中国邮轮游客的产品认知、情感表达与品牌形象感知——基于在线点评的内容分析
|
摘要
近年来,国际邮轮产业加快了由欧美市场向亚太地区转移的步伐。在国家"515"和"一带一路"倡议的双重推力下,中国大陆已经发展成为全球邮轮业的战略性新兴市场。目前,培育邮轮文化、做大客源市场、增强邮轮产品认知度和邮轮品牌辨识度是中国邮轮业迫切需要解决的关键问题,而深刻理解本土游客对邮轮产品的感知情况至关重要。以国内最大的中文在线旅游平台——携程旅行网(www.ctrip.com)的游客点评数据为样本,以2016年在中国投放大型(7万t级以上)豪华船舶的邮轮企业为研究对象,通过文本分析中的词频分析、语义网络分析、情感分析以及满意度分析等方法对中国游客的邮轮产品形象感知、情感表达、满意度评价以及在不同邮轮品牌上的差异性进行了系统性研究。研究发现:中国游客对邮轮产品的形象感知表现出"核心层—次核心层—过渡层—边缘层"的语义网络结构,其中核心层要素反映了与国际邮轮市场基本一致的邮轮产品形象。此外,游客对邮轮旅游总体表现出积极的情感色彩,对邮轮服务、邮轮住宿、邮轮餐饮、邮轮玩乐等属性的满意度较高,但对岸上观光表达出较多的负面情绪和较低的满意度。特别是国内游客对邮轮品牌的辨识度缺失。在核心形象方面,品牌之间并无显著性差异,品牌特色主要体现在语义网络边缘层的长尾词汇上。最后,提出了提升国内邮轮产品认知度、满意度以及品牌形象辨识度的管理建议。
There is no doubt that the cruise industry has become one of the most actively and rapidly developed segments in the entire tourism and leisure market. In recent years, the global cruise industry has accelerated the pace of transferring from the European and American markets to the Asia-Pacific region with exciting growth rates, especially to China. As the largest component of the Asian market, China is undergoing rapid development in terms of both infrastructure construction and cruise ship/passenger service. In the dual thrust of the national "515" and "The Belt and Road" initiative, China has become the strategic emerging market for international cruise lines. Since the first ocean cruise ship's arrival in 2006, there had been more than 20 homeporting ships from 4 cruise groups(Royal Caribbean, Carnival,MSC and Norwegian) sailing from more than 10 sea ports of China as of 2017. All cruise companies are trying to create competitive and distinctive cruise products and services for Chinese tourists. At present, the emerging market is facing difficulties and challenges on effectively cultivating cruise culture, enlarging the tourist market, and enhancing awareness of cruise product and cruise brand identification. The key is to better understand local tourists' perception of cruise tourism. We collected 1691 cruisers' online comments from www.ctrip.com, the largest OTA in China, on four cruise lines, including Royal Caribbean Cruises, Costa Cruises, Princess Cruises and Sky Sea Cruises. We analyzed these comments and explored Chinese cruisers' perception of image, emotion and satisfaction for cruise tourism itself and different cruise brands. The data contain both cruisers' review contents and satisfaction scores for six attributes of service: accommodation, shore excursion, dining, entertainment and guide leader. The content analysis shows that for Chinese tourists, cruise tourism is perceived as a leisure vocation with a high level of service, dining, accommodation and entertainment,offering the opportunity of shore excursions, suitable for the family, elderly and children. Highfrequency words and relevant semantic networks illustrate that there is no significant difference in perceived image between different cruise lines. The sentiment analysis shows that Chinese cruisers express overall positive and optimistic emotions toward cruise tourism. In addition,results of the satisfaction analysis show that cruisers are strongly satisfied with the cruise features of service, accommodation, dining, entertainment and sports, while weakly satisfied with shore excursion. There is significant difference in dining, accommodation, entertainment and shore activity between brands; no significant difference is found in service and guide leader. Finally, according to the results, some implications and suggestions for promoting the cruise tourism in China are proposed.
