摘要
The conversion study on the environmental quality criteria between water/air and soil is the need to carry out research on soil-environmental quality standards in an all-round way, and also the demand for solving emerging problems in this field using the system dynamic and the overall view. Carrying out this study is of practical significance and theoretical values in the face of formulation and revision of soil-environmental quality standards in China. Firstly, the theoretical basis and relative models of soil-water and soil-air systems were expounded, respectively. And on this basis, a preliminary conceptual model about the conversion was constructed. After that, the current worldwide environmental quality criteria/standards for soil, water and air media were introduced based on their types, concerned pollutants and hierarchical classification, and their variation were also analyzed briefly. Particularlly, the key points for the conversion of environmental quality criteria between soil and water and/or between soil and air were discussed, respectively, while combined with the relative researching results. Finally, this conversion study was commented and prospected.
The conversion study on the environmental quality criteria between water/air and soil is the need to carry out research on soil-environmental quality standards in an all-round way, and also the demand for solving emerging problems in this field using the system dynamic and the overall view. Carrying out this study is of practical significance and theoretical values in the face of formulation and revision of soil-environmental quality standards in China. Firstly, the theoretical basis and relative models of soil-water and soil-air systems were expounded, respectively. And on this basis, a preliminary conceptual model about the conversion was constructed. After that, the current worldwide environmental quality criteria/standards for soil, water and air media were introduced based on their types, concerned pollutants and hierarchical classification, and their variation were also analyzed briefly. Particularlly, the key points for the conversion of environmental quality criteria between soil and water and/or between soil and air were discussed, respectively, while combined with the relative researching results. Finally, this conversion study was commented and prospected.
引文
ANZECC.2000.Australian and New Zealand Guidelines for Fresh and Marine Water Quality.Australian and New Zealand Environment and Consevation Council
AG.2012.Air Quality Standards.Canberra:Department of Sustainability,Environment,Water,Population and Communities
Bai X,Casey F X M,Hakk H,DeSutter T M,Oduor P G,Khan E.2015.Sorption and degradation of 17β-estradiol-17-sulfate in sterilized soilwater systems.Chemosphere,119:1322-1328
Borggaard O K,Gimsing A L.2008.Fate of glyphosate in soil and the possibility of leaching to ground and surface waters:A review.Pest Manag Sci,64:441-456
Bozlaker A,Muezzinoglu A,Odabasi M.2009.Processes affecting the movement of organochlorine pesticides(OCPs)between soil and air in an industrial site in Turkey.Chemosphere,77:1168-1176
Cabrerizo A,Dachs J,Jones K C,BarcelóD.2011.Soil-Air exchange controls on background atmospheric concentrations of organochlorine pesticides.Atmos Chem Phys,11:12799-12811
Cao Z H,Zhou J M.2008.Soil Quality of China(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Carlon C,Dalla Valle M,Marcomini A.2004.Regression models to predict water-soil heavy metals partition coefficients in risk assessment studies.Environ Pollut,127:109-115
CCME.1999.Canadian Water Quality Guidelines for the Protection of Aquatic Life.Winnipeg:Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment
Chen F,Zhou Q X.2009.Toxic effects of galaxolide and cadmium on Daphnia magna under polluting flow containing soil-water interfaces from urban areas(in Chinese).China Environ Sci,29:58-62
Chen H M.1996.Heavy Metal Pollution in Soil-Plant System(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Cidu R,Biddau R,Dore E,Vacca A,Marini L.2014.Antimony in the soilwater-plant system at the Su Suergiu abandoned mine(Sardinia,Italy):Strategies to mitigate contamination.Sci Total Environ,497-498:319-331
