混合现实技术辅助神经外科精准手术研究进展
摘要
混合现实技术(Mixed Reality,MR)的进展,为实现外科精准手术实时术中定位导航提供了可能。在神经外科精准手术的理念下,MR技术在优化手术设计、精准术中定位、促进医患沟通、提升医疗教学方面,具备临床应用价值与潜力。本文结合MR技术特点,阐述现阶段MR技术在神经外科辅助穿刺引流、肿瘤切除、医患沟通及医师培训等方面的应用现状,探讨其在辅助临床决策、优化手术方案、促进神经外科精准诊疗的研究进展。
引文
[1]Renfrow JJ,Strowd RE,Laxton AW,et al.Surgical Considerations in the Optimal Management of Patients with Malignant Brain Tumors[J].Curr Treat Options Oncol,2017,18(8):46.
[2]Sang S,Wanggou S,Wang Z,et al.Clinical Long-Term Follow-Up Evaluation of Functional Neuronavigation in Adult Cerebral Gliomas[J].World Neurosurg,2018,119:e262-e271.
[3]Moche M,Trampel R,Kahn T,et al.Navigation concepts for MR image-guided interventions.J Magn Reson Imaging,2008,27(2):276-291.
[4]Maciunas RJ,Computer-assisted Neurosurgery[J].Clin Neurosurg,2006,53:267-271.
[5]Pinggera D,Kerschbaumer J,Bauer M,et al.Accuracy Validation of Neuronavigation Comparing Headholder-Based System with Head-Mounted Array-A Cadaveric Study[J].World Neurosurg,2018,120:e313-e317.
[6]Yetisen AK,Martinez-Hurtado JL,Unal B,et al.Wearables in Medicine[J].Adv Mater,2018,e1706910.
[7]Elmi-Terander A,Burstr9m G,Nachabe R.et al.Pedicle Screw Placement Using Augmented Reality Surgical Navigation with Intraoperative 3 D Imaging:A First In-Human Prospective Cohort Study.Spine(Phila Pa 1976),2019,44(7):517-525.
[8]Pandya A,Siadat MR,Auner G.Design,implementation and accuracy of a prototype for medical augmented reality[J].Comput Aided Surg,2005,10(1):23-35.
[9]Kramers M,Armstrong R,Bakhshmand SM.et al.Evaluation of a mobile augmented reality application for image guidance of neurosurgical interventions[J].Stud Health Technol Inform,2014,196:204-208.
[10]Mitrasinovic S,Camacho E,Trivedi N,et al.Clinical and surgical applications of smart glasses[J].Technol Health Care,2015,23(4):381-401.
[11]Wu ML,Chien JC,Wu CT,et al.An Augmented Reality System Using Improved-Iterative Closest Point Algorithm for On-Patient Medical Imag e Visualization.Sensors(Basel),2018,18(8).pii:E2505.doi:10.3390/s18082505.
[12]Mitsuno D,Hirota Y,Akamatsu J,et al.Telementoring Demonstration in Craniofacial Surgery with Holo Lens,Skype,and Three-Layer Facial Models[J].J Craniofac Surg,2018,30(1):28-32.
[13]Fernandes de Oliveira Santos B,Silva da Costa MD,Centeno RS,et al.Clinical Application of an Open-Source 3 D Volume Rendering Software to Neurosurgical Approaches[J].World Neurosurg,2018,110:p.e864-e872.
[14]Hendricks BK,Hartman J,Cohen-Gadol AA.Cerebrovascular Operative Anatomy:An Immersive 3 D and Virtual Reality Description[J].Oper Neurosurg(Hagerstown),2018,15(6):613-623.
[15]Tagaytayan R,Kelemen A,and Sik-Lanyi C.Augmented reality in neurosurgery[J].Arch Med Sci,2018,14(3):572-578.
[16]Kim DN,Chae YS,Kim MY.X-ray and optical stereobased 3 D sensor fusion system for image-guided neurosurgery[J].Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg,2016,11(4):529-541.
[17]Zhang X,Chen G,Liao H.High-Quality See-Through Surgical Guidance System Using Enhanced 3-D Autostereoscopic Augmented Reality[J].IEEE Trans Biomed Eng,2017,64(8):1815-1825.
[18]Eftekhar B.A Smartphone App to Assist Scalp Localization of Superficial Supratentorial Lesions-Technical Note[J].World Neurosurg,2016,85:359-63.
[19]Bernardo A,Virtual Reality and Simulation in Neurosurgical Training.World Neurosurg,2017,106:1015-1029.
[20]Guha D,Alotaibi NM,Nguyen N,et al.Augmented Reality in Neurosurger y:A Review of Current Concepts and E-merging Applications.Can J Neurol Sci,2017,44(3):235-245.
[21]Contreras Lopez WO,Navarro PA,Crispin S.Intraoperative clinical application of augmented reality in neurosurgery:A systematic review.Clin Neurol Neurosurg,2019,177:6-11.