There is no doubt that the cruise industry has become one of the most actively and rapidly developed segments in the entire tourism and leisure market. In recent years, the global cruise industry has accelerated the pace of transferring from the European and American markets to the Asia-Pacific region with exciting growth rates, especially to China. As the largest component of the Asian market, China is undergoing rapid development in terms of both infrastructure construction and cruise ship/passenger service. In the dual thrust of the national "515" and "The Belt and Road" initiative, China has become the strategic emerging market for international cruise lines. Since the first ocean cruise ship's arrival in 2006, there had been more than 20 homeporting ships from 4 cruise groups(Royal Caribbean, Carnival,MSC and Norwegian) sailing from more than 10 sea ports of China as of 2017. All cruise companies are trying to create competitive and distinctive cruise products and services for Chinese tourists. At present, the emerging market is facing difficulties and challenges on effectively cultivating cruise culture, enlarging the tourist market, and enhancing awareness of cruise product and cruise brand identification. The key is to better understand local tourists' perception of cruise tourism. We collected 1691 cruisers' online comments from www.ctrip.com, the largest OTA in China, on four cruise lines, including Royal Caribbean Cruises, Costa Cruises, Princess Cruises and Sky Sea Cruises. We analyzed these comments and explored Chinese cruisers' perception of image, emotion and satisfaction for cruise tourism itself and different cruise brands. The data contain both cruisers' review contents and satisfaction scores for six attributes of service: accommodation, shore excursion, dining, entertainment and guide leader. The content analysis shows that for Chinese tourists, cruise tourism is perceived as a leisure vocation with a high level of service, dining, accommodation and entertainment,offering the opportunity of shore excursions, suitable for the family, elderly and children. Highfrequency words and relevant semantic networks illustrate that there is no significant difference in perceived image between different cruise lines. The sentiment analysis shows that Chinese cruisers express overall positive and optimistic emotions toward cruise tourism. In addition,results of the satisfaction analysis show that cruisers are strongly satisfied with the cruise features of service, accommodation, dining, entertainment and sports, while weakly satisfied with shore excursion. There is significant difference in dining, accommodation, entertainment and shore activity between brands; no significant difference is found in service and guide leader. Finally, according to the results, some implications and suggestions for promoting the cruise tourism in China are proposed.
引文
[1]孙晓东,冯学钢.中国邮轮旅游产业:研究现状与展望.旅游学刊,2012,27(2):101-112.[Sun Xiaodong,Feng Xuegang.Cruise tourism industry in China:Present situation of studies and prospect.Tourism Tribune,2012,27(2):101-112.]
[2]汪泓.中国邮轮产业发展报告.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2016.[Wang Hong.Annual Report of China's Cruise Industry.Beijing:Social Science Academic Press,2016.]
[3]孙晓东.中国邮轮旅游业:新常态与新趋势.旅游学刊,2015,30(1):10-12.[Sun Xiaodong.Cruise tourism industry in China:New state and new trend.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(1):10-12.]
[4]Sun X,Feng X,Gauri D K.The cruise industry in China:Efforts,progress and challenges.International Journal of Hospitality Management,2014,42:71-84.
[5]孙瑞红,叶欣梁.我国游客对邮轮公司的品牌感知.水运管理,2014,36(3):34-38.[Sun Ruihong,Ye Xinliang.The brand perception of Chinese tourists to cruise company.Shipping Management,2014,36(3):34-38.]
[6]徐小波,赵磊,刘滨谊,等.中国旅游城市形象感知特征与分异.地理研究,2015,34(7):1367-1379.[Xu Xiaobo,Zhao Lei,Liu Binyi,et al.Study on perceived image of Chinese tourist cities.Geographical Research,2015,34(7):1367-1379.]
[7]Baloglu S,Mc Cleary K W.A model of destination image formation.Annals of Tourism Research,1999,26(1):868-897.
[8]皮瑞,郑鹏."网评少林":少林寺旅游认知、情感、整体形象研究.干旱区资源与环境,2017,31(4):201-207.[Pi Rui,Zheng Peng.A research on Shaolin Temple's tourism cognitive image,affective image and overall image:Based on web text.Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2017,31(4):201-207.]
[9]刘力.旅游目的地形象感知与游客旅游意向:基于影视旅游视角的综合研究.旅游学刊,2013,28(9):61-72.[Liu Li.Screen-induced tourism:Perceived destination image and intention to visit.Tourism Tribune,2013,28(9):61-72.]
[10]匡红云,徐继红,王莹.基于经济及情感视角的欠发达红色省域游客满意度影响因素.上海第二工业大学学报,2016,33(3):236-242.[Kuang Hongyun,Xu Jihong,Wang Ying.Factors influencing tourist satisfaction for under-developed red-tourism province from perspective of economy and emotion.Journal of Shanghai Polytechnic University,2016,33(3):236-242.]
[11]粟路军,黄福才.服务公平性、消费情感与旅游者忠诚关系:以乡村旅游者为例.地理研究,2011,30(3):463-476.[Su Lujun,Huang Fucai.A study on the relationships of service fairness,consumption emotions and tourist loyalty:A case study of rural tourists.Geographical Research,2011,30(3):463-476.]
[12]贾衍菊,林德荣.旅游者服务感知、地方依恋与忠诚度:以厦门为例.地理研究,2016,35(2):390-400.[Jia Yanju,Lin Derong.Tourists'perception of urban service,place attachment and loyal behaviors:A case study of Xiamen.Geographical Research,2016,35(2):390-400.]
[13]于鹏,张宏梅.韩国国家形象感知与旅游意向研究:以中国潜在旅游者为例.旅游学刊,2016,31(12):62-75.[Yu Peng,Zhang Hongmei.An empirical study on South Korea country image perceptions and tourists'travel intentions:A case study of potential chinese tourists.Tourism Tribune,2016,31(12):62-75.]
