摘要
为了探讨公共危机管理研究处在什么样的状态,本文运用文献共被引分析、突发检测、高被引论文统计方法,收集了1985年以来公共危机管理研究领域的核心文献。通过内容分析,本文讨论了公共危机管理研究的主题和理论演进过程。研究表明,公共危机管理可以划分为三大领域:公共危机过程管理、风险沟通与危机沟通、适应性危机管理。在三十多年的演进过程中,公共危机管理研究经历了危机管理向危机治理、风险沟通向危机沟通、拒绝危机向适应危机的转变。整体上看,公共危机管理研究的概念、理论尚处于"碎片化"阶段。作为跨学科研究尝试的"不确定性"、"脆弱性"、"韧性研究"还没有形成独立的研究体系。下一步,公共危机管理研究需要关注三个研究领域之间的交叉与融合问题。
The objective of this paper is to illustrate how international crisis management research evolves in past three decades.This paper applied four methods in finding and discussing core papers including Analysis of Highly Cited Paper and Hot Paper,Author Co-citation Analysis,Burst Detection Analysis and Contents Analysis.Based on the contents analysis of more than 100 core papers,the authors reveal that process management,crisis communication and adaptation management are three leading areas in crisis management research literature in public administration.Crisis process management put the emergency response at top superior task to governments at emerging time and now crisis governance is focus in present.Risk communication turning to crisis communication reveals that crisis management research absorbed and integrated knowledge from communication and risk management.Cross-disciplinary research is emerging including vulnerability analysis,uncertainty management and adaptation management.However,the paper concludes that public crisis management research is still fragmented,which calls for more cross-disciplinary and integrative work in the future.Crisis management research articles and works are fully dispersed.This analysis may omit some key literatures because of the limitation of research techniques and process.
引文
[1]COMFORT L K,CIGLER B A,WAUGH W L J.Emergency Management Research and Practice in Public Administration:Emergence,Evolution,Expansion and Future Directions[J].Public Administration Review,2012,72(4):539-548.
[2]高小平,六一弘.我国危机管理研究述评(上)[J].中国行政管理,2009(8):29.
[3]吕孝礼,张海波,钟开斌.公共管理视角下的中国危机管理研究[J].公共管理学报,2012,9(3):112.
[4]HEWITT K.Interpretations of Calamity from the Viewpoint of Human Ecology[M].Boston:Allen and Unwin,1983.
[5]PERRY R W,QUARANTELLI E L.What is a Disaster?New Answers to Old Questions[M].Bloomington,Indiana:Xlibris Corporation,2005.
[6]TURNER B A.Causes of Disaster:Sloppy Management[J].British Journal of Management,1994,5(3):215-219.
[7]SHRIVASTAVA P,MITROFF I I,MILLER D,et al.Understanding Industrial Crises[J].Journal of Management Studies,2010,25(4):285-303.
[8]FINK C F.Some Conceptual Difficulties in the Theory of Social Conflict[J].Conflict Resolution,1968,12(4):412-460.
[9]WILLIAMS C A,HEINS R M.Risk Management and Insurance[M].New York:Mc Graw-Hill,1985.
[10]HAIMES Y Y.On the Complex Definition of Risk:A Systemsbased Approach[J].Risk Analysis,2009,29(12):1647.
[11]HALPERN J J.Cognitive Factors Influencing Decision-making in a Highly Reliable Organization[J].Organization&Environment,1989,3(2):143-158.
[12]PAUCHANT T,MITROFF I.Transforming the Crisis-prone Organization[M].San Francisco:Jossey Bass,1992.
[13]SCHWARTZ H S.On the Psychodynamics of Organizational Disaster:The Case of the Space Shuttle Challenger[J].Columbia Journal of World Business,1987,22(1):59-67.
[14]HERMANN C F.Some Consequences of Crisis Which Limit the Viability of Organizations[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1963,8(1):61-82.
[15]乌里尔·罗森塔尔,等.应对危机[M].郑州:河南人民出版社,2014.
[16]ARJEN B.From Crisis to Disaster:Toward an Integrative Perspective[M]//PERRY R W,QUARANTELLI E L.What is a Disaster?New Answers to Old Questions.Bloomington,Indiana:Xlibris Corporation,2005.
[17]ROSENTHAL U,BOIN A,COMFORT L K.Managing Crisis:Threats,Dilemmas Opportunities[M].Charles C.Thomas:Springfield,2001.
