刘蓉与李续宾、李续宜兄弟交谊考论
|
摘要
晚清时期,湘军集团中涌现出许多杰出人物,在当时常能左右时局,对后世亦有一定影响。刘蓉与李续宾、李续宜兄弟都堪称湘军中的元老,他们在出身、性格、经历等方面有许多相似之处,在十几年的时间里始终保持着较为密切的交往,建立了非常深厚的友谊,又都因生逢晚清乱世、具有超群才干脱颖而出,成为独当一面的要员,确乎是近世官场上的异数?。他们的成功具有历史的必然性,也反映出时代的局限性。
During the late Qing Dynasty,many outstanding figures emerged in the Xiang Army Group,and had great influence on the development of modern Chinese history. Liu Rong and Li Xubin,Li Xuyi brothers were all the elder statesmen of the Xiang Army Group,who had many similarities in family,character,experience and so on. They kept close contact and established a deep friendship for more than ten years,and they all became important people at that time because of their outstanding talents. Their life experience reflected both the inevitability of history and the limitation of the times.
During the late Qing Dynasty,many outstanding figures emerged in the Xiang Army Group,and had great influence on the development of modern Chinese history. Liu Rong and Li Xubin,Li Xuyi brothers were all the elder statesmen of the Xiang Army Group,who had many similarities in family,character,experience and so on. They kept close contact and established a deep friendship for more than ten years,and they all became important people at that time because of their outstanding talents. Their life experience reflected both the inevitability of history and the limitation of the times.
引文
[1]刘蓉.习说[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:7.
[2]刘蓉.秦鹤仙家传[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:226.
[3]刘蓉.谕培基培垕[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:226.
[4]傅耀琳.李续宾年谱[M]//梅英杰.湘军人物年谱:一.长沙:岳麓书社,1987.
[5]刘蓉.祭李忠武公文[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008.
[6]张晨怡.罗泽南友人弟子述略[J].史学月刊. 2006(3).
[7]刘蓉.书陈懿叔赠言后[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:36.
[8]罗泽南.答刘孟容书[M]//罗泽南.罗泽南集.长沙:岳麓书社,2010.
[9]刘蓉.罗忠节公《四书义》序[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:30.
[10]刘蓉.赠罗仲岳[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:280.
[11]罗泽南.春日怀刘大霞仙[M]//罗泽南.罗泽南集.长沙:岳麓书社,2010:20.
[12]梁绍辉.曾国藩评传[M].南京:南京大学出版社,2006:629.
[13]刘蓉.钟君墓表[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:221.
[14]罗正钧.王錱年谱[M]//梅英杰.湘军人物年谱:一.长沙:岳麓书社,1987:46.
[15]陆宝千.刘蓉年谱[M].台北:中央研究院近代史研究所,1979.
[16]左宗棠.与夏憩亭方伯[M]//左宗棠.左宗棠全集:书信一.长沙:岳麓书社,2009.
[17]胡林翼.致李续宜(咸丰八年四月初九日)[M]//胡林翼.胡林翼集:第二册.长沙:岳麓书社,1992:182.
[18]郭嵩焘.罗泽南年谱[M]//梅英杰.湘军人物年谱:一.长沙:岳麓书社,1987:28.
[19]曾国荃.复李续宜(咸丰九年正月十三日)[M]//曾国荃.曾国荃集.长沙:岳麓书社,2006:6.
[20]胡林翼.致刘蓉(咸丰九年三月二十七日)[M]//胡林翼.胡林翼集:第二册.长沙:岳麓书社,1992:292.
[21]刘蓉.与胡咏芝宫保书[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:120.
[22]刘蓉.与李希庵中丞书[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008.
[23]曾国藩.次韵何廉昉太守感怀述事十六首[M]//曾国藩.曾国藩全集·诗文.长沙:岳麓书社,1986:90.
[2]刘蓉.秦鹤仙家传[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:226.
[3]刘蓉.谕培基培垕[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:226.
[4]傅耀琳.李续宾年谱[M]//梅英杰.湘军人物年谱:一.长沙:岳麓书社,1987.
[5]刘蓉.祭李忠武公文[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008.
[6]张晨怡.罗泽南友人弟子述略[J].史学月刊. 2006(3).
[7]刘蓉.书陈懿叔赠言后[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:36.
[8]罗泽南.答刘孟容书[M]//罗泽南.罗泽南集.长沙:岳麓书社,2010.
[9]刘蓉.罗忠节公《四书义》序[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:30.
[10]刘蓉.赠罗仲岳[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:280.
[11]罗泽南.春日怀刘大霞仙[M]//罗泽南.罗泽南集.长沙:岳麓书社,2010:20.
[12]梁绍辉.曾国藩评传[M].南京:南京大学出版社,2006:629.
[13]刘蓉.钟君墓表[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:221.
[14]罗正钧.王錱年谱[M]//梅英杰.湘军人物年谱:一.长沙:岳麓书社,1987:46.
[15]陆宝千.刘蓉年谱[M].台北:中央研究院近代史研究所,1979.
[16]左宗棠.与夏憩亭方伯[M]//左宗棠.左宗棠全集:书信一.长沙:岳麓书社,2009.
[17]胡林翼.致李续宜(咸丰八年四月初九日)[M]//胡林翼.胡林翼集:第二册.长沙:岳麓书社,1992:182.
[18]郭嵩焘.罗泽南年谱[M]//梅英杰.湘军人物年谱:一.长沙:岳麓书社,1987:28.
[19]曾国荃.复李续宜(咸丰九年正月十三日)[M]//曾国荃.曾国荃集.长沙:岳麓书社,2006:6.
[20]胡林翼.致刘蓉(咸丰九年三月二十七日)[M]//胡林翼.胡林翼集:第二册.长沙:岳麓书社,1992:292.
[21]刘蓉.与胡咏芝宫保书[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008:120.
[22]刘蓉.与李希庵中丞书[M]//刘蓉.刘蓉集:下册.长沙:岳麓书社,2008.
[23]曾国藩.次韵何廉昉太守感怀述事十六首[M]//曾国藩.曾国藩全集·诗文.长沙:岳麓书社,1986:90.