2000年以来棕地可持续再开发研究进展——基于可视化文献计量分析
|
摘要
棕地是可持续土地管理的潜在资源,棕地可持续再开发对改进城市环境和振兴经济具有积极影响。以棕地再开发的规划设计类文献为研究对象,基于WebofScience和CNKI数据库中"棕地"主题的论文统计,通过文献增长趋势对比和论文研究方向分布的分析,阐明棕地再开发在中国逐渐受到关注的现状,进一步根据"棕地再开发"的论文搜索结果进行主题、关键词和引文的共词网络分析和聚类分析,计量分析得出2个研究热点,分别是"棕地时空特点研究"和"棕地再开发分类和评价研究"。在未来相关研究中建议,利用地理信息系统收集整理棕地信息,并逐步建立数据库;加强棕地再开发效率上的研究,依据动态数据精细研究结果;完善棕地再利用评估决策体系和决策水平。
Brownfield is a potential resource for sustainable land management. The sustainable redevelopment of brownfields has positive impacts on improving urban environment and revitalizing the economy. The article reviews the planning aspects of brownfield redevelopment. Based on the growth trend of "brownfield" papers and the distribution of the research direction in Web of Science and CNKI, the article clarifies the fact that brownfield redevelopment has gradually received academic attentions. According to the search results of "brownfield development", co-word network analysis and the cluster analysis of themes, keywords and citations are made. The two research hotspots are obtained from the analysis, which are "space and time characteristics of brownfield" and "classification and evaluation in brownfield redevelopment". It is suggested that in the relevant research in future, GIS will be used to collect and sort out the information of brownfield, and gradually establish a brownfield database. In addition, more research should focus on the efficiency of brownfield redevelopment. By studying the results of dynamic data; we could improve the evaluation decision system and decision-making level in brownfield redevelopment.
Brownfield is a potential resource for sustainable land management. The sustainable redevelopment of brownfields has positive impacts on improving urban environment and revitalizing the economy. The article reviews the planning aspects of brownfield redevelopment. Based on the growth trend of "brownfield" papers and the distribution of the research direction in Web of Science and CNKI, the article clarifies the fact that brownfield redevelopment has gradually received academic attentions. According to the search results of "brownfield development", co-word network analysis and the cluster analysis of themes, keywords and citations are made. The two research hotspots are obtained from the analysis, which are "space and time characteristics of brownfield" and "classification and evaluation in brownfield redevelopment". It is suggested that in the relevant research in future, GIS will be used to collect and sort out the information of brownfield, and gradually establish a brownfield database. In addition, more research should focus on the efficiency of brownfield redevelopment. By studying the results of dynamic data; we could improve the evaluation decision system and decision-making level in brownfield redevelopment.
引文
[1]张丽芳,濮励杰,涂小松.废弃地的内涵、分类及成因探析[J].长江流域资源与环境,2010,19(2):180.
[2]Adams D,Sousa C D,Tiesdell S.Brownfield development:A comparison of north American and British approaches[J].Urban Studies,2010,47(1):75-104.
[3]Alker S,Joy V,Roberts P,et al.Brownfield definition[J].Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,2010,43:49-69.
[4]Bardos R,Jones S,Stephenson I,et al.Optimising value from the soft re-use of brownfield sites[J].Science of the Total Environment,2016,563-564:769-782.
[5]王欢欢,樊海潮.美国“棕色区域”的治理法律介评[J].环境科学与管理,2007,32(7):18-21.
[6]郑晓笛.论棕地再开发与工业建筑遗产保护的关系[J].北京规划建设,2011(1):82-85.
[7]肖龙,侯景新,刘晓霞,等.国外棕地研究进展[J].地域研究与开发,2015,34(2):142-147.
[8]National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy.Cleaning up the past,Building the future:A national brownfield redevelopment strategy for Canada[M].Ottawa:Renouf Publishing Co.Ltd,2003.
[9]沈瑾,赵铁政.棕地与绿色空间网络:唐山南湖采煤沉陷区空间再利用[J].建筑学报,2006(8):28-30.
[10]曹康,金涛.国外“棕地再开发”土地利用策略及对我国的启示[J].中国人口资源与环境,2007,17(6):124-129.
[11]郭凡.棕地治理研究文献综述[C]//中国法学会环境资源法学研究会,桂林电子科技大学.生态安全与环境风险防范法治建设:2011年全国环境资源法学研讨会(年会)论文集(第二册).2011.
[12]林慧颖,宋飏,王士君.城市棕地信息识别及数据库建设方法研究:以长春市为例[J].中国土地科学,2016,30(7):80-87.