[18]DRABEK T E.Managing the Emergency Response[J].Public Administration Review,1985,45(1):85-92.
[19]PETAK W J.Emergency Management:A Challenge for Public Administration[J].Public Administration Review,1985,45(1):3-7.
[20]PREBLE J F.Integrating the Crisis Management Perspective into the Strategic Management Process[J].Journal of Management Studies,1987,34(5):769-791.
[21]JANIS I L,MANN L.Decision Making:A Psychological Analysis of Conflict[J].Academy of Management Review,1980,5(1).
[22]HERERK G M,JANIS I L,HUTH P.Decision-making during International Crisis-is Quality of Process Related to Outcome[J].Journal Of Conflict Resolution,1987,31(2):203-226.
[23]STALLINGS R A,QUARANTELLI E L.Emergent Citizen Groups and Emergency Management[J].Public Administration Review,1985,45:93-100.
[24]COVELLO V T.Society for Risk Analysis International Workshop on Uncertainty in Risk Assessment,Risk Management,and Decision Making[J].Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,1988,151(3):551.
[25]KASPERSON R E.6 Propositions on Public-Participation and Their Relevance for Risk Communication[J].Risk Analysis,1986,6(3):275-281.
[26]KASPERSON R E,RENN O,SLOVIC P,et al.The Social Amplification of Risk---A Conceptual Framework[J].Risk Analysis,1988,8(2):177-187.
[27]SCHNEIDER S K.Governmental Response to Disasters---The Conflict between Bureaucratic Procedures and Emergent Norms[J].Public Administration Review,1992,52(2):135-145.
[28]PHILIP R B,JACK K,DENNIS W.Recovery after Disaster:Achieving Sustainable Development,Mitigation and Equity[J].Disasters,1993,17(2):93-109.
[29]ZEEV M,NASRIN A.Regime Types and International Conflict,1816-1976[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,1989,33(1):3-35.
[30]WILLIAM J D.Democracy and the Management of International Conflict[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,1993,37(1):42-68.
[31]GROGORY W,FISHER M,MORGAN G,et al.What Risks are People Concerned about[J].Risk Analysis,1991,11(2):303-314.
[32]IAN S.Demographic Influences on Risk Perceptions[J].Risk Analysis,1993,13(4):413-420.
[33]RICHARD P B,HANK C,SMITH J.Politics and Scientific Expertise:Scientists,Risk Perception,and Nuclear Waste Policy[J].Risk Analysis,1993,13(4):425-439.
[34]JAMES F,BURNS J W,MERTZ C K,et al.Trust as a Determinant of Opposition to a High-level Radioactive Waste Repository:Analysis of a Structural Model[J].Risk Analysis,1992,12(3):417-429.
[35]HARRY O,DETLOF V W.Expert Judgment in Risk Analysis and Management:Process,Context and Pitfalls[J].Risk Analysis,1992,12(1):83-93.
[36]AUGUSTINE N R.Managing the Crisis You Tried to Prevent[J].Harvard Business Review,1995,73(6):147.
[37]HEATH R.Crisis Management for Managers and Executives[M].London:Financial Times Management,1998.
[38]ALLICE F,LORI A P.Poverty and Disasters in the United States:A Review of Recent Sociological Findings[J].Natural Hazards,2004,32:89-110.
[39]FOTHERGILL A,MAESTAS E G,DARLINGTON J D.Race,Ethnicity and Disasters in the United States:A Review of the Literature[J].Disasters,1999,23(2):156-173.
[40]BENNOIT W L.Account,Excuse and Apologies:A Theory of Image Restoration Strategies[M].Albany:State University of New York Press,1995.
[41]HEATH R L.Strategic Issues Management:Organizations and Public Policy Challenges[M].CA:Sage,1997.
[42]SLOVIC P.Perception of Risk[J].Science,1987,236(277):280-285.
[43]MELISSA L F,ALI A,PAUL S,et al.The Affect Heuristic in Judgments of Risks and Benefits[J].Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,2000,13:1-17.
[44]PAUL S,RICHARD S.Public Perceptions of the Potential Hazards Associated with Food Production and Food Consumption:An Empirical Study[J].Risk Analysis,1994,14(5):799-806.
[45]SJOBERG L.Factors in Risk Perception[J].Risk Analysis,2000,20(1):1-11.
[46]GEORGE F L,et al.Risk as Feelings[J].Psychological Bulletin,2000,127(2):267-286.