Cousins I T,Beck A J,Jones K C.1999.A review of the processes involved in the exchange of semi-volatile organic compounds(SVOC)across the air-soil interface.Sci Total Environ,228:5-24
Dai S G.2006.Environmental Chemistry(in Chinese).2nd ed.Beijing:Higher Education Press
Danish EPA.1997.Soil Quality Criteria for Selected Compounds.Copenhagen:Danish Environmental Protection Agency
Du G Laing,Vanthuyne D R J,Vandecasteele B,Tack F M G,Verloo M G.2007.Influence of hydrological regime on pore water metal concentrations in a contaminated sediment-derived soil.Environ Pollut,147:615-625
EA,DEFRA.2002.The Contaminated Land Exposure Assessment(CLEA)Model:Technical Basis and Algorithms.London:Food and Rural Affairs,Environment Agency
EC.2013.Air Quality Standards.Belgium:European Commission
Feng K,Yu B Y,Ge D M,Wong M H,Wang X C,Cao Z H.2003.Organochlorine pesticide(DDT and HCH)residues in the Taihu Lake Region and its movement in soil-water system.Chemosphere,50:683-687
Feng M Q,Zhen B M,Zhou X D.2009.Water Environment Simulation and Prediction(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Feng X B,Chen Y C,Zhu W G.1996.The fluxes of volatile mercury over soil surface in Guizhou province(in Chinese).Chin J Environ Sci,1720-22
Fent K.2004.Ecotoxicological effects at contaminated sites.Toxicology205:223-240
Filipovi?V,Coquet Y,Pot V,Houot S,Benoit P.2014.Modeling the effec of soil structure on water flow and isoproturon dynamics in an agricultural field receiving repeated urban waste compost application.Sc Total Environ,499:546-559
Franco A,Trapp S.2008.Estimation of the soil-water partition coefficien normalized to organic carbon for ionizable organic chemicals.Environ Toxicol Chem,27:1995-2004
Garc?a-Herruzo F,Rodr?guez-Maroto J M,Garc?a-Delgado R A,GómezLahoz C,Vereda-Alonso C.2000.Column study of the influence of air humidity on the retention of hydrocarbons on soil.Chemosphere,411167-1172
Harner T,Bidleman T F,Jantunen L M M,Mackay D.2001.Soil-air exchange model of persistent pesticides in the United States cotton belt Environ Toxicol Chem,20:1612
He X,Chen S,Quan X,Zhao Y Z,Zhao H M.2009.Temperature-dependence of soil/air partition coefficients for selected polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and organochlorine pesticides over a temperature range of-30 to+30°C.Chemosphere,76:465-471
Hicks B B,Baldocchi D D,Meyers T P,Hosker Jr R P,Matt D R.1987.Apreliminary multiple resistance routine for deriving dry deposition velocities from measured quantities.Water Air Soil Pollut,36:311-330
Hippelein M,McLachlan M S.1998.Soil/air partitioning of semivolatile organic compounds.1.Method development and influence of physicalchemical properties.Environ Sci Technol,32:310-316
Jarvis N J.2007.A review of non-equilibrium water flow and solute transport in soil macropores:Principles,controlling factors and consequences for water quality.Eur J Soil Sci,58:523-546
Jung J E,Lee D S,Kim S J,Kim D W,Kim S K,Kim J G.2010.Proximity of field distribution of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons to chemica equilibria among air,water,soil,and sediment and its implications to the coherence criteria of environmental quality objectives.Environ Sc Technol,44:8056-8061
Kalf D F,Crommentuijn T,van de Plassche E J.1997.Environmenta quality objectives for 10 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons(PAHs)Ecotoxicol Environ Saf,36:89-97
Kile D E,Chiou C T,Zhou H,Li H,Xu O.1995.Partition of nonpolar organic pollutants from water to soil and sediment organic matters Environ Sci Technol,29:1401-1406
Lee S Z,Allen H E,Huang C P,Sparks D L,Sanders P F,Peijnenburg W JG M.1996.Predicting soil-water partition coefficients for cadmium Environ Sci Technol,30:3418-3424
Lepper P.2002.Towards the derivation of quality standards for priority substances in the context of the water framework directive-identification of quality standards for priority substances in the field of water policy(Contract No.B4-3040/2000/30637/MAR/EI).German:Fraunhofer-Institute