[14]郑慧.基于中国旅游者需求的邮轮旅游产品开发对策研究.青岛:中国海洋大学博士学位论文,2009.[Zheng Hui.Research on the development strategy of cruise tourism products based on the demand of domestic tourist.Qingdao:Doctoral Dissertation of Ocean University of China,2009.]
[15]张璟,曹睿,杨媛媛,等.青岛国内邮轮旅游市场现状与潜力调查分析.消费导刊,2010,(4):1-4.[Zhang Jing,Cao Rui,Yang Yuanyuan,et al.Investigation and analysis on current situation and potential of domestic cruise tourism market in Qingdao.Consume Guide,2010,(4):1-4.]
[16]高洪云,张言庆,谭晓楠.青岛市居民邮轮旅游认知及消费意愿研究.青岛职业技术学院学报,2016,29(1):13-16.Gao Hongyun,Zhang Yanqing,Tan Xiaonan.A study on residents'cognition and consuming intention about cruise tourism in Qingdao.Journal of Qingdao Technical College,2016,29(1):13-16.]
[17]黄嘉瑞,叶欣梁,金佳雯.上海游客对邮轮旅游的整体感知度研究.经营管理者,2014,(20):96-97.[Huang Jiarui,Ye Xinliang,Jin Jiawen.A study on the overall perception of cruise tourism in Shanghai.Manager'Journal,2014,(20):96-97.]
[18]Ahmed Z U,Johnson J P,Ling C P,et al.Country-of-origin and brand effects on consumers'evaluations of cruise lines.International Marketing Review,2002,19(3):279-302.
[19]Hyun S S,Kim M G.Negative effects of perceived crowding on travelers'identification with cruise brand.Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2015,32(3):241-259.
[20]王媛,许鑫,冯学钢,等.基于文本挖掘的古镇旅游形象感知研究:以朱家角为例.旅游科学,2013,27(5):86-95.[Wang Yuan,Xu Xin,Feng Xuegang,et al.Research on tourists'percieved image of ancient town using web text mining methods:A case study of Zhujiajiao.Tourism Science,2013,27(5):86-95.]
[21]Leung D,Law R,Hoof H V,et al.Social media in tourism and hospitality:A literature review.Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2013,30(1-2):3-22.
[22]Litvin S W,Goldsmith R E,Pan B.Electronic word-of-mouth in hospitality and tourism management.Tourism Management,2008,29(3):458-468.
[23]Dellarocas C.The digitization of word of mouth:Promise and challenges of online feedback mechanisms.Management Science,2004,49(10):1407-1424.
[24]Clemons E K,Gao G.Consumer informedness and diverse consumer purchasing behaviors:Traditional mass-market,trading down,and trading out into the long tail.Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2008,7(1):3-17.
[25]Klein L R.Evaluating the potential of interactive media through a new lens:Search versus experience goods.Journal of Business Research,1998,41(3):195-203.
[26]Luo Q J,Zhong D.Using social network analysis to explain communication characteristics of travel-related electronic word-of-mouth on social networking sites.Tourism Management,2015,46(46):274-282.
[27]廉同辉,余菜花,宗乾进.我国旅游网站的网络结构研究:基于社会网络分析法.旅游科学,2012,26(6):80-88.[Lian Tonghui,Yu Caihua,Zong Qianjin.A study on net-work structure of China's tourism website:Based on a social network analysis.Tourism Science,2012,26(6):80-88.]
[28]Papathanassis A,Knolle F.Exploring the adoption and processing of online holiday reviews:A grounded theory approach.Tourism Management,2011,32(2):215-224.
[29]Ren L P,Zhang H Q,Haobin Y Y.Understanding customer satisfaction with budget hotels through online comments:Evidence from home inns in China.Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality&Tourism,2015,16(1):45-62.
[30]丛丽,吴必虎.基于网络文本分析的野生动物旅游体验研究:以成都大熊猫繁育研究基地为例.北京大学学报:自然科学版,2014,50(6):1087-1094.[Cong Li,Wu Bihu.Wildlife tourism experience based on Internet text content analysis:A case study of Chengdu research base for giant panda breeding.Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis,2014,50(6):1087-1094.]
[31]冯捷蕴.北京旅游目的地形象的感知:中西方旅游者博客的多维话语分析.旅游学刊,2011,26(9):19-28.[Feng Jieyun.Perceptions of the image of Beijing's tourist destinations:An analysis of the multi-dimensional discourses on the blogs from Chinese and western tourists.Tourism Tribune,2011,26(9):19-28.]
[32]张天问,吴明远.基于扎根理论的旅游幸福感构成:以互联网旅游博客文本为例.旅游学刊,2014,29(10):51-60.[Zhang Tianwen,Wu Mingyuan.The constitution of tourism well-being based on a grounded theory analysis of Internet travel blogs.Tourism Tribune,2014,29(10):51-60.]