[47]GAILLARD J C.Alternative Paradigms of Volcanic Risk Perception:The Case of Mt.Pinatubo in the Philippines[J].Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research,2008,172(3):315-328.
[48]PIAZZA J A.Draining the Swamp:Democracy Promotion,State Failure,and Terrorism in 19 Middle Eastern Countries[J].Studies in Conflict&Terrorism,2007,30(6):521-539.
[49]URGOON B.On Welfare and Terror-Social Welfare Policies and Political-Economic Roots of Terrorism[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,2006,50(2):176-203.
[50]ARAJ B.Harsh State Repression as a Cause of Suicide Bombing:The Case of the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict[J].Studies in Conflict&Terrorism,2008,31(4):284-303.
[51]HOFFMAN B,MCCORMICK G H.Terrorism,Signaling,and Suicide Attack[J].Studies in Conflict&Terrorism,2004,27(4):243-281.
[52]BERREBI C,KLOR E F.On Terrorism and Electoral OutcomesTheory and Evidence from the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,2006,50(6):899-925.
[53]HUMPHREYS M.Natural Resources,Conflict,and Conflict Resolution-Uncovering the Mechanisms[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,2005,49(4):508-537.
[54]COLLIER P,HOEFFLER A.Resource Rents,Governance,and Conflict[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,2005,49(4):625-633.
[55]WIKSTROEM P H,TREIBER K H.Violence as Situational Action[J].International Journal of Conflict and Violence,2009,3(1):75-96.
[56]HAFNER-BURTON E M,MONTGOMERY A H.International Organizations,Social Networks,and Conflict[J].Journal of Conflict Resolution,2006,50(1):3-27.
[57]G譈NNE覶D,SALMAN F S.Assessing the Reliability and the Expected Performance of a Network under Disaster Risk[J].OR Spectrum,2011,33:499-523.
[58]BALCIK B,BEAMON B M.Facility Location in Humanitarian Relief[J].International Journal of Logistics:Research and Applications,2008,11(2):101-121.
[59]METE H O,ZABINSKY Z B.Preparing for Disasters:Medical Supply Location and Distribution[J].Interfaces,2009,35(4):1082-1095.
[60]LEMPERT R J,COLLINS M T.Managing the Risk of Uncertain Threshold Responses:Comparison of Robust,Optimum,and Precautionary Approaches[J].Risk Analysis,2007,27(4):1009-1026.
[61]BAKULI D L,MACGREGOR S J.Resource Allocation in State-Dependent Emergency Evacuation Networks[J].European Journal of Operational Research,1996,89(3):543-555.
[62]RODRIGUEZ J T,VITORIANO B,MONTERO J.A NaturalDisaster Management DSS for Humanitarian Non-Governmental Organizations[J].Knowledge-Based Systems,2010,23(1):17.
[63]WAUGH W L,STREIB G.Collaboration and Leadership for Effective Emergency Management[J].Public Administration Review,2006,66:131-140.
[64]MOYNIHAN D P.The Network Governance of Crisis Response:Case Studies of Incident Command Systems[J].Journal of Public Administration Research And Theory,2009,19(4):895-915.
[65]TORSTEN G,FRITZ R.People at Risk of Flooding:Why Some Residents Take Precautionary Action While Others Do Not[J].Natural Hazards,2006,38:101-120.
[66]ALLEN K M.Community-Based Disaster Preparedness and Climate Adaptation:Local Capacity-Building in the Philippines[J].Disasters,2006,30(1):81-101.
[67]KNOBLOCH W S,TAYLOR L.The Blame Game:Elements of Casual Attribution and Its Impact on Siding with Agents in the News[J].Communications Research,2008,35(6):723-744.
[68]BOIN A,HART P'T,MCCONNELL A.Crisis Exploitation:Political and Policy Impacts of Framing Contests[J].Journal of European Public Policy,2009,16(1):81-106.
[69]DONAHUE A K,JOYCE P G.A Framework for Analyzing Emergency Management with an Application to Federal Budgeting[J].Public Administration Review,2001,61(6):728.
[70]ADUBATO S.What were They Thinking?Crisis Communication---The Good,the Bad,and the Totally Clueless[M].New Brunswick,NJ:Rutgers University Press,2008.
[71]ALBEAK E.Protecting the Swedish Blood Supply against HIV:Crisis Management without Scandal[M]//BOVENS M,HART P,PETERS B G.Success and Failure in Public Governance:A Comparative Analysis.Cheltenham:Edward Elgar,2001:551-566.
