". The cooperation gambling question relates supply chain result. The paper emphasis on using the gambling theory has supplied the chain overall income situation, simultaneously described the supply chain benefit pattern.
     In the sixth part, uses DEA weight supply chain achievements. After fully studied the current supply chain achievements appraisal present situation, this article has established the investment-delivers the supply chain achievements appraisal system, chose in DEA the C2R model to appraise in some profession supply chain management improvement effect, through the promotion systematization management level may make the supply chain benefit truly to increase, then the overall benefit will obtain the guarantee, the individual loses falls to low, enable the physical distribution cost to be under the control, fundamentally has suppressed the trade off.
引文
[1] BoukasE K Ship Andijani A Robust, inventory-Production Stochastic demand[J]. Optic mal Control Application control Problem with the sand Methods, 1999, 20: 1: 20.
    
    [2] Seder age D, Fujiwara O, Luong HT, Determing optimal order splitting and reorder level for N-supplier inventory systems[J]. European Journal of Operation Research,1999, 116 (20): 389-404.
    [3] Lee H L, Billington C, Managing supply chain inventory: Pitfalls and Opportunities [J]. Sloan. Management Review, 1992, spring, 65-73.
    [4] Dober D W, Burt D N. purchasing and supply management[M]. Text and cases (6th ed New York, 1996.
    [5] Bob Lowson. Managing the Supply Chain to Meeting Consumer Demand[M]. John Wiley & Sons. Ltd, 1999.
    [6] John Femie Sparks. Logistics and Retail Management[M]. Insights in top currant Practice and trends from leading experts, Koran Pale Limit, 1999.
    [7] Quinn, Franeis J Reengineering the Supply Chain An Interview with Michael Hammer[J]. Supply Chain Management Review, 1999 (4): 20-26.
    [8] Marien, Edward J The Four Supply Chain Enablers[J]. Supply Chain Management Review, 2000, 3-4: 60-68.
    [9] Blaekwell, Roger D, Kristina. The Century of Consumer: Converting SupplyChain Into Demand Chain[J]. Supply Chain Management Review, 1999 (3): 22-32.
    [10] Bas Groothedde, Cees Ruijgrok, Lori Tavasszy. Towards collaborative intermodal hub networks A case study in the fast moving consumer goods market[J]. Transportation Research Part E, 2005, 41: 567-583.
    
    [11] Chaug-Ing Hsu, Hui-Chieh Li. Optimal delivery service strategy for Internet shopping with time dependent consumer demand[J]. Transportation Research Part E, 2006,42:473-497.
    
    [12] Gavirneni S, Kapuscinski R, Tayur S. Value of information in capacitated supply chains[J]. Management Science, 1999, Vol.45, No.1: 16-24.
    
    [13] Chung Piaw Teo, Jinong Ou and Mark Goh. Impact on inventory costs with consolidation of distribution centers[J]. HE Transactions, 2007, 33: 99-110.
    
    [14] Koichi Shintani, Akio Imai, Etsuko Nishimura, Stratos Papadimitriou. The container shipping network design problem with empty container repositioning[J]. Transportation Research Part E, 2007, 43: 39-59.
    
    [15] Oum Tae Hoon, Park Jong-Hun. Multinational firms location preference for regional distribution centers: focus on the Northeast Asian region [J]. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 2004, 3: 101-121.
    
    [16] Shailesh S Kulkarn, Michael J Magazine and Amitabh S Raturi. On the trade offs between risk pooling and logistics costs in a multi plant network with commonality [J]. HE Transactions, 2005, 37: 247-265.
    