[33]许亚元,姚国荣.基于在线点评的黄山风景区旅游形象感知研究.世界地理研究,2016,25(2):158-168.[Xu Yayuan,Yao Guorong.Study on image perception of Huangshan Mountain based on online reviews.World Regional Studies,2016,25(2):158-168.]
[34]郭风华,王琨,张建立,等.成都“五朵金花”乡村旅游地形象认知:基于博客游记文本的分析.旅游学刊,2015,30(4):84-94.[Guo Fenghua,Wang Kun,Zhang Jianli,et al.Rural tourism destination image of the case in"Five Golden Flowers",Chengdu:Based on the text mining of blogs.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(4):84-94.]
[35]刘雯,高峰,洪凌子.基于情感分析的灾害网络舆情研究:以雅安地震为例.图书情报工作,2013,57(20):104-110.[Liu Wen,Gao Feng,Hong Lingzi.Research on Internet public opinions of disaster based on sentiment analysis:Taking Ya'an earthquake as an example.Library and Information Service,2013,57(20):104-110.]
[36]李艳红,梁毓琪,郝晓玲.上海自贸区国内外关注力分布研究:基于新闻报道和期刊文献的视角.中国管理科学,2014,22(s1):544-551.[Li Yanhong,Liang Yuqi,Hao Xiaoling.Study on the domestic and International attention distribution of Shanghai free trade zone:News reports and journal literature perspective.Chinese Journal of Management Science,2014,22(s1):544-551.]
[37]傅慧芬,赖元薇.消费电子品品牌社交媒体内容营销策略研究:基于联想、华为、HTC和三星微信公众号的内容分析.管理评论,2016,28(10):259-272.[Fu Huifen,Lai Yuanwei.Social media content marketing strategy of consumer electronics brands:Content analysis of Lenovo,Huawei,HTC and Samsung's brand sites on We Chat.Management Review,2016,28(10):259-272.]
[38]Zhang Z Q,Ye Q,Song H Y,et al.The structure of customer satisfaction with cruise-line services:An empirical investigation based on online word of mouth.Current Issues in Tourism,2015,18(5):450-464.
[39]Sohns K,Michael B.Online content mining&its potential for cruise management.In:Alexis Papathanassis.Cruise Sector Growth.Wiesbaden:Gabler,2009:171-185.
[40]Brejla P,Gilbert D.An exploratory use of web content analysis to understand cruise tourism services.International Journal of Tourism Research,2014,16(2):157-168.
[41]Park S,Ok C,Chae B,et al.Using twitter data for cruise tourism marketing and research.Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2015,33(6):885-898.
[42]陈培,张红,杜雪楠.基于网络游记的城市旅游目的地形象探究:以西安市为例.资源开发与市场,2014,30(11):1401-1404.[Chen Pei,Zhang Hont,Du Xuenan.Travel destination image exploration based on the network:Taking Xi'an city as an example.Resource Development&Market,2014,30(11):1401-1404.]
[43]汪泓.中国邮轮产业发展报告.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2015.[Wang Hong.Annual Report of China's Cruise Industry.Beijing:Social Science Academic Press,2015.]
[44]王永明,王美霞,李瑞,等.基于网络文本内容分析的凤凰古城旅游地意象感知研究.地理与地理信息科学,2015,31(1):64-67,79.[Wang Yongming,Wang Meixia,Li Rui,et al.Destination image perception of Fenghuang ancient town based on content analysis of travelers'web text.Geography and Geo-Information Science,2015,31(1):64-67,79.]
[45]杨昆,姬梅,陈娅玲.基于网络游记的西藏旅游目的地形象探析.旅游论坛,2013,6(3):60-65.[Yang Kun,Ji Mei,Chen Yaling.Study on tourist destination image of Tibet based on online travel notes.Tourism Forum,2013,6(3):60-65.]
[46]邹勇文,田逢军.网络虚拟社区中的南昌市旅游空间意象图景.资源科学,2017,39(2):314-324.[Zou Yongwen,Tian Fengjun.View of tourism space image of nanchang city on network virtual community.Resources Science,2017,39(2):314-324.]
[47]Rambocas M.Marketing research:The role of sentiment analysis.Fep Working Papers,2013.http://wps.fep.up.pt/wps/wp489.pdf,2017-11-12.
[48]Sanz-Blas S,Buzova D.Guided tour influence on cruise tourist experience in a port of call:An e WOM and questionnaire-based approach.International Journal of Tourism Research,2016,18(6):558-566.
[49]Lai K,Li Y.Core-periphery structure of destination image:Concept,evidence and implication.Annals of Tourism Research,2012,39(3):1359-1379.
[50]吕兴洋,沈雪瑞,梁佳.在线信息搜索对目的地感知形象演化影响研究.旅游学刊,2015,30(10):70-79.[Lv Xingyang,Shen Xuerui,Liang Jia.The effect of online information search on destination perceived image development.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(10):70-79.]