[13]崔雷,刘伟,闫雷,等.文献数据库中书目信息共现挖掘系统的开发[J].数据分析与知识发现,2008,24(8):70-75.
[14]Chen C.CiteSpace II:Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359-377.
[15]Frantál B,Greer-Wootten B,Klusá?ek P,et al.Exploring spatial patterns of urban brownfields regeneration:The case of Brno,Czech Republic[J].Cities,2015,44:9-18.
[16]Kunc J,Martinát S,Tonev P,et al.Destiny of urban brownfields:spatial patterns and perceived consequences of post-socialistic deindustrialization[J].Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences,2014(41E):109-128.
[17]VojvodíkováB,Potu?ník M,BürgermeisterováR.The database on brownfields in ostrava(Czech Republic):Some approaches to categorization[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2011,19(4):50-60.
[18]陈亚萍.中美城市棕地生态恢复和景观重构的对比研究[D].苏州:苏州大学,2016.
[19]Page G W,Berger R S.Characteristics and land use of contaminated brownfield properties in voluntary cleanup agreement programs[J].Land Use Policy,2006,23(4):551-559.
[20]何丹,江红.欧美棕地的治理与再开发[J].城市问题,2012(8):85-90;96.
[21]Sousa C A D.Brownfield redevelopment in Toronto:an examination of past trends and future prospects[J].Land Use Policy,2002,19(4):297-309.
[22]林慧颖.基于多学科视角的城市棕地改造技术体系构建[D].吉林:吉林大学,2016.
[23]蔡希.武汉市棕地开发策略研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2008.
[24]Cheng F,Geertman S,Kuffer M,et al.An integrative methodology to improve brownfield redevelopment planning in Chinese cities:A case study of Futian,Shenzhen[J].Computers Environment&Urban Systems,2011,35(5):388-398.
[25]Ferrara V,Beriatos E,Brebbia C A.Brownfield identification:different approaches for analysing data detected by means of remote sensing[J].Wit Transactions on Ecology&the Environment,2008,107:45-54.
[26]Stuczynski T,Siebielec G,Korzeniowskapuculek R,et al.Geographical location and key sensitivity issues of post-industrial regions in Europe[J].Environmental Monitoring&Assessment,2009,151(1-4):77-91.
[27]Skála J,Vácha R,?echmánkováJ,et al.Various aspects of the genesis and perspectives on agricultural brownfields in the Czech Republic[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2013,21(2):46-55.
[28]Hayek M,Novak M,Arku G,et al.Mapping industrial legacies:building a comprehensive brownfield database in geographic information systems[J].Planning Practice&Research,2010,25(4):461-475.
[29]Chrysochoou M,Brown K,Dahal G,et al.A GISand indexing scheme to screen brownfields for area-wide redevelopment planning[J].Landscape&Urban Planning,2012,105(3):187-198.
[30]Michael R T.A GIS-based decision support system for brownfield redevelopment[J].Landscape&Urban Planning,2015,58(1):7-23.
[31]Rizzo E,Pizzol L,Zabeo A,et al.An information system for brownfield regeneration:providing customized information according to stakeholders'characteristics and needs[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2018,217:144-156.
[32]Dolezelova L,Hadlac M,Kadlecova M,et al.Redevelopment potential of brownfields:A-B-Cclassification and its practical application[J].Ekonomie A Management,2014,7(2):34-44.
[33]Dixon T.The property pevelopment industry and sustainable urban brownfield regeneration in England:An analysis of case studies in Thames Gateway and Greater Manchester[J].Urban Studies,2007,44(12):2379-2400.
[34]Logan J.Greening the Rust Belt:A green infrastructure model for right sizing America's shrinking cities[J].Journal of the American Planning Association,2008,74(4):451-466.
[35]Christopher A,Sousa D.Unearthing the benefits of brownfield to green space projects:An examination of project use and quality of life impacts[J].Local Environment,2006,11(5):577-600.
[36]Sanches P M,Pellegrino P R M.Greening potential of derelict and vacant lands in urban areas[J].Urban Forestry&Urban Greening,2016,19(9):128-139.
[37]陈寿岭,赵谷风,袁敏.可持续城市绿地在现代棕地治理再开发中的创新性应用:以AECOM伦敦奥林匹克公园项目为例[J].中国园林,2015,31(4):16-19.
[38]邓位.城市更新概念下的棕地转变为绿地[J].风景园林,2010,17(1):93-97.
[39]Mathey J,R??ler S,Banse J,et al.Brownfields as an element of green infrastructure for implementing ecosystem services into urban areas[J].Journal of Urban Planning&Development,2015,141(3):1-13.
