引入参照点的旅行时间价值分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
摘要:在运输经济学中,研究旅行时间价值的重要性显而易见。早在20世纪60年代,学者们就已经对旅行时间价值进行了大量的理论与实证研究。一般研究认为,旅行时间价值是不易受到决策主体的经历、预期或禀赋影响的,其价值的节约是提高时间资源利用效率的最直接形式,同时也是促进交通运输业不断发展的基本动力。然而,由于旅行时间本身的不可逆性与不可交易性,又会使其价值评判在很大程度带有主观性,这可以体现为大多数旅行者为旅行时间损失和收益所赋予的价值是不对称的:损失的旅行时间价值要高于收益。伴随着经济的高速发展与交通运输技术的不断成熟完善,人们对旅行时间价值的评价观念已经发生了重大转向:从单纯节约的视角转变为越来越强调包括准时可靠在内的损失厌恶视角。而从这种转向来看,旅行时间价值对于人们的意义更应该在于不要让旅行时间延误造成更大的损失。同时,这种评价观念的转向也意味着交通运输业的发展面临着重要的阶段性转变。因此,从损失厌恶视角对旅行时间价值进行重新审视和计量也就具有了重要的理论与现实意义。
     在利用效用理论研究旅行时间价值的众多研究中,由于很少有学者从损失厌恶的视角来考察旅行时间价值,这就导致了传统分析方法存在一个缺陷——忽视了参照点的重要作用。因此,从这种意义上来说,传统的旅行时间价值研究应该是一种单一视角的静态分析思路和方法。基于此,作者在假设交通运输需求作为一种衍生需求的前提下,从出行选择角度出发对传统旅行时问价值研究范式进行修正,其主要工作与研究观点如下:一、从出行选择角度出发,创新性地将参照点引入旅行时间-运输费用替代关系的无差异曲线分析中,并依据参照点位置对旅行时间进行了“收益”和“损失”区分,进而建立了一个损失与节约并举的双重视角旅行时间价值分析框架,来阐释人们在评价旅行时间价值时的路径依赖现象与损失厌恶效应。而从深化研究的视角来看,该分析框架有助于进一步阐述旅行时间价值的可靠性与非匀质性,并得出相对旅行时间价值对出行选择影响更大的推论。二,利用参照点依赖分析框架改进传统的旅行时间价值研究模型,有助于验证普遍存在的旅行时间价值损失厌恶效应。同时,该模型也得出了人们对旅行时间的损失厌恶程度要高于对票价的损失厌恶程度的经验规则。三,根据参照点依赖的旅行时间价值模型推导出的运输系统或通道的旅行时间价值测算模型具有较强的操作性,这对改进单一节约视角来测算旅行时间价值模型的缺陷,重新认识运输系统评估体系以及完善交通规划模型构建等多方面具有重要的启示。
     除此之外,参照点依赖的分析思路可能应用的领域还包括旅行时间的弹性分析、“错时上下班”政策解释和旅行时间服务满意度探讨等。
ABSTRACT:In transport economics, studies on the value of travel time are obviously important. In the early1960s, scholars have been doing a number of theoretical and empirical reserach on the value of travel time. It is commonly believed that the value of travel time is less susceptible to the decision-makers'experience, expectation or endowment, saving on the value of travel time is the most direct form to improve the resource utilization efficiency, and is also the fundamental impetus to the development of transportation industry. However, travel time itself is irreversible and cannot be traded, which make its value judgment subjective to a great extent. It can be embodied in that value of travel time of the losses and gains given by most travelers is asymmetric: loss of travel time is worth more than the profit. Along with the high-speed development of economy and transportation technology, the evaluation concept of value of travel time has significantly changed. It changes from the angle of purely saving into more and more emphasis on loss aversion. And in the point of this shift, the significance of value of travel time to people lies in not making a greater loss of travel time delays. At the same time, the shift of evaluation concept also means that the development of transportation industry is facing an important periodical transformation. Therefore, the re-examination and measurement from the perspectives of loss aversion have great theoretical and practical influence on value of travel time.
