费托合成浆态床反应器结构与工程放大研究进展
|
摘要
由于气液固三相同时存在及内构件的设置,费托合成浆态床反应器传递和反应过程复杂,在反应器设计与工业放大上面临着巨大挑战。介绍了费托合成浆态床反应器的结构特点,概述了近年来费托合成浆态床反应器流体力学、反应器放大的研究进展与成果,并分析了内构件对流体力学和反应器放大的影响。从反应器结构与模型等方面论述了浆态床反应器工程设计的重点和关键,为反应器性能优化与放大提供可行的解决思路与方案。
Due to the existence of gas - liquid - solid three - phase and the installation of internal components, the transfer and reaction process of slurry bed reactor in Fischer--Tropsch synthesis is complex, which poses great challenges in reactor design and industrial scale--up. This paper introduced the structure of slurry bubble column reactor and also reviewed the recent researches on dynamics and reactor scale-ups. The influences of internals on hydrodynamics and scale-up were analyzed as well. Crucial factors in terms of structure and model in the process of reactor design were included, which may provide a feasible scheme and solution for optimization and scale-up of slurry bubble column reactor.
Due to the existence of gas - liquid - solid three - phase and the installation of internal components, the transfer and reaction process of slurry bed reactor in Fischer--Tropsch synthesis is complex, which poses great challenges in reactor design and industrial scale--up. This paper introduced the structure of slurry bubble column reactor and also reviewed the recent researches on dynamics and reactor scale-ups. The influences of internals on hydrodynamics and scale-up were analyzed as well. Crucial factors in terms of structure and model in the process of reactor design were included, which may provide a feasible scheme and solution for optimization and scale-up of slurry bubble column reactor.
引文
[1]徐志新.费托合成反应器的技术进展[J].科技创新导报,2014,24:47-50.Xu Z X.Technical progress of Fischer-Tropsch synthesis reactor[J]. Science and Technology Innovation Herald,2014,24:47-50.
[2]L.-S.范.气液固流态化工程[M].北京:中国石化出版社,1993:386.
[3]Vogelap,Van Dykb,Saibam.GTL using efficient cobalt Fischer-Tropsch catalysts[J]. Catalysis Today,2016,259:323
[4]吴昊,胡志海,聂红.低温法FT合成进展及技术对比[J].石油炼制与化工,2010,41(4):1-5.Wu H,Hu Z H,Nie H. Advances in low temperature Fischer-Tropsch synthesis and comparison of technologies[J].Petroleum Processing and Petrochemicals,2010,41(4):1-5.
[5]Gandhi B,Prakash A,Bergougnou M A.Hydrodynamic behavior of slurry bubble column at high solids concentrations[J].Powder Technology,1999,103:80.
[6]要辉.费托合成工艺研究进展[J].工业技术,2013,17:61-62.Yao H.Research progress in Fischer-Tropsch synthesis process[J]. Science&Technology Information,2013,17:61-62.
[7]惠宇,王玉璋,翁史烈.双切环流气体分布器性能的实验研究[J].化学工程,2011,39(3):18-21.Hui Y,Wang Y Z,Weng S L.Experimental investigation on performance of twin-tangential annular flew gas distributor[J].Chemical Engineering,2011,39(3):18-21.
[8]神华集团有限责任公司,中国神华煤制油化工有限公司.一种新型浆态床反应器气体进料分布器:CN201728094U[P].2011-02-02.
[9]神华集团有限责任公司,北京低碳清洁能源研究所.气体进料分布器和三相浆态床反应器:CN204564077[P]. 2015-08-19.
[10]中石化洛阳工程有限公司.一种用于浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN203379868U[P]. 2014-01-08.
[11]中国石化集团洛阳石油化工工程公司.一种用于浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN103240038B[P]. 2015-04-18.
[12]北京石油化工工程有限公司.浆态床反应器气体分布结构:CN104209069B[P]. 2015-12-30.
[13]中国石化集团洛阳石油化工工程公司.一种用于三相浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN202666816U[P]. 2013-01-16.
[14]中石化洛阳工程有限公司,中石化炼化工程(集团)股份有限公司.用于浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN104338494A[P]. 2015-02-11.
