健康影响评估研究进展
|
摘要
健康影响评估基于循证的方法,评估政策、规划和工程项目潜在的健康影响,并提出改善健康的建议。通过健康影响评估可促进卫生部门与其他部门的合作,提高决策者的健康意识,增加利益相关者的参与程度,改善健康不平等。本文对2000—2018年美国、英国、澳大利亚和加拿大等国家健康影响评估的研究成果进行综述,提出我国开展健康影响评估建议,旨在为我国开展健康影响评估提供参考。
Health impact assessment(HIA) is an evidence-based methodology to assess the potential impacts of a policy,program or project and to make recommendations for health improvement. HIA can promote the cooperation between health and non-health sectors,raise the awareness about health in decision-makers,increase the participation of stakeholders and change health inequality. This paper reviews the international studies into HIA from 2000 to 2018, providing reference for HIA development in China.
Health impact assessment(HIA) is an evidence-based methodology to assess the potential impacts of a policy,program or project and to make recommendations for health improvement. HIA can promote the cooperation between health and non-health sectors,raise the awareness about health in decision-makers,increase the participation of stakeholders and change health inequality. This paper reviews the international studies into HIA from 2000 to 2018, providing reference for HIA development in China.
引文
[1]MINDELL J,ISON E,JOFFE M.A glossary for health impact assessment[J].Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health,2003,57(9):647.
[2]CARMICHAEL L,BARTON H,GRAY S,et al.Integration of health into urban spatial planning through impact assessment:Identifying governance and policy barriers and facilitators[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2012,32(1):187-194.
[3]DANNENBERG A L,BHATIA R,COLE B L,et al.Growing the field of health impact assessment in the United States:an agenda for research and practice[J].American Journal of Public Health,2006,96(2):262-270.
[4]PARRY J,STEVENS A.Prospective health impact assessment:pitfalls,problems,and possible ways forward[J].British Medical Journal,2001,323(7322):1177-1182.
[5]BIRLEY M.Health impact assessment:principles and practice[M].London:Routledge,2013.
[6]HARRIS-ROXAS B,HARRIS E.Differing forms,differing purposes:a typology of health impact assessment[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2010,31(4):396-403.
[7]ISON E.The introduction of health impact assessment in the WHOEuropean Healthy Cities Network[J].Health Promotion International,2009,24(suppl1):64-71.
[8]HEBERT K A,WENDEL A M,KENNEDY S K,et al.Health impact assessment:a comparison of 45 local,national,and international guidelines[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2012,34(1):74-82.
[9]COUNCIL N R.Improving health in the United States:the role of health impact assessment[M].Washington D.C.:National A-cademies Press,2011.
[10]FARQUHAR D.NCSL's Health Impact Assessment Project:an analysis of state health impact assessment legislation:[EB/OL].(2014-07-17)[2019-05-28].http://www.ncsl.org/research/enviro nment-and-natural-resources/an-analysis-of-state-health-impactassessment-legislation635411896.aspx.
[11]林经纬,尹文强,宋春燕,等.英国健康影响评估成功经验及对我国的借鉴与启示[J].中国卫生经济,2018,37(11):93-96.
[12]CARMICHAEL L,BARTON H,GRAY S,et al.Health-integrated planning at the local level in England:Impediments and opportunities[J].Land Use Policy,2013,31:259-266.
[13]GREEN L.Health impact assessment(HIA)in Wales:from voluntary to statutory[J].European Journal of Public Health,2017,27(suppl3):241.
[14]HAIGH F,HARRIS E,HARRIS-ROXAS B,et al.What makes health impact assessments successful?Factors contributing to effectiveness in Australia and New Zealand[J].BMC Public Health,2015,15(1):1009.
[15]HARRIS P,SPICKETT J.Health impact assessment in Australia:a review and directions for progress[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2010,31(4):428-432.
[16]HAIGH F,HARRIS E,CHOK H N,et al.Characteristics of health impact assessments reported in Australia and New Zealand2005-2009[J].Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health,2013,37(6):534-546.
[17]MCCALLUM L C,OLLSON C A,STEFANOVIC I L.Advancing the practice of health impact assessment in Canada:obstacles and opportunities[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2015,55:98-109.
[18]MCCAIG K.Canadian insights:the challenges of an integrated environmental assessment framework[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2005,25(7-8):737-746.
[19]MCCALLUM L C,OLLSON C A,STEFANOVIC I L.An adaptable health impact assessment(HIA)framework for assessing health within environmental assessment(EA):Canadian context,international application[J].Impact Assessment&Project Appraisal,2018,36(1):5-15.
[20]HIA Coordinating Unit.Thailand's rules and procedures for the HIAof public policies[M].Nonthaburi:National Health Commission Office Thailand,2010.
[21]PHOOLCHAROEN W,SUKKUMNOED D,KESSOMBOON P.Development of health impact assessment in Thailand:recent experiences and challenges[J].Bulletin of the World Health Organization,2003,81(6):465-467.
[22]CHANCHITPRICHA C.Effectiveness of health impact assessment(HIA)in Thailand:a case study of a Potash mine HIA in Udon Thani,Thailand[D].Norwich:University of East Anglia,2012.
[23]MIDDLETON C,PENGKAM S,TIVASURADE J A.Water governance and collective action[M].London:Routledge,2017.
[24]黄正.我国建设项目健康影响评价的问题与对策[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2011.
[25]CHANG I S,YILIHAMU Q,WU J,et al.Health impact assessment in environmental impact assessment in China:Status,practice and problems[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2017,66:127-137.
[26]LINZALONE N,BALLARINI A,PICCINELLI C,et al.Institutionalizing health impact assessment:a consultation with experts on the barriers and facilitators to implementing HIA in Italy[J].Journal of environmental management,2018,218:95-102.
