摘要
针对突发灾害事故应急决策过程中存在的专家群体之间的冲突问题,构建突发灾害事故应急决策冲突协调模型。首先,根据冲突与一致性相对的关系,基于模糊逻辑理论提出一种应急决策冲突程度表示方法,定量表示应急决策冲突程度,确定冲突阈值;其次,结合应急决策冲突实际,提出冲突协调策略,设计冲突协调步骤;最后,将该模型应用于实际案例中,验证模型的合理性、可行性。研究表明:该模型能够全面反映应急决策专家的偏好,定量表示应急决策冲突程度,并具有协调消解决策者之间冲突的作用。
For the sake of resolving conflicts in emergency decision making process of disaster accidents,a model of conflict coordination for decision-making was established. Firstly,according to the relationship between conflict and consistency,a representation method for conflict degree of emergency decision making was proposed based on the fuzzy logic theory,and the conflict threshold was determined. Then the conflict coordination strategies were proposed and the steps of conflict coordination were designed in combination with actual situation of conflict. Finally,the rationality and feasibility of the model were verified through an actual case. The study indicates that this model can fully reflect experts' preferences in emergency decision making,quantify the degree of conflict,and could coordinate and eliminate the conflict among decision makers.
引文
[1]徐选华,汪业凤.非常规突发事件应急决策协调过程建模研究[J].中国应急管理,2011(8):23-27.XU Xuanhua, WANG Yefeng. Research on modeling of unconventional emergency response decision coordination process[J]. China Emergency Management,2011(8):23-27.
[2]万奇锋.应急决策中的复杂大群体冲突测度及冲突协调研究[D].长沙:中南大学,2012.WAN Qifeng. Research on complex large group conflict measurement and conflict coordination in emergency decision making[D]. Changsha:Central South University,2012.
[3]余高锋,李登峰,邱锦明,等.考虑偏好冲突的多类评价信息群体决策方法[J].控制与决策,2016,31(11):2 013-2 018.YU Gaofeng,LI Dengfeng,QIU Jinming,et al. A multi-class evaluation information group decision making method considering preference conflict[J]. Control and Decision-Making,2016,31(11):2 013-2 018.
[4]高平,夏登友,周扬.基于模糊逻辑理论的应急决策冲突程度表示方法研究[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2018,14(12):158-163.GAO Ping,XIA Dengyou,ZHOU Yang. Research on representation method for conflict degree of emergency decisionmaking based on fuzzy logic theory[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology,2018,14(12):158-163.
[5] ZHUGE Hai. Conflict decision training through multi-space co-operation[J].Decision Support Systems,2000,29(2):111-123.
[6] BEN-ARIEH David,CHEN Zhifeng. Linguistic group decision-making:opinion aggregation and measures of consensus[J].Fuzzy Optimization&Decision Making,2006,5(4):371-386.
[7] PARREIRAS R O,EKEL P Y,MARTINI J S C,et al. A flexible consensus scheme for multicriteria group decision making under linguistic assessments[J]. Information Sciences,2010,180(7):1 075-1 089.
[8] VIEDMA Herrera Enrique,ALONSO Sergio,CHICLANA Francisco,et al. A consensus model for group decision making with incomplete fuzzy preference relations[J]. IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems,2007,15(5):863-877.
[9]沈建飞,王丽亚,黄海量.多指标方案评价中群体一致性的判断和调整方法[J].工业工程与管理,2005(5):79-82,87.SHEN Jianfei,WANG Liya,HUANG Hailiang. Consensus measuring and adjusting for multi-attributes group decision under fuzzy logic[J]. Industrial Engineering and Management,2005(5):79-82,87.
[10]赵占梁,龚传信,刘铁林.需求分析中stakeholder冲突协商机制分析[J].计算机工程与设计,2008,29(3):551-559.ZHAO Zhanliang, GONG Chuanxin, LIU Tielin. Analysis of consulting mechanism of stakeholder's conflicts in requirement analysis[J]. Computer Engineering and Design. 2008,29(3):551-559.
[11]夏登友,钱新明,康青春,等.基于云模型的应急决策方法[J].北京科技大学学报,2014,36(7):972-978.XIA Dengyou,QIAN Xinming,KANG Qingchun,et al. Emergency decision making method based on the cloud model[J].Journal of University of Science and Technology Beijing,2014,36(7):972-978.