     In plenty of researches on value of travel time by utility theory, because very few scholars examine value of travel time from perspective of loss aversion, which led to a defect in traditional analysis method--gnored the important role of reference point. Therefore, in this sense, traditional researches on value of travel time should be ideas and methods of static analysis from single perspective. So based on the assumption that the demand for transportation should be a derivative, the author made some modifications for researches on traditional value of travel time from the perspective of travel choice, and the main work and research ideas are as follows:1. innovatively brought the reference point into indifference curve analysis of travel time and transport cost alternative from perspective of travel choice, and distinguished "profits" and "loss" in line with the reference point position, and thus established a framework of value of travel time analysis with dual perspectives in both losses and savings in order to explain path dependence and loss aversion effect when people evaluate value of travel time. However, from perspective of deepening the researches, this analysis framework helps further explain the reliability and non-uniformity of value of travel time, in which it was conclude that relative value of travel time has more influence on travel choice.2. Utilized reference-dependence analysis framework to improve traditional researches on value of travel time, which helps to validate the effect of universal value of travel time loss aversion. In the meantime, this model concluded that the degree of travel time loss aversion by people should be greater than loss aversion for ticket prices.3. the measurement model in which value of travel time of transportation system or channel derived from reference-dependencies more operational, which helps a lot to improve the defect of value of travel time model from saving perspective to estimate model, re-recognize the evaluation system of transportation and complete the transportation planning model establishment and etc.
     Besides, the applications of reference point analysis include elastic analysis of travel time, policy of "staggered working hours", and discussion on degree of satisfaction for travel time services, and so on.
引文
① 米昂内尔.罗宾斯:《经济科学的性质和意义》,商务印书馆(2001),P17.
    ① 荣朝和教授认为一定时间期限内,利用一种或多种运输工具,实现客户所需的从起始地到最终目的地的位移服务即为运输产品。
    ① 谢旭轩等,“北京市交通拥堵的社会成本分析”,《中国人口.资源与环境》,2011年21卷1期。
    ② 王轶闻.国内外城市交通拥堵现状研究,职业,2012(32),P129-130。
    ① 加里.贝克尔:《人类行为的经济分析》,P129,格致出版社,2008。
    ① 后续研究成果具体参见Kenneth.Button. Transport Economics (3th Edition).Edward Elgar,2010, P104.
    ① Yates F J, Stone E R. The risk construct; Rjsk-taking behavior, New York Wiley,;1-25.,1992
    ① Fiegenbaum A,Hart S,Dan L. Strategic Reference Point Theory,Slrategic Management Journal,17:219-235,1996.
    ④ 将参照点认为是现状的包括Kahneman,Tversky(1979,1991,1992),Hsee &Abelson(1991)等学者;而将参
    照点认为是预期的则有Dembo(1931)和Siegel(1957)等学者.
    ① Kahneman, Tversky:Prospect theory:an analysis of decisions under risk. Econometrica,47(2):3-291.1979.