[27]KERNER B.Building capacity for local health departments to conduct health impact assessment[R].National Association of County&City Health Officials,2016.
[28]SUKKUMNOED D.Integrating health impact a ssessment with the policy process:lessons and experiences from around the world[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press,2013.
[29]LEE J H,ROBBEL N,DORA C.Cross-country analysis of the institutionalization of health impact assessment[R].Geneva:World Health Organization,2013.
[30]MANNHEIMER L N,GULIS G,LEHTO J,et al.Introducing health impact assessment:an analysis of political and administrative intersectoral working methods[J].European Journal of Public Health,2007,17(5):526-531.
[2]CARMICHAEL L,BARTON H,GRAY S,et al.Integration of health into urban spatial planning through impact assessment:Identifying governance and policy barriers and facilitators[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2012,32(1):187-194.
[3]DANNENBERG A L,BHATIA R,COLE B L,et al.Growing the field of health impact assessment in the United States:an agenda for research and practice[J].American Journal of Public Health,2006,96(2):262-270.
[4]PARRY J,STEVENS A.Prospective health impact assessment:pitfalls,problems,and possible ways forward[J].British Medical Journal,2001,323(7322):1177-1182.
[5]BIRLEY M.Health impact assessment:principles and practice[M].London:Routledge,2013.
[6]HARRIS-ROXAS B,HARRIS E.Differing forms,differing purposes:a typology of health impact assessment[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2010,31(4):396-403.
[7]ISON E.The introduction of health impact assessment in the WHOEuropean Healthy Cities Network[J].Health Promotion International,2009,24(suppl1):64-71.
[8]HEBERT K A,WENDEL A M,KENNEDY S K,et al.Health impact assessment:a comparison of 45 local,national,and international guidelines[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2012,34(1):74-82.
[9]COUNCIL N R.Improving health in the United States:the role of health impact assessment[M].Washington D.C.:National A-cademies Press,2011.
[10]FARQUHAR D.NCSL's Health Impact Assessment Project:an analysis of state health impact assessment legislation:[EB/OL].(2014-07-17)[2019-05-28].http://www.ncsl.org/research/enviro nment-and-natural-resources/an-analysis-of-state-health-impactassessment-legislation635411896.aspx.
[11]林经纬,尹文强,宋春燕,等.英国健康影响评估成功经验及对我国的借鉴与启示[J].中国卫生经济,2018,37(11):93-96.
[12]CARMICHAEL L,BARTON H,GRAY S,et al.Health-integrated planning at the local level in England:Impediments and opportunities[J].Land Use Policy,2013,31:259-266.
[13]GREEN L.Health impact assessment(HIA)in Wales:from voluntary to statutory[J].European Journal of Public Health,2017,27(suppl3):241.
[14]HAIGH F,HARRIS E,HARRIS-ROXAS B,et al.What makes health impact assessments successful?Factors contributing to effectiveness in Australia and New Zealand[J].BMC Public Health,2015,15(1):1009.
[15]HARRIS P,SPICKETT J.Health impact assessment in Australia:a review and directions for progress[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2010,31(4):428-432.
[16]HAIGH F,HARRIS E,CHOK H N,et al.Characteristics of health impact assessments reported in Australia and New Zealand2005-2009[J].Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health,2013,37(6):534-546.
[17]MCCALLUM L C,OLLSON C A,STEFANOVIC I L.Advancing the practice of health impact assessment in Canada:obstacles and opportunities[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2015,55:98-109.
[18]MCCAIG K.Canadian insights:the challenges of an integrated environmental assessment framework[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2005,25(7-8):737-746.
[19]MCCALLUM L C,OLLSON C A,STEFANOVIC I L.An adaptable health impact assessment(HIA)framework for assessing health within environmental assessment(EA):Canadian context,international application[J].Impact Assessment&Project Appraisal,2018,36(1):5-15.
[20]HIA Coordinating Unit.Thailand's rules and procedures for the HIAof public policies[M].Nonthaburi:National Health Commission Office Thailand,2010.
[21]PHOOLCHAROEN W,SUKKUMNOED D,KESSOMBOON P.Development of health impact assessment in Thailand:recent experiences and challenges[J].Bulletin of the World Health Organization,2003,81(6):465-467.
[22]CHANCHITPRICHA C.Effectiveness of health impact assessment(HIA)in Thailand:a case study of a Potash mine HIA in Udon Thani,Thailand[D].Norwich:University of East Anglia,2012.
[23]MIDDLETON C,PENGKAM S,TIVASURADE J A.Water governance and collective action[M].London:Routledge,2017.
[24]黄正.我国建设项目健康影响评价的问题与对策[D].武汉:华中科技大学,2011.
[25]CHANG I S,YILIHAMU Q,WU J,et al.Health impact assessment in environmental impact assessment in China:Status,practice and problems[J].Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2017,66:127-137.
[26]LINZALONE N,BALLARINI A,PICCINELLI C,et al.Institutionalizing health impact assessment:a consultation with experts on the barriers and facilitators to implementing HIA in Italy[J].Journal of environmental management,2018,218:95-102.
[27]KERNER B.Building capacity for local health departments to conduct health impact assessment[R].National Association of County&City Health Officials,2016.
[28]SUKKUMNOED D.Integrating health impact a ssessment with the policy process:lessons and experiences from around the world[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press,2013.
[29]LEE J H,ROBBEL N,DORA C.Cross-country analysis of the institutionalization of health impact assessment[R].Geneva:World Health Organization,2013.
[30]MANNHEIMER L N,GULIS G,LEHTO J,et al.Introducing health impact assessment:an analysis of political and administrative intersectoral working methods[J].European Journal of Public Health,2007,17(5):526-531.