[15]陈强,蔡连波,盛维武,等.浆态床反应器气体分布器组性能实验研究[J].石油化工设备,2016,45(4):12-17.Chen Q,Cai L B,Sheng W W,et al.Study on combined performances of gas distributor for slurry-bed reactor[J]. Petro-Chemical Equipment,2016,45(4):12-17.
[16]武汉凯迪工程技术研究总院有限公司.用于三相浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN204522946U[P]. 2015-08-05.
[17]内蒙古伊泰煤制油有限责任公司.一种新型浆态床反应器气体分布器:CN202876778U[P]. 2013-04-17.
[18]Nippon steel engineering Co.,Ltd. Bubble column-type fischer-tropsch synthesis slurry bed reaction system:US8057744B2[P]. 2011-11-15.
[19]贺飞.费托浆态床反应器蜡分离系统的设置和优化[J].能源化工,2015,36(5):5-10.He F.Arrangement and optimization of wax separation system in slurry bed reactor in Fischer Tropsch process[J]. Energy Chemical Industry,2015,36(5):5-10.
[20]中石化洛阳工程有限公司,中石化炼化工程股份有限公司.一种浆态床反应器的过滤内构件:CN104174338A[P].2014-12-03.
[21]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石油化工科学研究院.一种浆态床环流反应器及其应用:CN102451651B[P]. 2014-12-31.
[22]Japan Oil,Gas and Metals National Corporation. Method for producing hydrocarbon oil,Fischer-Tropsch synthesis reaction device,and hydrocarbon oil production system:US9181492B2[P]. 2015-11-10.
[23]江苏克莱斯克能源装备有限公司.一种浆态床反应器内置过滤组件:CN102107130B[P]. 2013-08-07.
[24]上海蓝科石化工程技术有限公司.一种用于三相浆态床反应器的产品过滤系统:CN102626568A[P]. 2012-08-08.
[25]神华集团有限责任公司,神华宁夏煤业集团有限责任公司.一种费托合成与分离的装置及方法:CN104888668A[P].2015-09-09.
[26]中国石油化工股份有限公司,石油化工科学研究院.一种浆态床反应及分离设备:CN202823321U[P]. 2013-03-27.
[27]中国石油化工股份有限公司,石油化工科学研究院.一种浆态床环流反应器及连续分离设备:CN203018065U[P].2013-06-26.
[28]GTL.F1 AG. Apparatus and method for conducting a Fischer-Tropsch synthesis reaction:US9278891B2[P]. 2016-03-08.
[29]Kazuhiko Tasaka,Yokohama-shi. Method of selectively removing catalyst from Fischer-Tropsch synthetic crude oil and method of recycling removed catalyst:US 2011/0281960A1[P]. 2011-11-17.
[30]中石化宁波工程有限公司,中石化宁波技术研究院有限公司.浆液中金属催化剂分离装置:CN204752624U[P]. 2015-11-11.
[31]中国石油化工集团公司,中石化洛阳工程有限公司.一种费托合成浆态床反应器中合成油和催化剂的分离设备:CN202638054U[P]. 2013-01-02.
[32]Rentech,inc. Integrated multi-step solid/liquid separation system for fischer-tropsch process:US2014/0286834A1[P].2014-09-25.
[33]高晋生,张德祥.煤液化技术[M].北京,化学工业出版社,2005.
[34]中国石油化工股份有限公司石油化工科学研究院.列管式换热器和费托合成浆态床反应器:CN204739934 U[P]. 2015-11-04.
[35]德艾科工程技术(上海)有限公司.一种新型浆态床反应器:CN104959084A[P]. 2015-10-07.
[36]中国石油化工集团公司,中国石化工程建设有限公司.一种用于浆态床费托合成反应器的自然循环取热方法及系统:CN103386280A[P]. 2013-11-13.
[37]北京石油化工工程有限公司.三相浆态床取热单元:CN203663810U[P]. 2014-06-25.
[38]REG synthetic fuels,LLC. Process for increasing the efficiency of heat removal from a Fischer-Tropsch slurry reactor:US9266082B2[P]. 2016-02-23.
[39]神华集团有限责任公司,中国神华煤制油有限公司.浆态床反应设备:CN102728286A[P]. 2012-10-17.