    ① Samuelson & Zeckhauser(1988)首次提出了现状偏见的概念。它是指人们对现有状况的过度偏好。
    损失厌恶的心理特征早在亚当.斯密的《道德情操论》一书中就有所提及。
    ① 事实上,在新古典经济学的解释框架内,希克斯认为人们为失去某种资源而愿意接受的价格(WTA)与为获得相同资源而愿意付出的价格(WTP)是大致相当的。
    ② 损失厌恶的心理特征早在亚当.斯密的《道德情操论》一书中就有所提及。
    ① 损失厌恶这一心理特征已经被证明对解释一些现场数据很有用处。具体案例可参见科林.凯莫勒等编,贺京同等译.《行为经济学及其新进展》一书。
    ① 而关于这两种模型的具体推导可参见关宏志编著的《非集计模型:交通行为分析的工具》一书的P10-25。
    ① 具体可参见,Samuelson & Zeckhauser(1988)在对哈佛大学增补卫生保健计划的实例研究和Johnson(1993)等人对宾西法尼亚州和新泽西州居民购买汽车保险决策的实例研究。
    ① 有关出行选择的影响因素研究具体可参见Abrantes(2004,2008),Wardman(1998,2001,2004,2011)等人的系列研究。
    ② 损失中性即默认旅行者对收益或损失赋予的权重是相等的,例如λ_(TIME)=λ_(PRICE)=1。
    ② 因为这种时间的控制可以为旅行者或运输企业带来更高的满足度和利益(Small,1982)
    ① 运用极大似然估计及牛顿-拉普松方法求解的具体过程可参见关宏志编著的《非集计模型:交通行为分析的工具》一书的P26-59。
    [1]Abrantes.P, Wardman.M. Meta-analysis of UK values of travel time:an update [J]. Transportation Research Part A 45, pp.1-17,2011.
    [2]Arrow,K. Essays in the Theory of Risk Bearing[M].Chicago:Markham Publishing Company,1971.
    [3]Arnott, R., De Palma, A., Lindsey, R.. Economics of a bottleneck. Journal of Urban Economics 27, pp.111-130,1990
    [4]Arnott, R., De Palma, A., Lindsey, R. A structural model of peak-period congestion:a traffic bottleneck with elastic demand. The American Economic Review 83, pp.161-179,1993
    [5]Arnott, R., De Palma, A., Lindsey, R. The welfare effects of congestion tolls with heterogeneous commuters. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,28, pp.139-161,1994.
    [6]Axhausen. Konig. Abay. et al. Swiss value of travel time savings[C].European Transport Conference. Strasbourg, pp.1-18,2004.
    [7]Axhausen. Hess. Konig. Abay. BateS &Bierlaire. Income and distance elasticities of values of travel time savings:New Swiss results[J].Transport Policy 15, pp.173-185,2008.
    [8]Basu.D, Maitra.B. Stated Preference Approach for valuation of travel time displayed as traffic information on a VMS board[J].Journal of Urban Planning and Development,136(3), pp.214-224,2010.
    [9]Bates J, Polak J, Jones P,Cook A. The valuation of reliability for personal travel [J]. Transportation Research E 37 (18), pp.191-229,2001.
    [10]Batley, R., Ibanez, J.N. Randomness in preferences, outcomes and tastes; an application to journey time risk. In:Proceedings of the International Choice Modelling Conference, Harrogate, UK, 2009
    [11]Becker.G. A theory of the allocation of time [J].The Economic Journal,75 (299), pp.493-517,1965.
    [12]Bhat, C.R. Accommodating variations in responsiveness to level-of-service measures in travel mode choice modeling [J].Transportation Research A 32 (7), pp.495-507,1998.
    [13]Bhat, C, Sardesai, R.,2006. The impact of stop-making and travel time reliability on commute mode choice. Transportation Research Part B:Methodological 40, pp.709-730.
    [14]Bogers, Zuylen.The importance of reliability in route choices in freight transport for various actors on various levels[C].Proceeding European Transport Conference Strasbourg:IEEE, 2004:pp.136-154,2004.
    [15]BOrjesson.M, Fosgerau.M, Algers.S.On the income elasticity of the value of travel time[J]. Transportation Research Part A,46,pp.368-377,2012.
    [16]Briesch, Krishnamurthi, Mazumdar, Raj. A comparative analysis of reference price model [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,24(9),pp.202-214,1997.
    [17]Brownstone.D, Ghosh.A, Golob.T et al. Drivers' willingness to pay to reduce travel time: evidence from the San Diegol 1-15 congestion priceing project[J].Transportation Research Part A 37,pp.373-387,2003
    [18]Brownstone.D, Small.K. Valuing time and reliability:assessing the evidence from road priceing demonstrations[J].Transportation Researeh Part A,39, pp.279-293.2005.