[51]王超,骆克任.基于网络舆情的旅游包容性发展研究:以湖南凤凰古城门票事件为例.经济地理,2014,34(1):161-167.[Wang Chao,Luo Keren.Research on the inclusive development of tourism in the perspective of internet public opinion:Case study on tickets policy of phoenix ancient city in hunan.Economic Geography,2014,34(1):161-167.]
[52]汪芳,孙瑞敏.传统村落的集体记忆研究:对纪录片《记住乡愁》进行内容分析为例.地理研究,2015,34(12):2368-2380.[Wang Fang,Sun Ruimin.Collective memory of chinese traditional villages:A case study of content analysis on the documentary homesickness in mind.Geographical Research,2015,34(12):2368-2380.]
[53]刘萌玥,陈效萱,吴建伟,等.旅游景区网络舆情指标体系构建:基于蚂蜂窝网全国百家5A级景区的游客评论.资源开发与市场,2017,33(1):80-84.[Liu Mengyue,Chen Xiaoxuan,Wu Jianwei,et al.Research on construction of index system of tourist attraction network public opinion:Based on tourists'reviews over 100 5A scenic spots on Mafengwo.Resource Development&Market,2017,33(1):80-84.]
[54]郑华伟.红色旅游价值观内化的网络文本研究:兼论国民幸福感的生成机制.旅游学刊,2016,31(5):111-118.[Zheng Huawei.Web-based text analysis of value internalization of red tourism:The generative mechanism of national happiness.Tourism Tribune,2016,31(5):111-118.]
[55]Chiappa G D,Andreu L,Gallarza M G,et al.Emotions and visitors'satisfaction at a museum.International Journal of Culture,Tourism and Hospitality Research,2014,8(4):420-431.
[56]Karamibekr M,Ghorbani A A.Sentiment Analysis of Social Issues.2012 International Conference on Social Informatics,Lausanne(Switzerland),2012,215-221.doi:10.1109/Social Informatics.
[57]Cruise Lines International Association(CLIA).2014 North American Cruise Market Profile.http://www.cruising.org/docs/default-source/research/clia_naconsumerprofile_2014.pdf,2016-01-15.
[58]Cruise Lines International Association(CLIA).Cruise Market Profile Study.http://www.cruising.org/docs/defaultsource/market-research/2011-market-profile-study.pdf?sfvrsn=0,2016-01-15.
[59]孙晓东.邮轮产业与邮轮经济.上海:上海交通大学出版社,2014.[Sun Xiaodong.Cruise Industry and Cruise Economy.Shanghai:Shanghai Jiaotong University Press,2014.]
[60]孙瑞红,叶欣梁.上海邮轮旅游市场开发的对策研究.经济问题探索,2007,(3):165-169.[Sun Ruihong,Ye Xinliang.Research on the development of Shanghai cruise tourism market.Inquiry into Economic Issues,2007,(3):165-169.]
[61]陈轩,耿红,翁大涛,等.上海邮轮通航影响与保障措施研究.交通标准化,2015,(3):37-41.[Chen Xuan,Geng Hong,Weng Datao,et al.Guarantee measures and influence of cruise navigation in Shanghai.Transport Research,2015,(3):37-41.]
[2]汪泓.中国邮轮产业发展报告.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2016.[Wang Hong.Annual Report of China's Cruise Industry.Beijing:Social Science Academic Press,2016.]
[3]孙晓东.中国邮轮旅游业:新常态与新趋势.旅游学刊,2015,30(1):10-12.[Sun Xiaodong.Cruise tourism industry in China:New state and new trend.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(1):10-12.]
[4]Sun X,Feng X,Gauri D K.The cruise industry in China:Efforts,progress and challenges.International Journal of Hospitality Management,2014,42:71-84.
[5]孙瑞红,叶欣梁.我国游客对邮轮公司的品牌感知.水运管理,2014,36(3):34-38.[Sun Ruihong,Ye Xinliang.The brand perception of Chinese tourists to cruise company.Shipping Management,2014,36(3):34-38.]
[6]徐小波,赵磊,刘滨谊,等.中国旅游城市形象感知特征与分异.地理研究,2015,34(7):1367-1379.[Xu Xiaobo,Zhao Lei,Liu Binyi,et al.Study on perceived image of Chinese tourist cities.Geographical Research,2015,34(7):1367-1379.]
[7]Baloglu S,Mc Cleary K W.A model of destination image formation.Annals of Tourism Research,1999,26(1):868-897.
[8]皮瑞,郑鹏."网评少林":少林寺旅游认知、情感、整体形象研究.干旱区资源与环境,2017,31(4):201-207.[Pi Rui,Zheng Peng.A research on Shaolin Temple's tourism cognitive image,affective image and overall image:Based on web text.Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2017,31(4):201-207.]