    [17] Yue Wu. Robust optimization applied to uncertain production loading problems with import quota limits under the global supply chain management environment[J]. International Journal of Production Research, Vol.44. No.5, 1 March 2006, 849-882.
    [18] Flynn J, Garstka. The optimal review period in a dynamic inventory model [J]. Operation Research, 1997, Vol.45, No.5: 736-750.
    [19] Giri B C, Goswami A, Chaudhuri K S. An EOQ model for deteriorating items with time varying demand and costs [J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society,1996, Vol.47, No.11: 1387-1405.
    [20] AMM Jamal, BR Sarker, S Wang. An ordering policy for deteriorating items with allowable shortage and permissible delay in payment[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society, 1997, Vol.48, No.8: 826-833.
    [21] John N. Management complexity theory and methods of system[M]. University of Mining Press, July 2006.
    [22] Baek R L, Smith Y D Kim. Adaptive inventory control models for supply chain management [J]. lntl Adv ManufTechnol, 2005, 26: 1184-1192.
    [23] Mehmet Ferhat Candas, Erhan Kutanoglu. Benefits of considering inventory in service parts logistics network design problems with time based service constraints[J]. HE Transactions, 2007, 39: 159-176.
    [24] Deloitte Consulting LLP, Chicago, Illinois. Adopting a customer-focused and process-centric supply chain[J]. Hydrcoarbon Processing, 2007, 11: 101-108
    [25] Rahul Kale, Philip T Evers, Martin E Dresner. Analyzing private communities on Internet-based collaborative transportation networks[J]. Transportation Research Part E, 2007, 43: 21-38.
    [26] Susan X.Li, Zhimin Huang, Allan Ashley. Improving buyer-seller system cooperation through inventory control [J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 1996,43: 37-46.
    [27] Wernerfelt B. A resource-based view of the firm [J]. Strategic Management Journal,1984, 12 (5): 89-96.
    [28] Prahalad C K, Hamel G. The core competence of the corporation [J]. Harvard Business Review, 1990, 5 (6): 89-98.
    [29] Teece D J, Pisano G, Shuen A. Dynamic capabilities strategic management [J]. Strategic Management, 1997, 18 (7): 23-36.
    [30] Michael A. Hitt, R. Duane Ireland, Robert E Hoskisson. Strategic Management:Competitiveness and Globalization[M]. South-Western College Pub, 2004: 347.
    [31] Hannah, Michael T, John Freeman. The Population Ecology of Organizations American Journal of Sociology[M]. Organizational Ecology Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1977.
    [32] Wouter Faes. The Pursuit of Global Purchasing Synergy[J]. Industrial Marketing Mangement, 2000, 29: 539-553.
    [33] Kenny J, Sean Examining and embracing the value of coalition participation[J].Employee Benefits Journal Brookfie 1 d, 2000, 3: 12-13.
    
    [34] Jean Nolleta, Martin Beaulieub. The development of group purchasing: an empiricalstudy in the healthcare sector[J] . Journal of Purchasing&Supply Management, 2003, 9: 3-10.
    [35] Mark Vigoroso. Buying consortiums suit some, not all[J]. Purchasing, 1998, 125(2): 7.
    [36] David Ball, Jo Pye. Library purchasing consortia: the UK periodicals supply market[J]. Learned Publishing, 2000, 13 (1): 2535.
    [37] Tulip, Sam. Joining forces[J]. Supply Management, 1999, 12: 24-30.
    [38] Fredo Schotanus, Jan Telgen, Luitzen de Boer. Unfair division of gains underequal price in cooperative purchasing[J]. Purchasing and Supply Management: Theory and Practice, 2005, 5: 135-144.
    [39] Ming-Jong Yao, Chuang-Chun Chiou. On a replenishment coordinationmodel in an integrated supply chain with one vendor and multiple buyers[J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 2004, 159: 406-419.
    [40] Stanisaw Bylka. A dynamic model for the single-vendor, multi-buyerproblem[J].International Journal of Production Economics, 1999, 59: 297-304.
    [41] S Viswanathan, Rajesh Piplani. Coordinating supply chain inventories through common replenishment epochs[J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 2001,129: 277-286.
    [42] York Y Woo, Shu-Lu Hsu, Soushan Wu. An integrated inventory model for a single vendor and multiple buyers with ordering cost reduction[J]. International Journal of Production Economics, 2001, 73: 203-215.
    
    [43] Chi Kin Chan, Bernard K-S Cheung. Solving the mufti-buyer joint replenishment Research Part problem with a modified genetic algorithm[J]. Transportation B, 2003,37: 291-299.
    [44] Zted Jemat, Ftkrt Karaesmen. Decentralized inventory control in a two stage capacitated supply chain[J]. HE Transactions, 2007, 39: 501-512.
    [45] Minghui Xu, Xiangtong Qi, Gang Yu & Hanqin Zhang. Coordinating dyadic supply chains when production costs are disrupted[J]. HE Transactions, 2006, 38: 765-775.
    [46] Martin Christopher. Logistics and Supply Chain Management[M]. Publishing House of Electronics Industry, 2003.1.: 177-285.
    [47] Joseph Kim-Keung. What can contemporary systems thinking offer to logistics management as a management discipline[J]. European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management, 1997, 6 (2): 77-81.
    
