摘要
AIM To identify the outcome measures that have been used in randomized controlled trials(RCTs) of exercise training in solid organ transplant(SOT) recipients and to link these outcomes to the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health(ICF) framework.METHODS Electronic literature searches of MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Cochrane, Scopus, and Web of Science were performed. We sought RCTs that investigated the effect of exercise training in SOT recipients. Reference lists of all eligible publications were searched for other appropriate studies not identified by the electronic search. A complete list of outcome measures used in the RCTs was generated and each of these was linked to an ICF category.RESULTS Four hundred and thirteen articles were retrieved, of which 35 met our inclusion criteria. The studies included were designed to compare the effects of exercise training programs to usual care or to another exercise training program and reported on recipients of heart(n = 21), kidney(n = 9), lung(n = 3) or liver(n = 2) transplant. Of the 126 outcome measures identified, 62 were used as primary outcome measures. The most commonly occurring primary outcomes were aerobic capacity using the peak VO2(n = 13), quality of life using the shortform-36(n = 8), and muscle strength(n = 7). Theseoutcome measures were linked to 113 ICF categories and the majority of outcomes fall into the body function domain(n = 93). CONCLUSION There is little standardization in outcome measures used in RCTs of exercise interventions in SOT recipients. The ICF framework can be used to select a core set of outcomes that cross all domains of ICF and that would be appropriate to all SOT recipients.
AIM To identify the outcome measures that have been used in randomized controlled trials(RCTs) of exercise training in solid organ transplant(SOT) recipients and to link these outcomes to the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health(ICF) framework.METHODS Electronic literature searches of MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Cochrane, Scopus, and Web of Science were performed. We sought RCTs that investigated the effect of exercise training in SOT recipients. Reference lists of all eligible publications were searched for other appropriate studies not identified by the electronic search. A complete list of outcome measures used in the RCTs was generated and each of these was linked to an ICF category.RESULTS Four hundred and thirteen articles were retrieved, of which 35 met our inclusion criteria. The studies included were designed to compare the effects of exercise training programs to usual care or to another exercise training program and reported on recipients of heart(n = 21), kidney(n = 9), lung(n = 3) or liver(n = 2) transplant. Of the 126 outcome measures identified, 62 were used as primary outcome measures. The most commonly occurring primary outcomes were aerobic capacity using the peak VO2(n = 13), quality of life using the shortform-36(n = 8), and muscle strength(n = 7). Theseoutcome measures were linked to 113 ICF categories and the majority of outcomes fall into the body function domain(n = 93). CONCLUSION There is little standardization in outcome measures used in RCTs of exercise interventions in SOT recipients. The ICF framework can be used to select a core set of outcomes that cross all domains of ICF and that would be appropriate to all SOT recipients.