[9]刘力.旅游目的地形象感知与游客旅游意向:基于影视旅游视角的综合研究.旅游学刊,2013,28(9):61-72.[Liu Li.Screen-induced tourism:Perceived destination image and intention to visit.Tourism Tribune,2013,28(9):61-72.]
[10]匡红云,徐继红,王莹.基于经济及情感视角的欠发达红色省域游客满意度影响因素.上海第二工业大学学报,2016,33(3):236-242.[Kuang Hongyun,Xu Jihong,Wang Ying.Factors influencing tourist satisfaction for under-developed red-tourism province from perspective of economy and emotion.Journal of Shanghai Polytechnic University,2016,33(3):236-242.]
[11]粟路军,黄福才.服务公平性、消费情感与旅游者忠诚关系:以乡村旅游者为例.地理研究,2011,30(3):463-476.[Su Lujun,Huang Fucai.A study on the relationships of service fairness,consumption emotions and tourist loyalty:A case study of rural tourists.Geographical Research,2011,30(3):463-476.]
[12]贾衍菊,林德荣.旅游者服务感知、地方依恋与忠诚度:以厦门为例.地理研究,2016,35(2):390-400.[Jia Yanju,Lin Derong.Tourists'perception of urban service,place attachment and loyal behaviors:A case study of Xiamen.Geographical Research,2016,35(2):390-400.]
[13]于鹏,张宏梅.韩国国家形象感知与旅游意向研究:以中国潜在旅游者为例.旅游学刊,2016,31(12):62-75.[Yu Peng,Zhang Hongmei.An empirical study on South Korea country image perceptions and tourists'travel intentions:A case study of potential chinese tourists.Tourism Tribune,2016,31(12):62-75.]
[14]郑慧.基于中国旅游者需求的邮轮旅游产品开发对策研究.青岛:中国海洋大学博士学位论文,2009.[Zheng Hui.Research on the development strategy of cruise tourism products based on the demand of domestic tourist.Qingdao:Doctoral Dissertation of Ocean University of China,2009.]
[15]张璟,曹睿,杨媛媛,等.青岛国内邮轮旅游市场现状与潜力调查分析.消费导刊,2010,(4):1-4.[Zhang Jing,Cao Rui,Yang Yuanyuan,et al.Investigation and analysis on current situation and potential of domestic cruise tourism market in Qingdao.Consume Guide,2010,(4):1-4.]
[16]高洪云,张言庆,谭晓楠.青岛市居民邮轮旅游认知及消费意愿研究.青岛职业技术学院学报,2016,29(1):13-16.Gao Hongyun,Zhang Yanqing,Tan Xiaonan.A study on residents'cognition and consuming intention about cruise tourism in Qingdao.Journal of Qingdao Technical College,2016,29(1):13-16.]
[17]黄嘉瑞,叶欣梁,金佳雯.上海游客对邮轮旅游的整体感知度研究.经营管理者,2014,(20):96-97.[Huang Jiarui,Ye Xinliang,Jin Jiawen.A study on the overall perception of cruise tourism in Shanghai.Manager'Journal,2014,(20):96-97.]
[18]Ahmed Z U,Johnson J P,Ling C P,et al.Country-of-origin and brand effects on consumers'evaluations of cruise lines.International Marketing Review,2002,19(3):279-302.
[19]Hyun S S,Kim M G.Negative effects of perceived crowding on travelers'identification with cruise brand.Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2015,32(3):241-259.
[20]王媛,许鑫,冯学钢,等.基于文本挖掘的古镇旅游形象感知研究:以朱家角为例.旅游科学,2013,27(5):86-95.[Wang Yuan,Xu Xin,Feng Xuegang,et al.Research on tourists'percieved image of ancient town using web text mining methods:A case study of Zhujiajiao.Tourism Science,2013,27(5):86-95.]
[21]Leung D,Law R,Hoof H V,et al.Social media in tourism and hospitality:A literature review.Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2013,30(1-2):3-22.
[22]Litvin S W,Goldsmith R E,Pan B.Electronic word-of-mouth in hospitality and tourism management.Tourism Management,2008,29(3):458-468.
[23]Dellarocas C.The digitization of word of mouth:Promise and challenges of online feedback mechanisms.Management Science,2004,49(10):1407-1424.
[24]Clemons E K,Gao G.Consumer informedness and diverse consumer purchasing behaviors:Traditional mass-market,trading down,and trading out into the long tail.Electronic Commerce Research and Applications,2008,7(1):3-17.
[25]Klein L R.Evaluating the potential of interactive media through a new lens:Search versus experience goods.Journal of Business Research,1998,41(3):195-203.
[26]Luo Q J,Zhong D.Using social network analysis to explain communication characteristics of travel-related electronic word-of-mouth on social networking sites.Tourism Management,2015,46(46):274-282.