[40]Barta G,Beluszky P,Czirfusz M,et al.Rehabilitating the brownfield zones of Budapest[J].Discussion Papers,2006(51):5-17.
[41]Wirth P,Lintz G.Rehabilitation and development of mining regions in eastern Germany-Strategies and outcomes[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2006,14(2):69-82.
[42]刘迪,孙娟,刘璟.结合棕地治理与改造的规划编制研究:以株洲清水塘老工业区控规为例[J].城市规划学刊,2014(1):99-105.
[43]Sousa C A D,Wu C,Westphal L M.Assessing the Effect of Publicly Assisted Brownfield Redevelopment on Surrounding Property Values[J].Economic Development Quarterly,2009,23(2):95-110.
[44]杨少荣,杨君,张少波,等.棕地再开发的调查与分析[J].湖南农业科学,2014(6):79-81;84.
[45]Navratil J,Krejci T,Martinat S,et al.Brownfields do not"only live twice":The possibilities for heritage preservation and the enlargement of leisure time activities in Brno,the Czech Republic[J].Cities,2017(74):52-63.
[46]Navratil J,Picha K,Martinat S,et al.Resident's preferences for urban brownfield revitalization:Insights from two Czech cities[J].Land Use Policy,2018,76:224-234.
[47]郭鹏,梁燕华,朱煜明.基于组合权法的棕地再开发多层次灰色评价[J].运筹与管理,2010,19(5):129-134.
[48]Vytautas B,Marija B,Vytautas P.Assessment of Neglected Areas in Vilnius City Using MCDM and COPRAS Methods[J].Procedia Engineering,2015,122:29-38.
[49]Morio M,Sch?dler S,Finkel M.Applying a multicriteria genetic algorithm framework for brownfield reuse optimization:improving redevelopment options based on stakeholder preferences[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2013,130:331-346.
[50]Nijkamp P,Rodenburg C A,Wagtendonk A J.Success factors for sustainable urban brownfield development:A comparative case study approach to polluted sites[J].Ecological Economics,2002,40(2):235-252.
[51]Alberini A,Longo A,Tonin S,et al.The role of liability,regulation and economic incentives in brownfield remediation and redevelopment:evidence from surveys of developers[J].Regional Science&Urban Economics,2005,35(4):327-351.
[52]Longo A,Campbell D.What are the determinants of brownfields regeneration?An analysis of brownfields in England[J].Queen's University Belfast,2007(9):24-26.
[53]Frantál B,Kunc J,NovákováE,et al.Location matters!Exploring brownfields regeneration in a spatial context(A case study of the south moravian region,Czech Republic)[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2013,21(2):5-19.
[54]Green T L.Evaluating predictors for brownfield redevelopment[J].Land Use Policy,2018,73:299-319.
[55]Beames A,Broekx S,Schneidewind U,et al.Amenity proximity analysis for sustainable brownfield redevelopment planning[J].Landscape&Urban Planning,2018,171:68-79.
[56]Koch F,Bilke L,Helbig C,et al.Compact or cool?The impact of brownfield redevelopment on innercity micro climate[J].Sustainable Cities&Society,2018,38:31-41.
[57]Chen I C,Lau C C,Yen C C,et al.A streamlined risk screening method for managing reutilization of abandoned factories in Taiwan[J].Sustainable Environment Research,2017,27(3):125-134.
[58]Xue B,Zhang L M,Geng Y,et al.Extended LandUse Coding System and Its Application in Urban Brownfield Redevelopment:Case Study of Tiexi District in Shenyang,China[J].Journal of Urban Planning and Development,2016,142(3):11-25.
[2]Adams D,Sousa C D,Tiesdell S.Brownfield development:A comparison of north American and British approaches[J].Urban Studies,2010,47(1):75-104.
[3]Alker S,Joy V,Roberts P,et al.Brownfield definition[J].Journal of Environmental Planning and Management,2010,43:49-69.
[4]Bardos R,Jones S,Stephenson I,et al.Optimising value from the soft re-use of brownfield sites[J].Science of the Total Environment,2016,563-564:769-782.
[5]王欢欢,樊海潮.美国“棕色区域”的治理法律介评[J].环境科学与管理,2007,32(7):18-21.
[6]郑晓笛.论棕地再开发与工业建筑遗产保护的关系[J].北京规划建设,2011(1):82-85.
[7]肖龙,侯景新,刘晓霞,等.国外棕地研究进展[J].地域研究与开发,2015,34(2):142-147.