    [48] Pirttila, Timo, Huiskonen Janne. A framework for cost-service analysis in differentiation of logistics services[J] . International Journal of Production Economics, 1996.8 (1-3): 131-137.
    [49] McDermott, Christopher M, Stock Gregory N. Organizational culture and advanced manufacturing technology implementation[J]. Journal of Operations Management,1999, 8 (5): 521-533.
    [50] Spalding J Q. Transportation industry Take the Right-of-way in the society[J]. HE solutions, 1998, No.7: 134-139.
    [51] Ana Paula Iannoni, Reinaldo Morabito. A discrete simulation analysis of a logistics supply system[J]. Transportation Research Part E, 2006, 42: 191-210.
    [52] Joakim Eriksson, Niclas Finne and Sverker Janson. Evolution of a supply chain management game for the Trading Agent Competition[J]. AI Communications, 2006,19: 1-12.
    [53] M S Osman, M A Abo-Sinna, A .H .Amer, O E Eman. A multi-level non-linear multi-objective decision-making under fuzziness[J] . Applied Mathematics and Computation, Volume 153, Issue 1, 25 May 2004: Pages239-252.
    [54]GeWang,Samuel H,Huang John P,Dismukes.Manufacturing supply chain design and evaluation[C].Advanced Manufacturing Technology.2004.
    [55]Lye A V,Bergen M E.Quick Response in manufacturer retailers' channels.Management science[J].1997,Vo143.No4.559-570.
    [56]Liane Eastona,David J Murphyb,John N.Pearson.Purchasing performance evaluation:with data envelopment analysis[J].European Journal of Purchasing &Supply Management,2002,(8):123-134.
    [57]A Gunasekaran,C Patel,E Tirtiroglu.Performance measures and metrics in a supply chain environment[J].International Journal of Operations & Production Management,2001,21:71-74.
    [58]Krause,Daniel,Seannell,V Thomas,Calantone,J Rojer.A Structural Analysis of the Effectiveness of Buying Firms Strategies to Improve Supplier Performance[J].Decision Sciences.Winter 2000,(1):33-55.
    [59]吴清一.物流学[M].北京:中国建材工业出版社,1996:53.
    [60]何明坷.物流系统论[M].北京:中国审计出版社,2001:21.
    [61]何明珂.现代物流与配送中心[M].北京:中国商业出版社,1997:91.
    [62]宋华.现代物流与供应链管理案例[M].北京:经济管理出版社,2001:170.
    [63]王之泰.现代物流管理[M].北京:中国工人出版社,2001:262.
    [64]唐纳德J鲍尔索克斯,戴维J克劳斯.物流管理一供应链过程的一体化[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1999:115.
    [65]罗纳德·H·巴罗.企业物流管理一供应链的规划、组织和控制[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2002:273.
    [66]菊池康也.物流管理[M].北京:清华大学出版社,1999:96.
    [67]高建兵,黄岩.企业物流成本的局部控制和综合控制[J].物流科技,2000,1:27-29.
    [68]高建兵,黄岩.企业物流成本的控制研究[J].物流技术,2000,3:53-55.
    [69]崔介何.电子商务与物流[M].北京:中国物质出版社,2002:22.
    [70]陆薇.企业物流成本初探[J].物流技术,2003,7:33-36.
    [71]高梦昭,张文杰.物流成本探析-运输成本与库存成本的关系研究[J].北方交通大学学报,2003,3:14-19.
    [72]黄福员,聂瑞华.非线性规划多目标优化物流成本随机模型的研究[J].华南师范大学学报,2003,3:56-58.
    [73]靳伟.企业物流成本计算和物流成本管理[J].中国物流与采购,2003,7:41-43.
    [74]王圣广,马士华.基于全球供应链的虚拟企业[J].管理工程学报,1999(3):9-16.