[27]廉同辉,余菜花,宗乾进.我国旅游网站的网络结构研究:基于社会网络分析法.旅游科学,2012,26(6):80-88.[Lian Tonghui,Yu Caihua,Zong Qianjin.A study on net-work structure of China's tourism website:Based on a social network analysis.Tourism Science,2012,26(6):80-88.]
[28]Papathanassis A,Knolle F.Exploring the adoption and processing of online holiday reviews:A grounded theory approach.Tourism Management,2011,32(2):215-224.
[29]Ren L P,Zhang H Q,Haobin Y Y.Understanding customer satisfaction with budget hotels through online comments:Evidence from home inns in China.Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality&Tourism,2015,16(1):45-62.
[30]丛丽,吴必虎.基于网络文本分析的野生动物旅游体验研究:以成都大熊猫繁育研究基地为例.北京大学学报:自然科学版,2014,50(6):1087-1094.[Cong Li,Wu Bihu.Wildlife tourism experience based on Internet text content analysis:A case study of Chengdu research base for giant panda breeding.Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis,2014,50(6):1087-1094.]
[31]冯捷蕴.北京旅游目的地形象的感知:中西方旅游者博客的多维话语分析.旅游学刊,2011,26(9):19-28.[Feng Jieyun.Perceptions of the image of Beijing's tourist destinations:An analysis of the multi-dimensional discourses on the blogs from Chinese and western tourists.Tourism Tribune,2011,26(9):19-28.]
[32]张天问,吴明远.基于扎根理论的旅游幸福感构成:以互联网旅游博客文本为例.旅游学刊,2014,29(10):51-60.[Zhang Tianwen,Wu Mingyuan.The constitution of tourism well-being based on a grounded theory analysis of Internet travel blogs.Tourism Tribune,2014,29(10):51-60.]
[33]许亚元,姚国荣.基于在线点评的黄山风景区旅游形象感知研究.世界地理研究,2016,25(2):158-168.[Xu Yayuan,Yao Guorong.Study on image perception of Huangshan Mountain based on online reviews.World Regional Studies,2016,25(2):158-168.]
[34]郭风华,王琨,张建立,等.成都“五朵金花”乡村旅游地形象认知:基于博客游记文本的分析.旅游学刊,2015,30(4):84-94.[Guo Fenghua,Wang Kun,Zhang Jianli,et al.Rural tourism destination image of the case in"Five Golden Flowers",Chengdu:Based on the text mining of blogs.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(4):84-94.]
[35]刘雯,高峰,洪凌子.基于情感分析的灾害网络舆情研究:以雅安地震为例.图书情报工作,2013,57(20):104-110.[Liu Wen,Gao Feng,Hong Lingzi.Research on Internet public opinions of disaster based on sentiment analysis:Taking Ya'an earthquake as an example.Library and Information Service,2013,57(20):104-110.]
[36]李艳红,梁毓琪,郝晓玲.上海自贸区国内外关注力分布研究:基于新闻报道和期刊文献的视角.中国管理科学,2014,22(s1):544-551.[Li Yanhong,Liang Yuqi,Hao Xiaoling.Study on the domestic and International attention distribution of Shanghai free trade zone:News reports and journal literature perspective.Chinese Journal of Management Science,2014,22(s1):544-551.]
[37]傅慧芬,赖元薇.消费电子品品牌社交媒体内容营销策略研究:基于联想、华为、HTC和三星微信公众号的内容分析.管理评论,2016,28(10):259-272.[Fu Huifen,Lai Yuanwei.Social media content marketing strategy of consumer electronics brands:Content analysis of Lenovo,Huawei,HTC and Samsung's brand sites on We Chat.Management Review,2016,28(10):259-272.]
[38]Zhang Z Q,Ye Q,Song H Y,et al.The structure of customer satisfaction with cruise-line services:An empirical investigation based on online word of mouth.Current Issues in Tourism,2015,18(5):450-464.
[39]Sohns K,Michael B.Online content mining&its potential for cruise management.In:Alexis Papathanassis.Cruise Sector Growth.Wiesbaden:Gabler,2009:171-185.
[40]Brejla P,Gilbert D.An exploratory use of web content analysis to understand cruise tourism services.International Journal of Tourism Research,2014,16(2):157-168.
[41]Park S,Ok C,Chae B,et al.Using twitter data for cruise tourism marketing and research.Journal of Travel&Tourism Marketing,2015,33(6):885-898.
[42]陈培,张红,杜雪楠.基于网络游记的城市旅游目的地形象探究:以西安市为例.资源开发与市场,2014,30(11):1401-1404.[Chen Pei,Zhang Hont,Du Xuenan.Travel destination image exploration based on the network:Taking Xi'an city as an example.Resource Development&Market,2014,30(11):1401-1404.]
[43]汪泓.中国邮轮产业发展报告.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2015.[Wang Hong.Annual Report of China's Cruise Industry.Beijing:Social Science Academic Press,2015.]