[8]National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy.Cleaning up the past,Building the future:A national brownfield redevelopment strategy for Canada[M].Ottawa:Renouf Publishing Co.Ltd,2003.
[9]沈瑾,赵铁政.棕地与绿色空间网络:唐山南湖采煤沉陷区空间再利用[J].建筑学报,2006(8):28-30.
[10]曹康,金涛.国外“棕地再开发”土地利用策略及对我国的启示[J].中国人口资源与环境,2007,17(6):124-129.
[11]郭凡.棕地治理研究文献综述[C]//中国法学会环境资源法学研究会,桂林电子科技大学.生态安全与环境风险防范法治建设:2011年全国环境资源法学研讨会(年会)论文集(第二册).2011.
[12]林慧颖,宋飏,王士君.城市棕地信息识别及数据库建设方法研究:以长春市为例[J].中国土地科学,2016,30(7):80-87.
[13]崔雷,刘伟,闫雷,等.文献数据库中书目信息共现挖掘系统的开发[J].数据分析与知识发现,2008,24(8):70-75.
[14]Chen C.CiteSpace II:Detecting and visualizing emerging trends and transient patterns in scientific literature[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359-377.
[15]Frantál B,Greer-Wootten B,Klusá?ek P,et al.Exploring spatial patterns of urban brownfields regeneration:The case of Brno,Czech Republic[J].Cities,2015,44:9-18.
[16]Kunc J,Martinát S,Tonev P,et al.Destiny of urban brownfields:spatial patterns and perceived consequences of post-socialistic deindustrialization[J].Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences,2014(41E):109-128.
[17]VojvodíkováB,Potu?ník M,BürgermeisterováR.The database on brownfields in ostrava(Czech Republic):Some approaches to categorization[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2011,19(4):50-60.
[18]陈亚萍.中美城市棕地生态恢复和景观重构的对比研究[D].苏州:苏州大学,2016.
[19]Page G W,Berger R S.Characteristics and land use of contaminated brownfield properties in voluntary cleanup agreement programs[J].Land Use Policy,2006,23(4):551-559.
[20]何丹,江红.欧美棕地的治理与再开发[J].城市问题,2012(8):85-90;96.
[21]Sousa C A D.Brownfield redevelopment in Toronto:an examination of past trends and future prospects[J].Land Use Policy,2002,19(4):297-309.
[22]林慧颖.基于多学科视角的城市棕地改造技术体系构建[D].吉林:吉林大学,2016.
[23]蔡希.武汉市棕地开发策略研究[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2008.
[24]Cheng F,Geertman S,Kuffer M,et al.An integrative methodology to improve brownfield redevelopment planning in Chinese cities:A case study of Futian,Shenzhen[J].Computers Environment&Urban Systems,2011,35(5):388-398.
[25]Ferrara V,Beriatos E,Brebbia C A.Brownfield identification:different approaches for analysing data detected by means of remote sensing[J].Wit Transactions on Ecology&the Environment,2008,107:45-54.
[26]Stuczynski T,Siebielec G,Korzeniowskapuculek R,et al.Geographical location and key sensitivity issues of post-industrial regions in Europe[J].Environmental Monitoring&Assessment,2009,151(1-4):77-91.
[27]Skála J,Vácha R,?echmánkováJ,et al.Various aspects of the genesis and perspectives on agricultural brownfields in the Czech Republic[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2013,21(2):46-55.
[28]Hayek M,Novak M,Arku G,et al.Mapping industrial legacies:building a comprehensive brownfield database in geographic information systems[J].Planning Practice&Research,2010,25(4):461-475.
[29]Chrysochoou M,Brown K,Dahal G,et al.A GISand indexing scheme to screen brownfields for area-wide redevelopment planning[J].Landscape&Urban Planning,2012,105(3):187-198.
[30]Michael R T.A GIS-based decision support system for brownfield redevelopment[J].Landscape&Urban Planning,2015,58(1):7-23.
[31]Rizzo E,Pizzol L,Zabeo A,et al.An information system for brownfield regeneration:providing customized information according to stakeholders'characteristics and needs[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2018,217:144-156.
[32]Dolezelova L,Hadlac M,Kadlecova M,et al.Redevelopment potential of brownfields:A-B-Cclassification and its practical application[J].Ekonomie A Management,2014,7(2):34-44.
[33]Dixon T.The property pevelopment industry and sustainable urban brownfield regeneration in England:An analysis of case studies in Thames Gateway and Greater Manchester[J].Urban Studies,2007,44(12):2379-2400.
[34]Logan J.Greening the Rust Belt:A green infrastructure model for right sizing America's shrinking cities[J].Journal of the American Planning Association,2008,74(4):451-466.