[40]中国石油化工股份有限公司,石油化工科学研究院.一种内循环式浆态床反应器及其应用:CN102416307A[P]. 2012-04-18.
[41]中国科学院上海高等研究院,陕西潞安环保能源开发股份有限公司,上海碧科清洁能源技术有限公司:CN103769008B[P]. 2016-01-20.
[42]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石化工程建设公司.一种浆态床费托合成反应器:CN201684588U[P]. 2010-12-29.
[43]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石化工程建设公司.一种费托合成浆态床反应器:CN102188938B[P]. 2014-03-19.
[44]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石化工程建设公司.一种用于费托合成的浆态床反应器:CN201735386U[P]. 2011-02-09.
[45]Mena P,Ferreira A,Teixeira J,et al.Effect of some solid properties on gas-liquid mass transfer in a bubble column[J].Chemical Engineering and Processing:Process Intensification,2011,50(2):181-188.
[46]Babaei R,Bonakdarpour B,Ein-mozaffari F.Analysis of gas phase characteristics and mixing performance in an activated sludge bioreactor using electrical resistance tomography[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal,2015,279:874-884.
[47]Li Z,Guan X,Wang L,et al.Experimental and numerical investigations of scale-up effects on the hydrodynamics of slurry bubble columns[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering,2016,8:963-971.
[48]Manjrekar O N,Dudukovic M P. Application of a 4-point optical probe to a slurry bubble column reactor[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,2015,131:313-322.
[49]Vandu C O,Koop K,Krishna,R. Volumetric mass transfer coefficient in a slurry bubble column operating in the heterogeneous flow regime[J].Chemical Engneering Science,2004,59:5417-5423.
[50]Zhang T W,Wang J F,Wang T F,et al. Effect of internal on the hydrodynamics in external-loop airlift reactors[J].Chemical Engineering and Processing,2005,44:81-87.
[51]Wang T F,Wang J F,Jin Y.Slurry reactors for gas to liquid processes:A review[J]. Industrial&Engineering Chemistry Research,2007,46:5824-5847.
[52]张煜,李红波,李兆奇,等.湍动浆态床流体力学研究(Ⅳ)带垂直列管束的浆态床流体力学模型与模拟[J].化工学报,2011,62(12):3373-3379.Zhang Y,Li H B,Li Z Q,et al.Hydrodynamics of turbulent slurry bubble column(Ⅳ)Modeling and simulation of bubble column with vertical pipe bundles[J]. Journal of Chemical Industry and Engineering,2011,62(12):3373-3379.
[53]张煜,李兆奇,李红波,等.湍动浆态床流体力学研究(Ⅴ)带多层水平网格构件的浆态床流体力学模型[J].化工学报,2012,63(2):387-392.Zhang Y,Li Z Q,Li H B,et al.Studies on hydrodynamics of turbulent slurry bubble column(Ⅴ)Modeling of bubble column with multi-layer screens[J]. Journal of Chemical Industry and Engineering,2012,63(2):387-392.
[54]Guan X,Gao Y,Tian Z,et al. Hydrodynamics in bubble columns with pin-fin tube internals[J]. Chemical Engineering Research and Design:2015,102:196-206.
[55]Al Mesfer M K,Sultan A J,Al-Dahhan M H.Impacts of dense heat exchanging internals on gas holdup cross-sectional distributions and profiles of bubble column using gamma ray Computed Tomography(CT)for FT synthesis[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal,2016,300(15):317-333.
[56]Desvigne D,Donnat L,Schweich D. Simulating the effects of liquid circulation in bubble columns with internals[J].Chemical Engineering Science,2006,61(13):4195-4206.
[57]Euzen J P,Trambouze P,Wauquier J P. Scale-up methodology for chemical processes[M]. Paris:Editions Technip,1993:244.
[58]Zhang K,Zhao Y L.Ascale-up strategy for low-temperature methanol synthesis in a circulating slurry bubble reactor[J].Chemical Engineering Science,2006,61:1459-1469.
[59]赵玉龙.浆态床FT合成反应器的工程放大[J].化学反应工程与工艺,2008,24(5):461-467.Zhao Y L.Engineering scale-up of the bubble column slurry reactor for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis[J]. Chemical Reaction Engineering and Technology,2008,24(5):461-467.