Li H,Lee L S,Fabrega J R,Jafvert C T.2001.Role of pH in partitioning and cation exchange of aromatic amines on water-saturated soils Chemosphere,44:627-635
Lin T,Zhang C,Shi X J,Wang D Y.2008.Mercury fluxes released at soil air interfaces in different Purpli-Udic Cambosols and the effects of environmental factors(in Chinese).Acta Sci Circum,28:1955-1960
Liu H X,Qi S H,Xing X L,Hu Y,Qu C K,Zhang L,Huang H F.2014Research progress on soil-air exchange of organochlorine pesticides(in Chinese).Saf Environ Eng,21:1-15
Liu W P.2006.Pesticide Environmental Chemistry(in Chinese).Beijing:Chemical Industry Press
Lyon B F,Ambrose R,Rice G,Maxwell C J.1997.Calculation of soilwater and benthic sediment partition coefficients for mercury.Chemosphere,35:791-808
Maggi C,Onorati F,Lamberti C V,Cicero A M.2008.The hazardous priority substances in Italy:National rules and environmental quality standard in marine environment.Environ Impact Assessment Rev,28:1-6
Meng W.2008.Technique of Total Amount Control for Water Pollutant in Watershed and its Application(in Chinese).Beijing:China Environmental Science Press
Minh L Q,Tuong T P,van Mensvoort M E F,Bouma J.1997.Contamination of surface water as affected by land use in acid sulfate soils in the Mekong River Delta,Vietnam.Agriculture Ecosyst Environ,61:19-27
MoEJ.2009.Environmental Quality Standards in Japan-Air Quality.Tokyo:Ministry of the Environment Government of Japan
MoEK.2010.Air Quality Standards.Seoul:Ministry of Environment Government of Korea
Nolan A L,Mclaughlin M J,Mason S D.2003.Chemical speciation of Zn,Cd,Cu,and Pb in pore waters of agricultural and contaminated soils using Donnan dialysis.Environ Sci Technol,37:90-98
Qi Y C,Jin J.2013.A comparative study on the typical national and international ambient air air quality standards(in Chinese).Energ Res Inf,29:67-73
Ren J,Wang X P,Gong P,Sheng J J,Yao T D.2013.Research progress on exchange of persistent organic pollutants at the air-soil interface(in Chinese).Prog Geo,32:288-297
Saleem M,Iqbal J,Shah M H.2014.Non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic health risk assessment of selected metals in soil around a natural water reservoir,Pakistan.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf,108:42-51
Shi J J,Guo J F,Chen H.2002.Dynamics of95Zr in the rice/water/soil system.Appl Radiat Isotopes,56:735-740
Shi R G,Zhou Q X,Cai Y M,Zhang H.2010.Contamination characteristics and source analyses of PAHs in contaminated flows from soilwater interfaces of Tianjin suburban areas,China(in Chinese).Acta Sci Circum,30:874-881
Teng Y,Zhou Q X.2015.Some relative problems of the equilibrium partition method for derivation of soil-environmental quality criteria(in Chinese).Asian J Ecotoxicol,10:58-65
ter Laak T L,Agbo S O,Barendregt A,Hermens J L M.2006.Freely dissolved concentrations of PAHs in soil pore water:Measurements via solid-phase extraction and consequences for soil tests.Environ Sci Technol,40:1307-1313
Thailand PCD.2010.Air Quality Standards.Bangkok:Thailand PCD
UK.2012.National Air Quality Objectives and European Directive Limit and Target Values for the Protection of Human Health.London:Department for Environment Food&Rural Affairs
US EPA.2005.Guidance for Developing Ecological Soil Screening Levels.Washington D C:Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response
US EPA.2012.National Ambient Air Quality Standards(NAAQS).Washington D C:Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards
US EPA.2009.National Recommended Water Qualilty Criteria.Washington D C:Office of Water and Office of Science and Technology
US EPA.1996.Soil Screening Guidance:User’s Guide.Washington D C:Office of Solid Waster and Emergency Response
US EPA.2003.Water Quality Criteria and Standards Plan:Priorities for the Future.Washington D C:US Department of Environmental Protection
Uusitalo R,Yli-Halla M,Turtola E.2000.Suspended soil as a source of potentially bioavailable phosphorus in surface runoff waters from clay soils.Water Res,34:2477-2482
VROM.2000.Annexes Circular on Target Values and Intervention Values for Soil Remediation.The Hague:Ministry of Housing,Spatial Planning and Environment