[22]Deib G,Johnson A,Unberath M.et al.Image guided percutaneous spine procedures using an optical see-through head mounted display:proof of concept and rationale.J Neurointerv Surg,2018,10(12):1187-1191.
[23]Cabrilo IA.Sarrafzadeh,P.Bijlenga,et al.,Augmented reality-assisted skull base surgery.Neurochirurgie,2014,60(6):304-306.
[24]Li Z,Li Y,Xu F,et al.Minimal invasive puncture and drainage versus endoscopic surgery for spontaneous intracerebral hemorrhage in basal ganglia.Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat,2017,13:213-219.
[25]Sun GC,Chen XL,Hou YZ.et al.Image-guided endoscopic surgery for spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral hematoma.J Neurosurg,2017,127(3):537-542.
[26]Sun GC,Wang F,Chen XL.et al.Impact of Virtual and Augmented Reality Based on Intraoperative Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Functional Neuronavigation in Glioma Surgery Involving Eloquent Areas.World Neurosurg,2016,96:375-382.
[27]Kersten-Oertel M,Gerard I,Drouin S,et al.Augmented reality in neurovascular surgery:feasibility and first uses in the operating room.Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg,2015,10(11):1823-1836.
[28]Kockro RA,Killeen T,Ayyad A,et al.Aneurysm Surgery with Preoperative Three-Dimensional Planning in a Virtual Reality Environment:Technique and Outcome Analysis.World Neurosurg,2016,96:489-499.
[29]Karmonik C,Elias SN,Zhang JY,et al.Augmented Reality with Virtual Cerebral Aneurysms:A Feasibility Study.World Neurosurg,2018,119:e617-e622.
[30]Marcus HJ,Pratt P,Hughes-Hallett A,et al.Comparative effectiveness and safety of image guidance systems in neurosurgery:a preclinical randomized study.J Neurosurg,2015,123(2):307-313.
[31]Davis MC,Can DD,Pindrik J,et al.Virtual interactive presence in global surgical education:international collaboration through augmented reality.World Neurosurg,2016,86:103-111.
[32]de Ribaupierre S,Eagleson R.Editorial:Challenges for the usability of AR and VR for clinical neurosurgical procedures.Healthc Technol Lett,2017,4(5):151.
[33]Gerard IJ,Kersten-Oertel M,Drouin S,et al.Combining intraoperative ultrasound brain shift correction and augmented reality visualizations:a pilot study of eight cases.J Med Imaging(Bellingham),2018,5(2):021210.
[34]Tonutti,M,Gras G,Yang GZ.A machine learning approach for real-time modelling of tissue deformation in imageguided neurosurgery.Artif Intell Med,2017,80:39-47.
[35]Zeng B,Meng F,Ding H,et al.A surgical robot with augmented reality visualization for stereoelectroencephalography electrode implantation.Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg,2017,12(8):1355-1368.
[2]Sang S,Wanggou S,Wang Z,et al.Clinical Long-Term Follow-Up Evaluation of Functional Neuronavigation in Adult Cerebral Gliomas[J].World Neurosurg,2018,119:e262-e271.
[3]Moche M,Trampel R,Kahn T,et al.Navigation concepts for MR image-guided interventions.J Magn Reson Imaging,2008,27(2):276-291.
[4]Maciunas RJ,Computer-assisted Neurosurgery[J].Clin Neurosurg,2006,53:267-271.
[5]Pinggera D,Kerschbaumer J,Bauer M,et al.Accuracy Validation of Neuronavigation Comparing Headholder-Based System with Head-Mounted Array-A Cadaveric Study[J].World Neurosurg,2018,120:e313-e317.
[6]Yetisen AK,Martinez-Hurtado JL,Unal B,et al.Wearables in Medicine[J].Adv Mater,2018,e1706910.
[7]Elmi-Terander A,Burstr9m G,Nachabe R.et al.Pedicle Screw Placement Using Augmented Reality Surgical Navigation with Intraoperative 3 D Imaging:A First In-Human Prospective Cohort Study.Spine(Phila Pa 1976),2019,44(7):517-525.
[8]Pandya A,Siadat MR,Auner G.Design,implementation and accuracy of a prototype for medical augmented reality[J].Comput Aided Surg,2005,10(1):23-35.
[9]Kramers M,Armstrong R,Bakhshmand SM.et al.Evaluation of a mobile augmented reality application for image guidance of neurosurgical interventions[J].Stud Health Technol Inform,2014,196:204-208.
[10]Mitrasinovic S,Camacho E,Trivedi N,et al.Clinical and surgical applications of smart glasses[J].Technol Health Care,2015,23(4):381-401.
[11]Wu ML,Chien JC,Wu CT,et al.An Augmented Reality System Using Improved-Iterative Closest Point Algorithm for On-Patient Medical Imag e Visualization.Sensors(Basel),2018,18(8).pii:E2505.doi:10.3390/s18082505.