[72]COOPER C,BLOCK R.Disaster:Hurricane Katrina and the Failure of Homeland Security[M].New York,NY:Times Books,2006.
[73]PHILLIPS T.Beslan:The Tragedy of School No.1[M].London:Granta,2007.
[74]MCCONNELL A.Success?Failure?Something inbetween?A Framework for Evaluating Crisis Management[J].Policy And Society,2011,30(2):63-76.
[75]TAYLOR-GOOBY P,ZINN J O.Current Directions in Risk Research:New Developments in Psychology and Sociology[J].Risk Analysis,2006,26(2):397-411.
[76]SIEGRIST M,GUTSCHER H,EARLE T C.Perception of Risk:the Influence of General Trust,and General Confidence[J].Journal of Risk Research,2005,8(2):145-156.
[77]POORTINGA W,PIDGEON N F.Trust in Risk Regulation:C ause or Consequence of the Acceptability of GM Food?[J].Risk Analysis,2005,25(1):199-209.
[78]LUOTN D,TULLOCH J.Life Would be Pretty Dull without Risk:Voluntary Risk-Taking and Its Pleasures[J].Health Risk&Society,2002,4(2):113-124.
[79]CONZOLA V C,WOGALTER M S.A Communication-Human Information Processing(C-Hip)Approach to Warning Effectiveness in the Workplace[J].Journal of Risk Research,2001,4(4):309-322.
[80]VISSCHERS V H,MEERTENS R M,PASSCHIER W W F,et al.Probability Information in Risk Communication:A Review of the Research Literature[J].Risk Analysis,2009,29(2):267-287.
[81]SUSAN L,CUTTER,CHRISTINA F.Temporal and Spatial changes in social vulnerability to natural hazards[EB/OL].[2008-05-22].http://www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.0710375105.
[82]NORRIS F H,STEVENS S P,PFEFFERBAUM B,et al.Community Resilience as a Metaphor,Theory,Set of Capacities,and Strategy for Disaster Readiness[J].American Journal of Community Psychology,2008,41(1-2):127-150.
[83]KELLENS W,TERPSTRA T,MAEYER P D.Perception and Communication of Flood Risks:A Systematic Review of Empirical Research[J].Risk Analysis,2013,33(1):24-48
[84]VIBIANNE H M,VISSCHERS,SIEGRIST M.How a Nuclear Power Plant Accident Influences Acceptance of Nuclear Power:Results of a Longitudinal Study Before and After the Fukushima Disaster[J].Risk Analysis,2013,33(2):333-347.
[85]MICHEAL K,LINDELL,RONALD W.The Protective Action Decision Model:Theoretical Modifications and Additional Evidence[J].Risk Analysis,2012,32(4):616-632.
[86]COOMBS W T.Ongoing Crisis Communication Planning,Managing and Responding(3rd edition)[M].Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage,2012.
[87]HOUSTON J B,HAWTHRONE J,et al.Social Media and Disasters:A Functional Framework for Social Media Use in Disaster Planning,Response,and Research[J].Disasters,2014,39(1):1-22.
[88]YAN J,LIU B F.The Blog-Mediated Crisis Communication Model:Recommendations for Responding to Influential External Blogs[J].Journal of Public Relations Research,2010,22(4):429-455.
[89]YAN J,LIU B F,ANAGONDAHALLI D,et al.Scale Development for Measuring Public`s Emotions in Organizational Crisis[J].Public Relations Review,2014,40:509-518.
[90]TONI G L A,VAN D M,JOOST W M,et al.Emotional Crisis Communication[J].Public Relations Review,2014,40:526-536.
[91]PARK J,SEAGER T P,RAO P S,et al.Integrating Risk and Resilience Approaches to Catastrophe Management in Engineering System[J].Risk Analysis,2013,33(3):356-366.
[92]AHERN J.From Fail-Safe to Safe-Fail:Sustainability and Resilience in the New Urban World[J].Landscape and Urban Planning,2011,100(4):341-343.
[93]ALLAN P,BRYANT M.Resilience as a Framework for Urbanism and Recovery[J].Journal of landscape Architecture,2011,6(2):34-45.
[94]BIRKMANN J,CARDONA O D,et al.Framing Vulnerability,Risk and Societal Responses:The MOVE Framework[J].Natural hazards,2013,67:193-211.