    [19]Button.K.Transport Economics. [M].Cheltenham,UK.Northampton,MA:Edward Elgar, pp.99-108,2010.
    [20]Calfeea.J, Winstonb.C.The value of automobile travel time:implications for congestion policy[J].Journal of Public Economics,69, pp.83-102,1998.
    [21]Carrion, C.. Value of reliability:actual commute experience revealed preference approach. Master's thesis, University of Minnesota, Twin Cities (USA),2010
    [22]Carrion, C., Levinson, D.. Value of reliability:high occupancy toll lanes, general purpose lanes, and arterials. In:Conference Proceedings of 4th International Symposium on Tranportation Network Reliability in Minneapolis, MN (USA),2010
    [23]Carrion, C., Levinson, D.. A model of bridge choice across the mississippi river in minneapolis. In:Levinson, D., Liu, H., Bell, M. (Eds.), Network Reliability in Practice:Selected Papers From the Fourth International Symposium on Transportation Network Reliability. Springer, pp.115-129, chapter8,2011
    [24]Daganzo, C The uniqueness of a time-dependent equilibrium distribution of arrivals at a single bottleneck. Transportation Science 19, pp.29-37,1985.
    [25]Daganzo, C. A pareto optimum congestion reduction scheme. Transportation Research Part B:Methodological 29B, pp.139-154,1995.
    [26]Daganzo, C.F.Fundamentals of Transportation and Traffic Operations, Emerald Group, 2007.
    [27]Daganzo.C, Garcia.R. A pareto improving strategy for the time-dependent morning commute problem. Transportation Science 34, pp.303-311,2000.
    [28]Dargay, Hanley. The demand for local bus service in England [J] Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,36 (1),pp.73-91,2002.
    [29]De Donnea, F.X. Consumer behaviour, transport mode choice and value of time:some micro-economic models[J].Regional and Urban Economics 1 (4), pp.355-382,1972.
    [30]David.Gerrne, Donald.Jones The full costs and benefits of transportation [M]. Springer, pp.215-219,1997.
    [31]De Jong, G.,Kouwenhoven, M, Kroes, E,Rietveld, P, Warffemius, P. Preliminary monetary values for the reliability of travel times in freight transport-European[J] Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research,9 (2), pp.83-99.2009
    [32]De Serpa, A.C. A theory of the economics of time[J].The Economic Journal 81 (321), pp.828-846,1971.
    [33]Dow.K, Cutter.S. Emerging hurricane evacuation issues:Hurrican Floyd and South Carolina[J]. Natural Hazardos Review,3 (1),pp.12-18,2002
    [34]Edward Morey, Kathleen Greer R. Using stated-preference quertions to investigate variation in willingness to pay for preserving marble monuments:classical heterogeneity and random parameters[J]. Journal of Cultural Economics,(27),pp.215-229,2003.
    [35]Ettema.D, Timmennans.H. Costs of travel time uncertainty and benefits of travel time information:conceptual model and numerical examples[J].Transportation Research Part C,14(5), pp.335-350,2006.
    [36]Evans, S.On the theory of the valuation and allocation of time[J].Scottish Journal of Political Economy 19, pp.1-17,1972
    [37]Evans, Morrison. Incorporating accident risk and disruption in economic models of public transport[J] Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,31,pp.117-146,1997.
    [38]Fosgerau, M., Engelson, L. The value of travel time variance. Transportation Research Part B,45,pp.1-8.,2011
    [39]Fosgerau, M.,Karlstrom, A.. The value of reliability. Transportation Research Part B, pp.44, 38-49,2010
    [40]Garcia, R..A Pareto improving strategy for the time-dependent morning commute problem. PhD thesis, University of California, Berkeley (USA),1999.