[12]Mitsuno D,Hirota Y,Akamatsu J,et al.Telementoring Demonstration in Craniofacial Surgery with Holo Lens,Skype,and Three-Layer Facial Models[J].J Craniofac Surg,2018,30(1):28-32.
[13]Fernandes de Oliveira Santos B,Silva da Costa MD,Centeno RS,et al.Clinical Application of an Open-Source 3 D Volume Rendering Software to Neurosurgical Approaches[J].World Neurosurg,2018,110:p.e864-e872.
[14]Hendricks BK,Hartman J,Cohen-Gadol AA.Cerebrovascular Operative Anatomy:An Immersive 3 D and Virtual Reality Description[J].Oper Neurosurg(Hagerstown),2018,15(6):613-623.
[15]Tagaytayan R,Kelemen A,and Sik-Lanyi C.Augmented reality in neurosurgery[J].Arch Med Sci,2018,14(3):572-578.
[16]Kim DN,Chae YS,Kim MY.X-ray and optical stereobased 3 D sensor fusion system for image-guided neurosurgery[J].Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg,2016,11(4):529-541.
[17]Zhang X,Chen G,Liao H.High-Quality See-Through Surgical Guidance System Using Enhanced 3-D Autostereoscopic Augmented Reality[J].IEEE Trans Biomed Eng,2017,64(8):1815-1825.
[18]Eftekhar B.A Smartphone App to Assist Scalp Localization of Superficial Supratentorial Lesions-Technical Note[J].World Neurosurg,2016,85:359-63.
[19]Bernardo A,Virtual Reality and Simulation in Neurosurgical Training.World Neurosurg,2017,106:1015-1029.
[20]Guha D,Alotaibi NM,Nguyen N,et al.Augmented Reality in Neurosurger y:A Review of Current Concepts and E-merging Applications.Can J Neurol Sci,2017,44(3):235-245.
[21]Contreras Lopez WO,Navarro PA,Crispin S.Intraoperative clinical application of augmented reality in neurosurgery:A systematic review.Clin Neurol Neurosurg,2019,177:6-11.
[22]Deib G,Johnson A,Unberath M.et al.Image guided percutaneous spine procedures using an optical see-through head mounted display:proof of concept and rationale.J Neurointerv Surg,2018,10(12):1187-1191.
[23]Cabrilo IA.Sarrafzadeh,P.Bijlenga,et al.,Augmented reality-assisted skull base surgery.Neurochirurgie,2014,60(6):304-306.
[24]Li Z,Li Y,Xu F,et al.Minimal invasive puncture and drainage versus endoscopic surgery for spontaneous intracerebral hemorrhage in basal ganglia.Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat,2017,13:213-219.
[25]Sun GC,Chen XL,Hou YZ.et al.Image-guided endoscopic surgery for spontaneous supratentorial intracerebral hematoma.J Neurosurg,2017,127(3):537-542.
[26]Sun GC,Wang F,Chen XL.et al.Impact of Virtual and Augmented Reality Based on Intraoperative Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Functional Neuronavigation in Glioma Surgery Involving Eloquent Areas.World Neurosurg,2016,96:375-382.
[27]Kersten-Oertel M,Gerard I,Drouin S,et al.Augmented reality in neurovascular surgery:feasibility and first uses in the operating room.Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg,2015,10(11):1823-1836.
[28]Kockro RA,Killeen T,Ayyad A,et al.Aneurysm Surgery with Preoperative Three-Dimensional Planning in a Virtual Reality Environment:Technique and Outcome Analysis.World Neurosurg,2016,96:489-499.
[29]Karmonik C,Elias SN,Zhang JY,et al.Augmented Reality with Virtual Cerebral Aneurysms:A Feasibility Study.World Neurosurg,2018,119:e617-e622.
[30]Marcus HJ,Pratt P,Hughes-Hallett A,et al.Comparative effectiveness and safety of image guidance systems in neurosurgery:a preclinical randomized study.J Neurosurg,2015,123(2):307-313.
[31]Davis MC,Can DD,Pindrik J,et al.Virtual interactive presence in global surgical education:international collaboration through augmented reality.World Neurosurg,2016,86:103-111.
[32]de Ribaupierre S,Eagleson R.Editorial:Challenges for the usability of AR and VR for clinical neurosurgical procedures.Healthc Technol Lett,2017,4(5):151.
[33]Gerard IJ,Kersten-Oertel M,Drouin S,et al.Combining intraoperative ultrasound brain shift correction and augmented reality visualizations:a pilot study of eight cases.J Med Imaging(Bellingham),2018,5(2):021210.
[34]Tonutti,M,Gras G,Yang GZ.A machine learning approach for real-time modelling of tissue deformation in imageguided neurosurgery.Artif Intell Med,2017,80:39-47.
[35]Zeng B,Meng F,Ding H,et al.A surgical robot with augmented reality visualization for stereoelectroencephalography electrode implantation.Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg,2017,12(8):1355-1368.