    [75]高自友,孙会君.现代物流与交通运输系统[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2005:104.
    [76]赵杰.管理系统工程[M].北京:科学出版社,2006:72.
    [77]蓝伯雄,郑晓娜,徐心.电子商务时代的供应链管理[J].中国管理科学,2000(3):1-7.
    [78]张岩.日本流通体制变革研究[D].辽宁:辽宁大学,2006.
    [79]胡志辉.基于成本分析的企业仓储类型决策研究[D].武汉:武汉理工大学,2005.
    [80]王家祥.现代企业物流信息系统研究[D].天津:天津大学,2005.
    [81]李艳丽.我国实施供应链一体化管理的问题与对策[J].交通企业管理,2007,4:57-58.
    [82]夏文汇.现代物流运作管理[M].四川:西南财经大学出版社,2003:251.
    [83]马新安,张列平,田澎.供应链内部成员满意[J].工业工程与管理,2001(6):14-17.
    [84]胡运权.运筹学教程[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2003:318.
    [85]刘荣华,孙皓,赵娟.基于供应链的运输决策研究[J].中国海洋大学学报,2007,1:63-65.
    [86]张雨石.产业供应链下库存与运输系统集成优化研究[D].大连:大连海事大学,2006.
    [87]孙清华,彭志忠.供应链多级库存控制应用研究[J].生产力研究,2008,2:56-58.
    [88]高克义.包装对物流成本和客户服务的影响研究[J].物流技术,2007,26(5):31-32.
    [89]王成林,李淑芬.促进流通加工发展的策略分析[J].物流工程,2007,5:48-49.
    [90]徐剑,孙莹.基于供应链的物流信息系统的构建[J].现代物流,2008,4:276-277.
    [91]刘英祥.论物流系统的成本控制主导性与效益背反性[J].现代物流,2006,32:25-27.
    [92]郑艺龙.企业物流成本管理[J].企业发展,2007,3:60-62.
    [93]于春荣,李宏图.存货成本与物流各功能活动之间存在效益背反的战略分析[J].工业技术经济,2005,24(8):114-115.
    [94]张永梅.浅谈企业降低物流成本的几种途径[J].内蒙古科技与经济,2007,11:82-83.
    [95]谢庆红,曾国平.现代企业物流成本管理障碍及对策[J].科技管理研究,2005,5:108-110.
    [96]宋伯慧,王耀球.装卸搬运设备配置优化研究[J].物流技术,2006,7:145-147.
    [97]王成林,李淑芬.促进流通加工发展的策略分析[J].物流工程,2007,5:48-49.
    [98]张丹.汽车制造企业精益供应物流研究[D].武汉:武汉科技大学,2006.
    [99]余海.物流领域中的二率背反现象及对应策略[J].商业研究,2006,7:186-188.
    [100]罗军林,盛革,张宁.基于联盟协同观的供应链成本控制体系的构建[J].商业研究,2007,8:50-53.
    [101]阮炳晨.系统科学对供应链管理的影响和利用[J].内蒙古农业大学学报,2007,6:134-136.
    [102]梁涛.基于自组织理论的企业集群形成机制分析[D].河北:河北工业大学,2006.
    [103]姚慧丽.基于自组织与熵理论的企业扩张机理与相关决策研究[D].南京:南京理工大学,2007.
    [104]周立华,宋殿辉,王玉民.供应链协同的竞争优势研究[J].长春工业大学学报,2007,19(2):4-6.
    [105]陈钦兰.供应链中企业合作协同的战略因素研究[J].山西财经大学学报,2007,29(3):83-88.
    [106]杨琼.供应链库存控制策略研究[D].江苏:江苏大学,2005.
    [107]段敏.基于战略成本管理视角的企业物流成本管理研究[D].成都:西南财经大学,2006.
    [108]孙道银,李东.供应链管理中的系统科学思想[J].经济与管理,2008,22(1):77-82.
    [109]于江海,张志亮.供应链系统的复杂自适应性研究[J].物流技术,2007,26(4):62-65.
    [110]邱苑华.管理决策与应用熵学[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2002.
    [111]曹悠琦.熵及耗散结构理论在企业物流系统中的应用[D].重庆:重庆大学,2007.
    [112]李洪心.基于SCOR的供应链管理模型研究[J].东北财经大学学报,2006,2:36-39.
    [113]唐洪雷.供应链各节点企业协同分析[J].合作经济与科技,2007,5:36-37.
    [114]张伟.汽车行业供应链博弈关系及收益分配模型研究[D].西安:长安大学,2006.
    [115]王岳峰,刘伟.考虑权重的Shapley值法虚拟企业伙伴利益分配策略的改进[J].上海海事大学学报,2005,26(4):81-83.
    [116]郑君君,刘恒,陈京华.供应链伙伴的合作博弈研究[J].科技进步与对策,2006,7:144-146.
    [117]王莺,贺盛瑜,刘小艳.考虑风险的供应链合作利益分配问题研究[J].商场现代化,2007,2:65-66.
    [118]韩景丰,赵道致.基于合作博弈分析的供应链结构的比较研究[J].工业工程,2007,10(3):11-14.
    [119]雷玲.基于耗散结构理论的供应链系统及管理绩效评价[J].商场现代化,2007,5:149-150.
    [120]李军.基于DEA的现代物流企业绩效评价指标体系研究[A].见:第八届中国青年运筹信息管理学者大会论文集[C].2006:425-432.
    [121]刘俊.基于SCOR绩效评价的供应链诊断模型[J].物流科技,2006,29(135):46-48.
    [122]李玉明,王海宏.基于DEA方法的企业物流系统绩效评价模型探讨[J].物流科技,2006,29(132):84-86.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700