引文
1 Didsbury M,McG ee RG,Tong A,Craig JC,Chapman JR,Chadban S,Wong G.Exercise training in solid organ transplant recipients:a systematic review and meta-analysis.Transplantation 2013;95:679-687[PMID:23364480 DOI:10.1097/TP.0b013e31827a3d3e]
2 Langer D,Burtin C,Schepers L,Ivanova A,Verleden G,Decramer M,Troosters T,Gosselink R.Exercise training after lung transplantation improves participation in daily activity:a randomized controlled trial.Am J Transplant 2012;12:1584-1592[PMID:22390625 DOI:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2012.04000.x]
3 Krasnoff JB,Vintro AQ,Ascher NL,Bass NM,Paul SM,Dodd MJ,Painter PL.A randomized trial of exercise and dietary counseling after liver transplantation.Am J Transplant 2006;6:1896-1905[PMID:16889545 DOI:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2006.01391.x]
4 Braith RW,Welsch MA,Mills RM,Keller JW,Pollock ML.Resistance exercise prevents glucocorticoid-induced myopathy in heart transplant recipients.Med Sci Sports Exerc 1998;30:483-489[PMID:9565927 DOI:10.1097/00005768-199804000-00003]
5 Braith RW,Mills RM,Welsch MA,Keller JW,Pollock ML.Resistance exercise training restores bone mineral density in heart transplant recipients.J Am Coll Cardiol 1996;28:1471-1477[PMID:8917260 DOI:10.1016/S0735-1097(96)00347-6]
6 McA dams-DeM arco MA,Law A,King E,Orandi B,Salter M,Gupta N,Chow E,Alachkar N,Desai N,Varadhan R,Walston J,Segev DL.Frailty and mortality in kidney transplant recipients.Am J Transplant2015;15:149-154[PMID:25359393 DOI:10.1111/ajt.12992]
7 McA dams-DeM arco MA,Law A,Salter ML,Boyarsky B,Gimenez L,Jaar BG,Walston JD,Segev DL.Frailty as a novel predictor of mortality and hospitalization in individuals of all ages undergoing hemodialysis.J Am Geriatr Soc 2013;61:896-901[PMID:23711111DOI:10.1111/jgs.12266]
8 McA dams-DeM arco MA,Law A,Salter ML,Chow E,Grams M,Walston J,Segev DL.Frailty and early hospital readmission after kidney transplantation.Am J Transplant 2013;13:2091-2095[PMID:23731461 DOI:10.1111/ajt.12300]
9 Kirkham JJ,Dwan KM,Altman DG,Gamble C,Dodd S,Smyth R,Williamson PR.The impact of outcome reporting bias in randomised controlled trials on a cohort of systematic reviews.BMJ 2010;340:c365[PMID:20156912 DOI:10.1136/bmj.c365]
10 Williamson PR,Altman DG,Blazeby JM,Clarke M,Devane D,Gargon E,Tugwell P.Developing core outcome sets for clinical trials:issues to consider.Trials 2012;13:132[PMID:22867278 DOI:10.1186/1745-6215-13-132]
11 Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials Initiative(COMET).Available from:URL:http://www.comet-initiative.org/
12 World Health Organization.Towards a common language for functioning,disability and health:ICF.World Health Organisation,2002 Available from:URL:http://www.who.int/classifications/icf/en/
13 Gilchrist LS,Galantino ML,Wampler M,Marchese VG,Morris GS,Ness KK.A framework for assessment in oncology rehabilitation.Phys Ther 2009;89:286-306[PMID:19147708 DOI:10.2522/ptj.20070309]
14 Moher D,Liberati A,Tetzlaff J,Altman DG.Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses:the PRISMA statement.PLo S Med 2009;6:e1000097[PMID:19621072 DOI:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097]
15 Kobashigawa JA,Leaf DA,Lee N,Gleeson MP,Liu H,Hamilton MA,Moriguchi JD,Kawata N,Einhorn K,Herlihy E,Laks H.Acontrolled trial of exercise rehabilitation after heart transplantation.N Engl J Med 1999;340:272-277[PMID:9920951 DOI:10.1056/NEJM199901283400404]