[60]中科合成油:国内煤制油领域先锋[J].新材料产业,2015,8:71.Synfuels China:China pioneer in coal to liquid industry[J]. Advanced Materials Industry,2015,8:71.
[61]李明忠,曲照贵.神华宁煤煤间接液化项目出油[J].中国石油和化工,2017,1:78.Li M Z,Qu Z G. Shenhua coal indirect liquefaction project produced oil[J]. China Petroleum and Chemical Industry,2017,1:78.
[62]Krishna R,Van Baten J M,Urseanu M I,et al.Design and scale-up of the bubble column slurry reactor for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,2001,56:537-545.
[63]Krishna R.A scale-up strategy for a commercial scale bubble column slurry reactor for Fischer–Tropsch synthesis[J].Oil&Gas Science and Technology,2000,55:359-393.
[64]Sie S T,Krishna R. Fundamentals and selection of advanced Fischer-Tropsch reactors[J].Applied Catalysis A:General:1999,186:55-70.
[65]Vanden Bleek C M,Schouten J C.Can deterministic chaos create order in fluidized-bed scale-up?[J].Chemical Engineering Science,1993,48(13):2367-2373.
[66]Van Batenj M,Ellenberge R J,Krishna R.Scale-up strategy for bubble column slurry reactors using CFD simulations[J].Catalysis Today,2003,79-80:256-265.
[67]Nottenkamper R.Zur hydrodynamic in blasensaueln reaktoren[D]. Germany:University of Dortmund,1983.
[68]Forret A,Schweitzer J M,Gauthier T,et al.Scale up of slurry bubble reactors[J]. Oil&Gas Science and Technology,2006,61(3):443-458.
[69]Krishna R,Ellenbergerj,Sie S T.Reactor development for conversion of natural gas to liquid fuels:A scale-up strategy relying on hydrodynamic analogies[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1996,51:2041-2050.
[70]Inga J R.Scale up and scale down of slurry reactions[D]. USA,PA:University of Pittsburgh,1997.
[71]Safoniuk M,Grace J R,Hackman L,et al. Use of dimensional similitude for scale-up of hydrodynamics in three-phase fluidized beds[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1999,54:4961-4966.
[72]Macchi A. Dimensionless hydrodynamic simulation of high pressure multiphase reactors subject to foaming[D]. Canada,Vancouver:University of British Columbia,2002.
[73]Shaikh A.Bubble and slurry bubble column reactors for syngas to liquid fuel conversion:mixing,flow regime transition,and scale-Up[D]. USA,Saint Louis:Washington University in St. Louis,2007.
[74]Kolbel H,Ackermann P. Apparatus for carrying out gaseous catalytic reactions in liquid medium:US 2853369[P].1958.
[75]Sasol Technology Proprietary)Limited. Method of operating a three-phase slurry reactor:US 8013025B2[P]. 2011.
[76]Ahmed A Y,Mohamed E H,Al-dahhan Muthanna H,et al.A new approach for scale-up of bubble column reactors[J].Chemical Engineering Research and Design,2014,92:1637-1646.
[2]L.-S.范.气液固流态化工程[M].北京:中国石化出版社,1993:386.
[3]Vogelap,Van Dykb,Saibam.GTL using efficient cobalt Fischer-Tropsch catalysts[J]. Catalysis Today,2016,259:323
[4]吴昊,胡志海,聂红.低温法FT合成进展及技术对比[J].石油炼制与化工,2010,41(4):1-5.Wu H,Hu Z H,Nie H. Advances in low temperature Fischer-Tropsch synthesis and comparison of technologies[J].Petroleum Processing and Petrochemicals,2010,41(4):1-5.
[5]Gandhi B,Prakash A,Bergougnou M A.Hydrodynamic behavior of slurry bubble column at high solids concentrations[J].Powder Technology,1999,103:80.
[6]要辉.费托合成工艺研究进展[J].工业技术,2013,17:61-62.Yao H.Research progress in Fischer-Tropsch synthesis process[J]. Science&Technology Information,2013,17:61-62.
[7]惠宇,王玉璋,翁史烈.双切环流气体分布器性能的实验研究[J].化学工程,2011,39(3):18-21.Hui Y,Wang Y Z,Weng S L.Experimental investigation on performance of twin-tangential annular flew gas distributor[J].Chemical Engineering,2011,39(3):18-21.