Wang D G,Yang M,Jia H L,Zhou L,Li Y F.2008.Seasonal variation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in soil and air of Dalian areas,China An assessment of soil-air exchange.J Environ Monit,10:1076-1083
Wang S F,Feng X B,Qiu G L,Fu X W,Wei Z Q.2007.Characteristics of mercury exchange flux between soil and air in the heavily air-polluted area,eastern Guizhou,China.Atmos Environ,41:5584-5594
Wang W T,Simonich S,Giri B,Chang Y,Zhang Y G,Jia Y L,Tao SWang R,Wang B,Li W.2011.Atmospheric concentrations and air-soi gas exchange of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons(PAHs)in remote rural village and urban areas of Beijing-Tianjin region,North China.Sc Total Environ,409:2942-2950
WHO.2005.Air Quality Guidelines-Global Update 2005.Bonn:WHORegional Office for Europe
Wong F,Alegria H A,Bidleman T F.2010.Organochlorine pesticides in soils of Mexico and the potential for soil-air exchange.Environ Pollut158:749-755
Xie N.2011.Basis of Traditional Chinese Medicine.Beijing:China Traditional Medicine Press
Xu H,Chen Y Q,Lin J Z,Zhu T.2010.Theory and Practice of Strategic Environmental Assessment in China(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Xie R L,Zhou Q X.2012.Methodology of water quality criteria in foreign countries and its future researching prospects(in Chinese).World SciTech R D,34:939-944
Yang X B,Yang X F,Li X.2013.Comparision of environmental air quality standards in China and abroad(in Chinese).Environ Sci Technol,1916-23
Yan S,Zhou Q,Gao J.2012.Methodology for derivation of water quality criteria for protecting aquatic environment and future development Critical Rev Environ Sci Tech,42:2471-2503
Ye C M.1997.Studies on Multi-Medium Evironmental Pllution(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Yuan L.1992.A study on the rule of volatilization and transformation of dimethylmercury in agricultural soils(in Chinese).J Agro-Environ Sci11:152-155
Yuan L,Zhong C L.1996.The volatilization and transformation of methylmercury in agricultural soils(in Chinese).J Agro-Environ Sci,15:58-61
Yu G,Niu J F,Huang J.2005.Persistent Organic Pollutants:A New Global Environmental Problem(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Zareitalabad P,Siemens J,Hamer M,Amelung W.2013.Perfluorooctanoic acid(PFOA)and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid(PFOS)in surface waters,sediments,soils and wastewater-A review on concentrations and distribution coefficients.Chemosphere,91:725-732
Zhang C,He L,Wang D Y,Zhang J Y.2005.Soil/air interface mercury exchange fluxes of several ground surface in Chongqing(in Chinese).Acta Sci Circum,25:1085-1090
Zheng S M,Zhou Q X,Yang F X,Li Y C,Wang Y F.2017.Discussion on the recommended value of the water quality of Chinese benzene system(in Chinese).Sci Sin Terrae,47:1493-1508
Zhou Q X.2005.Health Soil Science:Soil Health Quality and Safety of Agricultural Products(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Zhou Q X.2010.Advances and prospect of research on environmental criteria/benchmarks and enactment of environmental standards(in Chinese).J Ecol Rural Environ,26:1-8
Zhou Q X,An J,He K X.2011.Research and prospect on soil-environmetnal criteria in China(in Chinese).J Agro-Environ Sci,30:1-6
Zhou Q X,Huang G H.2001.Environmental Biogeochemistry&Global Environmental Changes(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Zhou Q X,Luo Y.2011.Pollution Eco-chemistry(in Chinese).Beijing:Science Press
Zhou Q X,Luo Y,Zhu L Y.2007.Scientific research on environmental benchmark values and revision of national environmental standards in China(in Chinese).J Agro-Environ Sci,26:1-5
Zhou Q X,Teng Y,Lin D S.2013.The principles and methods of deriving and determining remediation criteria for contaminated soils(in Chinese).J Agro-Environ Sci,32):205-214
Zhou Q X,Teng Y,Liu Y.2017.A study on soil-environmental quality criteria and standards of arsenic.Appl Geochem,77:158-166
Zhou Q X,Teng Y,Zhan S H,Tong L.2014.Fundamental problems to be solved in research on soil-environmental criteria/standards(in Chinese).J Agro-Environ Sci,33:1-14