16 Painter PL,Hector L,Ray K,Lynes L,Dibble S,Paul SM,Tomlanovich SL,Ascher NL.A randomized trial of exercise training after renal transplantation.Transplantation 2002;74:42-48[PMID:12134097 DOI:10.1097/00007890-200207150-00008]
17 Mitchell MJ,Baz MA,Fulton MN,Lisor CF,Braith RW.Resistance training prevents vertebral osteoporosis in lung transplant recipients.Transplantation 2003;76:557-562[PMID:12923444 DOI:10.1097/01.TP.0000076471.25132.52]
18 Painter PL,Hector L,Ray K,Lynes L,Paul SM,Dodd M,Tomlanovich SL,Ascher NL.Effects of exercise training on coronary heart disease risk factors in renal transplant recipients.Am JKidney Dis 2003;42:362-369[PMID:12900820 DOI:10.1016/S0272-6386(03)00673-5]
19 Braith RW,Magyari PM,Pierce GL,Edwards DG,Hill JA,White LJ,Aranda JM.Effect of resistance exercise on skeletal muscle myopathy in heart transplant recipients.Am J Cardiol 2005;95:1192-1198[PMID:15877992 DOI:10.1016/j.amjcard.2005.01.048]
20 Juskowa J,Lewandowska M,Bart?omiejczyk I,Foroncewicz B,Korabiewska I,Niewczas M,Sierdziński J.Physical rehabilitation and risk of atherosclerosis after successful kidney transplantation.Transplant Proc 2006;38:157-160[PMID:16504691 DOI:10.1016/j.transproceed.2005.12.077]
21 Bernardi L,Radaelli A,Passino C,Falcone C,Auguadro C,Martinelli L,Rinaldi M,ViganòM,Finardi G.Effects of physical training on cardiovascular control after heart transplantation.Int J Cardiol 2007;118:356-362[PMID:17050012 DOI:10.1016/j.ijcard.2006.07.032]
22 Karapolat H,Eyig?r S,Zoghi M,Yagdi T,Nalbangil S,Durmaz B.Comparison of hospital-supervised exercise versus home-based exercise in patients after orthotopic heart transplantation:effects on functional capacity,quality of life,and psychological symptoms.Transplant Proc 2007;39:1586-1588[PMID:17580194 DOI:10.1016/j.transproceed.2007.01.079]
23 Braith RW,Schofield RS,Hill JA,Casey DP,Pierce GL.Exercise training attenuates progressive decline in brachial artery reactivity in heart transplant recipients.J Heart Lung Transplant 2008;27:52-59[PMID:18187087 DOI:10.1016/j.healun.2007.09.032]
24 Karapolat H,Eyigor S,Zoghi M,Yagdi T,Nalbantgil S,Durmaz B,Ozbaran M.Effects of cardiac rehabilitation program on exercise capacity and chronotropic variables in patients with orthotopic heart transplant.Clin Res Cardiol 2008;97:449-456[PMID:18317667DOI:10.1007/s00392-008-0648-7]
25 Pierce GL,Schofield RS,Casey DP,Hamlin SA,Hill JA,Braith RW.Effects of exercise training on forearm and calf vasodilation and proinflammatory markers in recent heart transplant recipients:a pilot study.Eur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil 2008;15:10-18[PMID:18277180 DOI:10.1097/HJR.0b013e3282f0b63b]
26 Wu YT,Chien CL,Chou NK,Wang SS,Lai JS,Wu YW.Efficacy of a home-based exercise program for orthotopic heart transplant recipients.Cardiology 2008;111:87-93[PMID:18376119 DOI:10.1159/000119695]
27 Haykowsky M,Taylor D,Kim D,Tymchak W.Exercise training improves aerobic capacity and skeletal muscle function in heart transplant recipients.Am J Transplant 2009;9:734-739[PMID:19344465 DOI:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2008.02531.x]