[8]神华集团有限责任公司,中国神华煤制油化工有限公司.一种新型浆态床反应器气体进料分布器:CN201728094U[P].2011-02-02.
[9]神华集团有限责任公司,北京低碳清洁能源研究所.气体进料分布器和三相浆态床反应器:CN204564077[P]. 2015-08-19.
[10]中石化洛阳工程有限公司.一种用于浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN203379868U[P]. 2014-01-08.
[11]中国石化集团洛阳石油化工工程公司.一种用于浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN103240038B[P]. 2015-04-18.
[12]北京石油化工工程有限公司.浆态床反应器气体分布结构:CN104209069B[P]. 2015-12-30.
[13]中国石化集团洛阳石油化工工程公司.一种用于三相浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN202666816U[P]. 2013-01-16.
[14]中石化洛阳工程有限公司,中石化炼化工程(集团)股份有限公司.用于浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN104338494A[P]. 2015-02-11.
[15]陈强,蔡连波,盛维武,等.浆态床反应器气体分布器组性能实验研究[J].石油化工设备,2016,45(4):12-17.Chen Q,Cai L B,Sheng W W,et al.Study on combined performances of gas distributor for slurry-bed reactor[J]. Petro-Chemical Equipment,2016,45(4):12-17.
[16]武汉凯迪工程技术研究总院有限公司.用于三相浆态床反应器的气体分布器:CN204522946U[P]. 2015-08-05.
[17]内蒙古伊泰煤制油有限责任公司.一种新型浆态床反应器气体分布器:CN202876778U[P]. 2013-04-17.
[18]Nippon steel engineering Co.,Ltd. Bubble column-type fischer-tropsch synthesis slurry bed reaction system:US8057744B2[P]. 2011-11-15.
[19]贺飞.费托浆态床反应器蜡分离系统的设置和优化[J].能源化工,2015,36(5):5-10.He F.Arrangement and optimization of wax separation system in slurry bed reactor in Fischer Tropsch process[J]. Energy Chemical Industry,2015,36(5):5-10.
[20]中石化洛阳工程有限公司,中石化炼化工程股份有限公司.一种浆态床反应器的过滤内构件:CN104174338A[P].2014-12-03.
[21]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石油化工科学研究院.一种浆态床环流反应器及其应用:CN102451651B[P]. 2014-12-31.
[22]Japan Oil,Gas and Metals National Corporation. Method for producing hydrocarbon oil,Fischer-Tropsch synthesis reaction device,and hydrocarbon oil production system:US9181492B2[P]. 2015-11-10.
[23]江苏克莱斯克能源装备有限公司.一种浆态床反应器内置过滤组件:CN102107130B[P]. 2013-08-07.
[24]上海蓝科石化工程技术有限公司.一种用于三相浆态床反应器的产品过滤系统:CN102626568A[P]. 2012-08-08.
[25]神华集团有限责任公司,神华宁夏煤业集团有限责任公司.一种费托合成与分离的装置及方法:CN104888668A[P].2015-09-09.
[26]中国石油化工股份有限公司,石油化工科学研究院.一种浆态床反应及分离设备:CN202823321U[P]. 2013-03-27.
[27]中国石油化工股份有限公司,石油化工科学研究院.一种浆态床环流反应器及连续分离设备:CN203018065U[P].2013-06-26.
[28]GTL.F1 AG. Apparatus and method for conducting a Fischer-Tropsch synthesis reaction:US9278891B2[P]. 2016-03-08.
[29]Kazuhiko Tasaka,Yokohama-shi. Method of selectively removing catalyst from Fischer-Tropsch synthetic crude oil and method of recycling removed catalyst:US 2011/0281960A1[P]. 2011-11-17.
[30]中石化宁波工程有限公司,中石化宁波技术研究院有限公司.浆液中金属催化剂分离装置:CN204752624U[P]. 2015-11-11.
[31]中国石油化工集团公司,中石化洛阳工程有限公司.一种费托合成浆态床反应器中合成油和催化剂的分离设备:CN202638054U[P]. 2013-01-02.
[32]Rentech,inc. Integrated multi-step solid/liquid separation system for fischer-tropsch process:US2014/0286834A1[P].2014-09-25.