[35]Christopher A,Sousa D.Unearthing the benefits of brownfield to green space projects:An examination of project use and quality of life impacts[J].Local Environment,2006,11(5):577-600.
[36]Sanches P M,Pellegrino P R M.Greening potential of derelict and vacant lands in urban areas[J].Urban Forestry&Urban Greening,2016,19(9):128-139.
[37]陈寿岭,赵谷风,袁敏.可持续城市绿地在现代棕地治理再开发中的创新性应用:以AECOM伦敦奥林匹克公园项目为例[J].中国园林,2015,31(4):16-19.
[38]邓位.城市更新概念下的棕地转变为绿地[J].风景园林,2010,17(1):93-97.
[39]Mathey J,R??ler S,Banse J,et al.Brownfields as an element of green infrastructure for implementing ecosystem services into urban areas[J].Journal of Urban Planning&Development,2015,141(3):1-13.
[40]Barta G,Beluszky P,Czirfusz M,et al.Rehabilitating the brownfield zones of Budapest[J].Discussion Papers,2006(51):5-17.
[41]Wirth P,Lintz G.Rehabilitation and development of mining regions in eastern Germany-Strategies and outcomes[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2006,14(2):69-82.
[42]刘迪,孙娟,刘璟.结合棕地治理与改造的规划编制研究:以株洲清水塘老工业区控规为例[J].城市规划学刊,2014(1):99-105.
[43]Sousa C A D,Wu C,Westphal L M.Assessing the Effect of Publicly Assisted Brownfield Redevelopment on Surrounding Property Values[J].Economic Development Quarterly,2009,23(2):95-110.
[44]杨少荣,杨君,张少波,等.棕地再开发的调查与分析[J].湖南农业科学,2014(6):79-81;84.
[45]Navratil J,Krejci T,Martinat S,et al.Brownfields do not"only live twice":The possibilities for heritage preservation and the enlargement of leisure time activities in Brno,the Czech Republic[J].Cities,2017(74):52-63.
[46]Navratil J,Picha K,Martinat S,et al.Resident's preferences for urban brownfield revitalization:Insights from two Czech cities[J].Land Use Policy,2018,76:224-234.
[47]郭鹏,梁燕华,朱煜明.基于组合权法的棕地再开发多层次灰色评价[J].运筹与管理,2010,19(5):129-134.
[48]Vytautas B,Marija B,Vytautas P.Assessment of Neglected Areas in Vilnius City Using MCDM and COPRAS Methods[J].Procedia Engineering,2015,122:29-38.
[49]Morio M,Sch?dler S,Finkel M.Applying a multicriteria genetic algorithm framework for brownfield reuse optimization:improving redevelopment options based on stakeholder preferences[J].Journal of Environmental Management,2013,130:331-346.
[50]Nijkamp P,Rodenburg C A,Wagtendonk A J.Success factors for sustainable urban brownfield development:A comparative case study approach to polluted sites[J].Ecological Economics,2002,40(2):235-252.
[51]Alberini A,Longo A,Tonin S,et al.The role of liability,regulation and economic incentives in brownfield remediation and redevelopment:evidence from surveys of developers[J].Regional Science&Urban Economics,2005,35(4):327-351.
[52]Longo A,Campbell D.What are the determinants of brownfields regeneration?An analysis of brownfields in England[J].Queen's University Belfast,2007(9):24-26.
[53]Frantál B,Kunc J,NovákováE,et al.Location matters!Exploring brownfields regeneration in a spatial context(A case study of the south moravian region,Czech Republic)[J].Moravian Geographical Reports,2013,21(2):5-19.
[54]Green T L.Evaluating predictors for brownfield redevelopment[J].Land Use Policy,2018,73:299-319.
[55]Beames A,Broekx S,Schneidewind U,et al.Amenity proximity analysis for sustainable brownfield redevelopment planning[J].Landscape&Urban Planning,2018,171:68-79.
[56]Koch F,Bilke L,Helbig C,et al.Compact or cool?The impact of brownfield redevelopment on innercity micro climate[J].Sustainable Cities&Society,2018,38:31-41.
[57]Chen I C,Lau C C,Yen C C,et al.A streamlined risk screening method for managing reutilization of abandoned factories in Taiwan[J].Sustainable Environment Research,2017,27(3):125-134.
[58]Xue B,Zhang L M,Geng Y,et al.Extended LandUse Coding System and Its Application in Urban Brownfield Redevelopment:Case Study of Tiexi District in Shenyang,China[J].Journal of Urban Planning and Development,2016,142(3):11-25.