    [41]Goodwin.A review of new demand elasticities with specical reference to short and long run effects of price changes[J]. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,26 (2),pp.155-163,1992.
    [42]Guadagni, Little.A logit model of brand choice calibrated on scanner data[J].Marketing Science,2(3),PP.203-238,1983.
    [43]Gunn, H. Spatial and temporal transferability of relationships between travel demand, trip cost and travel time[J].Transportation Research E 37 (18), pp.163-189,2001.
    [44]Hal R,Arkes,Hirshleifer, Jiang, Lim.A cross-cultural study of reference point adaptation: evidence from China,Korea,and the US[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,112(2),pp.99-111,2010.
    [43]Hardie, Johnson, Fader.Modeling loss aversion and reference dependence effects on brand choice[J].Marketing Science,12(4), pp.378-394,1993
    [44]Hensher, D. A. Behavioral value of travel time savings in personal and commercial. automobile travel[M] In:David.Gerrne, Donald.Jones. The Full Costs and Benefits of Transportation:conceptual and theoretical issues. Springer, pp.215-219,1997.
    [45]Hensher, D.A Measurement of valuation of travel time savings[J]. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,35 (1), pp.71-98,2001.
    [46]Hensher, D.A. Hypothetical bias, choice experiments and willingness to pay[J]. Transportation Research Part B,44, pp.735-752,2010.
    [47]Jansson.Optimal Public Transport Price and Service Frequency[J].Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,27, pp.33-50,1993
    [48]Jansson. Optimal pricing and financing of rail passenger service [EB/OL]. http://www.thredbo-conference-series.org/downloads/thredbo8_papers/thredbo8-workshopD-Jansso n.pdf
    [49]Jara-Diaz, S. Allocation and valuation of travel-time savings[M]. Handbook of Transport Modeling. Pergamon, pp.303-319,2000.
    [50]Jara-Diaz, S. On the goods-activities technical relations in the time allocation theory[J]. Transportation,30 (3), pp.245-260,2003.
    [51]Jara-Diaz, S.. Transport Economic Theory, Emerald Group,2007.
    [52]Jara-Diaz, S, M. Munizaga, P. Greeven, R. Guerra & K. Axhausen.Estimating the value of leisure from a time allocation model[J]. Transportation Research Part B 42, pp.946-957,2008.
    [53]Johnson, M. Travel time and the price of leisure [J]. Western Economic Journal 4, pp.135-145.1966.
    [54]Kenneth Train. Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation[M]. Cambridge:Calnbridge University Press.pp.15-23,2002.
    [55]Kahneman. D, Tversky.A. Prospect theory:an analysis of decisions under risk[J]. Econometrica,47(2), pp.263-291,1979.
    [56]Katsikopoulos, Fisher, Anthony.Risk attitude reversals in driver's route choice when range of travel time is provided[J]. Human Factors,44(3),pp.466-467.2002
    [57]Klapper,Ebling,Temme.Another look at loss aversion in brand choice data:can we characterize the loss averse consumer? [J]. International Journal of Research in Marketing, 22(3),pp.239-254,2005
    [58]Knight, T.An approach to the evaluation of changes in travel unreliability:a safety margin hypothesis[J].Transportation 3(4), pp.393-408,1974.
    [59]Kraus.Discomfort externalities and marginal cost transit fares[J].Journal of Urban Economics,29,pp249-259,1991
    [60]KOsaegi.B, Rabin.M. A model of reference-dependent preferences[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics 121(4), pp.1133-1165,2006
    [61]Lam.T, Small, K. The value of time and reliability:measurement from a value pricing experiment[J].Transportation Research E 37 (2-3), pp.231-251,2001.
    [62]Laih, C. Queueing at a bottleneck with single-and multi-step tolls. Transportation Research Part A:Policy and Practice 28A, pp 197-208,1994.