[33]高晋生,张德祥.煤液化技术[M].北京,化学工业出版社,2005.
[34]中国石油化工股份有限公司石油化工科学研究院.列管式换热器和费托合成浆态床反应器:CN204739934 U[P]. 2015-11-04.
[35]德艾科工程技术(上海)有限公司.一种新型浆态床反应器:CN104959084A[P]. 2015-10-07.
[36]中国石油化工集团公司,中国石化工程建设有限公司.一种用于浆态床费托合成反应器的自然循环取热方法及系统:CN103386280A[P]. 2013-11-13.
[37]北京石油化工工程有限公司.三相浆态床取热单元:CN203663810U[P]. 2014-06-25.
[38]REG synthetic fuels,LLC. Process for increasing the efficiency of heat removal from a Fischer-Tropsch slurry reactor:US9266082B2[P]. 2016-02-23.
[39]神华集团有限责任公司,中国神华煤制油有限公司.浆态床反应设备:CN102728286A[P]. 2012-10-17.
[40]中国石油化工股份有限公司,石油化工科学研究院.一种内循环式浆态床反应器及其应用:CN102416307A[P]. 2012-04-18.
[41]中国科学院上海高等研究院,陕西潞安环保能源开发股份有限公司,上海碧科清洁能源技术有限公司:CN103769008B[P]. 2016-01-20.
[42]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石化工程建设公司.一种浆态床费托合成反应器:CN201684588U[P]. 2010-12-29.
[43]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石化工程建设公司.一种费托合成浆态床反应器:CN102188938B[P]. 2014-03-19.
[44]中国石油化工股份有限公司,中国石化工程建设公司.一种用于费托合成的浆态床反应器:CN201735386U[P]. 2011-02-09.
[45]Mena P,Ferreira A,Teixeira J,et al.Effect of some solid properties on gas-liquid mass transfer in a bubble column[J].Chemical Engineering and Processing:Process Intensification,2011,50(2):181-188.
[46]Babaei R,Bonakdarpour B,Ein-mozaffari F.Analysis of gas phase characteristics and mixing performance in an activated sludge bioreactor using electrical resistance tomography[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal,2015,279:874-884.
[47]Li Z,Guan X,Wang L,et al.Experimental and numerical investigations of scale-up effects on the hydrodynamics of slurry bubble columns[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering,2016,8:963-971.
[48]Manjrekar O N,Dudukovic M P. Application of a 4-point optical probe to a slurry bubble column reactor[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,2015,131:313-322.
[49]Vandu C O,Koop K,Krishna,R. Volumetric mass transfer coefficient in a slurry bubble column operating in the heterogeneous flow regime[J].Chemical Engneering Science,2004,59:5417-5423.
[50]Zhang T W,Wang J F,Wang T F,et al. Effect of internal on the hydrodynamics in external-loop airlift reactors[J].Chemical Engineering and Processing,2005,44:81-87.
[51]Wang T F,Wang J F,Jin Y.Slurry reactors for gas to liquid processes:A review[J]. Industrial&Engineering Chemistry Research,2007,46:5824-5847.
[52]张煜,李红波,李兆奇,等.湍动浆态床流体力学研究(Ⅳ)带垂直列管束的浆态床流体力学模型与模拟[J].化工学报,2011,62(12):3373-3379.Zhang Y,Li H B,Li Z Q,et al.Hydrodynamics of turbulent slurry bubble column(Ⅳ)Modeling and simulation of bubble column with vertical pipe bundles[J]. Journal of Chemical Industry and Engineering,2011,62(12):3373-3379.
[53]张煜,李兆奇,李红波,等.湍动浆态床流体力学研究(Ⅴ)带多层水平网格构件的浆态床流体力学模型[J].化工学报,2012,63(2):387-392.Zhang Y,Li Z Q,Li H B,et al.Studies on hydrodynamics of turbulent slurry bubble column(Ⅴ)Modeling of bubble column with multi-layer screens[J]. Journal of Chemical Industry and Engineering,2012,63(2):387-392.
[54]Guan X,Gao Y,Tian Z,et al. Hydrodynamics in bubble columns with pin-fin tube internals[J]. Chemical Engineering Research and Design:2015,102:196-206.