[44]王永明,王美霞,李瑞,等.基于网络文本内容分析的凤凰古城旅游地意象感知研究.地理与地理信息科学,2015,31(1):64-67,79.[Wang Yongming,Wang Meixia,Li Rui,et al.Destination image perception of Fenghuang ancient town based on content analysis of travelers'web text.Geography and Geo-Information Science,2015,31(1):64-67,79.]
[45]杨昆,姬梅,陈娅玲.基于网络游记的西藏旅游目的地形象探析.旅游论坛,2013,6(3):60-65.[Yang Kun,Ji Mei,Chen Yaling.Study on tourist destination image of Tibet based on online travel notes.Tourism Forum,2013,6(3):60-65.]
[46]邹勇文,田逢军.网络虚拟社区中的南昌市旅游空间意象图景.资源科学,2017,39(2):314-324.[Zou Yongwen,Tian Fengjun.View of tourism space image of nanchang city on network virtual community.Resources Science,2017,39(2):314-324.]
[47]Rambocas M.Marketing research:The role of sentiment analysis.Fep Working Papers,2013.http://wps.fep.up.pt/wps/wp489.pdf,2017-11-12.
[48]Sanz-Blas S,Buzova D.Guided tour influence on cruise tourist experience in a port of call:An e WOM and questionnaire-based approach.International Journal of Tourism Research,2016,18(6):558-566.
[49]Lai K,Li Y.Core-periphery structure of destination image:Concept,evidence and implication.Annals of Tourism Research,2012,39(3):1359-1379.
[50]吕兴洋,沈雪瑞,梁佳.在线信息搜索对目的地感知形象演化影响研究.旅游学刊,2015,30(10):70-79.[Lv Xingyang,Shen Xuerui,Liang Jia.The effect of online information search on destination perceived image development.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(10):70-79.]
[51]王超,骆克任.基于网络舆情的旅游包容性发展研究:以湖南凤凰古城门票事件为例.经济地理,2014,34(1):161-167.[Wang Chao,Luo Keren.Research on the inclusive development of tourism in the perspective of internet public opinion:Case study on tickets policy of phoenix ancient city in hunan.Economic Geography,2014,34(1):161-167.]
[52]汪芳,孙瑞敏.传统村落的集体记忆研究:对纪录片《记住乡愁》进行内容分析为例.地理研究,2015,34(12):2368-2380.[Wang Fang,Sun Ruimin.Collective memory of chinese traditional villages:A case study of content analysis on the documentary homesickness in mind.Geographical Research,2015,34(12):2368-2380.]
[53]刘萌玥,陈效萱,吴建伟,等.旅游景区网络舆情指标体系构建:基于蚂蜂窝网全国百家5A级景区的游客评论.资源开发与市场,2017,33(1):80-84.[Liu Mengyue,Chen Xiaoxuan,Wu Jianwei,et al.Research on construction of index system of tourist attraction network public opinion:Based on tourists'reviews over 100 5A scenic spots on Mafengwo.Resource Development&Market,2017,33(1):80-84.]
[54]郑华伟.红色旅游价值观内化的网络文本研究:兼论国民幸福感的生成机制.旅游学刊,2016,31(5):111-118.[Zheng Huawei.Web-based text analysis of value internalization of red tourism:The generative mechanism of national happiness.Tourism Tribune,2016,31(5):111-118.]
[55]Chiappa G D,Andreu L,Gallarza M G,et al.Emotions and visitors'satisfaction at a museum.International Journal of Culture,Tourism and Hospitality Research,2014,8(4):420-431.
[56]Karamibekr M,Ghorbani A A.Sentiment Analysis of Social Issues.2012 International Conference on Social Informatics,Lausanne(Switzerland),2012,215-221.doi:10.1109/Social Informatics.
[57]Cruise Lines International Association(CLIA).2014 North American Cruise Market Profile.http://www.cruising.org/docs/default-source/research/clia_naconsumerprofile_2014.pdf,2016-01-15.
[58]Cruise Lines International Association(CLIA).Cruise Market Profile Study.http://www.cruising.org/docs/defaultsource/market-research/2011-market-profile-study.pdf?sfvrsn=0,2016-01-15.
[59]孙晓东.邮轮产业与邮轮经济.上海:上海交通大学出版社,2014.[Sun Xiaodong.Cruise Industry and Cruise Economy.Shanghai:Shanghai Jiaotong University Press,2014.]
[60]孙瑞红,叶欣梁.上海邮轮旅游市场开发的对策研究.经济问题探索,2007,(3):165-169.[Sun Ruihong,Ye Xinliang.Research on the development of Shanghai cruise tourism market.Inquiry into Economic Issues,2007,(3):165-169.]
[61]陈轩,耿红,翁大涛,等.上海邮轮通航影响与保障措施研究.交通标准化,2015,(3):37-41.[Chen Xuan,Geng Hong,Weng Datao,et al.Guarantee measures and influence of cruise navigation in Shanghai.Transport Research,2015,(3):37-41.]