    [63]Mackie.J, Jara-Diaz.S, Fowkes.S. The value of travel time savings in evaluation[J]. Transportation Research E,37 (18), pp.91-106,2001.
    [64]Manel Baucells,Martin Weber, Frank Welfens. Reference-point formation and updating[J]. Management Science,57(3),pp.506-519,2011.
    [65]McFadeen. Conditional logit analysisi of qualitative choice behavior in P.Zarembka, Frontiers in Econometrics[M].New York:Academic Press,1974.
    [66]Mcintosh, Quarmby. Generalised cost and the estimation of movement cost and benefit in transport planning[M].London:Department of Environment,1970.
    [67]Meilan Jiang, Takayuki Morikawa. Theoretical analysis on the variation of value of travel time savings[J].Transportation Research Part A, (38), pp.551-571,2004.
    [68]Metz, D. Travel time constraints in transport policy[J].Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers Transport,157(2), pp.99-105,2004
    [69]Metz, D. Time and motion:how limited travel time constrains mobility[J].Traffic Engineering and Control,47(9), pp.380-382,2006.
    [70]Metz, D. The Myth of Travel Saving.[J]. Transport Reviews,28(3), pp.321-336,2008.
    [71]Mohring.Optimization and scale economics in urban bus transportation[J].American Economic Review,62,pp.591-604,1972.
    [72]Newell, G. The morning commute for nonidentical travelers. Transportation Science 21, pp.74-88,1987
    [73]Ngostino, Uumberto, Francesca. A behavioral choice model for the evaluation of railway supply and pricing policy[J].Transportation Research A,34(85), pp.395-404,1999.
    [74]Noland.R, Small, K. Travel-time uncertainty, departure time choice, and the cost of morning commutes. Transportation Research Record 1493, pp.150-158,1995.
    [75]Noland.R, Small.K., Koskenoja, M., Chu.X. Simulating travel reliability[J].Regional Science and Urban Economics 28, pp.535-564,1998.
    [76]Noland, R., Polak, J. Travel time variability:a review of theoretical and empirical issues[J].Transport Reviews,22(1),pp.39-54,2002.
    [77]Oort, O. The evaluation of traveling time[J]. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,3, pp.219-286,1969.
    [78]Polak, J. A more general model of individual departure time choice. In:PTRC Summer Annual Meeting, Proceedings of Seminar C,1987.
    [79]Polak, J.. An overview of the recent literature on modelling the effects of travel time variability. Working Paper (London:Centre for Transport Studies,Imperial College),1996
    [80]Pratt, J. Risk Aversion in Small and in the Large.[J].Econometrica,32,pp.122-136,1964
    [81]Samuelson, Zeckhauser. Status quo bias in decision making [J].Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, l,pp.7-59,1998
    [82]Senna, L. The influence of travel time variability on the value of time. Transportation 21, pp.203-228,1994.
    [83]Shires, Jong, An international meta-analysis of values of travel time savings [J].Evaluation and Program Planning.32, pp.315-325,2009
    [84]Small, KAScheduling of consumer activities:work trips[J].American Economic Review 72, pp.467-479.1982.
    [85]Small.K., Noland.R., Koskenoja.P Socio-economic attributes and impacts of travel reliability:a stated preference approach[R]. California PATH Research Report,1995.
    [86]Small.K., Winston, C. Yan, J.Uncovering the distribution of motorists' preferences for travel time and reliability[J].Econometrica 73, pp.1367-1382,2005.
    [87]Small.K., Winston.C, Yan.J. Differentiated road pricing, express lanes, and carpools: exploiting heterogeneous preferences in policy design[R]. Brookings-Wharton Papers on Urban Affairs, vol.7, pp.53-96.2006.
    [88]MVA Consultancy.The value of travel time saving:research into the value of time[M]. In: Layard.R,Glaister.S.Cost-Benefit Analysis.London:Cambridge, pp.205-211,1994.