[55]Al Mesfer M K,Sultan A J,Al-Dahhan M H.Impacts of dense heat exchanging internals on gas holdup cross-sectional distributions and profiles of bubble column using gamma ray Computed Tomography(CT)for FT synthesis[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal,2016,300(15):317-333.
[56]Desvigne D,Donnat L,Schweich D. Simulating the effects of liquid circulation in bubble columns with internals[J].Chemical Engineering Science,2006,61(13):4195-4206.
[57]Euzen J P,Trambouze P,Wauquier J P. Scale-up methodology for chemical processes[M]. Paris:Editions Technip,1993:244.
[58]Zhang K,Zhao Y L.Ascale-up strategy for low-temperature methanol synthesis in a circulating slurry bubble reactor[J].Chemical Engineering Science,2006,61:1459-1469.
[59]赵玉龙.浆态床FT合成反应器的工程放大[J].化学反应工程与工艺,2008,24(5):461-467.Zhao Y L.Engineering scale-up of the bubble column slurry reactor for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis[J]. Chemical Reaction Engineering and Technology,2008,24(5):461-467.
[60]中科合成油:国内煤制油领域先锋[J].新材料产业,2015,8:71.Synfuels China:China pioneer in coal to liquid industry[J]. Advanced Materials Industry,2015,8:71.
[61]李明忠,曲照贵.神华宁煤煤间接液化项目出油[J].中国石油和化工,2017,1:78.Li M Z,Qu Z G. Shenhua coal indirect liquefaction project produced oil[J]. China Petroleum and Chemical Industry,2017,1:78.
[62]Krishna R,Van Baten J M,Urseanu M I,et al.Design and scale-up of the bubble column slurry reactor for Fischer-Tropsch synthesis[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,2001,56:537-545.
[63]Krishna R.A scale-up strategy for a commercial scale bubble column slurry reactor for Fischer–Tropsch synthesis[J].Oil&Gas Science and Technology,2000,55:359-393.
[64]Sie S T,Krishna R. Fundamentals and selection of advanced Fischer-Tropsch reactors[J].Applied Catalysis A:General:1999,186:55-70.
[65]Vanden Bleek C M,Schouten J C.Can deterministic chaos create order in fluidized-bed scale-up?[J].Chemical Engineering Science,1993,48(13):2367-2373.
[66]Van Batenj M,Ellenberge R J,Krishna R.Scale-up strategy for bubble column slurry reactors using CFD simulations[J].Catalysis Today,2003,79-80:256-265.
[67]Nottenkamper R.Zur hydrodynamic in blasensaueln reaktoren[D]. Germany:University of Dortmund,1983.
[68]Forret A,Schweitzer J M,Gauthier T,et al.Scale up of slurry bubble reactors[J]. Oil&Gas Science and Technology,2006,61(3):443-458.
[69]Krishna R,Ellenbergerj,Sie S T.Reactor development for conversion of natural gas to liquid fuels:A scale-up strategy relying on hydrodynamic analogies[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1996,51:2041-2050.
[70]Inga J R.Scale up and scale down of slurry reactions[D]. USA,PA:University of Pittsburgh,1997.
[71]Safoniuk M,Grace J R,Hackman L,et al. Use of dimensional similitude for scale-up of hydrodynamics in three-phase fluidized beds[J]. Chemical Engineering Science,1999,54:4961-4966.
[72]Macchi A. Dimensionless hydrodynamic simulation of high pressure multiphase reactors subject to foaming[D]. Canada,Vancouver:University of British Columbia,2002.
[73]Shaikh A.Bubble and slurry bubble column reactors for syngas to liquid fuel conversion:mixing,flow regime transition,and scale-Up[D]. USA,Saint Louis:Washington University in St. Louis,2007.
[74]Kolbel H,Ackermann P. Apparatus for carrying out gaseous catalytic reactions in liquid medium:US 2853369[P].1958.
[75]Sasol Technology Proprietary)Limited. Method of operating a three-phase slurry reactor:US 8013025B2[P]. 2011.
[76]Ahmed A Y,Mohamed E H,Al-dahhan Muthanna H,et al.A new approach for scale-up of bubble column reactors[J].Chemical Engineering Research and Design,2014,92:1637-1646.