28 Mandel DW.Comparison of Targeted Lower Extremity Strengthening and Usual Care Progressive Ambulation in Subjects Post-Liver Transplant:ARandomized Controlled Trial.Available from:URL:http://xueshu.baidu.com/s?wd=paperuri:(15d7def06167aa5c5228841b35d7d3a7)&filter=sc_long_si gn&sc_ks_para=q%3DComparison+of+Targeted+Lower+Extremity+Stre ngthening+and+Usual+Care+Progressive+Ambulation+in+Subjects+PostLiver+Transplant%3A+A+Randomized+Controlled+Trial&tn=SE_baiduxueshu_c1gjeupa&ie=utf-8&sc_us=11096312547240331258
29 Hermann TS,Dall CH,Christensen SB,Goetze JP,Prescott E,Gustafsson F.Effect of high intensity exercise on peak oxygen uptake and endothelial function in long-term heart transplant recipients.Am J Transplant 2011;11:536-541[PMID:21219582 DOI:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2010.03403.x]
30 Ihle F,Neurohr C,Huppmann P,Zimmermann G,Leuchte H,Baumgartner R,Kenn K,Sczepanski B,Hatz R,Czerner S,Frey L,Ueberfuhr P,Bittmann I,Behr J.Effect of inpatient rehabilitation on quality of life and exercise capacity in long-term lung transplant survivors:a prospective,randomized study.J Heart Lung Transplant 2011;30:912-919[PMID:21489819 DOI:10.1016/j.healun.2011.02.006]
31 Christensen SB,Dall CH,Prescott E,Pedersen SS,Gustafsson F.A high-intensity exercise program improves exercise capacity,selfperceived health,anxiety and depression in heart transplant recipients:a randomized,controlled trial.J Heart Lung Transplant 2012;31:106-107[PMID:22153554 DOI:10.1016/j.healun.2011.10.014]
32 Nytr?en K,Rustad LA,Aukrust P,Ueland T,Hallén J,Holm I,Rolid K,Lekva T,Fiane AE,Amlie JP,Aakhus S,Gullestad L.High-intensity interval training improves peak oxygen uptake and muscular exercise capacity in heart transplant recipients.Am JTransplant 2012;12:3134-3142[PMID:22900793 DOI:10.1111/j.1600-6143.2012.04221.x]
33 Rustad LA,Nytr?en K,Amundsen BH,Gullestad L,Aakhus S.One year of high-intensity interval training improves exercise capacity,but not left ventricular function in stable heart transplant recipients:a randomised controlled trial.Eur J Prev Cardiol 2014;21:181-191[PMID:23185084 DOI:10.1177/2047487312469477]
34 Kawauchi TS,Almeida PO,Lucy KR,Bocchi EA,Feltrim MI,Nozawa E.Randomized and comparative study between two intrahospital exercise programs for heart transplant patients.Rev Bras Cir Cardiovasc 2013;28:338-346[PMID:24343683 DOI:10.5935/1678-9741.20130053]
35 Kouidi E,Vergoulas G,Anifanti M,Deligiannis A.A randomized controlled trial of exercise training on cardiovascular and autonomic function among renal transplant recipients.Nephrol Dial Transplant2013;28:1294-1305[PMID:23129823 DOI:10.1093/ndt/gfs455]
36 Nytr?en K,Rustad LA,Erikstad I,Aukrust P,Ueland T,Lekva T,Gude E,Wilhelmsen N,Hervold A,Aakhus S,Gullestad L,Arora S.Effect of high-intensity interval training on progression of cardiac allograft vasculopathy.J Heart Lung Transplant 2013;32:1073-1080[PMID:23906899 DOI:10.1016/j.healun.2013.06.023]
37 Dall CH,Snoer M,Christensen S,Monk-Hansen T,Frederiksen M,Gustafsson F,Langberg H,Prescott E.Effect of high-intensity training versus moderate training on peak oxygen uptake and chronotropic response in heart transplant recipients:a randomized crossover trial.Am J Transplant 2014;14:2391-2399[PMID:25135383 DOI:10.1111/ajt.12873]
38 Monk-Hansen T,Dall CH,Christensen SB,Snoer M,Gustafsson F,Rasmusen H,Prescott E.Interval training does not modulate diastolic function in heart transplant recipients.Scand Cardiovasc J 2014;48:91-98[PMID:24320690 DOI:10.3109/14017431.2013.871058]