    [89]Tim, Dick. Coping with unreliable transportation whencollecting children:Examining parents'behavior with cumulative prospect theory[J].Transportation Research Part A,43, pp.511-525,2009.
    [90]TransFund. Project Evaluation Manual[R].TransFund New Zealand.1998
    [91]Truong T P,HensherD A.Measurement of travel time values and opportunity cost from a discrete-choice model[J].The Eeonomic Joumal,95(378), pp438-451,1985.
    [92]Turvey, Mohring. Optimal bus fares[J].Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,9(3) pp.280-286,1975.
    [93]Tversky.A, Kahneman.D. Loss aversion and riskless choice:a reference-dependent Model[J]. Quartely Journal of Economics,106(11),pp.1039-1061,1991
    [94]Varian, H.. Microeconomic Analysis, third ed. W.W. Norton and Company, New York,1978
    [95]Vaziri.M., Lam.N. Perceived factors affecting driver route decisions. Journal of Transportation Engineering 109, pp.297-311,1983.
    [96]Vickrey.W.S. Congestion theory and transport investmen[J]The American Economic Review 59 (2), pp.251-260,1969
    [97]Vickrey. Externalities in Public Facility Use:the Case of Highway [J] Accidents National Bureau of Economic Research, pp317-338.1970.
    [98]Von Neuman, J., Morgenstern, O. Theory of Games and Economic Behavior. Princeton University Press,1944.
    [99]Wardman, M. The value of travel time:a review of british evidence[J]Journal of Transport Economics and Policy 32, pp.235-316,1998
    [100]Wardman, M.A review of British evidence on time and service quality valuation[J] Transportation Research E 37(18), pp.107-128,2001
    [101]Wardman, M. Public transport values of time[J]Transport Policy 11, pp.363-377,2004
    [102]Wardman,M,Nicolas Ibanz.The congestion multiplier:Variations in motorists' valuations of travel time with traffic conditions[J]Transportation Research Part A 46, pp.216-217 2012.
    [103]Zamparini.L, Reggiani.A. Meta-analysis and the value of travel time savings:a transatlantic perspeetive in passenger transport[J]Networks and Spatial Eeonomies,7, pp.377-396, 2007
    [104]Zamparini.L,Reggiani.A. Freight transport and the value of travel time savings:a Meta-analysis of empirical studies[J].Transport Reviews,27(5), pp.621-636,2007
    [105]陈小君,林晓言.铁路旅客期望与旅客满意关系研究[J].铁道学报,32(4):23-26,2010.
    [106]陈小君,林晓言.错峰出行政策的行为经济学分析[J].综合运输,(3):27-31,2013.
    [107]陈小君,林晓言.基于运输时间价值的路径选择行为研究[J].北京交通大学学报(社会科学版),12(2):7-14,2013.
    [108]戴蒙德等著,贺京同等译.行为经济学及其应用[M].中国人民大学出社,P297-317,2011.
    [109]关宏志编著.非集计模型——交通行为分析工具[M].人民交通出版社,P1-50,117-120,160-168,2004.
    [110]凯莫勒等著,贺京同等译.行为经济学新进展[M].中国人民大学出版社,P64-190,2010.
    [111]柳茂森.论旅客运输时间价值的决定[J].公路交通科技,18(4):97-101,2001
    [112]荣朝和.交通-物流时间价值及其在经济时空分析中的作用[J].经济研究,(8):133-146.
    [113]斯梅尔瑟等著,罗教讲等译.经济社会学手册(第二版)[M].华夏出版社,P107-127,2009.
    [114]于秀林,任雪松.多元统计分析[M].中国统计出版社,P78-90,1999.
    [115]周伟.旅客时间价值[J].交通运输工程学报,3(3),110-116,2003.
    [116]宗芳,隽志才,张慧永,贾洪飞等.出行时间价值计算及应用研究[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,9(3):114-119,2009.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700