39 Pascoalino LN,Ciolac EG,Tavares AC,Castro RE,Ayub-Ferreira SM,Bacal F,Issa VS,Bocchi EA,Guimar?es GV.Exercise training improves ambulatory blood pressure but not arterial stiffness in heart transplant recipients.J Heart Lung Transplant 2015;34:693-700[PMID:25662857 DOI:10.1016/j.healun.2014.11.013]
40 Pooranfar S,Shakoor E,Shafahi M,Salesi M,Karimi M,Roozbeh J,Hasheminasab M.The effect of exercise training on quality and quantity of sleep and lipid profile in renal transplant patients:a randomized clinical trial.Int J Organ Transplant Med 2014;5:157-165[PMID:25426284]
41 Riess KJ,Haykowsky M,Lawrance R,Tomczak CR,Welsh R,Lewanczuk R,Tymchak W,Haennel RG,Gourishankar S.Exercise training improves aerobic capacity,muscle strength,and quality of life in renal transplant recipients.Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 2014;39:566-571[PMID:24766239 DOI:10.1139/apnm-2013-0449]
42 Tzvetanov I,West-Thielke P,D’Amico G,Johnsen M,Ladik A,Hachaj G,Grazman M,Heller R,Fernhall B,Daviglus M.A novel and personalized rehabilitation program for obese kidney transplant recipients.Transplant Proc 2014;46:3431-3437
43 Dall CH,Gustafsson F,Christensen SB,Dela F,Langberg H,Prescott E.Effect of moderate-versus high-intensity exercise on vascular function,biomarkers and quality of life in heart transplant recipients:A randomized,crossover trial.J Heart Lung Transplant 2015;34:1033-1041[PMID:25840503 DOI:10.1016/j.healun.2015.02.001]
44 Greenwood SA,Koufaki P,Mercer TH,Rush R,O’Connor E,Tuffnell R,Lindup H,Haggis L,Dew T,Abdulnassir L,Nugent E,Goldsmith D,Macdougall IC.Aerobic or Resistance Training and Pulse Wave Velocity in Kidney Transplant Recipients:A 12-Week Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial(the Exercise in Renal Transplant[ExeR T]Trial).Am J Kidney Dis 2015;66:689-698[PMID:26209542DOI:10.1053/j.ajkd.2015.06.016]
45 Karelis AD,Hébert MJ,Rabasa-Lhoret R,R?kel A.Impact of Resistance Training on Factors Involved in the Development of NewOnset Diabetes After Transplantation in Renal Transplant Recipients:An Open Randomized Pilot Study.Can J Diabetes 2015;40:382-388[PMID:26656280 DOI:10.1016/j.jcjd.2015.08.014]
46 Cieza A,Stucki G.Content comparison of health-related quality of life(HRQOL)instruments based on the international classification of functioning,disability and health(ICF).Qual Life Res 2005;14:1225-1237[PMID:16047499 DOI:10.1007/s11136-004-4773-0]
47 Williams TJ,Mc Kenna MJ.Exercise limitation following transplantation.Compr Physiol 2012;2:1937-1979[PMID:23723030DOI:10.1002/cphy.c110021]
48 Mathur S,Janaudis-Ferreira T,Wickerson L,Singer LG,Patcai J,Rozenberg D,Blydt-Hansen T,Hartmann EL,Haykowsky M,Helm D,High K,Howes N,Kamath BM,Lands L,Marzolini S,Sonnenday C.Meeting report:consensus recommendations for a research agenda in exercise in solid organ transplantation.Am J Transplant 2014;14:2235-2245[PMID:25135579 DOI:10.1111/ajt.12874]
49 Cleemput I,Dobbels F.Measuring patient-reported outcomes in solid organ transplant recipients:an overview of instruments developed to date.Pharmacoeconomics 2007;25:269-286[PMID:17402802 DOI:10.2165/00019053-200725040-00002]
50 Trojetto T,Elliott RJ,Rashid S,Wong S,Dlugosz K,Helm D,Wickerson L,Brooks D.Availability,characteristics,and barriers of rehabilitation programs in organ transplant populations across Canada.Clin Transplant 2011;25:E571-E578[PMID:21955056 DOI:10.1111/j.1399-0012.2011.01501.x]
